News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by willis936 on Sunday December 22, 2024 @09:33PM (#42491201)
I'm not sure how DMCA enforcement isn't a clear violation of the 1st amendment. If you are connected you can use the government to stop speech? Isn't this the kind of thing that US feels very strongly is not okay?
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by thayne on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:31PM (#42491491)
Also the seventh amendment (the content is removed without any trial by jury, and that can sometimes have considerable monetary harm to the content creator) and the fifth amendment (there is a process but it is very questionable, with basically no requirement of evidence of infringement, and no presumption of innocence).
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:18PM (#42491730)
> fifth amendment (there is a process but it is very questionable, with basically no requirement of evidence of infringement, and no presumption of innocence)

There is also no “capital, or otherwise infamous crime,” “criminal case,” or taking of private property “for public use, without just compensation” [1].

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_Amendment_to_the_Unite...

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by thayne on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:06AM (#42491932)
I will admit that the fifth amendment case isn't as clear cut as the others, by the letter of the law, but:

> nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law

I would argue that at least in some cases dmca takedown notices can deprive people of property, either by preventing them from making an income from their content, or causing them to lose access to a service for which they paid money, or have access to something of value.

I also think it deprives the poster of some degree of liberty.

Even if it isn't against the letter of the law it is against the spirit.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:36AM (#42492070)
> Even if it isn't against the letter of the law it is against the spirit

By that notion YouTube has the right to call a jury if I decide to cancel.

Where we agree is in the sanctions. For the safe harbor to be removed there should be more process, and it should be explicit.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by hahn-kev on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:34PM (#42491815)
Except you don't have a legal right to post content on a private platform, that private company can do whatever they want, they aren't required to give you freedom of speech.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by thayne on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:26AM (#42492023)
DMCA is a legal mechanism that the platform has to comply with. This isn't a case of a private company removing something that violates the ToS, it is a law that can be easily be abused by a third party to cause content to be taken down.

It's like if there was a law that said if you send a notification to a storage or logistics company that you think one of their customers has counterfeit goods in their storage, the storage company is legally obligated to destroy the suspect property, regardless of whether there is any evidence that it is actually counterfeit. Or even just, that company is no longer allowed to provide service to that customer, and is allowed to seize and keep any property they currently have control over.

I could also talk about how many of these platforms have too much power, and the lack of competition makes it problematic if they have control to censor as they please, but that is really a different topic.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by foobarchu on Monday December 23, 2024 @12:27AM (#42492034)
IANAL but I think this justification sits on very shakey ground when the private company is doing it in the name of the law (DMCA). For the same reason, I of course think the government demanding encryption backdoors by private companies violates the fifth amendment.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by cratermoon on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:03PM (#42491354)
When the government does it, it's bad. When the Free Market™ does it, that's innovation.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by omgwtfbyobbq on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:28PM (#42491475)
The 1st amendment applies to the government, so it wouldn't apply unless the DMCA request is to a government website.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by foota on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:43PM (#42491557)
The DMCA is a law that restricts the ability of people to make speech. The government is the one doing the restricting, even if the place the speech is being done isn't controlled by the government.

The argument you're making is applicable when a website decides not to publish your speech (they're not the government, so the 1st amendment is irrelevant), but the DMCA is different.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by omgwtfbyobbq on Monday December 23, 2024 @06:09PM (#42498345)
The 1st amendment only applies to freedom of speech that the government can control/affect directly.

Using the DMCA like this is censorship by copywrite, and it does go against freedom of speech in society at large, but it's not a 1st amendment issue.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_by_copyright

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 23, 2024 @06:16PM (#42498371)
Lots of arguing around the point, perhaps.

Freedom of speech is an American ideal. It's in the Bill of Rights because it was so important. Not as a tool to restrict this right to just government infringements. It is supposed to be a universal right.

I often wonder at those arguing that it's 'ok' somehow in some circumstances because, not protected except for the govt! Somehow they've lost sight of the ideal.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by omgwtfbyobbq on Monday December 23, 2024 @09:37PM (#42499277)
My dude, it's restricted to just government infringements (Congress) in the Bill of Rights.

> Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Bill_of_Rights

If it was supposed to be a universal right for everyone/everything, it would be something like "no one shall make a law..."

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @08:35AM (#42501802)
Kid, that's what I said.

American ideals are not restricted to the Bill of Rights. My entire point.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by omgwtfbyobbq on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:16PM (#42504600)
That's not what you said.

> It's in the Bill of Rights because it was so important. Not as a tool to restrict this right to just government infringements.

In the Bill of Rights, it's restricted to just government infringements.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by foota on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:00PM (#42504062)
Interesting, thanks for clarifying. I guess the fact that people can counter claim means the ability of someone to truly limit someone else's speech is probably limited, and it's on websites to support that (which I don't think all do, but it's up to them?)

Almost makes me wish it was mandatory for companies to support counter claims and to treat a customer no differently if they've filed a counter claim. (E.g., GitHub can't close your repos as long as you file a counter claim, unless they would have regardless of the DMCA claim.)

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by willis936 on Sunday December 22, 2024 @10:45PM (#42491569)
It's the other way around. The 1st amendment protects public speech from the government, not the government from the public. Since DMCA is a law made and enforced by the government it is used illegally against the public in violation of the 1st amendment.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by omgwtfbyobbq on Thursday December 26, 2024 @06:23PM (#42518657)
Yes and no. The governments powers wrt speech are limited, but certain things like threats, yelling fire in a crowded theater, and other crimes/regulations do not have 1st amendment protections.

The DMCA is an exception because it's a law, just like a threat or any other illegal material/etc would be and removal of that thing can be mandated by law without it being a 1st amendment issue.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 22, 2024 @11:25PM (#42491762)
> 1st amendment applies to the government, so it wouldn't apply

Eh, the DMCA is still a law providing for civil and criminal sanctions based on speech. There are probably fundamental First Amendment problems with copyright.

The answer to why the DMCA—and copyright as a whole—can exist is the Copyright Clause [1].

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Clause

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by kube-system on Monday December 23, 2024 @01:09AM (#42492216)
Section 8 of the Constitution explicitly allows Congress to protect copyright.

> To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries;

The 1st amendment didn't repeal this.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by atoav on Monday December 23, 2024 @07:07AM (#42493826)
Yeah, but current practise isn't in any way promoting the Progress of Science and useful Arts.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by kube-system on Monday December 23, 2024 @05:10PM (#42498006)
SCOTUS has ruled multiple times that Congress has the authority to determine policy that they believe best fulfills this part of the clause.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by atoav on Monday December 23, 2024 @07:26PM (#42498676)
Meaning the words of your constitution are worth nothing, gotcha.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by int_19h on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @07:43PM (#42506044)
This actually kinda makes sense, and the argument goes like this. It is rather obviously subjective what constitutes "promoting science and useful arts" (including the very definition of "useful" etc). So when it comes to enforcing this clause, you need some body to decide on what these translate to in practice. And this can be either the courts or the legislature. Between the two, the legislature is the one that citizens have more control over, so giving it the ability to decide is intended to make these kinds of abuses easier to rectify (just vote for the right guys!) as opposed to dealing with obstinate courts.
Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by kube-system on Friday December 27, 2024 @05:01PM (#42526472)
Let me assure you that you haven't discovered something hundreds of years of legal scholars didn't yet realize. You are simply mistaken as to how that clause is interpreted within the context of the rest of the document ... part of which outlines the division of roles and responsibilities for judging and executing that clause.

All of that aside, "science and useful arts" never referred to the little guys. This always referred to the interests of commercializing those endeavors.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by willis936 on Monday December 23, 2024 @07:12AM (#42493849)
Correct, just as section 8 didn't repeal the 1st amendment. Congress does not have power to enact legislation that violates the 1st amendment.

Since section 8 exists DMCA is nearly entirely redundant. Repealing DMCA would do nothing to strip copyright owners of their rights.

Re:'United Healthcare' Using DMCA Against Luigi Mangione Images by kube-system on Monday December 23, 2024 @05:22PM (#42498083)
DMCA has withstood a lot of 1A tests in court, even some very specific and narrow fair-use claims. The suggestion that the entire law is infringing is simply unfounded. There are many limitations that the court allows on speech under the 1A, and most of those aren't even listed as exceptions in the Constitution, as copyright is in section 8. As unpopular as it may be, the constitutionality is pretty solid.

> Repealing DMCA

Be careful what you wish for. Repealing DMCA would mean repealing Safe Harbor provisions, which would just make it just about impossible to run websites with user-submitted content. DMCA might have some problems, but do you really want website owners to be held liable for everything a user posts on their site?

> Since section 8 exists DMCA is nearly entirely redundant.

Absolutely not. There is zero overlap between the two. Section 8 doesn't establish any copyright law at all. It merely establishes Congress's right to regulate it.

> Repealing DMCA would do nothing to strip copyright owners of their rights.

That's a pretty loaded statement to make. There are obviously things that rights owners couldn't do if the DMCA was repealed. I think what you're really arguing that those things don't matter? That could be a valid opinion, but it's still irrelevant. If Congress has the power to regulate something, they also have the power to regulate it ineffectively.