News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:12AM (#33882354)
> all AI art is confined to digital medium (at least for now, 3D printing might change that). You can't see the brushstrokes like in a real life, physical painting.

For now. There's no technical reason why we can't have CNC painting machines - there's plenty of existing tech in manufacturing that has the required precision and range of motion. I think we don't see such machines because there is no business need for them - or at least, there wasn't.

To date, the kind of digital images you'd want to reproduce using a CNC painter would be drawn by actual artists, using their hands and - most likely - tools like pens and drawing tablets. The work of an artist is similar enough to actual painting that, if there's a need for the 3D texture, they can just... use real brush on real canvas. There technically is a market for cheap reproductions, but AFAIK this one is covered by "painter farms" - warehouses full of low-paid painters mass-producing paintings, in countries with cheap labor costs.

Now, if you could get the ML model produce "original" work, encoded as a time series of brush strokes (either straight from the model, or by another model turning JPEGs into painting instructions), then this just might provide an incentive for CNC painters. It might even start as a hobby thing - there's lots of people who would build such machine, the way they build 3D printers now, so they could produce their own paintings at home. Those same people will be unlikely to pay a far-away painter farm instead.

> Dancing is one that will be very hard to copy, because you need actual humans for it.

AFAIR that was already done, to a passable level, by Boston Dynamics, a few years ago. Sure, that was a one-off carefully choreographed stunt, but it demonstrated that 1) robotics can handle dancing just fine, and 2) the result is actually enjoyable to watch. The missing bit is software, but given the ML work being done in recent years, in particular all those video editing/generating models that start by parsing human movement from input videos, I think it won't be hard for someone to start generating dance moves.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by tartoran on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @07:23PM (#33889070)
But what you’ll not have is a human behind it, with a human story and struggles. But yes, I could see mass produced paintings a la CNC becoming common. It will be more expensive than prints but only a few levels above ikea art since it’ll be mass produced.