News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nailer on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:21AM (#35872161)
The right to protest is important, but there's a different between disruption and protest that I feel you're overlooking.

> Our tolerance for any disruption, whether through protest or otherwise, will be low.

> We will deal robustly with anyone intent on undermining this celebration.

This sounds like you'll be arrested if you leap in front of the motorcade, scream something in church, etc. Not if you carry a sign protesting the monarch. along the route

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by swores on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:24AM (#35872175)
And yet... people were arrested for having signs along the route. The police don't deserve any benefit of the doubt that you're trying to give them.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by silasdavis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:32AM (#35872261)
Indeed they were arrested and held for 16 hours on the basis of 'being equipped for locking on'. An newly created offence barely a week old.

They had cargo ties to hold their placards during transit. Of no practical use for locking on.

The metropolitan police has since says it 'regrets they were unable to join other protestors'.

Between this and the online safety bill there are some dreadful dacronian laws making it onto the statue books in the UK in recent months. Compounding other forms of monitoring and criminalising speech under hate and anti terror laws.

It definitely could happen here.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by makomk on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:42AM (#35872342)
Not quite. According to the protestors, they had ties that were supposedly going to be used to secure the placards to things as part of the protest (presumably to railings). Any tie that could be used to secure the pole on a placard to something could obviously be used by protestors to lock their own body to the same thing, and the Met are a bit twitchy about this due to having repeated problems with it over the last few years and especially months. (That's also why there's now a law allowing them to stop protestors before they lock themselves to things in the first place.)
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Symbiote on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:02AM (#35872479)
Cable ties, luggage straps or string should be of no concern. They're very easily cut by the police, even if the person is uncooperative.

"Lock on" protesters have used things like bicycle locks and handcuffs to shackle themselves to railings or each other. These are difficult to cut without injuring the person, especially if they're not cooperating.

Here's the Public Order Act, rushed through and taking effect from 3 May, with the coronation on 6 May: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2023/15/enacted

I'd argue cable ties, straps and string aren't capable of causing "serious disruption", and I assume the police/prosecutor agree. It's very concerning that the police made the arrests anyway.

(I also disagree with the law, but I'm more concerned that the police abused it.)

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by swores on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:47AM (#35872382)
Considering the Met have officially apologised and announced "regret" for the specific arrests that were allegedly for that reason, it's hard to care about that excuse any more.

The protestors arrested say a) they were reversible plastic straps (i.e. no use for human locking on at all), and b) they had discussed their plans with the official police liaison team who approved it all before the event, then the police on the ground refused to care about that nor tried to discuss with the liaison team while making the arrests.

There's also various clips going round, for example this police officer saying they "might" arrest people just for chanting "not my king". Which is just blatantly wrong, albeit possibly down to incompetent officers as much as bad policy (though bad policy seems likely). https://twitter.com/francesleach_/status/1654789805685854208...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by secretsatan on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:39AM (#35872783)
They could do that on a regular basis though, arrest, release, say sorry, nothing to see.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by swores on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:46AM (#35872848)
They, in fact, do do it on a regular basis. See, for example, the multiple occasions on which they've arrested accredited journalists for covering Just Stop Oil protests, only to apologise a day or two later as if it's perfectly natural their officers didn't realise journalists are allowed to cover protests without being arrested.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @10:15AM (#35874656)
Is there no recourse against wrongful arrest?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by masfuerte on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:01PM (#35876397)
If an officer believes an arrest is lawful he can arrest you. Trying to prove he knew it wasn't lawful but did it anyway is very difficult.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by gambiting on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:02AM (#35872480)
>>Any tie that could be used to secure the pole on a placard to something could obviously be used by protestors to lock their own body to the same thing

Nonsense, all you need to tie a sign to a pole is a piece of string that wouldn't hold a human body. If they want to keep that legislation in it should be specific - things like handcuffs, heavy chains with padlocks.....even that I think is an overreach, but it would be better than whatever the law says now.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by cesaref on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:23AM (#35872653)
Exactly - if you take too broad a view, then the protesters having arms and fingers could be considered devices for 'locking on' to something.

Personally I think this has generated renewed interest and publicity for the republican movement, which means in a way, the protest has been a success due to the police action.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by Symbiote on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:32AM (#35872737)
The law says there's an offence "attach themselves to another person, to an object or to land" — which could include holding hands — but for "being equipped" it needs to be an object: "A person commits an offence if they have an object with them in a place other than a dwelling with the intention that it may be used in the course of or in connection with the commission by any person of an offence under section 1(1) (offence of locking on)."

I'll not be at all surprised if later this year the Metropolitan Police arrest protesters from linking arms while surrounding a building or blocking a road.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by silasdavis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:52AM (#35873608)
I have seen them reported as luggage straps

> which turned out to be luggage straps.

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/may/09/labour-says-...

Easily cut or removed in either case.

For the record I do not think locking on should be criminalised in general in the first place, much less for it to be preemptively policed based the discretion of some copper.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by standardUser on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:50AM (#35872406)
Many people have a cavalier attitude about someone "being arrested" but it's actually the violent and comprehensive denial of all basic human rights, often done on a whim. We should be reserving such an extreme measure for people who represent a real and urgent threat of violence, and almost never otherwise. Our tolerance towards arrest as a routine procedure is, to me, baffling and unjustifiable.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by jonatron on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:29AM (#35872229)
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by jl6 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:34AM (#35872285)
"We were just holding placards" describes one part of the protest. Another was:

> groups and individuals were planning to use and throw rape alarms in order to disrupt the coronation procession.

... which is less defensible. Personally I hope a balance is found between allowing protest and preventing egregious disruption.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by swores on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:39AM (#35872316)
The people they arrested for giving out rape alarms were part of a charity who are in central london every weekend giving them out to women at night - they were arrested the night before, i.e. a very weird time for them to be out if their intention was to protest, and I've not heard anything about the police having any actual reason to believe these people intended to protest at all?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by selfhoster11 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:23AM (#35872650)
Not only that - their reflective wests bore the logo of the City of Westminster [0]

[0]: https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article29914468.ece/AL...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by willis936 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:45AM (#35872359)
Okay but why are people being arrested for the crime of "soon will be holding a sign"?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by silasdavis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:02AM (#35873707)
I think we're more or less there already:

https://youtu.be/6__jx4YSfNI

The crime of offence, to someone.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by willis936 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:03PM (#35876425)
That was during the period of Queen Elizabeth's funeral.

I am referring to people being actually arrested in the past week for the crime of having a sign.

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/09/world/europe/uk-police-co...

>The police found placards and “items which at the time they had reasonable grounds to believe could be used as lock-on devices,” according to the statement, and arrested six people “on suspicion of going equipped for locking on.”

>The protesters who were arrested said that the devices were in fact luggage straps to fasten banners. After the police investigation failed to prove that anyone had intended to use the straps to lock on, all six had their bail canceled and no further action would be taken against them, the police said.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by misnome on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:08AM (#35872527)
And, if that statement was just an outright fabrication by the police?
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by whostolemyhat on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:09AM (#35872539)
That's the Met's version of events; what they actually did was arrest charity workers the night before, from a charity the Met works closely with[1].

1. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/may/08/arrests-coro...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nailer on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:34AM (#35872748)
I think you (and, judging by the moderation, other people on HN) mistakenly believe I don't support the right to protest, I very much do, and have a habit of supporting (both financially and otherwise) various civil liberties organizations.

However I do like to see logical, robust arguments.

> "Our tolerance for any disruption, whether through protest or otherwise, will be low."

> "We will deal robustly with anyone intent on undermining this celebration."

(and then later)

> And yet... people were arrested for having signs along the route.

Be clear in what it is you object to. It seems like you want to attack the hypocrisy of arresting non-disruptive protests.

Quoting the police saying disruption will not be be allowed, when instead you are concerned about non-disruptive protesters being arrested, weakens and distracts from your argument.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by swores on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:48AM (#35872872)
I personally am against both the newly passed legislation, and against police arresting people for not even breaking the ridiculous new laws. I'll complain about both :)
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nailer on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:27AM (#35873996)
Sure. Here's an example of a more robust response, written from you to me, borrowing some of Silas' points:

> Personally I support disruptive action (insert rationale here).

> Furthermore, the talk of disruptive action is frequently used to mask action against non-disruptive protest. People were arrested for having signs along the route. Others they were arrested and held for 16 hours on the basis of 'being equipped for locking on' which were actually cargo ties to hold their placards during transit - of no practical use for locking on."

By responding to the current topic, before bringing up the other, it strengthens your points on both.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by cameronh90 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:10AM (#35873127)
Note that there were quite significant peaceful and good natured anti-monarchy protests over the weekend, and the vast majority of those taking part weren't arrested. So, we're obviously not talking about some widespread systematic crackdown on protest at this stage, but rather what appears to be a very bad call on the part of (some?) Met officers. At this stage it's too early to know why these individuals ended up being arrested, but it seems to me like some officers on the ground hugely overstepped the mark and I hope the arrested parties get a good settlement out of it.

However. There is clearly wider context that makes having a fair discussion about this difficult.

On the side against the police and government, there have been far too many instances in the past few years of bad calls, misconduct and, in some cases, using the position of authority to sexually abuse or murder women. There have also been reports finding evidence of systemic racism, homophobia and misogyny within the Met. These do not appear to be isolated incidents. It would appear the Met has a serious cultural problem, and the new Met police chief has admitted this is the case. There hasn't been any real discussion on whether authoritarianism is a factor, but police officers are bound to lean towards authoritarianism and would imagine that's makes them likely to abuse their power. On top of that, this recent police powers bill has been rushed through and hasn't been scrutinised as much as it probably would have been if they weren't working to the deadline of the coronation.

On the other hand, there have been a lot of disruptive protests lately causing, I think it is fair to say, a level of havoc that is not considered by most British people to be a protected form of protest. The Just Stop Oil, Animal Rebellion and Extinction Rebellion protests in particular have illegal disruption as an explicit goal. They have been blocking roads, gluing themselves to trains, throwing paint over art at galleries and have publicly stated they have plans to step up the disruption. The majority of Brits do not support this form of protest and have been demanding the police crack down on them, and I suspect there would have been a huge level of criticism against the police if they had allowed one of these groups to disrupt the coronation. Demonstrations and organised marches aren't controversial, but few people consider these new disruptive tactics to be a legal expression of protest. The other thing to consider is despite the recent issues, the UK is one of the countries where you are least likely to experience any sort of police brutality or corruption, and despite the coronation being controversial and attended by many thousands, only 52 people were arrested over the weekend, which is pretty good going for such a major event.

Personally, I'm sympathetic to these protest movements and agree with their goals, but we need to have a limit to what we consider protected protest. If they still want to take part in illegal protest and risk prosecution for political purposes, that is entirely up to them to decide whether their cause is worth that. But obviously we need to make sure the crack down on those sorts of groups doesn't spill over into limiting free expression as it has done here, and any police officer with these kind of authoritarian tendencies ought to be screened out of the police.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by callahad on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:33AM (#35872271)
The police themselves have expressed "regret" over the arrests and made personal apologies to those arrested. [0]

Now, I doubt the sincerity of that regret, but the fact that they're choosing that message at all means there's no cause for a devil's advocate here. It's a bad law, poorly implemented.

[0]: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65530967

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:47AM (#35872379)
I doubt the police would express regret for enforcing the law, however bad a particular law may be. I'm pretty sure they are expressing regret knowing they acted unlawfully even under the new law.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by InCityDreams on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:13AM (#35873163)
"We regret you feel bad about you being arrested by us".
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by knorker on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:58AM (#35872445)
The same police that had the chief say "oh they weren't supposed to, he he he" when people were arrested for quietly holding A4-sized signs a few months ago on this topic.

They're fascists. That used to be hyperbole, but now they're actually arresting people for their peaceful opinions on the government.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by 1827163 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:10AM (#35872548)
Yes, that is because the Overton window has shifted so far towards authoritarianism. If it didn't the Police would find resistance both within, from the population and from the government as well.

People should hold up a blank piece of paper, that echoes what people do in russia to protest against the war.

https://www.independent.co.uk/tv/news/russian-police-arrest-...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by sokoloff on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:29AM (#35872702)
Interesting to contrast the (sometimes) global opinion that the US First Amendment is too extremist with the current situation in the UK arising in part from the lack of such an extremist "Congress shall make no law...abridging the freedom of speech" framework.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by 1827163 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:02AM (#35873035)
That's how far the Overton window has shifted, when the 1st Amendement of the US Constitution is being branded as "extremist". What dark times we are living in....

And he whole society is shifting in the process, the public becomes more tolerant of the erosion of liberty. While the government starts to clamp down on our freedoms more than ever before. That is how we arrived at the place we are at now, with widespread mass surveillance and censorship. All supposedly accepted by the public in the name of "safety".

With the public maybe so accustomed to that feeling of supposed safety that they might actually oppose rolling back the surveillance in some cases?

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by barry-cotter on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:14AM (#35873837)
> That's how far the Overton window has shifted, when the 1st Amendement of the US Constitution is being branded as "extremist".

The US’ freedom of expression rights are so much stronger than any other state I’m aware of that calling them extreme is quite accurate. There’s nothing like the First Amendment in any other country.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by 1827163 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:19AM (#35873897)
Yes, the US is at the forefront of individual liberty, it is highly advanced in this respect. And it is likely the reason for its economic prosperity over the decades.

Many of the other countries in the world are collectivist. The recent shift in the Overton Window is a regression towards pre-Enlightenment values.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by RansomStark on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:00AM (#35872470)
I disagree, from a UK government perspective, its a excellent law, implemented perfectly.

Yeah, there was a little backlash this time. The police have issued an apology, maybe a few front line officers will be disciplined (somewhat unlikely), then it'll all be forgotten and next time it will barely make the news, and after that its just an everyday occurrence.

The opposition (Labour) party is refusing to say they will repeal the legislation if they win the next election, they haven't said they won't, that's not the politicians way, but what they did say was “We can’t come into office, picking through all the conservative legislation and repealing it” [0].

make no mistake this isn't a law our government wants, its a law our parliament wants, both sides of the house, and it is here to stay, whether we the people want it or not.

It's almost like people that want power and control become politicians to enact laws that give them power and control... Maybe we need some kind of checks and balances on the power of parliament, or maybe, the desire to be a politician should make you ineligible for the role.

[0] https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/may/08/labour-urge...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by 1827163 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:19AM (#35872622)
Yes, many people who crave power and control will gravitate to positions of authority. In many cases it's a diagnosable psychiatric disorder, a personality disorder, that causes it. The behavior is compulsive, they have to be in control at all times. And there is a cluster of symptoms that come together, it's possible to spot this.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by nprateem on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:05AM (#35873069)
Of course Labour won't repeal it. At the first disruptive protest the Tories will have them over a barrel.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by silasdavis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:05AM (#35873743)
They might as a concession for confidence and supply from the Liberal Democrats. Which might suit all involved since the lib dems could be blamed in such an event.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by _joel on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @12:15PM (#35876578)
No point shooting yourself in the foot when you're this clear in front... Ammendements will be made, I'm confident of that, when they actually have the power to do so.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by samwillis on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:25AM (#35872192)
> I feel you're overlooking

Just to clarify, my comment is not passing any judgment or offering any analysis. I intend to provide context in the aftermath of this weekend, and why I assume this has been posted and voted to the top of the homepage.

Of course there is nuance, and not all "protest" activities can be justified.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by HyprMusic on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:29AM (#35872226)
26 people were arrested for signs, t-shirts and flags.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/royal/1767017/just-stop-oil-c...

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by becquerel on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @06:32AM (#35872258)
Some would argue that protest is meant to be disruptive.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:51AM (#35872910)
As such, they are not a human right. You have the right to talk; you don't have the right to force the others to listen to you.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by account42 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:03AM (#35873050)
Speaking in a public place is not forcing others to listen to you.

If you are only allowed to talk where noone can listen you then you do not in fact have free speech.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:13AM (#35873155)
I was replying to: "protest is meant to be disruptive".

Speaking in a public place is free speech.

Interrupting a motorcade is not free speech. Pushing people around to get in from of cameras is neither.

By the way, I'm using these two possible behaviours as examples of disruptive actions that do not constitute free speech. I'm not stating that people in London were arrested due to such behaviours.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by account42 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:31AM (#35873383)
> Interrupting a motorcade is not free speech.

Depends entirely on the kind of interruption. Remember that a mortorcade is itself already a disruption of the normal use of a public space.

> Pushing people around to get in from of cameras is neither. By the way, I'm using these two possible behaviours as examples of disruptive actions that do not constitute free speech. I'm not stating that people in London were arrested due to such behaviours.

Yes, that's called a strawman. And you are using very imprecise language to boot - pushing people around can describe a number of behaviors from a gentle nudge to ouright assault.

Saying that protests should be allowed to be disruptive does also not mean that any kind of disruption needs to be accepted. Obviously if a protest prevents effectively detains you it is not ok. But having to take a slight detour or hearing people say things you want to ignore, that's something that is effectively required for a protest to have any result at all.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:56AM (#35873663)
> is effectively required for a protest to have any result at all

I'll say it again: you don't have the right to expect that your protest be successful.

Democracy (and the UK isa democracy) means that the status quo is fine for the majority of the people. If anyone had the right to change things at their whim, that would become a dictatorship.

Protesting is to inform people at large of a problem you feel important, but the solution cannot be up to you alone. And if you can't even convince people to listen to you without coercing them, why do you think your protest should be successful?

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by hiatus on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:34AM (#35873414)
> Interrupting a motorcade is not free speech.

Am I not exercising free speech if I talk over you? Why is interrupting a motorcade any different? Motorcades are arguably expressions in and of themselves.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @09:03AM (#35873730)
> Am I not exercising free speech if I talk over you?

In civilized places, we do not talk over another. We take turns to speak.

> Why is interrupting a motorcade any different?

It is not different indeed. They are both wrong. Especially if the motorcade is organized by the public authority in a democracy, and the protestor is a small group in search of an audience that could not be bothered to listen to their arguments.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pyth0 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:57AM (#35872986)
Given the fact that people are being arrested for holding up signs, it does not seem that they "have the right to talk".
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by pif on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:19AM (#35873231)
I was replying to: "protest is meant to be disruptive".

I agree that holding up signs is not a good reason for an arrest.

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by account42 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:59AM (#35873009)
It's concerning that the French seem to be the only ones that still understand this in Europe.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by whostolemyhat on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @07:12AM (#35872556)
The Republic protest was a planned protest, ie they were co-ordinating with the police for weeks beforehand about what they were going to do, where and when, which the Met told them was ok[1]. Then on the morning they were arrested, and have now been released and not charged.

1. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-65530967

Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by class4behavior on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:00AM (#35873014)
And you're overlooking the fact that laws always appear to solve some trouble or evil, even if the definition of said trouble is nonsensical or evil itself.
Re:UN Human Rights Chief Urges UK to Reverse ‘Deeply Troubli... by tailspin2019 on Tuesday May 09, 2023 @08:03AM (#35873053)
> Not if you carry a sign protesting the monarch along the route

This is exactly what many arrested were doing (or were intending to do)