News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by JamesBarney on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:17PM (#38960955)
Given low fertility rates, companies that provide daycare should get large tax breaks.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by anthomtb on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:27PM (#38961078)
Why does fertility rate matter? Subsidizing daycare seems beneficial in any circumstance.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by loeg on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:54PM (#38961415)
Consensus viewpoint is that population stability or (modest) growth is probably ideal from a long-term economics perspective. If fertility rates were sky high, you wouldn't need to incentivize parenting as much to achieve that outcome.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by shiroiuma on Monday January 15, 2024 @11:01PM (#39009325)
Yeah, but who cares about long-term economics? If you're a public corporation, the only thing that matters to you is short-term profits and stock price, and doing things in the society's long-term interest is usually against your short-term interest. Normally, we have governments and regulations to serve as a check here and worry about the long-term interests of society, but that requires a citizenry that votes for such policies. America's voters don't care much about this, as seen by their voting patterns, so it's wrong to worry about long-term economics there.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by willcipriano on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:42PM (#38961254)
> Why does fertility rate matter?

I don't want to post spoilers here, but the inverted population pyramid is going to result in some interesting times.

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by AlexandrB on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:50PM (#38961356)
So would a permanent, non-inverted pyramid. Gotta bite the bullet at some point.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by JeffSnazz on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:52PM (#38961393)
Only for people scared of degrowth. It's not that scary if you actually have some kind of consensus mechanism or conflict resolution, which is the thing we actually lack as a country that's scary as shit.

Anyway, politicians could always loosen immigration. More people = bigger economy, higher wages for the rest of us, and generally immigrants have higher fertility rates. Somehow neither party wants to acknowledge this.

(yes, the above would come with inflation too—this can be reclaimed pretty easily from the top of the wealth pyramid with taxes.)

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by astrange on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:54PM (#38962009)
> and generally immigrants have higher fertility rates

Not by much, it's only higher in the origin country afaik.

> yes, the above would come with inflation too

Growing the economy isn't inflationary.

> this can be reclaimed pretty easily from the top of the wealth pyramid with taxes

Rich people don't contribute to inflation as much because they have lower marginal propensity to consume. You need to combat demand-side inflation by taking money away from everyone else, and supply-side inflation by increasing production.

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by JeffSnazz on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:23PM (#38963274)
> Growing the economy isn't inflationary.

It is if you provide a route to citizenship for ~16M americans, many of which are not making minimum wage.

> Rich people don't contribute to inflation as much because they have lower marginal propensity to consume. You need to combat demand-side inflation by taking money away from everyone else, and supply-side inflation by increasing production.

The goal is to use the inflation to drive a reduction in wealth inequality. If the rich person finds it unfair, I'm sure they can find something to mop their tears with.

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by astrange on Friday January 12, 2024 @01:31AM (#38964694)
> It is if you provide a route to citizenship for ~16M americans, many of which are not making minimum wage.

Hmmm, I think it more counters a deflationary trend of older local people retiring. It is true that people earning more is likely inflationary (but that's better than all alternatives).

> The goal is to use the inflation to drive a reduction in wealth inequality.

Causation would go the other way round. Wealth taxes are inflationary, insofar as taxes are paid in USD and so you have to sell your assets to get the USD, causing extra transactions. That's a problem since most other kinds of tax are deflationary.

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by ChainOfFools on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:01PM (#38961492)
Idiocracy, the best accidental documentary of our generation, strikes again
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by mupuff1234 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:19PM (#38960995)
Or you could just give the tax break to the parents instead of creating another corporate tax loophole that will most likely be abused.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by acdha on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:35PM (#38961172)
A tax break only helps people who are paying enough in taxes for it to matter and when it’s well calibrated to match what daycare costs. It would generally be better for the government to provide daycare because they have much better scale and consistency on funding, employment – daycare employees are notoriously underpaid because it’s such a high overhead business – and especially real estate. Using state buildings and getting the workers on healthcare plans which have better economies of scale would be a lot more sustainable economically than having a bunch of small businesses with far less leverage trying to do it on a smaller scale.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by loeg on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:58PM (#38961461)
> A tax break only helps people who are paying enough in taxes for it to matter

No, tax deductions help higher rate taxpayers more, but "tax breaks" is a more broad/relaxed term that includes tax credits. Tax credits benefit everyone who files taxes and meets the criteria for the credit.

> It would generally be better for the government to provide daycare

Eh, that is kind of a wholly different argument. In some ways the credit is obviously better (maybe it frees up one partner who wants to to stay-at-home parent), and it can be used more flexibly than a government-provided care program, even if you assume arguendo that the government program would be good and/or good value.

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by acdha on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:10PM (#38963191)
If you’re going to be that pedantic, be sure to specify that you mean refundable tax credits – and then perhaps acknowledge the second half of the compound statement you’re replying to.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by ytdytvhxgydvhh on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:29PM (#38961100)
Individual parents aren’t generally in a position to open a daycare and make a meaningful difference in the supply of childcare. Employers may be able to do so.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by throwaway6734 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:49PM (#38961350)
give the parents the money and let them decide what to do with it
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by RhysU on Friday January 12, 2024 @06:21AM (#38966740)
All day cares will suddenly increase in price to the tune of the tax break.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by ndriscoll on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:36PM (#38963352)
BLS data[0] indicate over 30% of married couples with children have a stay-at-home parent, and census data[1] indicate over 20% of childcare is provided by a non-parent relative. So family providing care is quite normal and close to the majority of the supply of childcare.

[0] https://www.bls.gov/news.release/famee.t04.htm

[1] https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2023/11/child-care.ht...

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by dgfitz on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:31PM (#38961115)
Or throw away the entire bullshit that is the US tax code and start over.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by JamesBarney on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:22PM (#38961024)
You could, either works.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by hot_gril on Thursday January 11, 2024 @06:38PM (#38961207)
Neither way really impacts fertility rate if that's the goal. Many countries, esp in west and north Europe, have already found out that you can't pay people to have kids.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by Rafuino on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:29PM (#38963309)
Funnily enough, the CHIPS Act has provisions that require recipients of grants of a certain amount to provide childcare to employees. That might be the way of the future if we explicitly subsidize more and more industries directly...