News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by kristianp on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:29PM (#39709197)
Maybe the words "success" and "failure" are too difficult to shoehorn into describing these tests, especially with the first two tests.

"Great progress" is a good intermediate.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:32PM (#39709229)
When you write a test case, you define what "Passed" means. If this test flight overall meets SpaceX's definition of "Passed", then it was a success, regardless of what anyone else thinks it should mean.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:51PM (#39709379)
If your test case for left pad passes when it outputs a string of the right length, your boss is going to judge whether it's a good test case. Since this is all being done on federal grant money, it's legitimate to have higher expectations. This test was good, though - the previous two were disappointing.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by f-securus on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:05PM (#39709493)
Holy cow. How are people downplaying something so revolutionary. Without those other tests SpaceX wouldn’t have done what it did today and they show progress each step. They are doing what nasa couldn’t (send stuff to space orders of magnitude cheaper) because they aren’t afraid to blow stuff up.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:26PM (#39709668)
They haven't gotten to the revolutionary part yet (fuel tankers in orbit, raptor relight, reusable first stage, reentry).
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by f-securus on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:43PM (#39709838)
Re-using rockets isn't revolutionary?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by jordanb on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:23PM (#39710189)
I think it might have been back when the shuttle did it in 1981.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by f-securus on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:54PM (#39710463)
The shuttle that cost 450 million per launch? (And disposable boosters)
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by paledot on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:12PM (#39710587)
The boosters parachuted to the ocean and were reused. Only the external fuel tank was not reusable. However, you're correct that the Shuttle failed utterly to realize the point of reusability, that being low cost and quick turnaround.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:42AM (#39714082)
Moving the goalposts. I didn't say it wasn't revolutionary either, just that they haven't gotten to that part yet.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:31PM (#39709715)
Nobody has done anything revolutionary and nobody has gotten to space an order of magnitude cheaper. The best estimates of SpaceX's cost advantage per kilo put it at 30-50% better than a Soyuz.

The Starship program so far has soaked up as much money as SLS, and hasn't even left orbit.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by jiggawatts on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:55PM (#39709949)
They did several revolutionary things with starship:

Full-flow staged combustion metholox engines.

Stainless steel construction.

Biggest rocket to have ever flown.

Highest thrust at launch of any rocket by a factor of two or so.

Live streaming of reentry via a space Internet network.

Etc…

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:06PM (#39710053)
Those all sound like incremental technology advances to me that have yet to deliver any real advances in capabilities. Which is nice - don't get me wrong - but not exactly worth rolling out the aircraft carrier for.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by jiggawatts on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:17PM (#39710142)
Someone else in this thread pointed out that Starship could get the ISS built in just 3 launches! It originally took dozens.

Quantity has a quality all of its own.

You should be familiar with this from IT: there’s nothing fundamentally different about the first computer that I’ve ever used to the one I have right now, the than the factor of a million difference in performance!

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:37PM (#39711213)
Starship today can't launch anything. Saying that it can launch the ISS in 3 launches is what Elon Musk says it can do. I don't trust Elon Musk's word for things until I see what someone does with those words. Generally, he is off by a factor of 10-100 on his promises.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by DarmokJalad1701 on Friday March 15, 2024 @01:17AM (#39712277)
> Starship today can't launch anything

Why not? With the capability demonstrated today, they can just as easily tweak the ascent profile to end up in a stable orbit outside the atmosphere. Their trajectory was suborbital on this flight on purpose.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by satiric on Sunday March 17, 2024 @03:21PM (#39737191)
Well, for one, the payload doors don't work.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by baq on Friday March 15, 2024 @04:01AM (#39713140)
Full flow methalox is absolutely revolutionary.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by thinkcontext on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:14PM (#39711074)
> The Starship program so far has soaked up as much money as SLS, and hasn't even left orbit

There's a bit of nuance to what you are claiming here.

SLS cost $11B to develop, which is estimated to be in the neighborhood of what Starship will cost when development is complete. We don't know how much has been spent so far.

A huge difference is that producing and launching an SLS rocket costs over $2B, while SpaceX is estimating $10M for Starship. Now, I don't trust that $10M number, that's what they aspire for it to cost. To do it they need to be able to reuse the stages dozens of times. It could take a long time to achieve that or they might not make it at all. However, $2B+ per launch is a whole 'nother level of expense.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by bandyaboot on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:14PM (#39709566)
The test flights have been right in line with how spacex does development and testing. I’m confident that everyone involved with granting them that money knew this going in.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by jordanb on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:25PM (#39710208)
It's fine that they've not yet completed any stated launch objectives in three tests and have, amongst them, 5 independent catastrophic vehicle loss events because that's what we expect out of SpaceX.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by zer0c00ler on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:09PM (#39709527)
I think each test served exactly its purpose and it's incredible to see the rapid progress. Unclear why you believe the first two were not a success at all? Did you expect a novel vehicle like this would just work the first time?
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:29PM (#39709700)
I do. SLS, Vulcan, and most other rockets from reputable space companies have worked first time.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by macintux on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:41PM (#39710344)
Those are also:

- More expensive than Starship, or

- Took longer to develop than Starship, or

- Are significantly less ambitious than Starship

(and those are definitely not exclusive ORs)

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:03PM (#39710525)
Going by total program cost, both of those are cheaper than Starship. SpaceX does this sleight of hand where they don't count their R&D cost in their calculations, but they do count it in other peoples' programs when comparing. SLS so far is about $2 billion in, and Starship seems to be at $2-3 billion. Vulcan is way cheaper than both.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by sobellian on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:50PM (#39710893)
- Source for Vulcan total program cost? All I can find is their per-launch pricing. Tory Bruno himself apparently said that "new rockets typically cost US$2 billion, including US$1 billion for the main engine."

- Not sure where you're getting the SLS number, the GAO report at https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-23-105609.pdf claims, "Since 2011, NASA has spent $11.8 billion to develop the initial SLS capability."

- I think the marginal cost is a fair question. The whole party line out of NASA was that this time Moon exploration would be sustainable. If each trip costs > $1B before you even put a payload on the rocket that's a big problem.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by pclmulqdq on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:36PM (#39711205)
I completely agree with you on marginal cost, but I don't believe SpaceX to provide accurate numbers for their own rockets before they are actually built (they love wishful thinking) or their competitors' (making your competitors look bad is better for you).
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by sobellian on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:05PM (#39711351)
Okay well respectfully I looked at the number you provided for the closest comparison rocket, SLS, and it was 6x too charitable.
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by relativ575 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:49PM (#39711282)
SLS flight cost is $2B. Each launch. Did you forget to include the decade prior? It's so expensive that it can fly no more than once a year. The next flight is scheduled for Sep 2025, three years after the first flight. I bet you think that isn't absurd.

SLS use leftover engines from the Shuttle era. Yet it still cost 160 millions. Each. Thrown away after each flight.

Vulcan is a conservative design with no reuse. It also uses BE-4 engine, which costs them nothing to develop.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by gabesullice on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:03PM (#39711001)
The word reputable was an interesting choice to describe Boeing. It also carries a bold implication that the space company shuttling astronauts to and from the ISS—only two days ago [1]—is… disreputable? Meanwhile, Boeing Starliner certainly didn't perform nominally on its first orbital flight test [2].

Space flight is hard and different testing methodologies are no silver bullet. But, I suppose we will know them by their fruits.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Crew-7

[2] https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/?p=802006

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by tibbydudeza on Friday March 15, 2024 @03:02AM (#39712779)
And the Saturn V
Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by inglor_cz on Friday March 15, 2024 @10:07AM (#39715898)
I wonder, who decides which space companies are "reputable" and based on which criteria.

It is quite a manipulative word to use.

Re:Starship's Third Flight Test by thinkcontext on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:55PM (#39710943)
> Since this is all being done on federal grant money

Its true that SpaceX has gotten federal money contract for landing on the moon to the tune of $2.9B. But the Starship program is going to cost a lot more than that, Musk estimated $10B and has done stock offerings to raise money. And you have to take into account that the federal money has to support 100% of the moon specific parts of development.

So, its true that the feds are helping w/ Starship development but "all" is not accurate.