News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by throw0101c on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:38PM (#38632072)
> […] (and Musk in general) have been over-promising and under-delivering for years now.

Related, "Tesla FSD Timeline":

> September 2014: They will be a factor of 10 safer than a person [at the wheel] in a six-year time frame

* https://motherfrunker.ca/fsd/

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38625380 (earlier today)

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by coffeebeqn on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:34PM (#38633784)
At this point anyone who takes his claims at face value is a fool
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by wolverine876 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:06PM (#38634849)
Is it legal to cheat the foolish and ignorant?
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by tw04 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:51PM (#38636395)
Actually, no. That's why there are laws against pyramid schemes, and false advertising.

https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/topics/truth-advertising

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/investor_protection_guide_py...

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by User23 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:58PM (#38636468)
Unless you're running for office. In that case you can lie to your heart's content about what you're offering.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by wolverine876 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @10:13PM (#38637353)
For good reason: We can't have politicians regulating the speech of the critics and opponents. Nothing is more protected in the US than political speech, esp (afaik) by someone running for office.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by someplaceguy on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:08AM (#38638019)
Who said anything about regulating speech?

You could just prosecute a politician if he didn't deliver what he promised, you know.

Outside politics (and depending on the context) this is called breach of contract, fraud, misrepresentation or, say, false advertising or consumer protection violation.

It's also colloquially called "holding someone accountable".

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by tw04 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:51AM (#38638246)
> You could just prosecute a politician if he didn't deliver what he promised, you know.

What you’re asking for is a dictator. Politicians can’t unilaterally decide what happens by design. I think what you mean to say is that you want to prosecute politicians if they don’t vote in alignment with their stated goals, but even that is loaded in the US.

Let’s assume we’re talking about a liberal politician.

If he or she ran on banning guns, introduced legislation to ban guns, but some conservative added a rider to ban abortion, should he or she be prosecuted for voting against their own bill? Because that kind of nonsense happens all the time.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by someplaceguy on Thursday December 14, 2023 @01:36AM (#38638478)
> What you’re asking for is a dictator.

No, I'm asking for the judicial system to prosecute politicians who make promises that they don't keep. Like they prosecute politicians in other instances of illegal behavior.

To be clear, I'm not saying that currently, it is illegal for politicians to make promises they don't keep. I'm saying it should be, in some form.

> If he or she ran on banning guns, introduced legislation to ban guns, but some conservative added a rider to ban abortion, should he or she be prosecuted for voting against their own bill? Because that kind of nonsense happens all the time.

Obviously not. I'm not advocating for putting politicians in prison willy nilly. But we should at least prosecute the obvious, egregious instances of the kind of wrongdoing I'm talking about.

Besides, the whole concept of a "rider" is stupid, corrupt and should be illegal as well (just like it is in other areas of the law). Then you wouldn't have that problem.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by wolverine876 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @01:44AM (#38638515)
Who will prosecute them? Another politician or someone appointed by one. It's politicians all the way down.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by keep_reading on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:18AM (#38638073)
Presidents aren't kings, so even they cannot guarantee their proposed policies will actually be enacted into law. That's the sticky bit.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by pstuart on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:15PM (#38634958)
It's legal to do lots of shitty things. But is it immoral to do so? Yes.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DoesntMatter22 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:58PM (#38632404)
To be fair FSD is the hardest software problem that man has ever attempted.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by mikestew on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:03PM (#38632491)
That's not being fair, that's making excuses. If the problem is that hard, don't be running your mouth about you'll have it done in six months, and charge people money while you work out the bugs.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DoesntMatter22 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:36PM (#38633059)
Never did Musk say "We'll have it done in six months".
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by delecti on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:48PM (#38633223)
This: https://motherfrunker.ca/fsd/ (linked in the GGP to your comment) links to this tweet from Jan 23, 2017 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/823727035088416768

When asked the question "At what point will "Full Self-Driving Capability" features noticeably depart from "Enhanced Autopilot" features?"

Elon responded "3 months maybe, 6 months definitely"

Also, lots of examples of "this year" stated in various Januarys, and multiple instances along the lines of "complete autonomy in 2 years" going back 8 years.

I suspect his statements are carefully made to not technically meet the legal definition for fraud, but colloquially he's absolutely a liar.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by jcranmer on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:50PM (#38633952)
> I suspect his statements are carefully made to not technically meet the legal definition for fraud, but colloquially he's absolutely a liar.

They're probably not carefully made, but fraud requires knowledge of falsity, and short of an internal report saying "this feature won't be ready before XYZ," it is going to be extremely difficult to prove Tesla knew the claims were false.

The other thing you'll run into is reasonability of reliance--at this point, with so many deadlines repeatedly blown through, it would be hard to demonstrate that a reasonable person could rely on a representation that a promised deadline would be met.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by JohnFen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:19PM (#38634263)
I would think it would be hard to find a reasonable person who takes anything Musk says seriously anymore and yet plenty seem to.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by medvezhenok on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:59PM (#38634772)
The reason people follow Musk is that even though he over-promises and under-delivers; the under-delivered product is still better than the alternatives (or at least was for a while).

People are not complete fools and can learn to discount over-the-top rhetoric; sure, some people are harmed by believing everything verbatim, but those people also fall for scams, etc, etc.

His statements are parsed as statements of intent more so than actual timeline commitments. We'll have FSD in 6 months = FSD is our main priority at the moment. And sure it also makes for PR/free advertising. Is it scammy? Probably. But he likely got more out of people by pushing this false narrative than would have been otherwise accomplished.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by JohnFen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:11PM (#38634904)
I have real trouble with "the ends justify the means" arguments.

> Is it scammy? Probably.

It's the behavior of a con artist.

> But he likely got more out of people by pushing this false narrative than would have been otherwise accomplished.

Even if that's the case, he could have had the same, or better, effect without the lying. The lying is clearly aimed at gaining investment money and preorders, though, not at some bizarre attempt at motivating engineers.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by czl on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @06:07PM (#38635517)
> The lying is clearly aimed at gaining investment money and preorders, though, not at some bizarre attempt at motivating engineers.

It would be dumb to be caught "lying" over and over and Musk is not know to be dumb. Consider the possibility Musk is using reflexivity to accelerate progress. When people become convinced something is possible and work towards that goal their strong belief changes reality because there is a feedback loop between reality and beliefs.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DonHopkins on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:16PM (#38636146)
It would be dumb to be caught agreeing with anti semitic tweets, and telling advertisers to "go fuck yourself", yet here we are. Your argument is invalid.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by czl on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @10:18PM (#38637391)
Intelligent people have faults and make mistakes like the rest of us. What sets them apart is they are often better at seeing this and fixing things. Did Musk not make amends for that tweet? Do you think advertising should control social media? Do you genuinely believe Musk is dumb?
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by tempestn on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @10:28PM (#38637426)
I believe Musk is smart, but also bipolar and narcissistic, and likely often on stimulants, which makes him regularly do dumb things.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by czl on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @10:42PM (#38637499)
Compared to a same aged person does Musk do more dumb things each day? Perhaps his few dumb things get amplified by his haters?

Any normal person that manages to earn themself what Musk has earned might that affect their personality? Maybe make them more narcissistic etc? Large wealth would not affect your psychology?

Regarding bipolar: It would not surprise me but is there evidence? Did he admit it?

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by phatskat on Thursday December 14, 2023 @09:39AM (#38641788)
Of course wealth affects one’s mental state, this is pretty well studied.

Also “earned” is a bit generous, he’s had a lot of “right people, right time, right place” in his life (not to mention a great start from the emerald mines).

Also why look at dumb things per day when what matters (to me) is the enormity of dumb actions? He bought Twitter for way more than it was worth because he had a hissy fit. He’s “concerned” that AI isn’t allowed to say the n-word. He did a live public call with Andrew Tate, Alex Jones, and Vivek Ramaswamy. I could do one simply dumb thing every day for my entire life and not live up to the sheer stupidity of this man’s actions.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by czl on Thursday December 14, 2023 @07:08PM (#38649311)
> Also why look at dumb things per day when what matters (to me) is the enormity of dumb actions?

Elephant does what elephant does and ants complain. What do you expect?

> He bought Twitter for way more than it was worth because he had a hissy fit.

You don't make mistakes? Your ability grow wealth is superior? How then do you judge?

> He’s “concerned” that AI isn’t allowed to say the n-word.

Might he be concerned about censorship in general? If something against the law it is against the law but what gives you the right to impose your notion of "proper" speech on others? Do people have a right not to be offended? The attack on the Charlie Hebdo newspaper office in Paris by Islamic extremists you think they were justified due to being offended by cartoons?

> He did a live public call with Andrew Tate, Alex Jones, and Vivek Ramaswamy.

Now you want to impose rules on others about who they are allowed to talk to in public?

> I could do one simply dumb thing every day for my entire life and not live up to the sheer stupidity of this man’s actions.

Elephant does what elephant does. Ant does what ant does. You can not compare them. I believe strong feelings cloud your view.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by rpy on Thursday December 14, 2023 @06:07AM (#38640090)
No, he did not make amends. He never even apologised for it.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by czl on Thursday December 14, 2023 @06:51PM (#38649142)
Who is on stage in this clip and what they are saying?

https://youtu.be/xHZ-Dvv2cN4?si=VdmfLrcEq6AFm-7W

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by jcranmer on Thursday December 14, 2023 @10:51AM (#38642655)
"Dumb" isn't the word I'd use; "incurious" is better. It's not that he's racist or antisemitic, I believe, but rather he doesn't have enough knowledge of history to recognize classic antisemitic tropes (or signs that someone is an outright Nazi) combined with some beliefs close enough to racist that he's liable to agree with antisemitic creeds without recognizing them as antisemitic tropes.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by advael on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:55PM (#38637244)
Do we assess a person's intelligence by what their frothing fanboys think of them now, or is that only for rich celebrities?
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by czl on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @10:11PM (#38637341)
Hater or fanboy does it matter? Do you not understand the concept of reflexivity? Intelligence can show truth. Intelligence can support some existing bias and hide truth. How does your intelligence serve you?
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by advael on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @10:17PM (#38637377)
When someone's entire argument is "doing x would be dumb, and we know this guy isn't dumb", I see value in pointing out that this is a rather circular logic
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by czl on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @10:28PM (#38637432)
I suspect you did not understand what I said and your bias affected your judgement. Please explain what you think I meant.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by advael on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @10:53PM (#38637566)
I had to look up reflexivity, as I was not previously familiar with it. I fail to see how it salvages your claim, and suspect you're fixating on this bit of economics trivia because you dislike that I made fun of the thing you said, and think I'm trying to get into a pissing contest about "intelligence", and like most ridiculous children who get into pissing contests about intelligence, seem to think that asking me to explain a concept with which I may then admit unfamiliarity might score you some points in such an undertaking. That about right?
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by czl on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:09PM (#38637667)
That is not correct. My words above require intelligence to understand and my ability to explain them in simpler terms is limited. This explanation from GPT4 is good. Hope it helps.

------

The reply you've presented suggests a debate about the intentions behind Elon Musk's public statements, specifically regarding whether he's misleading people for financial gain or using a strategy known as "reflexivity" to motivate progress.

1. *Lying for Financial Gain*: The first part of the reply posits that Musk might be making false or exaggerated claims ("lying") to attract investment and preorders for his projects. This view implies that Musk's primary goal is to secure funding by convincing investors and customers of the feasibility and near-term success of his ventures, even if those claims are not entirely grounded in current realities.

2. *Reflexivity to Accelerate Progress*: The second part of the reply introduces a different perspective, suggesting Musk might be employing a concept known as reflexivity. This idea, often associated with financier George Soros, posits that market participants' beliefs can shape market realities. Applied here, it means Musk could be making ambitious or seemingly unrealistic statements with the intention of inspiring his teams and the broader public. The underlying belief is that if people are convinced that a challenging goal is achievable, their collective effort and belief can actually bring that goal closer to reality, creating a positive feedback loop between belief and outcome.

The reply seems to be wrestling with the notion of whether Musk's statements are purely manipulative for financial gain or part of a sophisticated strategy to create self-fulfilling prophecies that drive technological and scientific breakthroughs. It reflects on Musk's reputation for not being "dumb," suggesting that his repeated bold claims might have a deeper strategic purpose rather than just being simple falsehoods.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by advael on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:33PM (#38637813)
The former seems to clearly be a more parsimonious explanation of what we've seen. After all, what is often at stake, as in the case of the linked article, is financing based on concrete promises of progress, and the claims made by Musk are never about problems no one else thinks are possible to solve at all, so the reflexivity position here seems more like a defensive motte rather than a meaningful strategic analysis
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by czl on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:11PM (#38637689)
My post above requires some explanation so here is GP4 explain it.

------

The reply you've presented suggests a debate about the intentions behind Elon Musk's public statements, specifically regarding whether he's misleading people for financial gain or using a strategy known as "reflexivity" to motivate progress.

1. *Lying for Financial Gain*: The first part of the reply posits that Musk might be making false or exaggerated claims ("lying") to attract investment and preorders for his projects. This view implies that Musk's primary goal is to secure funding by convincing investors and customers of the feasibility and near-term success of his ventures, even if those claims are not entirely grounded in current realities.

2. *Reflexivity to Accelerate Progress*: The second part of the reply introduces a different perspective, suggesting Musk might be employing a concept known as reflexivity. This idea, often associated with financier George Soros, posits that market participants' beliefs can shape market realities. Applied here, it means Musk could be making ambitious or seemingly unrealistic statements with the intention of inspiring his teams and the broader public. The underlying belief is that if people are convinced that a challenging goal is achievable, their collective effort and belief can actually bring that goal closer to reality, creating a positive feedback loop between belief and outcome.

The reply seems to be wrestling with the notion of whether Musk's statements are purely manipulative for financial gain or part of a sophisticated strategy to create self-fulfilling prophecies that drive technological and scientific breakthroughs. It reflects on Musk's reputation for not being "dumb," suggesting that his repeated bold claims might have a deeper strategic purpose rather than just being simple falsehoods.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DonHopkins on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @06:56PM (#38635974)
Tell that to the disembodied pulverized head that was attached to somebody who took his claims at face value, and try explaining to his widow that her late husband was a complete fool to fall for it, so it's not Musk's fault.

The final 11 seconds of a fatal Tesla Autopilot crash: A reconstruction of the wreck shows how human error and emerging technology can collide with deadly results

https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/interactive/2023/t...

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by The_Colonel on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:52PM (#38634672)
If you're not following Musk every day, and maybe just know he's the Tesla/rocket guy, why wouldn't you take him seriously?

Somehow, this sounds like shifting blame from the liar to others ...

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by JohnFen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:06PM (#38634844)
I wasn't assigning or shifting blame for anything. I was just expressing that I am baffled by the reality.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DonHopkins on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @06:53PM (#38635941)
And I think it's safe to say that sycophants bending over backwards to carry Musk's water like DoesntMatter22 aren't reasonable people, don't base their opinions on facts or reality, and shouldn't be taken seriously.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DoesntMatter22 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:57PM (#38636459)
What I've said is completely factual. Surprisingly a lot of people like who won't actually prove that he said that. Because the fact is that he didn't.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by HWR_14 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:56PM (#38634733)
> fraud requires knowledge of falsity

Does it? Is there no "average person should be aware" level?

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:05PM (#38634835)
> fraud requires knowledge of falsity,

The civil tort of fraud (criminal fraud is different) generally requires either knowledge of falsity or reckless indifference to the truth.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by NovemberWhiskey on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:07PM (#38634867)
>fraud requires knowledge of falsity

Or recklessness as to falsity - like not caring whether the statement was true or false.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by wolverine876 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:08PM (#38634873)
> with so many deadlines repeatedly blown through, it would be hard to demonstrate that a reasonable person could rely on a representation that a promised deadline would be met.

That enables fraudsters, of course. Also, what about people who don't spend all their time on the Internet, on HN, reading about Elon Musk? They buy stocks and cars too.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by Hamuko on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:28PM (#38634375)
>I suspect his statements are carefully made to not technically meet the legal definition for fraud

2017 was before the infamous "funding secured" tweet, so I imagine there was no care in crafting his statements.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by isk517 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:05PM (#38633445)
Those don't count because Elon had this fingers crossed when he made those tweets. /s
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DoesntMatter22 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:15PM (#38633570)
This question was not asking about when FSD was going to work but when Enhanced Autopilot would noticeably depart from FSD. No where in there did it say "FSD will be working completely in 6 months".

They did in fact diverge, no where was that a statement that FSD would be complete by then.

It's ironic you are calling him a liar when your response seems to either be completely dishonest itself or you are not aware of the subject at hand.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by tedivm on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:40PM (#38633839)
In October of 2016-

> By the end of next year, said Musk, Tesla would demonstrate a fully autonomous drive from, say, a home in L.A., to Times Square ... without the need for a single touch, including the charging.

So you're technically right- he said three months, not six.

https://www.nbcnews.com/business/autos/driverless-tesla-will...

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DoesntMatter22 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:31PM (#38634415)
I don't see any direct quote of him saying what you are claiming. Please post that quote if you can find it
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by Fountain1320 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:29PM (#38635109)
Quote came from a conference call.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5SfDmL0sv3w

At ~6:20.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DoesntMatter22 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @06:07PM (#38635518)
Thank you for posting this. More proof of what I said. He did not say that they would definitively do it, he said exactly at the timestamp that you gave: "Our goal is".

So clearly didn't say that it would happen for certain

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:38PM (#38636756)
Announced goals still need to have a connection with reality or they're lies.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by NotACop182 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:16PM (#38634232)
I never understood someone so determined to ignore all the evidence. Yet when confronted doubles/triples down with excuses.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by natch on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:51PM (#38634657)
Confronted with evidence that nowhere supports the claims. We really are in bizarro world here, rife with sloppy thinking and fuzzy smears. Certainly Elon shoots off his mouth and has underestimated timelines, but the specific claims being made about those mistakes go way beyond and into lala land.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by flextheruler on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:25PM (#38634343)
It’s called the sunk cost fallacy anyone who owns a Tesla and Tesla stock has been extremely susceptible for years now
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DoesntMatter22 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:41PM (#38635221)
There is no proof. He never said it. People keep posting other quotes but none where he says what they claim.

If you have proof of a direct quote where he says that FSD will be done withing 6 or 3 months for certain than please post it.

Otherwise, attacking me is dishonest

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by r3d0c on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:47PM (#38633220)
lol... but he has been saying "it'll be out next year" for many years

but please, keep defending in bad faith

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:18PM (#38632728)
I watched a panel discussion on self driving cars in 2015 with several legit experts in the technology (I believe Sebastian Thrun was one of them). There were also some CEOs. The experts all said there’s no way the tech would deploy before 2025, potentially later. The CEOs were saying 2018 or 2019.

The experts had a clear view way back then, the CEOs just don’t want to listen.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:34PM (#38633009)
Waymo deployed cars without safety drivers to Tempe in 2021.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by aeturnum on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:01PM (#38633405)
This is always a game of boundary-setting. In one way that's true, in another way Waymo is 21+ years behind[1]. People have been setting up 'particular vehicles' to navigate 'particular areas' for decades. If the Waymo "self driving car" is an expansion of older site-specific tech, then there's nothing new under the sun. If their car is can be put anywhere then it just being able to drive in Tempe isn't proof of that.

IMO the truth is more with the experts. Each new location seems to require a lot of tuning to get right and function in a way the company is happy with. If a "self driving car" is one we can drop anywhere and have it drive we are still waiting on that.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ParkShuttle

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:12PM (#38633535)
Oh, come on, these kinds of false analogies don't help to elucidate, only to confuse.

There is a universe of difference between something like ParkShuttle (its own right of way, using magnets in the road to detect position) and modern autonomous vehicles. Saying modern autonomous vehicles have environmental constraints is valid, saying that makes then no different than a "people mover on wheels" is not.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by aeturnum on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:43PM (#38634564)
So my analogy is false huh? Then say a true one!

The point is that "deployed to a limited area" is not what people are thinking when they talk about a "self driving car." Of course ParkShuttle isn't the same as Waymo (or any other modern self-driving car) - but the question is how far we've come!

Are you claiming Waymo is ready to drive anywhere in the world? I do not think that's Waymo's position. So where are we? Cut through the rhetoric and tell it like it is - or join the rest of us who are speculating from the sidelines with incomplete information.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by deepsun on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:40PM (#38634532)
By the way, Particular Vehicles have been safely serving Particular Areas for decades: airport driverless shuttles. Slowly expanding from there is the right way to go, not "New York to Palo Alto by 2017", as Musk promised.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by aeturnum on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:46PM (#38634596)
Yah, without any evidence to back it up my personal suspicion is that we'll arrive at a local maxima of "full self driving on highways and instrumented roads" in ~20 years. I think the area has a lot of potential, but so much of the hype (and stock price) is tied up with "a car that can drive better than a human everywhere" which seems impossible for anyone to produce.

Just like with IoT we'll eventually arrive at a boring, useful state...it will just take a while.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by cycomanic on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:59PM (#38633376)
I'd argue even waymo is still far away from FSD. Driverless cars on a restricted set of roads with a remote operator monitoring things (and the ability to quickly resolve issues), is nowhere close to what I (and the general public I would argue) understands as fully self driving.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:34PM (#38633780)
Sure, if you set the goalposts in a place that's unachievable we'll never reach them.

- even human drivers cannot safely operate in all locations/conditions

- all self-driving cars will need a mechanism for cops to talk to a human

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by kelnos on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:46PM (#38633899)
The goal is to replace a human driver in every situation where a human driver could or would drive, with an equivalent or (ideally) better safety record.

Are you suggesting that Waymo is there? I don't think the evidence would support that. Even if we relax that goal a bit so the self-driving car can disengage and refuse to drive in, say, the most difficult 20% of situations, I don't think we can say Waymo is there, either.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by mannykannot on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:53PM (#38633984)
You just moved the goalposts in order to set up a straw-man argument!

One can quite reasonably point out that level 5 autonomy has not yet been achieved without moving the level 5 goalposts.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by boc on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:56AM (#38638276)
IDK, the Waymo cars that drive around SF meet my definition of full self driving. They handle a ton of weird traffic patterns, pedestrians, pickup zones, and very dense urban environments much better than I think you realize. Unless you live here, you probably aren't aware of their capabilities.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:53PM (#38635359)
Sure but the panel discussion was talking about consumer release of self driving cars, which really requires level 5 capabilities in a wide variety of conditions, not just ideal weather.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DoesntMatter22 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:38PM (#38633085)
Experts are wrong all the time. The experts said that solar prices would come down but were off by nearly an order of magnitude in how long it took.

With something this hard it's extremely tough to tell for sure when it will happen and often progress goes in chunks where it seems like it's going to happen but then doesnt.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by LamaOfRuin on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:30PM (#38633745)
Many experts predicted price declines with pretty fair accuracy. The large groups of experts that were making these forecasts for purposes of global planning for mitigation of climate change were often intentionally conservative because the danger of planning with that assumption outweighs anything you lose by making more conservative predictions.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by kelnos on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:50PM (#38633958)
Sure, but I'd trust experts in a field over a bunch of CEOs who have a vested interest in claiming something will be ready sooner rather than later.

Even CEOs who are an experts are by their very nature too biased to take at face value.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by r3d0c on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:48PM (#38633239)
> The experts said that solar prices would come down but were off by nearly an order of magnitude in how long it took.

citation required

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by zbyte64 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:14PM (#38633556)
I agree with all of this, but if the problem is too hard for the expert, why would I listen to a billionaire/CEO?
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by mulmen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:46PM (#38633897)
Experts have a narrow, deep view while CEOs have a wide, shallow view.

If the expert works in a lab developing new experimental solar panels they probably don’t see a clear path to mass production.

The CEO might know another manufacturing expert that does see a path to production and have enough high level understanding to know the methods are compatible.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by tcmart14 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:33PM (#38635143)
In this case yes, but in this case we have to assume the research side has achieved it's goal (its proven a material exists with the desired properties), now it is a manufacturing problem. If the lab can't produce the material, the manufacturing lines have nothing to manufacture with. And that seems to be the case with FSD. CEOs make wild claims, but the tech isn't there. The material has not been proven to exist in a lab with the desired properties.

Like a CEO saying, I have a material that can protect wearers from nuclear fusion blasts and it will be on the market in 6 months, but the experts in the field have yet to actually prove that material exists and create it in a lab.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by mulmen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:44PM (#38636342)
Sure, agree in this case.

But the point is that we are all equally capable of being wrong. Especially when we step outside our area of expertise. CEOs are just another type of expert but their domain is organization. We have to consider the source’s experience relative to the domain in question before we can decide if their prediction is trustworthy.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by zbyte64 on Monday December 18, 2023 @12:49PM (#38685769)
Both might be equally capable but the incentives are entirely different. An Engineer is motivated to deliver accurate predictions because that's their job. A CEO is not motivated to deliver accurate predictions because their main job is to hype their product and services.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DonHopkins on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:20PM (#38636184)
In this case the actual CEO we all know we're talking about is a serial confabulist who publicly agrees with anti semitic conspiracy theories and tells his advertisers to go fuck themselves, so your abstract hypothetical arguments generously giving some unspecified billionaire CEO the benefit of the doubt don't hold any water.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by mulmen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:34PM (#38636279)
It’s unfair to put words in my mouth to make your own unrelated point. It’s your choice to interpret my words as a defense of Musk.

If I wanted to defend Musk I would do it explicitly. You don’t need to read between the lines.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by skygazer on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:32PM (#38633770)
He also does dubiously claim to be an expert in many fields, although despite the success of the engineers working for him, his greatest personal expertise appears to be sycophant creation — competence can only propel one so far.

Although one should never believe the ravings, useful work does surprisingly often nucleate around them, just not to the degree or with the speed promised.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by medvezhenok on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:02PM (#38634805)
Not many people, even experts, predicted the success of ChatGPT even five years ago - and most have moved their timeline for AGI up significantly because of its release.

AI is a hard field to make predictions in.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @10:12PM (#38637344)
> AI is a hard field to make predictions in.

Right but "hard to predict" does not mean "it will happen whenever I want it to happen". You can't look at a very hard problem, where a good sample of the world's experts say it will take more than 10 years to solve, and just say "I bet we can do it in 4 years" just because you want that to be true.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by phatskat on Thursday December 14, 2023 @09:46AM (#38641878)
Do you have sources on those predictions moving up “significantly” because of ChatGPT? Predicting words that sound good together, as a result of a prompt, based on a pre trained set of data is vastly different from AGI.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by medvezhenok on Thursday December 14, 2023 @03:13PM (#38646634)
I can't find the exact article I read it in at the moment, but ChatGPT was definitely a turning point where a bunch of people reeled in their predictions by a decade.

(The median expert prediction was between 2040-2060 previously, now quite a few people have moved that timeline to before 2035).

https://medium.com/@paul.k.pallaghy/chatgpt-did-any-one-remo...

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/hQysqfSEzciRazx8k/forecastin...

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by bdcravens on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:59PM (#38632436)
Possibly, but then don't make promises and have the audacity to charge for it
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by serf on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:47PM (#38633221)
who in their right mind would look at any problem in any field with the title of "hardest problem" and then put a schedule to it?
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by pyrale on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:46PM (#38635268)
A deluded narcissist?
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by signatoremo on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @06:13PM (#38635558)
Apparently 1700 AI experts in the field just recently did:

https://research.aimultiple.com/artificial-general-intellige...

Check out for more predictions by experts:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_singularity

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by fragmede on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:07PM (#38632555)
I dunno, AGI seems like a hard problem too.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by mensetmanusman on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:32PM (#38634431)
We will know that AGI is more likely to be solved when FSD is easily solved.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by acdha on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:44PM (#38633179)
FSD is a substantial subset of AGI: driving is full of edge cases where you need to be able to reason about unusual conditions or behavior by other drivers, understand what someone like a flagger or police officer is saying, etc.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by deepsun on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:41PM (#38634544)
Not necessarily -- we can have AGI, but it might be too resource-intensive to put in a mobile platform like a car.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by mannykannot on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:10PM (#38634181)
It is not obvious that even level 5 FSD will require either self-awareness or a theory of mind: adequate modeling of the possible behaviors of nearby actors in the immediate future may be "all" it takes, and current systems are struggling with that.

Of course, if one were to define FSD in terms of being so capable that it could also likely pass the Turing test (or whatever better replacement we come up with as a measure of AGI), then, by definition, it would be close to as hard a problem as AGI itself.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by acdha on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:33PM (#38634448)
I said “substantial subset” precisely to avoid this kind of tangent. My point was simply that there are a lot of edge cases we have no clear path to solving which are masked at the current level by punting the problem to the human driver. We are a very long time from being able to build cars without manual controls even if we might hit the point where a majority of driving miles are automated long before then.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by mannykannot on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:25PM (#38637052)
"Substantial subset" is precisely the claim here that I have my doubts about. I think it is entirely possible (for the reason I gave previously) that AGI is at least as far beyond level 5 autonomy as level 5 autonomy is from the current state of road vehicle automation.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by fragmede on Thursday December 14, 2023 @03:22AM (#38639056)
Cars without manual controls are closer than you think. The Waymo cars do just fine without a human driver in the seat, and before they got suspended, Cruise was just starting a pilot program with vehicles without manual controls called the Cruise Origin. Sale of such a vehicle to the general public is a ways off but for a taxi service we're pretty close.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by acdha on Thursday December 14, 2023 @07:49AM (#38640758)
Cruise reportedly had human interventions every 4-5 miles. I haven’t seen a similar figure for Waymo, who are generally believed to be considerably better.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by JoshTriplett on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:26PM (#38632886)
Safe AGI is a hard problem. AGI is, sadly, not hard enough.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by AlexandrB on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:09PM (#38632586)
This is important to consider when judging Tesla's engineering capability, but not when judging Elon Musk's highly optimistic promises.

Either Elon is aware of the fact that FSD is really hard and he's lying repeatedly about being able to deliver it "later this year". Or he is not aware that FSD is as hard as you say and needs to "hit the books" and understand the problem better. I don't really see an "out" here after so many missed promises.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:50PM (#38635321)
Software timelines are notoriously hard to forecast because you're essentially trying to predict how long it will take to do something nobody has done before.

So you look at what's left to do and as long as you don't run into any unforeseen issues you say, looks like about six months from now.

Sometimes you don't run into any unforeseen issues and it turns out to be about six months.

Sometimes you do, and then it takes longer. So a year later you found an unexpected problem that delayed you by a year. Someone asks you how long you think it will take again, that issue delayed you by a year but that was a year ago, so you say, looks like about six months from now.

Eventually the estimate will be true but nobody knows when because nobody knows how to make an accurate estimate. Because you have to know how hard it is to do in order to know how long it will take, which nobody knows until after somebody has actually done it.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by seadan83 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @06:39PM (#38635806)
Just reminded of the an old trope for estimates, either:

- less than 3 months

- 3 months

- 6 months

Anything less than 3 months - is an accurate estimate. Otherwise, 3 months is the amount of time it takes to do _anything_, right? If it's a really hard problem, then we say, okay, it's 6 months. At the end of the day, those 3 months and 6 months means "NFC", which goes back to the estimation technique that everything is either a "1", "TFB", or "NFC". 3 months = TFB, 6 months = NFC

On a more serious point, we (as software engineers) generally feel we can solve almost any problem with 3 months worth of resources and effort. 3 to 6 months sometimes (IMO) can be a bit of the scariest estimate to give or receive.

For reference & more on NFC/TFB/1 estimation technique: https://pm.stackexchange.com/questions/26218/how-to-implemen...

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by Wytwwww on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:41PM (#38636321)
> Software timelines are notoriously hard to forecast

Perhaps. Of course, we all know for a certainty that this had almost nothing to do with you're describing. The people how were actually designing the software knew that it won't happen in six months. I doubt Musk wasn't aware of that, so the only alternative that he was lying.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday December 14, 2023 @02:54PM (#38646398)
> Of course, we all know for a certainty that this had almost nothing to do with you're describing. The people how were actually designing the software knew that it won't happen in six months.

How do we know this?

Waymo has had this "almost" working for years. In theory you could get from the status quo to actually working in a short period of time, if you're sufficiently smart or lucky and have the right resources.

Or you could hit a wall for years.

The things currently happening with LLMs and image generation were the sort of things many people said were many years away, if not impossible, but we got there by basically throwing a lot of compute at some clever but relatively simple ML algorithms. Nobody knows until you try.

It's obvious that his estimates are optimistic, but optimism isn't inherently malicious.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by Wytwwww on Friday December 15, 2023 @05:28PM (#38659606)
> How do we know this?

Some life experience + common sense?

> In theory you could get from the status quo to actually working in a short period of time,

In theory we could build a rocket that would fly a person to the moon in 6 months.

> if you're sufficiently smart

If that's the case, you wouldn't be making such bold claims (or rather actually believing in them yourself)

> LLMs and image generation were the sort of things many people said were many years away,

Does that include the people who were actually working on them in OpenAI?

> It's obvious that his estimates are optimistic, but optimism isn't inherently malicious.

In some cases it's either malice or stupidity/delusion.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday December 16, 2023 @03:30AM (#38662738)
> Some life experience + common sense?

If you asked people with "life experience + common sense" if generative AI would soon be possible six months before it actually was, they'd have said no and been wrong.

> In theory we could build a rocket that would fly a person to the moon in 6 months.

Kennedy said it would be done by the end of the decade, people called him crazy, and then it happened. The people saying it couldn't be done were still saying it right up until the day it happened.

> If that's the case, you wouldn't be making such bold claims (or rather actually believing in them yourself)

I don't think he, or anyone, believes that it will definitely happen in six months. He's giving the optimistic end of the range, but everybody knows that.

> Does that include the people who were actually working on them in OpenAI?

Before they had them working internally? Yeah, it did. Nobody knew it would work until it actually worked.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by Wytwwww on Saturday December 23, 2023 @02:14PM (#38747138)
> the AI would soon be possible six months before it actually was, they'd have said no and been wrong.

GPT 3.5 / 4 were an iteration of previous models, their performance wasn't that exceptionally surprising if you were working in the field.

Also, these are fundamentally different problems. Self-driving requires massive amounts of real-world testing and then you have all the regulatory and safety/legal stuff to do. That's simply infeasible in 6 months no matter what. Generative AI has no such constraints.

> Kennedy said it would be done by the end of the decade, people called him crazy, and then it happened. The people saying it couldn't be done were still saying it right up until the day it happened.

So? I don't see any link to what we're discussing. Kennedy didn't really have that much direct involvement in the moon program.

What we're discussing is an equivalent of the head of NASA, in ~1966 or so publicly declaring that they'll send a crewed mission to the moon in 6 months (even though everyone knew that wasn't possible no matter how hard everyone worked).

> He's giving the optimistic end of the range,

He's just saying random unsubstantiated stuff because that's just what he does all the time (or because he wants to sell more cars IDK).

> Yeah, it did. Nobody knew it would work until it actually worked.

I'm pretty sure that was an iterative process, so they knew quite a while before it actually "worked" (could be released to the public).

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by freejazz on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:04PM (#38634824)
One would think this would be a good reason to not promise that you'll have solved it within a timeframe that's not even remotely realistic
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by didntknowya on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:17PM (#38634991)
can't be that hard if he claimed he could finish it in 3-6months.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by DonHopkins on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @06:51PM (#38635918)
There's a lot of water you're carrying there, Stan.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by marginalia_nu on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:54PM (#38636425)
Especially if that is true, maybe don't promise a solution before having it working?