News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Pannoniae on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:58PM (#37865194)
I have come to a funny realisation recently. It's not my eyesight which is becoming worse, it's the UIs which are becoming worse. The tiny scrollbars with laughable contrast are in no way accessible to anyone. I've recently switched to using KDE with the Oxygen theme and it's a joy to use without any eye strain.

These scrollbars are absolutely pathetic, with no room for customisation. (good luck theming a locked-down application) It's blatant how UI designers don't give a damn about the users' needs, not even in FOSSland. I am not entirely sure why this is the case but it's a sad regression from the days when we had good-looking, functional, accessible and snappy software. Not locked-down, unthemable electron bullshit.

Also, we wouldn't need "dark mode" or the such if the UIs had any contrast and were legible.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by speeder on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:36PM (#37865482)
I don't use dark mode for contrast, I use because a lot of software "light mode" is just plain white. And screens been getting more and more powerful.

Often using software without white mode the thing is so bright, that the walls near me get lighted up as if I was using a flashlight or something.

Thus I have to make the screen less bright, but often this also make the screen colors and contrast get all screwy and I still can't see anything.

I miss Win 9x era grey interface... it wasn't beautiful but I could actually see stuff.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Groxx on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:59PM (#37865660)
... Ya know, I haven't thought about that before, but screens are a lot brighter now aren't they. I wonder how much of the dark mode thing is just that the old good defaults are now eye-burningly bright, so of course people don't like them as much.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by franga2000 on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:04AM (#37867255)
Screens can get brighter now, but if your screen is too bright, that's entirely on you. Adjusting the brightness is trivial and you can even do it without using the buttons on the display (DDC/CI).
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by TazeTSchnitzel on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:48AM (#37868733)
On the contrary, some new monitors are so bright even on their lowest setting that you have to find alternative solutions.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by layer8 on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:40AM (#37869069)
That’s really just bad tech not fit for the purpose, though.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by poszlem on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:12AM (#37869715)
Oh, okay, problem solved then.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by layer8 on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:01AM (#37870088)
I mean, don’t buy those. There are enough suitable monitors on the market.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:37AM (#37870462)
Sure, if you're made of money.

Not everyone is.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by petsfed on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:11PM (#37874336)
About 3 years ago, I actually did research about monitors before buying one, for the first time in my tech-using life (which started around 1990, as I recall). Up until that point, it was never a question of "what is the best monitor for my application?", but rather "what's the biggest, highest-resolution monitor in my (pitiful) price range, that Best Buy (or whoever) has on hand right now?"

That's pretty much the issue here in a nutshell.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by layer8 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:52AM (#37879049)
It began for me 15 years or so ago when backlights started to make high-pitched noises and 16:10 monitors started to become less common. It’s been rough since for various reasons, but brightness not going low enough isn't something I've experienced as a widespread issue. SRGB mode is pretty dim at 120 cd/m², so monitors usually are able to go at least that low, and typically much lower.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by magicalhippo on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:22AM (#37869784)
I have a (marginally) HDR monitor, and I run Windows 10's HDR mode. Immediately it was noticeably blander than non-HDR, but I've quite grown to like it. I find it very pleasant to use for long stretches for work and such.

When I play games I get the vivid colors and contrast so all good.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by robotnikman on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:44PM (#37874024)
Interesting, I have an HDR monitor but never tried actually using the HDR function. It does seem to make a difference and feels nicer on the eyes. I'll have to see how it affects games too.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by mmis1000 on Sunday October 15, 2023 @03:09AM (#37887596)
Windows map sdr color in HDR mode in the way that srgb profile monitor display sdr color. So it is actually what it intended to be.

It's just that monitors nowadays don't even default to SRGB profile.

Windows in hdr mode with hdr monitor(vesa certified) and windows in sdr with a monitor set to srgb mode should have an almost identical visual.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by mgbmtl on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:36AM (#37869440)
Sometimes when using Wayland on my laptop, I have to switch back to X11 just because Wayland has no way of controlling the contrast.

(I tried searching a few times, no luck..)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by LeifCarrotson on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:02AM (#37870100)
"Too bright" depends entirely on the context. I control-tab and alt-tab like a maniac these days (might reduce that by getting a fourth display, used to think that would be excessive but the Overton window has shifted and I'm coming around on the idea).

The default UI here on HN features your username in #828282 on a background of #F6F6EF [1], a contrast ratio of 3.54:1. The up and downvote arrows are #999999 on #F6F6EF [2], a ratio of 2.62:1. On a high-brightness screen, these less-intense contrasts look great. And this is far from the only place with 'nice calm greys' that are intentionally used by designers to reduce eye strain.

I run Visual Studio in dark mode, and Windows Explorer in dark mode, and Notepad++ in dark mode, and Omron Sysmac Studio in dark mode, and Autocad Electrical in dark mode, and Alibre CAD at the default (light gray) theme, and they look great. I'm in a nice, bright office, with (4) daylight 4' T8 LED bulbs directly overhead, and a whiteboard as the backdrop to my monitors, so it's not like I'm a recluse in a dark cave. The monitor brightness is not wrong.

At least, it's not wrong until I win-right or alt-tab over an Excel document or an old version of Studio 5000, where the color profile is stuck at black text on a white background. Then I'm instantly blinded. I can't set half the monitor (just the part over the Excel spreadsheet) to the right contrast and brightness to make Excel acceptable, because then I can't see better-designed apps.

And don't get me started on opening up a movie or game after work's done. "Set your brightness so the logo is barely visible." Yeah, no. "Game of Thrones is a cinematic show and therefore you have to watch it like you’re at a cinema: in a darkened room." Wagner and Snyder are watching their productions on studio-grade OLEDs. I won't put a show on the integrated screen of my old Thinkpad or Precision laptops, I know those displays are trash (and they're small, I only put stuff that's easy to see on them), but no brightness setting on my relatively nice IPS LCDs can comfortably handle the diversity of content they're used to display.

[1] https://webaim.org/resources/contrastchecker/?fcolor=828282&...

[2] https://webaim.org/resources/contrastchecker/?fcolor=999999&...

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by VoodooJuJu on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:58AM (#37870689)
This is something that has always boggled my mind.

>Gee, this stark white brightness is hurting my eyes, maybe I should turn down the brightness on my display...

>Nah, I'll just demand every single company completely overhaul the CSS and contrast of everything while begrudgingly suffering the eye-burning whiteness of companies that haven't yet overhauled their CSS

Like wtf?

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by zamadatix on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:21PM (#37872286)
If everyone would design against properly calibrated monitors it would be fine, you could just set it to the standard calibration, but they don't so there is no universally good brightness you'd never need to change for. It's like webpage sizes, if everyone built and tested their UIs at the standard physical screen scaling then you would run into a lot less variance in website sizes.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Groxx on Saturday October 14, 2023 @01:26AM (#37878294)
If everyone had calibrated monitors and every app and website was the same brightness, yes.

Instead, it varies wildly, often for good reasons... and then switching windows exposes you to extreme shifts. E.g. switch between photograph editing and a giant white text document, nothing's gonna save you then - stuff that looks correct and good for photography is absurd when most of your screen is the same as the sun.

Calibration is one thing, perceived brightness of the whole screen with specific content is another. And it's heavily influenced by how many nits are available, particularly since calibration will often try to use as much of that range as possible.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by zamadatix on Saturday October 14, 2023 @07:14PM (#37885149)
Calibration in this case isn't about providing "and so everything then looks like it's the same brightness, because it's calibrated" it's about "and so the same modifications can be applied to everything consistently, because it's all calibrated". I.e. just lowering the brightness a bit below the intended value now is impossible. One thing built on a monitor with it's brightness curve undercalibrated and one with its brightness curve overcalibrated will look two different kinds of wrong when shifted by such a transform. That would not be the case with calibrated sources, everything would shift in the same way and you're able to have it look "wrong" (i.e. darker, capped, brighter, whatever) exactly the way you want, consistently.

Taking it to the DPI example, having things built at a standardised DPI isn't about making everything appear the same physical size it's about making everything tuned against a consistent physical size for the exact same reason, default is always intended and your global adjustments are always consistently resulting in the source material being larger than intended or smaller than intended instead of "well, depends how uncalibrated the source was if it's still smaller or larger than intended".

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Friday October 27, 2023 @07:46AM (#38037281)
> Calibration in this case isn't about providing "and so everything then looks like it's the same brightness, because it's calibrated" it's about "and so the same modifications can be applied to everything consistently, because it's all calibrated".

You seem to be assuming the commenter you replied to didn't know that. As I understood it, all they were saying is that advice about calibration is useless for people who don't do photo editing, but whose problem is exactly that different windows have such wildly varying brightness that switching from one to another often makes everything look either pitch dark or third-degree-interrogation light in your eyes.

Which category of people do you think there are more of? My bet is on the latter. They need... Well, if you don't want to call it "another kind of calibration", you're free to come up with another term.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by vonjuice on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:25PM (#37873118)
My phone's lowest brightness is way too high for night use (yes even with a blue light filter), it's super annoying.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Groxx on Saturday October 14, 2023 @01:24AM (#37878284)
Yeah - I'm glad Android finally has the "extra dim" mode to reduce that with oleds (only barely effective with LCDs), but it comes at the cost of awful contrast. Lower output is much better in comparison.

I like being able to see my phone in sunlight nowadays, but there have definitely been some tradeoffs.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hulitu on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:01AM (#37867612)
> screens are a lot brighter now aren't they.

No. You just use them in the dark.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Zekio on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:56AM (#37868000)
screens output way more nits these days, I remember not being able to see a screen properly because a lamp was on due to the monitors only having 200ish nits, these days you can get +1000 nit monitors, this is especially true for HDR monitors
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by speeder on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:21AM (#37868961)
You just reminded me of something funky.

To play PS5 I bought a monitor instead of a TV, because the place where I had to install the screen in the rented apartment is tiny, and tiny TVs are just crap with tons of input lag. So I got a gaming LG monitor.

Many PS5 games, specially those with HDR support, offer help in adjusting the brightness, often in the form of showing a very dark and a very bright image side by side, and telling you to adjust your settings until both are visible.

I found out that no matter what I do, this never happens. In the end the best setting is when NEITHER are visible. If the dark image is visible, the screen is so bright it feels like staring into a flashlight. If the bright image is visible, the screen is so dark that I can't see the contents of the screen with my curtains open or the lights turned on. I can't wrap my head around how someone can make a screen be so crap.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by kuschku on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:08AM (#37869689)
Cheap LG monitors have contrast turned up too high. Turn it down and you'll be able to have both visible at the same time.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by lozenge on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:01AM (#37870094)
It looks better in the showroom under retail lighting. Take a look through all the settings.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by abofh on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:55AM (#37869575)
No. I suffer from an eye pigment issue, meaning bright actually hurts. Old screens don't hurt even on white. New screens physically hurt.

You, however, should stay in the dark.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by least on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:57AM (#37870672)
Does being outside generally hurt your eyes? Most complaints about brightness of screens has to do with the contrast between it and ambient lighting. When I'm in a dark room a bright screen is going to be hard to use. In a well lit room it's not an issue. It's kind of why ambient light sensing is a nice feature.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by eru on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:44AM (#37871193)
> Does being outside generally hurt your eyes?

I'm not the OP, but yes, going outside sometimes also hurts my eyes, depending on how bad the sun is.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by wkat4242 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:08PM (#37865718)
True. I use my screen with 0% brightness during the day and I have to reduce contrast during the night (which leads to reduced colour depth). Using dark mode is unavoidable for this reason.

Display manufacturers should really not just look at the maximum brightness but also the minimum.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by anjel on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:34PM (#37865872)
...with light light blue labeled data fields against a white background. Its nothing less than sadistic. Thanks Redmond, may I have another?
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by panzi on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:09AM (#37868897)
Yeah, I run my monitor at 20% brightness, unless for watching movies. Then I change to 50%. Wish it would had presets.

Anyway, I prefer the ever so slightly beige Interface of Windows 2000. Same contrast and GUI esthetics, but less drab grey.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by WarOnPrivacy on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:39AM (#37871811)
> a lot of software "light mode" is just plain white. And screens been getting more and more powerful.

Yep. Without darkmode, my screens light up my neighbors fence like those Appalachian backyard streetlights.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by gattr on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:07PM (#37872891)
I've been using dark themes whenever possible for a few years now, but recently realized much of unpleasantness of light mode comes for me from it being too blue w.r.t. the ambient lighting conditions. Playing with the slider in "Night Color" under KDE or "Night light" under Windows does the trick.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by kps on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:18PM (#37873030)
Or change your monitor's colour temperature setting. It probably defaults to 6500K, and you want something in the 5000K–6000K range.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by gattr on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:11PM (#37875685)
But the SW sliders are much more convenient; say, at work the desirable blue light level varies quite a lot (e.g., a sunny afternoon with blinds half-closed vs. a rainy morning), and a smooth adjustment is very nice to have.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Gualdrapo on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:30PM (#37865439)
One thing I just love about KDE is that when you right-click on an "empty" area of a scrollbar, it offers you options to go to the very top or the very bottom of whatever view you're seeing.

I seem to recall that something like QtCurve offered buttons to do that within the scrollbar.

If only everyone did that, many time wasted in scrolling would be saved and "go to the top" buttons in websites wouldn't exist

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by shiroiuma on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:51AM (#37868353)
That sounds nice, but I'm using KDE right now and just tried it on several apps and it doesn't work. In Chrome, it just brings up the regular right-click menu the browser normally provides. In actual KDE apps, it does nothing.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:44AM (#37871866)
It didn't work for me either.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by jfim on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:14PM (#37865332)
> I have come to a funny realisation recently. It's not my eyesight which is becoming worse, it's the UIs which are becoming worse.

We've hit peak usability about twenty years ago, in the Windows 2000 era. The screenshot in the article is actually from about that era, it's one of the early 10.x (10.3 I believe) OS X releases.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by masswerk on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:09PM (#37866130)
Arguably, Snow Leopard was peak interaction design. Just for the highly functional visual grouping of elements. (MacOS has drifted off from this quite a distance, since.)
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by eadmund on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:11AM (#37869709)
> Arguably, Snow Leopard was peak interaction design.

System 7 or 8, methinks. Clean, cool and collected.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by agloe_dreams on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:01AM (#37870730)
Today in HN: A billion armchair rants about Windows 2000 being the best UI forgetting just how much it actually sucked at usability or accessibility features.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by steve1977 on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:49AM (#37871257)
I'll have to admit that I don't know about its accessability features, but I was at least as productive in Windows 2000 and XP as I am in todays systems.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hulitu on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:22PM (#37873078)
In Windows 10 i lost a lot of time because of UI bugs: double click registered on single mouse clicks, UI elements dissapearing when connecting monitors, no scrollbars, no window border, no titlebar.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:41AM (#37871842)
It's possible that people remember how much it sucked, but they also recognize that the UI sucks even more now.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by jwells89 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:17PM (#37865348)
> Also, we wouldn't need "dark mode" or the such if the UIs had any contrast and were legible.

Contrast is a factor yes, but the other thing that's happened with the flat UI epidemic is banishment of mid grays and light grays in favor of stark white and off-whites, making "light mode" much more bright looking than it had been previously. It's no wonder people were clamoring for dark mode after blinding flat UI had taken over.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hypercube33 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:31PM (#37865447)
Not only that but it seems like color from icons has gone - now we get black and white ones. I'd get it if these companies making the UX were small, because yes its super hard to deal with accessibility and different color blindness but I agree - we've lost anything but the extremest of the extreme colors.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by jwells89 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:35PM (#37865477)
The ironic thing about icons losing their color and detail is that it happened right as high DPI displays began to become commonplace in consumer hardware. We have these amazing screens with barely visible pixels and the excellent color reproduction being wasted on rendering monochrome lines.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by bitwize on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:48PM (#37865978)
Forget Gtk or Qt, we may as well link against libXaw. It's a perfect match for the detail in "modern" UIs.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hulitu on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:04AM (#37867640)
Xaw is much, much better. Colors are configurable, scrollbar width is configurable.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by masklinn on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:23AM (#37867008)
Monochrome lines are cool tho, ink or charcoal can be gorgeous, and “barely visible pixels” are genuinely needed to get them.

That aside, high dpi displays are still a rare sight on desktops, there’s not many of them and the aspect ratios and ancillary features are extremely limited.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by shiroiuma on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:30AM (#37868223)
>That aside, high dpi displays are still a rare sight on desktops

No, they aren't. ALL displays these days are high-dpi, when you compare to the 640x480 and 800x600 screens that were normal in the late 1990s. But the window managers back then were FAR better (in functionality and appearance) than what most of us use today.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by masklinn on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:50AM (#37868754)
> No, they aren't.

Yeah they are.

> ALL displays these days are high-dpi, when you compare to the 640x480 and 800x600 screens that were normal in the late 1990s.

Leaving side your wilful misunderstanding of fairly standard concepts, no they are not: the monitors you are talking about were generally tiny, and the minor increase in median pixel density was largely counteracted by the blocky precision of LCD pixels.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by mort96 on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:39AM (#37869911)
In modern parlance, "high-DPI" or "HiDPI" does not refer to your 24" 1080p screen. That's solidly a "low-DPI" screen; it's perfectly usable with UI elements rendered at "1x".
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by steve1977 on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:39AM (#37871138)
Not really. DPI is dots per inch. As screens were much smaller then, their DPI (or rather PPI) wasn’t much less.

For example, Macintosh was 72 ppi for a long time ( it is 109 ppi now).

My first LCD screen was 15“. And that was for a desktop, not a laptop. 17“ or 19“ were for rich guys or graphics designers ;)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by dredmorbius on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:41AM (#37869476)
There's also an increasing prevalence and popularity of e-ink displays. Though some of these are colour-capable, most are monochrome, and I've definitely had challenges negotiating apps and content which use colour as a key differentiator.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by mort96 on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:37AM (#37869890)
Is there actually an increasing prevalence and popularity of e-ink displays? I know there technically exists some "high refresh rate" e-ink screens these days (meaning you can get 10 FPS if you're comfortable with a whole lot of ghosting), but aren't e-ink screens still pretty much only used in dedicated e-book readers?

Personally, I think it's just that monochrome icons are fashionable. I can't imagine that the GIMP developers for example chose to make GIMP's icons monochrome because that works better on e-ink screens.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by dredmorbius on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:47PM (#37876433)
There's a wide range of e-ink tablets and displays available. Many of the tablets run Android and are largely the same as any other Android device. The displays can be used with any OS, obviously. There are also e-ink phones (smart and otherwise), watches, and other devices.

For text and graphics, you'd generally want to use a higher-quality, lower-refresh-rate mode. Which is to say that there's quite a bit of established UI/UX knowledge that wants a refresh. I've distilled a set of basic principles: persistence is free, pixels are cheap, paints are slow, colour is (mostly) nonexistent, and the more ambient light the better. Paginated-navigation (whole screen changes in one go), line-art, and dithered or halftoned images work relatively well, raster images not quite so much, though can be acceptable.

<https://diaspora.glasswings.com/posts/638a8d10e041013afba844...>

For a demonstration of a wide range of displays (the best ones are featured last) as of 2021, see: <https://yewtu.be/watch?v=KdrMjnYAap4>

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by dredmorbius on Saturday October 14, 2023 @01:31AM (#37878308)
And specifically addressing prevelance and popularity ... I'm mostly commenting based on my own perception. Looking for more solid data ...

... I'm having difficulty finding e-ink / electronic paper market research, though one hit suggests an 8.5% CAGR: <https://dataintelo.com/report/global-e-ink-sales-market/>.

Using HN as a rough proxy, I see fairly substantial growth. Note that HN submissions overall have been fairly constant since 2012, per dang.

"e-ink"

  2007:  1
  2008:  7
  2009:  14
  2010:  18
  2011:  24
  2012:  28
  2013:  24
  2014:  24
  2015:  16
  2016:  25
  2017:  22
  2018:  39
  2019:  35
  2020:  60
  2021:  88
  2022:  84
"Electronic Paper" has minimal hits, though by years above: 0, 0, 1, 0, 1, 2, 1, 0, 1, 6, 1, 1, 0, 0, 8, 1.

"Digital paper" has an even smaller smattering of hits.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:55PM (#37876853)
I doubt Apple began removing color years ago for a display technology they never used.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by dredmorbius on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:59PM (#37877493)
That wasn't my argument ...

... though Apple has had monochrome devices (the original Mac, the handheld Newton) ...

... and often makes preparations years on advance for long-term strategic moves.

I'm putting very low emphasis on that last, as e-ink really doesn't seem to fit particularly well with the Apple ethos, except, perhaps, for watches.

But if Apple were planning, or even contemplating, an e-ink device, ordering a flat white UI/UX might be precisely the first step in getting there.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:19PM (#37877816)
What was your argument? Apple's historic monochrome devices are irrelevant. And Apple used color on color displays in those times.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by dredmorbius on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:55PM (#37877953)
My argument here (<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37869476>) is that across all OSes, and for the Web generally, being mindful of monochrome, low-refresh-rate displays is something that should be front-of-mind for UI/UX teams and design.

Many of these issues already exist, e.g., for documents which are likely to be printed on monochrome devices. Colour is useful where available, but it is not universally available.

(And that's before addressing issues such as colourblindness or other disability / accessibility considerations.)

My original comment was not at all specific to Apple (you'd introduced them to the discussion), other vendors, or any specific OS or application. Simply that monochrome and e-ink are increasingly concerns.

But since you raised the topic of Apple, and since, contrary to your initial statement that, broadly speaking, monochrome was "a display technology they never used", I'm both correcting the record, and noting that should there be a monochrome or e-ink prospect on Apple's roadmap, and further noting that Apple rather famously does not announce such roadmaps in advance, that flat/white would in fact fit with e-ink remarkably well.

What that has to say about whether or not Apple is contemplating any such move I am, of course, entirely ignorant.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Thursday October 26, 2023 @09:59PM (#38033837)
Since decades being mindful of monochrome displays and color blindness meant selecting appropriate colors and using different shapes along with different colors. Removing color where available is not useful.

Any explanation of the anti color trend must explain Apple's participation. Especially because Microsoft and GNOME appeared to imitate Apple.

I did not say monochrome was a display technology Apple never used. You named e ink. And monochrome is not a display technology.

Other trends included more transparency in content areas, links almost unidentifiable without color, and other reliance on small shade differences. And Apple made all app icons the same shape. All worse for e ink.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Friday October 27, 2023 @07:50AM (#38037305)
> Colour

OK, that does it. You're a Hong Kong viking, not a Seattle baker.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Monday October 16, 2023 @03:40AM (#37896816)
> it seems like color from icons has gone - now we get black and white ones.

No, light grey -- or some other light pastel colour -- and white.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by g-b-r on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:14PM (#37865335)
I think it's just become common belief among developers that scrollbars are bad... (facepalm)
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by wildrhythms on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:58AM (#37869190)
My experience is 'developers' have no issue with scrollbars; it's the higherups and designers that find scrollbars antiquated and obsolete in a world with touchscreen devices.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by g-b-r on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:29PM (#37877034)
true
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by treyd on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:06PM (#37865709)
> It's blatant how UI designers don't give a damn about the users' needs, not even in FOSSland.

Especially with this new "don't theme my app" movement. It's really unfortunate. The issues with CSS stylesheets in GTK should be solved with replacing CSS with a better way to describe styles, not with just throwing it all away and not letting the user set their own themes.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Pannoniae on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:13PM (#37865749)
Yup. GNOME/GTK is a lost cause in my eyes. Literally worse UX than Windows.

The developers basically say "fuck you" if your use case does not perfectly align with their "vision".

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Gigachad on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:06PM (#37866115)
Honestly I want the app to just set its look exactly. I really don't care if different programs look slightly different as long as its internally consistent in app.

What I hate is installing a program that was designed for a KDE distro and because you run gnome all the icons are the same color as the background and alignments on things are whack.

Package it all up in a flatpak so it looks and works exactly the same on all distros. One complete and verified experience.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Pannoniae on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:15PM (#37866167)
"One complete and verified experience." These words sound sickening to me. None of these have anything to do with accessibility, or respecting the user.

The user should be in control of his computer. That includes the programs on it. Locking it down so you can have "verified authentic design" is just straight-up user-hostile.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pseudalopex on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:57PM (#37866466)
Those words reminded me of Apple's 1984 commercial.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Gigachad on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:23AM (#37866643)
This is the main reason I switched to MacOS. Was sick of everything on Linux being contentiously broken out of the box with the excuse "Oh you are meant to just configure the icon colours and toolbar padding yourself"

The programs can still be open source so you can recompile with whatever look you want, but they should bundle a working experiance by default.

But linux users seem more obsessed with curating custom themes over having things actually work.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Pannoniae on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:19AM (#37866988)
I shouldn't have to recompile something to customise it. Make the defaults whatever you want sure, but even if you don't provide GUI config, provide an environment variable or a config file. "just recompile it" is incredibly user-hostile.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by kaba0 on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:40AM (#37871149)
And who will make sure that the program actually works properly in that one-off hacked up, “press spacebar to heat up CPU” configuration you have?

Linux userspace is buggy, and I think this very-minimalistic approach sort of grown out from frustration about that. And they may be right, maintainers really don’t have the resources to do much better, especially when most frameworks they depend on has their own share of fatal, almost impossible to fix bugs.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by treyd on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:58PM (#37866475)
I disagree. The user has accessibility needs and preferences that the app developers necessarily can't know about. App developers shouldn't be trying to enforce styles/themes/icons on the user when they might be completely unusable depending on their needs. The inconsistencies between KDE and GNOME apps/themes are annoying, but that's a solvable problem.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by gonzo41 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:10PM (#37865739)
There's also the consideration that a decent style sheet can be ~100 - 200 lines long. Yet I see ~5000 line css files that have so much custom formatting for JS frameworks that build everything with divs, rather than using semantic HTML5 which has accessibility baked in.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by MereInterest on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:38PM (#37865912)
It seems like there's two wildly different ways that CSS gets used. In one style, a CSS class is a semantic category of things on the page, and the style sheet defines how it looks. In the other, a CSS class has no semantic meaning, and the style sheet defines a list of options to choose from. It's the difference between `<div class="user-comment>` and `<div class="bg-lt-gray-fg-dark-gray-bold-text">`.

The first type of CSS can be written succinctly, but the second cannot.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by SkiFire13 on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:30AM (#37867041)
"don't theme my app" is not about users theming their apps, but instead against distros theming by default and more importantly the expectation that you could theme every app with a generic theme.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pwdisswordfishc on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:02AM (#37869219)
Same difference. If you don’t support theming done by distros, you don’t support theming full stop.

I suspect even their attitude towards theming done by end-users is more akin to ‘well sure, if you insist, you have the full source code, I can’t stop you, but you’re on your own’ than considering it a fully supported configuration.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hju22_-3 on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:12AM (#37869713)
Hard disagree with your first paragraph. An application can have endless customization abilities, but still doesn't need to let the system choose a theme for it to support "full theming" as you put it.

There can also be legitimate reasons not to support it. On the top of my head, for example, the default theme being the most tested, etc., etc. In a perfect world, they'd all be tested and well integrated, but there's limited man power going around, and the world isn't perfect.

Though I otherwise agree.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by bluGill on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:16AM (#37870238)
Distros SHOULD be theming all applications. Once thing a distro can do well is create a theme for their distro so everything looks the same.

Maybe distros are not doing a good job of this, but that is one thing they have the power to do. QT, GTK2, SDL, wxwidgets, and more toolkits I can't even think of should all fit together on my desktop and look the same. xfce, gnome, and kde all have some nice apps, they should mix and match. This is a HARD problem, but that isn't an excuse to not face it.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:39AM (#37871818)
> Distros SHOULD be theming all applications. Once thing a distro can do well is create a theme for their distro so everything looks the same.

I would reject a distro that did this (unless I could disable it). But users should be able to make everything look the way that works the best for them.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by bluGill on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:58PM (#37873518)
Wait, we haven't even seen this theme or how well it is done and you already reject it?
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:34PM (#37877880)
Yes, because there is no way such a thing could be done that would be great for everyone. Different people have different needs.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by asoneth on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:43AM (#37871862)
I would also like to live in a world where it is easy for end-users and distros to theme apps. But with current technologies and cultural expectations this results in an untenable testing and support burden on app developers.

We could shift cultural expectations so that distro maintainers become the first tier of support for all app issues in their distro, and escalate issues to app developers if and only if they've confirmed that the issue is distro-agnostic. That would be sustainable for app developers but could be a heavy burden for small distro teams.

> This is a HARD problem, but that isn't an excuse to not face it.

Agreed, I just don't think it's the responsibility of app developers to solve.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by o11c on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:22PM (#37865804)
"Dark mode" is needed in dark rooms, since screens don't autoadjust their backlight based on the room's white point.

The concept of "white point" is often spoken of in terms of color, but brightness very much does matter too. It is painful for there to be something (especially something large) brighter than "white".

**

That said, we should have automatic dark mode based in inverting HSL's "lightness" (this can trivially be done directly in RGB, just check the min and max color channel of the pixel, then adjust all channels to flip them), rather than requiring ad-hoc color schemes all over the place.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by callalex on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:44PM (#37865950)
This is one thing Apple got right a veeeery long time ago. Every screen they have sold since like the mid 2000s, both integrated and standalone, has had auto brightness. I don’t understand why other manufacturers still can’t that right, to this day, no matter the price category. Even most non-Apple smartphones these days still suck at this.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by bee_rider on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:51PM (#37866008)
I’m surprised Linux doesn’t have some ubiquitous “use the camera to do auto-brightness” option (pinging the camera on a proprietary OS would be creepy, but if it is open source…).
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by callalex on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:55PM (#37866046)
That wouldn’t work very well because pretty much every webcam has auto exposure adjustment. Also a camera is good at determining how much light is in the room behind you, not how much light is hitting the screen. There really is no substitute for a photodiode and a halfway decent control algorithm. It only costs a penny so there really is no excuse not to include one.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by bluGill on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:18AM (#37870258)
I know a lot of people who have covered their camera with tape. Some laptops even come with a physical shutter. This is something company policy often recommends - if the camera is physically covered an attacker can't see the next product we are working on.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:43AM (#37871858)
When I buy a laptop, one of the things I'm looking for is that it doesn't have an integrated camera at all. It's happened sometimes that I can't find one, then I cover the camera with tape.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by theodric on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:09PM (#37874307)
The Lunar dev has a variety of recipes for a hardware widget you can build which allows their macOS-only brightness-control app to implement adaptive brightness on any monitor that permits backlight control over DDC/CI. I'm sure a more-motivated and clever person than me could tap into that hardware and use it to drive ddcutil/ddccontrol outputs on Linux.

https://lunar.fyi/sensor

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by layer8 on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:49AM (#37869121)
> screens don't autoadjust their backlight

CRT monitors had easy dials to quickly adjust brightness and contrast. You almost did it automatically without thinking when you had developed the motor memory. Nowadays monitor controls are often fiddly and awkward. But I still use them to adjust brightness to the environment.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by theodric on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:00PM (#37874201)
There are some tools out there that will allow you to bind hotkeys (or at least provide a widget) to send brightness-adjustment commands via DDC/CI over the HDMI/DP cable to your desktop monitor. This may improve your UX. My 2015 and 2021 Dell monitors both support the functionality, with differing degrees of finesse.

Non-exhaustive list:

Linux: https://github.com/ddccontrol/ddccontrol || https://github.com/rockowitz/ddcutil

macOS: https://github.com/MonitorControl/MonitorControl

Windows: https://github.com/emoacht/Monitorian

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by biocross on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:04PM (#37877512)
If you’re looking for something that allows media keys and custom keyboard shortcuts: https://displaybuddy.app/

Works on both Windows and Mac

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by layer8 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:39AM (#37879009)
Monitorian requires a subscription for hotkeys and CLI, unfortunately.

Twinkle Tray is an alternative: https://github.com/xanderfrangos/twinkle-tray

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by tom_ on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:28PM (#37865832)
How old are you? I bet you a pound you're 40, or thereabouts. Trust me, your eyesight is becoming worse...
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by tom_ on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:30PM (#37865848)
I got a downvote. OK, let's upgrade that to 2 pounds ;)

(Of course, that was a lot of money when we were both young...)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by vidanay on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:38PM (#37865904)
I'd down vote you if I could see the damn tiny arrow.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by tom_ on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:41PM (#37865928)
I gave you an upvote, so it cancels out.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by worik on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:45AM (#37866791)
I voted.

Up. Down. I'm really not sure....

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Pannoniae on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:36PM (#37865888)
I am 20 years old^^
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by tom_ on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:45PM (#37865956)
Actually a mildly interesting response! - thanks. If we ever meet, £2 is yours.

When I was 20, the idea that my eyesight might have become meaningfully worse over time never really occurred to me. Fascinating.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Pannoniae on Thursday October 12, 2023 @10:50PM (#37865999)
You seem like an interesting person^^:)
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by keyringlight on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:50AM (#37869129)
One thing that I've found interesting (in my 40's and slight astigmatism) is how the effects of eyesight show up in interfaces or where there's contrast with brightness/darkness.

In the physical world that'd be issues like bright points like car headlamps or street lights having a large corona/starburst, or if you're looking at a bright object against a dark background such as reading a book where it's lit in a darker room the 'bloom' will obscure what's behind it. On a screen with much brightness I'll get similar effects if there's contrast. I've been window shopping for a HDR display for a while now and wondering how much benefit I'd get out of it seeing as the main selling points are the brightness/contrast, especially when you're getting into the various forms of local dimming to present the media at its best.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by kps on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:18AM (#37870251)
Whatever the monitor, you will want to adjust it after buying. Default ‘showroom’ settings are much too bright unless you're working outdoors. Start with something like https://www.photofriday.com/info/calibrate or http://www.lagom.nl/lcd-test

For me, with (mostly-corrected) astigmatism and some (uncorrectable) higher-order aberration, dark on light is the only thing I can read fluently. The worst case is ‘black holes’ on a light page, as are fashionable for illustrating command line examples (and f—ing github's CI log view), especially combined with Las Vegas syntax colouring of varying brightness.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by thaumasiotes on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:23PM (#37866216)
True, but not relevant and not a contradiction of the comment. Pannoniae says that the empirical decline in usability of software is attributable to changes in the UI and not attributable to changes in his eyes. The fact that changes in his eyes exist is not a refutation.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by katakuri on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:11AM (#37867291)
I love oxygen theme. I was so glad to find out that it was still installable as an application style in KDE 5. I hope it still is in the next one
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hulitu on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:00AM (#37867600)
> I am not entirely sure why this is the case

Earlier we had ICCCM (inter client communication convention manual). Now we have freedesktop.org.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by alpaca128 on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:47AM (#37867934)
> we wouldn't need "dark mode" or the such if the UIs had any contrast and were legible

Have you tried dark mode in Windows 11? It turns the entire window bar black, if multiple window bars happen to overlap it is impossible to tell them apart visually. On top of that in some programs it also turns the close/min/max window buttons completely black unless hovered by the cursor!

Microsoft should fire everyone at the company who ever made a UX design decision - except for the people who made the Windows Phone 8 UI, their only consistent and intuitive UI in the last 15 years.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Dalewyn on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:23AM (#37869351)
I use "dark" mode in Windows 11, but it turns the title bar a nice blue shade since I actually went and configured it (it's right next to the mode setting). I actually can't configure the color in "light" mode where it's always white if I recall, though.

The other criticisms are valid though, the last good Explorer UI was Windows 7.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by psd1 on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:59AM (#37870068)
Windows Phone was visually stunning. Thanks for reminding me of it!

I don't know what you mean about turning the window bar black. Did you set the theme to "high contrast"? I've used dark mode on windows since it became an OS feature and never had that problem.

Microsoft's UX has been poor since Win8, but not for graphical reasons. 10 and 11 look great out of the box - far better than any other OS I've seen, although tbf I haven't done much distro-hopping.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Podgajski on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:24AM (#37869354)
If we are talking UI we need to talk about Apple.

The first thin I do on MacOS is turn on the scroll bars. Yes, MacOS Has them set as "Only Show When Scrolling" by default, which is probably the most ridiculous setting.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by leokennis on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:26AM (#37869374)
I saw those fat candy looking aqua scrollbars in the linked article and I immediately thought how great OS X used to look and work. Truly sad the mess macOS is now.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by tannhaeuser on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:18AM (#37869763)
Not getting it. I mean, if Mac OS lets you configure scroll bars (and I haven't noticed a problem with the defaults so far either) that's much much more than can be said about gnome isn't it? Where gnome theming has gone from black magic in v3 to ... anathema in v4.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:32AM (#37869854)
It seems like most people who scroll use touch, wheel, or other non-scroll-bar interfaces, and the scroll bars are just a visual indicator of document size and position while navigating it. I know I do— and have for 20 years unless I was using a shitty laptop without a scrolling input method. Maybe unless I'm scrolling through literally millions of lines of text, which is infrequent enough that I'd prefer to have them hidden and revealable by scrolling a bit.

Not having them take up screen real estate and working with most people's usage styles while being configurable for others is the right decision. The problem is systems and applications that don't let you configure them.

People talk about accessibility and their preferences like they are absolute truths— it's a lot more complex. Not having scroll bars sucks for people that never got comfortable with other scrolling input methods and people who use sight interfaces, for example. They couldn't possibly be less relevant to people who use screen readers, and as an input method rather than an Univision visual indicator, only slightly more relevant to people on phones and tablets. Phone and tablet usage has outpaced regular computer usage for quite some time, and that informs users interaction style. Adding visible UI elements adds cognitive load, and for people who never worked with scroll bars out of necessity, they're just another bulky animated distraction on the screen. Most younger users would probably think them about as useful as an always-visible on-screen keyboard.

I guarantee you— the designers at Apple who chose to hide those scroll bars probably thought more about scrolling more than every one of these commenters combined, and that was before they did formal usability studies.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by lozenge on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:55AM (#37870031)
The days of usability studies are long gone.* It's now change for the sake of change.

Spot the indication that not all settings sections are shown in this screenshot, in all display settings and lighting conditions that your device might be used in.

https://imgur.com/a/pMUKwjT

https://imgur.com/a/2ADNH2B

* Were they ever there? I can't believe this dialog background - https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2001/10/macosx-10-1/4/ - was the "winner" in any usability study. This was removed in 2003-11 with the release of 10.3.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:57PM (#37875538)
a) That scroll bar decision was made a long time ago

b) Problems with specific dialog boxes or dynamically created features is evidence of problems with those dialog boxes or dynamically created features. As someone who's worked both as a developer and a designer, often the engineers win.

c) Assuming that these topics are simple enough for off-the-cuff reckonin' to validate or invalidate them are exactly why the engineers shouldn't win when it comes to interface decisions.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by bluGill on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:58AM (#37870054)
Does anyone apply formal usability studies anymore? (not just do them - do they apply the results). I was trained in formal UX long ago, and many UIs today outright violate common rules we learned back then. High contrast was considered important for low vision users even if it looked ugly then. Now most UIs are lower contrast and while they look nicer, they are less usable.

Of course I learned long ago and so I'm willing to accept that what was best practices back then might be wrong given new research that I'm not aware of. However this seems unlikely.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by williamcotton on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:39AM (#37870481)
I go to the store to buy a hammer. I’m a hammer user and I use the hammer.

Or I go to the store and I buy heroin. I’m a heroin user and I use the heroin.

These UIs we speak of, are they hammers, or are they heroin?

Because I’m currently looking at a high contrast screen using a mixture of Unix tools created from the late 60s to yesterday.

I’m looking at an Excel spreadsheet made by a team of lawyers that is in a UI. The lawyers themselves highlighted and handled the contrast of the document. Beyond the table itself, Excel’s menu bar is easy to read for the basic operating needs of a spreadsheet. I mean come on, the pivot table UI is clearly masterful. (If Excel was a native plaintext tabular format and you could pipe stdin/out to the GUI app? Gimme!)

However, a lot of software is basically useless these days. It’s not designed from the beginning to be productive in any shape or form.

Some stoned dance by a junkie under a highway overpass is definitely some kind of expressive art form. How much more productive is the expressive art forms promoted by TikTok, Twitter or Twitch?

There’s clearly a scale at play. I’m as big fan of Twitch as much as I’m a big fan of the Buffalo Bills. I’ve always appreciated the sociological aspects of sports. To add some context to my definition of productivity, I would say that group sporting events are overall productive from a sociological perspective, be it IPL cricket or Fortnite tournaments.

TikTok is clearly and quite obviously towards the junkie dance scale of things.

From an experiential position there was not much of a difference between my observations of a woman filming herself doing a weird little dance on the sidewalk while completely oblivious to the rest of the world and the junky on the next block doing a weird little dance on the sidewalk while completely oblivious to the rest of the world. This basic object-level assessment of the actions that we and others experience with our physical bodies is core to the very notion of “meaning”. The “meaning” is just the stoned dance.

I know of no junkies famous for only being junkies but there are definitely TikTokers famous for only being TikTokers so don’t confuse this for some strict equivalence.

I’m just trying to establish a kind of framework for discussing the relationship between productive UI and productive software tools.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Friday October 27, 2023 @08:08AM (#38037422)
> These UIs we speak of, are they hammers, or are they heroin?

A hammer is useful for doing stuff, which modern UIs increasingly aren't. So it seems they aren't hammers.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by asoneth on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:39AM (#37870472)
Formal usability testing is still practiced in enterprise, military, and professional products.

From what I've seen from colleagues in the consumer space they've predominantly switched to A/B testing and statistical clickstream/log analyses, though large companies sometimes still do run lab studies for important decisions and to rationalize the giant one-way mirror they installed.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:17PM (#37875738)
It depends on how big/important/popular of a product you're talking about, but most software that your average joe uses (operating systems, native communication apps, national websites) likely either conduct significant usability testing or largely inform their designs using great usability testing from people like the mozilla foundation and the nielsen norman group. And no-- neither of those organizations have to be perfect for that to be a perfectly valid approach, and if you follow that guidance, you'll never end up with a 'very low contrast' interface.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:13PM (#37875704)
A)Yes. I've been in the software business in some capacity for the better part of 25 years and software usability right now is miles beyond what it used to be. Thinking otherwise is a function of nostalgia.

B) if you're doing dev work, you're probably not entirely cognizant of how different your software selection and usage patterns are than most people's, even for non-dev things.

C) there's a whole lot of interfaces out there and the great ones work so naturally and intuitively that you don't even notice them. Those are the ones for which many assume the design decisions were so obvious that they didn't even need designers. That's so so not true.Look at the most popular user-facing software: web browsers are all obsessed with usability (mozilla actually does some of the best open usability research out there.) Instagram, Tik Tok, Facebook, Twitter, et al... Incredibly clear and usable for their target market. Can't get much higher contrast than you do in email applications and other communication apps. There are tools to guage if your text color/background color/ and text size make for readable text according to the WCAG and I have never had a job, either as a designer or as a developer, where AA compliance wasn't a minimum for all functional elements. Most common user-facing interfaces that regularly use light or white text on colored backgrounds, like the iMessage interface or signal, benefit from OS-level accessibility enhancements like increased text size, which are very commonly used among the people who need them. My non-tech-savvy elderly relatives all knew about them through the setup process on their devices when they first bought them, and never looked back. Looking through every communication or other popular user-facing software package on my Galaxy U22 using a default theme shows nothing even remotely low-contrast.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Sakos on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:14AM (#37870871)
> the designers at Apple who chose to hide those scroll bars probably thought more about scrolling more than every one of these commenters combined, and that was before they did formal usability studies.

This blind appeal to authority shouldn't convince anyone.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:20PM (#37875766)
If you've got an actual point to make instead of just poking at one little part of what I said, I'd respond.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Sakos on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:40AM (#37879015)
That point is how you justify all your conjecture. Rethink what you wrote because all you're really doing is relying on anecdotes. I can literally say the opposite (I always use the scrollbar for scrolling and everybody I know does too) and we'd have made zero progress.

You haven't actually made an argument worth arguing about. It's devoid of value and it's not a productive addition to the conversation.

And don't bother wasting any more of my time. I don't care. You clearly have nothing to say.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Saturday October 14, 2023 @10:27AM (#37880707)
Yes. This is exactly the sort of 90 word response made by someone who doesn't have time to waste on arguments they don't care about.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:17AM (#37870902)
> Phone and tablet usage has outpaced regular computer usage for quite some time, and that informs users interaction style.

"Informs"?!? Deforms!

WTF does phone usage have to do with sabotaging the UI on a computer???

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by JohnFen on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:34AM (#37871770)
Because designers and devs don't want to have to do multiple designs. Everyone's aiming for one design that works for everything. The problem is that such a thing is impossible.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:00PM (#37875570)
Vollying back your flipness-- This sort of reductive assumption about software design is why companies that need people who aren't developers to actually use their products hire interface designers.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by deprecative on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:17PM (#37876977)
Most employers I've had are all about getting engineers to be everything. Designers, infrastructure, QA, UI/UX, and even product/project managers.. everything.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Saturday October 14, 2023 @12:20AM (#37878051)
Sounds like you need new employers. The only people who want that are shortsighted managers who don't care that they know nothing about users' needs, and that's certainly not a universal disposition in the software business.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by deprecative on Saturday October 14, 2023 @05:59PM (#37884637)
This has been true of every employer I have ever had. It's true outside of "tech" as well but nearly all of my experience has been as a software engineer.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Sunday October 15, 2023 @01:01AM (#37887010)
I've worked in the software business for the better part of 25 years and my experience differs.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by yowlingcat on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:27PM (#37872353)
People are generationally creatures of habit. Newer generations are entering the workforce for whom their first personal computing device was a touchscreen smartphone. With that context in mind, it's not surprising that a "native" responsive experience to them will be mobile centric rather than desktop centric. The market then evolves to cater to the needs of its largest cohorts.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:25PM (#37875814)
Yes. To engineers, the interface is something you use to interact with software. To users, the interface is the software. When they buy (with money or creepy analytics for marketers) software, they're buying an interface. As anybody in business knows, you're not in the business you think you're in, you're in the business your customers think you're in, and if they expect software to behave in a way it can't, their competitor is a half-inch down the app store results/google listing/etc.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:59PM (#37875553)
Controls? Regardless of whether or not you like the changes, device usage changes the way people use other devices. What you deem "correct" is not the objective universal truth you think it is. Not knowing that is why almost all FOSS interfaces are an absolute dumpster fire.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by indymike on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:22AM (#37870966)
> Phone and tablet usage has outpaced regular computer usage for quite some time

This does not excuse making terrible user experiences elsewhere.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by chefandy on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:19PM (#37875749)
I think you're missing the point. Usability is not prescriptive. You implement what your users have the easiest time using. Touch interfaces change how people interact with interfaces. If you care about usability, you work with people on that and not against them.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by LeanderK on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:31AM (#37870404)
> Yes, MacOS Has them set as "Only Show When Scrolling" by default, which is probably the most ridiculous setting.

I have used MacOS every day for 10 years and i've never, except in exceptional circumstances, used the scrollbar to scroll. I don't see anybody in my circle using it. They all have the "Only Show When Scrolling" setting on.

I don't think this is ridiculous and I would enable the setting if turned off by default.

I also spend 99% percent of my time in full-screen mode in safari, vscode or terminal. So the top bar is also hidden by default. I think this is much more focused.

[dead]
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by LeanderK on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:14AM (#37898741)
it might be how you're using the computer. It shows by touching (not scrolling) the trackpad (and if I correctly remember also the magic mouse?).
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by agloe_dreams on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:59AM (#37870696)
I can, 100% say that I haven't used a scroll bar on the web in years. I do find the hidden scroll more aesthetically pleasing.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Sakos on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:15AM (#37870883)
Yes, we should absolutely make everything less accessible in the name of aesthetics. That's made computer interfaces so much better in the past 20 years.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by agloe_dreams on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:48PM (#37872650)
That's just it.

It is a choice, you can turn it on or off.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by ImPostingOnHN on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:50AM (#37871949)
Most people could say the same thing about wheelchair ramps, another form of accessibility
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by thepra on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:49AM (#37869990)
You're right about the scrollbar contrast, even though I've customized the hell out of the scrollbar in my collAnon pwa I made the mistake to make it less contrasting for design appeal reasons alone. I guess that's gonna go in the next release
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by kps on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:56AM (#37870045)
> Also, we wouldn't need "dark mode" or the such …

People with cataracts may benefit from dark mode. People with glaucoma or higher order aberrations (e.g. me) may benefit from light mode. Web sites should use `prefers-color-scheme`; native GUI programs should use the native equivalents (or default colours); command-line programs should not assume a particular background.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by hulitu on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:19PM (#37873044)
The main problem is that there is no dark or light mode. It is light gray on white or dark gray on black (and the white and black are also gray). It is just sick.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by kps on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:04PM (#37873573)
Low contrast is a problem, but high-contrast light mode and high-contrast dark mode are each also problems for some people.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Friday October 27, 2023 @08:17AM (#38037489)
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pjettter on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:05AM (#37870769)
I often wish we had more analog control in the digital world. I wish there were turn knobs instead up/down buttons with 10 steps (where it is easy to accidentally leave a menu... When trying to get back to where you were, you are suddenly adjusting something else entirely). Manual control with digital devices has become too digital and too cumbersome.

It used to be easy to adjust contrast and brightness on a display, volume on an amplifiee, an analog TV, a termostat, a car radio, etc.

I realize that we are not really on course (yet?) for reintroducing a lot of analog controls, but in the end, our world is analog. Input is analog via speech, muscle motion, etc. Output is analog, via light and other vibrations that reach our senses. Why isn't control more analog? It's probably a cost thing.

I would totally buy a display or a laptop with analog controls. I don't even care if the turn dial actually has 16M steps, so long as the response is pretty much immediate and feels like a real potentiometer. It should feel like direct manipulation and like you're in control, instead of these digital roundabout abominations.

As to the subject, I imagine having some knobs that I can adjust under different circumstances to quickly vary intensity or cycle through alternatives in order to make things more readable or audible.

90% Of what we do is in the browser today. Browsers could have an "accessibility" API such that turn knobs (bluetooth? whatever) could be used for control. Like scroll wheels but on steroids?

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by xahrepap on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:10AM (#37870827)
And when you finally have a along controls everything is overloaded.

Dish forced a new remote on us last time a device broke and they replaced it. It has far fewer buttons. I’m sure it helps getting familiar with it on a super basic level. But the old one wasn’t that complicated anyhow.

But here’s the kicker: there’s no fast forward or rewind buttons. There no stop button. No record button. All of these (and more) have been turned into menu items and/or secret chords on the remote.

Oh. And it has a mic on it too. Hard pass.

Tv remote is just the easy example. I see it all over the place. Sleek no longer is pretty to my eyes. If I see something that I have to interact with these days and it looks sleek, I see frustration.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by rapind on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:11PM (#37872170)
The worst offender of this is the Apple TV remote. Most of my actions with the Apple TV remote have been unintentional.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Mumps on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:23PM (#37872307)
Makes me think of the "MacBook Wheel" [0] from ages past.

It's really a shame how user-hostile design can be.

[0] https://youtu.be/9BnLbv6QYcA?feature=shared

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pjettter on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:42PM (#37873337)
Haha! I haven’t seen anything from the onion in years. They kind of became irrelevant at some point :)
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by addicted on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:23PM (#37873101)
Apple TV remotes have always been so awful.

I remember when Front Row for the Mac was announced. I loved Front Row (although the supported content was far too limited).

But despite Fromt Row’s limited functionality and simplistic interface, the Apple Remote still didn’t feel adequate.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by miramba on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:31PM (#37873872)
I just got an Apple TV and got crazy with the unintentional swipes and touches. Then I discovered you can turn that off, to click-only. It‘s much better now, maybe that helps you too.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by ourmandave on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:16PM (#37873009)
The reverse of that is the 4-in-one replacement remote with it's bazillion buttons.

It's like a 747 cockpit.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pjettter on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:25PM (#37873121)
At least everything is in a designated place!

That’s another thing I like about the analog world.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pjettter on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:22PM (#37873084)
Yes direkt a 1:1 mapping of an analog (button/knob) would work better than what you describe.

Multifunction buttons… that never existed in the analog world? Or is that what is called “mode”? Send vs receive etc. Does anyone have a concrete example?

I’m not a remote control designer but I would think it would be fun to give it a try! Maybe I will :)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by breakfastduck on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:19AM (#37870928)
Most plugins used in music software do take that approach. Where the plugin interfaces are modelled to look 'like hardware' in most cases, with nobs, sliders, all the things you'd expect on a hardware compressor / synth etc.

I like it.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by sojournerc on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:50AM (#37871259)
Even better, I connect a midi keyboard so I can use its knobs and faders to manipulate the plugins. Much better feel, and for something like eq, it's nice to be able to manipulate multiple things at once
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Wistar on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:46AM (#37871902)
“…it's nice to be able to manipulate multiple things at once.”

Particularly if one thing affects another in a ripple-effect or chain reaction. It is great to be able to adjust at least two values at once. Keeps you from going back-and-forth adjusting in ever smaller increments to get to the settings you want.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by utexaspunk on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:04AM (#37871455)
Knobs on a mouse UI suck
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by breakfastduck on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:07AM (#37871479)
Not this in this use case, in fact quite the opposite.

generally most want to have a knob they can adjust and not worry about the underlying value. It's in line with the philosophy of tweaking settings and not using your eyes to judge if its in the right position.

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pjettter on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:36PM (#37873245)
Halleluja!
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Wistar on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:40AM (#37871825)
The dressing up of digital controls to mimic analog controls is called skeuomorphic although I have not encountered the term in a long time.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skeuomorph

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pjettter on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:34PM (#37873217)
Yes, the “digital version” that mimics the analog one. It was cute in the mid 90’s.

I want actual physical knobs.not sure what that would be called. Potentiometers?

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by Wistar on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:08PM (#37873612)
Rotary encoders, I think.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pjettter on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:27PM (#37873141)
But then you have to “draw circles” with your mouse?
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by couchand on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:52PM (#37873452)
The UI usually maps linear motion quite naturally. In real use the control is mapped to a physical knob via MIDI, if you'll be tweaking it on the fly.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by riversflow on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:28PM (#37873848)
I wanted to learn Ableton and have determined that it,s futile unless I get a MIDI controller
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by breakfastduck on Thursday October 19, 2023 @02:54PM (#37947023)
Absolutely untrue, but a MIDI keyboard will certainly improve the experience.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by riversflow on Friday October 27, 2023 @01:22PM (#38041272)
I hope you see this, just noticed your reply! Thanks for the encouragement, music production/DJing is something I really want to get into, so encouragement is extremely welcome. :) My problem when I tried using it was that the knobs were really difficult to adjust with my mouse, like it didn’t feel responsive. Am I doing something wrong?
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by codedokode on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:27PM (#37873844)
No. There are so many plugins and so many knobs that you will never have enough MIDI control panels and time to set them up.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by ang_cire on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:44AM (#37871876)
This is actually one of the things I love about my Mini Cooper; they have cool physical toggle switches that feel like you're in a cockpit instead of the all-digital interfaces that feel like a coffee bar.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by pjettter on Friday October 13, 2023 @01:30PM (#37873179)
My 2014 GLK is like this. Mostly, somewhat. Not getting anything newer until they figure it out!
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by miramba on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:43PM (#37874014)
It seems we are so amazingly primitive that we still think touch screens are a pretty neat idea for anything. But I’m sure analog controls will come back at some time in the future: First in really expensive cars, as expression of luxury. Only cheap cars will still have the cheap touch screens. Slowly, the old new way of interaction will trickle down to anything else. Like it went for the digital watch, ubiquitous for a short time, then a return to analog. Although those Casios seem to have a retro-retro comeback lately. I think even real keyboards might be a cool feature of future high-end smartphones.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by kaba0 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @01:09PM (#37882250)
I mean, for most things a touchscreen is pretty much the ultimate human interface — we are fundamentally hand-based creatures and the ability to re-render the same glasspane into a controller for anything is still magic.

There are of course things where more specialized inputs are required, but for the rest, touchscreens are here to stay*

* One improvement I would like to see it about their surface — we can no longer blind type on phones, because we can’t feel the borders of the buttons - but I think we have the tech to dynamically make the screen’s surface rougher/smoother. Another idea is to bring back 3D touch (and potentially improve on that - maybe it could even take some 3D vector as input?)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by CRConrad on Friday October 27, 2023 @07:58AM (#38037352)
> It seems we are so amazingly primitive that we still think touch screens are a pretty neat idea for anything.

That looks familiar somehow... How many leaves should I pay you for this insight?

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by awiejailwrj on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:53AM (#37871981)
My current favorite is the vanishing scrollbars that appear for two seconds after you start scrolling. Chrome is awful with this. When I'm trying to review a couple-thousand-line PR, Chrome stutters and freezes, and the scrollbar won't show up for several seconds and then it immediately vanishes as the UI catches up with the input. Or sometimes I click on the ephemeral scrollbar but my click doesn't register until after it's vanished again. It's infuriating.
Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by stcredzero on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:15PM (#37873701)
The tiny scrollbars with laughable contrast are in no way accessible to anyone...It's blatant how UI designers don't give a damn about the users’ needs

I’ve seen this trend going on for over a decade now, like a slow parabolic arc. Somehow the aim of developers and designers turned around 180 degrees and became less and less about pleasing the users and more and more about impressing other people in your field. (Both programming and design.)

Re:Scrollbars Are Becoming a Problem by ilyt on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:58PM (#37874173)
It's also sad that 10-15 years ago near-everything I used was just themed based on system/windows manager and it was possible to make those changes system-wide (with some mess if you used QT apps with gnome and vice versa, but still), and now we're locked in hellhole of HTML and CSS "native" apps