News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by kundi on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:17PM (#41662112)
It's disappointing to see how they cannot see what it means for libgen to exist in the broader sense.

Books should be free for all, and we should encourage and educate people to donate back the value they received from them

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by lucb1e on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:17PM (#41662823)
> donate back the value they received from them

Maybe this is not the topic you were going for but this triggers me because I've long wondered how to do pricing fairly in general. If you're a monopolist or in a highly competitive market, what strategy could you use regardless to arrive at a fair price? I think the answer is cost + a little bonus because nothing else really works. If I had to pay the value it brings me for everything in life... what are my glasses worth, half my salary? The work computer (as an IT person) is maybe three quarters of my salary? That already does not add up and I still haven't paid for the food I need or my office chair

The person who makes it knows the cost price and needs to set a price for money to work, I think. Which is not to say that donations can't work, you can always feel free to make an exception and give the author a good day, but it wouldn't work as a general payment model I don't think

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by johnnyanmac on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:13PM (#41664569)
It's an eternal struggle. The "perfect capitalist" wants infinite money with zero cost labor. The "perfect consumer" wants high quality products for free delivered instantly.

Even if we assume a more altruistic ideal, a businessman needs enough money to keep providing their services. But as the economy gets worse, that breaking point becomes less and less obtainable for a reasonable consumer (who's price is "cheap enough to maintain their QoL"). You can't really fix that without lobbying to being down living expenses as a whole.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by BadHumans on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:08PM (#41664029)
There is no pricing that would satisfy the person you are responding to other than free.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by Dylan16807 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:48PM (#41664797)
"Price" is not being used in a completely literal sense here. The core of the comment is how to calculate "value they received", and neither person involved would say it's $0.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by BadHumans on Thursday September 26, 2024 @08:42PM (#41665149)
I fully understand what they are saying. I'm saying it doesn't matter. There is a group of people that believe anything above free is too much. For both software and books.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by Dylan16807 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:20PM (#41665352)
If you're talking about people that think nothing should be paid, then kundi is not one of those people, and you're responding in the wrong place.

If you're talking about people that think payment should be optional but encouraged, then your "There is no pricing that would satisfy the person" "it doesn't matter" argument is incorrect. It does matter to those people and you can have a productive discussion about the correct amount.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by BadHumans on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:55PM (#41665525)
Encouraging people to donate does nothing. People are encouraged to donate to open source and you see how many open source projects the internet depends on that are wildly underfunded. Maybe you believe people are more charitable than I do.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by Dylan16807 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:59PM (#41665837)
This is an entirely different conversation though, and it doesn't invalidate the conversation they were having earlier about the correct amount.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by ASalazarMX on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:21PM (#41665671)
There is a group of people that believe getting less money than the maximum they can is too little. Let's not base business models on extremes. For example, Humble Bundle has shown there are other ways.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by BadHumans on Friday September 27, 2024 @08:23AM (#41669595)
You haven't used Humble Bundle lately have you? They increased their minimums on the bundle and increased their required cut. Now, did they do this because they are hurting for money or for greed? I don't know.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by account42 on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @08:30AM (#41707514)
The latter, "Humble" has long been just a brand and does no longer reflect the ethos of those running it.

> In October 2017, the company was acquired by Ziff Davis through its IGN Entertainment subsidiary.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by salawat on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:34AM (#41671784)
...And they aren't unreasonable when these things have been rendered non-rivalrous goods.

Tell me, what price should your parents have charged you for teaching you to tie your shoes? To cook? To clean? Get back to me when the cost of digital reproduction requires factories, and trucking fleets, and paper mills. Oh wait... It doesn't. It requires transliteration to the written word, document layout, and maybe a little marketing so the world knows it's there.

If the paper book can be delivered for $8.99, there is no excuse for the ebook to be $8.99 per reader en perpetuity. Even Thomas Jefferson bloody understood that concept 200 years ago. One who lights their own candle off of another's leaves the one who was lit off of none the worse. So to with knowledge. The owners of industrial printing presses are just terrified of the possibility of the dawn of their own irrelevance. So they dump what money they get in creating artificial information asymmetries to exploit tor profit. And therein lay the root of all evil.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday September 26, 2024 @08:44PM (#41665170)
An obvious candidate in this case would be the pro-rata share of the cost of creation. Possibly offset by ability to pay, e.g. if you can afford to pay a little more then do so because some people can't afford to pay as much and you still want the overall total to cover the cost.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by BobaFloutist on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:08PM (#41662696)
How should authors get paid? What about editors?
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by saulrh on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:27PM (#41662951)
Unconditional basic income. Grants for the arts. Stipends. Unconditional basic income. Sponsorships. Unconditional basic income. Donations. Maybe even unconditional basic income.

Look, no artistic endeavor needs to make a billion dollars. Even when something does take a billion dollars in revenue, none of it goes to the artists anyway! Music labels and movie studios and book publishers are infamous for creative accounting and bogus contracts and outright lies to fuck over almost every person that actually contributed to the art. They're worse than politicians. It's all there to funnel even more money to people who are already rich. If you put artists on basic income you're not paying them any less, you're not losing anything, 99.9% of them come out ahead of where they would've been if they'd sold their work for money. Maybe add a couple more nines to that list. For every multimillionaire movie star or generation-defining author there are literally hundreds of thousands of artists just barely scraping by. Capitalist art only benefits the leeches.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by daedrdev on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:21PM (#41663530)
If the UBI is high enough for people to live on with no other income, then I think it will be too expensive for the state to avoid going bankrupt as millions of people stop doing productive work to live easy lives.

If it is not enough to live on, then only the independently wealthy can do art, which goes against the exact goal you stated.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by dbspin on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:12PM (#41664059)
> as millions of people stop doing productive work to live easy lives

Or alternately, millions of people will cease busy work which adds no value - and engage in genuinely productive tasks instead. Caring for their families, locally growing food, building collaboratively, teaching and learning form one another. We only reach for succour and addiction when dispirited and alienated. Graeber was far too conservative in his definition of bullshit jobs. The vast mass of us now work in the production of bureaucratic services so far removed from an actual good as to be incalculable. Our work is bullshit, or worse - actively destructive, and we know it.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by dwallin on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:10PM (#41664046)
That's clearly a false dichotomy, even the post you are replying to outlined a number of ways which an artist might supplement their income.

Also the idea that a significant UBI would lead to people just coasting seems patently false. Every bit of evidence shows that when given the opportunity the majority of individuals are driven to improve the quality of their lives; and also, that quality is measured in relative and not absolute terms.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by daedrdev on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:02PM (#41664492)
I guess I'm a pessimist then.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:00PM (#41665247)
The amount of money you actually need to live if you're willing to live a spartan lifestyle is quite modest, e.g. sleep four to a room, eat a lot of rice and beans, exist in the absence of luxury.

Most people want more than this and will work for it. But accepting it as a form of sacrifice to achieve your other goals is hardly a problem -- and then people can create their art or start their own business with sweat equity before it generates any revenue etc.

Artists would then get the UBI and whatever they get in terms of patronage, donations, art sales, etc. Neither of which might be enough to live a middle class life on its own, but both together makes it happen. And then the people who make a go of it but never manage to produce "art" anybody cares enough to support at all never make it out of the tenement and retain that incentive to do better or find a different path in life.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by account42 on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @09:10AM (#41707889)
> And then the people who make a go of it but never manage to produce "art" anybody cares enough to support at all never make it out of the tenement and retain that incentive to do better or find a different path in life.

And importantly, they continue to have their basics covered while they do that. Part of the reason most people end up stuck in bullshit jobs is trying for something better is too risky.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by tharmas on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:30PM (#41662985)
Authors? Its the publishers who get paid. The authors just write the words.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by lyu07282 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:52PM (#41663224)
Authors and editors should be able to live from their work and libgen et al should exist as well. I don't think it's so incomprehensible to imagine that reality because we are living that reality right now. We can also save a lot of money if we get rid of publishers. People will always buy physical books that will be enough to sustain authors, on top of that we can subsidize from taxes. You have to remember that not everyone is a liberal.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by daedrdev on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:17PM (#41663500)
The vast majority of authors are not popular enough to live on their works. Publishers actually loose money publishing vast majority of their books, meaning most authors gain value from the publisher since the publisher clearly is loosing money to the author.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by fsflover on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @10:13AM (#41708725)
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by didgetmaster on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:31PM (#41662269)
Do the same people who think that every line of code ever written should be free; also think that every book, article, or painting should also be free?

Or are there people who draw lines and say that one type of work product should always be free while it is OK to charge for another?

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by jazzyjackson on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:37PM (#41662327)
they might suggest various other revenue models aside from royalties.

For instance, taking on production of art as a commission or pre-sale, releasing a book once a fundraising goal has been met, but not attempting to sue people for unauthorized copies after the fact

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by littlestymaar on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:34PM (#41662290)
Maybe get back to the original 20 years of copyright protection instead of the insane “70 years after death of the author” that has been made solely for the interest of the IP holders?
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:11PM (#41662734)
Eh idk but books should definitely be free. We can talk about the rest once the books are free.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by didgetmaster on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:52PM (#41664409)
So if authors refuse to spend the time and resources needed to get a work ready for publication because they will be denied any compensation for doing so; should they be forced to write them anyway so that you can have your free books?
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by Dylan16807 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:56PM (#41664855)
What's the purpose of this question? Their answer is almost certainly "no", and that doesn't contradict anything they've said in this conversation.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:06PM (#41665582)
Correct yes I totally want to make authors into literal slaves.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by RunSet on Friday September 27, 2024 @10:24AM (#41670883)
Fiendish; the most clever part is that authors who are already slaves to their own creative urges may not notice any change.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by yard2010 on Friday September 27, 2024 @11:05AM (#41671370)
Let's say books are free like they should be. What about water? Housing? (Public) Transportation?
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @09:40AM (#41708254)
I’d probably argue a ubi but yeah in effect
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by johnnyanmac on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:15PM (#41664583)
My code could effectively be free. The thing is most consumers don't care for code, they care for products. So I don't think open sourcing a currently closed source project would impact 99% of tech out there.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by ang_cire on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:17PM (#41664602)
All my code (that isn't owned by a business, contractually) is free (well, technically I have a couple of private repos, but they're not paid access, they're just not available). So are all of the translation and commission work I did: people were paying to choose what I'd do next, not to keep something exclusive for themselves.

Corporatism is going to be the death of art, because we've normalized the idea that art is an ancillary function of some business project that first and foremost wants to generate profit.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by JonChesterfield on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:21PM (#41662151)
Do you have thoughts on persuading people to spend years of their lives writing books for zero compensation?
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by dleeftink on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:39PM (#41662363)
Many have done so, and will continue to do. No one has to be persuaded if they have thoughts on their mind. Compensation is the side-effect.

[0]: https://monoskop.org

[1]: https://www.rheingold.com/texts/tft/

[2]: https://computerhistory.org/collections/

[3]: https://oapen.org/

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by BobaFloutist on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:09PM (#41662715)
So, that creates a world (not too dissimilar to our own, but notably so) where only the independently wealthy can ever afford to produce art full time. Can you see any downsides to that world?
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by pksebben on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:33PM (#41663017)
I'd be more on board with this take if it were artists engaging in these lawsuits. Elsevier doesn't elicit the same sympathy, though.

'Stealing' from a company with 2B in profit (much from publicly funded research), LibGen is looking a lot like Robin Hood to Elsevier's Prince John.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by johnnyanmac on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:19PM (#41664615)
It's the same issue. If writers could meaningfully get an audience who buys their work independently, they wouldn't need a publisher.

Publishers offer support and printing, but ultimately an author needs a publisher to spread reach (i won't say "make money", because authors sure won't make much). Becsuse it's all about being loud and publishers have resources to be loud. Much better odds compared to a grassroots community paying a fair price when the author is ready to release.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by rudnevr on Friday September 27, 2024 @08:11AM (#41669478)
The problem is that publishers, being the middleman, take over authors the same way the supermarket network takes over the food producers. Publishers own the shelf and a price label, and being less numerous and more organized, they can effectively own the audience's attention. They can help, they can also shut author down. They're not ultimately interested in maximizing availability, because they profit directly from the gap. That's why they need restrictions and ways around them.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by Hunpeter on Friday September 27, 2024 @02:56AM (#41667139)
Maybe a billion-dollar company has more money to spend on lawsuits than artists do? Doesn't make them the good guys, but I'm not surprised that it's them doing it.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by ursuscamp on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:42PM (#41663132)
The greatest and most lasting art in human history was created by artists who were sponsored by the wealthy as their only source of income.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by BobaFloutist on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:29PM (#41664684)
So you don't think there's a downside to the wealthy having a defacto monopoly on what art gets created?
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by dansitu on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:03PM (#41663369)
This is survivorship bias: art owned and protected by wealthy sponsors has a much higher chance of making it through the years. Most art is folk art, and has been lost to the centuries.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by johnnyanmac on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:20PM (#41664620)
The did say "longest lasting art". It feels more survivor bias to mention the Picasso's of history over the many more wealthy who spent their time in the craft.

It's not fair, but it makes sense. And sure the most well known art is not the best art. But a place like this should know the best tech is rarely the most popular product.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by yreg on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:07PM (#41662685)
I dislike copyright as much as the next guy, but the people who want to write and share free books can (and do) do that now as well.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by johnnyanmac on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:23PM (#41664640)
Being paid and knowing they can spend their livelihood writing while paying rent is about the best persuasion you can have. Aside from the wealthy who don't need to worry about that.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by k_roy on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:35PM (#41662307)
The people who are using libgen, are probably also not the people who would pay an author for a book anyway.

Not saying I agree or disagree one way or another, but that's really probably the reality.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by PhysicsStudent7 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:54PM (#41662535)
I've bought multiple physics textbooks which I've first downloaded from libgen. I'm not going to spend 50-100€ of my money on a book before skimming through the contents first. Also some textbooks on niche topics can cost more than 200€ or cannot be found at all.

The alternative would be to make a request for my university library to get the book, but I don't know how long that would take if it would happen at all.

Would the world be a better place if I stuck to studying only the books in local libraries and what I can personally afford? I personally don't think so.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by johnnyanmac on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:25PM (#41664663)
Sounds like a good opportunity to start lobbying to raise library funding, maybe even overhaul it into the 21st century so we can reasonably have a government funded "Netflix of books" of sorts.

Also long term, but it'd kill like, 5 birds with one stone.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by littlestymaar on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:38PM (#41662347)
> The people who are using libgen, are probably also not the people who would pay an author for a book anyway

Quite the opposite: as with all piracy, the ones who pirate stuff are also the ones who spend the most money buying the stuff they pirate. (For books there's the obvious reason that paper is still by far the best reading experience, but it was also true of DVD, video games, music CDs etc. but these people wouldn't have spent more money if piracy was impossible).

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by catlikesshrimp on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:51PM (#41662503)
The only med books I bought were atlases (histology, anatomy, etc) Everything else I borrowed, photocopied or bought second hand. Many of my classmates did the same. In our group, very few rich students ever photocopied or bought second hand

If books weren't sold for profit, we would have better books, only released less often. Back then, we didn't have so many yearly releases, and I honestly think that isn't needed.

Why would we have better books you say? Similar to how open source projects draw very good programmers. Some do it for prestige, and some weird ones do it for the joy o f doing true quality work. IMHO

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by k_roy on Friday September 27, 2024 @08:41PM (#41676916)
> Quite the opposite: as with all piracy, the ones who pirate stuff are also the ones who spend the most money buying the stuff they pirate. (For books there's the obvious reason that paper is still by far the best reading experience, but it was also true of DVD, video games, music CDs etc. but these people wouldn't have spent more money if piracy was impossible).

you take a few interesting leaps in a failed attempt of.... trying to turn opinion into fact?

> the ones who pirate stuff are also the ones who spend the most money buying the stuff they pirate.

Uhhh, wot??

Please provide ANY source for this. Really. Like even if it's a blog you wrote and was a creative writing experiment for you, publish it. Just so I can mock you.

> (For books there's the obvious reason that paper is still by far the best reading experience, but it was also true of DVD, video games, music CDs etc. but these people wouldn't have spent more money if piracy was impossible).

So at this point, I hope it's clear that you are a bit silly. But...

> For books there's the obvious reason that paper is still by far the best reading experience

This level of intellectual dishonest is horrible, especially if it's legitimate.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by littlestymaar on Saturday September 28, 2024 @02:36PM (#41682113)
How do you expect do have any kind of conversation with this behavior? Flagging is the only thing that you'll get.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by k_roy on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @11:37AM (#41709825)
And how can you expect to have any level of honest discussion if you are going to make insane assertions, with zero backup of anything resembling facts, and then get bent out of shape when called out about it.

I'm sorry that I called you intellectually dishonest and you got mad, but it's the truth.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by tharmas on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:33PM (#41663018)
>The people who are using libgen, are probably not the people who would pay an author for a book

Isn't that supposed to be the publisher's job? They don't. Just ask the authors.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by amelius on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:49PM (#41662465)
This is like saying that no great software would exist if people didn't get paid for developing software.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by visarga on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:06PM (#41662673)
> Do you have thoughts on persuading people to spend years of their lives writing books for zero compensation?

Most books make very very little income for the author. So it is already the case.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by daedrdev on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:29PM (#41663611)
I don't think we should make it even worse for them. They are at least going to make some money for their long months or years of work with a chance to make it big.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by nanna on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:11PM (#41662736)
I buy most of my books second hand. The author doesn't get anything from that either. Should it be illegal?
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by johnnyanmac on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:33PM (#41664707)
I think a used market exchange where someone had to buy each product is a different scale from one buyer who uploads infinite copies to the internet.

It's a tragedy of the commons. Not a commons of the product tho, of the ability to keep the creations flowing.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by shiroiushi on Thursday September 26, 2024 @08:35PM (#41665096)
The secondhand market helps the firsthand market: people are more likely to buy something at the offered price if they know they can resell it on the secondhand market later.

Can you imagine what the automobile market would look like if you couldn't trade-in or sell your car and just had to trash it? New cars sales would plummet.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by hotspot_one on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:53PM (#41662528)
Do you think books which are written by people who had to be persuaded to write them are worth reading?
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by visarga on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:09PM (#41662710)
Yes, the second order effects of money incentive. Internet and movies also suffer from enshittification.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by daedrdev on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:30PM (#41663634)
I think the chance of financial success can incentivize the author to make a better work. Let the authors who are willing to write for free release their work for free.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by jazzyjackson on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:39PM (#41662360)
They should find a patron or grant making institution that values the production of knowledge, not publishers who seek property to license out.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by emaro on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:29PM (#41662230)
I think a UBI could be a good start.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by readthenotes1 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:05PM (#41662662)
I'm willing to receive that. How much will you be giving me?
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by __MatrixMan__ on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:24PM (#41664168)
Iirc the current rate is 120 CRC per month. Sign up here: https://circles.garden/welcome/onboarding

The real question is: are you willing to build a community around accepting it? Otherwise it's just numbers.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by ndileas on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:31PM (#41662265)
Lots of people already do, in essence.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by littlestymaar on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:35PM (#41662309)
Wait until you discover that researchers aren't compensated by publishing corporations for their papers. Or that most book authors get ridiculous royalties in their publishing contract (a few percent of the price, including for ebooks that are being sold at the price of paper copies) unless they are already famous.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by Sebb767 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:00PM (#41663964)
> Wait until you discover that researchers aren't compensated by publishing corporations for their papers.

Yes, but most researchers are compensated by either the state, universities or companies hoping to profit of their research. Little high-level research is done for the fun of it.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by littlestymaar on Friday September 27, 2024 @02:11AM (#41666821)
Given how low the pay can be when not working on hot topics, one could argue that most research is in fact done for the fun of it.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by JonChesterfield on Tuesday October 01, 2024 @02:49AM (#41705302)
ACM charged me to publish. After I'd written the paper and after their peer review process which was not convincingly value adding, but it was something like $100 so I paid it. Overall experience makes it likely I'll just post to arxiv instead next time.

(In fairness that fee did nominally grant access to read other papers by them as well, but the credentials they sent out didn't let me log in and I didn't bother contacting them to resolve it)

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by mullingitover on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:15PM (#41663480)
Yes: we can pay authors nothing. It works. In fact we can make them grovel to get something published, and even get them to pay for the privilege of being considered for the publishing we're offering zero compensation for.

We can give ourselves a cool name. "Elsevier" has a nice ring to it.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by readthenotes1 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:09PM (#41662706)
What it means for libgen to exist in the broader sense is that we are used to pilfering what we value but cannot afford.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by daedrdev on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:15PM (#41663475)
I think the creator of a book should be able to charge for their work if they desire to do so for a reasonable amount of time, actually, especially considering most authors don't make a lot of money form their works.
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by zozbot234 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:31PM (#41663643)
> Books should be free for all

Most books that are in the public domain today (hence with no legal hindrances whatsoever) are still not meaningfully free or available to all. Copyright turns out to be simply a minor issue when viewed in a larger perspective; actually making works meaningfully available whenever this can be done free of legal issues is actually a lot more important. Note that this encompasses discovery and findability (e.g. through detailed cataloging) as well as practical access (e.g. through availability in a variety of open formats). It's a hard problem and one that's far from being comprehensively addressed.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:25PM (#41664178)
I agree with the sentiment.

Also, interesting username.

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by johnnyanmac on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:10PM (#41664543)
Books are ideally free for all as is. That's the goal of a library. But we know how that's going...
Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by mistrial9 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:41PM (#41664758)
>Books should be free for all

yes certainly, thank your local library.. your country has them?

> we should encourage and educate people

yes certainly, but many people have had income from a book economy. Some certain books of great quality might increase in price. How can people wish for no-book economy so quickly?

Re:U.S. court orders LibGen to pay $30M to publishers, issue... by goochphd on Friday September 27, 2024 @10:10AM (#41670710)
I don't even mind paying up front anymore. I'm in a position where I can afford it now, though for most of my adult life I've relied on sites like this to make ends meet.

However the only thing I want from publishers is DRM-free e-books (same for music). If you offer a way for me to actually own the digital property I'm buying, I'm going to buy it. If you make it hard or impossible to transfer between my devices, or share with my wife and kids (i.e. how physical media works), you're not getting my money and I'll find another way to get the book.