News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by dxbydt on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:58AM (#35456279)
Speaking as an immigrant - Worked in SF most of last decade. Left in 2018. Crime was on a steady uptick while I was there. Once in the Bart, a young man grabbed a cellphone from the guy seated right next to me & bolted out of the train. The train started, and the cellphone owner gave chase. The Bart police arrived soon after, with guns pointed straight at the passengers. The robber was fast and jumped over the turnstile & got away with the cellphone. I felt like I was like in a cops and robbers movie. People are trying to peacefully commute to work and instead you are subjected to guns in your face because of some shiny iphone. Rest of the train trip was some heated political debate between the left & the left-left, arguing what should be done. The left wanted to integrate the youth into the tech community by offering free coding classes so they wouldn't rob cellphones. The left-left argued for free iphones for everybody. I was like, hey how about catching the robber & some jailtime, which is what they'd have done where I come from. Ofcourse I didn't actually say anything, I don't feel comfortable talking about your politics.

I work in a suburb in the rural midwest now. Neighborhoodscout says my odds are 1 in 1100. So my chances of being a victim have improved from 1 in 18 to 1 in 1100. How does it feel ? 8 year old kids here bike to school a mile away, snow or shine, no cps, nothing. As to property crime - once we went away for the weekend & the garage door acted up in our absence. So for a whole 3 days, the garage was wide open & anybody could have walked in & grabbed whatever. Nothing was taken. On the contrary there was a nice note from the neighbor about applying grease on the railing so the garage door stays closed.

So if you are an immigrant & safety is a priority, yeah there are many towns in the midwest southwest etc. where you can be very safe. Houses are quite cheap & I was able to buy my house with straight cash, but ironically that cash was earned in SF! Indeed, I now get paid 4x less than what I made as a programmer back in SF.

So yeah, from an immigrant pov, it looks like in this country you first have to pay your dues. Work in some high-crime zone like SF,NYC etc, accumulate capital. Then move to some peaceful rural place in the midwest with no crime & no nothing. We don't even have a mall.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by Shocka1 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:42PM (#35457799)
I'm born and raised Midwest. I've lived in smaller cities and have absolutely zero desire to go back to that environment. Midwest living is one of the best kept secrets in the US, even though the secret is definitely out now. I make coastal money - it can be done although it takes some negotiating skills.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by TehShrike on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:43PM (#35462082)
did you mean "larger cities"?
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by Shocka1 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @04:15PM (#35473763)
Good point I probably should have clarified a little better. I meant smaller as in slightly smaller than NYC/Seattle, etc.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:01PM (#35457208)
> So for a whole 3 days, the garage was wide open & anybody could have walked in & grabbed whatever. Nothing was taken. On the contrary there was a nice note from the neighbor about applying grease on the railing so the garage door stays closed.

Everyone seems to be missing a piece of critical non-political information.

One setting is rural, everyone owns the house, lives there long-term, everyone knows neighbours. You don't want to ruin relationship with neighbours for $100.

The other setting is Urban, you don't know neighbours, you don't care what they think. Everyone appears out of nowhere and disappears into obscurity.

The social dynamics is totally different, and the housing crisis has a big role to play in it.

Also you do not Have_To own the house to feel like you live there long term and know neighbours - many European countries have social housing, or massive restrictions on landlords kicking out tenants. So tenants stay in the same place for decades, and there is a real community.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by smsm42 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:35PM (#35457689)
You can have Urban setting without the squalor that is currently swallowing the Bay Area. I know it because I have seen it - in the same place. The difference between what I have seen in SF when I came there for the first time, in early 2000s, and what I am seeing now, in 2023, is striking. Everybody has a long list of reasons why, but the basics are clear here I think - it's not that you can't have urban setting with reasonable quality of life. It's that somehow whatever is being done in the Bay Area does not lead to this - very possible otherwise - outcome. It's not some inevitable law of nature - it's what people do, how they organize their society, and it's clear that the way they do it now leads to some consequences and so far they are not intent to change their ways substantially - so the consequences will continue.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by DeusExMachina on Thursday April 06, 2023 @07:24AM (#35466887)
I live in an urban setting, Amsterdam, 1M+ inhabitants in the area. I barely know my neighbors. And yet, the description of the parent could apply to life here.

I once forgot a briefcase on the street out of a bar in the center after work. I realized only when I got home. I got back there, sure that I would not find it anymore. I come from Italy and that is just the norm there.

Not only I found it, but someone moved it out of the way of the bike rack where I forgot it. So it was definitely noticed, and yet nobody took it.

Another anecdote. Once at a dancing event, the organizer just left and went to sleep. He told me that if people wanted a drink, they could just grab one from the fridge and put money in the money box. Where I come from, the fridge would have been emptied and the money box would have disappeared.

It's not a matter of urban vs. rural. It's a matter of culture.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by notch898a on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:45PM (#35457848)
My neighbors hardly know each other and we definitely don't know the people in the (low-rent) apartment complex next door where gun-shots are heard monthly.

The reason why people don't come in and take the shit out of our houses in my shit neighborhood is not because we all know each other. It is because unlike in SF, that would be a death wish (sure maybe not the first time, but it would not take many times). Also unlike in SF the police will probably pat the back of the home owner while what is left of the robber is removed from the property.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by foolinaround on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:53PM (#35457977)
this "not knowing the neighbors" is a flimsy excuse at best. This is mostly true of any densely populated city around the world, where people move in for jobs.

In the past few years, crime in some US cities are committed by certain groups of the population - who are partly encouraged by the local powers.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by inglor_cz on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:04PM (#35458141)
"The other setting is Urban, you don't know neighbours, you don't care what they think. Everyone appears out of nowhere and disappears into obscurity."

And yet crime levels in various urban settings are wildly different, from places like Johannesburg on one extreme of the continuum to Reykjavík or Tokio on the other one.

Looking at the worst cities worldwide as far as homicide goes, almost all the top contenders are from Mexico, South Africa, Brazil, the US or Colombia, with Mexico being heavily overrepresented. 17 of the top 50 homicide metropolises are Mexican. Damn.

There isn't a single European or Asian city in that list. Germany has some 60 per cent of the Mexican population, but isn't present in the top 50 at all. Heck, even India and China just aren't there, and they together account for almost half of mankind.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_homicide_rat...

The pattern is too non-random to claim that urban life in itself is somehow inherently dangerous. It is only dangerous if your governance sucks.

And yes, SF governance sucks, though not to the degree of Ciudad Juarez - but that is a low, low hurdle to clear.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by throwaway60701 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:56PM (#35458852)
Seems like all the cities with ethnically uniform population established for hundreds of years are safe, while those much younger cities with historically lots of immigration from various different places are unsafe. Not sure what the US should do with that, it's not like there is (almost) anybody other than immigrants or any truly old cities at all.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by alchemist1e9 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:10PM (#35459001)
What has you rejecting a much simpler hypothesis that strict law enforcement makes cities safe? pursing, arresting, and severe punishment of criminals.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:24PM (#35459170)
You've just blended all of justice system into a single metric that is too basic.

If you want 'tough on crime' that actually works, but you have to be tough on all crime, including crime in the police. And make sure the entire justice process works.

UK has a 'tough on crime' government, they've increased severity of sentences, but have cut funding to the police. The rate of prosecution, i.e. how likely you are to get caught, fell off a cliff. Also now that police is poorly paid, we have corruption in the police.

Research shows that certainty of punishment is far more important than severity of punishment. Criminals are chancers.

Then we have to make sure that suspects get proper legal council. The current plea bargain system in US is absurd. You can prosecute some poor shmuck for a crime, they can't afford a lawyer, and state lawyer sucks, so they take the plea. Taxpayer pays for their imprisonment, police reports great success. Meanwhile real criminal goes free to commit more crimes with more experience. And they will be harder to catch next time.

Most european countries do not have severe punishment of criminals, yet crime rates aren't crazy.

I havent been to US, so i am not sure about any Bay Area shenanigans

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by alchemist1e9 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:21PM (#35460528)
> Research shows that certainty of punishment is far more important than severity of punishment.

So we completely agree because I’m pretty sure that is all that actually matters.

The issue in US currently is a deranged political fade has taken hold that sees criminals as victims of their circumstances and has started not punishing criminals.

It can be simultaneously true that criminal behavior is often a result of bad circumstances AND that it requires consistent punishment, not that the first point negates the 2nd. Instead social programs need to focus on improving circumstances that lead to criminal behavior not removing punishments.

This political fade is a bankrupt flawed ideology that is effectively mass social psychosis or insanity.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by bandyaboot on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:20PM (#35461206)
> It can be simultaneously true that criminal behavior is often a result of bad circumstances AND that it requires consistent punishment, not that the first point negates the 2nd. Instead social programs need to focus on improving circumstances that lead to criminal behavior not removing punishments.

The problem is there’s another flawed political ideology that tells us that—investing in social programs to improve the circumstances that lead to criminal behavior—is bad because communism.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by throwaway60701 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:24PM (#35459174)
The fact that many US cities have very strict law enforcement and yet they're on the list. Meanwhile, I really wouldn't say we have as strong law enforcement here in EU as it is in the US.

UK is regarded as extremely highly policed state by other Europeans and yet it's less safe than here in mainland Europe.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by Symbiote on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:59PM (#35459634)
> UK is regarded as extremely highly policed state by other Europeans

Which ones? Britain is one of very few countries in Europe where the police don't routinely carry guns, and are perceived as approachable.

I think you should look instead at inequality. Britain has the worst income equality in Europe.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by throwaway60701 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:31PM (#35459963)
The street police doesn't carry guns, but what about all these cameras?

My police is approachable and I don't care about the gun on their belt. I saw them use it for protection of the citizens - I appreciate they have it and don't consider it over-policing.

It's not about the gun, it's about the rights of the police. The police here carries a gun but has zero rights/power against citizens not breaking any laws. They can't even stop you and ask for your ID - that would be considered "communism" here.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by Symbiote on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:36PM (#35461404)
The UK doesn't even have an identity card system.

It's not worth continuing the discussion since you haven't said which country.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by inglor_cz on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:15PM (#35459069)
Too many exceptions from this rule.

Vienna is pretty mixed since the times of the Austro-Hungarian empire, but fairly safe. Glasgow is almost purely Scottish, but dangerous. Naples is probably less ethnically mixed than Rome, but more dangerous. Marseille is a lot worse than Genoa etc.

I don't doubt that particular kinds of immigration can worsen crime situation considerably, but some places can manage that and some fail miserably. You can even see it in the same city if the political representation changes. AFAIK the current mayor of Barcelona is notorious for letting street crime fester.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by rippercushions on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:04PM (#35459693)
The Mexican cities topping the chart have very little immigration, while many safe Asian cities like Singapore, Hong Kong, Dubai have huge amounts of immigration from all over the world.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by throwaway60701 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:30PM (#35459944)
Singapore, Hong Kong and Dubai are all places that practice extreme police/state overreach unacceptable by western standards. I don't consider a city that will have a person flogged for littering a safe place.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by rippercushions on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:37PM (#35460044)
You will not get flogged for littering in any of those, although Singapore famously does have judicial caning for intentional vandalism. And unlike the US, you are extremely unlikely to get shot by the police.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by throwaway60701 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:47PM (#35460165)
Oh it's caning and only sometimes, well then that's absolutely fine.

...

No it isn't. Absolutely not. No way. Never coming there. Damn this place. Doesn't matter what the offense has to be, it's never fine.

Do you think that each and every judgement of judicial caning was correct? That mistakes can't happen?

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by kareemsabri on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:35PM (#35462014)
People will get up in arms over caning but throw 20 year olds in jail for 25 years.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by inglor_cz on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:39PM (#35460069)
"a city that will have a person flogged for littering"

Isn't this mostly a myth? You will get fined for littering in Singapore just like elsewhere, though their fines are higher and the police arguably enforces laws against littering more eagerly than in the West. Caning (not flogging) is reserved for more serious offences (IIRC the lightest one is vandalism.)

Dubai employs flogging, but for Shariah offences, not for littering.

Hong Kong doesn't use judicial corporeal punishment at all.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by rippercushions on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:53PM (#35460894)
Yes. The normal punishment for littering in Singapore is a fine, while repeat offenders may get Corrective Work Orders, meaning having to pick trash off roads while wearing a yellow flouro vest saying so. Caning is not on the menu.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corrective_work_order

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:58PM (#35460952)
> Dubai ... practice extreme police/state overreach

Like all 'proper oldschool' conservative societies, in Dubai laws is applied only to the 'right people'.

For example extramarital sex is a crime, but if you open Tinder it's full of hookers.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by comte7092 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:28PM (#35460597)
Have you considered actually checking your numbers on that?

There are tons of immigrants in Germany/Western Europe and east Asia.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by throwaway60701 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:31PM (#35461335)
There's nowhere near the amount of immigrants you see in the US, where it's practically everyone. The more eastern you go, the less immigration. In Poland, Czechia and Slovakia there are major cities with zero non-white people and single digit percent immigrants from nearby states.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by comte7092 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:49PM (#35461536)
>There's nowhere near the amount of immigrants you see in the US, where it's practically everyone

That is an absurdly inaccurate assertion.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by inglor_cz on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:43AM (#35465003)
"In Poland, Czechia and Slovakia there are major cities with zero non-white people and single digit percent immigrants from nearby states. reply"

There are Vietnamese communities in CZ/SK everywhere, even in very rural areas, but, you won't see them much in the streets, because they spend their life indoors working, and they usually own their shops, living right behind them, so they aren't even seen commuting to work and back. Quite often the only small grocery in a village or a small town is Vietnamese-owned.

But maybe East Asians are now considered (elevated? condemned?) as basically white by the American racial discourse?

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday April 06, 2023 @05:44AM (#35466253)
Indeed, is my problem with American racial discourse too - once you dig beyong sufrace level, it's inconsistent and primitive.

Whether left or right, their concept of ethnicity is primitive. white/black/asian.

Are Russians same ethnicity as Germans? Are Germans same ethnicity as Bavarian? Russian government considers Russia to have ~100 ethnic groups native to Russia.

Us discourse is either about skin-colour, or about man-made country borders.

The only scientifically based concept is Haplogroups, bur noone knwos about them.

The rest is man-made concepts and culture.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by comte7092 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @03:04PM (#35472898)
>Whether left or right, their concept of ethnicity is primitive.

>The rest is man-made concepts and culture.

You got to it at the end. There’s nothing about any of it that is scientific, it’s all just culture.

The reason why it’s “primitive” in America is because that is what is true in the American context. It just doesn’t map to the European context.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by robopsychology on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:09PM (#35458215)
Have you ever been to Tokyo? One of the largest cities in the world yet has way way lower robberies/homicides than US cities.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by za3faran on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:32PM (#35458533)
Also many Gulf states and cities (Dubai, Sharjah, etc.).
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by ThrowawayTestr on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:13PM (#35459051)
Japan is one of the most racially homogenous countries on earth.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by smsm42 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:54PM (#35459580)
That sounds a bit racist, like "certain racial setups can live in prosperity, but as soon as you get certain other races in the mix, you should abandon all hope of having good quality of life". I prefer to think mutable policies have more to do with it than immutable genetic traits.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by huhhii77 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:21PM (#35459844)
Bluebirds tend to prefer the company of other bluebirds
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by wolverine876 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:08AM (#35464369)
You mean, they don't create fictional 'races' of bluebirds and then spread hate about each other, including by asserting it's somehow inevitable? Oh, to be a bluebird rather than a Hacker News reader today.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by huhhii77 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:56AM (#35465089)
Bluebirds tend to prefer the company of other bluebirds.

Lions prefer lions. Hyenas prefer hyenas. They coexist. But they prefer the company of their own. And that's ok. It is nature.

No need to add complexity. It's nature. Always has been. Always will be.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by trafficante on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:43PM (#35460122)
As far as real world examples, there does seem to be evidence of an unfortunate “safe city” axis requiring either racial/cultural homogeneity or extremely heavy handed authoritarianism.

Ironically, America in the 90s and early 2000s seemed to be approaching a sweet spot where cultural expectations and “mild” authoritarian policing were successful at crushing urban crime rates. This whole thread is full of longtime West Coasters bemoaning how much better city life was in “the good old days” of 10-15 years ago. Odd how there’s zero political will to simply go back to what worked.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by thephyber on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:29PM (#35460619)
So you point out that it doesn’t match your priors and double down on not exploring whether your priors are correct. I find it more useful to be curious whether the parent’s stats are correct.

Also worth pointing out that homogeneity isn’t only along an axis of race. Example: There are plenty of Mexican Americans who are extremely racist towards newer Mexican immigrants to their neighborhoods. LATimes has done several pieces about this dynamic. People will always find reasons to put other people in categories.

Also worth pointing out that the society in Japan is more overtly racist towards outsiders of any race. My source is a life-long friend (white American living in Japan for 15+ years) who overheard lots of conversations when the locals think he doesn’t understand their words.

America has been a “melting pot” for a while, so we have moved our racial/homogeneity issues at least one layer below polite discussion. Most Americans will put up a façade about not being racist, but don’t actually put any effort to align their behaviors.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by s1artibartfast on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:46PM (#35460823)
>America has been a “melting pot” for a while, so we have moved our racial/homogeneity issues at least one layer below polite discussion

Sadly, I think identity politics has tossed the melting pot ideals aside. It encourages zero sum thinking where different groups are enemies and relative sucess is what matters. This means pulling others down is just important than lifting people up. Unfortionatly, it is easier to pull people down than lift them up.

Crab bucket mentality in practice.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by wolverine876 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:06AM (#35464362)
Racism hasn't damaged melting pot ideals? It's really hard to overlook centuries of it, and the widespread increase in overt racism in the last 7 years - including on Hacker News.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by s1artibartfast on Thursday April 06, 2023 @08:53AM (#35467694)
I suppose it has, although I do wonder why now. It seemed like the ideal was strong enough to stand up before the civil rights movement.

My theory racism and identity politics have a positive feedback relationship. That is to say identity politics is counterproductive at bringing about a less biased society.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by smsm42 on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:32AM (#35479115)
There are plenty of people who hate other people for various reasons. We have a hot war with hundreds of thousands of people right in now in Europe, without any racial component involved. I fail to see how this provides any justification for racism though.

Yes, Japan is a very high-conforming and ethnically homogeneous society. It is also a low-crime society. However, to derive just from that that absence of racial homogeneity alone leads to high crime makes no more sense than claiming that not using logographic scripts leads to violence - since Asian society are generally less violent than, for example, the US. You need to do much more work than just picking one difference and attribute everything to it.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by gwright on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:02PM (#35461002)
Perhaps "Japan is one of the most culturally homogenous countries on earth" would have been more helpful? It wouldn't surprise me if that was the intent of the comment either. The way people discuss and conceptualize "race" and "culture" is quite complicated. They are often muddled together in a way that can be hard to untangle.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by smsm42 on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:38AM (#35479154)
* * *
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by eastbound on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:55PM (#35459585)
No relation to criminality, there are many countries with racially diverse backgrounds and peaceful communities. Sydney is one of them and Sydney has both Whites and Asians. Singapore has a lot of all of them.

It’s not the homogeneity.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by papa-whisky on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:30PM (#35460621)
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by eastbound on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:39PM (#35460738)
Exactly as I said, violence is not due to the mix between Asians and Whites, therefore it’s not mixing people that causes violence. It’s inviting the wrong people.

Please read the first line in the main body of your article and you’ll find the answer. It’s so predictable it’s more accurate than science.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by zztop44 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:38PM (#35461420)
Sorry, but it sounds like you’re saying that allowing the “wrong” type of immigrant is what causes violence and using Cronulla as evidence?

Cronulla was a one-off event almost 20 years ago, was extremely shocking and out of the ordinary, and as far as I can remember no-one died. As such, it’s not a great example of anything much, other than the fact that ethnic tensions existed between white and Arab communities in Australia in the mid-2000s (which is not all that surprising given the context of 9/11, the Iraq War, etc)

I do agree with your first point, however, that Sydney is a good example of one of the most multicultural cities in the world being quite safe, without requiring authoritarian policing (lockouts and drug dogs in train stations aside)

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by wolverine876 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:10AM (#35464383)
Are you trying to hint a racist ideology, that the "wrong people" are some race you don't like. Maybe individuals make their own choices, and the ones who choose to be racists are the wrong people. What a dream if they all left for their own country.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by eastbound on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:09AM (#35464760)
Look, absolutely everyone in this entire page is trying to dodge strictly enforced DDR Germany-style taboo about saying the truth, so I’m not gonna say what is the obvious source of most criminality in the West.

But I’ll stop you right there from swaying the blame onto someone else and reaching entirely false conclusions. What crime is NOT due to:

- Crime is not due to poverty. Plenty of poor cities who aren’t violent.

- Crime is not due to previous crime. Put white felons on an island and you get Australia, as the joke says.

- Crime is not due to high-density area. Tokyo.

- Crime is not due to immigration or displacing population. Ukraine migrant kids who spoke French astonishingly fluently in 6 months, a better score than all kids from “other” French backgrounds.

- Crime is not due to mixing population. Singapore.

Each of them is easily proven by finding great counter-examples of constructive people being moved/concentrated to place X or Z and not having high criminality.

It must be something else, something which can be found in all evoked areas and not found in peaceful areas, but I’m not going to say it.

Is it water?

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by pcthrowaway on Thursday April 06, 2023 @06:38AM (#35466573)
It.. sounds like you are hinting that you think the violence is caused by a specific ethnicity of people? Because if you're not, it'd be good to make that clear. Maybe you're saying it's a result of imported cultural values that encourages violence?

Also, your list doesn't mean some combination of those things can't result in worsening incidence of violent crime.

My own belief is that its some combination of:

- Extreme wealth inequality

- High cost of living

- High incidence of poverty (relative to the aforementioned cost of living)

- Poor social safety net

- Poor community cohesion and trust

- Individualistic cultural attitudes (as opposed to collectivist cultural attitudes)

- Poor public protection

- Easy access to drugs (including alcohol)

I think the drugs just become a symptom of the problem; people get addicted because they are suffering (see rat park). They develop antisocial behaviours, which reduces community cohesion and trust. The city then becomes less happy overall, and it becomes a cycle

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by eastbound on Thursday April 06, 2023 @05:41PM (#35474914)
> Also, your list doesn't mean some combination of those things can't result in worsening incidence of violent crime.

When kicked out of the front door, try to come back through the backdoor?

You can create convoluted science that a combination of those factors leads to violence. Since it’s a combination, it’s even less provable, a correlation doesn’t cause causation, and I’ll keep finding counter examples, to which you will find even more convoluted reasons.

But there is a much, much simpler hypothesis, and for my part it explains the world with accuracy and predictability. What defines a science is its ability to predict the future based on some inputs.

So, my stance is to never make a decision based on prejudice, which is satisfying in terms of humanism, but don’t forget that people will reliably get killed, mugged and raped, and in quantity, if you don’t watch out for the thing-I’ll-not-say which was ever predictable. And it’s both our responsibility to put our family out of harm’s way, and an incredible feat of the XXIth century that we’re feeding our own relatives into a crime machine that reliably gets them killed or raped.

Speaking from experience. But everyone who has a grave opinion on this topic has, someday, seen a relative crossing the path of those people.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by medler on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:45PM (#35460133)
People say this but are never able to offer any evidence for this claim. The fact is that Japan is much less homogeneous than white westerners tend to believe, and has liberalized immigration substantially in recent years.

You’ll hear stats about the high percentage of Japanese people in Japan, but those statistics invariably refer to Japanese citizens, not ethnic Japanese.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by bart_spoon on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:35PM (#35460681)
Yes, but Japan isn’t safe and harmonious because of racial makeup, it’s save and harmonious because of cultural inclinations. In Japan, the individual defines themselves with a much greater emphasis on their place in society. Societal good is given far more importance than in other countries. In Western nations, individualism is so strong it borders on narcissism, in my opinion, and a consideration for society always takes back seat to the individual. Countries like the US will never achieve the social cohesion of Japan, not because of racial makeup, but because we are too obsessed with ourselves.

At least, that’s my belief as an American who has spent several years living in Japan.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by ThrowawayTestr on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:53PM (#35461581)
>Japan isn’t safe and harmonious because of racial makeup, it’s save and harmonious because of cultural inclinations.

Perchance those things are related?

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by jerojero on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:38PM (#35462040)
Unless you believe racially japanese people are significantly different to people from other asian countries. No.

What really are the genetic basis to say Japan is a country that's markedly different from other asian populations?

The people living in Japan have not lived there for long enough for their genetic to become too different from those of other asian countries. Culture on the other hand changes much more rapidly. Culture is the "genetics" of society, it is passed down from generation to generation and it mutates and these mutations are also hereditary... it's just much faster than biological processes.

But ultimately, it seems very unlikely (and as far as I know, there's very little evidence that suggests this is the case) that race and genetics will have a huge effect on culture. Specially given that countries with similar genetic populations will have vastly different cultures.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by barry-cotter on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:11AM (#35464032)
> The people living in Japan have not lived there for long enough for their genetic to become too different from those of other asian countries.

The Ainu’s skin tone is more like Caucasians than East Asians and the majority population, (Yamato?) are noticeably shorter than the Koreans to whom they are most closely related. There’s clearly been enough isolation, for long enough, for some differentiation. That’s not to say the distribution of traits doesn’t overlap. We’re not talking Sardinians and Swedes here, never mind Bantu and Basque.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by decafninja on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:55AM (#35465081)
A lot of the pros and cons of Japanese society could apply to Korean society too. There is a lot of overlap.

Seoul, like Tokyo, could also be described as a HNer’s dream city. Ultra safe, ultra clean, amazing transit. And like Tokyo, a city like Seoul could never exist in the US for similar reasons.

(Then again, cars and public transit coexist somewhat harmoniously in Seoul, with cars being an aspirational item for many Koreans, so maybe it’s not a dream city for the banallcars HNer crowd)

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by AuryGlenz on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:31AM (#35464921)
I’m not sure why it’s so hard for people to believe that evolution can indeed affect our brains just like everything else.

Keep in mind the culture of the various regions could easily cause fast natural (?) selection. I’m no expert on Japan’s history, and even less so on China/Korea/etc. I know enough that Japan had periods of pretty constant war, and that the young and the brash would essentially volunteer to be mercenaries. It seems to me that could pretty quickly weed out the most aggressive genes in a population. It would be different, of course, if soldiers were conscripted instead.

That’s just one example and as I said, I’m not a historian. Another example would be America. People always come up with silly reasons why we became the dominant world power. In my opinion the reason is simple: the people that immigrated here were risk takers, hard workers, and dreamers. Their kids would inherit those genes.

So, I’d say culture begets genetics which begets culture…

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by spookybones on Thursday April 06, 2023 @11:01AM (#35469239)
I would suggest you read up on the history of mercenaries worldwide and the history of youth volunteering for wars worldwide. These are by no means traits particular to Japanese people. I would also suggest you read up on the United States global positioning before and after WW2. It was regionally isolated from the brunt of the war, which allowed it to loan money and sell weapons and resources at very favorable rates for the majority of the war. This can’t be excluded from a simple explanation of its global dominance.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by AuryGlenz on Thursday April 06, 2023 @04:23PM (#35473874)
I'm very well aware of what people's argument is for why the US became dominant, and I'm sure it was a factor.

Yet that didn't happen to other regionally isolated countries like Mexico or Brazil - hell, or even Canada.

And yes, youth always volunteer for wars. Like I said, I'm not a historian and my example was just an example of how things could guide selection. That said I don't think many countries had something similar to what ronin, or even samurai, were. It was a fairly unique system.

China's Great Leap Forward would be another example of something that could guide who lived to procreate and who didn't.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by gond0r on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:09PM (#35472104)
"I’m not sure why it’s so hard for people to believe that evolution can indeed affect our brains just like everything else."

because publicly acknowledging this obvious reality comes at a cost: you WILL be attacked. most people do not want to be attacked and would rather take the easier route of pretending to not notice this or anything that's going to cause them a problem.

they have even done studies with 1 day old babies where the scientist holds the baby's nose shut and guess what, babies of different races react in different ways. same as when they take baby boys and girls and put them in a room the boys go for the toy trucks and the girls go for the dolls. i'm sorry but that study doesn't need to happen if you don't live in an ivory tower and have to act like a politician because you have so much money to lose for having the wrong opinion.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by bart_spoon on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:30PM (#35461964)
You think that cultural values are influenced by race? I certainly don’t. Culture a construct, not genetically determined. Let me put it this way, if you waved a wand to make America as racially homogenous as Japan, it would still have all the same discord because it would still all be Americans, and American culture is narcissistic and sociopathic.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by decafninja on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:55PM (#35471918)
I’d say it’s more influenced by having common ground with your fellow citizens, and race is one potential factor.

It’s why even in America you see racial/ethnic blocs and enclaves form. Hence the mentions of an “Asian voting bloc” or “Hispanic voting bloc”, during elections. Would we be hearing about such things if the US was monoracial? Even among many divisions, it would be one less divisive factor.

(yes, I’m aware in the past things were carved up even among whites - such as Italians vs. Irish etc)

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by slaw on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:58PM (#35460953)
Jamaica is also one of the most racially homogeneous countries on earth. Yet safety there is the opposite from Japan.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by a_bonobo on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:31PM (#35462943)
This is a myth - Japan does not collect data on ethnicity/background [1], so we just don't know. Japan has a (to foreigners) invisible and extensive caste system [2] and a long history of looking down at Japanese of Korean background (who are quite common, but again, there are no official stats by Japan - South Korea tracks about 800k people in Japan [3]), plus all those Japanese of Brazilian background (Brazil estimates at least 1.4 million of those [4]

[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-34615972

[2] https://qz.com/2029525/the-20-countries-that-dont-collect-ra...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koreans_in_Japan

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_Brazilians

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by eldaisfish on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @10:07PM (#35463217)
Your sources have little to nothing to do with the racial homogeneity in Japan although your initial point is correct - Japan does not collect data on ethnicity.

A glance at Japan's history and geography will tell you that Japan is an incredibly homogenous country as far as ethnicity goes.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by a_bonobo on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:03AM (#35464334)
'Racial homogeneity' is not a thing in biology

Furthermore, up until 1869 Hokkaido was a separate kingdom peopled by the Ainu - Japan has a long history of exchanging people with Korea. It's not some fabled walled-off kingdom, it's a regular country full of regular people

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by cat_plus_plus on Thursday April 06, 2023 @12:00AM (#35463961)
And Fremont or Cupertino are murder capitals of the world by that logic? Nah. Even unskilled immigration reduces local crimes rates in US. Kind of obvious, people who made an effort to come to a country tend to try hard to make it work.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by TimDotC on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:32PM (#35459279)
I'm all for adopting policies that resemble that of Japan/Tokyo. However, half the country would accuse you of autocratic behavior and infringing on constitutional rights.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by smsm42 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:57PM (#35459607)
I am having hard time thinking about any example where San Francisco government did not implement some policy because the other half of the country didn't like it. If anything, that'd be even more reason for them to implement it, just to "own" "those stupid idiots".
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by anotherman554 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:04PM (#35461027)
The San Francisco government is not the only source of policy in San Francisco. If the San Francisco government wanted to implement strict gun control like they have in Tokyo, for example, they would be blocked by the Supreme Court judges elected by the rest of the country.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:08PM (#35461067)
> Supreme Court judges elected

Not how that works.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by anotherman554 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @11:25AM (#35469630)
I'm well aware of how it works. The country votes into office the politicians who nominate and vote for the Supreme Court judges.

If I was being more careful I could have written the country "indirectly elects" the Supreme Court judges. My basic point still stands, San Francisco policy is in many ways set by the entire country.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by smsm42 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:43PM (#35472593)
Err, SF had strict gun control for years. Getting carry permit in the whole Bay Area has been mostly a "who do you know" thing. Recent SCOTUS decisions made that approach theoretically illegal, but in practice the city is still requires long procedure to get a permit, and is not very generous with permits:

So far the city is processing 72 applications, and they expect to get nearly 100 to 200 more over the next year. Which is very different from the four we processed in the past 10 or so years

Source: https://californiaglobe.com/articles/san-francisco-begins-is...

Certainly 100 permits a year are not going to change things much and definitely four issued in the last 10 years didn't, and if anything sounds like "strict gun control", then four people allowed to carry in 10 years is it.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by anotherman554 on Monday April 10, 2023 @08:11AM (#35511383)
Some public policy can't be effectively implemented on the local level. Tokyo's gun control is it's nation's gun control.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by trafficante on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:33PM (#35459989)
Nah, the far right are quite happy to point to Tokyo as an example of the superiority of an ethnically/culturally homogenous society.

Singapore is a better example, but requires a form of authoritarianism to pull off that would be unacceptable to both the right and the left.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by girvo on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:45PM (#35460816)
It would only be unacceptable to the right because that hypothetical authoritarianism would apply equally to themselves
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by ArtemZ on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:14PM (#35462375)
What if ethnically/culturally homogenous societies are just superior?
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by robopsychology on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:50PM (#35462643)
I’d like to think they aren’t, other people are just used as scapegoats to blame bad things on
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by wolverine876 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:04AM (#35464344)
You don't have the courage to be openly racist?
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by midoridensha on Thursday April 06, 2023 @04:12AM (#35465668)
Exactly which race is his statement advocating as superior? There's a bunch of ethnically homogeneous nations in the world, and their ethnicities are quite different from each other. Japanese are not the same ethnicity as Norwegians.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by TehShrike on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:34PM (#35462002)
I don't believe the low crime levels in Japan/Tokyo are the result of policy decisions. I suspect they are the result of a community-oriented culture enforced by other means.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by buzzert on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:01PM (#35462242)
No, that couldn't be further from the truth. The police have extremely prominent placement in Japanese society. Look up "kōban" ("police boxes")[0]. If you visit Japan, you'll see these things everywhere, on every street corner.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K%c5%8dban

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by midoridensha on Thursday April 06, 2023 @04:10AM (#35465647)
I don't see how a cop sitting in a little box on various street corners equals "extremely prominent placement in society". In fact, I rarely see cops on patrol in the city, unless there's something going on.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by wolverine876 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:02AM (#35464333)
Which policies? Which constitutional rights, and are they unimportant to you?
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by cat_plus_plus on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:45PM (#35463882)
Japan is in the middle of demographic collapse, obviously you don't see a lot of murders in retirement communities (though LA and Half Moon Bay shooters gave it a try a few months back).
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by midoridensha on Thursday April 06, 2023 @10:22PM (#35477256)
If you think Tokyo is a "retirement community", you've obviously never been here.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by decafninja on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:35AM (#35464951)
As someone else mentioned, Japan is one of the most culturally homogenous societies in the world.

Japan takes few immigrants, but those that do immigrate there are expected to be guests and live within the established norms of Japanese culture and society.

That’s the opposite mindset of the US - especially the liberal leaning areas, where the society is expected to accept and respect diversity and differences.

You can immigrate to Japan as a Westerner (or even as a outwardly similar looking East Asian from Korea or China, etc), live there for decades and become fully assimilated into Japanese society, even gain citizenship, but still be treated as an outsider - not necessarily disrespectfully.

You could probably say the same for other East Asian countries such as Korea, China, Taiwan, etc.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by BrandoElFollito on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:34PM (#35459996)
As much as I love my country (France), our housing laws are fucked beyond repair.

Someone gets in your house while you are on vacation? Bad luck, you will live on the street before the law sloooo...ooo..wly makes is way and you are almost there but, bad luck this is winter now and you cannot get anyone out and then comes summer and, shit, they now have a baby and they cannot be thrown out.

You will also get a fine if you try to do it your own way, and they will sue you on top of that. And sue you if they get harmed in your house

No surprise that in other to rent a box you need to be royal.

We have a great social system I wholeheartedly support. And then come the leeches we are to week to get rid of and everyone suffers because of that.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by chr1 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:15PM (#35461145)
Have you considered that maybe this wholhearted support of social system is what allows the leeches to come and causes everyone to suffer?
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by JPKab on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:13PM (#35462356)
SF was always unequal. I lived there in 2002-2003 for a year. There was a ton of inequality. The crime is out of control NOW for obvious reasons that conflict with your prior beliefs, so you embrace this silly theory of "if people had more free/cheap stuff they'd be nicer".

Massively reducing prosecutions causes police to stop arresting people since they get released without being charged. This changes the incentive structure for criminals. They get more aggressive, more brazen, and they tell their friends. This isn't complicated.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by BonoboIO on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:29PM (#35457601)
Free iPhones for everyone so nobody would steal anymore …

Hahaha. What a joke. Unbelievable. So disconnected from reality.

[dead]
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by girvo on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:53PM (#35460901)
Yeah that story was amusing at best. I half expected it to end with “That residents name? Albert Einstein” or something equally silly, and yet everyone here is falling for it hook, line and sinker because it confirms their beliefs. HN is supposed to be better than this.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by tablespoon on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:24PM (#35461243)
> Do you really believe that this public discourse occurred on a public train after a theft? Do you think they had a lively debate in the commons about how to solve crime?

> I'm a bit surprised people are seriously believing this. This is someone's shower thoughts six hours later when they strawmanned some ridiculous positions to caricaturize "opponents".

You're trying to portray the story as fabricated, but that's likely wrong. IMHO, it's more likely exaggerated (e.g. there probably wasn't a "lively debate in the commons," more likely comments directed at no one in particular morphing two opinionated randos getting mad at each other).

>> So if you are an immigrant & safety is a priority, yeah there are many towns in the midwest southwest etc. where you can be very safe. Houses are quite cheap & I was able to buy my house with straight cash, but ironically that cash was earned in SF!

> Like, where is this low-income "suburb" (two hours from a major center...) that has no crime? As someone who grew up in a smaller town in the rust belt, I find their claim hysterical.

He didn't say it was "low-income," just cheaper compared to SF. I grew up in a smaller city in the Midwest (four hours from a major center), and his account rings true to me. There's more to the Midwest than the rust belt.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by tablespoon on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @11:30PM (#35463804)
I can't reply to your other comment because it's dead. However, I wanted to respond to this:

> And FWIW, every single small city I checked around 2 hours outside of Chicago has property crime rates worse than Chicago! Isn't that amazing? No, it isn't, unless you're deluded enough to believe their nonsense.

There's a lot of Midwest outside of that region. Even if what you say is true*, it's a skewed sample that can't reasonably be assumed to represent the whole.

* Which I doubt, especially there can be confounding effects in whatever statistics you're looking at, like differing reporting rates (which was already called out in this thread or a similar one, w.r.t San Francisco).

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by eBombzor on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:53PM (#35459570)
I agree with Joseph
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by smsm42 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:27PM (#35457580)
Yeah, that's what I did too. SF has the money, but once you get certain amount of money you start to ask yourself if it's time to get some quality of life, and whether to have to wade around drug addicts and excrement on the street is worth a chance of having more money. SF area (not only SF, same for San Jose) has gone downhill a real lot last ~15 or so years. And somehow people there are completely fine with it, judging from their voting patterns. I don't understand that, but I can't do anything about it, just move out to a place where people value quality of life more. Ironically, covid helped a lot here - many more companies became ok with remote work, and developed processes that allow to accommodate people working outside of the physical office.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by silisili on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:16PM (#35456537)
Do you mind if I ask whereabouts you moved to?
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by dxbydt on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:55PM (#35457107)
suburb 2 hours from chicago. i have a few friends i visit in illinois, also in indiana and in columbus,ohio. its all very similar here, hard to tell apart. full of corn fields, windmills, large homes with giant basement, poorly funded schools with an outdated syllabus that lags behind asian schools by 5+ years, looking at my kids textbooks. people are quite poor out here. median household income stats is like 60k. if you like water view you can try michigan, otherwise its basically landlocked. again, i am just an average asian immigrant. i am not trying to "disrupt the local economy" like the person below claims. i am sorry he feels that way.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by smsm42 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:36PM (#35457712)
> median household income stats is like 60k

That's pretty much average for the US.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by Yhippa on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:11PM (#35457329)
Do you feel that the trade-off is worth it? I constantly go back-and-forth over my head about whether or not, it’s better to deal with what you’re doing in the rural areas or if the amenities are worth the pain of living near a big city.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by silisili on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:32PM (#35459972)
Not OP, but can provide my insight.

It all depends on you, your age, and what you like. If you're a people person who loves and needs interaction, shopping, coffee/beer nightly, absolutely don't move out there.

If you are a homebody who just wants to be left alone, move far, far away.

I'm somewhere in between. I like to get out once or twice a week, then be left alone most of the other times. What I strongly prefer is a place in a small town/city that's within 30 mins or so of a bigger city. And that town/city needs to have its own shopping, groceries, restaurants, post office, etc, because having to drive 30 minutes every time you need a battery or something gets old really, really fast.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by silisili on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:27PM (#35459217)
Thanks!

I ask for no reason other than interest. No blame at all, I also prefer cities like you describe. I've lived all over the US, in some places like you describe (in KY, which isn't far), so was curious.

I absolutely love visiting W Michigan, a real hidden gem. Definitely go check out Holland and the sand dunes north of there if you've never been. Unfortunately, the brutal winters mostly keeps me from moving to that general area.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by s5300 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:07PM (#35456416)
>> Houses are quite cheap & I was able to buy my house with straight cash, but ironically that cash was earned in SF!

So… you came to the MidWest just to contribute here to the very problem you were trying to escape

This is going to end well for society. Remind me in 20 years.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by dang on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:31PM (#35457642)
Personal attacks and flamewar are not allowed here. We ban accounts that post like that, so please don't.

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by throwaway049 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:10PM (#35456465)
The problem they escaped was high crime rates. Do you think they came to the Midwest to commit crime?
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by Akronymus on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:51PM (#35457040)
I assume the comment you replied to meant the policies that led to the high crime rate. Which, I know many people who fear people leaving big cities to keep voting for the policies that lead to why they left the city in the first place.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by Retric on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:03PM (#35457232)
Cities crime rates have little to do with their local politics. Giuliani for example got a great deal of praise for lowering crime in NYC but wildly different approaches also seemed to “work” in other cities.

Look at a graph of murder rates for LA vs NYC and their surprisingly similar even with very different politics. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/05/18/us/chicago-mu...

Chicago, NYC, LA, and many other US cities all had similar trends over similar time periods which line up with national trends. https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/murd...

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by Yhippa on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:12PM (#35457346)
Aren’t the politics very similar?
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by Retric on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:16PM (#35457415)
NYC had “tough on crime” republican governor’s for about half of that time period. Try and locate their policies on the graph before looking up the details.

“Broken Windows” policing was a radically different paradigm that initially got a great deal of praise because it seemed to be working.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by deanCommie on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:45PM (#35456965)
Do you think SF had a high crime rate before the tech industry crated intense wealth inequality and a homelessness crisis?
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by twblalock on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:04PM (#35457248)
I know for sure it did. SF was famous for it for decades. It's even worse now.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by s5300 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:19PM (#35456583)
No, they’re coming & heavily disrupting the local economy which will lead to the current population unable to afford their lives after some time, which will lead to crime.

Do you disagree?

Call me crazy, but perhaps if those in SF could afford a home/ to live/ the basic necessities of a U.S. citizen, they wouldn’t be out on the streets being low lifes.

Not all of them, some people are truly irredeemable - but truly irredeemable people are typically doing much harder crimes than property theft & petty break-ins.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by cscurmudgeon on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:34PM (#35456804)
So you are against migration?
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:15PM (#35457395)
I think the gp is referring to coming in and buying a house for cash, something which is likely unaffordable for people who grew up in that community (because op says that pay scales are about 1/4 of what they are in tech metros).
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by cscurmudgeon on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @01:59PM (#35458062)
Yes, so against migration. Migration always introduces these factors.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by anigbrowl on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:53PM (#35459563)
No, not necessarily.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by cscurmudgeon on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @06:41PM (#35461450)
Even poor migrants increase demand for housing unless they somehow can live in the meta verse or carry their own housing like a snail.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by notch898a on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:39PM (#35456883)
Wow, you sound like the people in my midwest hometown who freaked out when the Punjabis came in and bought all our gas stations.

When you look at the desperate parts of the midwest, of the ones that weren't always that way, you'll find most of the worst of the ones became that way after all the skilled / rich people left coupled with other capital flight. Not the other way around.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by alchemist1e9 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:02PM (#35458111)
I never understand these types of comments, appeals to empathy over individual rationalism. How do people not understand at this point that societies are shaped by individuals making rational selfish choices in their own interests within a market system.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by rcpt on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:26PM (#35456685)
The Midwest famously has no empty space
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by s5300 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @12:31PM (#35456759)
Empty space isn’t livable homes & other buildings communities need to flourish & history has shown the free market won’t not greatly abuse the local population if they ever do decide to come in and build any.

In other words, the entire point of my comment. Thank you for your assistance.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by def_true_false on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @07:01PM (#35461649)
I don't get takes like this. What are you even suggesting? More friction on moving from one place to another?

Most rural US problems seem to come from unwillingness to build higher density. Europe has plenty of 5k-20k towns with relatively dense centers that have all the basic services. At the upper end of that range you can even get things like hospitals. And that's in a country with basically no property taxes.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by muyuu on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:38PM (#35460050)
the wealthier cities won't remain wealthier forever with rampant crime and civil disarray

once upon a time, not that long ago from a historical PoV (the 1950s), Detroit was THE wealthiest city in the USA and it's now among the poorest

and if you look at the decay of those once-wealthy city, the pattern is that they took it for granted and stopped caring and competing

hard times make good men, etc etc

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by 908B64B197 on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:50PM (#35460200)
> Rest of the train trip was some heated political debate between the left & the left-left, arguing what should be done. The left wanted to integrate the youth into the tech community by offering free coding classes so they wouldn't rob cellphones. The left-left argued for free iphones for everybody. I was like, hey how about catching the robber & some jailtime, which is what they'd have done where I come from.

What I wonder is where are the fathers in this scenario. I can't imagine the conversation about the son's income coming from stealing phones going very well with his father.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by TMWNN on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @10:31PM (#35463395)
>What I wonder is where are the fathers in this scenario.

All the fathers stepped out for a pack of smokes some years ago and didn't come back.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by heartbreak on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:52PM (#35460883)
> The left wanted to integrate the youth into the tech community by offering free coding classes so they wouldn't rob cellphones. The left-left argued for free iphones for everybody. I was like, hey how about catching the robber & some jailtime

For what it’s worth, these are solving two different problems. The reported train discussion was a disagreement on a solution to the systemic problem. Jailing the perpetrator only treats the problem with that specific person. Both problems need solutions.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by maratbn on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @08:45PM (#35462610)
Jailing the perpetrator also warns other potential perpetrators that they might also be jailed if they perpetrate the same crime.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by heartbreak on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:46PM (#35463053)
Local SF politics notwithstanding, criminals figure they won’t get caught, not that they won’t get punished. But sure, jailing individuals can be considered a systemic fix, too.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by djfobbz on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @09:33PM (#35462956)
As an immigrant myself who moved here in the early 90s, I can no longer recognize certain parts of US as they’ve completely degraded (in terms of quality of life) at an exponential rate. My general observation is that it’s mainly been wealthy urban cities with ultra liberal policies which in-turn directly affect the local middle class…causing them to flee out to suburbs if not another state.
Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by wolverine876 on Thursday April 06, 2023 @01:00AM (#35464319)
> The left-left argued for free iphones for everybody.

A little implausible?

> Work in some high-crime zone like SF,NYC etc, accumulate capital.

People love living in these cities, as real estate prices show. It's not 'paying dues'; those are much more preferred than small towns, as those real estate prices show. You of course are free to prefer whatever you like.

Re:Bob Lee, Former CTO Square, Creator of CashApp, Stabbed t... by dang on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:16PM (#35472223)
I've detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35454781 and moved it to the top level (just for technical reasons - the first page of the thread is currently too comment-heavy).