News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by MonkeyMalarky on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:47AM (#33880770)
Grim? There's a company out there using AI voice modification to make south Asian call center workers sound American on the phone. It's just depressing any way you look at it.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by dylan604 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:55AM (#33880929)
If they were really good at their job, they wouldn't need Asian employees. They'd just use the AI chat to handle everything. Why does an AI need a human to feed it what to say? That's not a very good AI. That's just voice modification, and that's been done for so long it's not even close to impressive. Have the AI hear the human voice, decide what to say that is relevant and useful, then generate a voice to deliver that information, then I'd almost be impressed.

What you described is pretty much how I feel all AI/ML is at this point. A decent website with a large humans operating in the background. Not impressed. At. All.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by unreal37 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:08AM (#33881175)
There are ML companies that monitor call center conversations and recommend what to say to the agent.

"ALERT! The customer just mentioned how long it takes to download files. Recommend a faster internet package."

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by jkestner on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:03AM (#33881078)
> If they were really good at their job, they wouldn't need Asian employees. They'd just use the AI chat to handle everything.

Well, sure, the software is training on the human conversations it mediates to do that next. Now I’ll just need my own chatbot representative optimized for solving my problems instead of the company I’m calling.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by have_faith on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:12AM (#33881268)
> Now I’ll just need my own chatbot representative optimized for solving my problems instead of the company I’m calling

More likely, you instruct your chat bot to call their chat bot to figure out the problem. Because they're bots, they can communicate at a much higher speed, thus bringing in a new era of High Frequency Support Calls.

Companies will build data centers close to the call centers, connected to them by line of sight satellite dishes, such that you can host your bot close to the support bot and shave off some ms connecting to them. This gets you closer to the front of the queue. This will be sold as a Good Thing, because it increases call frequency and allows calls to be priced by the market instead of the pesky phone companies.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by MonkeyMalarky on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:29AM (#33881595)
This is hilarious and the future I imagined when Google announced Duplex: AI assistant to AI voice chat bot over POTS. Clearly the most efficient robust API interface ever conceived.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by mplanchard on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:31AM (#33881631)
Thanks, this cracked me up! It reads to me like something out of a David Foster Wallace story.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:00AM (#33882180)
> Why does an AI need a human to feed it what to say? That's not a very good AI.

I'd say it's less about what, and more about how. AI can't simulate the emotional layer of the conversation in real-time just yet. Selecting the right words, tone, cadence, knowing when to pause and when to interrupt - it's all intuitive to us, and it's the core tool for the scammers[0] on the phone.

The companies are still trying to save on labor costs, hence outsourcing. The voice modification allows them to have their cake and eat it too - to move their call centers to countries with low labor costs, far away from their targets, while defeating the main heuristic people have to detect scammers: the caller sounding like a foreigner from a far-away country, despite claiming to represent a local company.

Until someone develops an AI for the emotional/manipulation layer, there's no point in adding AI for conversation here: the scripts the scam callers use are cheap, scalable, and work well enough.

> Have the AI hear the human voice, decide what to say that is relevant and useful, then generate a voice to deliver that information, then I'd almost be impressed.

That's actually what's been done for years now. Try calling the helpdesk of any large company, you'll most likely be greeted by a bot that tries to converse with you. It works as well as you can expect a chatbot attached to voice recognition to work - about the only thing it's good at is delaying and denying requests to connect you with a human.

In this case, the company can actually replace most of the support workers with a shitty chatbot because it's you who is calling them - they have no reason to care or make it easy for you to achieve anything.

----

[0] - I classify first-party and third-party telemarketing, cold calls and tech support scams as just different flavors of the same thing: preying on the vulnerable.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by rpastuszak on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @09:54AM (#33880902)
think of the brain power, and the human potential we’re wasting on solving such shitty problems.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by Larrikin on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:29AM (#33881587)
I'd rather the brain power be used on creating art/empowering artists and intelligently answering prompts as opposed to creating a surveillance state to show ads, thinking of ways to lock down computers so they are no longer general computing devices and just corporate app delivery devices, refactoring a website again to use a different JavaScript framework, figuring out how to insert middleman payments at scale into food delivery, etc.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by rchaud on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:48AM (#33881962)
That's what most people would rather have, too.

The issue is that the financial capital required to action these things rests in the hands of people who would much rather have this technology used for more profitable ad delivery services.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by samdcbu on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:10AM (#33881209)
If this is depressing let me tell you about quants and consultants, the true black holes of human capital.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by beaker52 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:07AM (#33881158)
Instead of just providing good services, we create new services to enable the original services to exist with the deficiencies they have, now you’ve got n services that enable 0.5 of the services you originally wanted. Sounds like a familiar problem to me. shudders
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by m00dy on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:11AM (#33881228)
Current capitalistic system defines what is valuable or what is not. As long as your solution to a problem generates a profit, the thing you are doing is valuable....
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by throwanem on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @10:25AM (#33881490)
Sounds like an alignment problem.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by throw10920 on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:47AM (#33883024)
You're conflating two very different meanings for the word "valuable" - one that means "to have monetary value", and another that means "has use for society", and so your comment doesn't make sense.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by drewcoo on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @12:56PM (#33884264)
> You're conflating two very different meanings for the word

The term you want is "equivocation." I don't think the gp is equivocating.

Also, "has use for society" is not a meaning of "value."

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/value

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by bradleykingz on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:13AM (#33882387)
Imagine using the same tech to make deaf speech properly intelligible.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by nilespotter on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:42AM (#33882913)
Why is that bad? I can't understand a thing they say. I would rather the call centers were in America, but I welcome this development.
Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @06:04PM (#33888349)
Most people are able to adjust their ears to an unfamiliar accent if they exert a bit of effort. It might be a little clumsy, and you might have to ask them to repeat themselves a few times, but that's just life for the millions of Americans who live in diverse cities, and those work for companies that employ non-native English speakers. MegaCorp isn't buying this tech to reduce this friction, though - they're buying it to appease the outright racist callers who verbally attack the employees and outright refuse to even try talking to them.

That said, I don't think forcing older rural folks to wrangle with a southeast Asian accent is going to solve any societal problems, and I imagine the call center workers in Asia would be big fans this tech if it reduces irate interactions and actually works well.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by GekkePrutser on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:35AM (#33918671)
It's not really about the accent. It's just that companies that outsource to Asia do so because they value the cost over quality. Because obviously in-house and in-region support is much better because the agents are more up to speed on the company and to the user's environment.

This expresses itself in other aspects than just location, and often the people working there have no product knowledge and just follow scripts. Because knowledgeable workers cost more. Works ok for 80% of the interactions but it really sucks if you're the 20% not covered by a script.

This gives Asian callcenters and the associated accent a bad name and leads to a kneejerk reaction from customers as the accent brings up memories of previous frustrating experiences.

Of course companies try to avoid this already with the mentioned software and also by moving to regions with more American-sounding people like the Philippines.

I worked in contact center management before and I've seen this effect a lot.

I'm sure there's excellent contact centers in the region too, but they have an uphill battle to prove themselves as most simply aren't.

Re:Tell HN: Tired of Hearing about ChatGPT by aiisjustanif on Tuesday December 06, 2022 @11:56PM (#33890758)
Apply this line of thought to most societal and social norms and it gets rather ugly.