The argument you're making is applicable when a website decides not to publish your speech (they're not the government, so the 1st amendment is irrelevant), but the DMCA is different.
Using the DMCA like this is censorship by copywrite, and it does go against freedom of speech in society at large, but it's not a 1st amendment issue.
Freedom of speech is an American ideal. It's in the Bill of Rights because it was so important. Not as a tool to restrict this right to just government infringements. It is supposed to be a universal right.
I often wonder at those arguing that it's 'ok' somehow in some circumstances because, not protected except for the govt! Somehow they've lost sight of the ideal.
> Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Bill_of_Rights
If it was supposed to be a universal right for everyone/everything, it would be something like "no one shall make a law..."
American ideals are not restricted to the Bill of Rights. My entire point.
> It's in the Bill of Rights because it was so important. Not as a tool to restrict this right to just government infringements.
In the Bill of Rights, it's restricted to just government infringements.
Almost makes me wish it was mandatory for companies to support counter claims and to treat a customer no differently if they've filed a counter claim. (E.g., GitHub can't close your repos as long as you file a counter claim, unless they would have regardless of the DMCA claim.)
The DMCA is an exception because it's a law, just like a threat or any other illegal material/etc would be and removal of that thing can be mandated by law without it being a 1st amendment issue.
Eh, the DMCA is still a law providing for civil and criminal sanctions based on speech. There are probably fundamental First Amendment problems with copyright.
The answer to why the DMCA—and copyright as a whole—can exist is the Copyright Clause [1].