News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by xeromal on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:22AM (#34275614)
This brings up a question for me. Does brain size always correlate to intelligence? I see a dolphin brain that looks very human and I think that it does, but then I see how smart crows are and I'd honestly say that they're smarter than my dog in most ways.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by fossuser on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:42AM (#34275921)
It’s an interesting question and the answer is also pretty interesting: https://obscuredinosaurfacts.com/post/2022/11/30/bird-brains...

There are a few factors and that post gives a nice overview.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by kick_in_the_dor on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:41AM (#34276981)
I haven't yet read the main article at that link, but its opening links to another long blogpost on whatbuywhy.com about the human brain and it's fascinating! Highly recommended: https://waitbutwhy.com/2017/04/neuralink.html
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by xeromal on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:45AM (#34275975)
Thanks! I've always been curious. Just opened this up.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:33AM (#34275793)
Birds have a higher neuron density. Each neuron is a mini Turing machine running on DNA instructions so they could also have better instinctual software.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by dcow on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:47AM (#34276007)
Not sure if that analogy holds exactly. Neurons don't “compute”, they simply emit a signal that depends on how “saturated” they currently are, right?
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:05AM (#34276314)
Feel free to research it. The ‘saturated’ analogy is overly simplistic and elides the incredible complexity of what’s actually going on.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by dcow on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:18AM (#34276549)
But neurons certainly aren’t mini Turing machines, either? Happy to inform myself more if you can point me in the right dorection.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:37PM (#34278917)
Cells perform a staggering number of parallel computations. Neurons are cells, and perform these same calculations and more in addition to emitting spikes. Spikes, rather than being the major form of computation, appear instead to be a means of maintaining synchronization.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by dcow on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:37PM (#34280684)
I quite honestly did not think of it this way. But it makes some sense. I always thought cells perform, for lack of a better term, self-maintenance operations independently from their macro function (the receiving and emitting of spikes, in this case). I did not think of the internal operations of a cell being connected to the macro function in any sophisticated or meaningful way. I would love to inform myself better on this topic since it is not by area of expertise, and I have an admittedly cursory understanding.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @04:39PM (#34281569)
I do think the field of psychopharmacology is probably sufficient to give an appreciation of the complexity involved at the same time as being useful to the practical understanding of how medications (and food) change behavior. It's also well studied and there are good books. I think Dr Stahl's books are the university standard. Like a lot of science though I think much of it is 'current best guess'.

For information on the modifying DNA expression in neurons that's under epigenetics and not as well studied.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by Choco31415 on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:08AM (#34276356)
That simplifies neurons a bit too much. There are a variety of neuron types including mirror neurons and pyramid neurons. These can feature more or less branching even.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by dcow on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:22AM (#34276639)
My point is they operate more like gates. They aren’t mini Turing machines.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by rolph on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:44AM (#34277044)
neurons have gates, these gates interconnect and form logic networks.

these are histeretic, programable, and dynamic.

the neuronal body state, the electro-osmotic environment, the past history of state are primary effectors of structure,and function resultant in the logic.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by Choco31415 on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:50PM (#34278216)
You are correct. Neurons are not Turing machines. However, they are complex enough that they can be Turing machines so it can be fun to call them that.

I didn’t expect this topic to be so controversial to be honest. I’m not surprised though.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by dcow on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:20PM (#34280453)
I fully admit I may be underinformed. I had thought, though, that neurons were not sophisticated in the way a Turing machine is and much more akin to memristors. However, that may be a memristor tinted view of the world.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by hackinthebochs on Friday January 06, 2023 @02:31PM (#34279672)
Neurons definitely compute. The dendrites that aggregate signals to initiate an action potential are not just simple summations but complex arrangements of signal promoters and inhibitors. The complexity of a pyramidal neuron is equivalent to a 5-8 layer artificial NN.

https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-computationally-complex-i...

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S089662732...

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:01PM (#34280159)
And that result is just from a computer simulation of a neuron that focuses on the dendrites and doesn't appear to extensively model the nucleus.

"Unfortunately, it’s currently impossible for neuroscientists to record the full input-output function of a real neuron, so there’s likely more going on that the model of a biological neuron isn’t capturing. In other words, real neurons might be even more complex."

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by jacquesm on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:04AM (#34276284)
This makes no sense in the way neurons work as far as I understand it. DNA 'instructions' are processed by the Ribosome to make proteins, it isn't software in a machine code sense but more of molecular specification for a piece of material to be produced.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ribosome

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:06AM (#34276321)
DNA does more than make proteins…
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by jacquesm on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:21AM (#34276618)
DNA doesn't make proteins at all...
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:23PM (#34278732)
Fine, DNA contains the instructions for much more than the production of proteins
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by dekhn on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:07PM (#34280266)
"Template" is a better term than instructions.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by rolph on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:56AM (#34277241)
in the strictest sense DNA doesnt make anything.

the interaction between DNA and polymerase class nucleo-polymers result in assembly of sequence conservative polymers.

for the most part this is RNAclass material, but includes DNA during replication and error correction events

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by dekhn on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:17AM (#34276527)
I only downvoted you because "each neuron is a mini Turing machine running on DNA instructions" isn't a very helpful observation except at the most abstract level.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:22AM (#34276633)
In my extensive research of neurons (as an independent/citizen scientist) it looks like the closest analogy to me. Neuron behavior is not only mediated by DNA but neurons can also write changes back into DNA, not to mention the nucleus soup that acts a bit like registers. I work on small molecule peptide medicine that changes gene expression in the neurons and other to glia cells to treat medical conditions.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by jacquesm on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:28AM (#34276749)
This isn't even wrong. Seriously, if you want to do science get educated, your statements on this subject ("I should add that I've taken to do my own research because I little faith in the actual scientists to do a good job, and the faith that I have left is diminishing.") make me discard your output as 'likely noise' rather than signal. If you want to be taken seriously then you should make a minimal effort to try to understand what it is that you are talking about, as it is you come across as a kook and that likely isn't your intention.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by edgyquant on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:41AM (#34276982)
Please attack something that user said that is unfactual instead of engaging with his stance on other matters
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by jacquesm on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:14PM (#34277585)
I don't like your phrasing this as the need to attack something unfactual or not, and it's not 'other matters' it is precisely this matter: to come up with stuff that goes against established science in a way that makes it difficult, if not impossible to argue with.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:36AM (#34276894)
I don’t work alone, I do work with scientists who I think are good. When I speak in generalizations it is just that a generalization. Science has been subtly redefined from a methodology to ‘what a scientist does’ and scientist these days produce papers.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by taneq on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:50AM (#34277150)
Do you have any evidence for this? Sounds interesting if so.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:13PM (#34277566)
The general field is Epigenetics (gene expression based on environment), and within that there is research on how peptides act as modulators by silencing and us-silencing different genes. You can get a list of known bioactive peptides by reading it from the DNA or by using mass spectrometry (there’s a proper name for this but it escapes me atm). So putting the two together you can have quite a bit of external control over gene expression.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by rolph on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:29PM (#34277854)
HPLC [1] or Electrophoresy [2] would be instrumental in isolating peptides based on mobility, and molecular mass.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-performance_liquid_chroma...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrophoresis

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:09PM (#34278518)
I was thinking of MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry devices used in Protiomics research. It’s a bit out of my field but I think it’s an improvement to HPLC.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by dekhn on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:24PM (#34278741)
Probably GC-MS? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_chromatography%E2%80%93mas... Dunno how that would isolate the sample, rather than just analyzing it though
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:43PM (#34279002)
I’m not involved in the process of acquiring the ‘omics data. I just analyze it and read papers from other people analyzing it. I think MALDI-TOF is the gold standard for proteomics.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by rolph on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:46PM (#34279037)
mass based deflection and deposition.

isolation,and analysis are two different activities, many instruments are capable of both modalities, depending on technique.

the problem is selecting a procedure that will not induce confounding artefacts of chemical, or physical interaction w the subject molecular entity.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by dekhn on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:30PM (#34277871)
Even if it's self-modifying, can continue state, etc, the Turing machine analogy is a bit of a stretch. And the current mainstream considers the primary function of neurons to be their information-transmitting capability, rather than their self-modifying ability.

Don't let my negative attitude keep you from doing research- I just think that epigenetics has been a bit overblown as a functional mechanism, or its just too hard to prove anything useful with experiments. Personally, if I was working on this I'd focus much more on neural differentiation during neurogenesis, rather than self-modification during "runtime".

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cjbgkagh on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:57PM (#34278352)
I’m aware of how attractive the information-transmitting analogy is given the elegance of the theory. A few simple rules when combined form an infinitely complex emergent behavior able to sufficiently explain all observations; what’s not to love about it.

I’m focusing on the epigenetic aspect of neurons due the possibility of the ME/CFS/LongCovid family of conditions being due to silencing of certain genes. The brain is closely linked with the immune system and I think the so while these present as immune conditions I believe it starts out more as a neural condition, maybe microglia. In addition it makes sense to focus on this area more as I can’t consciously restructure the neurons in my brain but I can introduce peptides that change gene expressions.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by f6v on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:28AM (#34275722)
I’d rather ask about body/brain ratio and % energy consumed by a brain.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by hutzlibu on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:28AM (#34275724)
"Does brain size always correlate to intelligence?"

Not really, otherwise whales and elephants would be way smarter, than us.

Well, some people say, they are, but it does not show in our intelligence tests.

And birds brains evolved differently than those of mammals, so maybe they are more efficient with their relative small brain? Because yeah, they are definitely smarter than dogs, who have a bigger brain.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by Zamicol on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:48AM (#34276023)
Maybe whales are "smarter" than us. How can we empirically test whale intelligence? Their technological abilities are obviously inferior, but I wouldn't be surprised if they were surprisingly intelligent in other ways. I'm trumpet dumb, that doesn't mean I'm not "overall smarter" or "niche smarter" than some people who play trumpet.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by prox on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:01AM (#34276220)
“For instance, on the planet Earth, man had always assumed that he was more intelligent than dolphins because he had achieved so much—the wheel, New York, wars and so on—whilst all the dolphins had ever done was muck about in the water having a good time. But conversely, the dolphins had always believed that they were far more intelligent than man—for precisely the same reasons.” - Douglas Adams
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by xen2xen1 on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:12AM (#34276442)
This quote is always in the back of my head anytime brain size or intelligence is discussed, and is especially when dolphins are mentioned. And, he has a point.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by prox on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:24PM (#34277751)
As I reflect on the quote more and more, I believe the dolphins have the right idea.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by hutzlibu on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:30PM (#34282217)
But apparently the dolphins in hitchhikers guide to the galaxy did a bit more, than just having a good time in the water - because unlike the humans, they managed to find a way to leave the earth, when it was destroyed. (Book 4)

And this is not further explained in the book, but it likely sounds like technology. And when you want to have and use technology, you have to do more than just splashing around..

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by prox on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:33PM (#34282262)
Since dolphins evolved a couple of times, they might had that tech lying around just in case. The point stands, dolphins use their tech so they can muck about in the water. Humans to compete in a rat race and for survival in its essence. Which come to think of it, is absolutely absurd if for any intelligent species. So we aren’t that smart.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by hutzlibu on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:40PM (#34282360)
"So we aren’t that smart."

Well, when you consider that we react to global crisis like a pandemic with more confrontation, than cooperation (there was no real exchange of technology between west and east and patents and licencing were still more important, than producing enough vaccines) and to the climate crisis rather with more wars over whats left of the ressources, than to unite and solve the problems - no, we are not.

We are smart enough to see, what could be possible, but unable to overcome primitive power struggles.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by vlunkr on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:57PM (#34282575)
That's some pretty serious cherry picking
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by hutzlibu on Friday January 06, 2023 @06:21PM (#34282802)
Well, do you really think humanity as its whole acted "smart" during the pandemic?

And cherrypicking, well climate change is the current problem, affecting the whole earth, so a smart species by my definition would act globally and coordinated and not only talk about it. But sure, by comparison we still seem to be the smartest around.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bmitc on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:16AM (#34276517)
> Not really, otherwise whales and elephants would be way smarter, than us.

How do you know that? I mentioned this in another comment, but dolphins and orcas have more folds in their brain than we do, and folding is associated with greater processing power and higher function. Additionally, the areas of their and whales' brains associated with emotional intelligence are much larger relative to the rest of their brain than the same areas in our brain are. Their brains are very, very interesting. For example, they keep one brain hemisphere active during sleep since they are conscious breathers, and they actually alternate which hemisphere is kept awake.

Whales, dolphins, and orcas are damn smart, and I think there's evidence enough that we cannot conclude that they aren't more intelligent than us. Although they lack technological development, this is due to their living environment and physiobiology and not due to their intelligence. Orcas in particular have achieved complete dominance of their environment, aside from human activity, and are geographically widespread with diverse cultures. There are many cases where orcas actually use humans as tools, even training humans to help them in hunts (and not the other way around).

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by taneq on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:50AM (#34277135)
Sorry to be crass but I'd assume intelligence is somewhat correlated with mastery of the physical world (I mean if it weren't we wouldn't care about things like AI alignment) and while cetaceans are clever mammals they're not very good at avoiding being soup. I sympathize with them, but if they were "way smarter than us" we would be running and hiding instead of debating how nicely we should treat them.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bmitc on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:46PM (#34278152)
I already addressed that though. Operating under the hypothetical and assumption that humans could survive in the ocean, humans couldn't develop technology and written history and knowledge in the ocean without having done so on land first, even with our hand dexterity, much less with fins.

Humans existed a long time before proper technology development, and those humans were just as intelligent as modern ones. The ability to create technology is not a requirement for higher intelligence.

Even then, orcas do use tools, what they have access to. Without technology, humans stand no chance against an orca, and that goes for any animal in the ocean, from blue whales to great white sharks.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:43PM (#34278998)
Then we should expect cetaceans to have developed long verbal/oral lineages, especially as their medium is much better for transmitting sound.

We see dialects, to an extent, in orcas, but we do not see the human behaviors we might expect.

The problem, I think, is in the pure consideration of it as intelligence. This is a limited view.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by kridsdale1 on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:58PM (#34280955)
You’re implying something is only showing intelligence if it shows complexity (long linguistic demonstrations here)

Isn’t it more intelligence to convey all the information that you need to with the highest efficiency?

We rate a poet who can convey tremendous meaning in few lines as superior to someone who is long winded and their writing is full of bullshit and tropes conveying nothing but using many words.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Friday January 06, 2023 @07:45PM (#34283610)
I’m suggesting that increasing complexity and nuance present in a substrate such as language is a prerequisite for high intelligence because high intelligence in individuals is a feature of groups, not individuals.

One person alone is without language and without advanced tools, no matter how big their brains. See feral children.

It is possible that cetaceans pushed long ago pushed past complex verbosity into communication via wisdom and are all enlightened beings. Maybe they communicate electrically. Maybe they are in a local maximum of telepathic connection. I hope so.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bmitc on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:07PM (#34284281)
> Then we should expect cetaceans to have developed long verbal/oral lineages

Why? But nonetheless, they have. They pass on locations, routes, hunting techniques, etc. vocally and behaviorally down through generations.

You and some of the other comments bring up a lot of things that don’t really have much to do with intelligence. They really only have anything to do with a human-centric view of intelligence.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Saturday January 07, 2023 @09:29PM (#34295386)
If you cannot build and communicate abstract concepts collectively your ability to select evolutionarily for increased capacity for abstract concepts seems to me to be very limited. I am all for different forms of intelligence, but at least attempt to define it and how it comes about.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by SkyBelow on Friday January 06, 2023 @02:32PM (#34279681)
>Humans existed a long time before proper technology development, and those humans were just as intelligent as modern ones. The ability to create technology is not a requirement for higher intelligence.

Is that actually true? In cases of feral or severely neglected children who lack any exposure to human language, isn't there an impediment that prevents them learning more complex language later in life that exceeds anything that could be attributed to reduced brain development due to nutrition?

World wide hasn't intelligence been increasing, and while part of that is due to better nutrition, another part is due to better childhood conditions to enable intelligence? Exposures to the technology of language, written language, and similar at a young age seem to lead to an increased capacity for intelligence later in life.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bmitc on Friday January 06, 2023 @04:15PM (#34281194)
Isn’t it true? Hominids and Homo sapiens were around millions and hundreds of thousands of years, respectively, before technology more advanced than basic tools showed up. And written history seems even shorter than that.

I’m not for sure what feral or neglected children has to do with this.

To address your later point, intelligence does not equal knowledge. Any increase in intelligence in a person’s life seems to be intralifetime and doesn’t spill over to further generations. Increasing intelligence through diet and behaviors and such are just mechanisms for exposing the underlying intelligence that’s already there.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by SkyBelow on Friday January 06, 2023 @04:34PM (#34281498)
>To address your later point, intelligence does not equal knowledge.

This is just one of the many paths to the fundamental question that plagues this sort of topic, what is intelligence. Is intelligence the capacity for gaining knowledge or having actually gained knowledge? Or maybe not directly related to knowledge at all, though the previous question was more about the capacity to gain vs the gaining than it was about knowledge.

It is known that the capacity a single individual changes based on what they were exposed to (feral/neglected children being the extreme negative cases, I'm not as well read on extreme positive cases). But perhaps we aren't talking about an individua's capacity and instead we are talking some baseline genetic average capacity for a larger group that doesn't take into account environmental cases pushing it to either extreme? But in such a case have we not defined intelligence so that technology's impact is excluded a priori?

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by yieldcrv on Friday January 06, 2023 @12:48PM (#34278185)
that's an assumption that more intelligence means that they would have to be motivated by revenge and vengeance as opposed to that being a distinctly human flaw
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bmitc on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:06PM (#34278487)
This is a good point, and it reminds me of something. I do wonder if the ability to be content is a sign of higher intelligence. Humans are decidedly discontented, and I can't help but be curious about that being a possible showcase of our ignorance.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by hutzlibu on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:17PM (#34282074)
"How do you know that? "

I do not know it. I am not an expert and had only limited, (but fascinating) contact with them.

But I would assume, if they would be "way smarter", than they could and would find ways of communicating with us. As far as I know, the research shows that they can communcicate towards each other quite well, but not towards us beyound very basic things.

But of course that reminds me of an old joke:

A donkey and a dog on a farm are talking to each other in the evening and the donkey complains that he has so much work to do, but would like to become a writer. The dog asks: why don't you tell the farmer? The donkey answers, are you crazy? If he finds out, I can read and write, I will also have to do his bookkeeping.

Meaning, maybe whales and co. could communicate with us, but choose not to. But if this would be the case, their reasoning would have to include some very astonishing things, as whales are still hunted - which they likely could almost completely stop by telling us exactly that.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bmitc on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:02PM (#34284238)
> But I would assume, if they would be "way smarter", than they could and would find ways of communicating with us. As far as I know, the research shows that they can communcicate towards each other quite well, but not towards us beyond very basic things.

That’s a human centric approach and a little strange, because how do we communicate with them? We can’t understand them or communicate with them any more than they can with us.

Old Tom was an orca off the Australian coast who, with his pod, trained humans on how to efficiently catch whales. Old Tom demanded the tongues of the whales, which was given to him by the whalers.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by 0xBABAD00C on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:17PM (#34282076)
> Whales, dolphins, and orcas are damn smart, and I think there's evidence enough that we cannot conclude that they aren't more intelligent than us.

Where's this evidence? What exactly does "more intelligent" mean to you? Do you think a dolphin can learn to play e.g. Chess? I doubt you can teach them to play even tic-tac-toe.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bpodgursky on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:25AM (#34275664)
Within generally similar animals, brain size is correlated with intelligence. Across different branches of the tree, it's harder to compare.

Bigger bird brains ~= smarter birds. Bigger dog brains ~= smarter dogs. But you can't directly compare dogs and birds in that way.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by kanzure on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:33AM (#34275787)
It's the absolute number of cortical neurons, not the size of the brain.

"Brains matter, bodies maybe not: the case for examining neuron numbers irrespective of body size" https://nyaspubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1749-...

"No relative expansion of the number of prefrontal neurons in primate and human evolution" https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1610178113

"The human brain in numbers: A linearly scaled-up primate brain" https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2776484/

"The elephant brain in numbers" https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnana.2014.0004...

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bpodgursky on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:26PM (#34280537)
Yeah, I don't think that's in contrast to what I said.

Neural architectures are very similar between closely related species, and differ wildly between birds and whales.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by User23 on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:51AM (#34276064)
Dogs have been bred for docility not intelligence. Their wild cousins, wolves, are considerably more intelligent, they’re just prone to get bored and engage in undesirable behaviors. I’m told that it’s very easy to teach a tame wolf tricks, but they quickly lose interest in obviously pointless activities, especially as they mature.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by taneq on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:52AM (#34277180)
So wolves have ADHD, right. :P
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:35PM (#34278894)
If you think about it, ADHD behaviors would likely be much more adaptive in the wild than non-ADHD. It is possible ADHD stems from genetic regression.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by tigerlily on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:43PM (#34278996)
What are you trying to say?
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:56PM (#34279189)
It is possible that the selective processes that led to ”modern” brains are essentially a process of self-domestication, and certain “diagnoses” are just reflections of diversity in that process.

If society collapsed I think it would be more beneficial to be ADHD than not.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by emmelaich on Friday January 06, 2023 @04:56PM (#34281832)
I've seen studies relating hyperactivity to Neanderthal and older genes.

They persist because not enough time has passed to mutate them out.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by taneq on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:30PM (#34282220)
Not them but just guessing... that most ADHD traits are only 'disordered' if you expect humans to be able to sit still, shut up, and focus exclusively on what you tell them to focus on for 8 hours a day?
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bmitc on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:14AM (#34276469)
Dolphins and orcas specifically actually have higher density of folds in their brains than human brains in addition to being big.

The book Deep Thinkers: Inside the Minds of Whales, Dolphins, and Porpoises is quite good.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by astrange on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:05PM (#34280236)
Plus, they have water cooling.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bmitc on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:09PM (#34284303)
Damn, I can’t believe I never thought of that explicitly. Haha.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by KMag on Saturday January 07, 2023 @03:23AM (#34286235)
Our brains are also water cooled, and yet our bodies often actively increase temperature.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by sieste on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:24AM (#34276681)
Not exactly an answer to your question, but a few studies report a weak positive correlation (around .3) between head size and IQ in humans.

https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=corr...

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:52PM (#34279116)
But several in your search, including the twin study, report no correlation, and others report correlation only within race and sex groups.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by clnq on Friday January 06, 2023 @02:53PM (#34280040)
If there's a weak correlation in a population, finding no correlation in some subpopulations and a stronger correlation in others is expected.

For example, a very weak correlation between GPA and job performance exists. In some disciplines, like law, the correlation is strong. In other fields, like extreme medicine, there is no correlation.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by astrange on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:04PM (#34280224)
Are there studies on GPAs of extreme medics? …Why?

(And how much education did they have? The field includes people who have and haven't gone to medical school, I assume.)

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by clnq on Friday January 06, 2023 @04:32PM (#34281469)
No, this was meant to be an intuitive example to illustrate what weak correlation means. It could have been about a correlation between the redness of a fruit and its sweetness. For the entire population of fruit, it is weakly correlated. For some apples, it is strongly correlated. And for tomatoes, there is no correlation.

Extreme medicine, which includes field, mountain, and battlefield medicine, is a specialization of general medicine. You can study it as a part of various programs. I studied it as a specialization in a general practitioner's MSc program in Central Europe. Depending on the region, it is probably possible to specialize in extreme medicine as a nurse or an EMT.

Among my peers at university, we had a large diversity of GPAs both at university and in high school prior. It was an interesting, physically intensive branch of medicine with very intensive training. It took a specific personality type (methodical, algorithmic, persevering) to succeed rather than aptitude for all components of a GPA. Mainly, it was more about precisely following specific schemas and diagrams from memory in complex rescue scenarios.

You needed perseverance because we had a lot of simulations and tests, up to three times a week, which new students would fail for months. GPA was also affected by that - 45% was an excellent score in that program, and some of the best students scored in the high 80s. That is because everything was measured by various simulators - time to ECG, time to defibrillation, callouts to the team, the interval between chest compressions, depth of chest compressions, intubation speed, depth, and so on. As a human, you would naturally do some chest compressions slightly deeper and others somewhat less deep than perfect, for example. If you cared about your GPA, you didn't specialize in extreme medicine.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by fsckboy on Sunday January 08, 2023 @01:45PM (#34301804)
you are suggesting that "caring about GPA" is what leads to high GPA. That's like suggesting that "caring about scoring stats" is the key to what leads athletes to accumulate high scoring stats.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by clnq on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:23PM (#34305549)
Certainly. Students who care about their GPA will put more effort into maintaining a high one. I am not claiming it is the only GPA determining factor.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Friday January 06, 2023 @07:38PM (#34283552)
Twins should be the ultimate check in whether head size actually means anything (otherwise it could just as easily be nutrition, sleep, or other factors that generally lead to growth).
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:06PM (#34283837)
> twins should be the ultimate check in whether head size actually means anything (otherwise it could just as easily be nutrition, sleep, or other factors that generally lead to growth)

Twins are great for ruling out genetic factors. It may still be the case that neonatal nutrition drives both head size and adult IQ.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by Retric on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:11PM (#34283872)
Depends on how sensitive the studies are. The pool of twins with significantly different brain sizes is presumably limited.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by airgapstopgap on Saturday January 07, 2023 @06:51AM (#34287227)
It's a solved question. Of course brain size relates to intelligence, albeit noisily. What, why do people assume that the increase in brain volume in the evolutionary record, concurrent with the increase in sophistication of material culture, doesn't set a prior for within-species effects of variance in this trait? Do we have another computational substrate besides brain contents? Would this skepticism be considered reasonable in the context of any other tissue and its quantifiable function, like muscle or bone?

This is the most up-to-date meta-analysis on the topic:

https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsos.211621

> Brain size and IQ associations yielded r = 0.24, with the strongest effects observed for more g-loaded tests and in healthy samples that generalize across participant sex and age bands.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by Teever on Saturday January 07, 2023 @11:06AM (#34289333)
> Would this skepticism be considered reasonable in the context of any other tissue and its quantifiable function, like muscle or bone?

let's run with that idea.

I have more muscle in my legs so I must be faster than a rabbit?

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by airgapstopgap on Saturday January 07, 2023 @10:13PM (#34295642)
Not necessarily faster, but you definitely have way more leg power.

Various hypotheses on how a larger brain is actually used to control a larger body and thus doesn't translate into specific "brain power" usable for intelligent activities are unsound.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by taneq on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:43AM (#34277022)
Birds are smarter per unit of brain matter than mammals and it baffles me why more people aren't intrigued by this.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by catskul2 on Friday January 06, 2023 @02:41PM (#34279828)
Which people are not intrigued by this?
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by perth on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:15PM (#34278607)
I’ve read there’s decent correlation on a few scientific journals on Google scholar. Namely, that while head size doesn’t guarantee intelligence, if you are predisposed to intelligence you can’t be as smart as someone else who is predisposed to intelligence but has a larger head.

See: the spatial packing problem in human brains

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by joe__f on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:23PM (#34278724)
Don't you want to look for something like brain/body mass ratio and see how that correlates with intelligence?
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by coyotespike on Friday January 06, 2023 @02:28PM (#34279619)
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:27PM (#34278773)
No because the structure and function of the organ is at least as important as the size. Size (or rather some bound of neuron/glial count + complexity) is more in the necessary-but-not-sufficient category.

Secondly the question is not well-posed enough to answer accurately. What is intelligence, in this case?

The cytoarchitecture of brain parcels/regions varies significantly. If you have a giant cerebellum you are not going to seem very smart to us, but you may have a very large brain. At the other end, people have lived normal (if perhaps internally simpler) lives with tiny fractions of a typical neocortex. [0]

0 : https://www.sciencealert.com/a-man-who-lives-without-90-of-h...

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by LarryMullins on Friday January 06, 2023 @07:13PM (#34283324)
Larger animals tend to have larger brains than smaller animals. If you divide the actual brain size of an animal by the size of brain an average animal that size would have, you get the "encephalization quotient". If you rank some common animals by encephalization quotient, most of the resulting order probably isn't surprising to many people:

    Human: 7.4 - 7.8
    Dolphins: 5.3
    Chimps: 2.2 - 2.5
    Ravens: 2.49
    Dog: 1.2
    Cat: 1.0
Some of them are surprising:

    Mouse: 0.5
    Rat: 0.4
Rats are certainly smarter than mice, so this analysis is obviously limited. Still, it seems to generally give expected results.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encephalization_quotient

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Friday January 06, 2023 @07:54PM (#34283692)
Very familiar with EQ. If you read the wiki article you cited, most of it is references to people disputing the relevance of EQ.

eg 0 Currently the best predictor for intelligence across all animals is [forebrain]neuron count.[[5]](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encephalization_quotient#cit...)

1 In a meta-analysis, Deaner et al. (2007) tested ABS, cortex size, cortex-to-brain ratio, EQ, and corrected relative brain size (cRBS) against global cognitive capacities. They have found that, after normalization, only ABS and neocortex size showed significant correlation to cognitive abilities.

2 The notion that encephalization quotient corresponds to intelligence has been disputed by Roth and Dicke (2012). They consider the absolute [number of cortical neurons] and [neural connections]as better correlates of cognitive ability.[[16]](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encephalization_quotient#cit...)

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bilsbie on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:11PM (#34284320)
Do we know why this is the case? It doesn’t seem like a larger body would need additional brainpower.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by im3w1l on Saturday January 07, 2023 @12:28AM (#34285526)
One idea I've proposed for this is that is mostly correlation and just a little causation. Like assume going bigger is in an easy to get a little bit smarter, but at a large energy cost. Then EQ measures how willing the animal is to invest in additional smarts. If it's willing to invest energy, then it will also mean that evolution will favor intelligent animals more strongly so it will evolve other ways of becoming smarter than just going bigger. Perhaps more faster or more efficient neurons or better mactro structure. And those other things are where the major benefits come from.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by bryanrasmussen on Saturday January 07, 2023 @01:56AM (#34285872)
well a bigger brain requires a bigger head requires a bigger body to carry it, so this would seem to push the chances of higher intelligence onto the animals with the bigger bodies. But I'd guess it is just a slight increase in the likelihood, since the structure is probably of more importance.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by nomel on Saturday January 07, 2023 @02:18AM (#34285970)
If you assume some sensor density, along the body, is required, then a larger body means more sensory cells, which necessitates more nerves, which requires more neurons to make sense of them in a meaningful way.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by 29athrowaway on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:25PM (#34284424)
NFT buyers: 0.001
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by cscurmudgeon on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:39PM (#34278949)
One analogy is computers: bigger is not more powerful, structure matters more.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by polski-g on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:44PM (#34279009)
Within a species, yes. There is a 0.41 correlation between brain size and intelligence in humans, for example.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by JamesBarney on Friday January 06, 2023 @02:25PM (#34279569)
Birds have evolved to have very space efficient neurons, due to their weight constraints.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by suzzer99 on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:00PM (#34281878)
Interestingly, the biggest bird of all, the ostrich, might also be the dumbest. Or at least ostriches are in the conversation with pigeons and turkeys.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by mtlmtlmtlmtl on Friday January 06, 2023 @10:37PM (#34284890)
Probably this is because the ostrich doesn't need to be as intelligent. No flight, big clumsy beak etc. And they can avoid predation just by being huge and kicking really hard.

City birds like crows and pigeons have puzzles they can play with like getting food out of garbage bins and so on. City birds tend to be more intelligent than countryside birds, even within the same species.

I always felt like cats are actually smarter than dogs in a lot of ways. Dogs have a lot of their brain power dedicated to manipulating and communicating with humans, as well as trainability. But untrained dogs just seem kinda stupid and helpless to me whereas cats can learn to be almost completely independent with next to no training. Dogs are evolved from pack animals of course which explains a lot of this.

I do love dogs though, just to be clear.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by Breadmaker on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:22PM (#34280488)
http://www.xenology.info/Xeno/3.3.htm some correlation atleast.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by terminal_d on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:33PM (#34280638)
https://pumpkinperson.com/2019/01/04/what-is-the-correlation...

https://pumpkinperson.com/2019/08/15/increasing-u-s-head-siz...

Last link has a formula to calculate cranial volume.

Animal intelligence is vastly underplayed. Ants seem to be a very intelligent creature but they're little more than part of nature to us. We're similarly adapted to our environment, and those animals are adapted to our patterns and mentation by virtue of millennia of close contact / purposeful genetic pushes (eg, dogs)

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by buywarbonds on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:15PM (#34282045)
No. A tiger is not 10x smarter than a house cat.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by feet on Friday January 06, 2023 @05:33PM (#34282272)
That assumes the correlation would be linear
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by stared on Friday January 06, 2023 @06:47PM (#34283080)
It is the easiest way to add more brainpower within the same architecture. Think: adding more RAM or another GPU.

Different architectures, like in tech, have different specs.

More is not always better, as a bigger brain is costly, and the price is only sometimes justified - as with buying more GPUs.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by hinkley on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:01PM (#34283789)
Dinosaurs had their chance and they lost, but I'm slightly terrified of the idea of a crow scaled up to the size of a chimpanzee, and I actually like corvids (though not as much as some). There are raptors roughly that size, so it's not impossible, unlike scaling an ant to the size of a crow, which would only give you a paperweight made out of chitin.

They clearly have a different 'instructions per cycle' ratio from mammal brains.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by stoat_meniscus on Friday January 06, 2023 @11:06PM (#34285090)
RISC? Reduced instruction set corvidae
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by Rury on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:23PM (#34284412)
Brain size has more to do with body size than anything. Most of your brain functions as a motor control and sensory processing center. To willfully move muscle in your body, requires brain power. This is why after a stroke, and a part of your brain dies, you can lose both the ability to move sections of your body, along with feeling anything in those sections.

As so, larger animals have bigger bodies, and hence typically have bigger brains in order to handle/control their larger bodies.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by agumonkey on Saturday January 07, 2023 @07:32AM (#34287463)
I'd be extremely interested, because good biological foundation for intelligence doesn't necessary leads to advanced thinking. Size + internal structure + context.