News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by mronetwo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:33AM (#33880480)
The entire AI/ML world is just extremely boring and depressing to me... I like to make art and now places like ArtStation get flooded with AI generated images. People, obviously, don't disclose that it's AI generated. It's the commenters that point that out.

I'm generally worried that we're creating a world which is not for us anymore. Maybe we should introduce boundaries to our world, just so we don't fall into a nihilistic pit of insignificance. Humans derive a lot from process, not the final product. Now we're creating tools to jump directly to the final product. Hedonistic treadmill gets faster and faster. Grim times.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by stanmancan on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:43AM (#33880692)
I’ve felt the same way. After years of patience and practice my kid has become a fantastic artist. I’m a bit concerned that at some point they might think “why bother?” and give it up after they see someone type some prompt in with “pencil, sketch” as a suffix.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by layer8 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:11AM (#33881233)
To be honest, I already got to the “why bother” state by seeing on the internet how many human artists are so much better than me.

And, on the other hand, if you actually have a specific vision of what you want to create, it is often quite difficult, or actually impossible, to get an AI to generate an output that fulfills your particular vision.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by xg15 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:02AM (#33882198)
> To be honest, I already got to the “why bother” state by seeing on the internet how many human artists are so much better than me.

I'm also learning to draw. As a counterpoint, I found it quite fun and enlightening to use artwork I like as practicing material. You can learn a lot by trying to copy parts of an artwork (without tracing and without uploading the result anywhere) : By copying, you still actually have to draw the artwork and deal with the same challenges that the original artist did - however you can use the original artwork as a sort of guide or cheat sheet on how those problems can be addressed.

I found it often even gave me a deeper appreciation for the original artist, because you see all the small, individual decisions they had to make to eventually get to the artwork - it felt sort of similar to reading code and trying to get into the head of the original developers.

You can also get creative and only copy parts of the artwork or change things or copy things from different images and stitch together a new piece - essentially doing by hand what image generators do automatically. (Just don't upload your new artwork anywhere without contacting the original authors first)

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by xtracto on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @05:28PM (#33888025)
These threads remind me a lot of some of Isaac Asimov "Robots" series novels. He painted a world where Robots and AI solved a lot of things, so people didn't have to do things that "worried them". It seems some lost any meaning for living.

I've been an "amateurish" guitar player for 30 years. I play chords, I do some OK picking and I love trying to "play" songs I like, even if badly played (I like speed metal and shredding, which I know I will never master in my lifetime).

Nevertheless, I do it because I like it, I've seen Satriani, Oscar Lopez, Steve Vai play, and I know I'll never be like them. However I don't think "why bother". I enjoy playing basic guitar some afternoons in my living room, and my wife enjoys listening to me while reading a book. I've always played for me first, and because I enjoyed it.

It is a very rare opportunity that we people have the ability/resources to do something just because we enjoy it. With the advent of this wave of AI, we will need to learn to do more things that way.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by cpsns on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:19PM (#33883612)
> To be honest, I already got to the “why bother” state by seeing on the internet how many human artists are so much better than me.

Same here, it's extremely hard to find motivation when I know every idea I have has been done better by someone who isn't me, or recently by a computer. In either case I can't meaningfully compete and if it's been done better, why do it at all?

This applies to art, but even more broadly than that. I get no satisfaction in creating something when I can see people who have done it far better than me via a quick search.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by mronetwo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:26PM (#33884730)
As long as it’s humans you know it’s achievable. You can pursue their level and doing that has value. I kind of believe that learning about art and getting better is just a great exercise for oneself. It makes you a better person.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by achenet on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:57AM (#33880956)
all AI art is confined to digital medium (at least for now, 3D printing might change that). You can't see the brushstrokes like in a real life, physical painting. Dancing is one that will be very hard to copy, because you need actual humans for it.

Not to mention, the kid may enjoy making art, and his/her art may give others joy, even if it's not a profitable career. It can still be a fun hobby - synthesizers have been around for nearly half a century now, but people still play guitar :)

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by electroly on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:00AM (#33881016)
> at least for now, 3D printing might change that

> Dancing is one that will be very hard to copy

I'm not sure I'd hang my hat on a particular current inability of AI, particularly inabilities where there's no obvious impediment to AI doing it. You're just begging for AI to eventually gain that ability, and now you're back where you started. Hooking AI up to physical actuators and getting it to work properly strikes me as a "this will 100% happen, I guarantee this is already being worked on" situation; basing your self-worth off the inability of AI to do those things seems like a ticking time bomb.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by binarymax on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:09AM (#33881186)
Indeed, this is already happening. This company is using human artist works for now, but the leap to a model producing such art is quite small at this point: https://art.art/blog/portia-de-rossi
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by achenet on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:08AM (#33881171)
alright then, I'll fallback to my backup - humans are cheaper.

They don't require mining rare earth metals, they're more versatile, and uh... oh gosh it's only a matter of time before we're all replaced by cheap carbon based robots. It's been real <3

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by nonameiguess on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:35AM (#33881702)
Seems like this is missing the point of dance, at least part of which is specifically watching humans. Right now, a pitching machine can throw harder than a human, but we still restrict baseball teams to only having humans on them. An automated motorbike can cover 100 meters faster than any human, but we don't allow motorbikes to compete in an Olympic sprint competition. A mechanical sumo wrestler wouldn't need to be intelligent, just heavier than the heaviest competitor, and it could already win against any human right now, but we don't do that.

Similarly, people still play chess, go, and Starcraft even though AI can beat them. Human Jeopardy matches still get televised even though Watson could beat them. We still have math olympics even though Wolfram Alpha could have won all of them decades ago.

I think human dancers are safe for as long as there are humans.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by electroly on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:07PM (#33883431)
Exactly. Things in life are not valuable pursuits just because an AI can't do them, nor do they stop being valuable once an AI can participate. OP seemed to suggest that AI being confined to digital art means that physical art still has value, but it doesn't follow at all. If I strap a paintbrush to a computer with AI, it doesn't devalue human painting. They're not related in that way.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:12AM (#33882354)
> all AI art is confined to digital medium (at least for now, 3D printing might change that). You can't see the brushstrokes like in a real life, physical painting.

For now. There's no technical reason why we can't have CNC painting machines - there's plenty of existing tech in manufacturing that has the required precision and range of motion. I think we don't see such machines because there is no business need for them - or at least, there wasn't.

To date, the kind of digital images you'd want to reproduce using a CNC painter would be drawn by actual artists, using their hands and - most likely - tools like pens and drawing tablets. The work of an artist is similar enough to actual painting that, if there's a need for the 3D texture, they can just... use real brush on real canvas. There technically is a market for cheap reproductions, but AFAIK this one is covered by "painter farms" - warehouses full of low-paid painters mass-producing paintings, in countries with cheap labor costs.

Now, if you could get the ML model produce "original" work, encoded as a time series of brush strokes (either straight from the model, or by another model turning JPEGs into painting instructions), then this just might provide an incentive for CNC painters. It might even start as a hobby thing - there's lots of people who would build such machine, the way they build 3D printers now, so they could produce their own paintings at home. Those same people will be unlikely to pay a far-away painter farm instead.

> Dancing is one that will be very hard to copy, because you need actual humans for it.

AFAIR that was already done, to a passable level, by Boston Dynamics, a few years ago. Sure, that was a one-off carefully choreographed stunt, but it demonstrated that 1) robotics can handle dancing just fine, and 2) the result is actually enjoyable to watch. The missing bit is software, but given the ML work being done in recent years, in particular all those video editing/generating models that start by parsing human movement from input videos, I think it won't be hard for someone to start generating dance moves.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by tartoran on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:23PM (#33889070)
But what you’ll not have is a human behind it, with a human story and struggles. But yes, I could see mass produced paintings a la CNC becoming common. It will be more expensive than prints but only a few levels above ikea art since it’ll be mass produced.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by mronetwo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:16AM (#33881343)
Imagine he might choose (or already does it) to do it professionally and struggle to make ends meet because “AI is just good enough. People still consume the media we produce. Why hire artists?”
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by d0liver on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:51AM (#33880848)
I'd still much rather see real art. It's kind of the difference between eating a homemade meal and eating manufactured crap out of a vending machine. And, from what I can tell, the art generators are basically just stealing other people's stuff. It'll probably be brought up as a real IP issue at some point.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by dale_glass on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:57AM (#33880968)
No, that's just not how they technically work. AI generators train on an image archive, but the resulting model doesn't include the actual pictures in it, and often contains only a tiny influence from each source image.

I think the current popular model works out to somewhere around a byte in the model per sample image.

Here's a diagram https://www.reddit.com/user/AnOnlineHandle made: https://i.redd.it/yxflzg0z6p3a1.png

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by lmarcos on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:56AM (#33882099)
Well, if I were an artist who wants to make work publicly available (previews?) and charge for it, I would make sure the license I use to publish my work explicitly states that it's not allowed to use my work as part of training data for any ML algorithm. If they want my work for that, then pay for it.

Hell, I think I as a developer could do that... Gonna invent a new open source license.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by dale_glass on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:07AM (#33882273)
Okay, but what's that supposed to achieve?

If you think you'll get paid, you probably won't because AI trains on very large datasets, and so pretty much any price per image would quickly get too expensive.

If you think it'll hamstring AI, I doubt it'll be for long. People will just end up curating their dataset better, and images that allow for it will continue to be created.

Also, per https://opensource.org/osd -- "No Discrimination Against Fields of Endeavor", so this likely won't get much uptake in open source circles either.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by dwild on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:32PM (#33890645)
>Okay, but what's that supposed to achieve?

Not being in the dataset maybe? There's many artists that hate that you can just write "in the style of" with their name.

So at least, if it does appear that it works with their name, they now either have been paid that amount, or they can sue for that amount of lost revenue. At least not everything would be lost.

I'm not a lawyer though, so really no idea whether this could even be possible as it's seems like currently it's fair use.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by dale_glass on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @04:27AM (#33892353)
> Not being in the dataset maybe? There's many artists that hate that you can just write "in the style of" with their name.

Very few artists have an unique style. Some are very recognizable, yes, but plenty others do more or less the same sort of thing.

There's thousands of photographers out there that go for the "razor sharp, high contrast closeup that shows every pore" style (https://photoaspects.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/black-an...) for instance.

With very limited exceptions you could go to a photographer and say "I want a photo that looks like this Vogue cover" and get it done.

> So at least, if it does appear that it works with their name, they now either have been paid that amount, or they can sue for that amount of lost revenue. At least not everything would be lost.

Don't be silly. If that logic worked, Microsoft could have sued Linus Torvalds for providing an OS for free. Or if you want to be a bit more exact, Sun Microsystems, IBM, or any other Unix vendor.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by d0liver on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:52PM (#33884204)
Encoding and compression also have the property that they vastly change the data _representation_ of information (often changing it completely). Yet, the underlying thing reamins the same in a way that's easily recognizable by a human. This is similar - sure, a transform is being applied that changes the representation of the data. But, ultimately, it's just mashing together large chunks of other people's IP.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by dale_glass on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:52AM (#33880866)
AI art is not nearly there yet, and has very significant areas in which it struggles a lot. The funny thing about it is that just like normal art there are easy and hard things to accomplish, but it's nigh impossible for a person new to this concept to tell which is which: https://xkcd.com/1425/

Overall, the easy part of AI art is generic portraits where you either don't care about the details, or want to use existing, popular things. Eg, you can ask for Harry Potter. And you can ask for a random character. But if you have a personal, distinctive design you made and want to bring to life, then it can get very tough pretty fast.

In fact, the best possible user for an AI generator would be an artist that's also capable of training a custom model. That opens up way more possibilities. Here's what this looks like:

https://www.reddit.com/r/NovelAi/comments/z7qat8/ai_as_a_too...

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by iamwpj on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @02:57PM (#33886145)
Every mind sees things different. The artist struggles to put that to a medium. The successful expression of their vision is extremely common, but the ability for anyone to even iterate on another artist's work is basically nonexistent. Even with AIs cranking out art, the obsessed will continue to fight to share their mind.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by MonkeyMalarky on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:47AM (#33880770)
Grim? There's a company out there using AI voice modification to make south Asian call center workers sound American on the phone. It's just depressing any way you look at it.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by dylan604 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:55AM (#33880929)
If they were really good at their job, they wouldn't need Asian employees. They'd just use the AI chat to handle everything. Why does an AI need a human to feed it what to say? That's not a very good AI. That's just voice modification, and that's been done for so long it's not even close to impressive. Have the AI hear the human voice, decide what to say that is relevant and useful, then generate a voice to deliver that information, then I'd almost be impressed.

What you described is pretty much how I feel all AI/ML is at this point. A decent website with a large humans operating in the background. Not impressed. At. All.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by unreal37 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:08AM (#33881175)
There are ML companies that monitor call center conversations and recommend what to say to the agent.

"ALERT! The customer just mentioned how long it takes to download files. Recommend a faster internet package."

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by jkestner on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:03AM (#33881078)
> If they were really good at their job, they wouldn't need Asian employees. They'd just use the AI chat to handle everything.

Well, sure, the software is training on the human conversations it mediates to do that next. Now I’ll just need my own chatbot representative optimized for solving my problems instead of the company I’m calling.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by have_faith on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:12AM (#33881268)
> Now I’ll just need my own chatbot representative optimized for solving my problems instead of the company I’m calling

More likely, you instruct your chat bot to call their chat bot to figure out the problem. Because they're bots, they can communicate at a much higher speed, thus bringing in a new era of High Frequency Support Calls.

Companies will build data centers close to the call centers, connected to them by line of sight satellite dishes, such that you can host your bot close to the support bot and shave off some ms connecting to them. This gets you closer to the front of the queue. This will be sold as a Good Thing, because it increases call frequency and allows calls to be priced by the market instead of the pesky phone companies.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by MonkeyMalarky on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:29AM (#33881595)
This is hilarious and the future I imagined when Google announced Duplex: AI assistant to AI voice chat bot over POTS. Clearly the most efficient robust API interface ever conceived.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by mplanchard on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:31AM (#33881631)
Thanks, this cracked me up! It reads to me like something out of a David Foster Wallace story.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:00AM (#33882180)
> Why does an AI need a human to feed it what to say? That's not a very good AI.

I'd say it's less about what, and more about how. AI can't simulate the emotional layer of the conversation in real-time just yet. Selecting the right words, tone, cadence, knowing when to pause and when to interrupt - it's all intuitive to us, and it's the core tool for the scammers[0] on the phone.

The companies are still trying to save on labor costs, hence outsourcing. The voice modification allows them to have their cake and eat it too - to move their call centers to countries with low labor costs, far away from their targets, while defeating the main heuristic people have to detect scammers: the caller sounding like a foreigner from a far-away country, despite claiming to represent a local company.

Until someone develops an AI for the emotional/manipulation layer, there's no point in adding AI for conversation here: the scripts the scam callers use are cheap, scalable, and work well enough.

> Have the AI hear the human voice, decide what to say that is relevant and useful, then generate a voice to deliver that information, then I'd almost be impressed.

That's actually what's been done for years now. Try calling the helpdesk of any large company, you'll most likely be greeted by a bot that tries to converse with you. It works as well as you can expect a chatbot attached to voice recognition to work - about the only thing it's good at is delaying and denying requests to connect you with a human.

In this case, the company can actually replace most of the support workers with a shitty chatbot because it's you who is calling them - they have no reason to care or make it easy for you to achieve anything.

----

[0] - I classify first-party and third-party telemarketing, cold calls and tech support scams as just different flavors of the same thing: preying on the vulnerable.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by rpastuszak on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:54AM (#33880902)
think of the brain power, and the human potential we’re wasting on solving such shitty problems.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by Larrikin on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:29AM (#33881587)
I'd rather the brain power be used on creating art/empowering artists and intelligently answering prompts as opposed to creating a surveillance state to show ads, thinking of ways to lock down computers so they are no longer general computing devices and just corporate app delivery devices, refactoring a website again to use a different JavaScript framework, figuring out how to insert middleman payments at scale into food delivery, etc.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by rchaud on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:48AM (#33881962)
That's what most people would rather have, too.

The issue is that the financial capital required to action these things rests in the hands of people who would much rather have this technology used for more profitable ad delivery services.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by samdcbu on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:10AM (#33881209)
If this is depressing let me tell you about quants and consultants, the true black holes of human capital.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by beaker52 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:07AM (#33881158)
Instead of just providing good services, we create new services to enable the original services to exist with the deficiencies they have, now you’ve got n services that enable 0.5 of the services you originally wanted. Sounds like a familiar problem to me. shudders
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by m00dy on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:11AM (#33881228)
Current capitalistic system defines what is valuable or what is not. As long as your solution to a problem generates a profit, the thing you are doing is valuable....
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by throwanem on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:25AM (#33881490)
Sounds like an alignment problem.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by throw10920 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:47AM (#33883024)
You're conflating two very different meanings for the word "valuable" - one that means "to have monetary value", and another that means "has use for society", and so your comment doesn't make sense.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by drewcoo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:56PM (#33884264)
> You're conflating two very different meanings for the word

The term you want is "equivocation." I don't think the gp is equivocating.

Also, "has use for society" is not a meaning of "value."

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/value

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by bradleykingz on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:13AM (#33882387)
Imagine using the same tech to make deaf speech properly intelligible.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by nilespotter on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:42AM (#33882913)
Why is that bad? I can't understand a thing they say. I would rather the call centers were in America, but I welcome this development.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @06:04PM (#33888349)
Most people are able to adjust their ears to an unfamiliar accent if they exert a bit of effort. It might be a little clumsy, and you might have to ask them to repeat themselves a few times, but that's just life for the millions of Americans who live in diverse cities, and those work for companies that employ non-native English speakers. MegaCorp isn't buying this tech to reduce this friction, though - they're buying it to appease the outright racist callers who verbally attack the employees and outright refuse to even try talking to them.

That said, I don't think forcing older rural folks to wrangle with a southeast Asian accent is going to solve any societal problems, and I imagine the call center workers in Asia would be big fans this tech if it reduces irate interactions and actually works well.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by GekkePrutser on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:35AM (#33918671)
It's not really about the accent. It's just that companies that outsource to Asia do so because they value the cost over quality. Because obviously in-house and in-region support is much better because the agents are more up to speed on the company and to the user's environment.

This expresses itself in other aspects than just location, and often the people working there have no product knowledge and just follow scripts. Because knowledgeable workers cost more. Works ok for 80% of the interactions but it really sucks if you're the 20% not covered by a script.

This gives Asian callcenters and the associated accent a bad name and leads to a kneejerk reaction from customers as the accent brings up memories of previous frustrating experiences.

Of course companies try to avoid this already with the mentioned software and also by moving to regions with more American-sounding people like the Philippines.

I worked in contact center management before and I've seen this effect a lot.

I'm sure there's excellent contact centers in the region too, but they have an uphill battle to prove themselves as most simply aren't.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by aiisjustanif on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:56PM (#33890758)
Apply this line of thought to most societal and social norms and it gets rather ugly.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by fullshark on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:48AM (#33880782)
Boundaries like paywalls and walled gardens with human verification of users seem inevitable to me as every other platform just becomes flooded with AI generated junk food.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by jollyllama on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:11AM (#33881231)
Indeed; artists will get wise and stop the AI exploitation from plagiarizing and laundering their product.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by fxtentacle on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:04PM (#33884414)
Too late, the datasets containing all human-generated artwork already exist.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by jollyllama on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:23PM (#33884697)
It'll be a great disproof of the whole "everything is derivative" line when they continue creating original and novel art.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by thenerdhead on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:55AM (#33880927)
Yeah depends how you look at it. It is very grim when you look at it from the hedonistic perspective. To avoid nihilism you have to consider the complete opposite. That you are contributing to the collective in a significant way, even if you suck at art, coding, writing, etc.

We're already quite deep in a meaning crisis. Nothing should stop each individual on this planet from searching for their meaning regardless of current innovation. Like you mention, humans grow from the pain and process, AI will never have that nor understand it.

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/11987.The_Myth_of_Sisyph...

EDIT: There's also a beautiful book regarding an existential courage to "be" which rejects this nihilism/meaninglessness.

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/175141.The_Courage_to_Be

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by 2devnull on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:05AM (#33881121)
Blame Walter Benjamin.

People, many of us, pay for human made art. Paul Graham is an investor and believer in art. He also believes ai has value.

Don’t be fooled. It’s a false dichotomy. Make better art. If you can’t be better than ai, you don’t “get” what art is in essence.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by mronetwo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:20AM (#33881400)
Seems you’re ignoring the entire professional space of people who want to make art and make money out of it. Impoverished internal lives of CEOs will always push them to pick cheap AI generated, laundered art, instead of hiring an artist. It’s cheaper and that all those people care about in the end.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by pksebben on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:31AM (#33881637)
this is less a problem with ai, and more a problem with persisting an economic model that had it's last major redesign in the 1700s.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by hectorlorenzo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:57AM (#33883233)
As it happened with book binders, printing press operators, tailors, lamplighters, milkmen... what is so special about professional artists?
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by 2devnull on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:04PM (#33883374)
Paul Graham is one the people who is supporting talented artists by buying their work.

The patronage system has brought much beauty to the world. It’s imperfect and one wishes you could remove the rich men from the art world, but tradition speaks of truths which you’d be wise to listen to.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by rchaud on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:00AM (#33882182)
> Make better art. If you can’t be better than ai, you don’t “get” what art is in essence.

I think that first sentence invalidates the second. "Better than AI" implies the artist's work should be more commercially successful than an AI's.

Which of these two enterprises are more likely to have a sales team?

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by 2devnull on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:01PM (#33883305)
Many artists, even the big names (van vogh), had no commercial success. If you’re an artist “for the money”, you are probably not going to be very happy with the outcome.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by thomastjeffery on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:26AM (#33882623)
Let's stop calling it AI: there is no intelligence, only something that resembles "learning".

Competition with art that is "generated" by ML is nothing more than an obfuscated way of competing with other artists whose works were used as a training dataset.

There is no artificial system today that actually creates art. All we have are systems that copy art in an intentionally vague fashion.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by 2devnull on Friday December 09, 2022 @10:42AM (#33922502)
There is art in building the ai. A great amount of art in the prompts. Art is omnipresent.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by lloeki on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:05AM (#33881135)
Could we make a ML filter thing that would detect ML generated art and shove it > /dev/null?

Oh, wait. Someone would plug it into a fitness function for their ML generating thing to drive it to not generate art that matches the filter.

Coming soon to ReCAPTCHA: "click on images that have been AI generated"

I wish I could dream again about technology.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by yonixw on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:07AM (#33881159)
I see it in a total different light (putting aside legal discussion).

Ever since learning to program, I hated redundancy of learning, learn loop in C#, learn loop syntax in Python etc. to the point I hated new languages and wanted all ecosystems to be centralized around few. Not to mention about getting depressed that I will never be able to draw anything good even tough there are many stories I want to tell with pictures I've imagined. All these "time" requirements have made me lose hope and guided me to just stick to my lane.

But since Copilot and Stable Diffusion came out I felt alive like never before. Suddenly I can get a boilerplate to a new language in a few click (and unit tests also!). I can create images I like and put my imagination into reality like never before. Every stable diffusion model is a new area I can expand into. I can waste hours in front of it just curios about how styles can be merged together.

All those "time" obstacles I thought were hardcoded in reality, just gone! I see it as an amazing advancement.

> ArtStation get flooded with AI generated images.

That is just spam, and low effort content, and yes, Stable diffusion also opened a spam route using it models. But I think it will be solved in a year or two. (Like those anti-deepfakes AI that are published now, few years after deepfakes)

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by Lewton on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:15AM (#33881322)
> But I think it will be solved in a year or two. (Like those anti-deepfakes AI that are published now, few years after deepfakes)

Anything used to detect ai generated images will be used to train image generators, there’s no escape

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by jkestner on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:11AM (#33881236)
Once we develop bots to automatically perform our consumer functions (damnit, Alexa, you were the chosen one), the loop will be closed and we can return to the trees.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by julvo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:16AM (#33881338)
> Now we're creating tools to jump directly to the final product

The same could've been said when the printing press or highly automated manufacturing was invented

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by masterof0 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:17AM (#33881365)
It just spam automation improvements in a nutshell.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by seydor on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:27AM (#33881532)
> Humans derive a lot from process, not the final product

One has to assume that Sisyphus was happy. But isn't that a bit sad

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by mronetwo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:36AM (#33881735)
Has to? Why? No one would ever defend the statement that “all processes make us happy”…
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by zild3d on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:49AM (#33881974)
"The struggle itself toward the heights is enough to fill a man's heart. One must imagine Sisyphus happy." are the final lines of Camus' essay
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by goatlover on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @12:34AM (#33890970)
One "must" imagine Camus was wrong. There are plenty of struggles humans do not find happy, particularly when they seem pointless or don't get you anywhere.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by spacemadness on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:31AM (#33882702)
How does this relate to art and fulfillment exactly?
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by gbjw on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @04:23PM (#33887253)
"God remains dead. And we have killed him. How shall we comfort ourselves, the murderers of all murderers?"

"Push this boulder, and imagine yourself happy."

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by serverholic on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:27AM (#33881535)
I wish I could upvote this 100 times. I feel like people get caught up in the, admittedly cool, individual projects but fail to see how this stuff is impacting our society as a whole.

Society sucks right now and abuse of technology is a huge part of it. I know people love their TikTok, Reddit, stable diffusion, etc. but the world would be better off without it.

And if you think blasting peoples brains with ADHD content on TikTok is bad then just wait for AI generated content. It’ll be way worse. Endless novelty at your fingertips. Whatever you can dream up will be generated on the fly for you to consume.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by sdwr on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:30AM (#33881609)
Retreat! Retreat to the local!
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by eternalban on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:38AM (#33881763)
> Humans derive a lot from process, not the final product.

tbh, your comment doesn't convey this belief at all. Btw a couple of generations ago artists were upset over people like Jeff Koons & Warhol. Creative process or fame/fortune. Pick one.

I can see commercial artists, illustrators, etc. who mostly end up doing what the client wants anyway (so "process" is not the main issue) to make a living being upset here. Corporate corridors and offices need "art" and sure, this trend will cut into that business. But not the tiniest of dents has been made in the universe of actually creative minds, imo.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by thedangler on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:08AM (#33882282)
I believe it is because people are naturally lazy these days. And if they can do something fast and easy that might make them a profit, not matter how crap it is, they will do it.

Look how many SaaS companies started up from openAI GPT-3 to create headlines, blog posts, grammar fixed, ect. You'll see the same thing with code soon.

Poeple are using those sites to create the same youtube videos and promoting the products with affiliate links.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by kelseyfrog on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:12AM (#33882355)
I don't think we're going to solve the lazy people problem before we solve the system-that-encourages-people-to-be-lazy problem. We cannot change behavior without changing incentives. Of course everyone is going to try to make a profit doing as little work as possible - we've built a system for incentivizing precisely that mode of work.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by egypturnash on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:12AM (#33882358)
My job is art and AI art is super depressing.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by hectorlorenzo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:54AM (#33883164)
There is something off about this argument. On one hand, you say "Humans derive a lot from process, not the final product", which I completely agree. But you also say "places like ArtStation get flooded with AI generated images", which seems to indicate there is a focus on showing off the final product.

I make pottery, and my pieces suck (in terms of shape, usability, even stability) compared to ones made by professional artists or in a factory. I cannot make two similar mugs for the life of me. But it is the process I enjoy, the learning, the improving. And the nice community I've built around me that shares the same passion.

Maybe I'm underestimating the power of text-to-image, but people still learn how to play the guitar (despite Ableton), or chess (despite Stockfish), or sculpture (despite 3D printing).

My honest question is: why should this time be different?

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by mronetwo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:02PM (#33883322)
You've posed a lot of questions, which I won't address. When it comes to "focus on showing off the final product" I don't think there is anything off here.

First of all there is the professional aspect of it. People just have to market themselves to get jobs. ArtStation (its predecessors actually) eradicated the new to have a portfolio website. It's THE place to host your work.

Then there is the need for validation. There is nothing wrong with wanting to be appreciated for your accomplishments. That's just one of our needs.

Community aspect is also important. People want to get better and they want to learn from others. Showing your work and exposing it to scrutiny or inspiring others is perfectly fine.

Lastly, I've never said that we derive EVERYTHING from the process. Final result is also important. It's just meaningless without the process, imo.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by hectorlorenzo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:12PM (#33883501)
I agree with all your points and I struggle to see how AI-generated imagery will change any of this. I honesty believe that people will still appreciate (or criticise, or ignore) your work and communities will still be formed around "traditional" artists.

As for the professional aspect of it, yes, designers, illustrators, copywriters, programmers will see their work deeply changed by this technology, to an extend that I do not understand at all. I share your worries in that front.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by mronetwo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @01:21PM (#33884668)
Well I’m just responding to the process vs final result, which I think you called inconsistent. Maybe I didn’t get what you were trying to say there though.

I also think that it actually might affect the way we value art. I’d need to spend a bit more time thinking about it but even on a surface level it seems that if we devalue something then people might not engage with it in the same way. We actually live in an age when the internet (and many other things) are destroying communities, and I do not think that online communities can feel that void. We need people around yet we push everyone away. Tech is a huge culprit in that. We need to be creative yet we build evidence we’re not that special or creative. Who knows many we actually are special and we’ll survive this.

I think there’s a lot to deconstruct here and I don’t think I’m prepared to write it down in a good way right now.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by tmountain on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:41PM (#33884024)
I also like making art, but AI has no bearing on my enjoyment in doing so. For me, it’s just a matter of carving out time to do my project organically (and analog), enjoying the process, and reflection on the results. Someone creating their own “work” with AI doesn’t make me enjoy the artistic journey more or less.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by gbjw on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @04:09PM (#33887074)
> Humans derive a lot from process, not the final product.

This is what gives me solace. Surely much of 'art' (in so far as a definition is useful) is not a static 'product' that you can replicate at will. It is a connection between two people: the artist and the consumer. Yes, AI 'art' can look aesthetically pleasing: but does it evoke emotion? Does it connect you to the 'artist'?