News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by crazygringo on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @08:53AM (#38695510)
> How many people died

I don't know, have any?

To play devil's advocate, trying to adjust the AC using regular buttons on an unfamiliar rental car can be a nightmare too. Trying to decipher the tiny icons and lights while driving, what magic combination of button presses and knob positions will work?

There's an argument to be made that for something like temperature control with its various modes (heat/vent/cold, strength/temperature, fan speed, which combination of vents), a large touchscreen is actually a far superior interface -- easier to see and more intuitive.

(Physical touch buttons on the steering wheel for basic adjustments-while-driving like temperature up/down and volume up/down are still important though.)

Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by jasongill on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @08:58AM (#38695555)
I think the difference here is that you are arguing that your first time adjusting the AC in a new car is cumbersome and distracting, which of course I think everyone can agree upon.

What the others in this thread are commenting on is the fact that in cars with touchscreen based controls, every time you adjust the AC in a car you drive every day, it is cumbersome and distracting.

Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by jsight on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:20AM (#38695790)
You are absolutely right, tbh. People make this into too much of a binary choice.

I've had cars with terrible physical controls and cars with really well thought out touchscreen controls combined with a lot of automation.

It isn't obvious that fumbling with buttons below the wheel, near my knee is better than the screen right in front of me. I can't even find them by touch easily, because they've made so many of them, including for nearly useless functions.

Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by tokai on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:03AM (#38695596)
Devils advocado is not some incarnation that makes saying the opposite into an actual argument.
Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by ricardobayes on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:20AM (#38695793)
Devil's avocado? Sorry, couldn't resist that one.
Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by ToucanLoucan on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:19AM (#38695782)
Doesn't change that we have no statistical data for "deaths caused by touchscreens." The nearest offered in the federal numbers that I can find is distracted driving which accounts for roughly 4,000 (which is an estimate) of the ~43,000 that occur in the United States, or ballpark 10%. But that 4,000 estimate includes things like cell phone distraction, your kid screaming in the back seat, or just straight up people not paying attention to the road. And, worth devils' avodacoing here, many newer infotainment systems include things like CarPlay and Android Auto which can if anything mitigate the distracting factor of shitty OEM interfaces.

I don't know how bad they actually are, I know there's been a drumbeat in media recently about how bad they are with no real data I've ever seen to back it up, and I know that I've, at this point, driven more miles with aftermarket touch screen interfaces than I have without and I have yet to be involved in even a minor accident, let alone a fatal one.

Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by jlg23 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:23AM (#38695821)
> There's an argument to be made that for something like temperature control with its various modes (heat/vent/cold, strength/temperature, fan speed, which combination of vents), a large touchscreen is actually a far superior interface -- easier to see and more intuitive.

I agree with "easier to see and more intuitive" and I'd use it when parked. But when driving, I don't want to "see", I want tactile feedback on whether I hit a control.

Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by herodoturtle on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:02AM (#38695586)
> trying to adjust the AC using regular buttons on an unfamiliar rental car can be a nightmare too

I don't agree with this logic.

When you rent a car it's common sense to familiarise yourself with the controls before you start driving it.

Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by bluGill on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:42AM (#38696078)
Mostly that isn't needed because the controls you need are generally obvious. Every car has accelerator and brake pedals (some also have a clutch) in the same position that works the same with no need to look. Likewise they all have a steering wheel in the same position that again works the same as every other car.

They have turn signal indicator that works the same. Most cars it is a lever off the side of the steering wheel. One car I drove (at night) instead had a switch on the dashboard - I successfully used this to signal my turn several times before I realized it wasn't a lever - but it worked like one so it didn't matter.

Because car makers have historically been good at doing consistent UIs like this when I get into a rental car the only think I need to figure out is where the key goes and how the transmission shifts (shift levers can be many different places and have many different patterns). Everything else important to driving is the same on all cars.

Things like the radio and climate system are not the same on all cars. However they are not critical to driving.

Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by generic92034 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @10:04AM (#38696381)
> Things like the radio and climate system are not the same on all cars. However they are not critical to driving.

They can be critical to driving, if you have to move your focus from the street to the screen for changing the settings.

Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by jsight on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:21AM (#38695800)
Apparently you haven't watched people leave the rental area at the airport.
Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by ExoticPearTree on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:29AM (#38695898)
You know the saying: common sense is not that common.
Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by hackernewds on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @08:56AM (#38695530)
you can use one of your senses (touch) while operating the car with another (vision) with physical buttons. I feel like your argument supports better designed physical buttons vs more touch buttons, with zero haptic feedback
Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by nicoburns on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @09:01AM (#38695580)
> trying to adjust the AC using regular buttons on an unfamiliar rental car can be a nightmare too. Trying to decipher the tiny icons and lights while driving

Ideally you ought to take 5 minutes to check these things out before you set off. And if there are buttons you at least can do this if you want to.

Re:Volkswagen Will Bring Back Physical Buttons in New Cars by closewith on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @08:54AM (#38695518)
> There's an argument to be made that for something like temperature control with its various modes (heat/vent/cold, strength/temperature, fan speed, which combination of vents), a large touchscreen is actually a far superior interface -- easier to see and more intuitive.

There is no argument. This is a ridiculous idea.