News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by brnt on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:00AM (#33593980)
So, having been around since the early bitcoin days, core to the salespitch back then was the fact you would have control. You'd have your coins in your wallet, and no need for banks etc. Apparently nobody does this anymore, and gives their wallets to these exchanges (i.e. banks) and balks when the obvious happens in pyramid schemes. People just don't get distributed currency if they promptly undistribute it.

Or is it I who's going the not getting things?

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by kkielhofner on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:33AM (#33594439)
As I've noted before on HN the entire concept of people being able to manage their own wallets flies against everything we know about people. People forget stuff, make mistakes, and lose things. The margin of error for a hardware wallet is tiny. It's not rare for crypto forums, twitter, etc to prescribe completely ridiculous processes and systems for securing wallets, backing up seed phrases, etc. There's an entire cottage industry built around people etching their seed phrases on steel plates for people to (I'm not kidding) bury them like they're gold in the 1800s.

Plus funds in a wallet require extra steps when you want to trade on an exchange (extra costs via gas, time, possible errors, etc). The use cases for crypto are so minimal for the general population one could argue it's only survived this long through making trades on exchanges - to what essentially amounts to gambling. You can't gamble with funds in a wallet which defeats the entire purpose of crypto for the vast majority of the "users" in the space.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by nanna on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:39AM (#33594530)
> As I've noted before on HN

One of the joys of HN is that on the whole no one knows who anyone else really is nor keeps track of what they've argued previously.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by skinnymuch on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:04AM (#33596021)
Some of us put out real info in our profiles.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by zen21 on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:36AM (#33596665)
Some people copy and paste other people’s profile info into their profiles.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by CliffStoll on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:23PM (#33597494)
some of us use our real names
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by skinnymuch on Monday November 14, 2022 @04:21PM (#33601300)
haha I never thought of that.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by dmitriid on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @02:09AM (#33606192)
Some of us are meat popsicles.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by timemct on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:59AM (#33594890)
> There's an entire cottage industry built around people etching their seed phrases on steel plates for people to (I'm not kidding) bury them like they're gold in the 1800s.

"I write these words in steel, for anything not set in metal cannot be trusted." - The Well of Ascension, by Brandon Sanderson

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by bussierem on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:19AM (#33596313)
I know this type of comment (and my own) is more common to reddit and commonly frowned upon in HN threads, but by god this made my morning thank you.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by Karzyn on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:42AM (#33596771)
FYI, that's what the little arrow next to their name is for.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by narcraft on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:54AM (#33597018)
I like this informative reply
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by poulpi on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:41AM (#33596739)
Actually, if you want something to stay, you should go for stone rather than metal.

Stone have low market value while metal can always be melted to do something else (like weapons).

It's one of my main take away of my art history lessons -> most antic art done on metal has been lost, but the stone remains!

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by itronitron on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:39PM (#33597789)
A friend of mine would use fiberglass resin, bondo, and plywood because they wanted their sculptures, which they then boxed into custom-sized crates, to last for at least one hundred years.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by inasio on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:26PM (#33604494)
That was also what they went with in the 3 body problem
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by pcthrowaway on Monday November 14, 2022 @06:43PM (#33603066)
I think certain types of metal have the advantage of being more likely to survive a fire, but I'm not sure.

Stone is susceptible to cracking/shattering if caught in a house fire right?

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by smileybarry on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:19AM (#33595218)
> There's an entire cottage industry built around people etching their seed phrases on steel plates for people to (I'm not kidding) bury them like they're gold in the 1800s.

I was stunned to see so many of these products on Amazon last time I searched for smartcard stuff. On that note, I hate that you can't search for smartcard products anymore without 80% of your results being crypto wallets.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by zen21 on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:38AM (#33596704)
It’s a great way to make money out of crypto!
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by wedn3sday on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:56AM (#33597044)
If there's one thing we should learn from gold rushes, its that you dont make it rich panning for gold, you make it rich selling gold panning gear.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by MichaelCollins on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:36AM (#33595516)
Print your private key on paper and lose it all when your house burns down.

vs

Give your private key to an exchange, and enrich the shitheads running the exchange when they run away with your money.

First option seems preferable. If you're going to lose your money, better for the money to be truly lost than to enrich a thief.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by 8ytecoder on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:00AM (#33595956)
Print your key works fine if I’m locking my “money” under a mattress. If the point of Bitcoin I was to replace currency then I’d still need an easy way to keep it close with my all times. So, carry your signed transfer title to your house in the wallet and lose your entire house to a mugging seems more appropriate as an analogy.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by andybak on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:01AM (#33595971)
> If you're going to lose your money, better for the money to be truly lost than to enrich a thief.

I'd quite like an option C

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by HideousKojima on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:22PM (#33597484)
Become a goldbug?
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by nemo44x on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:04AM (#33596024)
You could put it in a fireproof safe or a safety deposit box or both.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by horsawlarway on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:08AM (#33596106)
Can we acknowledge that both of those options are utter trash compared to conventional banking, though?

The system that the crypto advocates hate on, but provides 250k per person + per bank + per account type as insurance by default to all registered financial institutions?

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by tablespoon on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:38AM (#33596706)
> Can we acknowledge that both of those options are utter trash compared to conventional banking, though?

Yes, yes we can.

The only things that ever justified the use of cryptocurrency were ideological fantasies and speculative gambling. Every other justification is just hype created as a post-hoc rationalization for one of those two things. If you look at any of them closely, they completely fall apart when compared with competitor technologies (such as fiat paper money esp. the US dollar, conventional banking, and even gold).

I look forward to a future where "crypto" again unambiguously means cryptography.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by alasdair_ on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:49AM (#33596895)
Buying drugs online was a real use case that actually worked, as was being able to smuggle wealth out of a country with exit restrictions.

As for legal uses, yeah, there are not many at the moment. Maybe some day there will be a DAO-type org that is worth being invested in or something but not today.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by tablespoon on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:53AM (#33596982)
> Buying drugs online was a real use case that actually worked,

Kinda sorta. Wasn't that back when people assumed cryptocurrency provided the same kind of privacy that cryptography does, which was (in retrospect), pretty dumb?

> as was being able to smuggle wealth out of a country with exit restrictions.

That one doesn't make much sense either. How are you supposed to get your cryptocurrency to smuggle out in such a country? Wire your money to a foreign exchange?

> As for legal uses, yeah, there are not many at the moment. Maybe some day there will be a DAO-type org that is worth being invested in or something but not today.

I agree the "best" actual use cases involve illegal activity, but I think even those are sketchy. Most of the ideas don't actually work unless cryptocurrency is ubiquitous, but that doesn't matter since it will never become ubiquitous without compelling use cases. And given the illegal activity it enables, even if it did have compelling use cases, it would probably be made illegal if it was on its way to becoming ubiquitous (which would instantly marginalize it in a way it could never overcome).

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by alasdair_ on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:12PM (#33597304)
For me, my one and only use of crypto (back in the day) was to put it through a mixer and then use it to pay for hosting for some TOR exit nodes in Iceland that I didn't want tied to me personally.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by tablespoon on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:53PM (#33598973)
> For me, my one and only use of crypto (back in the day) was to put it through a mixer and then use it to pay for hosting for some TOR exit nodes in Iceland that I didn't want tied to me personally.

That use case at least makes some sense and isn't illegal, but there are probably only dozens of users who'd ever want to do something like that, which isn't enough to support a payment ecosystem.

There are also probably conventional alternatives that probably work for that. I'm somewhat paranoid about getting doxxed based on some teenage internet experiences. There are a couple of forums out there with paywalls that exist mainly to reduce moderator workload, and (10-15) years ago I was able to subscribe with a combination of Visa gift cards and PayPal. The gift cards let you enter (un-validated) identity information so they could be used like credit cards online, and PayPal didn't seem to like them but there was a long delay before they were detected. So I created a throwaway PayPal account with a small-denomination gift card as a payment source, paid for the membership, and abandoned the PayPal account (which would eventually get locked).

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by sweetbitter on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:39PM (#33599747)
> Kinda sorta. Wasn't that back when people assumed cryptocurrency provided the same kind of privacy that cryptography does, which was (in retrospect), pretty dumb?

Well, there are currencies that do provide strong anonymity, so no?

But yeah agreed that cryptocurrency doesn't have that many use cases, just as cash has a declining number of them. I hope someone makes an Amazon-like platform for it.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by MichaelCollins on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:31AM (#33596551)
Abso-fucking-lutely. The best time to not be involved in crypto was always, and the second best time is now. Get out now if you have any sense.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by nobody9999 on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:34PM (#33600605)
>Abso-fucking-lutely. The best time to not be involved in crypto was always, and the second best time is now. Get out now if you have any sense.

But I have drugs to buy and cannabis to smoke and joints to roll before I sleep.[0]

More seriously, there are use cases for cryptocurrency (smart contracts are a different think, unaddressed here), they're just mostly illegal.

Whether that illegality is appropriate or not is another question.

That said, there are use cases for cryptocurrency.

[0] With apologies to Robert Frost.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by dmitriid on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @02:13AM (#33606218)
> smart contracts are a different think, unaddressed here

Let me address this, then:

- they are not smart

- they are not contracts

- they are programs written in esoteric programming languages running on world's slowest and most inefficient VM

- due to esoteric nature their own authors cannot find trivial bugs in their implementations that are exploited at scale which would make any real platform nonviable

- cannot be updated or reverted because blockchain

- have literally no use outside the virtual imaginary world of crypto

- have zero legal standing, and cannot be enforced

- in every single case would be more efficient and better served by Visual Basic running on a single Raspberry Pi from a sqlite database.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by zeroclip on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @03:38AM (#33606768)
Do you really feel that Uniswap is better run with sqlite on a Raspberry Pi? If so, you are advocating for putting your money into a CEX, because somebody has to own and control that database and physical device.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by dmitriid on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:11AM (#33606955)
> Do you really feel that Uniswap is better run with sqlite on a Raspberry Pi?

Literally everything I wrote applies to Uniswap.

> because somebody has to own and control that database and physical device.

You've missed the point completely.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by zeroclip on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:19AM (#33607000)
Your point is that centralized financial services on sqlite is good, decentralized protocols on a blockchain is bad? If that is your point, it's a funny one to make in a thread about a CEX collapsing.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by dmitriid on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @04:58AM (#33607249)
> Your point is that centralized financial services on sqlite is good, decentralized protocols on a blockchain is bad?

Where exactly in this comment did I say that: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33606218?

> If that is your point, it's a funny one to make in a thread about a CEX collapsing.

What's funny is inventing arguments for other people and valiantly fighting against them.

"Smart contracts" were mentioned as "other uses of crypto currency, as yet unaddressed". I addressed them. I couldn't even care less how you made the illogical leap from that to whatever you accuse me of.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by zeroclip on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @05:36AM (#33607553)
Uniswap is a good application of smart contracts. Your comments explicitly suggest that Uniswap would be better run on something like sqlite, which needs a centralized owner, which is functionally the same as replacing a DEX with a CEX.

> in every single case would be more efficient and better served by Visual Basic running on a single Raspberry Pi from a sqlite database

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by dmitriid on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @06:01AM (#33607730)
Funny how out of 8 points listed, all you've latched onto a single one.

Let me rewrite this on point in a single sentence "this ineffecient unenforceable bug-ridden fest that can only use the imaginary tokens can be run more efficiently from a single Raspberry Pi".

Does this help?

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by zeroclip on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:03AM (#33608115)
I'm not sure you are replying in good faith.

But, you are still making the claim that a decentralized smart contract protocol would be better replaced with a centralized traditional database on a Raspberry Pi. We disagree.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by dmitriid on Tuesday November 15, 2022 @07:31AM (#33608322)
> I'm not sure you are replying in good faith.

Come on. You started with assigning me arguments and thoughts I never said and thought.

> you are still making the claim that a decentralized smart contract protocol would be better replaced with a centralized traditional database on a Raspberry Pi.

A person who claims that their opponent makes arguments in bad faith ignores everything their opponent says and keeps pretending their opponent said something he didn't.

There are eight bullet points. Read them. Understand them. However, I'm not going to continue this conversation.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by dvngnt_ on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:33AM (#33596597)
I've never seen it as a replacement, but a supplement with it's own pros and cons
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by gureddio on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:52AM (#33596960)
Well it can't be a replacement anyway. You can't really spend it anywhere
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by rglullis on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:32AM (#33596583)
Have you seen how much wealth was destroyed in 2008?
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by Filligree on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:38AM (#33596691)
2008 doesn't seem like a good argument for "Re-running the entire history of finance scams, up to and including 2008 if we can get that far".
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by rglullis on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:45AM (#33596810)
2008 wasn't caused by a finance scam. It was caused by an already heavily-regulated banking industry, supported by governments addicted to growth.

Not that different from what is happening now with the crypto "exchanges", by the way.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by bboygravity on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:59AM (#33597105)
Wow, you must've missed that little something about Glass Steagal.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by rglullis on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:31PM (#33597631)
Wow, you must've missed the point entirely.

I'm talking about how both bubbles were a consequence of all the money being pumped relentlessly by governments. That it was going to pop, we should not have no doubt. If it wasn't for crypto "exchanges", it would be a dot-com v2 (bigger and badder), or it would be something else entirely... but at the end of the day, as long as we have governments addicted to growth, we will have boom and bust cycles.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by rufusroflpunch on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:49AM (#33596897)
In Lebanon, people are robbing banks to get their own money out. Maybe they are a little bit more comfortable than you are with holding keys to an unseizable asset.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by asoneth on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:37PM (#33597744)
If you live in the US and are hedging against the collapse of the FDIC you may be better served by investing in things like dried goods and seeds than cryptocurrencies.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by horsawlarway on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:33PM (#33599642)
Correct.

Banking may well collapse in the US (I'm not betting it will - quite the opposite, to be honest - but historically speaking it's not an impossibility.)

The issue is that if banking in the US collapses... well - we have much, much bigger issues than "crypto". You'd be far better served with a stash of dried/canned products and a gun or three.

Also - it won't be crypto that matters in this case. It will be the new currency of whatever regional nation states pop up in the US after the collapse, or if the federal gov manages to hang on, the new USD.

Side note - last time I bought in bulk (because hedging against this is relatively cheap, all things considered) split peas were the best bang for the buck in terms of cost/calorie. Just slightly beating out plain white sugar.

75 days of food for 4 people at 2000 calories per day cost about $350 (not including storage containers) and will last a very long time if it's composed of dried legumes, flour, oats, sugar, rice, oil, etc... in airtight containers.

If you cook yourself and rotate through, it's actually a fairly cost effective way to eat cheap and healthy (although without any additional inputs - also very bland) while also keeping storage on hand and not feeling like a complete prepper.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by alextheghost on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:08AM (#33596110)
You do know there are fireproof safes that you can keep in your home right?
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by SV_BubbleTime on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:23AM (#33596395)
FYI, there is a world of BS around "fire proof" anything. It's all about the time it's around fire.

If your house burns to the ground and collapses in on itself, the extreme majority of fire proof safes, aren't. If the fire dept shows up and it's out in an hour and it wasn't buried, your things will probably be alright.

I dealt with a guy's gun collection stored in his $10,000 "fire proof" safe stored in his garage. Almost everything was garbage. Saved a handful of parts here and there.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by alangibson on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:42AM (#33596757)
Exactly. Given enough time the inside of the safe will be the same temperature as the outside.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by bbarnett on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:57AM (#33597079)
No, man, it's like insulated and stuff!
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by alana314 on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:32AM (#33596580)
Put it on encrypted distributed backup that you control. I don't know why more people don't do this.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by unilynx on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:50AM (#33596918)
How do you manage the keys to this encrypted backup ?
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by notch656a on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:47AM (#33596856)
I'm amazed how many people think the average person can't memorize a 12 word phrase. Most people I know can memorize their social security number, address, at least one if not more passwords, their own phone number as well as the phone number of at least one loved one for emergencies, the DOB of their children and their own DOB. Most of that is a gobligook of numbers rather than words.

Absolutely no one needs to be putting a private key on paper in their house, that is insanity.

---------------

RE:

>The question is if you can reliably remember it in ten or twenty years without ever using it in the interim.

I check my bank account daily for fraudulent transactions; it would behoove anyone storing any sizeable amount of value to check/refresh on that daily, however that looks like for your form of storage.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by alasdair_ on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:50AM (#33596925)
>I'm amazed how many people think the average person can't memorize a 12 word phrase.

The question is if you can reliably remember it in ten or twenty years without ever using it in the interim.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by boppo1 on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:54AM (#33595825)
>There's an entire cottage industry built around people etching their seed phrases on steel plates for people to (I'm not kidding) bury them like they're gold in the 1800s.

I was about to say this isn't the worst opsec until I realized you mean people are sending businesses their passphrases and not purchasing an etching kit to make the plate themselves.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by ChadNauseam on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:08AM (#33596094)
Your first instinct was right, they come with little steel squares with individual letters pre-etched, and when you receive them you arrange them yourself into your seed phrase
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by SV_BubbleTime on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:17AM (#33596277)
The venn of arts and crafts, paranoid delusions, and blockchain.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by sydd on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:32AM (#33596588)
Heh I would not call them paranoid after all these crypto collapses.

Say I'd have $100000 in a crypto wallet, I'd etch it too and keep it in a safe instead of giving it to a website with no state backed guarantees.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by danaris on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:44AM (#33596792)
The delusion part is believing that it would still be worth $100k after an amount of time that would warrant burying something in the ground.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by zukzuk on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:44AM (#33596809)
The paranoia pertains to burying metal plates underground, preparing for a post-collapse future. As if bitcoin will be a viable currency when we're all trying to figure out food and shelter.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by 2sk21 on Monday November 14, 2022 @05:10PM (#33601978)
Also, this assumes that there is plentiful electricity in this post apocalyptic future to mine bitcoins!
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by grey-area on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:49AM (#33596896)
You could just print it on a piece of paper and put it in a safe!
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by JackFr on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:50AM (#33596919)
The funny part of that is that you literally cannot have $1000000 in a crypto wallet, because that's not how dollars work. Oh, you've got something in your crypto wallet, but it ain't dollars.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by matai_kolila on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:54AM (#33597021)
Of course he can have $100,000 in his wallet, that $80k will be usable to exchange in return for $50k of goods, for sure!
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by defterGoose on Monday November 14, 2022 @07:33PM (#33603547)
It's still some of the worst opsec if they're literally burying steel and expecting that to be hunky dory.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by Animats on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:53AM (#33597002)
There's a market here for a safe way to store crypto. Something like a thing you carry with you, a thing you can keep at home, a thing you have a friend hold, a thing you have in a safety deposit box, and info a service holds for you. Some combination of majority votes, time delays in days or weeks, and warning messages lets you recover from loss and damage. With backup from an insurance company. But nobody has addressed that market.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by bredren on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:58AM (#33597090)
Variations of this have been tried many times, for example hardware wallets.

But a lot of this is too troublesome or adds too many hoops to jump through than is practical for many people.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by Animats on Monday November 14, 2022 @03:43PM (#33600724)
Yes. Someone has to get the user experience right.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by bredren on Monday November 14, 2022 @04:49PM (#33601710)
FWIW, that user experience is most likely Coinbase, or something very much like Coinbase. Not only is the UX good, but customer funds are taken seriously now and have been for a long time.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by Animats on Monday November 14, 2022 @08:42PM (#33604189)
Coinbase still has custody of customer assets, though. That's what has to be either eliminated or insured to avoid trouble.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by bredren on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:28PM (#33604893)
To avoid what trouble, specifically?

If it’s risk of customer funds mismanagement, coinbase is just not in the same galaxy as the folks who have blown customer trust.

If it’s securing funds, to prevent hacks, CB offers cold storage. Lumps of crypto can be transferred out of their control as needed to manage risk.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by chromatin on Monday November 14, 2022 @04:00PM (#33600962)
I can speak only about Bitcoin, not "cryptocurrencies" generally (and in fact, all of the real innovation in secure storage that I am aware of is happening on Bitcoin, with crypto lagging by many years).

> But nobody has addressed that market.

Au contraire! You've correctly identified an important market! There is both existing work and ongoing development that tries to satisfy exactly what you've asked about (and doesn't involve burying etched steel plates).

Encumbering your bitcoin with the requirement for multiple, M of N threshold signatures ("multisig") is an important way to protect large amounts. Companies like Unchained Capital [0] provide a service wherein the user holds two keys and the company holds 1 key in a 2-of-3 multisig setup; if the company key is needed, video authentication and other procedures are required.

Other, non-company-assisted multisig setups use schemes such as you propose; one example is the Nunchuk wallet [1] which allows you to sign multisig transactions on your own, or request signature(s) from a key held by a family member or friend, passing the PSBT (partially signed Bitcoin transaction) over a secure communication channel.

Finally, two great examples of physical devices to protect your Bitcoin are (1) the Tapsigner [2], which is an NFC-enabled smartcard holding your secp256k1 private key that does on-card signatures; and (2) Jack Dorsey's Block (formerly Square) is developing a hardware wallet that integrates with your smartphone [3] -- one neat innovation here is that policies can be set such that the user may spend small amounts of funds with the phone only; but larger transactions require a thumbprint or pin on a physical device.

You also mentioned time delays -- this is also supported by Bitcoin script; advancements such as miniscript [4] allow you to express complex spending conditions in a tree-like way.

[0] https://www.unchained.com/ [1] https://nunchuk.io/ [2] https://tapsigner.com/ [3] https://wallet.build/ [4] https://miniscript.fun/

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by rchaud on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:15AM (#33594176)
> Apparently nobody does this anymore, and gives their wallets to these exchanges (i.e. banks) and balks when the obvious happens in pyramid schemes.

The name of the game is pump and dump, you can't play the game (speculation) if you're not on the field (the exchange).

Crypto's marketing is 'financial freedom' as in get-rich-quick, not free as in libre.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by qudat on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:32AM (#33594429)
That's right. Not to mention the transaction fees are so high that moving from a wallet you own to an exchange can cost non-insignificant amount of money.

Add on top of that the general volatility of crypto, people not wanting to deal with maintaining their own wallet, and you have a recipe for people keeping their funds on exchanges.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by bogomipz on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:35AM (#33595492)
>"Not to mention the transaction fees are so high that moving from a wallet you own to an exchange can cost non-insignificant amount of money."

I realize that transaction fees are probably a moving target but is there a ballpark figure you or someone else could say? I'm guessing it's percentage-based?

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by xanthrax on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:27AM (#33596465)
It is not percentage based but based on the demand for the next block space. That demand is on the basis who will pay the most per byte for each transaction so your is based on the number of bytes in your transaction (usually directly proportional to the number of inputs and outputs) and how quickly you want it in the next block. Currently about 44 cents will guarantee you in the next block - note this is a moving target based on the competition for block space. mempool.space is a good visualisation.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by michaelt on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:56AM (#33597049)
According to https://ycharts.com/indicators/bitcoin_average_transaction_f... it's varied between $2 and $0.5 in the last 6 months. There have been times (mid-2021) where it was >$20 for a single payment.

Needless to say, this is much more affordable for a million-dollar transaction than for buying a cup of coffee :)

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by qudat on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:00PM (#33597121)
I used to trade with eth every once in awhile. It wasn't uncommon for a tx fee to be on the order of $5-20.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by ncallaway on Monday November 14, 2022 @02:54PM (#33599983)
> I realize that transaction fees are probably a moving target but is there a ballpark figure you or someone else could say?

I'll give the answer for Bitcoin as of a couple of years ago, and others can chime in for things like Etherium and other cryptocurrencies.

With bitcoin it's not a fixed fee, it's more like a priority bid. So, there's a pool of "pending" transactions that any miner can grab from. Each pending transaction has a bid for its transaction fee. Each miner will then grab whatever set of transaction it wants to bundle into a block, and try and compute the hash for that block. Once a miner finds a hash for that block, all the transactions in that block are added to the chain and the transaction is "complete" (in practice, people will often wait until one or two blocks are added _after_ the transaction is included in the block chain to be _sure_ it's done).

So, to your question, ultimately the transaction fee is a bid for how quickly you want your transaction included. You can bid $0, and it's likely your transaction will _never_ be included. It doesn't really matter how _much_ you're transferring, but _how quickly_ you need it included in the chain.

How much you'd practically pay for a transaction (in USD) has been super variable over the lifetime of Bitcoin. It fluctuates with how many miners there are, how many transactions are happening, and the exchange rate of BTC to USD (since the feeds are paid in BTC). See the chart at the bottom of this page: https://privacypros.io/tools/bitcoin-fee-estimator/

It looks like it's generally between $0.75-$1.00 right now. So if you're making a transaction of $1M the fee is trivial, but if you're buying a cup of coffee for $5 it's...pretty high.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by julianlam on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:11AM (#33594122)
No, that's exactly it. People love the idea of decentralization and doing things on your own, except then they realize that it's actually kind of hard to be off-exchange and still be liquid (whatever the hell that means in crypto-land).

So basically no real change except they're much more exposed to risk (fraud and market swings notwithstanding)

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by tomjakubowski on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:25AM (#33594317)
I think so many cryptocurrency users avoid maintaining their own wallet for the same reasons most people (these days) don't store all their wealth as cash or gold under the mattress: it's both inconvenient and easy to lose.

Of course what folks are seeing now is that it's real easy for exchanges to lose their buttcoin deposits too.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by 0xAFFFF on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:24AM (#33594292)
The core truth in this day and age is that nobody (understand this a non-significant minority if you prefer) wants to host their own stuff. It's way more convenient to use centralized services that do the heavy lifting for you. If you don't have that convenience, you can't have mass adoption.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by Watchwatcher on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:50AM (#33595735)
Another way to say, you reap what you sow, right?
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by dralley on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:31AM (#33594412)
Distributed currency turns out to be too difficult for most people, and a currency that only 5% of the population can use isn't very useful.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by matt_s on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:24AM (#33594299)
I think once crypto gained traction beyond early adopters into more mainstream people it became an "app" and that "app" was the exchange and non tech, non crypto people don't put more effort into it then that.

What is alarming and becoming more revealing is how much of this crypto was being back-doored from one crypto "product" (exchange, fund, coin, ICO, etc.) into another. In programmer terminology: it looks like there are (were) a lot of pointers to the same memory address.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by spamizbad on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:24AM (#33594290)
Most people hold Bitcoin these days in the hopes of making money. The distributed consensus nature of crypto is irrelevant.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by Ajedi32 on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:50AM (#33596911)
This is the key to understanding a lot of things about the "cryptocurrency community". There are two groups there with wildly different interests.

A large chunk (probably even a majority) of the people involved in the cryptocurrency space don't actually care about cryptocurrency as a technology at all, they're just there to make money. To these people, market price is everything, and the technology is irrelevant except to the extent that it affects the market price.

Then in the other camp there's a group of people who don't care about the current trading price, they're just interested in the technology and the new capabilities it enables.

I'm in that second camp (perhaps unsurprisingly, since this is Hacker News), so in my view this story isn't really all that interesting or surprising. From a legal/societal perspective, yeah this is terrible and probably someone should go to jail. But from a technical perspective, the fact that exchanges can scam people out of their money is hardly new information. As the saying goes: not your keys, not your crypto.

Though obviously for those who are interested in cryptocurrency solely to make money on speculation, yeah this is a big story.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by knorker on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:23AM (#33594278)
You're not taking crazy pills. It's become abundantly clear that the vision of everybody being their own bank will never work.

People don't want to be their own bank, just like they don't want to be their own bakery, or their own farmer.

Sure, some people do bake their own bread, but they do it either because they have to, or because they enjoy it.

So the people who control their own keys need to have a reason to do so. Because it takes more effort than not managing your own bank.

What exactly are the reasons to run your own bank? What problems in your life are solved by it?

I can think of a two:

* You want to hold more cash than FDIC guarantees. * You think the government will seize money out of savings accounts, as happened in Cyprus.

These have to be weighed against the facts that while not literally in your mattress, the money becomes pretty easy to steal, for anyone willing to point a gun at you. And being your own bank comes with obligations, too, so the government will come after you if they want to drain your bank. And the justice system can put you in a box if you don't comply.

Basically: If you already have a bank, why would you not just use it? And if they refuse to do your thing (like order a hit), then buy tokens and pay a hitman in tokens.

If there were FDIC for tokens at your real bank, redeemable in same number of tokens, then any general public that wanted to use cryptocurrency would likely just use that. Because outside of fringe LARPing nobody wants to run their own bank.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:25AM (#33594321)
> You want to hold more cash than FDIC guarantees

This is a solved problem up to millions of dollars [1]. The real third case is you’re doing something illegal.

[1] https://accountopening.fidelity.com/ftgw/aong/aongapp/fdicBa...

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by mikeyouse on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:01AM (#33594917)
Yeah - there's a whole industry of this.. I worked with a large nonprofit that had something like $50M FDIC insured through CDARs.

https://www.intrafinetworkdeposits.com/

I suspect the government / Fed will have something to say about these in the future since it's a bit contra the purpose/intent of FDIC insurance but for the moment, you can abstract away all of the complications.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by eternalban on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:37AM (#33594507)
> Basically: If you already have a bank, why would you not just use it?

Basic corollary: if you already use a bank, why not just use money?

> If there were FDIC for tokens at your real bank, redeemable in same number of tokens, then any general public that wanted to use cryptocurrency would likely just use that. Because outside of fringe LARPing nobody wants to run their own bank.

So the only remaining question is why would normies who say (according to you) amen to all above would need crypto besides a ponzi-speculative joy ride?

On one had we have funny money backed by a world power and all its resources, and protected by ICBMs and an impressive navy and bases around the world and a financial infrastructure around USD & convertibles.

On the other hand we have funny tokens issued by "genius" -mushrooms- who are elevated into the spotlight by the likes of Forbes magazine and the rest of the media circus, protected by nothing [though the genius scammers themselves are apparently protected ..]

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by knorker on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:46AM (#33594665)
> So the only remaining question is why would normies who say (according to you) amen to all above would need crypto

Exactly. They don't. Not as a currency. It's gambling. And "normies" don't want to run a bank just to gamble.

> money backed by a world power and all its resources, and protected by ICBMs

And e.g. in the US the USD is not just protected from outside threat (ultimately) by ICBMs, but also internally by the fact that tax is due in USD.

There are cryptocurrency advocates who say that the USD is backed by nothing. Which is a very odd thing to say because as long as the US has tax laws there will be demand for the USD (under penalty of prison), to pay your taxes. Demand for a thing creates value for that thing.

Anyone who thinks that backing is not real is likely to feel the physical effects of its reality.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by asoneth on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:50AM (#33594731)
The use of intermediaries is due to the deficient user experience of cryptocurrencies and cryptocurrency community:

1) They downplay the expertise and knowledge required to manage your own tokens.

2) They advocate for the use of cryptocurrencies by normal (i.e. non-expert) users as this increases the value of their holdings.

3) They prefer to blame users who make mistakes, are hacked/scammed, or otherwise lose (real) money for their lack of technical expertise.

Given this, it's not surprising that the enormous gap between naive engineering assumptions and human reality is filled by intermediaries despite how consistently they fail. As long as cryptocurrencies continue to exist beyond a tiny niche I don't see this changing.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by nobody9999 on Monday November 14, 2022 @04:17PM (#33601222)
Agreed.

The knowledge gap between "normies" and "crypto-aficionados" is pretty large.

Which is, of course, why so many crypto "businesses" turn out to be scams of one sort or another -- the asymmetry of information makes most folks easy meat for scammers.

To point up this asymmetry, go ahead and watch this[0]. The lack of knowledge WRT crypto-currencies (let alone smart contracts) among the hoi polloi is striking in comparison to those who are in the know.

[0] https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/crypto-decoded/ (Recent NOVA episode).

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by ineedasername on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:51AM (#33594741)
You get things, I think, but bitcoin’s transaction bottleneck meant it was never going to be able to handle anything approaching wide scale adoption for day to day transactions. Attempts to address that with other coins or centralized exchanges is at least one of the major factors that lead to this point.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by phone8675309 on Monday November 14, 2022 @09:54AM (#33594815)
The people who were pushing the fact that you'd have sole control over your wallet were those who wanted to be immune from the government seizing their money: scammers, criminals, tax dodgers, and exchange runners (a combination of the first three).

Those people put a bunch of money into bitcoin to inflate the price, but they need a bunch of rubes trading the currency to keep the value of the coin (relatively) stable so they can withdraw their holdings, but they don't care much if those rubes have full control, and that's where exchanges come in.

Exchanges are there as a way for the first movers and the ultra-wealthy to extract wealth from uninformed, naive new investors into crypto.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by cypress66 on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:36AM (#33595517)
> The people who were pushing the fact that you'd have sole control over your wallet were those who wanted to be immune from the government seizing their money: scammers, criminals, tax dodgers, and exchange runners

How sad that you think the only people that cares about not giving governments control of everything are "scammers, criminals, tax dodgers, and exchange runners".

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by tootie on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:02AM (#33594936)
I read an interesting thread on why this isn't a pyramid scheme. Basically there's no one at the top. It's decentralized so there's a loose federation of edges arranged in a many-sided polygon. So we need a new name. Instead of Ponzi, this is a Nakamoto Scheme.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by oblio on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:34AM (#33595485)
That's much better. It's not a monopoly, it's an oligopoly :-)
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by abruzzi on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:36AM (#33595506)
DePy - decentralized pyramid.

I say this in jest. There are more than one reason to be interested in crypto, but when bitcoin suddenly went from 1BTC=USD$1 to $1BTC=USD$100 (I don't actually know when the boom happened--I wasn't watching that closely) the individualist, libertarians were obscured by the quick-buck types looking to turn their thousand into a million. Thats when the scammers all came out.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by tylersmith on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:09AM (#33595070)
Many people are managing our own coins, you just don't hear from us because we don't get burned every year.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by ryandrake on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:02AM (#33595993)
Somehow, humanity has gotten good at taking systems that were designed to be decentralized and distributed (like crypto, E-mail, personal websites, and so on) and instead, surrender them to a few big companies who become single points of failure. We keep failing to learn from this every time.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by Apocryphon on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:16AM (#33596266)
It’s almost as if most people are too busy to figure out the complex processes at doing things themselves, and the very concept of civilization is built on exchanging good and services for money whereby tasks are delegated to parties that are better suited to focus on them.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by asoneth on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:58PM (#33598084)
I suspect the problem is due to the fact that designers of decentralized systems often underestimate the importance of the user experience.

Managing your own mail server, website, social media instance, music streaming, cryptocurrency wallet, power grid, vegetable garden, etc requires more time and skill than just paying someone else to do it for you. The result is that most people end up using a handful of centralized offerings except for a small niche of enthusiasts who derive enjoyment from the work and/or can justify spending the additional time.

Ultimately it's up to the designers of distributed systems to make them trivially easy to use if they want them to be popular and remain distributed. (Napster and maybe BitTorrent are the examples that come to mind.) Otherwise it remains a niche for enthusiasts and/or ends up with centralized intermediaries.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by goodoldneon on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:28AM (#33595365)
You still have people with their own wallet. But the vast majority of people don't want to deal with the complexity of decentralization so they prefer centralization
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by chasd00 on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:54AM (#33595823)
I think the vast vast majority of people just want to increase the balance of their checking account. The fastest way to do that with crypto is speculating on an exchange. I bet 95% of the people getting burned on these exchanges don't even know what a "wallet" is (in the context of crypto currencies).
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by fleddr on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:41AM (#33595595)
The thing is that the people that are most active in crypto and typically have the largest stacks are traders. They grow their stack by shorting/longing, leverage, staking and DeFi, all of which require an exchange.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by zeroclip on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:48AM (#33595703)
A lot of crypto investors are day traders or naive hodlers who have no idea what blockchain and DeFi means. But DeFi protocols like Uniswap and Aave are holding up fine and are incapable of pausing user withdrawals.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by alasdair_ on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:58AM (#33597092)
There is still the question of how to convert your crypto to actual spendable dollars again. Sure, uniswap will let you get another token but you still need an exchange to get dollars. This gets particularly important when, say, the giant scam that is Tether finally crashes and burns,
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by zeroclip on Monday November 14, 2022 @01:09PM (#33598285)
Yes, a regulated centralized exchange is valuable for on and off ramp. All they would need to do is process user transactions, take a small fee, and not gamble with user funds. Regulators could do audits and keep consumers protected.

But regulators have failed to provide clear framework for exchanges in the US[1], so most CEXes are running off shore.

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2022/11/11/op-ed-crypto-markets-need-re...

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by probiab on Monday November 14, 2022 @10:58AM (#33595907)
You do have control. You can start your own blockchain and keep the transactions flowing. Of course, transactions imply other people will use your chain. It's like you can create value not by gold, or tobacco, or even math, but by the very trust people have in your asset. And this brings us to a concept that some may be familiar with but is relatively new to the crypto community. A new kind of coin is here.

This is a concept that probably never existed before crypto, called "fiat." "fiat" is the latest and greatest in crypto technology. True decentralization. Multiple countries. Multiple municipalities. Multiple systems, multiple institutions, multiple protocols and multiple contracts, the picture of decentralization that crypto could only dream of. And of course, if you make a mistake, you can revert your transaction, a form of technology crypto has not yet mastered. Oh, NFTs? Please. "fiat" utilizes advanced art international HS92 commodities exchange codes to kick start the burgeoning modern art scene of completely legitimate businesses.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by kypro on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:08AM (#33596112)
I think it depends on your goals.

I mean, do you store all your cash under your bed in case your bank go bust? People keep crypto on the exchange because it makes transactions easier, and in some cases you might have other perks such as being able to lend it for interest or spend it with crypto credit cards.

This idea that you can have a digital currency without some kind of bank or exchange is fundamentally flawed imo. Unless you believe the only valid usecase of crypto is as a digital alternative to physical gold then it probably makes more sense on an exchange. The main issue here is that the exchanges are not regulated.

But I suppose given the lack of regulation I would have to agree with you that the only safe use case right now is as a "store of value" in a cold wallet.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by amadeuspagel on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:30AM (#33596529)
> Apparently nobody does this anymore

The right way to do that is to use a hardware wallet. There are many companies making and selling those, so there's definitely a market for that.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by runeb on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:33AM (#33596607)
That is still the promise and unlock of cryptographic currencies. But that does not seem to be the use case for much of the people I've seen in the space the last years. I think the fact it is crypto currencies is incidental, it is all about earning money through appreciation of some popular asset.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by dqpb on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:35AM (#33596634)
I do this (for the most part). Whenever I buy currency on an exchange, I Immediately transfer it to a personal wallet. This is actually what drove me away from anything based on Ethereum, because the transfer speed and fee system for Ethereum is so horrendous, I found myself leaving that currency in the exchange managed wallets.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by ransom1538 on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:40AM (#33596731)
Fuck. Exchanges. Fuck them. I lost all my money in the early days to an exchange. I knew no better it was too early.
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by treffer on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:40AM (#33596736)
Well, run a full bitcoin node. I am doing thwt.

It's close to just running your own email / fileserver etc. IMHO.

So while possible it's also annoying and not worth it for most people, and I get that.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by pc86 on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:43AM (#33596784)
The same thing has happened with git over time, no? Decentralized source control, forking whatever you want/have access to when you have a flash of inspiration, etc.

Now everything is in github, gitlab, or bitbucket, and centralized there.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by anon84873628 on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:47PM (#33597938)
Pretty good analogy. Discovery and trade (clones/PRs) are so much easier in a centralized system.

At one point I asked (rather naively - not trying to sound wise here) whether our dependence on GitHub was an outage risk. Response from CTO was that git is distributed and everyone has a copy and whatnot. In retrospect, yeah, the code is not lost, but we had never actually built the infrastructure / tested the procedures to actually handle that fallback to a distributed world...

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by setgree on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:44AM (#33596795)
Trading is addictive. Like all forms of gambling, it lights our reward centers up.

On decentralized exchanges, you pay each time you trade (gas fees and such). That cuts right through the endorphin rush.

Centralized exchanges keep those fees low by making everything centralized. It's akin to casinos keeping their guests comfortable and liquored up.

As a person who works in crypto, I'd like to see us engage with this more forthrightly. When we cut out gambling, how many use cases are left? How many are viable today?

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by dotnet00 on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:45AM (#33596832)
"Not your keys, not your coin" is a popular adage, but it doesn't really seem like many people follow it. Thus the popularity of coins with high transaction fees.

The original crypto culture which emphasized privacy (although speaking of a public list of all transactions ever performed on the network as privacy oriented is pretty hilarious), control and decentralization has for the most part been lost to crypto's eternal September.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by lawn on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:46AM (#33596839)
That's because nobody really cares about what crypto can do anymore, and only cares about making fast money.

If you internalize this fact, then it explains why people just keep their coins on exchanges, why they buy centralized "cryptocurrencies" , why they leap at the chance of buying the latest Paris Hilton NFT and why they keep defending Tether as legitimate.

Fundamentals are thrown out of the window unfortunately.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by IndrekR on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:53AM (#33596988)
> People just don't get distributed currency if they promptly undistribute it.

Same as with source code version control. As soon as distributed VCS appears (git), people promptly centralize it with another abstraction layer (github, gitlab, bitbucket, etc).

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by hristov on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:55AM (#33597039)
The crypto community is very much to blame for this. Initially, back when bitcoin was hovering about $1 per coin, everyone was talking about personal wallets, and educating people how the wallet was just a bunch of numbers you can write on a piece of paper and which you can keep hidden in the lining of your pants, etc.

But then bitcoin started getting popular and emerging towards mainstream culture, the talk about wallets seized. All the new crypto firms started marketing accounts and "cloud wallets" and the personal pocket wallet was never mentioned.

Crypto then continued to advance in mainstream culture and personal wallets were kept a secret. I doubt the average crypto user even knows about personal wallets.

And if you disagree, please prove me wrong. There are many crypto commercials on mainstream media, show me one that has mentioned that you can keep a personal wallet.

So the crypto industry is to blame for this. They basically hid the most important part of crypto from the public because they would make more money without it.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by remram on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:01PM (#33597133)
Is that the right takeaway? People didn't know cryptocurrencies could be kept on your computer? Or could it be that users just don't want to deal with the complexity enabled by cryptocurrencies, and the bank model is just the natural one that always appears when the public starts making use of money?
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by bbarnett on Monday November 14, 2022 @12:00PM (#33597124)
Greybeard here. This just sounds like AWS to me. The cloud! The wondrous cloud!
Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by SevenNation on Monday November 14, 2022 @11:58AM (#33597085)
The user growth is high enough that at any given time roughly half of the people involved have been at it for less than 18 months. So the space is dominated by the least-savvy and has been for some time.

Many people will never be capable of self-custody because the lack the interest to do it. They see money to be made and ignore the warnings of those who try to explain what they have on an exchange is a promise of money, not money itself.

When you say "nobody does this anymore," that's kind of true, but also not true. Those who have learned the hard way do, the newbies (which vastly outnumber the first group) don't.

Self custody requires knowledge of some basic math, cryptography, and the ability to understand basic security principles.

User growth explodes with exchange rates. Those diving in understand very little about what they're doing and should stay out. They don't listen to people saying such things and the result is, well, predictable.

Re:Crypto Exchange AAX Suspends Withdrawals by netheril96 on Monday November 14, 2022 @08:22PM (#33604023)
I do it. Certainly some people else.