News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:55AM (#39704052)
The test is essentially a success at this point. Starship can take payload to orbit and open/close the payload doors. The remaining things are icing on the cake. They can refine re-usability while flying payloads.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by golol on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:04AM (#39704941)
One technical modification: They need engine relight in orbit to work to deliver payloads, otherwise Starship will stay in orbit and they can not test reentry.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by neffo on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:19AM (#39705142)
You need a second burn just to enter orbit. You burn at the top of the sub-orbital arc (opposite side of the earth) to enter orbit.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by exDM69 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:11PM (#39705760)
No, that's inefficient and real spacecraft don't do that for typical low earth orbits. Works in Kerbal Space Program, though.

Normal orbital insertion is a single burn to orbit (with staging). With the correct initial roll and pitch, the spacecraft follows a perfect gravity turn and ends up in a near circular orbit at main engine cut off.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotancohen on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:36PM (#39706064)
Do they typically burn softly until near apogee, then put on the power until raising the orbit on the other side to their current altitude? In KSP, I can easily get an orbit on a single burn (with staging) but getting it circular obviously requires adding energy at apogee.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by exDM69 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:50PM (#39706235)
No, most rocket engines have quite limited amount of throttle capability and run near maximum thrust until cutoff.

The rocket yaws and pitches in the first seconds of flight while the vehicle is still subsonic, then flies a gravity turn trajectory at zero angle of attack (facing the direction of travel) at near maximum thrust. Any errors accumulated during early part of the flight will be corrected by adjusting the timing of the second stage cutoff based on radar tracking.

The initial pitch over is just a few degrees off vertical, but must be precise to a fraction of a degree (KSP tolerances are higher due to small planet).

You can get a pretty good circular orbit in Kerbal Space Program with one burn if you do a few attempts and trial and error binary search for the optimal initial pitchover angle, but it's very difficult to do without throttling the 2nd stage burn. If I recall correctly, the MechJeb mod can do a precise single burn to orbit.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotancohen on Thursday March 14, 2024 @01:04PM (#39706410)
Thank you. Yes, I figured that real life engines could not throttle enough for the maneuver as stated. I am familiar with the gravity turn, but I just don't see how energy can be added continuously, uniformly right up to a circular orbit. But I've not really put much effort into trying to understand that, I'll start looking more at real life pitch angles at various altitudes. Maybe I just need to start that gravity turn sooner - you mention that it already starts in the first few seconds. Thank you.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by exDM69 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @02:43PM (#39707496)
In vanilla KSP1 with a reasonable orbital launcher, fly up to 1000m altitude and tap D on your keyboard 1 to 10 times. Then hands off until 2nd stage and then throttle down to avoid overshooting the apoapsis.

Finding the correct number of key taps to get the right pitch angle is the key. The throttle can only help so much.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotancohen on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:52PM (#39710910)
Will do, thanks. 1000 m is in fact much lower than I usually pitch. Off the pad I've been giving just a touch of pitch to ensure that the rocket is on the right trajectory, but didn't start the gravity turn until maybe 5000 m or so to get out of the thick atmosphere sooner. Yes, I would have quite the AoA for a little while.

Thank you. Though I don't expect to open KSP any time in the near future, I love to know how the real rockets do it.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by exDM69 on Friday March 15, 2024 @05:10AM (#39713554)
1000m is much higher than real rockets pitch over, but good for KSP with forgiving aerodynamic stress. It's just a convenient round number and gives a few seconds of breathing room to make sure the fiery end of the rocket points to the ground before start of maneuvering.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotancohen on Friday March 15, 2024 @09:14AM (#39715110)
I do remember the Shuttle pitch and roll real early, though I thought that was to point the antennas (K-band was it?) at the receivers.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by exDM69 on Saturday March 16, 2024 @04:53AM (#39724313)
The roll is to change the orbital inclination, the pitch is to set ascent trajectory.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotancohen on Monday March 18, 2024 @01:18AM (#39740696)
Got it, great. Much appreciated!
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by ericbarrett on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:47PM (#39709350)
MechJeb + Realism Overhaul offers a "Primer Vector Guidance" ascent controller that (I think) is based on the space shuttle's Powered Explicit Guidance. It's definitely designed to work with more realistic spacecraft; it can ullage with RCS, doesn't need to throttle, etc.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by numpad0 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:58PM (#39706350)
IIUC real launchers do a single burn to orbit because S2 TWR is not very high and relight is finicky. Launchers that has relightable S2 and/or hypergolic S3 routinely do circularization burns.

There are reasons "apogee" is more recognized word than "apoapsis".

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by lupusreal on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:23PM (#39708534)
> There are reasons "apogee" is more recognized word than "apoapsis".

What are you getting at? The -gee suffix means Earth. Apogee is apoapsis of an orbit around Earth. People playing KSP speak of apoapsis because Kerbin isn't Earth.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by numpad0 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:46PM (#39708748)
IRL they always did and therefore discussed "apogee kicks" after payload release into elliptical transfer orbit(literally GTO). That's where I'm getting at.

If you think about it, there can't be an ellipse that intersects a circle while also being fully encompassed by the latter. That's to say the periapsis can't be higher than the maneuver altitude that the off-apsis burn takes place as the other guy is suggesting.

On real rockets they add small shelf-stable stage such as the spinny boi Star-48 or the notoriously narcoleptic Fregat, inside fairings between S2 payload interface to actual payload, or let the payload pull itself into the final orbit at a great expense.

Yes, you can keep the S2 burning all the way to Ap and then burn at -45deg at Ap to deform the ellipse back into a circle, or fly a by the book gravity turn trajectory, but that's not the most energy efficient insertion, only what are situationally beneficial when there is land below and acceleration is limited.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by firebaze on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:52PM (#39709394)
They do this while performing the burn of the (in this case) 2nd stage. "No, that's inefficient" is misleading, IMHO. They also waste some delta-V by starting the circularization burn a little bit early.

You surely know that, but mathematically it is unavoidable to have a 2nd burn at the apoapsis to have an orbit (with a periapsis > the initial launch altitude, minus gravity and atmospheric losses), albeit it may start earlier (while wasting a slight amount of delta-v).

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:53PM (#39706289)
> You need a second burn just to enter orbit

Not necessarily - it is completely dependent on the ascent profile. For example, during the Apollo program, the Saturn V would fly directly into a parking orbit and only relight the S-IVB for the Trans-Lunar Injection burn.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by travisgriggs on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:36AM (#39704585)
I wouldn’t classify the re-entry survival problem as icing. But otherwise, I agree with you.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:47AM (#39704736)
They can launch payloads that bring in revenue while working on that problem. There is a good chance they put a bunch of Starlinks on the next flight.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Laremere on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:57AM (#39704868)
They might do one to test deployment, but it'd be a throwaway. Their relight test was skipped (not said why), so they still don't have confirmation they can control where Starship re-eneters. Until that happens, it's very unlikely they'll target actual orbital velocity. The Starlink satellites do have thrusters, but they're ion engines, so not nearly enough thrust to get that last bit into orbit before they'd re-enter.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by toomuchtodo on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:38AM (#39705401)
As long as it is profitable when thrown away, the math works. Remember, until Falcon 9, they were always thrown away (except for Shuttle). Even if not profitable in the short term, the delta between cost and breakeven is an R&D expense.

Payload able to be delivered to orbit safely and insurable? Ship it. The more you do, the faster you get better.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by baq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:20AM (#39705154)
99% chance that they lost attitude control hence couldn't point the business end towards wherever they wanted to. we know they can relight the engine on the booster and we know they can relight for landing burns.

no surprise if the next launch has a couple pre-production big starlink birds.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by LorenDB on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:25AM (#39705216)
On the contrary, they absolutely had attitude control. Otherwise reentry would have seen the ship tumbling out of control and quickly breaking up. Instead, SpaceX was able to begin a controlled reentry in the upright position, indicating nominal orientation performance.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Laremere on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:11PM (#39705765)
My bet on the re-entry failure is that they have really poor attitude control. They definitely had some, but you can also see at different points that the plasma was shifting directions. At T+46, it was doing a spin as the first plasma started to show. At T+47, it was going down on the edge of the heat shields. At T+47:40 it appears to be going down engine first.

Moreover, I'm guessing the reason they skipped the mock re-entry burn was due to not being able to settle the propellant. Though it's really hard to tell if the turning of the Starship was to rotate which side was getting heating from the sun, or if it was spinning out of (or with less than desired) control.

Tim Todd noticed that the gas thrusters were icing over and then releasing the ice. So it's a reasonable guess that this was part of the issue, but that's leaning even more into speculation territory.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Laremere on Thursday March 14, 2024 @02:13PM (#39707178)
I just noticed that I typed "Tim Todd" instead of "Tim Dodd". It's past the edit period so I shall forever live with this shame. In my defense, I was on 5 hours of sleep so I could watch the launch.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by bdamm on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:46PM (#39708750)
You are a contemporary yet timeless sort of gentleman. Well done.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Plasmoid2000ad on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:38AM (#39705397)
I'm no so sure, it at least looked like it was tumbling before and throughout re-entry. If they had attitude control, I think they would have at least stopped the visible rotation at some point before re-entry?

I'm not sure why the ship not immediatly breaking up, but eventually breaking up is proof that they at attitude control - especially against what the live feed showed - rotation.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotancohen on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:40PM (#39706105)

  > If they had attitude control, I think they would have at least stopped the visible rotation at some point before re-entry?
Maybe they thought the flaps would help stabilize once hitting some atmosphere. In fact, that seemed to happen though not before quite a bit of plasma cooked the unshielded side.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by baq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:35AM (#39705359)
they were tumbling, just slowly. they started reentering side first. that it broke at 65km was unsurprising - shuttle experienced peak heating about there.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by numpad0 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:23PM (#39705904)
I'd speculate one of main tank bulkheads breached and gas kept leaking from payload door which overpowered RCS. Then, during reentry, the vehicle briefly managed to regain attitude by aerodynamic forces on the flaps, but became north-northwest aligned and broke up.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by bitcurious on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:11PM (#39705756)
> know they can relight the engine on the booster and we know they can relight for landing burns.

Do we know that? Booster crashed into the water at full speed; landing reignition failed.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by apendleton on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:37PM (#39706080)
They did demonstrate this during their Starship-only bellyflop/landing tests a couple of years ago. This wasn't in space, though, obviously, and wasn't after an extended coast period. So... we know they can relight them under at least some circumstances, but whether or not they can under _these_ circumstances is maybe unclear.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by throwuwu on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:55AM (#39704849)
Exactly, they’ve reached feature parity with large expendable launch systems so they can piggyback paying customers with a high risk threshold (starlink) on flights they’d be doing anyways. Given their cadence this phase won’t last long, they’ll likely achieve at least one successful landing next flight.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by gorkish on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:18PM (#39705848)
Yes this would all be true, if it were true. It is likely to become true at IFT-4 but they are very demonstrably not quite where you say they are.

This was still a suborbital flight and they cannot do much of anything that is commercially practical on suborbital flights (like launch satellites, even if they raise their apogee). They appear to have not had good control authority in coast and reentry. They did not do a relight/deorbit burn test that is likely an obstacle to tackle before they can make orbital flights. I assume we'll get some confirmation about these things soon enough, but please, you can be optimistic without being hasty.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @02:09PM (#39707149)
> This was still a suborbital flight and they cannot do much of anything that is commercially practical on suborbital flights

If they had flown a slightly steeper ascent and burned for a little longer (possibly a minute if not less), they would have ended in a stable orbit. Not doing that was intentional.

They do not need engine relight capability to reach orbit - plenty of orbital rockets exist that cannot relight their final stage.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by bdamm on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:42PM (#39708719)
Yes, but the point was that they can't launch starlinks or just about any commercially meaningful payload until they are reliably in orbit, and they can't reliably get into orbit until they demonstrate at least one relight, because they need to reliably re-enter the atmosphere for the reusability tests.

So they are at least one more launch away from launching starlinks.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:08PM (#39708993)
> commercially meaningful payload until they are reliably in orbit,

Which then can do without a relight.

> and they can't reliably get into orbit until they demonstrate at least one re-light

And part of testing deorbit/landing capability includes testing that they can relight the engine.

So they could launch the next one with Starlinks (possibly test articles of those as well since no full-size V2 satellites have been laucnhed yet). Get it into orbit and include a deorbit burn/re-entry as part of the flight plan. If the latter part somehow still does not work out ... they still got Starlinks into orbit. And they now have more data to fix it on the next flight. They already have several vehicles lined up for static fires and flight tests.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by bandyaboot on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:55PM (#39709417)
They won’t put starship into orbit until they can test relight. They won’t risk, nor would they be allowed to risk putting it up there without a demonstrated ability to bring it back down in a controlled manner.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Friday March 15, 2024 @01:15AM (#39712270)
> They won’t put starship into orbit until they can test relight.

Why can't they test relight? Also, they are already filing paperwork for IFT-4:

https://apps.fcc.gov/oetcf/els/reports/STA_Print.cfm?mode=cu...

"Application includes a sub-orbital first stage booster and an orbital second stage"

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by bandyaboot on Friday March 15, 2024 @10:14AM (#39715975)
They can test relight, but my point was that they wouldn't do it with Starship in orbit, because if it doesn't work, then they have no idea where it's coming back down. But maybe that's not as much of a problem as I had assumed given what's stated in the FCC application.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by zardo on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:41PM (#39710356)
> They do not need engine relight capability to reach orbit - plenty of orbital rockets exist that cannot relight their final stage.

I don't think SpaceX is interested in having uncontrolled Starship re-entries. It's large enough that (even without a heat shield) debris will very likely make it down to surface.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by gorkish on Friday March 15, 2024 @10:41AM (#39716293)
> They do not need engine relight capability to reach orbit - plenty of orbital rockets exist that cannot relight their final stage

I’m sure they will have this thing plez dispensing cybetrucks all the way to mars in short order. But I’m also pretty sure that the FAA and whoever SpaceX buys their insurance from are gonna need pretty good assurance that they can control where that thing comes down. Expendable orbital stages are designed and engineered for safe end of life operations and uncontrolled reentery. Starship is not.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by ortusdux on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:03AM (#39704931)
They have also been eager to launch version 2.0 starlink satellites, but they don't fit in the falcon fairing. The first couple batches of those would be test articles as well, so I'd be surprised if the next starship launch doesn't a few on board.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotnet00 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:42AM (#39705457)
They've been launching a version of the v2 sats that do fit in the Falcon 9 fairing and supposedly have all the functionality of the larger versions. The issue is that F9 can only carry ~24 of those at a time, which slows down the pace of expansion a lot.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by ortusdux on Thursday March 14, 2024 @01:59PM (#39707051)
The new 'Pez dispenser' on the starship is designed for the full sized V2 sats, which are about 2x the mass of the V2 minis.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by wongarsu on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:44AM (#39704689)
They have a great pipeline for building ships. They want reusability, but for near-term needs like deploying bigger Starlink satellites and their moon lander contract they could probably power through without reentry survival. It would be expensive, but unlike in-orbit refueling not really mission critical
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by ncallaway on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:29PM (#39705968)
> but for near-term needs like deploying bigger Starlink satellites and their moon lander contract they could probably power through without reentry survival

Starlink sat deployment, probably. I’m not convinced on the moon lander contract though. Each mission requires the moon lander itself, plus a number of tanker launches to refuel the moon lander. I think it’s something like 8-15 tanker launches.

If each of those tanker launches is an expendable vehicle that’s… probably economically survivable, but definitely not sustainable.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by generalizations on Thursday March 14, 2024 @01:56PM (#39707024)
Though, if the tankers are expendable they won't have to reserve fuel for the landing, and the number needed to refuel would probably be at the lower end of that estimate - maybe even 6-10?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by imtringued on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:38PM (#39709779)
If you can't reuse the boosters, then a series of Starship launches to the moon will cost as much as one SLS. The complex launch architecture demands reusability. It's a deal-breaker without it.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by TMWNN on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:47AM (#39704743)
My understanding is that Starship is financially comparable to Falcon 9 on a per-payload basis even if fully expended.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotancohen on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:44PM (#39706156)
Comparable to Falcon 9? Unlikely - they've got three dozen Raptor engines on that thing, which alone account for the entire cost (not price) of a Falcon 9 flight. Maybe it is comparable to legacy launch providers, such as the Deltas and Atlases. But unlikely comparable to a Falcon 9 launch, even considering the larger payload.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by avmich on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:40PM (#39708693)
In https://payloadspace.com/starship-report/ the cost of Falcon-9 launch is estimated as $15M. One Raptor is less than $1M, but full Starship has 39 Raptors.

Starship will be much more attractive when it will become fully reusable though.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dzhiurgis on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:31PM (#39709218)
You are launching 8x more payload vs ~15 reuses of Falcon9
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by senectus1 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:37PM (#39710781)
the weights isn't the only upgrade, the SIZE is another very important metric....

They'll be able to get much larger objects up there without having to piece them together up there. Especially important for habitable objects and factory objects.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotancohen on Friday March 15, 2024 @03:19AM (#39712883)
The current iteration of Starship has a payload bay door fit only for the Starlink satellite.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by senectus1 on Friday March 15, 2024 @10:18PM (#39722744)
"The current iteration" is also just a proof of concept. Their published plans include fliptop and large bay doors. not to mention the HLS (Human Landing System) that includes an airlock.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by cryptonector on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:02AM (#39704910)
If so that would be amazing.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by thinkcontext on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:12PM (#39711398)
That's what they aspire to. The only way to get there is if they are able to achieve reuse into the dozens of times and there's no guarantee they will be able to do that. I hope they are able to but there's still a lot of work to get there.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by bell-cot on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:00AM (#39704902)
If their cost per kg to orbit, with total loss of both Booster and Starship, is substantially lower than any of their competitors - then it is success, and recovery is just icing on their profit margins. Er, cake.

(And would be very cool marketing and PR, obviously. Not that SpaceX has much need for either of those.)

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by avmich on Thursday March 14, 2024 @01:33PM (#39706755)
No quite; even if 1st and 2nd stages deliver cargo to orbit cheaper than competition, you still has to make sure there is enough demand to pay back the cost of Starship creation. That demand may require not just being cheaper, but to being substantially cheaper than competition, to enable additional uses.

What SpaceX is doing with Starlink reminds of the situation with early versions of Windows, when, as Bill Gates described, the industry wasn't keen to produce applications for it. So Microsoft started writing Word and Excel in house. Similarly, SpaceX created Starlink which needs lots of launches, and which couldn't exist with previous level of launch prices, but is able to make profits if the prices are as low as SpaceX can provide.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by cchance on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:28PM (#39705959)
Re-entry is icing because every other cargo rocket besides falcon, lands just like IFT3 lol
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by imtringued on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:40PM (#39709798)
Artemis 5 only needs three New Glenn rockets. Artemis 3 and 4 need significantly more Starships.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by johnyzee on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:41AM (#39704655)
Yeah, breaking up in-air during re-entry (at 65 km going by last telemetry) seems like a potential big issue to fix.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotnet00 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:48AM (#39704758)
OP's point is that the tests become a bit cheaper and a bit easier to get licenses for since they can get to orbit and can deploy Starlinks. The reentry problems of course have to be fixed, but the FAA mishap investigation will involve fewer delays, just like how Falcon 9 was able to keep flying, attempting landings without having to wait for a mishap investigation to finish every time a landing failed.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by usrusr on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:44PM (#39708731)
Iirc F9 had its main challenge in that final suicide burn. Usually the boosters made it there just fine and then "only" failed to get the parameters aligned just right.

Based on what we saw today, the main chokepoint for Starship might be right in that hot reentry telemetry blind spot. Debugging without logs.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:24PM (#39709155)
Unlike with F9, in this case they most probably had high-bandwidth telemetry all the way till the vehicle broke up (if the high-def video stream is anything to go by). So, they probably have a lot more data this time. Even the video can yield information - for example, given that the cameras were mounted on the flaps, they can probably back out the actuation angles from that.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by usrusr on Friday March 15, 2024 @11:36AM (#39716925)
Video feed interruption was very much expected, and went through a series of on/off before the final signal. From what we saw in the live presentation, both scenarios are possible: breakup while transmission was up, transmitting as long as latency allows, with hopefully good explanations in the log, or a disconnect from the challenging radio situation in the reentry plasma long before something went wrong.

Unless they do find some failure buildup in the logs they did receive, it will be difficult to tell disconnect due to breakup from breakup (long) after disconnect. Gradual signal loss on the receiving side would indicate that it's likely the latter, but I'm not sure a signal loss unrelated to breakup would necessarily be gradual. I'd guess atmospheric properties can change fast at reentry velocity.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotnet00 on Friday March 15, 2024 @01:14PM (#39718139)
In the livestream they mentioned that they lost signal on both Starlink and TDRS simultaneously, which is why they figured it had broken up at that point. They were prioritizing the telemetry over video frames on Starlink, and TDRS can only handle telemetry.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by usrusr on Friday March 15, 2024 @01:27PM (#39718307)
Thanks, must have missed that detail in the stream. Hope they find a good explanation candidate in the data!
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotnet00 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:52PM (#39708820)
It sounded like they might have had flight data recorders on-board which might have survived through reentry with telemetry. If so, they'd have some logs, but yes, figuring out reentry will likely be the main challenge for now, not only is it hard to debug, even getting to it requires everything else to go more or less perfectly.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by smallmancontrov on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:18PM (#39709094)
With all the solid state gizmos we have today, is it really that difficult to make a blackbox that can survive serious impact G-forces, especially if it just needs to work and doesn't need to be safety rated?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by tempaway444641 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:45AM (#39704715)
The point they were trying to make is that getting up is MVP, getting back down can be figured out later
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by baq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:23AM (#39705194)
it's the expected outcome of an imperfect (literally not precisely perfect) reentry. something went wrong. it could be a very minor thing like a stuck valve somewhere. we'll know in the next test if they figured it out.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:55PM (#39706315)
> Yeah, breaking up in-air during re-entry (at 65 km going by last telemetry) seems like a potential big issue to fix.

That's what pretty much every non-SpaceX rocket does today with very few exceptions.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by ta1243 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:19PM (#39707898)
And indeed every spacex rocket. Starship is the second stage -- and a second stage on a F9 burns up in the atmosphere just as much as Starship from IFT3 did.

The big things to fix seem to be

1) The roll rates for starship (which prevented the inflight relighting test)

2) The Booster relights, which didn't have enough lighting to soft land.

Both of those feel like minor problems.

I'm amazed that the propellant transfer demo seems to have worked first time, and of course they managed to get the tihng up there in the first place.

The reusability of the Starship part of the system is a much bigger unknown, but that doesn't seem to be necessary for the next launch.

Wouldn't surprise me if the next try is by the end of April

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by engineer_22 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:18PM (#39707886)
bright side: booster made it all the way to splashdown
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by senectus1 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:39PM (#39710808)
haha, it was travelling at 1100 km/h...

Not so much a splashdown but a smashdown :-D

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by engineer_22 on Friday March 15, 2024 @11:15AM (#39716683)
to have been a fly on the wall... was surely a site to behold :)
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by aeternum on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:43PM (#39708721)
Why? Saturn V broke up in-air during re-entry on every "successful" launch as does every ULA rocket.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by johnyzee on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:06PM (#39708979)
Because that is their stated design goal for Starship.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:25PM (#39709163)
And you don't need to meet that goal to start launching (risk-tolerant) payloads to orbit during their test flights. Especially with such a hardware-rich development program.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by gameshot911 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:44PM (#39706160)
I'm not sure the payload doors successfully opened and closed. Anyone have more details?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by hagbard_c on Thursday March 14, 2024 @01:06PM (#39706435)
I heard the announcement about the door opening and saw - what I assume to be - live images from the inside which showed the door first opened, then closed so it seems that test worked.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by MostlyStable on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:27PM (#39709686)
Scott Manley seems to believe that there was some kind of malfunction with the doors[0]. I couldn't really tell from the video, but he certainly knows a hell of a lot more in this domain than I do. He does agree that overall the test was highly successful though.

[0]https://youtu.be/8htMpR7mnaM?t=512

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by hagbard_c on Thursday March 21, 2024 @05:50PM (#39784821)
Here's an evaluation of things going wrong on the flight by three 'Youtube space flight watchers' (Fraser Cain, Scott Manley and Marcus House) including possible mishaps with the cargo door:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVic941kQ44

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by ajross on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:35AM (#39704577)
Not quite: the apogee burn they had planned didn't happen (no word as to why yet), so the ship didn't technically demonstrate the capability reach orbit. It came back down in the Indian ocean on its original suborbital trajectory, essentially like an ICBM.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:38AM (#39704615)
That is a matter of the trajectory they chose on purpose for this test flight. A different flight profile would have given them a perigee above the atmosphere (rather than -50 km)
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Laremere on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:46AM (#39704721)
Parent's (correct) point is that it isn't a matter of the ascent trajectory. They can't leave the Starship up in orbit, and where it reenters needs to be controlled.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:53AM (#39704826)
> They can't leave the Starship up in orbit, and where it reenters needs to be controlled.

Why? Plenty of boosters re-enter uncontrolled and burn up all the time.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotnet00 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:22AM (#39705180)
Typically American policy is to have a controlled reentry option for as much as possible. The disposable first stages of all rockets don't need a controlled reentry because they are always suborbital and thus their splashdown location is relatively well known ahead of time. The second stages are typically supposed to deorbit and burn up over water after a launch to LEO. There are occasional cases where something goes wrong and they fail to deorbit, which is when we sometimes hear of the burn up due to gradual orbit decay being witnessed over land.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Laremere on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:04AM (#39704939)
Afaik, when talking about objects large enough that some debris will actually hit the ground, only China intentionally lets their final stage re-enter uncontrolled. Everyone else at least has a plan for controlling re-entry. SpaceX has lost control of some of their Falcon 9 second stages before, but that's the exception not the rule.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by wolf550e on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:14AM (#39705071)
Starship is huge and heavy and made of steel, it will not burn up on reentry, if it falls on a populated area it will kill people. They will not be allowed orbital trajectories until they demonstrate they can control the deorbit burn.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotancohen on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:47PM (#39706195)
An empty Starship has a very low ballistic coefficient, it will be torn apart by the atmosphere if not carefully controlled. Add to that the FTS and there is no real danger to population on the ground.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by wolf550e on Thursday March 14, 2024 @01:36PM (#39706788)
Of course it will not maintain its shape, but the pieces that land will be large.

It's made of 4mm thick steel sheets, and the FAA disagrees with you.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by mlyle on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:08PM (#39708392)
Columbia was torn apart by the atmosphere... and dropped huge chunks that were a danger to people on the ground-- some as large as a VW Beetle.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Toutouxc on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:02AM (#39704922)
First thing that comes to mind: Starship has a lot of protection against burning up, so huge chunks of it could survive and cause damage.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by terramex on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:00AM (#39704895)
Non-reusable boosters don't go into orbit and perform calculated crash into ocean soon after launch.

Small second stages and spacecrafts can be allowed uncontrolled orbital reentries because they usually burn-up. Starship is too big for that, debris would rain like when Space Shuttle Columbia disintegrated over land. They most likely will need to show engine relight capability to control reentry point before going orbital.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by golol on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:08AM (#39704993)
Ok so they could leave Starship in orbit and launch payloads like that. The idea however is to launch payloads WHILE testing reentry and landing. This requires an engine relight in orbit.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:03PM (#39708948)
> WHILE testing reentry and landing.

> This requires an engine relight in orbit.

The latter is part of the test at this point of development

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by ajross on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:59AM (#39704890)
Stated simply: zero-thrust "orbits" repeat the same trajectory again and again. So if you end your burn in the outer atmosphere near your launch pad, the next time around you will be back in the outer atmosphere (near where the the launch pad "was", ignoring the rotation of the planet). And since there's air there providing resistance, you'll re-enter and crash.

Getting to orbit requires at least one more burn near the apogee of the original orbit to circularize it and ensure the spacecraft doesn't approach the atmosphere again. Starship didn't do the apogee burn they intended to do, so didn't demonstrate this capability.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DiggyJohnson on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:42PM (#39706140)
Singe burn to orbit is pretty common though in reality, with the dynamics of staging, engine throttling, and precision insertion capabilities most modern rockets can hit the mark.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:57PM (#39706345)
> Getting to orbit requires at least one more burn near the apogee of the original orbit to circularize it and ensure the spacecraft doesn't approach the atmosphere again

The Saturn V went direct to Earth orbit without requiring relighting the third stage engine.

[dead]
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotnet00 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:44AM (#39704698)
That's impressive revisionism. Where's the Soviet reusable launch vehicle that is half the price, is able to reuse even one stage and takes less than a month to refurbish?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by iwontberude on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:45AM (#39704716)
Nevermind
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by GolfPopper on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:50AM (#39704774)
Sounds like the Russians could clean up in space-launch market. Why aren't they?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotnet00 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:57AM (#39704866)
The latest Soyuz revision is ~$50m per launch, it has a payload less than half of a Falcon 9 that lands on a droneship, and ~2/3rd of a Falcon 9 that returns to launch site. Making it twice the cost per kg. The highest flight rate it has ever achieved has been 2/month. It has a 96% success rate.

The latest Falcon 9 revision is ~$67m per launch. Lately it flies every ~3 days. Over the past year it has flown ~100 times. It has a 99.4% launch success rate, and a 98% landing success rate.

Clearly this shows that the Russians are superior.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by golol on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:09AM (#39705011)
>The latest Falcon 9 revision is ~$67m per launch

And that is the price, the cost is unknown but likely lower.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotnet00 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:25AM (#39705225)
Yeah, the internal cost is believed to be ~$30m, but I didn't compare on that number since we don't have a well known number for Soyuz's internal cost.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by iwontberude on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:33AM (#39705328)
I don’t know what I’m talking about. Thanks for the info.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by tempaway444641 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:19PM (#39705855)
Props for replying
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:48AM (#39704754)
Interesting. What is this amazing Russian rocket that can put 200 metric tons in Low Earth Orbit while being expendable?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by blkhawk on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:52AM (#39704799)
Good thing that falcon 9 is already very much less than "half" the price.

And starship should be utilized fully will probably ven cheaper for the same mass-to-orbit

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by tempaway444641 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:53AM (#39704825)
Show me anyone that _ever_ got a cost per kg to leo cheaper than spacex
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dang on Thursday March 14, 2024 @01:27PM (#39706678)
Please don't replace the text of comments like this once they have replies. It's unfair to the users who responded because now their comments lack the necessary context to be understood.

We're all wrong sometimes and it would be fine to add an "Edit:" after the original text followed by an explanation or retraction or whatever you want.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by iwontberude on Friday March 15, 2024 @03:33PM (#39719779)
I agree, please revert the edits
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dang on Friday March 15, 2024 @11:24PM (#39723098)
That's kind of you, but I think it's enough if you'll simply fix the problem going forward.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by enraged_camel on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:33AM (#39704535)
I think they also successfully demoed in-space fuel transfer.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by xondono on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:36AM (#39704588)
Fuel transfer with what? That would require things like docking
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Tor3 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:38AM (#39704612)
They transferred something like 10 tonnes of fuel from one end of the ship to the other.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by enraged_camel on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:39AM (#39704630)
They performed an in-ship fuel transfer, from one chamber to another. My understanding is that this is a very important pre-requisite for an actual transfer from one ship to another, because of the need to keep the fuel at cryogenic temperatures during the transfer, which is apparently not easy. Last time it was done was decades ago, but in kilograms. SpaceX just demoed a transfer of tons of fuel.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by extraduder_ire on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:32PM (#39706017)
Bigger problem than keeping it cryogenic is getting it to one side of the tank while in orbit, so the pumps don't run "dry". Harder than just doing an ullage burn first too, because moving that amount of mass around also moves the vehicle.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by hagbard_c on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:38AM (#39704614)
Transfer internally between tanks in the bottom and top of the ship. This was one of the planned tests, I have not heard whether it was accomplished though.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by dotnet00 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:43AM (#39704677)
There was a callout saying that it was successful.

Edit: On the other hand tweets from Gwynne suggest that they still need to review the data to see if it was a success.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by cchance on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:32PM (#39706011)
They used tanks inside the ship to transfer from 1 to another to prove the process, was discussed and called out as success, and talked about many times before the flight
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by bane on Thursday March 14, 2024 @01:45PM (#39706889)
Here's a fun thought, how many Starship launches would it take to put the equivalent mass of the ISS up in the same orbit?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @01:49PM (#39706942)
The ISS weighs ~420 metric tons. That is 2-3 expendable launches or 3-4 reusable ones.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by trailynx on Thursday March 14, 2024 @02:47PM (#39707533)
for comparison, building the ISS took 40 assembly flights [0] (36 of them from the Space Shuttle)

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assembly_of_the_Internationa...

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by GeoAtreides on Thursday March 14, 2024 @02:23PM (#39707302)
Jesus Christ, that really puts it into perspective what a game changer starship is
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by bane on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:01PM (#39707687)
Now do the same calculation in units of hubble space telescope and james webb space telescope masses.

Then look at expected reusable launch cost and figure out how many HSTs or JWSTs we could have put in orbit for the same cost.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by 93po on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:56PM (#39708275)
JWST would also be incredibly less expensive if it didn't have to do the very complex folding required by smaller rockets
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Retric on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:48PM (#39708775)
JWST would still have been an extremely novel and therefore expensive on Spaceship. We just don't build anything that uses that kind of sun shield or those sensors etc and everything needs to work on one shot, thus serious engineering effort.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Teever on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:00PM (#39709988)
With Starship flights it should be the right combination of cheap enough, frequent enough, and big enough to enable whole new paradigms of construction in space.

We'll be able to design modular space telescopes that benefit from economies of scale, so that we'll be shipping up the sun shield in separate pieces anyways so if any particular one is lost that's okay we'll have an assembly line to produce more.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Retric on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:17PM (#39710139)
Launching several doesn't solve the issue of needing a design and construction that actually works. For something nobody has ever built before and we can't really test in zero g without launching etc.

Unfolding the heat shield was a relatively minor design issue compared to say the instruments, we just had less ability to actually test it on the ground.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by birdman3131 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:29PM (#39709199)
How much larger could we have made it still doing the folding on starship?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by 93po on Friday March 15, 2024 @12:09AM (#39711983)
I have no idea. Ariane 5 rocket has payload dimensions of 15x50 feet. Starship is 26x56ft. The unfolded mirror is 21 feet across, so if you increased that by 73%, then 36 feet. This is all probably really unfounded assumptions

The benefit of starship here is probably being able to massively reduce the expense and risk of future JWST duplicates that don't need to fold. Also in the launch cost, which was $1 billion for Ariane 5 whereas Starship would be in the tens of millions.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Shawnj2 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:10PM (#39709537)
Launching JWST on Starship would still be incredibly expensive because JWST is at the Lagrange point on the other side of the moon and 1 starship needs like 30 other starships to fuel it to get there
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by 93po on Friday March 15, 2024 @12:02AM (#39711947)
How do you explain how the Ariane 5 used for the JWST, with a mass to GTO half that of Starship, was able to position the JWST without 60 launches?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by Shawnj2 on Friday March 15, 2024 @12:08AM (#39711982)
Simple, it’s designed to launch a payload into lunar orbit and starship isn’t. To move something using starship into lunar orbit you need to move an entire starship there while the Ariane 5 is designed to do it in 1 launch at the expense of much less payload capacity and no reusability.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by 93po on Friday March 15, 2024 @11:46AM (#39717042)
I still don't follow. The Ariane 5 launched the JWST with enough fuel to get where it's needed. Starship can launch the exact same payload, plus twice the entire weight in extra fuel. Starship also offers no-reusability launch options for stuff just like this.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by danw1979 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:21PM (#39707920)
Not just the capacity per launch but the cost per launch also.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:16PM (#39707864)
How many launches are required to land on the Moon?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:02PM (#39708937)
Depends on what lunar lander hardware is being used. If we were using Apollo hardware:

Apollo LM: 16 metric tons (landing about 5 tons on the moon)

Apollo CSM: 29 metric tons

The third stage of the Saturn V, called the S-IVB, (which was used for the trans-lunar injection burn) weighed 123 tons - however this was also used to get into the initial orbit.

Starship can launch 150 tons to LEO in reusable mode or ~200 mt when expended. The Saturn V was able to launch 141 tons to LEO. So it should theoretically be possible for Starship to launch an LM+CSM stack with an S-IVB with enough fuel for a trans-lunar injection burn. Then fly the rest of the mission as in Apollo.

Or we can refuel the Starship a few times in LEO using a bunch of re-usable flights and land 100 tons of payload on the lunar surface. The latter is probably cheaper and simpler at this point.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by GuB-42 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:52PM (#39709918)
According to this: https://youtu.be/OoJsPvmFixU?si=Df6Eq9uq6IJCApUs&t=1730

Six... eight... more like twelve... at least 15

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by rtkwe on Thursday March 14, 2024 @02:32PM (#39707389)
Big things they still need to hit are soft splashdown of both stages because recovery and reuse are critical to the economics of Starship. From the stream it looks like they had barely any engines light during the landing burn and I could see several missing tiles on the second stage. Way fewer were missing though which is a bonus, last time they were visibly missing a lot of tiles even before they lost the stage.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by jkjkjjjkjkj on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:01PM (#39707694)
Well, the second stage definitely needs to survive re-entry if it wants to carry passengers. But it seems to work as-is for orbital cargo.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by mgiampapa on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:20PM (#39707906)
Passenger rating isn't even in the cards for Starship for a long time. You ride to LEO on a Faclon-9 with a proven track record for the foreseeable future.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by avmich on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:50PM (#39708800)
"Foreseeable" is roughly "five years"? Starship HLS (Human Landing System) is currently planned to land on the Moon, with people, in 2026. It may very well slip a year, two or three - but landing on the Moon this decade still seems quite possible. Or you consider "passengers" different enough than "crew"?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by mgiampapa on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:03PM (#39708952)
Yes, landing on the Moon without an atmosphere is vastly different from orbital flight on earth and has an entirely different risk profile.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by grecy on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:39PM (#39709280)
Interesting Asterix on that is the humans will only be on Starship from Lunar orbit down to the moon surface and then back to lunar orbit again.

No humans aboard during Starship launch, transit to and from the moon or re-entry.

(For completeness, humans will do all that other stuff aboard SLS and Orion. Starship literally only ferries them down the moon and back up again)

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by avmich on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:28PM (#39709692)
Yes, but HLS is just one example. In, say, ten years it may look very possible that Starships with people will fly on LEO. Is it beyond foreseeable future?.. I just don't understand why such a pessimistic estimate.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by mgiampapa on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:37PM (#39709770)
In my view, since I was the one that said it, anything more than 5 years away is perpetually 5 years away until it's been proven. Yes, eventually when Starship has enough launches and a track record it will get human rated by NASA to carry astronauts. This is the only actual certification for human space flight worth paying attention to right now. It's possible to get on a rocket otherwise, but the US government isn't going to pay for the ride. Getting flight certified by NASA is expensive and requires a level of experience with the vehicle that doesn't make sense for at least 5 years given we have a cheap and safe ride to LEO via Falcon / Dragon. Nobody is going to rush human flight on Starship, it's only going to have people on it once it's already in space.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by avmich on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:56PM (#39709957)
I'll still take this as progress. With thermonuclear reactors it's perennial 20 years, similar for flying cars, in-house robots, manned flight to the Mars, so 5 years as a stand-in for "foreseeable future" sounds like a good step ahead.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by grecy on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:43PM (#39710839)
I just looked it up.

The first Falcon 9 flight was June 2010.

The first Falcon 9 with astronauts was May 2020.

10 years to get human certified.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by mgiampapa on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:06PM (#39711358)
That was also with a rush order on it due to the Shuttle's retirement.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by grecy on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:20PM (#39711751)
Good point.

In those 10 years Falcon 9 flew 84 times [1].

So I would think Starship needs to fly roughly a similar number of times before it will be human rated. Even if they launch one a month from now on, it will take ~7 years. So I think we're a while away from NASA certifying Starship for human flight, though I wonder in SpaceX would just put their own people on it regardless.

[1] https://www.popularmechanics.com/space/rockets/g32758515/fal...

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by kristianp on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:29PM (#39709197)
Maybe the words "success" and "failure" are too difficult to shoehorn into describing these tests, especially with the first two tests.

"Great progress" is a good intermediate.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:32PM (#39709229)
When you write a test case, you define what "Passed" means. If this test flight overall meets SpaceX's definition of "Passed", then it was a success, regardless of what anyone else thinks it should mean.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:51PM (#39709379)
If your test case for left pad passes when it outputs a string of the right length, your boss is going to judge whether it's a good test case. Since this is all being done on federal grant money, it's legitimate to have higher expectations. This test was good, though - the previous two were disappointing.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by f-securus on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:05PM (#39709493)
Holy cow. How are people downplaying something so revolutionary. Without those other tests SpaceX wouldn’t have done what it did today and they show progress each step. They are doing what nasa couldn’t (send stuff to space orders of magnitude cheaper) because they aren’t afraid to blow stuff up.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:26PM (#39709668)
They haven't gotten to the revolutionary part yet (fuel tankers in orbit, raptor relight, reusable first stage, reentry).
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by f-securus on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:43PM (#39709838)
Re-using rockets isn't revolutionary?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by jordanb on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:23PM (#39710189)
I think it might have been back when the shuttle did it in 1981.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by f-securus on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:54PM (#39710463)
The shuttle that cost 450 million per launch? (And disposable boosters)
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by paledot on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:12PM (#39710587)
The boosters parachuted to the ocean and were reused. Only the external fuel tank was not reusable. However, you're correct that the Shuttle failed utterly to realize the point of reusability, that being low cost and quick turnaround.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:42AM (#39714082)
Moving the goalposts. I didn't say it wasn't revolutionary either, just that they haven't gotten to that part yet.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:31PM (#39709715)
Nobody has done anything revolutionary and nobody has gotten to space an order of magnitude cheaper. The best estimates of SpaceX's cost advantage per kilo put it at 30-50% better than a Soyuz.

The Starship program so far has soaked up as much money as SLS, and hasn't even left orbit.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by jiggawatts on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:55PM (#39709949)
They did several revolutionary things with starship:

Full-flow staged combustion metholox engines.

Stainless steel construction.

Biggest rocket to have ever flown.

Highest thrust at launch of any rocket by a factor of two or so.

Live streaming of reentry via a space Internet network.

Etc…

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:06PM (#39710053)
Those all sound like incremental technology advances to me that have yet to deliver any real advances in capabilities. Which is nice - don't get me wrong - but not exactly worth rolling out the aircraft carrier for.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by jiggawatts on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:17PM (#39710142)
Someone else in this thread pointed out that Starship could get the ISS built in just 3 launches! It originally took dozens.

Quantity has a quality all of its own.

You should be familiar with this from IT: there’s nothing fundamentally different about the first computer that I’ve ever used to the one I have right now, the than the factor of a million difference in performance!

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:37PM (#39711213)
Starship today can't launch anything. Saying that it can launch the ISS in 3 launches is what Elon Musk says it can do. I don't trust Elon Musk's word for things until I see what someone does with those words. Generally, he is off by a factor of 10-100 on his promises.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Friday March 15, 2024 @01:17AM (#39712277)
> Starship today can't launch anything

Why not? With the capability demonstrated today, they can just as easily tweak the ascent profile to end up in a stable orbit outside the atmosphere. Their trajectory was suborbital on this flight on purpose.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by satiric on Sunday March 17, 2024 @03:21PM (#39737191)
Well, for one, the payload doors don't work.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by baq on Friday March 15, 2024 @04:01AM (#39713140)
Full flow methalox is absolutely revolutionary.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by thinkcontext on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:14PM (#39711074)
> The Starship program so far has soaked up as much money as SLS, and hasn't even left orbit

There's a bit of nuance to what you are claiming here.

SLS cost $11B to develop, which is estimated to be in the neighborhood of what Starship will cost when development is complete. We don't know how much has been spent so far.

A huge difference is that producing and launching an SLS rocket costs over $2B, while SpaceX is estimating $10M for Starship. Now, I don't trust that $10M number, that's what they aspire for it to cost. To do it they need to be able to reuse the stages dozens of times. It could take a long time to achieve that or they might not make it at all. However, $2B+ per launch is a whole 'nother level of expense.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by bandyaboot on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:14PM (#39709566)
The test flights have been right in line with how spacex does development and testing. I’m confident that everyone involved with granting them that money knew this going in.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by jordanb on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:25PM (#39710208)
It's fine that they've not yet completed any stated launch objectives in three tests and have, amongst them, 5 independent catastrophic vehicle loss events because that's what we expect out of SpaceX.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by zer0c00ler on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:09PM (#39709527)
I think each test served exactly its purpose and it's incredible to see the rapid progress. Unclear why you believe the first two were not a success at all? Did you expect a novel vehicle like this would just work the first time?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:29PM (#39709700)
I do. SLS, Vulcan, and most other rockets from reputable space companies have worked first time.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by macintux on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:41PM (#39710344)
Those are also:

- More expensive than Starship, or

- Took longer to develop than Starship, or

- Are significantly less ambitious than Starship

(and those are definitely not exclusive ORs)

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:03PM (#39710525)
Going by total program cost, both of those are cheaper than Starship. SpaceX does this sleight of hand where they don't count their R&D cost in their calculations, but they do count it in other peoples' programs when comparing. SLS so far is about $2 billion in, and Starship seems to be at $2-3 billion. Vulcan is way cheaper than both.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by sobellian on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:50PM (#39710893)
- Source for Vulcan total program cost? All I can find is their per-launch pricing. Tory Bruno himself apparently said that "new rockets typically cost US$2 billion, including US$1 billion for the main engine."

- Not sure where you're getting the SLS number, the GAO report at https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-23-105609.pdf claims, "Since 2011, NASA has spent $11.8 billion to develop the initial SLS capability."

- I think the marginal cost is a fair question. The whole party line out of NASA was that this time Moon exploration would be sustainable. If each trip costs > $1B before you even put a payload on the rocket that's a big problem.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:36PM (#39711205)
I completely agree with you on marginal cost, but I don't believe SpaceX to provide accurate numbers for their own rockets before they are actually built (they love wishful thinking) or their competitors' (making your competitors look bad is better for you).
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by sobellian on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:05PM (#39711351)
Okay well respectfully I looked at the number you provided for the closest comparison rocket, SLS, and it was 6x too charitable.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by relativ575 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:49PM (#39711282)
SLS flight cost is $2B. Each launch. Did you forget to include the decade prior? It's so expensive that it can fly no more than once a year. The next flight is scheduled for Sep 2025, three years after the first flight. I bet you think that isn't absurd.

SLS use leftover engines from the Shuttle era. Yet it still cost 160 millions. Each. Thrown away after each flight.

Vulcan is a conservative design with no reuse. It also uses BE-4 engine, which costs them nothing to develop.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by gabesullice on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:03PM (#39711001)
The word reputable was an interesting choice to describe Boeing. It also carries a bold implication that the space company shuttling astronauts to and from the ISS—only two days ago [1]—is… disreputable? Meanwhile, Boeing Starliner certainly didn't perform nominally on its first orbital flight test [2].

Space flight is hard and different testing methodologies are no silver bullet. But, I suppose we will know them by their fruits.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Crew-7

[2] https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/?p=802006

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by tibbydudeza on Friday March 15, 2024 @03:02AM (#39712779)
And the Saturn V
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by inglor_cz on Friday March 15, 2024 @10:07AM (#39715898)
I wonder, who decides which space companies are "reputable" and based on which criteria.

It is quite a manipulative word to use.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by thinkcontext on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:55PM (#39710943)
> Since this is all being done on federal grant money

Its true that SpaceX has gotten federal money contract for landing on the moon to the tune of $2.9B. But the Starship program is going to cost a lot more than that, Musk estimated $10B and has done stock offerings to raise money. And you have to take into account that the federal money has to support 100% of the moon specific parts of development.

So, its true that the feds are helping w/ Starship development but "all" is not accurate.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by senectus1 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:35PM (#39710760)
the open and close of the payload doors was a failure.

Not that i think its a big deal... but its important to acknowledge failures so we can learn from them.