News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:34PM (#38633009)
Waymo deployed cars without safety drivers to Tempe in 2021.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by aeturnum on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:01PM (#38633405)
This is always a game of boundary-setting. In one way that's true, in another way Waymo is 21+ years behind[1]. People have been setting up 'particular vehicles' to navigate 'particular areas' for decades. If the Waymo "self driving car" is an expansion of older site-specific tech, then there's nothing new under the sun. If their car is can be put anywhere then it just being able to drive in Tempe isn't proof of that.

IMO the truth is more with the experts. Each new location seems to require a lot of tuning to get right and function in a way the company is happy with. If a "self driving car" is one we can drop anywhere and have it drive we are still waiting on that.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ParkShuttle

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:12PM (#38633535)
Oh, come on, these kinds of false analogies don't help to elucidate, only to confuse.

There is a universe of difference between something like ParkShuttle (its own right of way, using magnets in the road to detect position) and modern autonomous vehicles. Saying modern autonomous vehicles have environmental constraints is valid, saying that makes then no different than a "people mover on wheels" is not.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by aeturnum on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:43PM (#38634564)
So my analogy is false huh? Then say a true one!

The point is that "deployed to a limited area" is not what people are thinking when they talk about a "self driving car." Of course ParkShuttle isn't the same as Waymo (or any other modern self-driving car) - but the question is how far we've come!

Are you claiming Waymo is ready to drive anywhere in the world? I do not think that's Waymo's position. So where are we? Cut through the rhetoric and tell it like it is - or join the rest of us who are speculating from the sidelines with incomplete information.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by deepsun on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:40PM (#38634532)
By the way, Particular Vehicles have been safely serving Particular Areas for decades: airport driverless shuttles. Slowly expanding from there is the right way to go, not "New York to Palo Alto by 2017", as Musk promised.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by aeturnum on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:46PM (#38634596)
Yah, without any evidence to back it up my personal suspicion is that we'll arrive at a local maxima of "full self driving on highways and instrumented roads" in ~20 years. I think the area has a lot of potential, but so much of the hype (and stock price) is tied up with "a car that can drive better than a human everywhere" which seems impossible for anyone to produce.

Just like with IoT we'll eventually arrive at a boring, useful state...it will just take a while.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by cycomanic on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:59PM (#38633376)
I'd argue even waymo is still far away from FSD. Driverless cars on a restricted set of roads with a remote operator monitoring things (and the ability to quickly resolve issues), is nowhere close to what I (and the general public I would argue) understands as fully self driving.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:34PM (#38633780)
Sure, if you set the goalposts in a place that's unachievable we'll never reach them.

- even human drivers cannot safely operate in all locations/conditions

- all self-driving cars will need a mechanism for cops to talk to a human

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by kelnos on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:46PM (#38633899)
The goal is to replace a human driver in every situation where a human driver could or would drive, with an equivalent or (ideally) better safety record.

Are you suggesting that Waymo is there? I don't think the evidence would support that. Even if we relax that goal a bit so the self-driving car can disengage and refuse to drive in, say, the most difficult 20% of situations, I don't think we can say Waymo is there, either.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by mannykannot on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:53PM (#38633984)
You just moved the goalposts in order to set up a straw-man argument!

One can quite reasonably point out that level 5 autonomy has not yet been achieved without moving the level 5 goalposts.

Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by boc on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:56AM (#38638276)
IDK, the Waymo cars that drive around SF meet my definition of full self driving. They handle a ton of weird traffic patterns, pedestrians, pickup zones, and very dense urban environments much better than I think you realize. Unless you live here, you probably aren't aware of their capabilities.
Re:FCC upholds denial of Starlink's $900M rural broadband su... by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:53PM (#38635359)
Sure but the panel discussion was talking about consumer release of self driving cars, which really requires level 5 capabilities in a wide variety of conditions, not just ideal weather.