News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by samwillis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:13AM (#35872113)
For little extra context here (for anyone not in the UK), since the OP article was published we had the coronation at the weekend during which many anti-monarchy protestors were arrested - despite prior approval and communication with the Police ahead of the protest. This has been seen as the first major use of these new powers:

> Police accused of ‘alarming’ attack on protest rights after anti-monarchist leader arrested

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/may/06/head-of-uks-...

Prior to the coronation the Met Police tweeted:

> Our tolerance for any disruption, whether through protest or otherwise, will be low.

> We will deal robustly with anyone intent on undermining this celebration.

https://twitter.com/metpoliceuk/status/1653745710724968448

Again, this has been seen as further moves by the Met to quash the right of protest in the UK.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nailer on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:21AM (#35872161)
The right to protest is important, but there's a different between disruption and protest that I feel you're overlooking.

> Our tolerance for any disruption, whether through protest or otherwise, will be low.

> We will deal robustly with anyone intent on undermining this celebration.

This sounds like you'll be arrested if you leap in front of the motorcade, scream something in church, etc. Not if you carry a sign protesting the monarch. along the route

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by swores on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:24AM (#35872175)
And yet... people were arrested for having signs along the route. The police don't deserve any benefit of the doubt that you're trying to give them.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by silasdavis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:32AM (#35872261)
Indeed they were arrested and held for 16 hours on the basis of 'being equipped for locking on'. An newly created offence barely a week old.

They had cargo ties to hold their placards during transit. Of no practical use for locking on.

The metropolitan police has since says it 'regrets they were unable to join other protestors'.

Between this and the online safety bill there are some dreadful dacronian laws making it onto the statue books in the UK in recent months. Compounding other forms of monitoring and criminalising speech under hate and anti terror laws.

It definitely could happen here.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by makomk on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:42AM (#35872342)
Not quite. According to the protestors, they had ties that were supposedly going to be used to secure the placards to things as part of the protest (presumably to railings). Any tie that could be used to secure the pole on a placard to something could obviously be used by protestors to lock their own body to the same thing, and the Met are a bit twitchy about this due to having repeated problems with it over the last few years and especially months. (That's also why there's now a law allowing them to stop protestors before they lock themselves to things in the first place.)
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Symbiote on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:02AM (#35872479)
Cable ties, luggage straps or string should be of no concern. They're very easily cut by the police, even if the person is uncooperative.

"Lock on" protesters have used things like bicycle locks and handcuffs to shackle themselves to railings or each other. These are difficult to cut without injuring the person, especially if they're not cooperating.

Here's the Public Order Act, rushed through and taking effect from 3 May, with the coronation on 6 May: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2023/15/enacted

I'd argue cable ties, straps and string aren't capable of causing "serious disruption", and I assume the police/prosecutor agree. It's very concerning that the police made the arrests anyway.

(I also disagree with the law, but I'm more concerned that the police abused it.)

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by swores on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:47AM (#35872382)
Considering the Met have officially apologised and announced "regret" for the specific arrests that were allegedly for that reason, it's hard to care about that excuse any more.

The protestors arrested say a) they were reversible plastic straps (i.e. no use for human locking on at all), and b) they had discussed their plans with the official police liaison team who approved it all before the event, then the police on the ground refused to care about that nor tried to discuss with the liaison team while making the arrests.

There's also various clips going round, for example this police officer saying they "might" arrest people just for chanting "not my king". Which is just blatantly wrong, albeit possibly down to incompetent officers as much as bad policy (though bad policy seems likely). https://twitter.com/francesleach_/status/1654789805685854208...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by secretsatan on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:39AM (#35872783)
They could do that on a regular basis though, arrest, release, say sorry, nothing to see.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by swores on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:46AM (#35872848)
They, in fact, do do it on a regular basis. See, for example, the multiple occasions on which they've arrested accredited journalists for covering Just Stop Oil protests, only to apologise a day or two later as if it's perfectly natural their officers didn't realise journalists are allowed to cover protests without being arrested.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:15AM (#35874656)
Is there no recourse against wrongful arrest?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by masfuerte on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:01PM (#35876397)
If an officer believes an arrest is lawful he can arrest you. Trying to prove he knew it wasn't lawful but did it anyway is very difficult.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by gambiting on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:02AM (#35872480)
>>Any tie that could be used to secure the pole on a placard to something could obviously be used by protestors to lock their own body to the same thing

Nonsense, all you need to tie a sign to a pole is a piece of string that wouldn't hold a human body. If they want to keep that legislation in it should be specific - things like handcuffs, heavy chains with padlocks.....even that I think is an overreach, but it would be better than whatever the law says now.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by cesaref on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:23AM (#35872653)
Exactly - if you take too broad a view, then the protesters having arms and fingers could be considered devices for 'locking on' to something.

Personally I think this has generated renewed interest and publicity for the republican movement, which means in a way, the protest has been a success due to the police action.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Symbiote on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:32AM (#35872737)
The law says there's an offence "attach themselves to another person, to an object or to land" — which could include holding hands — but for "being equipped" it needs to be an object: "A person commits an offence if they have an object with them in a place other than a dwelling with the intention that it may be used in the course of or in connection with the commission by any person of an offence under section 1(1) (offence of locking on)."

I'll not be at all surprised if later this year the Metropolitan Police arrest protesters from linking arms while surrounding a building or blocking a road.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by silasdavis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:52AM (#35873608)
I have seen them reported as luggage straps

> which turned out to be luggage straps.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/may/09/labour-says-...

Easily cut or removed in either case.

For the record I do not think locking on should be criminalised in general in the first place, much less for it to be preemptively policed based the discretion of some copper.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by standardUser on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:50AM (#35872406)
Many people have a cavalier attitude about someone "being arrested" but it's actually the violent and comprehensive denial of all basic human rights, often done on a whim. We should be reserving such an extreme measure for people who represent a real and urgent threat of violence, and almost never otherwise. Our tolerance towards arrest as a routine procedure is, to me, baffling and unjustifiable.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by jonatron on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:29AM (#35872229)
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by jl6 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:34AM (#35872285)
"We were just holding placards" describes one part of the protest. Another was:

> groups and individuals were planning to use and throw rape alarms in order to disrupt the coronation procession.

... which is less defensible. Personally I hope a balance is found between allowing protest and preventing egregious disruption.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by swores on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:39AM (#35872316)
The people they arrested for giving out rape alarms were part of a charity who are in central london every weekend giving them out to women at night - they were arrested the night before, i.e. a very weird time for them to be out if their intention was to protest, and I've not heard anything about the police having any actual reason to believe these people intended to protest at all?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by selfhoster11 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:23AM (#35872650)
Not only that - their reflective wests bore the logo of the City of Westminster [0]

[0]: https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article29914468.ece/AL...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by willis936 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:45AM (#35872359)
Okay but why are people being arrested for the crime of "soon will be holding a sign"?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by silasdavis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:02AM (#35873707)
I think we're more or less there already:

https://youtu.be/6__jx4YSfNI

The crime of offence, to someone.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by willis936 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:03PM (#35876425)
That was during the period of Queen Elizabeth's funeral.

I am referring to people being actually arrested in the past week for the crime of having a sign.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/09/world/europe/uk-police-co...

>The police found placards and “items which at the time they had reasonable grounds to believe could be used as lock-on devices,” according to the statement, and arrested six people “on suspicion of going equipped for locking on.”

>The protesters who were arrested said that the devices were in fact luggage straps to fasten banners. After the police investigation failed to prove that anyone had intended to use the straps to lock on, all six had their bail canceled and no further action would be taken against them, the police said.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by misnome on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:08AM (#35872527)
And, if that statement was just an outright fabrication by the police?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by whostolemyhat on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:09AM (#35872539)
That's the Met's version of events; what they actually did was arrest charity workers the night before, from a charity the Met works closely with[1].

1. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/may/08/arrests-coro...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nailer on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:34AM (#35872748)
I think you (and, judging by the moderation, other people on HN) mistakenly believe I don't support the right to protest, I very much do, and have a habit of supporting (both financially and otherwise) various civil liberties organizations.

However I do like to see logical, robust arguments.

> "Our tolerance for any disruption, whether through protest or otherwise, will be low."

> "We will deal robustly with anyone intent on undermining this celebration."

(and then later)

> And yet... people were arrested for having signs along the route.

Be clear in what it is you object to. It seems like you want to attack the hypocrisy of arresting non-disruptive protests.

Quoting the police saying disruption will not be be allowed, when instead you are concerned about non-disruptive protesters being arrested, weakens and distracts from your argument.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by swores on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:48AM (#35872872)
I personally am against both the newly passed legislation, and against police arresting people for not even breaking the ridiculous new laws. I'll complain about both :)
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nailer on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:27AM (#35873996)
Sure. Here's an example of a more robust response, written from you to me, borrowing some of Silas' points:

> Personally I support disruptive action (insert rationale here).

> Furthermore, the talk of disruptive action is frequently used to mask action against non-disruptive protest. People were arrested for having signs along the route. Others they were arrested and held for 16 hours on the basis of 'being equipped for locking on' which were actually cargo ties to hold their placards during transit - of no practical use for locking on."

By responding to the current topic, before bringing up the other, it strengthens your points on both.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by cameronh90 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:10AM (#35873127)
Note that there were quite significant peaceful and good natured anti-monarchy protests over the weekend, and the vast majority of those taking part weren't arrested. So, we're obviously not talking about some widespread systematic crackdown on protest at this stage, but rather what appears to be a very bad call on the part of (some?) Met officers. At this stage it's too early to know why these individuals ended up being arrested, but it seems to me like some officers on the ground hugely overstepped the mark and I hope the arrested parties get a good settlement out of it.

However. There is clearly wider context that makes having a fair discussion about this difficult.

On the side against the police and government, there have been far too many instances in the past few years of bad calls, misconduct and, in some cases, using the position of authority to sexually abuse or murder women. There have also been reports finding evidence of systemic racism, homophobia and misogyny within the Met. These do not appear to be isolated incidents. It would appear the Met has a serious cultural problem, and the new Met police chief has admitted this is the case. There hasn't been any real discussion on whether authoritarianism is a factor, but police officers are bound to lean towards authoritarianism and would imagine that's makes them likely to abuse their power. On top of that, this recent police powers bill has been rushed through and hasn't been scrutinised as much as it probably would have been if they weren't working to the deadline of the coronation.

On the other hand, there have been a lot of disruptive protests lately causing, I think it is fair to say, a level of havoc that is not considered by most British people to be a protected form of protest. The Just Stop Oil, Animal Rebellion and Extinction Rebellion protests in particular have illegal disruption as an explicit goal. They have been blocking roads, gluing themselves to trains, throwing paint over art at galleries and have publicly stated they have plans to step up the disruption. The majority of Brits do not support this form of protest and have been demanding the police crack down on them, and I suspect there would have been a huge level of criticism against the police if they had allowed one of these groups to disrupt the coronation. Demonstrations and organised marches aren't controversial, but few people consider these new disruptive tactics to be a legal expression of protest. The other thing to consider is despite the recent issues, the UK is one of the countries where you are least likely to experience any sort of police brutality or corruption, and despite the coronation being controversial and attended by many thousands, only 52 people were arrested over the weekend, which is pretty good going for such a major event.

Personally, I'm sympathetic to these protest movements and agree with their goals, but we need to have a limit to what we consider protected protest. If they still want to take part in illegal protest and risk prosecution for political purposes, that is entirely up to them to decide whether their cause is worth that. But obviously we need to make sure the crack down on those sorts of groups doesn't spill over into limiting free expression as it has done here, and any police officer with these kind of authoritarian tendencies ought to be screened out of the police.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by callahad on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:33AM (#35872271)
The police themselves have expressed "regret" over the arrests and made personal apologies to those arrested. [0]

Now, I doubt the sincerity of that regret, but the fact that they're choosing that message at all means there's no cause for a devil's advocate here. It's a bad law, poorly implemented.

[0]: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65530967

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:47AM (#35872379)
I doubt the police would express regret for enforcing the law, however bad a particular law may be. I'm pretty sure they are expressing regret knowing they acted unlawfully even under the new law.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by InCityDreams on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:13AM (#35873163)
"We regret you feel bad about you being arrested by us".
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by knorker on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:58AM (#35872445)
The same police that had the chief say "oh they weren't supposed to, he he he" when people were arrested for quietly holding A4-sized signs a few months ago on this topic.

They're fascists. That used to be hyperbole, but now they're actually arresting people for their peaceful opinions on the government.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by 1827163 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:10AM (#35872548)
Yes, that is because the Overton window has shifted so far towards authoritarianism. If it didn't the Police would find resistance both within, from the population and from the government as well.

People should hold up a blank piece of paper, that echoes what people do in russia to protest against the war.

https://www.independent.co.uk/tv/news/russian-police-arrest-...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by sokoloff on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:29AM (#35872702)
Interesting to contrast the (sometimes) global opinion that the US First Amendment is too extremist with the current situation in the UK arising in part from the lack of such an extremist "Congress shall make no law...abridging the freedom of speech" framework.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by 1827163 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:02AM (#35873035)
That's how far the Overton window has shifted, when the 1st Amendement of the US Constitution is being branded as "extremist". What dark times we are living in....

And he whole society is shifting in the process, the public becomes more tolerant of the erosion of liberty. While the government starts to clamp down on our freedoms more than ever before. That is how we arrived at the place we are at now, with widespread mass surveillance and censorship. All supposedly accepted by the public in the name of "safety".

With the public maybe so accustomed to that feeling of supposed safety that they might actually oppose rolling back the surveillance in some cases?

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by barry-cotter on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:14AM (#35873837)
> That's how far the Overton window has shifted, when the 1st Amendement of the US Constitution is being branded as "extremist".

The US’ freedom of expression rights are so much stronger than any other state I’m aware of that calling them extreme is quite accurate. There’s nothing like the First Amendment in any other country.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by 1827163 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:19AM (#35873897)
Yes, the US is at the forefront of individual liberty, it is highly advanced in this respect. And it is likely the reason for its economic prosperity over the decades.

Many of the other countries in the world are collectivist. The recent shift in the Overton Window is a regression towards pre-Enlightenment values.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by RansomStark on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:00AM (#35872470)
I disagree, from a UK government perspective, its a excellent law, implemented perfectly.

Yeah, there was a little backlash this time. The police have issued an apology, maybe a few front line officers will be disciplined (somewhat unlikely), then it'll all be forgotten and next time it will barely make the news, and after that its just an everyday occurrence.

The opposition (Labour) party is refusing to say they will repeal the legislation if they win the next election, they haven't said they won't, that's not the politicians way, but what they did say was “We can’t come into office, picking through all the conservative legislation and repealing it” [0].

make no mistake this isn't a law our government wants, its a law our parliament wants, both sides of the house, and it is here to stay, whether we the people want it or not.

It's almost like people that want power and control become politicians to enact laws that give them power and control... Maybe we need some kind of checks and balances on the power of parliament, or maybe, the desire to be a politician should make you ineligible for the role.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/may/08/labour-urge...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by 1827163 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:19AM (#35872622)
Yes, many people who crave power and control will gravitate to positions of authority. In many cases it's a diagnosable psychiatric disorder, a personality disorder, that causes it. The behavior is compulsive, they have to be in control at all times. And there is a cluster of symptoms that come together, it's possible to spot this.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nprateem on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:05AM (#35873069)
Of course Labour won't repeal it. At the first disruptive protest the Tories will have them over a barrel.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by silasdavis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:05AM (#35873743)
They might as a concession for confidence and supply from the Liberal Democrats. Which might suit all involved since the lib dems could be blamed in such an event.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by _joel on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:15PM (#35876578)
No point shooting yourself in the foot when you're this clear in front... Ammendements will be made, I'm confident of that, when they actually have the power to do so.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by samwillis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:25AM (#35872192)
> I feel you're overlooking

Just to clarify, my comment is not passing any judgment or offering any analysis. I intend to provide context in the aftermath of this weekend, and why I assume this has been posted and voted to the top of the homepage.

Of course there is nuance, and not all "protest" activities can be justified.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by HyprMusic on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:29AM (#35872226)
26 people were arrested for signs, t-shirts and flags.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/royal/1767017/just-stop-oil-c...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by becquerel on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:32AM (#35872258)
Some would argue that protest is meant to be disruptive.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:51AM (#35872910)
As such, they are not a human right. You have the right to talk; you don't have the right to force the others to listen to you.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by account42 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:03AM (#35873050)
Speaking in a public place is not forcing others to listen to you.

If you are only allowed to talk where noone can listen you then you do not in fact have free speech.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:13AM (#35873155)
I was replying to: "protest is meant to be disruptive".

Speaking in a public place is free speech.

Interrupting a motorcade is not free speech. Pushing people around to get in from of cameras is neither.

By the way, I'm using these two possible behaviours as examples of disruptive actions that do not constitute free speech. I'm not stating that people in London were arrested due to such behaviours.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by account42 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:31AM (#35873383)
> Interrupting a motorcade is not free speech.

Depends entirely on the kind of interruption. Remember that a mortorcade is itself already a disruption of the normal use of a public space.

> Pushing people around to get in from of cameras is neither. By the way, I'm using these two possible behaviours as examples of disruptive actions that do not constitute free speech. I'm not stating that people in London were arrested due to such behaviours.

Yes, that's called a strawman. And you are using very imprecise language to boot - pushing people around can describe a number of behaviors from a gentle nudge to ouright assault.

Saying that protests should be allowed to be disruptive does also not mean that any kind of disruption needs to be accepted. Obviously if a protest prevents effectively detains you it is not ok. But having to take a slight detour or hearing people say things you want to ignore, that's something that is effectively required for a protest to have any result at all.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:56AM (#35873663)
> is effectively required for a protest to have any result at all

I'll say it again: you don't have the right to expect that your protest be successful.

Democracy (and the UK isa democracy) means that the status quo is fine for the majority of the people. If anyone had the right to change things at their whim, that would become a dictatorship.

Protesting is to inform people at large of a problem you feel important, but the solution cannot be up to you alone. And if you can't even convince people to listen to you without coercing them, why do you think your protest should be successful?

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by hiatus on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:34AM (#35873414)
> Interrupting a motorcade is not free speech.

Am I not exercising free speech if I talk over you? Why is interrupting a motorcade any different? Motorcades are arguably expressions in and of themselves.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:03AM (#35873730)
> Am I not exercising free speech if I talk over you?

In civilized places, we do not talk over another. We take turns to speak.

> Why is interrupting a motorcade any different?

It is not different indeed. They are both wrong. Especially if the motorcade is organized by the public authority in a democracy, and the protestor is a small group in search of an audience that could not be bothered to listen to their arguments.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pyth0 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:57AM (#35872986)
Given the fact that people are being arrested for holding up signs, it does not seem that they "have the right to talk".
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:19AM (#35873231)
I was replying to: "protest is meant to be disruptive".

I agree that holding up signs is not a good reason for an arrest.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by account42 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:59AM (#35873009)
It's concerning that the French seem to be the only ones that still understand this in Europe.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by whostolemyhat on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:12AM (#35872556)
The Republic protest was a planned protest, ie they were co-ordinating with the police for weeks beforehand about what they were going to do, where and when, which the Met told them was ok[1]. Then on the morning they were arrested, and have now been released and not charged.

1. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65530967

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by class4behavior on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:00AM (#35873014)
And you're overlooking the fact that laws always appear to solve some trouble or evil, even if the definition of said trouble is nonsensical or evil itself.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by tailspin2019 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:03AM (#35873053)
> Not if you carry a sign protesting the monarch along the route

This is exactly what many arrested were doing (or were intending to do)

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Randomizer42 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:00AM (#35872466)
I can't believe in the year 2023 we still have this bullshit coronation, monarchy business especially in Europe that constantly tries to tell the world they are democratic. What a load of steaming cow dung. It is a joke.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by vasco on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:05AM (#35872501)
Once you go down this rabbithole you see how most people are hostage to their school system. Most European countries with monarchies today have a majority of their population approving of the system - or so we're told in polls.

Seeing as the monarchy is completely against any other modern values of equality and equity and diversity, the only explanation is indoctrination in the school system somehow works. I cannot fathom for example how progressive countries like the Netherlands are pro-monarchy, but I live here among them and can tell you that while there's dissent, the majority of the country supports it. It's the subject that most boggles my mind in the modern world.

Sweden and Denmark being more examples of countries that say they are pro equality while keeping a family above all others.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by jltsiren on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:29AM (#35872705)
For most people, the monarchy just means a bunch of state-sponsored celebrities who participate in weird rituals. They don't bother opposing it for ideological reasons, because it's pretty inconsequential. The monarchy is a symbol, like the flag or the national anthem. It costs some money, but people don't see any particular reason to get rid of it, because there is no obvious harm in it.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by noirscape on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:30AM (#35872715)
The main reason why the Netherlands at least doesn't care so much about their monarch is because the role is completely neutered by the Dutch constitution. The King or Queen functionally has zero power over much of anything - their role is pretty much entirely ceremonial in purpose (they can theoretically choose to not sign laws, but this would just result in them getting sidestepped).

This is in very stark contrast to the UK monarchy, which does hold very considerable power and control over the government still.

Its less "people approve of the system" and more "people don't have any issues with the system". Anti-monarchism just isn't really a thing here because the monarchy is just... kinda bland? The most solid argument here is that it's a money sink, which is a fair point but not enough for most to protest it.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by mtsr on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:47AM (#35872862)
There's also a sentiment among even people in the Netherlands who might otherwise be republicans, that the current situation might actually be the lesser evil, compared to an elected head of state. Especially with populism on the rise, etc.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by vasco on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:55AM (#35872955)
It's a strange world when you can be convinced that voting is worse than "God's appointments".

Edit: to the comment below, now you're advocating for ilegitimacy as a benefit to a position that "holds no power". It's a very weird position to hold, but if you believe that, then do an opt-in lottery system among all your citizens, not something predetermined by birth with a bunch of lies and religion around it. I'd like to read your arguments about dictatorships too, they're probably great.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by tialaramex on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:23AM (#35873275)
The rationale goes like this: If you don't like the monarch, who has this job purely as an accident of birth, well, too bad, they're a person, that's all you were guaranteed. They might have a grating voice, or love hot pink way too much, or insist on calling people "Mate" for no god damn reason, but nobody picked them.

And if you do like them, the same, maybe they've got a brilliant smile, they like the long floral outfits you prefer, they think kittens are better than puppies like you do, but nobody picked them.

They don't have any democratic legitimacy, which is crucial because this means it's clear that democratically the elected legislature is in charge. The monarch can't be making rules, they're not a government they're just a living symbol.

Whereas if you vote for somebody to be President or whatever, that person now has democratic legitimacy. Their preference for kittens is granted the legitimacy of the masses, even though probably most people didn't vote for them because they believe kittens are better, too bad, that's all endorsed. If the Elected President disagrees with the Elected Legislature, somehow their meddling is legitimate, even they can argue, rightfully endorsed by The People.

Unless you're confident that everything you believe can be summarised as a single living individual, and that the majority of other people agree with you, an Elected President is clearly worse than a Monarch.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:57AM (#35873666)
Well, in the US, Supreme Court appointments are for life. That's for a reason - it's supposed to be isolated from politics so as to judge justly. It's not, but it would be even more subject to politics if judges were appointed to four-year terms (or worse, elected).
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by orhmeh09 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:25AM (#35875786)
This rising tide of populism you speak of implies people in the Netherlands would prefer the "greater evil" of an elected head of state. Why not give people what they actually want?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by kaanski on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:54AM (#35872952)
> The King or Queen functionally has zero power over much of anything - their role is pretty much entirely ceremonial in purpose (they can theoretically choose to not sign laws, but this would just result in them getting sidestepped).

This is the same in the UK I’m not sure I see the stark difference. The Monarch doesn’t really have power over parliament.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by hnhg on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:59AM (#35873012)
It is actually rather opaque in the UK. It took a lot of work to find out the following, which not be the full of extent of what goes on: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/feb/08/royals-vette...
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by kaanski on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:26AM (#35873320)
So the Queen read bills and gave her opinion on them, which is public record, before they were debated? And that constitutes political power?

It also states that this is a purely formal part of the parliamentary process and she never refused something being debated, even if she did parliament could override it.

I’d argue that if David Beckham tweeted his annoyance at a bill being passed it would have more influence. Not to mention the hundreds of lobby groups that get their way.

I think people forget that the relationship between Monarch and people in Britain has always been different to the rest of Europe. No Magna Carta or equivalent document was signed anywhere else in Europe in the 1200s. It took the famously rebellious France 150 years to abolish their monarch after the English did.

Personally I don’t mind the monarchy, if they replace it then fine, but I want it replaced with something decent. I definitely don’t want to see a US style presidential republic set up here, with executive orders, etc.

I’ve said this before in another thread but growing up as a not very well off ethnic minority the Queen seemed to care more about me than anyone in parliament. The monarch in the UK shows more civil devotion and service than any politician.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by tialaramex on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:03AM (#35873049)
> This is in very stark contrast to the UK monarchy, which does hold very considerable power and control over the government still.

It's exactly like you've described for the Netherlands. Our Monarchs have no actual power, beyond the power that comes with being famous wealthy old white people anyway. English Kings haven't had real power over the Westminster Parliament since it executed King Charles in 1649.

Charles thought as King he could do whatever he wanted, Parliament disagreed, Parliament won and since he didn't accept that outcome they executed him. That's pretty definitive. He was dead, they were not.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by eternalban on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:22AM (#35873262)
Monarchy is a system, and like all systems it has all sorts of parts, including the lonesome fellow wearing the crown. "Our king has no power" yet there is all that machinery of state and you think it is just for 'sentiment and aesthetic' reasons?

That song and dance to beguile the masses is how the ruling keep ruling. Does this really need to be spelled out?

Charles was executed because he, as king, was in conflict with his own set: the ruling class. It was a civil war. But if he was in accord with his class you can bet your pretty neck that it would be in jeopardy if you went againt that ruling class.

> Charles thought as King he could do whatever he wanted

That is right. A monarch is there so that an entire class can do whatever it wants. But s/he will not fare well if they act against the class that upholds their reign. It is the same exact precise equation the world over modulo some rare historic exceptions.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by tialaramex on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:09PM (#35876498)
> "Our king has no power" yet there is all that machinery of state and you think it is just for 'sentiment and aesthetic' reasons?

No, it's operated for and on behalf of the Government. Notionally "His" Government, but we elected it, so it's ultimately our fault.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by andruby on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:04AM (#35873057)
I'm not entirely sure about the money sink.

It's probably hard to build an honest accounting of the financial benefits of having a monarch. The diplomatic missions and relations they maintain probably have some (hard to measure) benefit. They have an entertainment value (for some). Tourism income (especially in the UK)?

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Al-Khwarizmi on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:39AM (#35872785)
There is indoctrination and manipulation going on at all levels. Can't speak about the Netherlands or Denmark, but in Spain the press never published anything remotely negative about the previous king, we typically had to find out from foreign press or minority separatist press. At one point, there was so much stench of degeneracy and corruption from that king (plus the ascent of a left-wing party with anti-monarchy tendencies in polls) that the powers that be apparently decided that it wasn't possible to keep the people content about him anymore, so they made him abdicate.

Now the press does talk somewhat about his exploits (probably disproportionally little, but it does) while the current king is reported as basically a saint and nothing remotely bad is ever said about him (to his credit he doesn't seem as much of a thief as his father, but if you read the mainstream Spanish press, you would think he pisses gold).

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by mtsr on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:50AM (#35872893)
That's at least definitely not the case in NL. There's been quite vocal criticisms about the kings choice to go on holiday during the pandemic, about subsidies for royal estates that are closed to the public, etc.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by bl0rg on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:17AM (#35872606)
History and tradition plays a major role in those opinions. No one is saying it is fair, but most are willing to overlook it.

Why do you, so confidently, state that the reason is the school system/indoctrination? I've gone to school in these countries, and I've never heard a pro-monarchy argument in class.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by antonvs on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:26AM (#35872677)
Have you heard an anti-monarchy argument in class? One way to maintain a status quo is just to avoid talking about it too much.

That was part of the original point of the New Atheism movement: that politely keeping quiet about religious beliefs encouraged believers to think that their beliefs were universally held or at least respected, among other things. Changing that, pushing back against the status quo, made a big difference.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by bl0rg on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:42AM (#35872808)
No, not that I recall. I've only heard about it being discussed in an objective manner.

Who is maintaining this "status quo" according to you? The media? The monarchs?

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by antonvs on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:54PM (#35877143)
Society as a whole maintains it. As long as not enough people object strenuously enough, it simply doesn’t get discussed and continues on the way it is - that’s pretty much the definition of status quo, “the existing state of affairs”.

> I've only heard about it being discussed in an objective manner.

I doubt that. What’s an example? Objectively, the existence of a monarchy is opposed to the ideals of an egalitarian society. Any discussion of a monarchy’s mere existence without covering such topics serves to reinforce the status quo - it normalizes its existence and lies by omission about its negative impacts.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by madeofpalk on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:37AM (#35872767)
In Australia I don't really hearing much of an anti-monarchy argument in school, but also not a pro-monarchy argument either. There was just a statement of fact about the monarchy that we live in.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by concordDance on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:52AM (#35872917)
Have you hear pro-caulk arguments in class? Caulk at least might have some relevance to those kids lives, the vestigial monarchy has none.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by andyferris on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:46AM (#35872851)
In Australia, I think fear of getting something like the US political system is why the monarchy is somewhat tolerated. (Though it wouldn’t survive a simple popular vote, the question is what is the “better” thing to replace it with, which monarchists successfully use as a wedge to divide the republican supporters)
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by born2discover on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:59AM (#35873006)
And yet Australia voted not to become a republic in 1999. Seems like it did survive a simple popular vote at that time.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by quickthrower2 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:29AM (#35873365)
Can something like a Royal Commission exist without that connection? Probably I would guess, in some other form. They seem to have real teeth.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by johnnymorgan on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:32AM (#35873387)
That lack of self awareness in this post is amazing.

Fyi your modern views are not that modern, anymore than a monarchist views are modern.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by throwaway46112 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:39AM (#35872786)
Despite republican propaganda there is nothing inherently evil about monarchies or inherently good about democracies.

Nor, judging by recent history, one is more prone to infringing civil and human rights than the other.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pyth0 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:50AM (#35872896)
I disagree. The existence of a monarchy necessitates the belief that the royal family is ordained by god to rule over their people. It requires you to buy into the idea that these regular people are somehow more worthy than anybody else. I think that by itself is inherently "evil".

Also, I don't see how this is a "republican propaganda" talking point. Online I've seen many conservative pundits celebrating the coronation.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by willbudd on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:15AM (#35873189)
Republican here refers to those who are in favor of republics (vis-a-vis monarchies). Not a certain degenerate political party in the USA.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pyth0 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:16AM (#35873205)
Ah my mistake, thanks for the correction.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by chimprich on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:06AM (#35873078)
> It requires you to buy into the idea that these regular people are somehow more worthy than anybody else.

Not necessarily. I'm fairly neutral on the (UK) monarchy: I don't particularly like the idea, but some people do and it doesn't negatively impact me at all.

I can see some (small) value in keeping a historical anachronism around, for the sake of culture and tourism. That view doesn't require any belief that a certain family is ordained by God or more worthy than anyone else.

If they had any actual political power I would feel very differently.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by krisoft on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:24AM (#35873289)
> If they had any actual political power I would feel very differently.

Well I have a bad news for you. They do.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/feb/08/royals-vette...

It is an informal and murky way to exert control but it is well documented and it is happening.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pyth0 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:16AM (#35873196)
I suppose the part that sours it for me is watching the extreme displays of wealth and decadence at a time when a large number of people in the UK are struggling financially. Quite a lot of countries in Europe still have monarchies, but the degree to which they are visibly celebrated in the UK seems to be much greater. This is where the argument for culture and tourism comes in, but I still think its wrong.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by frob on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:44AM (#35873515)
It probably negatively impacts your post-tax income. All of that showy opulence has to be paid for by someone and I'm pretty sure Chuckie Threes hasn't worked a day in his life.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by mixtur2021 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:02AM (#35873043)
No it doesn't. I am an atheist and I do not believe the King is ordained by any form of deity. I look past that and support the constitutional monarchy settlement on the grounds of tradition/culture, how it provides constitutional checks and balances, how it can be a unifying figure against the negatives of elected head of state populists etc e.g. president Blair or president Farage. I am not saying this is the setup which I would use for any new countries, but it works at least for us. It also works for many countries in Europe.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pyth0 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:09AM (#35873112)
You don't have to be religious to recognize that this is the stated reason for which the royal family was given its legitimacy. Obviously that is not the sole reason for its continued existence, but (as an outside observer) all of the rituals and ceremony surrounding the coronation seem to further entrench that idea.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by mixtur2021 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:18AM (#35873223)
Nuance there is that the legitimacy in the form of line of succession has been governed by law too (and no doubt conquest historically) at least following the glorious revolution of 1688. It has jumped around.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:53AM (#35873610)
But religion was also the stated reason given for the legitimacy of the US revolution. "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights..."

The US becoming far more atheist doesn't undermine the legitimacy of the US democracy, even if the original stated basis isn't regarded as valid any longer. The same can be true of the monarchy.

Mind you, I'm not actually a supporter of the monarchy. Where I'm from, we don't bow to monarchs. I'm just saying that this argument against the monarchy does not seem valid to me.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by George83728 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:30PM (#35877640)
The US Revolution kicked the British government out of the region that would become the United States, but did not itself create the government that the US operates under. That happened 13 years later, when the present secular US Constitution went into effect.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by dathos on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:18AM (#35872613)
Not unlike a “two” party system
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:21AM (#35872635)
Well, idiot Brexiteers complained about EU not being democratic!
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by concordDance on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:55AM (#35872957)
I see more and more of this style of heated "fuck the outgroup!" posts on hackernews now. I don't know why this has started happening, but it's pretty sad watching HN decline...
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by blibble on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:11AM (#35872552)
could be worse

could be a US style presidential system

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by mardifoufs on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:07AM (#35874521)
Actually the US presidential system is still better than what the UK has.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by blibble on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:17PM (#35878332)
the new US took the powers of the King and made the new office considerably more powerful

not an improvement

> Actually the US presidential system is still better than what the UK has.

2022 Democracy Index has the UK (and almost all other Western constitutional monarchies) rated as full democracies

the US is not

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by jamiegreen on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:45AM (#35872836)
God Save the King
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by concordDance on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:50AM (#35872884)
This seems like a consensus building post tone-wise. Would be nice to cut back on this sort of thing in favour of posts emphasizing facts, reasoned arguments and other light (as opposed to heat) generating things.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by frob on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:41AM (#35873484)
Fact: it's undemocratic and downright naive to choose your leader based on who came out of the previous leader in what order.

Fact: it's undemocratic to arrest people without charges, especially when it is just for expressing displeasure at the current government.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by concordDance on Wednesday May 10, 2023 @03:17AM (#35884637)
A bit bare bones but certainly a step in the right direction.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by zo1 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:03AM (#35872489)
""> Our tolerance for any disruption, whether through protest or otherwise, will be low. > We will deal robustly with anyone intent on undermining this celebration."

If only they had this much zest and conviction for actual, troubling issues, dangerous issues. While I agree that disrupting a ceremony now is in poor taste, there are much bigger issues at play in the UK that deserve hands-on policing.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nprateem on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:02AM (#35873042)
> disrupting a ceremony now is in poor taste

Sorry, what? And it's in good taste to piss away hundreds of millions of taxpayers money on a coronation? Please explain why people having a problem with this shouldn't exercise their right to protest.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by mistrial9 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:32AM (#35874056)
as an American, and not emotionally involved in this topic.. the answer must include actions by degree.. that is, protest by civilized actions, cards and flyers, costumed theater, symbolic union of people via presence or art.. not riot, break windows, steal, attack police or others.. etc
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by WickyNilliams on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:01AM (#35874432)
They arrested people for the former. The latter are illegal in any case
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nprateem on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:09AM (#35874559)
Well really they preemptively arrested people, before they'd protested at all. I'm glad this abuse of power hasn't gone unnoticed.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:31PM (#35876839)
> And it's in good taste to piss away hundreds of millions of taxpayers money on a coronation?

The British royal family is accretive to the U.K. The coronation brought in billions of dollars of tourism and earned media. There are legitimate gripes one may have about the British royals, but costing the taxpayer isn't one of them, unless we're at the point of seizing their private lands.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nprateem on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:39PM (#35876947)
Yeah yeah this old excuse. It's conveniently unquantifiable, uncomparable to the alternative, and obfuscated by not knowing how much they're really worth and therefore what's reasonable to pay them. In addition there are plenty of non- working royals on the gravy train happily benefitting from their accident of birth without lifting a finger.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by wootland on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:16AM (#35873868)
> While I agree that disrupting a ceremony now is in poor taste

Most people would consider coronating Jimmy Saville's BFF king to be in extremely poor taste. The protesters are the only respectable thing about this farce.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by account-5 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:30AM (#35872713)
Not the MET, the UK government. The MET are just enforcing the law the UK gov enacted, regardless of whether you like the MET or not they didn't suddenly decide to attack the right to protest.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by bearmode on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:40AM (#35872796)
The Met can choose not to enforce fascist laws if they want to.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by switch007 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:44AM (#35872830)
Yes and no. What they decide to enforce is largely political. They won’t get away with ignoring things the Home Secretary wants enforced for very long before some chief is called in to a meeting in which they perspire heavily.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by born2discover on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:54AM (#35872951)
Police does not hold any discretionary powers on whether to enforce a law. In a functional State, Police is a subordinate of the executive branch, not it's willing accomplice. It can't enforce laws it deems "ok" and turn a blind eye on those it deems "meh".
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by malnourish on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:02AM (#35873044)
Police absolutely have discretionary powers; it would be logically incompatible for them to not have such powers.

They have a chain of command, and at each level decide where to focus their efforts (guided by existing laws, to be sure). Patrol routes are chosen, dispatchers must (effectively) triage calls, and officers make decisions like whether to assess a warning or a citation.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by aceofspades19 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:33AM (#35873405)
But that is not true, most countries have what is called prosecutorial discretion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prosecutorial_discretion The police can, for the most part, decide whether or not to enforce laws. They can also choose not to investigate certain crimes as they simply don't have the time to look into absolutely everything. Furthermore, if police had to literally enforced every law on the books to the letter, they would not be able to drive or walk down the street without having to arrest people constantly.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by jon-wood on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:19AM (#35873898)
I sometimes wonder if this would be a net benefit in the long term. My hunch is that after a week or two of people being constantly arrested, and the accompanying collapse of society, there’d be a push to repeal laws that aren’t relevant anymore and revise those that were overly broad.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by aceofspades19 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:49AM (#35875155)
Yeah I agree, its kind of silly that we allow ancient irrelevant and overly broad laws to stay on the books, especially in most societies that ignorance of the law is not an excuse. For example, in Canada, the police can issue a DUI if you have a BAC exceeding the limit for driving up to 2 hours after you have parked your car. If they literally went to every bar and drinking establishment (or door to door) and enforced that to the letter, it would be changed in quite a hurry.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by dotancohen on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:38PM (#35878615)
> Furthermore, if police had to literally enforced every law on the books to the letter, they would not be able to drive or walk down the street without having to arrest people constantly.

It sounds to me that addressing that problem at the enforcement level, as opposed to the legislative level, is the wrong place to address it.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by aceofspades19 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:02PM (#35881953)
Yes of course but I was not describing how things should be, I was describing how they currently are.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by harimau777 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:26AM (#35873327)
If that were literally true, then the police would arrest everyone who goes even a mile over the speed limit. Everyone who throws out junk mail addressed to a previous renter.[1] Etc.

So there is definitely at least some sense in which the police have discretion. The question is when and how much.

[1] I don't actually know if that's illegal in the UK; in the US it's a federal offense.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Guthur on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:23AM (#35873285)
They are not meant to enforce anything, they bring before the courts. Enforcement is a police state.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by bearmode on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:57AM (#35872989)
And yet, this happens literally every day. Many individual officers, if not entire forces, have effectively stopped enforcing marijuana posession laws. If that happens, why not refuse to enforce fascist anti-protest laws?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by _joel on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:13PM (#35876540)
Incorrect. They absolutely do and I've seen it with my own eyes.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by account-5 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:39PM (#35876949)
Downvoted for pretty much the truth.

I think it's a little silly people pointing to the extremely limited "discretion" police have and saying they should have used it to ignore the law. That's not how police discretion works and in modern policing it hardly exists alongside it's counterpoint which is : neglect of duty.

Policing is not a job I'd want to do. Damned if you do, damned if you don't; and everyone knows how to do it better than the people actually doing it. But those people given the chance wouldn't do any better.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:09AM (#35873109)
These laws in general may qualify but specifically is it really fascist not to tolerate protest of the coronation in a monarchy? It isn't fascist just to have rules.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Retric on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:20AM (#35873243)
Yes, objecting to protests like this is fascist.

Read up on how fascist regimes centralize power, arresting people who object was and is a major aspect of it. By outlawing decent you eventually normalize support for your regime such that even people who despise what’s going on are eventually unwilling to say so.

They may have gotten external damnation for it, but China’s cracking down on protests worked: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1989_Tiananmen_Square_protests... What seems counterintuitive is the CCP still makes it very clear you’re not allowed to talk about it because they want people to live in fear. Thus, they very much want people to know and not talk about it.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by vixen99 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:43AM (#35873507)
How about what comes about as a result of this- https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1766760/just-stop-oil-prot...
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:51AM (#35873597)
Something interesting here is whether your right to protest extends to being paid to protest. If it can be shown an NGO is paying you to engage in a disruptive protest, are you really exercising some kind of human right? IDK, that seems new. It doesn't strike me as being in the spirit of the protected right.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by tuukkah on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:11AM (#35874596)
Free choice of employment is article 23.1 in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights:

> Everyone has the right to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favourable conditions of work and to protection against unemployment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_work

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:28PM (#35881168)
Not really relevant. A plumber may have the human right to work (granting such a thing makes any sense for arguments sake), but if someone pays him to cut off the water supply to a neighbourhood, he can hardly defend himself by invoking that right. Someone who is paid to agitate---I dont know if they can then invoke the human right to protest. Is that really in the spirit of law?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:46AM (#35873527)
Do you actually think preventing disruptions to the coronation is an indication the British government is becoming Fascist? Fascism has other attributes. Is there a dictatorial power emerging in Britain? Is there an increase in militarism? Is there even a right wing government (no)? Is the government expressing ideas of a natural social hierarchy (no...some of the opposition may be). Whatever is going on, fascism is not the right word.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by spinningslate on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:16AM (#35873860)
Definition of fascism from Merriam-Webster[0]:

> 1. a political philosophy, movement, or regime (such as that of the Fascisti) that exalts nation and often race above the individual and that stands for a centralized autocratic government headed by a dictatorial leader, severe economic and social regimentation, and forcible suppression of opposition

> 2. a tendency toward or actual exercise of strong autocratic or dictatorial control

The current Uk government has introduced laws to limit protest as described in this topic; it's also looking to limit the right to strike (ref. current health service pay disputes). Both are consistent with the definition above.

[0] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fascism

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:35AM (#35874104)
Where is the dictator or "autocrat"? It doesn't meet either definition at all. I am not here to defend these laws in general, but I don't think ensuring no disruptions to the coronation has much to do with them (they used them against maybe 6 people and didnt even charge all of them?). And I don't think it is indicative of anything like fascism. It might be indicative of something else bad that is happening in the UK political body.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by trasz4 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:49AM (#35874267)
How is an unelected king not a dictator?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by kelseyfrog on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:15AM (#35874652)
Help me understand what exactly he's dictating.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by rayiner on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:10AM (#35874563)
Because he has no power to dictate anything?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by trasz4 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:52AM (#35875228)
UK is not a constitutional monarchy. The king could have me executed. The only reason they don't is the lack of need vs the expected public backlash.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by defen on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:33PM (#35876860)
That's just the nature of power and not unique to the UK. Joe Biden could declare you an enemy combatant and drone strike you.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by trasz4 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:26PM (#35877583)
Sure, but he's an elected official, not a random hereditary dude.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:24PM (#35881135)
Joe Biden could do this and get away with it. Arguably Obama did, as stated above---there might be better examples. If Charles tried, no one would probably listen, and even if he did, once word got out it would probably actually be the end of the monarchy. Charles is not a dictator, autocrat or anything else. And in fact the US president, though elected, is much further along the spectrum towards autocrat than the British monarch. Many actual autocrats are in fact elected, so this distinction isn't really important anyway.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by brightlancer on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:35PM (#35877714)
Obama _did_.

¨Anwar Nasser Abdulla al-Awlaki ... was an American imam who was killed in 2011 in Yemen by a US government drone strike ordered by President Barack Obama. Al-Awlaki became the first US citizen to be targeted and killed by a drone strike from the U.S. government.¨

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anwar_al-Awlaki

He was a terrorist but he still had rights. And then there was the murder of his non-combatant son who was "collateral damage" from a drone strike on a restaurant:

¨Abdulrahman Anwar al-Awlaki ... was a 16-year-old United States citizen who was killed while eating dinner at an outdoor restaurant in Yemen by a drone airstrike ordered by U.S. President Barack Obama on October 14, 2011.

...

¨Another U.S. administration official speaking on condition of anonymity described Abdulrahman al-Awlaki as a bystander who was "in the wrong place at the wrong time," stating that "the U.S. government did not know that Mr. Awlaki's son was there" before the airstrike was ordered.[8] When pressed by a reporter to defend the targeted killing policy that resulted in Abdulrahman al-Awlaki's death, former White House press secretary Robert Gibbs deflected blame to the victim's father: "I would suggest that you should have a far more responsible father if they are truly concerned about the well-being of their children. I don't think becoming an al-Qaeda jihadist terrorist is the best way to go about doing your business."¨

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Abdulrahman_al-Aw...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by dctoedt on Thursday May 11, 2023 @10:04AM (#35902264)
> The king [Charles III] could have me executed.

Really? If Charles suddenly issued an order, "seize @trasz4, take him/her to the Tower of London, and chop off his head," do you seriously think anyone in the UK would obey him? More likely Parliament would start the process of declaring him to be Mad King Charles and appointing William as Prince Regent in his place.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by edgyquant on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:34AM (#35874080)
Your definition is exactly what that poster stated it was. No it isn’t in line with that definition.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:24AM (#35873951)
They didn't prevent "disruptions" they prevented peaceful protests (non-disruptive).

I've seen messages online heralding how great it is that everyone loves the king, their evidence being the BBC had no news of any dissent, and there was no evidence of dissent on the ground.

The reality is police arrested people for planning peaceful protests, and the BBC provided their usual biased reporting.

This is not good.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by George83728 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:24PM (#35877548)
The British royal family have been a nest of actual fascists for a century now. If it were up to them at the time, and there weren't other geopolitical realities to contend with, they'd have allied with Nazi Germany.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Retric on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:31PM (#35881196)
Banning the types of peaceful protests allowed based on the content of their message is deeply fascist.

The British government is seriously leaning into censorship, surveillance, and nationalism which is a very dangerous combination. They have even vilified an out group namely immigrants and cracked down on decent. Add in propaganda with strong ties between the government and large private companies really does make me nervous, though I am not expecting things to devolve very quickly the historic left/right divide isn’t particularly important here.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by 1827163 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:45AM (#35874208)
Possibly the early stages of fascism? Something to do with neoliberalism? To me it's more of a shift to authoritarianism or totalitarianism.

Totalitarianism equates dissent with violence [1]. And here in the UK we have the "Prevent programme" where people who dissent against the prevailing political opinions can be labelled "extremists" even though they have not done anything illegal [2]. Which is very, very concerning. The laws relating to this were passed in 2015.

I fear that those who complain about the restrictions on freedom of speech and erosion of civil liberties in general, here in the UK, could be considered "extremists" by this government and subjected to Prevent related surveillance by intelligence agencies such as GCHQ.

1. https://fee.org/articles/14-signs-of-totalitarianism/

2. https://www.rightsandsecurity.org/assets/downloads/Prevent-i...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by rayiner on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:08AM (#35874539)
Centralizing power and arresting people who cause a disruption isn’t especially characteristic of fascism. China is a communist country, not fascist. You’re deeply confused.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Retric on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:44AM (#35875082)
Fascism is a reference to a specific political ideology. Fascist can refer to either that specific system or the ways in which that system operated.

https://www.dictionary.com/browse/fascist

“a person who is dictatorial or has extreme right-wing views.” Not the OR is intended as either applies rather than an AND where someone must also have extreme right wing view.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by rayiner on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:10AM (#35875513)
Sorry, “dictionary.com” is not persuasive. By your logic, for example, ISIS are fascists rather than theocrats, or run of the mill monarchies like in Thailand are fascist. It’s just ignorant and reveals someone who isn’t properly educated.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Retric on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:22AM (#35875742)
This is in reference to specific kinds of activities not the overall political system. People will call unusually restrictive librarians fascist. It’s just how languages evolve over time.

Fascism: “2: a tendency toward or actual exercise of strong autocratic or dictatorial control” https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fascism

It also mentions the the first definition which you’re thinking of is usually capitalized.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by rayiner on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:03PM (#35876431)
> People will call unusually restrictive librarians fascist. It’s just how languages evolve over time.

Language evolution is a process. And part of that process is literate people arguing against the uneducated evolving the language in non-sensical directions.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Retric on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:26PM (#35878462)
This definition has been in dictionaries for 50+ years, so the evolution happened a long time ago.

Arguing at this point is just ignorance.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by brightlancer on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:52PM (#35877980)
I agree that fascism is much more specific than how most folks use it, but as a tangent I would argue that China is no longer Communist (with Chinese characteristics) and instead transitioned to Fascism after the death of Mao.

China is not just nationalist but often racist, two characteristics of Fascism but not Communism (which is internationalist and egalitarian). China pushes a market economy under strict government control, creating three legs of Workers, Business Leaders and Government, a facet of Fascism; this is contrasted with the single leg of Communism where everyone is a Worker.

Regardless of whether they're Communist™ or Fascist™, the Chinese government is brutal to its people and often threatens (former) citizens abroad with harm to family members in the PRC. The label is less important than recognizing what they're doing.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:49AM (#35875151)
It's very strange to me how one day 15 or 20 years ago, everything bad in the world was suddenly fascist. Before that time, there was at least this pervasive assumption that something could be bad or undesirable while not wearing jackboots.

And then a switch flipped.

In every government which abuses its people, arresting dissidents was the first resort of the dictators and autocrats.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Retric on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:55AM (#35875271)
It’s much older than that, and an outgrowth of both propaganda and the degree to which those governments really did pioneer various methods of social control. This may have simply been timing. The widespread adoption of radio and movies suddenly made it a lot easier to influence society.

Beyond that they really just took things much further, it’s hard to find direct parallels to the scale and influence on society of say the Hitler Youth in the 1800’s or before.

History is full of dictators and political purges, but before this they focused on those with actual power.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by dotnet00 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:58AM (#35875327)
That's a characteristic of authoritarianism in general and not specifically fascism.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Retric on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:03AM (#35875402)
Earlier forms of authoritarianism like absolute monarchy didn’t necessarily include those elements.

Fascist political movements/governments however pioneered them. Thus they techniques are labeled fascist even if they where quickly adopted by communist countries etc.

PS: Fascism: “2: a tendency toward or actual exercise of strong autocratic or dictatorial control” https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fascism

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by dotnet00 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:18PM (#35876627)
I'm not seeing how fascism can be said to have pioneered them, concepts of lese majeste - which, for a monarchy is essentially equivalent to the crime of dissenting against the government - have existed for centuries all over the world.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Retric on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @02:16PM (#35878324)
Scale makes a huge difference here. Early governments used more compromises like: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decimation_(punishment) rather than just killing thousands of people.

As to timing, it’s the same technological developments which resulted in large companies becoming common and being linked to government for the first time with new options for governmental control.

Radio, telegraph, calculators/computers, and trains allowed for much larger a more homogeneous organizations. The Hitler Youth for example didn’t have similar parallels in the 1800’s and before.

At the same time individuals became less useful to the state. Large prison populations are really expensive in terms of guards and lost productivity. Similarly execution means removing potentially productive people. Historically, only a small number of people within a society would get made examples of until industrialization increased productivity to the point where states could suddenly afford to have secret police capturing large percentages of the population.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by dotnet00 on Thursday May 11, 2023 @03:56PM (#35907596)
After taking some time to think about it, I see what you mean now. It makes sense.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by George83728 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:32PM (#35877672)
> Earlier forms of authoritarianism like absolute monarchy didn’t necessarily include those elements.

Mostly because the technology and bureaucratic mechanisms were not yet sufficiently developed to implement it. It's not as though kings wielding absolute power, ostensibly justified by their god, were champions of liberalism. Maybe a handful liked to think of themselves as liberal humanists, but that was just vanity. More often, these kings had every inclination to be an overt absolute tyrant but simply lacked the technical and organizational means to control large populations in the ways which were developed in the 19th and 20th centuries.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Retric on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:09PM (#35881018)
I absolutely agree. Calling such things Modern Authoritarian Practices is more descriptive but it’s simply not what caught on making the meaning less clear.

Calling internet censorship etc fascist is a natural evolution of things, but IMO somewhat dilutes the idea. Creating an out group and book burning are part of the playbook, but public spaces have always had some regulations.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:19AM (#35873236)
Is this written in Jest?

A real monarchy with absolute power is a facist state by today's standards.

Like you literally didn't have any rights and could be killed on the whim of a noble. Even Magna Carta didn't grabt any rights to peasants and riffraff. The times before it were even more tyranical

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by MagicMoonlight on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:38AM (#35873460)
Fascism is the name of an actual political ideology, it doesn’t just mean “things I don’t like”
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by hnbad on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:48AM (#35873549)
OP clearly meant "fascist" as a shorthand for "extremely authoritarian and non-democratic", which is a common colloquial usage.

But yes, fascism typically includes an appeal to a (imagined) past glory, a close collaboration between corporations and the state, a designated enemy who is both weak enough to be an easy target and strong enough to pose an existential threat and an empowerment of the military and police force. This list doesn't cover most monarchies by any stretch of the imagination even though there are obvious overlaps.

EDIT: I also think it's simplistic to call fascism an ideology as even the historical examples share as many differences as similarities when analyzed as ideologies. I think it's more accurate to call it a strategy or mechanism, or maybe a meta-ideology. There is no "fascist economic model" for example. It's goal is to bring about a social hierarchy through the use of excessive force and typically waves of ever-expanding mass killings of undesirables. It needs an other to eliminate to maintain itself, making it inherently self-destructive.

I think the most accurate description I've seen of fascism is as an "immune system of capitalism" or "capitalism in crisis": it primarily kills the weak, those unable to work, those unwilling to work and those posing a direct or indirect threat to the social order required to maintain the owner-worker hierarchy (e.g. trade unions, socialists, even progressives) and when it eventually collapses, is overthrown or fades away, it reinstates a liberal market economy (i.e. capitalism) while having mostly maintained the power of those that were previously wealthy or were even able to expand their wealth through collaboration.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:21AM (#35873916)
People use "literally" to mean "figuratively", as well. It doesn't help discussion to allow the blurring of distinctions.

In the context of this thread, there seems to be the implication that the new laws the UN is objecting to have something to do with the arrests of protestors. After some digging, I can't find evidence that more than a few people (6) were arrested under that law (which generally seems rather bad)? And these people weren't even all charged? It seems to centre around the claimed possession of devices to lock themselves to things in public. Arresting a handful of people you think are maybe going to chain themselves to infrastructure to disrupt an internationally important event---maybe the government didnt act the best here but this hardly seems indicative of a great threat to human rights or a rise of fascism in the UK. I would personally worry more about airport security.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by peyton on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:18AM (#35874697)
> There is no "fascist economic model" for example.

It was literally conceived as an economic system between socialism and capitalism. I think your interpretation is simply incorrect.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by lo_zamoyski on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:18AM (#35873880)
Is your post written in jest? Nobles could not "literally" kill peasants on a whim. This is a preposterous claim. The nobility had a duty to protect the peasants on their land and they were bound by various general and specific moral duties toward them. Whatever the faults of the people and arrangements of that era, what you've written is a caricature, like something pulled out of the stockpile of slanderous nonsense that appeared in Enlightenment pamphlets and other rags.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by neaden on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:44AM (#35876121)
While they are exaggerating robber knights were a total thing where two nobles feuding would rob/kill each others peasants as part of it. Different times and places might have rules against it, the Holy Roman Empire very famously outlawed it but actual enforcement on the ground was minimal because there is nobody around to actually enforce those decrees. This isn't going into actual wartime conflicts at all in which case mass murder of non combatants was absolutely a common thing that was essentially sanctioned.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by _joel on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:12PM (#35876518)
Unless it's a Scotsman carrying a crossbow in York....

https://www.stupidlaws.com/it-is-lawful-to-kill-a-scotsman-i...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by shawabawa3 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:22AM (#35873267)
One of the main characteristics of fascism is forcible supression of opposition so I think a government that doesn't tolerate peaceful protest is in some sense fascist
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:36AM (#35873425)
Doing one thing that fascist government's sometimes do does not make you a fascist government. The UK might be tending toward fascism, but not allowing disruptive protests of the coronation is not really an indicator one way or the other. The king is certainly not a dictator, having little power at all.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:35AM (#35874086)
So like: sure the attacker stabbed someone, beat them with a baseball bat, punched and kicked them, but the attacker didn't use a gun so it wasn't violent.

The king has no power, that's why he's able to easily bend the national broadcaster and the police force to his will with ease ... that's why we have to get his consent to pass any laws ... that's why the armed services pledge allegiance to him (as monarch) and not to the UK ... that's why we pay him 100s of £millions from taxes ... that's why we organise a hugely costly parade for him in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis ... these are all signs he has no power /s

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by rayiner on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:18AM (#35874692)
This is basic vocabulary. “Violence” is a word that encompasses a range of actions. “Fascism” is a word that refers to a specific political ideology combining various elements.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by trasz4 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:51AM (#35874289)
In UK the king has absolute power, its just that they don't exercise it because in a civilised country they would need to be guillotined afterwards.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by ChuckNorris89 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:08AM (#35875471)
Then it means he doesn't have that power. What kind of power is that which you can't exercise? If you can't exercise it, it means you don't have it.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by trasz4 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:06PM (#35876463)
He can, he just doesn't want to. And if he did we'd probably have no insight into what even happened. The society doesn't even know kings' finances.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:28PM (#35876789)
> He can, he just doesn't want to. And if he did we'd probably have no insight into what even happened

Of course we do, the order would be ignored. (To whom would he even give the order?) English history is written in constitutional crises.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by trasz4 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @01:27PM (#35877600)
[citation needed]
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @03:14PM (#35879075)
> [citation needed]

Well, the death penalty was abolished in the U.K. in the 1990s, so you'd have that to start. Prior to that, you'v got habeus corpus, which goes back to somewhere between the Magna Carta and Interregnum.

Even at its height, the British crown's power to unilaterally command executions had been intentionally curtailed for centuries.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by onetimeusename on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:52PM (#35877121)
by this reasoning, I also have absolute power. I just choose not to exercise it because I would be ignored/arrested/guillotined afterwards.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by edgyquant on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:35AM (#35874101)
That’s a characteristic of literally every authoritarian regime.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by rayiner on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:10AM (#35874569)
That’s like saying that having four limbs is a major characteristic of mammals so anything with four limbs is kind of a mammal. Many governments of different forms don’t generate protest. For example, in both theory and in practice, suppression of protest is entirely compatible with democracy. In a democratic country with high social cohesion, like Singapore, protest is often a disgruntled minority trying to undermine the democratic will.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by stracer on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:54PM (#35877145)
"Democracy" is more general term than "liberal democracy", the latter includes protecting political freedoms. Suppressing protests because majority wants to is democratic, but it is not liberal democratic.

Liberal democracy is a check on the possible dangerous consequences of full naive democracy.

Hitler's regime came to power democratically.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by rayiner on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:59PM (#35877213)
Only if you think protesting is a “political freedom” and I think that’s debatable even in the context of liberal democracy. A minoritarian veto is anti-democratic, no matter what prefix you put on that term.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pseudalopex on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @03:35PM (#35879332)
Protest is not a veto. Even if your definition of democracy is unchecked majority rule.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by stracer on Friday May 12, 2023 @01:19PM (#35919104)
What would "political freedom" be if it did not include the right of political expression?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:28AM (#35873343)
Does the UK have rules against protesting the coronation of the monarchy? Are they following them? Or are they bending/breaking the rules to shut down the protests, to avoid making the new monarch look bad?

Breaking the rules to prohibit protest in one specific case may not be fascist, but it isn't the rule of law...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:37AM (#35873441)
There are probably very old rules about disrupting the coronation, yes. I expect it has been illegal for hundreds of years.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:41AM (#35873483)
There is also not a really deep right to protest in British law. The right to protest comes from their signing the European convention on human rights (they have some law called Human Rights Act). It is not enshrined fundamentally as in the United States afaik.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by neaden on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:50AM (#35876226)
At the coronation of William the Conqueror the soldiers were really nervous, no one was sure how people would react to William's coronation for a variety of reasons. There was a large crowd outside the church. At a certain point in the ceremony was the acclamation where the people are asked if they accept the king. This was asked in French, then English. Somehow the Norman soldiers got confused at this point and thought this was a start of a riot and began to attack the crowd and set some houses on fire. Some of the more enterprising Norman soldiers took the opportunity to loot nearby houses. The ceremony fairly abruptly ended at that point with no one inside being sure what was going on.

So I guess the MET can point to that as an example of historical precedent and how they handled themselves with relative restraint.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by runsWphotons on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:46PM (#35882644)
haha. They should just respond to the ensuing criticism and law suits in french.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by bearmode on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:36AM (#35873426)
They literally introduced new laws to curb protests a few weeks ago. That law is what they used to arrest peaceful protestors.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by RobotToaster on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:20AM (#35873901)
If you want to split hairs it's feudal not fascist, although that's just as bad, if not worse.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by rayiner on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:07AM (#35874526)
It’s not splitting hairs, it’s completely different.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by b800h on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:15AM (#35875591)
That's absurd. We should have more feudalism, not less. It would act as a restraint on hypercapitalism.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by onetimeusename on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:49PM (#35877093)
No, it's not fascist. What the anti-monarchists failed to mention is that the protestors were not arrested because they were protesting, they were arrested under suspicion of attempting to lock-on[1] but were later released without charges because of a lack of evidence. There is a debate to be had about what a peaceful protest is but frequently people use the right to disrupt other people's lives such as blocking roads. I don't think there should be a human right that can deny other people the right to use public roads and paths. That would deny others the right to protest peacefully also.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lock-on_(protest_tactic)

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by toyg on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:53AM (#35872933)
"Just executing orders" has not been valid justification since 1946, I believe.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:12AM (#35873142)
Easy to say.

I am still waiting for US public to rise up againsy unconstitutional survailance.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by barry-cotter on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:23AM (#35873282)
True if you just lost a war. Otherwise it seems to go very far though the phrase is verboten.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:09AM (#35874557)
See recent treatment of whistleblowers in any Western, democratic country.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by sgjohnson on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:23PM (#35876689)
Just look up Julian Assange for the worst case scenario.

His fate is almost certainly worse than death.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:30PM (#35882554)
The role of the Australian Government in doing absolutely nothing to help an Australian whose human rights are being trampled is telling about the structure and priorities of Western power...

... and how "Eastern" it's starting to look.

Freedom, along with a whole lot other words, doesn't mean what it used to mean.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by eptcyka on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:53AM (#35872941)
The police chose to not enforce a variety of laws in Hyde park on the 20th of April.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by londons_explore on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:54AM (#35873622)
Marijuana smoking day.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by citizenkeen on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:01AM (#35873702)
This isn't Reddit
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:18AM (#35873879)
>The day [20 April] usually draws in huge crowds of Marijuana aficionados with attendees in the realm of 11,000 people.

>Cannabis is a Class B drug in the UK, meaning there is the possibility a five-year prison sentence if you are caught in possession of the drug. >In what countries is weed legal?

>While medicinal cannabis was made legal in the UK in 2018, it is still illegal to use it recreationally.

>If you are caught growing Marijuana, you can face up to 14 years in prison, an unlimited fine or both.

https://metro.co.uk/2023/04/20/what-is-420-the-meaning-behin...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by justinclift on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:20AM (#35873246)
It's not like they don't have discretion to choose whether or not to arrest people. :/
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nrawe on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:43AM (#35874190)
Not quite. Technically, the MET is operationally independent from the government. They asked for additional powers to curb groups that were taking disruptive means (like gluing themselves to roads), and the government gave that to them through the change in the law.

Now, whether there are backchannels on this for the coronation is a different matter...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by psychphysic on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:04AM (#35875417)
They also have broad latitude and seem to have erred far, far on the side of preventing a peaceful protest to protect a one off event.

While failing in their objection to allow a peaceful protest for a one off event...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by 908B64B197 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:10AM (#35875514)
> Technically, the MET is operationally independent from the government

This reminds me of the meltdowns around the state media labels on Twitter for government-backed state medias.

Ultimately, these are entities created and funded by the government...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by mschuster91 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @11:19AM (#35875685)
> The MET are just enforcing the law the UK gov enacted

The police as an institution always also has their own influence on politics. And if there is one thing police across the world wants, it's to get rid of protests.