Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su...
by cycomanic on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:59PM
(#38633376)
I'd argue even waymo is still far away from FSD. Driverless cars on a restricted set of roads with a remote operator monitoring things (and the ability to quickly resolve issues), is nowhere close to what I (and the general public I would argue) understands as fully self driving.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su...
by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:34PM
(#38633780)
Sure, if you set the goalposts in a place that's unachievable we'll never reach them.
- even human drivers cannot safely operate in all locations/conditions
- all self-driving cars will need a mechanism for cops to talk to a human
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su...
by kelnos on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:46PM
(#38633899)
The goal is to replace a human driver in every situation where a human driver could or would drive, with an equivalent or (ideally) better safety record.
Are you suggesting that Waymo is there? I don't think the evidence would support that. Even if we relax that goal a bit so the self-driving car can disengage and refuse to drive in, say, the most difficult 20% of situations, I don't think we can say Waymo is there, either.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su...
by mannykannot on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:53PM
(#38633984)
You just moved the goalposts in order to set up a straw-man argument!
One can quite reasonably point out that level 5 autonomy has not yet been achieved without moving the level 5 goalposts.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su...
by boc on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:56AM
(#38638276)
IDK, the Waymo cars that drive around SF meet my definition of full self driving. They handle a ton of weird traffic patterns, pedestrians, pickup zones, and very dense urban environments much better than I think you realize. Unless you live here, you probably aren't aware of their capabilities.