News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by clnq on Friday January 06, 2023 @02:53PM (#34280040)
If there's a weak correlation in a population, finding no correlation in some subpopulations and a stronger correlation in others is expected.

For example, a very weak correlation between GPA and job performance exists. In some disciplines, like law, the correlation is strong. In other fields, like extreme medicine, there is no correlation.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by astrange on Friday January 06, 2023 @03:04PM (#34280224)
Are there studies on GPAs of extreme medics? …Why?

(And how much education did they have? The field includes people who have and haven't gone to medical school, I assume.)

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by clnq on Friday January 06, 2023 @04:32PM (#34281469)
No, this was meant to be an intuitive example to illustrate what weak correlation means. It could have been about a correlation between the redness of a fruit and its sweetness. For the entire population of fruit, it is weakly correlated. For some apples, it is strongly correlated. And for tomatoes, there is no correlation.

Extreme medicine, which includes field, mountain, and battlefield medicine, is a specialization of general medicine. You can study it as a part of various programs. I studied it as a specialization in a general practitioner's MSc program in Central Europe. Depending on the region, it is probably possible to specialize in extreme medicine as a nurse or an EMT.

Among my peers at university, we had a large diversity of GPAs both at university and in high school prior. It was an interesting, physically intensive branch of medicine with very intensive training. It took a specific personality type (methodical, algorithmic, persevering) to succeed rather than aptitude for all components of a GPA. Mainly, it was more about precisely following specific schemas and diagrams from memory in complex rescue scenarios.

You needed perseverance because we had a lot of simulations and tests, up to three times a week, which new students would fail for months. GPA was also affected by that - 45% was an excellent score in that program, and some of the best students scored in the high 80s. That is because everything was measured by various simulators - time to ECG, time to defibrillation, callouts to the team, the interval between chest compressions, depth of chest compressions, intubation speed, depth, and so on. As a human, you would naturally do some chest compressions slightly deeper and others somewhat less deep than perfect, for example. If you cared about your GPA, you didn't specialize in extreme medicine.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by fsckboy on Sunday January 08, 2023 @01:45PM (#34301804)
you are suggesting that "caring about GPA" is what leads to high GPA. That's like suggesting that "caring about scoring stats" is the key to what leads athletes to accumulate high scoring stats.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by clnq on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:23PM (#34305549)
Certainly. Students who care about their GPA will put more effort into maintaining a high one. I am not claiming it is the only GPA determining factor.
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by svnt on Friday January 06, 2023 @07:38PM (#34283552)
Twins should be the ultimate check in whether head size actually means anything (otherwise it could just as easily be nutrition, sleep, or other factors that generally lead to growth).
Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:06PM (#34283837)
> twins should be the ultimate check in whether head size actually means anything (otherwise it could just as easily be nutrition, sleep, or other factors that generally lead to growth)

Twins are great for ruling out genetic factors. It may still be the case that neonatal nutrition drives both head size and adult IQ.

Re:Human gene linked to bigger brains was born from seemingl... by Retric on Friday January 06, 2023 @08:11PM (#34283872)
Depends on how sensitive the studies are. The pool of twins with significantly different brain sizes is presumably limited.