but if I must take an alternative position: the last time I used youtube without premium (which happens sometimes because its not so smooth to log in if its a temporary session); the number and length of the ads was absurd, multiple levels of unskippable ads, minutes long, with volume that is much higher than the content itself. Awful experience and I can see why people who don’t have the free money want to lower it a little.
Thats of course not including sponsored content which contains an ad inside the video itself- even YT premium users get those.
"anyway, you can switch from the high end monopolist to the low brow monopolist so I don't see what you're complaining about" Yes, you don't.
the right to wear hair-shirts is not the only principle that counts.
The only part of Youtube that I find valuable is the content. Not the UI, not the comments, algorithm. Free content hosting is nice, but it's not the only platform hosting videos for free.
If I wanted to pay for a streaming service, it'd be Nebula (https://nebula.tv/), because I know it benefits creators.
But I'm never turning off the adblocker, thank you.
Huh? Ad revenue and Premium subscription also ends up as direct payouts for YouTube creators, what are you talking about? Why the need for this BS?
I follow a wide variety of channels, but there are maybe a dozen to 20 that I would consider essential. Maybe 3-4 are on Nebula.
I think for a lot of viewers and creators, YouTube is simply inevitable at this point.
I'm using NewPipe (https://newpipe.net) on Android TV which provides an ad-free YouTube experience just like the Android phone version of NewPipe. Piped would also work on an Android TV browser like TV Bro (https://github.com/truefedex/tv-bro).
The legitimacy of ad blocking is well-established. People have been using DVRs, VHS players, and tape recorders to capture and consume ad-free broadcasts for decades.
You're only looking at this from your own point of view. The content producers are looking for monetization options, and youtube is the only game. Nebula might be sufficient for some small amount of content producers, but it's unlikely to hit mainstream, and not enough people want to pay.
It's unfortunate, but ads are the only game in town on the internet atm.
How is this any different from changing the channel, leaving the room, or just hitting the mute button and closing your eyes in the scenario of "regular" TV when adverts or any other content you don't want to see appears? Compelled consumption should be illegal.
If you created a painless, super easy way to remove all ads, i'm sure that TV channels will also find it hard to sell to advertisers, and thus, their revenue would decrease.
We had that almost 3 decades ago:
https://www.orlandosentinel.com/1995/09/20/with-this-vcr-com...
I always found it bizarre that other people did not do the same
Since ad sections are your typical break from a program to get to the fridge or toilet or whatever, the DSP transform makes sure you still hear the ads and pick up dialog even when far away from the TV.
Downmixing audio so that you can both hear dialogue and not lose eardrums to music and 'splosions seems to be an intractable decades old problem for the movie industry but it sure as hell been solved a dozen times over by the ad biz.
It was very shocking to go from 75dB to an ambient 30dB or something like that out in the countryside. I'd have much preferred to talk over or zone out over the commercials without the suddenly shocking lack of auditory stimulus!
I watch TV on my tablet now, streamed from a Raspberry PI with a TV Hat. Again, I activate the popup player, start browsing, maybe checking HN or whatever. I put the volume off. Maybe I start doing something else. The advantage of a tablet is that I can bring it with me wherever I go in my house. The TV, not so much. I rarely switched on my TV in the past two years.
Of course on cabled channels, they get part of the fee of your package.
There is no "compelessed consumption", there is available package "this for free with ads", or "this for a fee", you're free to chose the one you want or neither.
I'm certain your company whichever it is would have an issue if I wanted to use its services but then run away when it came time to pay the bill.
Now before you dismiss this as childish and/ or obnoxious: please consider the point. We cannot gloss over _what_ we "have" to watch and not just that it's an ad.
It is true that things have to be paid for and I am 100% for this. But if you want me to basically degrade myself in order for me to get to watch your content, then wtf?
But the most important issue is that as long as malware can spread through ads (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malvertising), everyone should be blocking all ads.
Or should we just continue consuming people's services and effort while blocking what's sometimes their only revenue stream?
I'd rather not use a service if it has ads and I can't remove them, instead of block them and make everyone else's experience worse.
In fact, not blocking internet advertising is a security risk.
If they get their house in order my opinion may change, but there's currently no business reason for them to change their existing lax systems; no pressure or threat from regulation to hold them liable for what they allow on their advertising networks.
That didn't last long...
Still doesn't protect you from in-video sponsorships (skullshare, OstVPN, etc.), product placements, etc. Some creators especially do these because it protects them from platform demonetization risk.
Same shit with paying for cabletv & movie theatre tickets. If anything, people that pay are their most valuable targets for ads.
Even a newspaper that I sub to runs ads and a zillion trackers against me. Ugh.
I get where you're coming from, but the platform could more to protect paying members from this. E.g. creators with over $x revenue must tag promos so the platform ships them for paying users
But now they have ads.
Also, YouTube is a video streaming monopoly, if it didn't exist there would be a significant chance of new streaming platforms to succeed, but given that it captured the marked such chance is unlikely to exist, monopoly that they achieved hosting videos free of ads (or very light on these) and now that they have the control want to force people to pay or watch a ridiculous amount of ads.
I listen to news and podcast-esque things in the car going to work or school drop-off / pick-up, on the way to sport etc. I'd begrudgingly tolerate the ads if the app background-played but it doesn't without paying for premium. I'm somewhere on an "entitlement" scale here, but background-play being a premium feature really feels like it's stretching the friendship.
So... alternative front-end it is. Great experience and no ads to boot.
Do you know that the paid version has this exact feature? This is a limitation of the ad-supported version, because advertisers are paying to actually have people watch their ad.
Imagine Youtube preventing you from adjusting the volume unless you paid. This is similar.
The said ability exists on the YT website if you use desktop mode on the mobile browser.
I already pay Google much more than I care to and am willing to in the form of my privacy and personal data because of the ubiquitious surveillance that Google performs on as many people as they possibly can.
If I could cut Google out of my life I would do it in an instant, but I can't because they won't allow it. In lieu of that I take whatever I can from them.
“To steal from a brother or sister is evil. To not steal from the institutions that are the pillars of the Pig Empire is equally immoral.” -- Abbie Hoffman
And I dislike YouTube's hostile ad escalation in recent years. One ad - fine, two ads - hmmm, three ads - what the hell. Unskippable ads. Inappropriate ads. Loud-ass eardrum ripping ads. Ads even on Premium.
They've tried? It seems like it would be pretty easy to detect ad sequences in larger channels.
I really dislike the attitude of defending megacorps and worrying about their bottom lines, especially anti customer ones like Google.
Things cost money. Every monetizing strategy involves users paying for it or the company making money from the users indirectly. OP mentions both of these. So tell me, what's a monetizing strategy other than these that works?
People consumed videos online at a very limited scale before YouTube, and those videos were usually hosted by few, generous individuals. Even if every user in the world decides to contribute 50% of their device storage for a decentralized streaming platform, I doubt it would even fit a small part of all videos in YouTube's catalog right now.
I really dislike the attitude of hating megacorps without really proposing any viable alternatives.
Consider a freemium model without the threat of adxtortion, obviously this would require youtube to offer a significant value add and/or premium content besides trying to be a monopoly and gatekeeping eyes. Make it purely subscription based (e.g. Netflix before ads). Ask creators to pay for the blue checkmark. Make it a loss leader. Plenty of adult streaming sites manages to do just fine without youtube style invasive ads. I'm sure much smarter people can name countless other ways as well, it also does not need to be a 1-1 alternative either.
This. PeerTube can provide similar benefits without centralization.
I remember I had this discussion after a school political debate in the 90s, with (adult) actual politicians. Textbooks at the time were not publicly funded, and naturally the textbook companies jacked up prices for their captive audience forced to buy their books.
This one party had the "brilliant" idea of ad-funded textbooks. I asked, if the textbook companies currently take $50 for the book, if it was instead funded by say McDonalds ads, how many extra burgers would each student have to buy that year? They didn't have any good answer to that.
It's the same as blocking YouTube ads; Google still pays the creator as if you had watched the ads, so your video playback is being subsidized by Google's ad business profits.
When you choose not to block ads, you aren't "supporting creators", you are supporting Google shareholders.
Google's shareholders might, for a while, for the sake of "control". But either way, it's not sustainable. The anti-adblockers are right about that part. They're just wrong that watching ads without spending a ton of money on the products help matters.
See here (picture gallery): https://johannes.freudendahl.net/2019/01/werbung-in-romanen/
The introduction goes like: "Only Kirk kept helping himself, because he was convinced he would need strength for the upcoming events." and then below the black bars the actual ad: "The reader should do same bla e.g. soup bla takes just 5 minutes etc"
Just some anecdote.
What about fair advertising? The main problem here nobody dares to talk about because dealing with it would undermine the very essence of capitalism: unlimited growth, is that there is no way to have fair advertising exactly as there's no way to have a fair use of any resources. Once you allow anything to be used for profit, it will be abused from the strongest players at the expense of the others until the last drop. It would be extremely easy to put well defined limits on how much advertising can be shown, and make the Internet a better place, but no way, it's anti capitalistic and therefore a no-no. Ad blockers weren't born the same day advertising came to the Internet, and many years passed until someone realized we needed them; that was the day surfing became such a horrid experience thanks to unlimited, pervasive and ever growing advertising.
edit: and, by the way, I still have to see some company going bankrupt because of ad blockers.
Why are you defending a multi billion dollar company from something that the users aren’t obliged to do in the first place?
People using their excess Internet connectivity, they already pay for for other reasons, to share content with others.
It works for socially disadvantaged, too.
(Some people are unable to afford it but that's an entirely separate social problem, and it would be unusual for somebody with the skills demonstrated in the article to be struggling to earn a living wage.)
What I would be interested in this protobuf inspection approach for would be implementing some decent parental controls. I would very much like to be able to enable/disable individual youtube channels. Currently all I can do is switch the whole site on and off. I have all the necessary infrastructure already, so I might give it a try.