Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by sfifs on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:11AM
(#37280163)
> removing the ability for the app to continue to play the clip in the background when switching to another app or locking the phone.
Do you know that the paid version has this exact feature? This is a limitation of the ad-supported version, because advertisers are paying to actually have people watch their ad.
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by BLKNSLVR on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:15AM
(#37280191)
Yes
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by izacus on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:27AM
(#37280259)
So they didn't remove it did they? You just refuse to pay for that service and spread bs to make you feel better?
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by BLKNSLVR on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:58AM
(#37280424)
They removed it from in front of the paywall to behind the paywall. The non-paid version used to do it. It was a memorably jarring experience working out WTF happened when background-play was rugged.
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by izacus on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:51AM
(#37280742)
I don't remember it ever playing in the background without a sub, when was that?
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by SergeAx on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:09AM
(#37280153)
The said ability also exists in a premium subscription. So what you effectively saying is that YouTube offers you a valuable feature, but you refuse to pay for it.
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by Tepix on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:40AM
(#37280320)
YouTube is not offering a valuable feature here. It's an OS feature. YouTube is going out of its way for you not to have this feature, unless you pay them (even though it wasn't them who brought you the feature to begin with).
I understand why this upsets people.
Imagine Youtube preventing you from adjusting the volume unless you paid. This is similar.
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by rightbyte on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:18AM
(#37280211)
It is fair to not want pay enshittification tax to rent seekers.
The said ability exists on the YT website if you use desktop mode on the mobile browser.
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by izacus on Sunday August 27, 2023 @03:28AM
(#37280265)
Asking you to pay for service costs and content is not rent seeking. That's not what that phrase means.
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by yard2010 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:14AM
(#37280856)
No but you have to agree on the enshitification part. Youtube turned to one of the worst UX apps I have on my phone, I hate paying them for such a shitty product and I'm waiting for the time they're off this planet
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by SergeAx on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:10AM
(#37281462)
But meanwhile you keep using that shitty awful app, aren't you?
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by laserlight on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:24AM
(#37280922)
Given that YouTube is a monopoly, I would call it rent seeking.
Re:Block YouTube Ads on AppleTV by Decrypting and Stripping ...
by izacus on Sunday August 27, 2023 @06:50AM
(#37281380)
Monopoly in what exactly?
I listen to news and podcast-esque things in the car going to work or school drop-off / pick-up, on the way to sport etc. I'd begrudgingly tolerate the ads if the app background-played but it doesn't without paying for premium. I'm somewhere on an "entitlement" scale here, but background-play being a premium feature really feels like it's stretching the friendship.
So... alternative front-end it is. Great experience and no ads to boot.