News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by ksec on Saturday January 21, 2023 @11:10PM (#34474176)
>“Complete nonsense,” retorts Pierre Ferragu of New Street Research, a financial firm. tsmc has almost simultaneously launched a new fab in Taiwan, with four times the wafer capacity—and more advanced technology—than the two proposed Arizona foundries. Its bet on America is more of a long-term insurance policy than an immediate game-changer. It enables tsmc to start the tough job of recruiting a workforce and amassing suppliers in America, providing a baseline for expansion “if the Chinese are crazy enough to bomb Taiwan”. For the foreseeable future, though, most r&d is likely to remain in Taiwan. So will at least four-fifths of tmsc’s capacity.

It is unfortunate the truth and decent analysts dont get enough press coverage because they dont fit the narrative of current trend.

- The only way to understand the Press is to remember that they pander to their readers' prejudices.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by kilroy123 on Saturday January 21, 2023 @11:12PM (#34474185)
It's also more of a backup for the US defense industry. Many of the chips that will be made in the US fabs can go directly toward military weapons.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by komali2 on Saturday January 21, 2023 @11:24PM (#34474261)
I suspect the PRC won't outright bomb much of Taiwan but instead go straight for the presidential palace in Taipei and try to force an ROC capitulation early.

I think they're counting on the ruling class / landowners / capitalists to pressure the government to capitulate at fear of property destruction, which I also expect to be in line with reality. Doing capitalism in a country like taiwan is better than in the PRC, but doing it in the PRC is better than not being able to do it at all because all your assets were obliterated.

What I think none of these people are counting on is that there are rabidly anti CPC people here in Taiwan, leftist or otherwise, and some of these people engage in post-military service training and drilling. I suspect that if the above comes to pass and the CPC is successful in forcing an ROC surrender, the factories are burning one way or the other, due to "self-sabotage" by workers or guerillas.

Then the PLA gets to have fun for a decade chasing guerillas around the choking thick jungle and mountains that make up the majority of the landmass in Taiwan. Many of these will be indigenous who have lived in the mountains for generations and per capita by demographic make up more of the (non conscripted) military than any other demographic.

I don't think any of this will come to pass though because I, like most people in Taiwan (including the usa consulate staff), believe the possibility of invasion is slim.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by tbihl on Sunday January 22, 2023 @12:32AM (#34474646)
> I suspect the PRC won't outright bomb much of Taiwan but instead go straight for the presidential palace in Taipei and try to force an ROC capitulation early.

Goes along with the mock presidential palace. https://thediplomat.com/2015/08/satellite-imagery-from-china...

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by csomar on Sunday January 22, 2023 @12:34AM (#34474658)
> I suspect the PRC won't outright bomb much of Taiwan but instead go straight for the presidential palace in Taipei and try to force an ROC capitulation early.

Taiwan is not Somalia. It's a fairly advanced country with a fairly good military (comparing to its size).

> I think they're counting on the ruling class / landowners / capitalists to pressure the government to capitulate at fear of property destruction, which I also expect to be in line with reality. Doing capitalism in a country like taiwan is better than in the PRC, but doing it in the PRC is better than not being able to do it at all because all your assets were obliterated.

China will do worse than Russia. People in Ukraine had reasons to join Russia, ie: their country is very corrupt and poor. I highly doubt the rich and educated Taiwanese will want to join the CPC.

> I don't think any of this will come to pass though because I, like most people in Taiwan (including the usa consulate staff), believe the possibility of invasion is slim.

The possibility is very slim at the moment. Of course, timing matter. In the future, it could go both ways. That will depend on the status of the US, China and Taiwan itself.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by komali2 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @12:56AM (#34474768)
> Taiwan is not Somalia. It's a fairly advanced country with a fairly good military (comparing to its size).

Yes, I live here, all of my friends have served in the military. They believe a likely strategy is gun boats coming up the river for the presidential palace.

BTW, the military is quite effective, but numbers about size usually include the conscripted, who are basically useless as soldiers as they get to shoot a gun maybe once during conscription and spend most of their time sweeping rocks because boomer officers stuck at conscript boot camp have outdated and ageist ideas about discipline and take out their resentment on the conscripts.

From my time in the PRC the same is true for pla conscripts.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by drran on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:08AM (#34474838)
People in Ukraine had reasons to break out of Jail of Nations, but I see no single reason to join RF instead of EU and NATO. Most Slavic nations are already in EU, except Ukraine and Belarus. Why Ukraine should join former Golden Horde?
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by morpheos137 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:35AM (#34474977)
How deluded by propaganda do people need to believe that Russia is the former Golden Horde.

Here is some education. Ukraine and Russia share a common, ethnic, linguistic and cultural heritage. They also share a common political heritage with the name of the country meaning borderland (of Russia). In fact Ukraine was no more an independent country than Wales until about 30 years ago.

While Russia economically recovered in the early 2000s ukraine stagnated, in part due to pervasive corruption.

Finally in 2014 the elected president of Ukraine was illegally driven out by a mob fired up by pie in the sky hopes of prosperity in the EU / Nato fold.

Now almost a decade later Ukraine is neither in the EU nor NATO and its territory has been ravaged by war.

Meanwhile a former comedian whose first language is Russian is president.

Is this what winning looks like?

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by jcranmer on Sunday January 22, 2023 @02:02AM (#34475099)
> While Russia economically recovered in the early 2000s ukraine stagnated, in part due to pervasive corruption.

That economic recovery was largely driven by a commodities boom, and the economic benefits of such are poorly distributed among Russians. That is to say, when you look at the poorer, rural sections of the country, the Ukrainians have done much better post-USSR than Russians have.

> Is this what winning looks like?

Well, in almost a year of war, Russia has managed to only temporarily capture one major city, failed to capture two more major cities (one of which is literally a day's march away from the border, and the other one only thrice as far). It also lost a flagship (to someone who doesn't really have a navy!), and the pride project in Crimea was put out of commission by Ukraine and still hasn't been restored for satisfactory military usage. Let's not forget the sheer number of officers and seasoned soldiers who are now dead.

In wider political ramifications, the non-aligned neighbors near it have suddenly decided that it is in their interest to join an opposing alliance. Russia's proxies in other countries have been undercut, but especially in Ukraine where pro-Russia sentiment has collapsed from about on par with pro-Western sentiment to near nonexistence. The largest customer of its primary export is planning on never buying from them ever again.

In contrast to all of that, yes, Ukraine is winning.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by Mikeb85 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @02:51AM (#34475321)
I see Russian propaganda is evolving...

Ukrainian language is closer to Czech and Slovak than to Russian. Ukrainian culture is closer to Polish and Slovak culture than Russian.

> They also share a common political heritage with the name of the country meaning borderland (of Russia)

"Kraj" means land or country. Borderland would be "O-krajina". Meanwhile Ukraine is "U-kraijina". Cyrillic О vs У.

The first historic mention of "Ukrajina" also predates Moscow and the Russian Empire.

And you want to talk democracy, Ukraine has had 5 presidents since Putin came to power. Versus 1 in Belarus and 1.5 in Russia (Medvedev counts as half).

> Now almost a decade later Ukraine is neither in the EU nor NATO and its territory has been ravaged by war.

That was Russia's doing not Ukraine's. This is some serious blame the victim mentality. No one made Russia invade.

And if Ukraine would rather suffer through a war than Russian occupation maybe that should be a sign of just how shitty Russia is...

Sorry but no one wants to be in the Russian world. Telling that your only allies are North Korea and Iran and that Lukashenko has even low-key sabotaged your invasion and refused to directly help...

I'm currently in the Czech Republic and I can tell you, everyone here would go to war before becoming a Russian sattelite again... Since joining the EU, this country has become quite rich. Higher GDP per capita and wages than Portugal. Almost at Spain's level. Versus Russia, Ukraine and Belarus being very poor... As for sentiment on Ukraine, there's Ukrainian flags absolutely everywhere. Ukrainian people too. They're even about to elect a former general and NATO Chairman as president...

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by inkyoto on Sunday January 22, 2023 @04:53AM (#34475869)
With all due respect, historical and linguistic assertions are borderline nonsense.

> Ukrainian language is closer to Czech and Slovak than to Russian. Ukrainian culture is closer to Polish and Slovak culture than Russian.

Which Ukrainian language? Western Ukrainian is closer to Polish due to a historical affiliation with and influence of the medieval Polish Kingdom first and the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth later. Eastern Ukrainian is most likely closest to the Ruthenian language. Both are independent and separate developments from the Russian language. Modern Standard Ukrainian is a fairly recent linguistic development and is an amalgamation of multiple branches of Ukrainian languages that took place throughout the course of the 19th century as the result of the almost clandestine work of many Ukrainian scholars during the times of the late Russian Empire.

> "Kraj" means land or country. Borderland would be "O-krajina". Meanwhile Ukraine is "U-kraijina". Cyrillic О vs У.

«kraj» has descended from a Proto-Slavic of *krajь. It can mean «region», «country» or «land», but it can also mean «outskirt», «edge» or «fringe». See https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/край for the explanation. "O-krajina" that you are citing can mean «fringe» or «edge» but not «borderland».

Semantically, «у» is a preposition that governs the genitive noun case and is translated as «at» or «by» into English in this and similar contexts, which means that «Ukraine» can also be translated as «at the edge/fringe/outskirt» or «by the edge», and such a meaning is shared across multiple East Slavic languages. See «Old East Slavic» section, the first meaning in https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/у for the explanation.

Whether «Ukraine» means «in the land/country» or «at/by the edge/fringe» has been hotly debated (oftentimes fuelled by nationalistic or political rhetoric from both, Russian and Ukrainian, sides) with no conclusive agreement having ever been reached.

> The first historic mention of "Ukrajina" also predates Moscow and the Russian Empire.

The historical name of Ukraine is «Ruthenia» in Western sources as it was the name it was known by to Papal legates in early mediaeval times, and is «Princedom (kingdom in English sources) of Galicia–Volhynia» in local sources. When exactly «Ukraina» emerged as the current name is still not very clear.

Princedom/Kingdom of Galicia–Volhynia emerged after the collapse of the Kievan Rus' in the aftermath of the Mongolian invasion and existed for slightly over a century until the Polish Kingdom forcibly absorbed it into Catholic Poland.

Moscow was founded in 1147 and was a backwater town for quite some time, whereas Princedom of Galicia–Volhynia came into existence almost a century later. Both existed in parallel and independently of each other.

These are plain and bland historical and linguistic facts, and there is no need to distort them with homebrewn armchair theories.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by Mikeb85 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @05:44AM (#34476086)
A lot of words to repeat Russian propaganda.

There was far more concerted Russification of Ukraine than Polish-ification...

The Ukrainian language is the Ukrainian language, what's spoken in the east is considered a Creole that's a combination of Russian and Ukrainian due to, well, centuries of Russification.

> «kraj» has descended from a Proto-Slavic of *krajь. It can mean «region», «country» or «land»,

Obviously. Every second place here is called "X Kraj". Literally the word used for region still.

> O-krajina" that you are citing can mean «fringe» or «edge» but not «borderland».

Okraj literally means border but it doesn't really matter, edge and border are literally the same thing in English. Dunno why you are insinuating it's different.

Language does evolve though, now there's different words (and more words) for edge, border, suburb, periphery, etc...

It's not clear that Kraj on it's own was "edge" or "border" though. Okraj definitely was however

> Moscow was founded in 1147

So I got one date wrong (I was thinking of Moscow's rise as an actual city state post-Mongol yoke, not the date they made a fort in a swamp especially since the first town was completely destroyed by the Mongols) but first mention of "Ukraine" is 1187. Long before the Russian Empire, before the Mongol invasions, long before Moscow was anything more than a small fort.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by inkyoto on Sunday January 22, 2023 @07:56AM (#34476902)
> A lot of words to repeat Russian propaganda.

Duly noted. Ignorance, the lack of historical as well as linguistic knowledge, and the lack of reputable and verifiable counterpoints on your behalf is now officialy Russian propaganda.

> The Ukrainian language is the Ukrainian language, what's spoken in the east is considered a Creole that's a combination of Russian and Ukrainian due to, well, centuries of Russification.

Please cease and desist. The prior statement had specifically called out the fact that Ukrainian has most likely descended – and please do yourself a favour to read it thrice – from the Ruthenian language which was an independent and a separate lingustic development and a separate language from the not yet existing Russian language, however with influences from Polish in what we now know as Western Ukraine. Ukranian being an insignificant dialect of Russian is the Russian Empire time propaganda. I fail to comprehend why you have chosen to contort previously stated facts so blatantly and obviously.

> Obviously. Every second place here is called "X Kraj". Literally the word used for region still.

> Okraj literally means border but it doesn't really matter, edge and border are literally the same thing in English. Dunno why you are insinuating it's different.

I beseech you to allow me to graciously lift the veil of your linguistic confusion. Consider the following examples (languages are listed out strictly in the alphabetical order):

Example 1:

English: the city fringe

Czech: okraj města

Polish: obrzeża miasta

Russian: окраина города (okraina goroda)

Slovak: okraj mesta

Ukrainian: околиця міста (okolycja mista)

Example 2:

English: at the city fringe / at the outskirts of the city

Czech: na okraji města

Polish: na obrzeżach miasta

Russian: на краю города (na kraju goroda)

Slovak: na okraji mesta

Ukrainian: на околиці міста (na okolyci mista)

Example 3:

English: the edge of the world

Czech: okraj světa

Polish: kraniec świata

Russian: край света (metaphorical or archaic) / край земли (kraj sveta / kraj zemli)

Slovak: okraj sveta

Ukrainian: краю світу (kraju svitu)

Example 4:

English: at the edge of the bed

Czech: na okraji postele

Polish: na skraju łóżka

Russian: на краю кровати / на краю постели (na kraju krovati / na kraju posteli)

Slovak: na okraji postele

Ukrainian: на краю ліжка (na kraju ližka)

What is obvious is that in some «kraj» related examples Russian is closer to Czech and Slovak with Ukrainian and Polish being closer to each other rather than Ukrainian being closer to Czech or Slovak (which is utter nonsense from both, historical and linguistic, points of view. But it won't convince you since Czech, Polish, Slovak and Ukranian are all Russian propaganda and are all admittedly Creole languages).

Should you have reputable lingustic counterpoints that can be cross-referenced, please provide them.

> So I got one date wrong […]

You have got too many things wrong, and you have to own up to it, stop spouting nonsense and admit to misrepresenting facts either out of sheer ignorance, or pushing your own personal agenda, or expressing a unsubstantiated strong opinion, or merely possessing a complete lack of knowledge on the subject. Most likely a combination thereof.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by Mikeb85 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @09:28AM (#34477672)
"the figures from there suggest that Ukrainian inherent intelligibility of Russian is close to zero."

When they found a Ukrainian population that hadn't been given education in Russian mutual intelligibility was next to zero. And Ukrainian and Russian split around 800 years ago...

From: https://www.academia.edu/4080349/Mutual_Intelligibility_of_L...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Name_of_Ukraine

On the name, including various discussions about the meaning of "Kraj".

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by inkyoto on Sunday January 22, 2023 @10:19AM (#34478160)
Ignorance is a bliss, and your linguistic and historical ignorance is admirable as well as it continues to push new limits.

Russian, as a distinct language, is a fairly recent historical development that is slightly over 400 years old, and dates back to the end of Times of Troubles and the end of the Polish–Muscovite War of 1609–1618 when Catholic Poland – after sacking Moscow and keeping it for two years under its rule – eventually ceased to be a threat. Old Ukrainian, as another distinct language, predates the emergence of Russian by a few centuries (if we are to trace its origins back to the Ruthenian language). Granted, it is all Russian propaganda to you nevertheless.

> "… Ukrainian inherent intelligibility of Russian is close to zero."

False. Previously cited, non-representative, examples point to varying degrees of the mutual intelligibility amongst Czech, Polish, Russian, Slovakian and Ukranian. Intellligibility hovers at the 50% level at least. So, no, it is not zero. You are yet to provide a single credible example other than handwaving and vacuous references to a pub style banter.

> On the name, including various discussions about the meaning of "Kraj". And the fact that "Krai" is still a type of division of land in Russia.

Also false. It is one of the many meanings, and you are persevering with twisting facts to suit your own narrative. I have pointed to sources in the Old Ukrainian dating back to 1496 and 1667 in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34471179#34477841, both of which state otherwise. Namely, that «ОУКРАИНА» and «ВКРАИНА» mean [at] «the fringe», «outskirts» or «the edge» (i.e. «окраїна»). You have provided no credible sources to back up your counterpoints so far.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by Mikeb85 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @10:28AM (#34478253)
> Old Ukrainian, as another distinct language, predates the emergence of Russian by a few centuries (if we are to trace its origins back to the Ruthenian language). Granted, it is all Russian propaganda to you nevertheless.

You do realize that Russian propaganda and various Slavic family language "trees" claim Ukrainian came from Russian, right? Thanks for proving my point.

> False. Previously cited, non-representative, examples point to varying degrees of the mutual intelligibility amongst Czech, Polish, Russian, Slovakian and Ukranian. Intellligibility hovers at the 50% level at least. So, no, it is not zero. You are yet to provide a single credible example other than handwaving and vacuous references to a pub style banter.

Did you even read my source? Obviously not.

It controls for the fact many of those subjects were taught Russian in school skewing results and controls for this by selecting populations with no education in Russian.

> Namely, that «ОУКРАИНА» and «ВКРАИНА» mean [at] «the fringe», «outskirts» or «the edge» (i.e. «окраїна»). You have provided no credible sources to back up your counterpoints so far.

You're literally proving my point because neither of those words are the same word as Україна...

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by inkyoto on Sunday January 22, 2023 @11:21AM (#34478903)
What exactly is the credibility of Robert Lindsay who describes themselves as:

«BA Journalism […] teaching credential. Political activist, linguist, amateur cold case murders sleuth, psychological counselor (!), long-time K-12 schoolteacher. Former paralegal, freelance journalist, magazine editor, field linguist, and cultural anthropologist. Founder of the Alt Left political movement. Interviewed on radio multiple times. Multiple offers to be on TV and in movies […]».

As well as describing the study method in the «Method» section on p.2:

«First, a Net search was done of forums where speakers of Slavic languages were discussing how much of other Slavic languages and lects they understand»

Also in the «Limitations» section on p. 5:

«The first limitation in this study is that it relies heavily on self-reports from native speakers on how much they understand of the other language. Although this would seem to be an excellent way to study this question, the problem is that speaker reports can be off by quite a bit».

Nevertheless. The paper reports the following results:

(Ukrainian is not clearly defined here, so I assume Standard Ukrainian is meant) «Ukrainian: Oral intelligibility: 90% of Balachka, 85% of Eastern Ukrainian, Transcarpathian Rusyn and Surzyk; 75% of Belarussian, 72% of Podlachian, 67% of Lemko Rusyn, 50% of Russian, 45% of Eastern Slovak, 40% of Polish, 35% of Russian, 25% of Kashubian, 20% of Slovak and Serbo-Croatian, and 12% of Hutsul Rusyn. Written intelligibility: 90% of Slovak, 85% of Russian, 60% of Bulgarian, and 50% of Polish».

Reported oral intelligibility of Russian by Ukrainians is cited at 50% followed by 35% in the same sentence and stands at 85% for written Russian. Even for such highly questionable numbers (50 and 35 – being stated merely a few words apart) and a more reassuring 85% figure, the result is clearly not «… Ukrainian inherent intelligibility of Russian is close to zero».

«Canadian Ukrainian: Oral intelligibility: 5% of Russian».

I am not sure what Canadian Ukrainian is.

«Western Ukrainian: Oral intelligibility: 79% of Lemko Rusyn, 75% of Rusyn, 60% of Eastern Ukrainian, 57% of Polish and Eastern Slovak, 40% of Slovak, and 30% of Russian».

30% intelligibility of spoken Russian. Sufficiently not a zero.

«Eastern Ukrainian: Oral intelligibility: 85% of Ukrainian, 70% of Russian, and 60% of Western Ukrainian».

Stands at 70% of the intelligibility for the spoken Russian. Not close to zero by any definition.

It also inadvertently back up the fact that Eastern and Western Ukrainian are sufficiently distinct from each other.

Since you seem to have a trouble reading in general, and do not appear to have read the only (questionable) source you have provided so far, it is a moot point to carry on with the discourse, for there is none to be had. Enjoy your fermented beverage and your crack with mates down at the pub.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by Mikeb85 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @11:43AM (#34479169)
> I am not sure what Canadian Ukrainian is.

Hahaha are you fucking serious. It's written there. There's also Google.

> It is often said that Ukrainian and Russian are intelligible with each other or even that they are the same language. This view is false and especially the latter statement is a product of Russian nationalism. Ukrainians can understand Russian better than the other way around, but this is complicated by very heavy bilingual learning on the part of Ukrainians. Ukrainian intelligibility of Russian is hard to measure, as Russian is widely spoken as a second language in Ukraine, and even if they don't speak it, Ukrainians have massive exposure to the language. The situation of Russian in Ukraine is similar to the role of Czech in Slovakia. Most Ukrainian speakers who do not speak Russian are in Canada. These speakers say they do not understand Russian at all. Therefore, inherent Ukrainian-Russian intelligibility may be much lower than as generally thought, and the higher numbers from Ukrainians in Ukraine must be due to bilingual learning and heavy exposure to Russian. The best place to study the inherent MI of these languages is among Ukrainian speakers in Canada, and the figures from there suggest that Ukrainian inherent intelligibility of Russian is close to zero.

Anyhow there's a significant amount of Ukrainian speakers in Canada who immigrated from before WWI through WW2. The study cites them since there's the only large Ukrainian-speaking group that isn't exposed to the Russian language.

Anyhow you're obviously just a Russian troll with too much time. Your sources don't show what you think they show and all you can do it repeat insults.

Also maybe read the section on the Russian language - lots of Turkic, French and German loan words. Only 10% of the same vocabulary as Ukrainian...

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by dang on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:32PM (#34492947)
Enough is enough. Since you've broken the site guidelines repeatedly and egregiously in this thread, and have been ignoring our requests to stop for yours, I've banned the account.

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30570056 (March 2022)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29477110 (Dec 2021)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29213642 (Nov 2021)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20671158 (Aug 2019)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15379419 (Oct 2017)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10819494 (Dec 2015)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10692593 (Dec 2015)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9886979 (July 2015)

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by Mikeb85 on Monday January 23, 2023 @02:00PM (#34493317)
Thanks but you guys are so obsessed with "civil discourse" and allowing "both sides" this place is becoming overrun with Russian trolls who simply recycle accounts. Sorry I can't help not replying to them, especially when they're far less civil.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by dang on Monday January 23, 2023 @02:33PM (#34493757)
Internet users frequently make grandiose claims about trolls, bots, foreign agents, astroturfing, etc. about accounts they simply disagree with. If you have specific links, I'd be happy to take a look. When we find accounts abusing HN, we ban them—and the threshold for banning gets lower quickly when it's a serial abuser. But someone else having an opposing view to yours is obviously not an abuse.

Btw, if you can find a case in the last, say, 3 years where I've used the word "civil" in articulating HN's rules, I'd like to see it. We left that behind a long time ago.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by dang on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:24PM (#34492828)
> Since you seem to have a trouble reading in general, and do not appear to have read the only (questionable) source you have provided so far, it is a moot point to carry on with the discourse, for there is none to be had. Enjoy your fermented beverage and your crack with mates down at the pub.

Your comments in this thread have broken the site guidelines so badly that this is easily across the line at which we ban accounts. I'm not going to ban you right now because you've also posted good comments. But if you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.

Among other things, please avoid nationalistic flamewar in the future. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by dang on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:23PM (#34492805)
Name-calling and personal attacks are not allowed here, and doubly not on divisive topics.

You can make your substantive points without stooping to that, so please do.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Edit: please see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34492828 also. We have to ban accounts that abuse HN the way you have done in this thread. I don't want to ban you, so we need you not to do this again.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by morpheos137 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @08:30AM (#34477147)
>I'm currently in the Czech Republic and I can tell you, everyone here would go to war before becoming a Russian sattelite again... Since joining the EU, this country has become quite rich. Higher GDP per capita and wages than Portugal. Almost at Spain's level. Versus Russia, Ukraine and Belarus being very poor... As for sentiment on Ukraine, there's Ukrainian flags absolutely everywhere. Ukrainian people too. They're even about to elect a former general and NATO Chairman as president

See this massively undermine your own argument. I.e. that Ukrainians are eager to align with the west to protect their supposed distinct nationality vs. they are greedy to get a piece of Western economic prosperity (the true reason).

However there are some problems with this cargo cult mentality.

1. Ukrainians can just move to the west, it has never been easier,and leave their steppes to Russians. In fact this is what's happening.

2. The most industrialized and resource rich portion of Ukraine is so called Novo Russia (New Russia) and it is in the east. Meanwhile the most nationalistic region of Ukraine, in the West in Galicia, was formerly the poorest part of the Austro-Hungarian empire so comparisons to Czech republic for example are unfounded.

3. There is no evidence that Russia wants to reassert itself over eastern Europe vs prevent expansion of Galician zealots east (you may call them Banderites or neofascists because that is what they are). These people have made up a national myth where somehow they are the true Russians.

Most of the black sea coast including crimea were under turkish dominion until the formation of cossacks and the incorporation of the territory into Russia. That was something like 200 years ago. Until 1990 the territory was filled with people who considered themselves the same as Russians including young Zelensky, whose first language is Russian.

The city of Donetsk, for example, was founded as a steel town in the Russian Empire, by an Englishman, Hughes, and populated by Russians.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by Mikeb85 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @09:54AM (#34477918)
> See this massively undermine your own argument. I.e. that Ukrainians are eager to align with the west to protect their supposed distinct nationality vs. they are greedy to get a piece of Western economic prosperity (the true reason).

Why not both? Let's face it, the Russian world is shit. Both in terms of freedom and prosperity. Everyone wants freedom and prosperity, calling Ukrainians "greedy" for it is simply insulting.

> There is no evidence that Russia wants to reassert itself over eastern Europe

Just listen to what the Russians actually say... That's the evidence, they say it themselves that they want to reassert their rule over everything that was previously "Russian".

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by jcranmer on Sunday January 22, 2023 @11:50AM (#34479255)
> people who considered themselves the same as Russians including young Zelensky, whose first language is Russian.

I think this is one thing that Russians are incredibly confused by: Russian-speaking does not imply that someone sees themself as Russian. The great analogy here is in Ireland: the vast majority of Irish are English-speaking monoglots, not Irish-speaking. And yet the Irish do not want to be part of Britain, and fought several rather violent conflicts towards that end. In Ukraine right now, Russian-speakers are switching to speaking Ukrainian to emphasize the degree to which they do not want to be seen as Russian.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by dang on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:30PM (#34492920)
We've had to ask you many times to avoid political and nationalistic flamewar on this site. You're still doing it, badly. If you keep doing it we will ban you.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Edit: you've even managed to foment religious flamewar in another thread simultaneously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34480562.

Edit 2: your other comments in this thread have been so abusive that I can no longer justify not banning you. I've therefore banned the account. Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34492947.

Since this is usually the point at which someone with strong ideological/nationalistic views usually says "you're just banning me because you're against me", I suppose I'll add that (1) I have no idea which side you're on—I don't scan comments that way; (2) we enforce these rules regardless of what people are arguing for or against; and (3) you've crossed the line countless times in the past and I specifically held off banning you—for years actually. Eventually the assumption of good faith just no longer holds up under this degree of abuse.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by drran on Sunday January 22, 2023 @03:50AM (#34475570)
> Ukraine and Russia share a common, ethnic, linguistic and cultural heritage.

Ukraine is the mix of Slavs and historic Russians (русичи) (from the town of Russia, now Old Russa, on Russia river, now Porussia river). "Russians" from Russian Federations are members of Russian orthodox church or citizens of Russian Federation. There was a split between "Polish" (Catholics) and "Russian" (Eastern Orthodox) members in Ukraine a few centuries ago.

> They also share a common political heritage with the name of the country meaning borderland (of Russia).

Nope. Ukraine is the original Russia, now called Kievan Rus by RF. "Ukraine" share same word root with such words as "ukryttia" (shelter), "ukriplennia" (reinforced structure). Modern equivalent world for "ukraine" is "ukripraion" (reinforced area of defense). Poland built multiple areas of defense ("ukraines") on their eastern border, so the whole area got name "Ukraine".

> In fact Ukraine was no more an independent country than Wales until about 30 years ago.

Bohdan Khmelnytskyi was Hetman of Ukraine since 1654, almost century before Russian Empire was created in 1721.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by morpheos137 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @08:07AM (#34476992)
Ukrainian ethnogenesis is happening in real time. If that is worth fighting for is up to Ukrainians and their native Russian speaking president.

However to portray it as something with a long history is fundamentally dishonest.

It is somewhat similar to the American revolution where people with common language and history rebelled against their parent nation and over time formed a new national identity of their own.

Bohdan Khmelynytski was a medieval peasant warlord. He can only be considered a founder of the Ukrainian nation in retrospect. At his time the main mission of his calvary was slaughtering poles and jews unfortunate enough to live in territory he controlled, as a kind of precursor to NAZI death squads several centuries later.

It is a historical fact that Ukraine and Russia are two branches of the same tree and are essentially the same ethnicity speaking different but mostly mutually intelligible dialects.

I mean Zelensky (who Khmelnytskyi would have killed) speaks Russian as his first language.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by inkyoto on Sunday January 22, 2023 @09:47AM (#34477841)
> Nope. Ukraine is the original Russia, now called Kievan Rus by RF.

False. As per historical findings, the current scientific consensus is that the origins of the Rus people (who ruled Kyiv/Kiev/Kievan Rus') are traced back to Norsemen from modern Sweden. As early as from Hellquist (published in 1922), p. 668 Ryssland, in Swedish (https://archive.org/details/svensketymologis00hell/page/668/...):

ryss (i.e. Rus'), folkslagsnamn, i ä. sv. ofta även rysse såsom alltjämt i Finnland; ännu Karl XII skriver rytzen, fsv. rysser, ryz, ryze, ryza — fno. ruzzar plur., da. russer, mlty. ruze, fhty. ruz(o), mhty. ruz (ty. russe) o. riuze (kvarlevan de i namnet på det forna tyska småfursten dömet Reuss, efter tillnamnet på regenthusets stamfader) — samtliga hty. former med sljud; av slav. rusi el. rus (enl. Ekblom kvar i en mängd ortnamn i guvernementet Novgorod m. m.; jfr ry. russkij, plur. russkije), varav mgrek. ros. Enl. vanlig uppfattning från fin. Ruolsi, Sverige, svensk, jfr ruoisalainen, svensk, i sin tur sannol., enl. Thomsen m. fl., till fsv. röper, rodd, ledung m. m., el. det därmed identiska fsv. Röpin, Roslagen o. angränsande delar av östkusten, varifrån en stor del vikingar o. nylnggare kommo. — De finska o. ryska formerna meds visa hän på en fsv. sammans. röp(r)s- (jfr Roslagen, ro spigg, ävensom Rrate Ant. tidskr. XX. 3: 30 f.) växl. med röpa(r)- i fsv. röparum, röparaitter. — Ryssland var in på 1000-t. ett svenskt skatteland. — Helt annorlunda t. ex. Knauer senast i IF 31: 67 f.: av ett Rusa, forntida namn på Volga; alltså: Volga-folk (jfr under bulgar). Osannolikt. — Härtill: Ryssland, fsv. Ryzaland. — Jfr ryss lä der.

Abbreviations are difficult to read, but this appears to be a recap:

(Swedish): «… av slav. rusi el. rus (enl. Ekblom kvar i en mängd ortnamn i guvernementet Novgorod m. m.; jfr ry. russkij, plur. russkije), varav mgrek. ros. Enl. vanlig uppfattning från fin. Ruolsi, Sverige, svensk, jfr ruoisalainen, svensk, i sin tur sannol., enl. Thomsen m. fl., till fsv. röper, rodd, ledung m. m., el. det därmed identiska fsv. Röpin, Roslagen o. angränsande delar av östkusten, varifrån en stor del vikingar o. nylnggare kommo …»

(English): «… of Slavic Rusi and likewise Rus (according to Ekblom remains in a number of place names in the governorate of Novgorod, etc.; cf. ry. russkij, plur. russkije), of which mgr. Rose. According to common perception from Finnish «Ruolsi», Sweden, Swedish, cf. «ruoisalainen», Swedish, in turn sannol., acc. Thomsen et al., to fsv. roper, rowing, lead, etc., etc. the thus identical fsv. Röpin, Roslagen and neighboring parts of the east coast, from where a large number of Vikings and newcomers came …».

«neighboring parts of the east coast, from where a large number of Vikings and newcomers came…» appears to be the cinch.

> "Ukraine" share same word root with such words as "ukryttia" (shelter), "ukriplennia" (reinforced structure). Modern equivalent world for "ukraine" is "ukripraion" (reinforced area of defense). Poland built multiple areas of defense ("ukraines") on their eastern border, so the whole area got name "Ukraine".

Also false. Existing historical and linguistic evidence do not support it:

1. From Tymchenko, E. K., editor (published in 1930, https://archive.org/details/staroukr2/page/474/mode/1up?view...), “вкраина; украина”, in Історичний словник українського язика [Historical Dictionary of the Ukrainian Language] (in Ukrainian), volume 1: notebook 1: А – Г, Kharkiv, Kyiv: State Publishing House of Ukraine, page 262:

«ОУКРАИНА ж. (1) (погранична територія) окраїна: ажь богь дасть по(д)ближаємься та(м) по(д) оукраини к тьімь нашимь паньствомь и огьтоуль дасть богь виправимь и шлємь до тебе нши(х) пословь о прия(з)ни и о мироу (б. м. н., 1496 ПДСВВ)»

(dated back to the year of 1496, an approximate translation): «ОУКРАИНА» – (1) (a border territory – «погранична територія») «the fringe» / «outskirts» / «the edge» («окраїна»): as God giveth [a chance] to approach «the edge» / «the fringe» of [the land] («оукраини») of those of our overloards (note the use of a Polish word – «паньствомь») and [огьтоуль (?)] giveth to God to remedie (remedy, fix) and [giveth] the helm to you to hear our words (or, speech) of accceptance and peace».

2. From Hrynchyshyn, D. H., editor (published in 1978, https://archive.org/details/tymch1930/page/262/mode/1up?view...), “оукраина”, in Словник староукраїнської мови XIV–XV ст. [Dictionary of the Old Ukrainian Language of the 14ᵗʰ–15ᵗʰ cc.] (in Ukrainian), volume 2: Н – Ѳ, Kyiv: Naukova Dumka, page 474:

ВКРАИНА, рж. Див. Украйна. XVI. Ино тими рази на вкраинахь оть татар многим таковая ся пригода и шкода пригожаєть Арх. ЮЗР. VIII, IV, 172 (1501). – (an approximate translation) «on those occasions at fringes (borderlands / edges – «вкраинахь») will be becoming useful and [шкода] will become useful (?)». The context is incomplete, therefore it is difficult to make sense out of it. The reference dates back to 1501.

ХУІI. Не єдно царство, князетво, земля, вкраина, повіть, вь жалоеньїх и лідво значньїхь руинахь зостають поверженьї Ак. ЗР. V, 141 (1667) – (an approximate translation) «Not a single kingdom, or a princedom, or a land, or a borderland («вкраина»), повіть (?), the granted [people] and important people are found defeated». The reference dates back to 1667.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by drran on Sunday January 22, 2023 @03:49PM (#34482070)
> False. As per historical findings, the current scientific consensus is that the origins of the Rus people (who ruled Kyiv/Kiev/Kievan Rus') are traced back to Norsemen from modern Sweden.

Before Plague of Justinian, original Russia (Русся) lived in the town of Russia. After the start of plague, they abandoned their town and spread over large territory, from Caspian Sea to Spain, so, after 541, original Russians can be traced back to a lot of places.

> Also false. Existing historical and linguistic evidence do not support it

Typical Russian style of discussion. Here is the evidence: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guillaume_Le_Vasseur_de_Beaupl...

> ВКРАИНА, рж. Див. Украйна. XVI. Ино тими рази на вкраинахь оть татар многим таковая ся пригода и шкода пригожаєть Арх. ЮЗР. VIII, IV, 172 (1501). – (an approximate translation) «on those occasions at fringes (borderlands / edges – «вкраинахь») will be becoming useful and [шкода] will become useful (?)». The context is incomplete, therefore it is difficult to make sense out of it. The reference dates back to 1501.

I'm the native speaker. You are just lying there. It's clearly written, "Vkraine, See Ukraine. ...".

Also, your attempts to convince that native speakers don't know the meaning of the word are pathetic.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plague_of_Justinian

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by dang on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:29PM (#34492895)
We've banned you for nationalistic flamewar before and have asked you repeatedly to stop. Since you're still abusing HN in this way, I've banned the account. Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with.

These rules apply regardless of how right your side is or you feel it is.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by dang on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:30PM (#34492908)
Please don't take HN threads further into nationalistic flamewar, regardless of how wrong someone is or you feel they are. This hell is not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by dang on Monday January 23, 2023 @01:29PM (#34492898)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34474658.

I've also banned your account for repeatedly abusing HN with nationalistic flamewar. Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34492895.

The flamewar you started (and perpetuated) here is among the worst I've ever seen. That's seriously not ok, regardless of how right your cause is or you feel it is.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by mrtksn on Sunday January 22, 2023 @12:44AM (#34474707)
> instead go straight for the presidential palace in Taipei

Will that work if the politicians work from home?

On the recent Brazilian uprising, when the election losers stormed the capital they found out that it is a holiday and there’s no some special object in the government buildings which makes you the new leader once you physically obtain it.

All they ended up doing was vandalism.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by jhou2 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:15AM (#34474879)
China is Taiwan's largest trading partner. 42% of Taiwan exports go to China and Hong Kong. 22% of Taiwan imports are from China. Around 200,000 to 400,000 Taiwanese work in China. China doesn't need to militarily invade Taiwan. Like Hong Kong, it can just wait until the economic reality is that Taiwan is already a vassal state dependent on China. At that point, it can move military troops into Taiwan if needed. There won't be a fight, because at that point, the USA will already be far more darkly insular.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by kmonsen on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:24AM (#34474927)
Sure the US is turning insular, the only thing all politicians are on is that bribery is good and China is the main enemy. Which still means that Taiwan will be defended.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by qwezxcrty on Sunday January 22, 2023 @06:11AM (#34476254)
China is the largest trade partner of many other countries, why only Taiwan worry about being turned into a vassal state?

The majority of population in Taiwan is Han Chinese, using almost the same language as mainland China. It's not surprising that many of them will like to work on the other side of strait if there are good opportunities. People from mainland China too, especially for people in Fujian and Guangdong.

And eventually, hypothetically, people in Taiwan prefer and choose to unite with mainland China, maybe after PRC evolved into something more ideologically acceptable, I see more good than issues.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by komali2 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @08:30AM (#34477145)
This is an outdated viewpoint that doesn't take into account the newer generations of Taiwanese who are developing a distinctly anti Chinese identity and rejecting what older people call "Han" (華人). The younger generations are leaning into and exploring the diverse heritage of the island itself, including by going out of their way to learn indigenous languages and incorporate aspects of indigenous culture.

Taiwanese are also inventing their culture from whole cloth, forming cultural alliances named cute things like "the bubble tea alliance" in a direct oppositional effort against CPC cultural imperialism that centers around han supremacy.

Every year that goes by the presumptive and han supremacist viewpoint that "Chinese is Chinese" evaporates further in Taiwan. Every day 台灣中文 diverges further from 普通話; they are now classified by linguists as separate forms of Mandarin entirely (not just because of the character set. Obviously the languages are mutually intelligible though).

It's worth pointing out that "use the same language" is kinda silly to say in either case. Though of course most PRC speak Mandarin, and most Taiwanese speak Taiwanese Mandarin, both nations are filled with bi and trilingual people speaking all sorts of dialects.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by qwezxcrty on Sunday January 22, 2023 @09:44AM (#34477816)
I agree to some extent, especially with the newer generation. I still hold the probably old school view point, that believe the separation of China and Taiwan is mostly a political problem caused by ideological differences. (And personally hoping that PRC can get democracy and then China and Taiwan can reunite in some form).

But I'd like to point out PRC also have more than Han Chinese. Even myself doesn't fit in the narrow sense Han (汉). There are all sorts of dialects and indigenous local culture. The difference of language and culture within PRC can be even bigger than the difference across the strait (for example, I almost cannot understand 粤语 but have zero problem talking to Taiwanese colleagues in our most native language).

I routinely visit Taiwan based websites, reading 繁体/正体中文 and post in 简体中文, and apparently have almost no difficulty getting myself and Taiwanese understood.

By the way, you mentioned bubble tea... There are so many bubble tea shops in mainland China, some invested by Taiwanese, and I really miss them after moving to Europe.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by cm2187 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:27AM (#34474942)
On the other hand if China bombs the fabs, 1) it cripple the west's economy (and potentially its military supply chain also), 2) it ceases to makes Taiwan a strategic asset to the West since there are no more fabs to defend. To me it's a no brainer, particularly if they think Taiwan won't let them capture the fabs anyway (will destroy them before China controls the territory).
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by rocqua on Sunday January 22, 2023 @02:56AM (#34475341)
The us has poored too much of it's legitimacy into defending Taiwan to just say 'fabs gone, you are on your own'. Deterrence requires a response if lines are crossed otherwise future deterrence is much less effective.

When the fabs are still on the board, the US might be a bit more vigorous, but I doubt anyone assumes fab capacity survives a Taiwan invasion.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by cm2187 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @05:31AM (#34476032)
Probably worth remembering the "red line" episode with Obama in Syria, or Biden's initial reaction to the invasion of Ukraine, which was to impose symbolic sanctions and see how it deterred Russia in a month.

The US is perfectly capable of some symbolic protest if it doesn't want to be involved in a particular conflict.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by topspin on Tuesday January 24, 2023 @11:39PM (#34514481)
> The US is perfectly capable of some symbolic protest if it doesn't want to be involved in a particular conflict.

Indeed. A long history of declining open conflict with the Soviet Union in several theaters supports this.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by 082349872349872 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @03:05AM (#34475372)
If London is the capital of Airstrip One, then Taipei and Tokyo are the capitals of Airstrips Two and Three; it's not just the fabs.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by JumpCrisscross on Sunday January 22, 2023 @03:45AM (#34475543)
> ceases to make Taiwan a strategic asset to the West since there are no more fab to defend

PRC control of Taiwan enables blockading Japan. It’s better strategy to turn Taiwan into China’s Afghanistan than abandon it because the fabs were blown. (One can also Werner von Braun Taiwan’s technical knowledge to the American homeland, thereby turning the entire endeavour into a Pyrrhic victory for Beijing.)

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by simonh on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:37AM (#34474989)
The old ‘capture the leadership and the country will surrender in a few days’ strategy. Works every time. The thing is I’m sure the PRC Intelligence service have done analyses of what would happen if Russia invaded Ukraine, and what would happen if China invaded Taiwan. I wonder what the first one said? If the credibility of the Taiwan scenario is tied in Xi’s mind to the credibility of the first, that would give us a rough idea of the likelihood he might go for it.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by Aeolun on Sunday January 22, 2023 @02:23AM (#34475185)
Well, you can always try. You lose nothing by trying to force the opposing force to capitulate first.

Of course it helps if you don’t seriously bungle the thing.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by simonh on Sunday January 22, 2023 @10:37AM (#34478350)
You lose a ton of credibility and weaken your position domestically. No leader relished the prospect of a humiliating defeat in a war of aggression. It can be severely career and life limiting.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by rjzzleep on Sunday January 22, 2023 @02:39AM (#34475254)
Why do people still compare Taiwan with Ukraine, can people not read maps? This isn't 1996 anymore. Contrary to the US China has hypersonic missiles that the US military admitted they work.

The area Russia has captured in Ukraine is 3 or 4 times the size of Taiwan. Ukraine borders a couple of NATO countries with huge borders, has pipelines going through its country that Russia didn't touch the entire conflict. Taiwan on the other hand is 150 miles away from China and thousands of miles away from its big backers. Most of eastern Ukraine was Soviet infrastructure heavily fortified over 8 years. Taiwan on the other hand is mostly uninhabitable mountains that barely have roads going through them with very densely populated cities on the west.

Taiwan gets its oil and gas from Indonesia and most of its resources from China. Last time they did missile drills they had to stop them because the launchers failed.

China just embargoed the island for a couple of days and nothing could move in an out. China doesn't really need to do anything to win. There isn't really any scenario where this plays out in Taiwans favour. The US can't even keep up with Russia's ammunition production[1], how would it match China's manufacturing?

While the US moves their warship through the area every now and then as a show of power everyone agrees that there is no protection from hypersonic or even most supersonic missiles and that much of the US Navy are sitting ducks if there were ever a real conflict.

Biden was born in 1942 and believes the world is stuck in the 90s. It's extremely dangerous to think and act like that.

[1] https://www.military.com/daily-news/2023/01/11/navy-might-ha...

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by rocqua on Sunday January 22, 2023 @02:59AM (#34475352)
What is the range on hypersonic missles? Perhaps the defense is avoiding detection and keeping a standoff distance until you want to strike?
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by rjzzleep on Sunday January 22, 2023 @03:28AM (#34475467)
“Launch in August of nuclear-capable rocket that circled the globe took US intelligence by surprise”

Not sure where your stand-off distance would be.

https://www.ft.com/content/ba0a3cde-719b-4040-93cb-a486e1f84...

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by JumpCrisscross on Sunday January 22, 2023 @03:43AM (#34475533)
Chinese and Russian hypersonic capabilities are a money bell for American defence contractors. For cross-strait warfare, they’re irrelevant. (Conventional artillery dominates at that range.)
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by simonh on Monday January 23, 2023 @07:16AM (#34487936)
Hard for American carrier based air assets and AEGIS cruisers to help defend Taiwan if they all got killed by hypersonic missiles.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by red-iron-pine on Monday January 23, 2023 @10:54AM (#34490319)
That carriers would be sunk pretty much instantly is a given, and has been for a while now. The USN invests heavily in subs, and you don't hear much about them for a reason...
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by cpursley on Sunday January 22, 2023 @06:13AM (#34476266)
You’re getting downvoted for stating extremely uncomfortable truths. It’s not what westerners want to hear. Ignoring these objective facts is foolish and dangerous.

The reality is, with hypersonics (currently deployed), Russia or China could disable entire surface battle groups and there’s not much the US could do about it (conventionally).

I encourage everyone to break from their myopia and get a better understanding of the significant geoeconomic and power realignments going on right now.

It’s no longer 1992. We’re either headed towards global nuclear holocaust or back to a multi-polar world. May calmer heads prevail.

Two books on these topics:

- https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/40658433

- https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/52962238-principles-for-...

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by gorilla0 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @06:35AM (#34476396)
Glad to see a book by Andrei Martyanov being recommended here. I have read all three of his books. There is no reason to trust or agree with everything he writes, but unfortunately the current trend is to try and suppress any kind of discussion rather than try and understand someone's viewpoint.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by cpursley on Sunday January 22, 2023 @06:45AM (#34476452)
I also don’t agree with everything he writes or says (his YouTube channel is wildly entertaining). But I trust him more than others as he’s a pro western US citizen who has a solid background in the Soviet navy (anti shipping missile expert, I believe). He even gets into military mathematics and field manuals from time to time.

https://www.youtube.com/user/smoothieX12

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by gorilla0 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @11:44AM (#34479181)
Yes I watch all his videos. My favourite is “Some very needed comparisons”. I started doing.(just for fun) a complete under-graduate and graduate course in Mathematics in my spare time after watching this video.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by cpursley on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:48PM (#34480820)
Are you doing an online course? Funny enough, I was thinking of the same thing (or at least some mathematics basics before an online CS curriculum). I'd love recommendations if you have any. Cheers.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by gorilla0 on Sunday January 22, 2023 @06:43PM (#34483614)
No, just via books. I have a degree in mathematics which I completed 20 years ago so part of it is just recalling what I had learned. But otherwise I just bought books covering the entire curriculum - some based on Susan Rigetti’s blog post on mathematics (should be easy to search).
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by pydry on Sunday January 22, 2023 @11:56AM (#34479363)
It's neither uncomfortable nor a truth. If it were that easy Taiwan would have been conquered years ago. It isn't Ukraine - China can't just invade by rolling tanks and artillery across a field.

Its invading force will have to cross a 150 mile sea where it will be decimated before landing on one of about 4 viable landing sites where the invading force will again be decimated. Setting up supply lines would essentially be impossible. Keeping morale up when 6 out of 10 invading soldiers snuff it before reaching the island will be impossible.

US carrier groups would be useless in this war, but they're useless against anything resembling a peer competitor. US nuclear subs would tear up the invading fleet though, while Taiwanese missiles would turn the PRC economic heartland to ash.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by cpursley on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:52PM (#34480874)
We're not in disagreement.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by dirtyid on Sunday January 22, 2023 @07:32PM (#34483968)
US subs can't operate permissively in strait and increasingly within 1IC where PRC has built comprehensive seabed monitoring infra. Or that current TLAMs from SSGNs aren't performant againt even shit tier Iraqi/Russian hardware (~50% failure/interception rates), of which US has only 4 with 612 shots. Nor does TW remotely have or can stockpile enough fires to dent PRC heartland with aggressive defense budget. For reference currently US doesn't either hence rush to build up stockpiles for potentially 100,000s aimpoints most of which will be delivered by b21s 10+ years from now and that's just for some current PLA targets. Realistically PRC would destroy most of TW C4ISR in openning strikes and prevent TW from threatening invasion fleet which would make 150 mile sea transit relatively uncontested. Under such conditions - open waters where modern sensors has less noise to sort - establishing maritime logistics would be easier to protect than the land/air logisitics wagon US had to sustain for AFG. Current US vision for TW porcupine doctorine rests on TW fighting to the last man on TW soil because it's forgone PRC can land massive amounts of troops and hardware. The hope is US can disrupt this as TW buys time, not TW itself. Ultimately, PRC simply wouldn't attempt landing without securing theatre air superiority first, by the time they commit to maritime invasion, thousands of UAVs and would be droning a TW resistence reverted to Taliban tier capabilites. The other fundemental uncomfortable truth is PRC can mine TW shores and destroy airfields long term to siege island, and historically sustained sieges that prevent resupply generally end in capitulation.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by cpursley on Sunday January 22, 2023 @10:17PM (#34485075)
All this plus PRC can blockade TW and completely sink their economy (while also straining all the economies that depend on their chips). In fact, they could even do that without physically invading the island after the C4ISR hit and just wait for TW to cry Uncle and capitulate. PRC has escalation dominance in this arena and without going nuclear, I don’t see the US winning. The solution here is political compromise (as it should have been in Ukraine).
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by simonh on Sunday January 22, 2023 @10:34AM (#34478316)
They’re not the same, I even pointed out some specific ways they are different. My point is though that if (just a guess) the PRC analysis said Russia would take Ukraine easily, the fact they got that one wrong points out flaws in their approach to strategic analysis. If their strategic analysts is flawed, then that damages the credibility of any of their analyses.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by nindalf on Sunday January 22, 2023 @01:42AM (#34475013)
> I, like most people in Taiwan (including the usa consulate staff), believe the possibility of invasion is slim.

There’s a paradox here. The more everyone believes this, the worse the preparations are and the more likely invasion becomes.

For instance, the RoC Army doesn’t have enough soldiers or the right equipment and pretty much everyone is ok with this because hey, possibility of invasion is slim. They prioritise buying vanity hardware like fighter planes instead of weapons that fit a porcupine strategy like Javelin missiles. (Porcupines don’t attack but defend really well).

You correctly point out that guerrillas can fight the PLA thanks to terrain. But that would be more realistic if they had a large supply of Javelins.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by qwezxcrty on Sunday January 22, 2023 @05:51AM (#34476126)
I, born on the another side of the strait, also believe the possiblity of attacking is very slim. PRC's economy is still pretty dependant on exports to western countries. If a war with ROC start, CPC will have to pay a great cost to compensate the loss in exports.

However, for some reason I don't understand, a significant portion of people from PRC are expecting a war to happen, and ridiculously believing such a war can be good to them. Maybe CPC is playing the old game again, posturing the "pro-democracy" entities as hostile in the propaganda to gain support politically.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by powerapple on Sunday January 22, 2023 @07:22AM (#34476664)
The only reasons could make PRC take over Taiwan is: 1) Taiwan declare official independence; 2) US blocks China from semiconductors so bad, it has to take over Taiwan to gain access to technologies.

CPC knows taking over Taiwan is costly to them, and it is not a good deal. It is not like we are so much better at analyzing the situation better than professionals.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by Aeolun on Sunday January 22, 2023 @02:20AM (#34475168)
I mean, they’re expanding to Japan too. I can totally see how having at least one fab in your country would make you much less worried about choosing TSMC as your supplier, even if most of their actual capacity isn’t there.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by MomoXenosaga on Sunday January 22, 2023 @09:51AM (#34477883)
The only reason why TSMC is expanding outside Taiwan is because protectionism is back. Americans don't want to admit it though.

Hilariously it will make Taiwan more vulnerable because it makes defending the island less necessary. During the cold war the enduring question was: is America willing to commit mass suicide to protect Western Europe if the USSR invades? Thankfully we never got a definitive answer on that.

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by waste_monk on Sunday January 22, 2023 @09:57PM (#34484935)
Supply chain security != protectionism. Losing access to chips would be an existential threat for most nations.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by mytailorisrich on Sunday January 22, 2023 @04:34AM (#34475765)
I suspect their investments in the US are also simply because the US asked them to and they (including the Taiwanese government) are not in a position to refuse.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by throwaway4good on Sunday January 22, 2023 @05:45AM (#34476094)
Of course it is. But for some interesting reason the Economist does not write about that.
Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by MomoXenosaga on Sunday January 22, 2023 @09:54AM (#34477913)
Yep the Dutch prime minister was recently in Washington to discuss this too. Biden wants ASML to stop selling machines to China.

"You are either with us or you are with the terrorists"

Re:Speak softly, and carry a big chip by roenxi on Sunday January 22, 2023 @05:07AM (#34475936)
It is in China's interests that Taiwan not be the centre of global chip manufacturing. And the US's interest. Europe's too. The situation is delicate, but I suspect in time Taiwan will become less strategically important. Too many powerful players would benefit from that industry going somewhere else. An economic competitive advantage is not enough to make the US take strategic risks, or to hold China off.

It makes sense that there would be literal conspiracies a work in this situation. If I were in Taiwan, I would assume that the US plant represents some sort of threat to the geopolitical status quo. Regardless of what some analyst thinks.