* You don't just take your kids in to work with you. The Google daycares were not any closer to whatever office you happen to work in than some third-party daycare. [edit: they weren't particularly close a long time ago when Google was concentrated in North Bayshore, and then became even less so as Google's offices were spread out more and people bounced around more often, and then became even less so with wfh...]
* You can't actually get in. There was a waitlist and your position on it actually got worse over time (because sibling priority), then later a lottery system where you pay money to play but never win.
* From what I heard recently from a daycare provider (I can't directly verify), it wasn't very good if you did get in. The typical tenure for a teacher was like a month, which is shockingly bad. Like how do you screw up pay/work environment so badly that's possible? And their understanding of children's needs wasn't great either. For example, they organized the kids into rooms by age (which is common but not universal) and...had no transition period at all or hint to the kids that these transitions were coming. They were just in one room one day with one set of teachers, then unexpectedly in another room with another set of teachers the next, which was super confusing and alarming to them.
* It was supposedly subsidized but still strangely expensive. [edit to add: when I first heard about it, this was explained to me as a consequence of it having very high-quality staff who are paid well, but this doesn't match up with the bullet above. Maybe what I heard from the daycare provider was wrong. Maybe quality has gone downhill. Maybe it was never good. I think there are a variety of factors that would have allowed it to continue existing until now without ever having been good. An absolutely tiny proportion of interested people actually were able to try it. Those who did probably felt very lucky to get in and disinclined to complain/give up their exclusive spot, and folks on the waitlist disinclined to listen to their complaints... additionally, many of the parents who went there had never had kids in another daycare to compare against...]
> You can't actually get in. There was a waitlist and your position on it actually got worse over time
This changed after covid. My understanding is that they struggled to fill classrooms due to people moving away from MTV / Palo Alto. We tried to convince friends to enroll their kids for fear of something like this happening. The closure was way worse than we expected (we thought they'd at least do a phased closure) and we kinda regret the advice we gave to friends since they're scrambling to find replacement care now.
> From what I heard recently from a daycare provider (I can't directly verify), it wasn't very good if you did get in
Daycare turnover has been bad industry wide, and our classroom had bad turnover in 2021 but it stablized since then. We've super loved our experience. Really great sanitary procedures, high quality learning objectives and measurement, healthy food, etc.
> It was supposedly subsidized but still strangely expensive.
Yes it's still shockingly expensive. Maybe this was self inflicted at first: I heard that when one of the Wojicki sisters had her kids there they changed out all classroom furniture every year, looked for way overqualified people to do the childcare (like Ph.Ds) and all that. It's not that over the top anymore today, but today they still pay the childcare workers very well by that industry's standards (they also get all the same days off as other alphabet workers) and the facilities are way bigger than others that you'd find on the peninsula, with a playground / yard for every N classrooms.
My personal feeling is: I understand why they'd cut this benefit. I _don't_ understand why they had to cut it in this fashion. Having another daycare company buy it out and handing over operations, or raising prices so it's not subsidized, or phasing out classrooms over N years to give parents plenty of time to find alternative care -- there are just better ways they could have ended this longstanding benefit.
> This changed after covid. My understanding is that they struggled to fill classrooms due to people moving away from MTV / Palo Alto.
Ahh, that explains how my across-the-street neighbor has a kid there.
> Daycare turnover has been bad industry wide, and our classroom had bad turnover in 2021 but it stablized since then. We've super loved our experience. Really great sanitary procedures, high quality learning objectives and measurement, healthy food, etc.
From what this provider told me, the Google daycares' turnover was bad even by industry standards.
Anyway, glad to hear you had a good experience there, and my sympathy as you try to find a replacement!
Edit: oh and $2500/mo for 0-2 yr olds..curious how that stacks up compared to Google day care!
Then my kids went to a Montessori style preschool. Small, run by the owner of 20+ years and a couple of long time staff members. That was great for us. The owner has since retired though and the school changed hands. Nothing lasts forever, I guess...
My kids went to a small local chain where some of the teachers have been with it since it was founded in the 90s, almost 30 years ago. Average tenure was like 10-15 years. Unfortunately they got bought by Bright Horizons last year, and have lost 4 teachers since the school year began (although luckily it's that 4 teachers have rotated into the 2 spots vacated, not that they lost 4 veteran teachers).
Labor aside, a 2 bedroom in Mountain View is quite expensive and doesn't come with learning materials, toys, classmates, etc.
Would be nice if rents were a smaller total of our living expenses though. Everyone would have more breathing room.
Lots of perks aren't widely used, but mostly by choice; a perk I could potentially use is still a perk, and it feels good to have that option.
Pushing toward remote work or asking someone to work on a different campus also makes the on-prem daycare a bit weird.
But yeah, a company day care that has enough spots to serve most interested parents would be a pretty nice perk. But, I think for most parents, a daycare near home is much better, especially those not working from office every day.
You mean the self-propelled code production units that cost more than the other self-propelled code production units? Why would we want to retain those?
I was hoping for flying cars, but as far as signs I am living in the future go, this will have to do
The metonymy of "Big Blue" was regularly used in the series (especially in the pilot) to describe IBM as a huge entity that a forcefully-made new division of a smaller company was competing against, to develop a personal computer in the 1980s.
This scene in the pilot about a salesman trying to convince another company's executives to choose his products over IBM's describes the feeling behind the term very well: https://youtube.com/watch?v=XOR8mk0tLpc&t=65
However I was a senior leader that was paid the salary to lead high stakes projects. YMMV
All the people I know, whose circumstances I don't share except by second-order family relations, and who are indeed well paid senior engineers, actually do have live-in nannies or au pairs. Which is why I mentioned that possibility.
You got my viewpoint and I can clarify if you would like. My goal was to ensure the best upraising of my child. This includes social interaction, so a nanny was a nonstarter. So the 20 minute commute was considered an acceptable trade off (just as others may consider the lack of social interaction in selecting a nanny). When we purchased a new home we factored in the additional 50 minute loss in time and once again put our childrens consideration over our own.
When you are in a leadership position and have to consider the real fact of working over 40 hours a week, those benefits or lack thereof become a factor you (and thus the company) must consider.
I hope this helps you understand, especially one day in the future when you are in this position!
On that note, per the other comment, the family I'm referring to all live in midtown manhattan where nannies and au pairs are the norm, and socialization amongst such families comes with the ecosystem. I assume people who have nannies in other built-up regions operate the same way, but maybe your mileage does vary.
Sure losing daycare benefit is a fault. Deciding to put your child in a lesser program because it won’t impact your commute has nothing to do with your job and entirely everything to do with you being a parent..
In my case I will pay to ensure the best upbringing for my children. And this means financially (paying for the best education) and temporally (waiting in traffic to pick them up from said learning institute).
It's not a matter of affording daycare is my point.
Kinda creepy how they're like company towns, though.
In our story, we were not able to get into the "elite" daycare that all the who's who of my city went to. That daycare cost $1500 - $1100 respectively. We ended up going to our daycare out of necessity which just turned out to be a really really good daycare, so we got lucky. But the point is the extra $2200/mo, as you noted, was part of my salary
Foster City Odyssey Preschool for toddlers is $2100 for school day, plus $500 extended day until 6pm.
https://www.odysseypreschool.com/foster-city-admissions
Pennisula Jewish is $3125 for toddlers until 5:30pm
https://pjcc.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/PJCC-Preschool-R...
The very concept of this is so absurd as to be entirely ridiculous. Title inflation at it's finest.
To think a person can have enough real-world experience to become "senior" in any field within 3-4 years is absolute insanity.
I do suspect if I ran into a 24 year old that called themself a "senior engineer" with a straight face, I'd likely burst out laughing...
Laughing is not taking out one's displeasure on someone.
You have made this statement before, but not taken the time to explain why you believe that. Perhaps if you explain your position others will be more sympathetic to it.
Someone has to have actual experience to be considered senior. Being a couple years out of college is not experienced.
> All it means is the individual has any amount of experience.
By this logic - what would we call someone with 15 years of experience? What about 25 years? Super Supreme Senior Engineer, Level 9000?
The field needs to stop inflating titles. It's bad enough having people willy-nilly call themselves "engineers", let alone tack-on qualifiers like "senior".
If your company wants to grossly inflate titles, fair enough - but your next job will then look like a demotion.
Counting someone as senior purely by a clock is also absurd. It's about knowledge, depth and breadth. A person with 3ish years of experience does not have either... we used to just call that "engineer".
But... go ahead, keep assigning recent graduates absurd titles. Inflating people's egos helps keep salaries low.
> Being a couple years out of college is not experienced.
Apparently you need one more counterexample? I certainly do not think one can be considered senior after 3-4 years as well.
But I would also be curious, how you would then call someone with 15 years, or oh my, 25 years of experience?
You can start hacking on things as a kid with little more than a computer and an internet connection. You can literally have junior engineer knowledge when graduating high school. Add in a bit of formal education and a few years of experience, you can be a legitimate senior engineer at 24.
In fact, one of the best engineers I ever worked with was 21 and working at staff level. Things just clicked with him, so it didn't take long in the professional world for him to round out his knowledge.
By contrast, most other fields require expensive equipment or advanced techniques to gain actual, real experience. A high schooler might be able to weld a track car together, but it's a lot harder for them to do FEA (finite element analysis) or load testing without serious equipment.
Life doesn't start at age 21.
You can't have a "makes decent estimations engineer", or "wasn't quit by the team lead engineer", or "gets paid twice as much data scientist". Some company go with "ninja" or "rockstar", or stick level numbers straight in the title but meh...so we settle for "senior" for most of these demarcations.
L3 is a new graduate
L4 is mid level (an engineer who you can generally trust to complete the tasks they're assigned)
L5 is Senior (who owns/shapes the direction of the team)
L6 is Staff (who has to see upcoming problems and shape efforts across the organization)
L7 shapes a product
L8 shapes a division
L9 shapes an industry
It's very possible that a 24 year old could become an L5 with a typical path: college 18-21, straight to Google for 3 years on the same team and becoming one of the main contributors on the team.
Considering that Google grew its headcount by over 50% between 2020 and 2022, there could be plenty of mid level engineers joining the 24 year old's team who they are able to lead now since they have an extra 3 years worth of experience + context in the specific area.
I think the image of this, as small as it is to the actual scenario of failing to provide care, paints a bleak picture.
We don't even care enough to cleanup the reminders of the pandemic.
About as ridiculous as relying on one particular employer for health care coverage
In an action that was a blow to union control of health plans and a stimulus to employer-controlled programs, the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947 banned union control of welfare funds based on employer contributions. On the positive side, an attempt to explicitly exclude employee benefits from the requirement for collective bargaining failed, and the law retained the vague language of the 1935 National Labor Relations Act that required management to bargain on "wages and conditions of employment." The law also established regulations for joint employer-union control of plans involving multiple employers. [1]
[1] - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK235989/Caveat: only if you absolutely need to go to work in the first place, or you couldn't remote for critical reasons (granted, someone being unremediably miserable at home would be one)
Otherwise dealing with kids is one of the primary factor in choosing remote work, and it's life changing.
A local, close to your home daycare means you have options on who brings the kids and who takes them. It's a few minutes away, so yes you get more time with your kids, it fits into a standard work break, you're there quick enough when puke hits the fan, you get access to your local doctors and hospitals who have your kids' records, etc. All of these "perks" persist if you change job, your kids go to school, etc.
[0] https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/GOOGL/alphabet/cas...
And sometimes your numbers can look better if your profit margin goes up even if your absolute profit goes down. A daycare is never going to have the marginal profit margin of, say, selling more ads.
I don't want to post spoilers here, but the inverted population pyramid is going to result in some interesting times.
Anyway, politicians could always loosen immigration. More people = bigger economy, higher wages for the rest of us, and generally immigrants have higher fertility rates. Somehow neither party wants to acknowledge this.
(yes, the above would come with inflation too—this can be reclaimed pretty easily from the top of the wealth pyramid with taxes.)
Not by much, it's only higher in the origin country afaik.
> yes, the above would come with inflation too
Growing the economy isn't inflationary.
> this can be reclaimed pretty easily from the top of the wealth pyramid with taxes
Rich people don't contribute to inflation as much because they have lower marginal propensity to consume. You need to combat demand-side inflation by taking money away from everyone else, and supply-side inflation by increasing production.
It is if you provide a route to citizenship for ~16M americans, many of which are not making minimum wage.
> Rich people don't contribute to inflation as much because they have lower marginal propensity to consume. You need to combat demand-side inflation by taking money away from everyone else, and supply-side inflation by increasing production.
The goal is to use the inflation to drive a reduction in wealth inequality. If the rich person finds it unfair, I'm sure they can find something to mop their tears with.
Hmmm, I think it more counters a deflationary trend of older local people retiring. It is true that people earning more is likely inflationary (but that's better than all alternatives).
> The goal is to use the inflation to drive a reduction in wealth inequality.
Causation would go the other way round. Wealth taxes are inflationary, insofar as taxes are paid in USD and so you have to sell your assets to get the USD, causing extra transactions. That's a problem since most other kinds of tax are deflationary.
No, tax deductions help higher rate taxpayers more, but "tax breaks" is a more broad/relaxed term that includes tax credits. Tax credits benefit everyone who files taxes and meets the criteria for the credit.
> It would generally be better for the government to provide daycare
Eh, that is kind of a wholly different argument. In some ways the credit is obviously better (maybe it frees up one partner who wants to to stay-at-home parent), and it can be used more flexibly than a government-provided care program, even if you assume arguendo that the government program would be good and/or good value.
[0] https://www.bls.gov/news.release/famee.t04.htm
[1] https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2023/11/child-care.ht...
A lot easier and cheaper to hire in South America right now.
> I'm getting tired of the trope that says avoiding old management frameworks like having asses in seats in an office in the US is driving offshoring
Your words, not mine.
It's easier to plug in remote employees than it was pre-pandemic, this cannot be denied.
So very few people will miss it.
It would be a totally different situation if this were a perk where there had been plenty of supply, so that it actually met employee demand.
genuine question as a bay area resident: which laws are you referring to? do you have a link to something?
I’m not convinced that any modern tech company is actually interested in keeping people around for too long.
I’d be thrilled to be proven wrong, but my own experience has me a bit cynical.
Childcare is good for folks in their mid-to-late twenties, and early thirties. Not even that “senior.” People older than that, often don’t need childcare as much.
So it seems as if they want to have a workforce of extremely young, unmarried people, or maybe a few older, “empty nesters.”
And it's a huge, huge perk. Taking your kids with you to work allows you to not make a second trip every morning and every evening to go to their daycare (which is never exactly on the way) it's good for morale, it's GREAT for work/life balance, it's good for the environment, and the kids spend more time with their parents.
PG&E closed their daycare at 77 beale (Downtown SF) when they moved their headquarters to the ghost-town building in Oakland and very explicitly announced they had no plans to re-open a daycare. If you're reading this and in a position where you can affect change, definitely consider a daycare on site, it's a very effective way to dramatically increase retention of senior employees.