News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by scottlamb on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:05PM (#38961536)
Google's daycare wasn't like that in so many ways, though.

* You don't just take your kids in to work with you. The Google daycares were not any closer to whatever office you happen to work in than some third-party daycare. [edit: they weren't particularly close a long time ago when Google was concentrated in North Bayshore, and then became even less so as Google's offices were spread out more and people bounced around more often, and then became even less so with wfh...]

* You can't actually get in. There was a waitlist and your position on it actually got worse over time (because sibling priority), then later a lottery system where you pay money to play but never win.

* From what I heard recently from a daycare provider (I can't directly verify), it wasn't very good if you did get in. The typical tenure for a teacher was like a month, which is shockingly bad. Like how do you screw up pay/work environment so badly that's possible? And their understanding of children's needs wasn't great either. For example, they organized the kids into rooms by age (which is common but not universal) and...had no transition period at all or hint to the kids that these transitions were coming. They were just in one room one day with one set of teachers, then unexpectedly in another room with another set of teachers the next, which was super confusing and alarming to them.

* It was supposedly subsidized but still strangely expensive. [edit to add: when I first heard about it, this was explained to me as a consequence of it having very high-quality staff who are paid well, but this doesn't match up with the bullet above. Maybe what I heard from the daycare provider was wrong. Maybe quality has gone downhill. Maybe it was never good. I think there are a variety of factors that would have allowed it to continue existing until now without ever having been good. An absolutely tiny proportion of interested people actually were able to try it. Those who did probably felt very lucky to get in and disinclined to complain/give up their exclusive spot, and folks on the waitlist disinclined to listen to their complaints... additionally, many of the parents who went there had never had kids in another daycare to compare against...]

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by kajecounterhack on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:46PM (#38961929)
FWIW from a current GCC parent:

> You can't actually get in. There was a waitlist and your position on it actually got worse over time

This changed after covid. My understanding is that they struggled to fill classrooms due to people moving away from MTV / Palo Alto. We tried to convince friends to enroll their kids for fear of something like this happening. The closure was way worse than we expected (we thought they'd at least do a phased closure) and we kinda regret the advice we gave to friends since they're scrambling to find replacement care now.

> From what I heard recently from a daycare provider (I can't directly verify), it wasn't very good if you did get in

Daycare turnover has been bad industry wide, and our classroom had bad turnover in 2021 but it stablized since then. We've super loved our experience. Really great sanitary procedures, high quality learning objectives and measurement, healthy food, etc.

> It was supposedly subsidized but still strangely expensive.

Yes it's still shockingly expensive. Maybe this was self inflicted at first: I heard that when one of the Wojicki sisters had her kids there they changed out all classroom furniture every year, looked for way overqualified people to do the childcare (like Ph.Ds) and all that. It's not that over the top anymore today, but today they still pay the childcare workers very well by that industry's standards (they also get all the same days off as other alphabet workers) and the facilities are way bigger than others that you'd find on the peninsula, with a playground / yard for every N classrooms.

My personal feeling is: I understand why they'd cut this benefit. I _don't_ understand why they had to cut it in this fashion. Having another daycare company buy it out and handing over operations, or raising prices so it's not subsidized, or phasing out classrooms over N years to give parents plenty of time to find alternative care -- there are just better ways they could have ended this longstanding benefit.

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by scottlamb on Thursday January 11, 2024 @07:52PM (#38961991)
Thanks for the updated perspective!

> This changed after covid. My understanding is that they struggled to fill classrooms due to people moving away from MTV / Palo Alto.

Ahh, that explains how my across-the-street neighbor has a kid there.

> Daycare turnover has been bad industry wide, and our classroom had bad turnover in 2021 but it stablized since then. We've super loved our experience. Really great sanitary procedures, high quality learning objectives and measurement, healthy food, etc.

From what this provider told me, the Google daycares' turnover was bad even by industry standards.

Anyway, glad to hear you had a good experience there, and my sympathy as you try to find a replacement!

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by kajecounterhack on Thursday January 11, 2024 @08:01PM (#38962091)
Thanks Scott <3
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by plasma_beam on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:48PM (#38963039)
FWIW not Google but have my child at a Kiddie Academy, and turnover is abysmal..monthly sounds right. And yeah they do class transfers by age and abrubtly so. And they’re in one room all day, though when it’s over 50 degrees they’ll go outside (I’m in Maryland and ya know..winter).

Edit: oh and $2500/mo for 0-2 yr olds..curious how that stacks up compared to Google day care!

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by scottlamb on Friday January 12, 2024 @01:40AM (#38964767)
My kids were at a Kiddie Academy for a while that was coincidentally down the street from a Google daycare. It was a pretty good experience at the time. Each room had at least one long time teacher (years). They eased them into the next room. But then management changed, they pushed those teachers out, we reported a couple ratio violations to the state, and we left. We tried to get the owners more involved (Kiddie Academy is a franchise), then we met the owners and thought maybe less involvement would be better...they got a decent director in the end but the damage was already done from our perspective.

Then my kids went to a Montessori style preschool. Small, run by the owner of 20+ years and a couple of long time staff members. That was great for us. The owner has since retired though and the school changed hands. Nothing lasts forever, I guess...

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by nostrademons on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:00AM (#38965351)
Kiddie Academy struck me as ~3rd/4th tier when I was looking at daycares - it was way down my list.

My kids went to a small local chain where some of the teachers have been with it since it was founded in the 90s, almost 30 years ago. Average tenure was like 10-15 years. Unfortunately they got bought by Bright Horizons last year, and have lost 4 teachers since the school year began (although luckily it's that 4 teachers have rotated into the 2 spots vacated, not that they lost 4 veteran teachers).

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by kajecounterhack on Friday January 12, 2024 @02:27PM (#38972736)
Was it The Wonder Years? I saw really mixed reviews on Yelp for that place and am curious if you have some insight into that.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by npunt on Thursday January 11, 2024 @09:43PM (#38962992)
Sounds a lot like the abrupt product cancellations they're known for.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by EasyMark on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:15PM (#38963224)
yeah they really sold whatever soul they had when they completely ditched the "don't be evil" slogan completely
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by charcircuit on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:21PM (#38963261)
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by Rafuino on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:27PM (#38963300)
Can you speak to how expensive? I'm trying to gauge childcare costs in the area and there's not a lot of transparency out there...
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by lordswork on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:33PM (#38963331)
I've heard from colleagues that it's about as expensive as rent in the Bay area.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by fshbbdssbbgdd on Thursday January 11, 2024 @11:59PM (#38963981)
Wow. Might as well rent a place for the grandparents and have them take care of the kid. And if you have two kids, it would be a huge savings. Something seems broken about the economics here.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by kajecounterhack on Friday January 12, 2024 @02:29PM (#38972755)
Assuming grandparents are local or unemployed and willing to move. And willing to do the work (maybe including food?)

Labor aside, a 2 bedroom in Mountain View is quite expensive and doesn't come with learning materials, toys, classmates, etc.

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by fshbbdssbbgdd on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:36PM (#38975107)
I mean, learning materials can toys can’t cost that much, and classmates would just make the savings even better…
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by kajecounterhack on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:37PM (#38963353)
This is correct. Our rent is about the same as childcare
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by viraptor on Friday January 12, 2024 @05:17AM (#38966258)
This feels like a good average globally, right? You have multiple staff per room (hopefully!) + admin staff + cook who need to pay their own rent+spending, then add the costs+mintenance of the daycare itself. Unless government-subsidised, I'd expect the daycare costs to be in the same ballpark as the local rent.
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by kajecounterhack on Saturday January 13, 2024 @01:04PM (#38982664)
In this world where rent is your dominant monthly cost, totally agree. The teacher student ratio for infants here is 1:3, honestly it should maybe be more.

Would be nice if rents were a smaller total of our living expenses though. Everyone would have more breathing room.

Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by kajecounterhack on Thursday January 11, 2024 @10:36PM (#38963348)
Close to 4k for under 2 yrs old. Bottom barrel places are 2800 for infants
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by tehlike on Friday January 12, 2024 @03:35AM (#38965572)
~$2900
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by hadlock on Friday January 12, 2024 @02:36PM (#38972849)
Childcare is universally the cost of a medium quality 1 bedroom apartment in a safe neighborhood, just about everywhere in the US
Re:Google lays off Bay Area workers, closes Mtn View child c... by shaftway on Friday January 12, 2024 @07:58PM (#38976271)
I looked into it pre-covid and was basically told that it's for the upper level executives. We went with an au pair for our 2 kids, and it cost less than having one kid in GCC.