News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by SentientAtom on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:43AM (#33449603)
If it works for you, why would you migrate to a different product with features or performance outside of your needs? We are so deep into a disposable society that we eagerly await the NEXT BIG THING (TM) without ever evaluating what our need consists of or whether we have any need for an upgrade to begin with.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by darau1 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:39AM (#33450092)
I know a guy that bought every new Samsung flagship device as soon as they hit stores. He said he just has to upgrade.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by guerrilla on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:41AM (#33450115)
I would hate it if everyone (or even many people) did this, but it's nice to know someone outside of Samsung has tried them all, but then again, I guess you wouldn't ncessarily get very neutral reviews from such a person.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by darau1 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:14AM (#33450439)
Well, I doubt he's had a bad experience because I don't think he ever has one long enough for it to start showing signs of age.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by aliqot on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:53AM (#33450225)
I wonder sometimes how can people reconcile buying a new X every Y and still be concerned about human rights and the environment, etc.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by rootusrootus on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:35AM (#33450726)
I expect that most people buy what they want and human rights and the environment are just something they discuss online.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by smolder on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:19AM (#33451398)
Probably true, though to different degrees for different folks. I've always taken joy in holding out for the right component upgrades for my PC and related gear to get the best bang for the buck and biggest leaps in performance. It's a lineage that's been going since 2000 or so, where at least one part always gets carried forward, and the rest is gifted or sold at steep discount. It started as me trying to get the most from my limited money, but decades later it's more about minimizing the guilt of frivolous e-waste. My last phone of 5 years sadly got the boot from my carrier, forcing an upgrade. I know I've seen other people take pride in their slow/picky upgrades, too.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by x86x87 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:22AM (#33451445)
Sometime this also happens in person.

Also being shamed for everything you do as bad for the environment or bad for human right does not work.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by automatic6131 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:05AM (#33450344)
You tell yourself you're allowing someone else to enjoy (nth-)last years X and Y at a lower price point, being subsidised by your use first.

Everyone can reconcile almost anything, practically humanity's superpower. It's rare the person that fails to - on any issue. I think we all do it all the time for most issues.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by tppiotrowski on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:09AM (#33451244)
"So convenient a thing to be a reasonable creature, since it enables one to find or make a reason for every thing one has a mind to do."

-Benjamin Franklin

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by coffeeblack on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:27AM (#33450611)
Both is to raise your social status among your “friends”.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by jasonlotito on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:32AM (#33450682)
I wonder sometimes how can people reconcile buying a new X ever and still be concerned about human rights and the environment, etc.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by benj111 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:59AM (#33450288)
Human rights?

That's kind of a tenuous link at best. You could make the case that buying more increases the opportunities for those at the bottom.

I'm not even necessarily making a factual statement here, but personally I don't feel that there's anything to reconcile.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by bunderbunder on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:12AM (#33450430)
A lot of raw materials that go into modern electronics are produced using slave labor, and the “recycled” devices tend to end up poisoning the environments of people in similarly disadvantaged communities.

I don’t know enough about these things to know whether buying more or less of these devices directly helps enslaved people, but I don’t think it’s a stretch to observe that rampant consumerism does fuel the postcolonial economic machine that perpetrates that kind of exploitation. And I think that those of us who stand to benefit the most from this system would do well to be extremely cautious about how we are incentivized toward motivated reasoning.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by toolz on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:27AM (#33450621)
It's also important to recognize consumerism has driven a lot of innovation which has benefited humanity. I venture to say one of the most impactful advancements in human history is providing access to the internet in almost every spot on the globe. That was influenced at least in part by so many people owning smart phones.

A sufficiently technologically advanced human species might be the only thing capable of stopping the next extinction event. Something that will almost certainly occur naturally without any intervention.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by x86x87 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:25AM (#33451491)
Hmm. A sufficiently technologically advanced human species may greatly accelerate the arrival of the next extinction event.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by toolz on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:53PM (#33460254)
Sure, but another extinction event without humans is more or less inevitable - with humans it may be preventable.

So our choices appear to be wait for the bad thing to happen or continue to drive each other to improve and learn, which consumerism does in fact provide great motive and drive for humans to improve (although not the only mechanism, I'm sure, just a large one we understand today). Hopefully we strike the right balance and solve these problems.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by bunderbunder on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:45AM (#33451792)
I always worry a little when something is both the purported solution to and the primary cause of a problem.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by jasonlotito on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:33AM (#33450694)
> A lot of raw materials that go into modern electronics are produced using slave labor,

Can you confirm this for Apple products? I couldn't find anything recent.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by benj111 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:48AM (#33450899)
Ok. Well there's 2 elements here, the factual and emotional.

Factually you could argue either way. I suppose broadly you could say that industrialisation is bad for those at the bottom in the short term. But after the hump things get better. Is that pain reasonable? Is it avoidable? Are we morally obligated to avoid it? Are all somewhat open questions.

The GP used the word 'reconcile' which to me is a more emotional metric. Personally I don't make the link (rightly or wrongly) between me buying X and person Y suffering. So personally I don't have anything to reconcile. That is a correct answer. It isn't the answer, but as an answer to the GP, it is legitimate.

I can also see it being a reasonable answer to say that in buying Congolese cobalt you are helping the country industrialise, which in the long term is a good thing. Again you may disagree with the reasoning or morality but it seems to me a legitimate way of reconciliation.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by irrational on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:50AM (#33450931)
How do you know any of them even are actually concerned about those issues and don't just give lip service (if even that)?
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by scarface74 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:05AM (#33451170)
So by only buying a new X every zY you’re somehow showing more concern about human rights?
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by biftek on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:47AM (#33451817)
Because it's not an individuals buying decisions harming those things? Those are the result of governments and corporations.

I'm not going to buy a new phone today and it sounds like you probably won't either, I'll check back in tomorrow and see how the environment is doing!

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by aliqot on Thursday November 03, 2022 @12:36PM (#33453608)
I don't own a telephone. This is just my outsider's perspective looking in with my curiosity hands out.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by lnsru on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:26AM (#33450605)
I know a guy who does this with Apple products. Half monthly salary for a phone for a year sounds extreme to me. Plus all the gimmicks that come with the phone - pad, phones and watch.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by ghaff on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:32AM (#33450683)
Admittedly there are tradeins. I know someone who does a fair bit of reviewing of camera gear including smartphone cameras. His approach seems to generally be to effectively rent a phone for a year.

With that said, I generally go for 3 years and use the older phone to drive my stereo, sometimes act as a travel spare, etc.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by rootusrootus on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:33AM (#33450695)
Wouldn’t be my choice for sure. But he presumably sells the old one.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by cableshaft on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:08AM (#33451227)
At least Apple products hold their value pretty well. I'm only just now starting to think about upgrading my 2015 Macbook Pro and it looks like I could still get $400 for it. A year old Apple device probably gets at least 60% of its MSRP back when sold.

I wouldn't do it personally (see me still using a >7 year old Macbook), but they're likely not dropping anywhere near the full MSRP every year, after they sell the old one.

Meanwhile, I've had three gaming Windows laptops during that same time, and two of them literally fell apart (one I kept using until enough of the plastic frame around the monitor cracked that I could no longer keep it in place with binder clips). The most recent one (ASUS ROG Strix G15) is still doing well, but I've only had it for about two years at this point.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by amelius on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:27AM (#33449971)
True. But perhaps 16k people sold their Pebble because they wanted a shiny new watch, and they were bought by 16k other people who can't afford that new watch.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by Cthulhu_ on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:36AM (#33450066)
sort-of-smart watch, you can get watches that tell the time for $5 or less.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by stinkytaco on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:37AM (#33450745)
I'm not sure why that's relevant. You can buy a shirt that covers your body for $5, but most of us are wearing something more expensive for a variety of reasons. If you are wearing a pebble, you probably want the sort of smart features.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by Gigachad on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:26AM (#33449953)
The pebble was a bit of a gimmick. It was the start of the future but on its own it was kind of worse than a regular watch. It looked ugly, had a terrible screen, didn’t have any of the stuff you mostly do with a smartwatch now. And half the features no longer work.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by yonaguska on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:38AM (#33450087)
And it had an insanely long battery life, I could respond to, and read text messages without opening my phone. It didn't have unnecessary stuff- it was simple and met my watch needs. I don't have a smartwatch now, because I'm not interested in having yet another computer on my wrist. I guess I've just decided to settle for a gimmicky automatic watch, it doesn't even have an alarm! And it dies if I stop using it for a few days.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by robertlagrant on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:46AM (#33450162)
Yeah I really liked mine. Still have it, I just don't get on with wearing any watch that much. I like how it had voice commands way back when.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by benj111 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:05AM (#33450357)
>And it had an insanely long battery life.

Is there a term for complementing something that is objectively much worse than what came before only because it's better than what we have now.

Stockholm syndrome?

Watch batteries used to last month's/ years / didn't need batteries at all.

It's the same with phones, they used to last a week easily, now we get excited when they last 2 days.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by stinkytaco on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:41AM (#33450797)
I don't think these are apples to apples comparisons. Yes, watches had much longer batteries, but they didn't have smart features. So you're really comparing the Pebble to something with a comparable feature set, like another smart watch.

Phones used to be powered directly from the wire and work even during a power outage and now they have batteries and die, but I'm still willing to trade that feature to have a GPS and text messaging.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by benj111 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:54AM (#33450990)
Well it's less featured than a modern smart watch so it's not an apples to apples comparison there, but the comparison was still made.

Further Casio made a range of smartish watches back in the day. I don't know battery life's but they weren't measured in days.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by stinkytaco on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:14AM (#33451320)
Some of it has to do with existing experience. I suspect many people in this thread have not worn something other than a smart watch with regularity in at least 15 years, possible longer if they were below watch wearing age when cell phones became common. Additionally, I'd argue that the pebble is closer to an apple watch than even a digital watch and certainly closer than an automatic watch. You chose to compare a smart phone to a flip phone rather than a POTS phone? Likely you either have very limited experience with POTS phones or you view the smart/flip comparison as more apt. Either way, I think context is important when making comparisons so I still think it's entirely fair to say "the Pebble has good battery life".

And those Casio watches were terrible. Even without a comparison to anything else, they just didn't work reliably.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by dotnet00 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:25AM (#33451481)
I agree with the existing experience point, I hadn't worn a "dumb" watch since middle school (~12 years ago) until I finally ended up buying a smart watch last month, which I wear nearly 24/7.

If it's just for telling the time I don't exactly need a watch, I'm almost always looking at or within reach of some device that can tell me the time anyway. A smart watch is useful for other purposes.

Also while weeklong battery lives would be nice, even needing to charge daily isn't too bad, I just stick it on the charger at night while relaxing and getting ready to sleep.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by yonaguska on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:41AM (#33450789)
For me, I didn't wear watches before. Pebble got me into it. And now I wear watches with no batteries, so maybe reverse Stockholm syndrome?

I loved my Garmin, but I hated the notifications. And I couldn't disable the fitness related notifications. I'm at a point where I hate all notifications though, and have them only enabled for work and my wife. Everyone/everything else can wait.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by MereInterest on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:24AM (#33450573)
I don't know of any official name, but it would be adjacent to the Rachet Effect [0]. Where the Rachet Effect is a steady increase in expectations, rather than a steady decrease, they both derive from the same limited time frame used for comparisons.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ratchet_effect

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by scambier on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:44AM (#33450843)
> Is there a term for complementing something that is objectively much worse than what came before only because it's better than what we have now.

What kind of smartwatch came before it, that had a battery that held for more than a week? And no, a simple watch is not a smartwatch, so that doesn't count.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by maratc on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:43AM (#33450824)
> settle for a gimmicky automatic watch

You probably mean the marvel of mechanical engineering that has zero dependency on the outside world, needs no software updates, and will still continue running as new for years after all the smart watches will turn into useless pucks?

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by adregan on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:28AM (#33451524)
Minimal dependency: you will have to get it serviced from time to time, but I find that charming—like getting a pair of shoes resoled or renewing a piece of wooden furniture. You’re extending the life of the object, some beyond your own lifespan.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by SyneRyder on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:19AM (#33450513)
> And half the features no longer work.

Which features don't work? I'm still wearing a Pebble Time Steel every day with Rebble Services and not encountering problems.

Okay, I guess Apple integration doesn't work anymore, but that's an Apple problem. If Apple allowed sideloading & half of the things you can do on Android, Pebble would still work there. I used to be an iPhone owner (I was one of those queue-on-day-one types that got a standing ovation from the Apple employees as you walked out of the Apple Store), but I am so glad I switched to Android.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by koenvdb on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:36AM (#33451642)
Funny that you say that, I did the exact opposite. Was quite an Android fanatic until I switched to iPhone and noticed how greatly everything was integrated. Next to the integration of my AirPods and Watch the apps on the iPhone are generally of better quality than my experiences on Android. Everything just feels a lot more native and faster. Probably caused by the fact that Apple is just a lot more stricter in what it allows developers to do + the fact that Android runs on literally thousands of different screen sizes, where there are only a couple of screen sizes that a developer has to take into account on the i(Pad)OS side.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by tekchip on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:51AM (#33450940)
That was v1. The latter versions solved most of those problems and rebble.io keeps a pebble 100% functional.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by dpcx on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:23AM (#33449926)
Well, the threat of the service going away is a pretty big one. Until we have devices that can work from our own hosted systems, this will always be a concern.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by fsflover on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:02AM (#33451122)
> Until we have devices that can work from our own hosted systems

We already do: https://pine64.org/pinetime.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by hedora on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:33AM (#33451611)
Is that working yet?

(I like my pine book pro; honest question.)

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by fsflover on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:35AM (#33451639)
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by GuB-42 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @09:53AM (#33450983)
- Parts breaking that can't be easily replaced. In particular Li-ion batteries have a limited lifespan, both in time and in number of cycles.

- Security: hackers constantly find new vulnerabilities. And depending on the kind of device, it can be a big deal.

- Services shutting down, it can be direct (if the device connects to the internet), or indirect (if some "companion app" is no longer available).

- Or just plain obsolescence. The device may be incompatible with modern standards, irrelevant, unfashionable, etc...

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by ZaoLahma on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:03AM (#33451140)
I bought a Big Brand Flagship Phone (tm), the Samsung Galaxy S9, in 2018. They stopped upgrading the OS with new functionality in 2020 only two years after its release, and this year they stopped providing security updates!

Considering how much functionality and information is on that phone that could affect my life in absolutely fantastically negative ways if it was hacked (online accounts including owned licenses for software, banking), I have little choice but to buy a new phone now, even though the hardware is more than adequate for my needs and even though new phones don't really do much more much better.

Planned obsolescence, or whatever you prefer to call it, really drives this behaviour.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by arsome on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:11AM (#33451267)
I've always been curious about this one - what kind of exploits are you concerned about that could wind up with those sorts of consequences? Most of the security updates tend to patch things which are local only or barely exploitable in the first place. Assuming you're not installing entirely untrustworthy software on daily basis, it's probably not much of a difference. Looking at the latest Android security report, even the "Critical" vulnerability reported is a code injection in data that's usually only available to the app that wrote it in the first place.

Important applications like the browser, webview, media players, etc are patched via Play Store regularly so untrusted data is usually processed through those pipelines regardless. Perhaps hardware decode on untrusted content could still provide a vector there, but judging by the practice it's not exactly a large one.

There haven't exactly been worm-grade exploits flying around in the mobile space, even big public things like StageFright pretty much turned out to be non-starters and the targeted attacks are so far ahead that I wouldn't even worry about public exploits - the private ones have you covered already even on the latest OS.

Maybe I'm the minority here, but I wouldn't exactly rush out and blow $1000 over anything short of an unpatched and readily exploitable RCE.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by fullstop on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:26AM (#33451503)
Regarding installing untrustworthy software, you also have to be mindful of software which has been acquired by another entity. Your trusty file manager could turn into something entirely different just by applications automatically updating.

This happened with ES File Explorer.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by ehnto on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:41AM (#33451737)
This is the duality of automatic updates, on one hand you don't automatically get security updates, on the other, you don't automatically get exploits from new owners or compromised accounts.

In a software project this is really a responsibility I think people don't appreciate that they have, especially in regards to package managers.

But for end user devices it's encouraged to have automatic updates on. I think this is a personal responsibility as no-one really has your back on your device, except the highly automated app store verification. Which in fairness to them, likely stops a lot of exploits/malware making it to user devices.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by thorin on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:32AM (#33451595)
Is this in the US only? I have a Samsung S9 (and a spare S9 actually), and the last update was installed on the 23 Sept 2022.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by bombcar on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:08AM (#33451223)
This alone is a huge reason that the iPhone is doing well - iOS 16 still runs on the 8 and iOS 15 releases are still getting patches: https://support.apple.com/guide/iphone/supported-models-iphe... https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT213490
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by olau on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:27AM (#33451512)
Interesting perspective. I have an iPad 3rd generation where Apple doesn't allow OS updates and doesn't allow installing a non-Apple browser engine. So it's essentially getting bricked as web sites start relying on features not implemented in the ancient Safari engine on it. Twitter, for instance, refuses to load. Youtube does work okayish, as long as you don't log in.

Once it's completely bricked, I'm throwing it out and not getting anything with an Apple logo. Unless something like the EU manages to make them open up.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by Retric on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:31AM (#33451574)
What 10 year old iPad alternative is still receiving updates?

I get the annoyance, but I just don’t see viable alternatives.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by bunderbunder on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:41AM (#33451727)
I imagine the argument is that a less locked-down device would be able to receive community support 10 years later.

I suspect, though, that that’s optimizing for perfection in rare cases rather than doing better overall. The number of iPads that survive to 10 years is presumably puny. The batteries wear out, they get dropped, etc. I would guess that the number of 2-3 year old devices that get replaced simply because the OS updates stop or the UX gets slow is much greater. In which case, perhaps Apple’s way of doing things is a net win over others’ in the aggregate.

Hard to say without any hard numbers, though.

(Disclaimer: A couple months back I opted to replace the battery on my 2013 MacBook, which is still going strong, instead of buying a new Framework laptop. That may indicate some bias.)

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by bombcar on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:33AM (#33451610)
I think the argument is that the alternatives can have Linux installed on them (though I suspect a 10 year old iPad can be jailbroken if you want to).

10 years is a dang good run for a tablet; only thing that really can hope to compete would be actual computers.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by fsflover on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:33AM (#33451602)
There are none, but PineTab will receive updates forever, since it can run mainline Linux kernel.
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by Angostura on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:32AM (#33451589)
For context, this model was discontinued 10 years ago
Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by dotnet00 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:51AM (#33451881)
To be fair the situation regarding updates is starting to improve now that new phones bring very little to the table besides faster processing and marginal camera improvements and similarly OS updates don't do much besides change the UI slightly.

Samsung (and IIRC Google) now promises at least 4 years of regular updates and 5 of security.

Re:Over 16,000 people still use a Pebble smartwatch by o10449366 on Thursday November 03, 2022 @10:34AM (#33451624)
Agree. I'm still using the original iphone SE from 2016. I've replaced the battery four or five times and see no reason to upgrade, even though it's officially out of support now.

Funnily, when I meet people now with the latest and greatest iphone and they see my old phone they often express they wish they still had one of them.