It's not about touch nor physicality of a button or knob, but about a control that is not dependent on UI state
Do you really believe that you can close your eyes and touch the "Start" button on a windows machine at arms length every time? Try it throughout your day. I doubt it.
The tactile feedback is important to know that you're making the adjustment you want, and to help you find the right control input.
We're both aging ourselves with "Start button", by the way.
It's exactly about touch! The fundamental point is not needing to turn your eyes from the road.
A dynamic tactile touch screen solves the problem of finding the controls, but if the knob that you find could be the volume or the temperature depending on the mode the UI is in, you're still likely to look down to check which one it is.
Edit: And even some clever solution like giving different shapes to different modes doesn't help a ton, because that still uses more brain cycles and time than "reach for where I know the volume knob is and turn it left". You'd have to reach out and feel the control, and if it's the wrong one then reach for the mode switcher and then find the correct control. That's distracting regardless of whether the eyes can stay on the road, and you're very likely to pull your eyes down instinctively to help with that complicated process.
There's two problems with this. Firstly it's generally unknowable what will appear where on the touschreen. Secondly even if you just want to know exactly where the touchscreen is then you need to look at it.
No, I disagree.
The heterogeneity and tactile response of the UI is fundamental, at least for me.
Which quadrant of the display is the control in? You flick your eyes to check. Ok, now is my finger in the right place? You need to check again. Is it at the right level…
For the terminally space-brained like me, buttons and dials work much better. You flick your eyes and can see where the control is and in relation to what. Now you can trace with your finger to the area of the controller, and feel around to locate it in relation to the other controls. If it is ridged, you have tactile feedback on its orientation.
I often and traveling with my wife, and get annoyed that I cannot some options because we are in motion - my wife is driving so there is nothing unsafe about me using the touchscreen. (when I drive I try to avoid looking at the infotainment - there is nothing on it that I need but it is still a distracting hazard)
Consider settings like: how long it takes for the car to shut off the lights automatically after you turn it off and lock it. Or other obscure things. You're not going to have physical buttons for that. You'd have a digital screen with next/previous/ok buttons. That isn't any better than using a touch screen to access those settings. Arguably worse UX.
Another posted suggested allow touch screens but have them not operate while car is in motion, with no override, and I think that's a much more targeted/palatable proposal with (maybe?) less unexpected consequences.
I assume you mean "no touchscreen controls" is extreme. I probably wasn't clear. By "controls" I meant those for "live" controls (environment, audio, etc). Touchscreen for settings totally make sense - as you said, it doesn't make sense to have physical inputs for settings like lights off delay.
>have them not operate while car is in motion
I'm okay with that too
Also who needs a nice big screen to watch Netflix while we are parked waiting to pick up our kid? We can watch on my phone, my wife doesn’t mind contorting herself to see.
Same reason why (in absence of extreme environmental conditions) difficult climbing routes are considered quite safe: Because people are aware of the danger in the specific situation.
Doesn't eliminate the need for safe design, tho, attaching giant spinning metal blades to dashboards might solve many problems, but few in favor of the driver.
If this were applicable to drivers made up of the general public, we wouldn't have a glut of accidents caused by people using their phones while driving.
The attitude of constant danger will even protect you from another weird climbing stat. Having avalanche survival/safety courses increases the probability that you will die in an avalanche. One of the people who taught me how to ice climb died in an avalanche. We don’t want more dead climbers.
I hate touch screen controls in cars for things that are adjusted during driving like everyone else here. But please let’s not go for a default of „the state has to allow it“ for all new inventions - as dumb as they may be.
What is there you think needs proving? People can adjust the volume knob or AC without looking. You literally cannot do this with a touchscreen.
"We got away from the physical throttles, and that was probably the number one feedback from the fleet - they said, just give us the throttles that we can use," said Rear Adm Galinis.
(EDIT: TFA also talks about buttons, and not being able to find information on screens).OP article is probably a case of the market working it out if Volkswagen is doing it without regulation. I doubt Tesla-like multi-modal touch screens are going to be default ever. They were never a good idea.
But regulation is essentially the people coming together to say "never again", and that is their right in a democracy. Like it or not as inventors or inventor-adjacent folks we might look more harshly at it. But we also have that power and I don't see a problem per se in using it to direct the market on somewhat trivial things like this.
My wife will finally be able to use my phone chargers b/c of the EU legislation on apple chargers.
That article is about controls on a military system. You make it sound as if people are steering their cars with touch controls, which they don't.
Screw overregulation, I do not want the government to assume that I am a complete idiot and regulate every single part of my life.
"Overregulation" is a squishy political term. We cancel each other out on this issue (assuming you're US-based). I'm not advocating for car controls to have regulations, but would be fine if they took sensible action. But they probably won't need to.
I think it also may not have mattered. We, as in contemporary humans, continue to devalue our attention/focus in regards to our technology. I think that’s the core problem with digital UI is they just requiring too much of our active attention where as physical knobs allow us to passively perform actions with muscle memory (low attention requirement)
If they took all the knobs and put some in the glove box and some inside the console and some in the back seat and so on… we wouldn’t consider that an invention. It would just be obvious that the knobs were difficult to access. That’s basically what they did but act like it’s fine because technically they’re still right there on the dash.
In summer 2017, the USS Fitzgerald collided with a container ship near the Japanese mainland in an accident that killed seven sailors. The McCain was off the coast of Singapore when it hit a container ship, killing 10 of the Navy destroyer's crew.
The report blames touch screens.
IMHO, car screens are useful to watch some telly or films during your boring commuting
yes, let's prevent regulators from applying and enforcing no brainer life saving safety regulations without first being required to spend decades studying each individual issue and then litigate each individual issue for another couple of decades, ensuring that nothing ever gets regulated ever
because that's what you're asking for, whether you realize it or not
That this hasn't happened yet might be because automotive regulation is in general a joke in this country, as the car companies run the economy and thus have strong influence government. But the pressure was building. Plus the customers hating the touch screens, as the article is saying, that will have been a small factor.
[0]: https://www.adac.de/verkehr/recht/verkehrsvorschriften-deuts...
We will always need to tune the temperature, switch turning indicators, turn on warning lights or change the volume.
Touch screens are only cheap. And it is questionable that we get any software update in ten years. Not even thinking three decades ahead.
And probably we will be glad that there are no software updates removing* or changing* features. With constant updates and internet connectivity we will not get any car safe.
Basically we want electric cars. Not computers, at least none we need to handle.
* e.g. Shimano Di2 (shifting groupset for roadbikes) with a Hammerhead bike computer: Shimano forced Hammerhead in 2022 to remove the support for the Di2 because Shimano now consider them as competitor. One of the reasons for mechanical groups is reliability! * Hello Windows Users. Do you like automatic updates? How about enforced updates? May we increase requirements?
With touch buttons or touch screens you only need to decide on the screen size and placement and everything can be done later in the development. It is quite an advantage from the car manufacturer's view.
It's planned obsolescence. Every part of the car should be good for 20 years. 20 years ago, we were using Moto Razrs and it would be 4 more years until iPhone changed how we think of touchscreens. These junk touchscreen cars from this era will not make it without extremely expensive repair
They’re infinitely modifiable in software.
If you’re doing a model refresh and want to add a button, you change a few lines of code instead of redesigning the dashboard and sourcing parts and adjusting the assembly process and updating the engineering documents and maintenance and repair manuals and…
With a touchscreen, you plan "touchscreen here" and the UI can be modified in software basically up to the point the first production car rolls off the line (and even after that, too).
For what it's worth: the physical buttons being linked to certain functionality from the beginning is the whole point, and is the defining characteristic of "good usability".
When your buttons change arbitrarily, you will always require eyesight to identify the buttons, which is radically unsafe and creates a horrifying UX since regulators have not yet banned all touchscreen use while a vehicle is moving
It's not clear. Does statistically normalized data show more or less death when buttons and levers were the only way to adjust temperature?
I don't know, have any?
To play devil's advocate, trying to adjust the AC using regular buttons on an unfamiliar rental car can be a nightmare too. Trying to decipher the tiny icons and lights while driving, what magic combination of button presses and knob positions will work?
There's an argument to be made that for something like temperature control with its various modes (heat/vent/cold, strength/temperature, fan speed, which combination of vents), a large touchscreen is actually a far superior interface -- easier to see and more intuitive.
(Physical touch buttons on the steering wheel for basic adjustments-while-driving like temperature up/down and volume up/down are still important though.)
What the others in this thread are commenting on is the fact that in cars with touchscreen based controls, every time you adjust the AC in a car you drive every day, it is cumbersome and distracting.
I've had cars with terrible physical controls and cars with really well thought out touchscreen controls combined with a lot of automation.
It isn't obvious that fumbling with buttons below the wheel, near my knee is better than the screen right in front of me. I can't even find them by touch easily, because they've made so many of them, including for nearly useless functions.
I don't know how bad they actually are, I know there's been a drumbeat in media recently about how bad they are with no real data I've ever seen to back it up, and I know that I've, at this point, driven more miles with aftermarket touch screen interfaces than I have without and I have yet to be involved in even a minor accident, let alone a fatal one.
I agree with "easier to see and more intuitive" and I'd use it when parked. But when driving, I don't want to "see", I want tactile feedback on whether I hit a control.
I don't agree with this logic.
When you rent a car it's common sense to familiarise yourself with the controls before you start driving it.
They have turn signal indicator that works the same. Most cars it is a lever off the side of the steering wheel. One car I drove (at night) instead had a switch on the dashboard - I successfully used this to signal my turn several times before I realized it wasn't a lever - but it worked like one so it didn't matter.
Because car makers have historically been good at doing consistent UIs like this when I get into a rental car the only think I need to figure out is where the key goes and how the transmission shifts (shift levers can be many different places and have many different patterns). Everything else important to driving is the same on all cars.
Things like the radio and climate system are not the same on all cars. However they are not critical to driving.
They can be critical to driving, if you have to move your focus from the street to the screen for changing the settings.
Ideally you ought to take 5 minutes to check these things out before you set off. And if there are buttons you at least can do this if you want to.
There is no argument. This is a ridiculous idea.
Unless your hand got caught in that 3d surface.
It was a valiant (/S) effort!
A couple of days ago there was an article on HN about the littering behaviour and causes of it. As some commenters noticed, the main reason is simply that people do whatever the hell they feel like doing, without much consideration. Driving and suddenly feel hungry? Eat something right now. There is a wrapper paper in one of your hands now and it's inconvenient to hold it while eating and driving? Throw it out of the window. Etc.
And yes, I've seen debaters on the Internet arguing for allowing DUI, for non-requirement of seat belts, for allowing smoking in public places etc, basically for anything that mildly inconveniences a person for a vague personal and/or public benefit. And on HN too, about a year or so ago?
P.S. About "eating food that is a fuel for your body" — there's a fancy term "postprandial somnolence" for that feeling of drowsiness after a meal. Definitely something you'd like to experience while driving (/S).
I would argue that the customs and expectations from different places arise from the different needs in those communities and/or the level of regulation that is tolerated from the people. Switzerland has a lot of winding mountain roads - so likely need two hands on the wheel at all times whereas North America has a lot of flat straight roads where it is quite reasonable to drive with one hand on the wheel for short periods of time. Also Tesla auto-pilot helps out.
Additionally I suspect that you argue so strongly in favor of no eating in your car makes me think that you live in a state with very strong control of your population and it is well tolerated by the population - with assumed upside benefits as a result.
If you need to turn on the defroster, pull over, turn on the defroster, and pull away again.
Just design the vehicle better. I can see the status of my HVAC without taking my eyes off of the road—it’s on a display mounted on top of my dash, forward toward the windshield—and turn on defrost mode with the press of a single, large physical button inset inside a large knob which provides a clear touch cue.[0] I have never had to take my eyes off the road to adjust any of this system.
[0] https://assets.bpwalters.com/images/bens_car_blog/10k_review...
The radio should only have minimal accessible controls while driving. However even then remember that the non-driver should get the ability to have more control.
The regulators are literally asleep at the wheel and this should have never been permitted for any critical adjustments such as temperature and even audio volume. The hazard button being the only exception is not enough and Tesla turned that into a capacities touch button on the cybertruck making using it with wet hands or gloves impossible.
In Switzerland you get fined if you eat while you drive! Having to hunt and take your eyes of the road to adjust the temp is way worse.
Now if touch screens had a dynamic 3d surface that you could navigate blindly it would be something else.