News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by chrismeller on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:07PM (#33268949)
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by willcipriano on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:14PM (#33269010)
The biggest problem in America: Things are inexplicably extremely expensive, especially if government is involved and nobody can give a straight answer as to why.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by VHRanger on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:30PM (#33269125)
It's not inexplicable.

The political system froze up to protect entrenched interests (NIMBY land owners).

It's making conscious efforts to make new construction onerous to get through permitting process. That restricts supply and enriches existing land owners.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by willcipriano on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:48PM (#33269233)
If expensive permitting is the problem, since it's the government doing the building shouldn't that not really be a "cost", order the department to waive any fees.

Also, If that were the case I would suspect that adding a bathroom to your house in SF would cost upwards of a million dollars as well but I doubt that's true. Correct me if I'm wrong.

A similar effect can be seen in ancient Rome, towards the end of the empire the millers started to produce less and less product from the same amount of grain. The mint that produced the coins would mysteriously lose large amounts of them, or they wouldn't contain the correct percentages of metals and nobody in power did anything about it. Well that's not entirely right, one person did and they killed him.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by bhelkey on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:59PM (#33269313)
> since it's the government doing the building shouldn't that not really be a "cost", order the department to waive any fees.

This assumes that the cost is due to fees imposed by the government.

From the article:

>> [The costs] include planning, drawing, permits, reviews and public outreach.

>> we expect to be able to complete [the toilet] in 2025

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by willcipriano on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:10PM (#33269384)
It couldn't cost more than say 200k (and that is pretty crazy the article says the plumbing hookups are there it's not like they have to dig up a city block to run a sewer line or something) to actually build the thing so we are talking what? A million and a half in illustration, planning and review for a single toilet?
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by bhelkey on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:41PM (#33270606)
I don't have any special insight here but, in other cases, environmental review and environmental lawsuits are a tool used to stifle new developments.

> a rejected San Francisco apartment complex...required a more than 1,110-page environmental assessment [1]

It is not socially acceptable to charge a million dollar permit for constructing a toilet. It is socially acceptable to make the process so onerous that it costs more than a million dollars to complete. Think of the environment.

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2022-04-20/the-landm...

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by throwayyy479087 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:54PM (#33269280)
Government has to get permits like the rest of us
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by anm89 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:53PM (#33269266)
It's pretty explicable. Our entire economic system is based on the premise that we should off shore the production of things to other places who are willing to deal with the nitty gritty and get it done at a price Americans can afford and then we regulate and enforce wages that ensure that those activities are prohibitively onerous and expensive to be done in the USA. This is literally by design.

It's great for multiplying the amount of physical things everyone gets to consume as long as the quality of those things isn't taken into account. It's a disaster in the event we actually need to build any physical things for ourselves.

We've been able to pretend this isn't true for the last 40 years as we wore our existing infrastructure down into the ground. It is becoming more apparent now as we fail to rebuild to the state we were in 70 years ago.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by missedthecue on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:53PM (#33269980)
This can't be the explanation, because the US has never offshored construction. You can't offshore construction. It's a service business that requires being on-site.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by anm89 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @10:13PM (#33270089)
Right, and this a big part of the reason that houses are prohibitively expensive. If you could offshore them they'd be affordable.

Americans can't afford to buy things made by Americans.

Again we papered over this issue with decades of supressed interest rates but the ruse can't last forever.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by julianapostate on Saturday October 22, 2022 @01:10AM (#33295800)
its been inshored to latin americans
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by bergenty on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:20PM (#33269437)
Getting a contractor to work on your home is ridiculously expensive too. The other day I paid $900 to replace a faucet for my tub.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by oceanplexian on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:40PM (#33269586)
I’ve had nothing but bad experiences with contractors. I had to do the exact same thing, while it wasn’t $900 it was $200-300 to have someone come out and replace a faucet. I ended up buying the tools and did it in ~20 minutes for like $20 in parts. I’ve done a lot of other projects and constantly get outrageous quotes from landscapers, plumbers, HVAC, etc.

My theory is that they prey on people that don’t know any better. Less and less people know how to DIY so they have no frame of reference for the real value of labor and get scammed.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by willcipriano on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:25PM (#33269474)
I'd love to see a breakdown of wages paid to plumbers, tilesetters and carpenters as well as all material and equipment costs vs everything else. I'd gamble it isn't even 20% of the total.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by gimoc on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:29PM (#33269504)
Couldn't you do it yourself? It's typically a relatively simple job, no need to get a contractor in. The tools to replace it, if you don't have them already, would have come in at a fraction of $900.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by bergenty on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:29PM (#33270504)
I could and I will moving forward. My wife ended up paying him when I was at work and she had no idea what it was supposed to cost.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by dzhiurgis on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:53AM (#33271919)
You can for now, while it’s legal. Electrical work is now illegal in many places.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by yucky on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:23PM (#33269832)
There is a straight answer. Government is far too big and inefficient, which adds tremendously to the cost when it is involved.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by moneycantbuy on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:19PM (#33269051)
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by missedthecue on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:34PM (#33269144)
I'm not sure how you would be able to codify it in a fair and just way, but this level of waste needs to be a crime. There needs to be accountability.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by sn0w_crash on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:28PM (#33269496)
This is already codified. It’s a political ideology that centers around throwing money into a bottomless pit of problems that never seem to be solved.

“Accountability” would mean a massive reduction in headcount, budget, and taxation. The likelihood of this happening in SF is….. you know the answer to that.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by jimrandomh on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:54PM (#33269281)
I think things in SF have gotten well past the point where people should believe that it's mere inefficiency, and start calling it what it is: corruption. This money is being embezzled, used as political favors, or otherwise misappropriated. There will be a story about a wasteful process, of course, some budget paperwork, and excuses. But unless a detective looks closely at the books, those excuses will probably be lies.

This particular price tag on this particular project isn't super important, but it looks to me like California government projects and public institutions have a pattern of doing this, adding up to a whole lot more than $1.7M.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by fragmede on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:24PM (#33269464)
Calling it corruption isn’t even a stretch. Nuru was ex-director of San Francisco Public Works, and plead guilty to a federal fraud charge.

https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Ex-S-F-Public-Wo...

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by anm89 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @07:57PM (#33269297)
Where's the corruption here? If you set up a system of regulation where a building a toilet costs 1.7M and then building a toilet costs 1.7M, that seems like inefficiency not corruption.

I'm open to being proven wrong here but it seems like this statement needs to be justified.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by citizenpaul on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:47PM (#33269630)
People that think like you interest me. Exactly how much would someone have to move against you before you simply stopped them and said this is enough regardless of evidence? Like would you die instead of fight back if it came to it?

Were your parents extremely well off? I don't see how one can make it through life without being wary of the bad intent other people can have without some sort of caretaker that will bail you out.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by jshzglr on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:05PM (#33269722)
If a proposal for a toilet needs to pass through several committees to be built, it sounds plausible that SF is just one bureaucratic monstrosity organized democratically. It doesn't need to be fraud, although frankly I wish it was. That would be easier to dismantle.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by anm89 on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:44PM (#33269928)
You are just making wild assumptions about my belief system. This is bordering on incoherent

Can you point to where I say any of this is good or show any sign of support for any of it?

Were your parent's uneducated? I don't see how you could make it through life with this level of reading comprehension.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by citizenpaul on Saturday October 22, 2022 @02:11PM (#33300588)
You said you don't believe there is some sort of corruption but were open to more info that would prove you wrong.

Yet when I am looking at a project that me and a couple of guys could do over a weekend then be told its going to cost enough for modest person to retire. I don't need extra evidence. I know immediately that corruption is at play. There is no honest answer that ends up at 1.7mil. Sure you will get a mile long list of "explanations" that are all part of the corruption. That pile of money is going into bank accounts at the end of the day and that's all there is too it.

How can a person not see this?

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by dzhiurgis on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:47AM (#33271888)
Ironically it would be cheaper if it were corrupted. People involved would actually be interested in cost cutting.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by greendestiny_re on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:03PM (#33269339)
Grand opening of a public toilet, escalator, or elevator is a common sight in Eastern Europe during an election campaign.

https://www.klix.ba/vijesti/bih/gradonacelnik-zivinica-sveca...

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by sn0w_crash on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:25PM (#33269470)
Eastern Europe is 100x cleaner and more beautiful than SF will ever be.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by anonygler on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:42PM (#33269601)
Meanwhile, in Florida:

https://twitter.com/MyFDOT/status/1582832749681201152

California is a failed experiment.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by lovich on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:22PM (#33269821)
Meanwhile in Florida

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/interactive-see-after-p...

You can find failed/failing/failing to implement infrastructure in every state in the US, it’s a national issue

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by anonygler on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:01PM (#33270340)
Counterpoint: California residents would've blocked the Condo development using CEQA and it'd be a hybrid parking lot/homeless encampment. Checkmate indeed.

It's a good thing the Millennium Tower is still standing.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by lovich on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:19PM (#33270437)
It’s not really a counterpoint when every place is fucked. I’m saying this from region that did the last mega engineering project in the US (the big dig) and that was even 20 years ago. We are one of the best areas for approving infrastructure projects and we still don’t approve enough to support the areas needs.

It is a national problem

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by systemvoltage on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:22PM (#33269822)
Honestly, as a Californian; I see this positively. We need our butts kicked a bit to make progress. I want California to be the best place in the world. It’s trying hard to not be.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by tracerbulletx on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @08:59PM (#33269692)
Is there a cost breakdown of what goes into an estimate like this? The 1.7 million number comes from somewhere, so how was it calculated, what parts of the process result in it being so high? Cost of labor for doing the actual job, materials, administrative salaries for the planning and regulatory hurdles? Surely that exists somewhere, and so if this is corruption seeing such a document should make it more obvious who is benefiting from it
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by techdragon on Thursday October 20, 2022 @12:21AM (#33270784)
This highlights one of my personal favourite ways to attack this problem, itemised cost breakdowns.

If they were required by law to keep sufficiently detailed account of the government money they are using, and while making these public by default might be hard to convince people of (due to obvious questions about commercial in confidence information)… just requiring them to exist as government records of the project opens a pathway for the existing FOI processes to grant access to these for public inspection when it’s in the public interest.

I really struggle to image how a FOI request to produce the itemised cost documentation of the 1.7 million dollar public toilet, might possibly not be in the public interest.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by dzhiurgis on Thursday October 20, 2022 @04:22AM (#33272075)
Container toilet from china - 10k

Installation - 2k

Rest - …

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by Kukumber on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:18PM (#33269800)
This almost sounds like some sort of corruption, but i must be over-reacting
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by tomcam on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @09:24PM (#33269835)
Why didn’t they open up the bids? My firm would’ve been willing to do that toilet for only $1.45 million and get it done within 18 months. Because we are go-getters

/s

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by HWR_14 on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:34AM (#33284549)
They are opening up the bids soon. Feel free to bid 1.45 MM, but that will probably be too high as the 1.7MM cost includes the architect, running the bid process, etc.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by tomcam on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:28PM (#33293667)
We obviously need to collab
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by jakear on Thursday October 20, 2022 @12:46PM (#33277345)
The real solution to the public defecation crisis is either unlocking bathrooms at night or more “single” use plastic bags. Anyone knows dog parks have less shit around when there are bags readily available, but somehow they haven’t connected that to the city in general. It used to be you could pretty reliably find a good clean plastic bag in any trash can. Not so anymore.

Problem is anyone proposing this in government would be cancelled for disgracing the homeless or some shit (I’m homeless, I get a free pass). The absolute worst part of the homeless experience is being in a city during the hours when bathrooms are locked and desperately needing to use one. Not proud of the things I’ve done in times of such calamity.

At least SF has people freely shooting up on the streets, so perhaps they won’t feel as compelled to prevent them from using bathrooms for the same? Anyone know if SF bathrooms get locked?

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by Gigachad on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:29PM (#33281028)
I don't think it's even possible to solve the public toilet problem without first solving the drug abuse problem. Everyone agrees it would be ideal to have toilet access to everyone, but no one has an answer for how you design a toilet that's impossible to abuse.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by bombcar on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:36PM (#33281119)
The guy is literally asking for doggie bags to be available so he can crap in a bag when toilets aren’t available/closed.

We need to not let the perfect be the enemy of the good, or the whole city turns into a toilet.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by jakear on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:54PM (#33281335)
Folks abuse drugs right on the street in SF. I don’t see why they’d prefer to take up a stall, where you’re much more likely to get noticed, complained about, and “handled”.

If not a doggy bag supply outside locked bathrooms, a roomful of toilets with no doors/walls/etc would be better than what we have now. Down with the idea that defecation is a naughtily private affair, bring back public bathhouses!

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by googlryas on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:35PM (#33281113)
You're saying people who are pooping on public sidewalks will willingly choose to poop into plastic bags on public sidewalks, if only they had them available?
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by jakear on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:49PM (#33281279)
I can’t speak for everyone, but some of them yes! If you were homeless and needed to shit in the middle of the night (usually avoidable, but stomach bugs can screw you - and they’re more common when you can only afford bottom of the barrel food), would you prefer to do it directly on the street in the vicinity of your bed where you’ll have to smell it and look at it for weeks, or into a bag where you can properly dispose of it immediately?

Now imagine you live in a community with a dozen other hobos, what sorts of policies would you legislate?

You know we aren’t that different, you and I.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by zwilliamson on Thursday October 20, 2022 @12:53PM (#33277434)
Just pay for a top of the line port-a-potty cleaned and purged daily. Will be cheaper and won’t look that bad. I used to hang out at the park daily with my dog. It would work out just fine.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by colpabar on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:25PM (#33280975)
They'd need to find someone who owns a port-a-potty company and is also married/related to someone on the city counsel, which could be a challenge.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by UberFly on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:27PM (#33281001)
You could have a village of port-a-pottys for a long time for 1.7mill. On second thought, the person cleaning it daily would need a 200k annual city salary, so maybe not.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by baby on Thursday October 20, 2022 @12:58PM (#33277502)
I'd really like to read an anonymous report from someone working in the government and who understands why the city is such a mess. Like, I read so many theories, but they mostly seem to be written by people with an agenda or who have no clue.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by jonathankoren on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:33PM (#33281079)
If this is anything like the $20,000 trash cans[0], the price is inflated because there's only one and so all the one time costs around design and manufacturing are put on a single item. When you amortize the costs across the entire production run, it falls to a tenth the price, but "$2,000 trash can" don't generate headlines and outrage because that's how much a sturdy municipal trashcan costs.[1]

[0] https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/san-francisco-pricey-t...

[1] https://www.trashcanswarehouse.com/Municipal-Trash-Cans-and-...

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by refurb on Thursday October 20, 2022 @08:45PM (#33282779)
The bigger question is why design a new trash can in the first place? Does no current trash can exist that would work?

There are hundreds of designs now for less than $1000 each.

https://trashcansunlimited.com/amp/metal-armor-series/

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by Turing_Machine on Thursday October 20, 2022 @06:45PM (#33281797)
I'm thinking of a bar in Dutch Harbor, Alaska, back in the day, where the owner got tired of repairing destruction and lined the whole bathroom with stainless steel plate, to which he welded stainless steel sinks, urinals, and toilets (as used in prisons).

At the end of the evening, he'd take the firehose in there to clean up.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by ZeroGravitas on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:37PM (#33282291)
So the basic lie here is the cost for the full process vs the cost for the actual construction.

This is just a small part of the ongoing and very popular conspiracy theory that all progressive government is actually an insane plot to destroy American society, if not human civilization.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by iancmceachern on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:38PM (#33282298)
I live in the city and come across human feces daily.

I've been thinking a lot about this, and after going through a year long process of trying to get the city (actually the port authority) to simply lock a dumpster at night as they say they do but don't actually.

SF in particular seems to look for fancy big expensive flashy solutions to problems rather than look to other cities who have solved the issue in a simple "KISS" approach.

In the example of the unlocked dumpsters which were and are a serious public health hazard (people and raccoons go though it every night and drag the trash all over the waterfront and immediate area) I kept calling the port just asking them to lock them at night. They said thos was already happening, but clearly wasn't. We went back and forth for months but I got nowhere. The port kept telling me they they got new big Belly Trash Cans and have asked to build a new dumpster enclosure. All that was 2 years ago and the dumpsters still sit open today. All I was asking for was for them to lock the dumpsters they said they were already locking, with the lock that's already on the dumpster. It's not a "build a new building" or buy expensive things problem. It's a simple people doing their job as promised problem.

Back to this. I've been thinking of starting a non profit that distributes 5 gallon buckets with toilet lids on them (they make them for camping, like this: https://www.amazon.com/Camco-Toilet-Seat-Proof-Waste/dp/B07N...)

A non profit that distributed these throughout the city, then picked them up every few days would do far more good than any of these other efforts I've seen proposed by the city. The problem is its not sexy, interesting or newsworthy, it's just work. Working with a startup or design team to yet again invent another solution is, so that's why the people in power do that. Not because its better.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by refurb on Thursday October 20, 2022 @08:18PM (#33282610)
It’s pretty wild. Chicago always had a reputation of corruption, but it’s pretty clear SF isn’t much better.

There have been convictions with garbage collection and the planning reviews and the mayor has connections to all those people.

It runs deep.

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by w1nst0nsm1th on Thursday October 20, 2022 @09:08PM (#33282955)
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by HWR_14 on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:32AM (#33284532)
It's a maximum amount allocated, and takes into account the possible costs of needing to start over because of building code changes and slowdowns due to power issues. As well as the cost for all the administration to decide on what kind of bathroom to build, a custom design, etc. It sounds high, but not insanely so.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by bumpian on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:01AM (#33284984)
> “They told me $1.7 million, and I got $1.7 million,” Haney explained. “I didn’t have the option of bringing home less of the bacon when it comes to building a toilet. A half a toilet or a toilet-maybe-someday is not much use to anyone.”

Did he not know how to bargain?

He just paid whatever amount people asked him to pay?

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by pyuser583 on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:07AM (#33285018)
He wasn’t in a position to bargain - which seems part of the problem.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by nasmorn on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:52AM (#33285269)
Vienna changed their freestanding restroom design a decade ago. It is all stainless steel now, they can clean it with a pressure hose, you can’t pee all over the seat. They are all the same and it is the first public toilet I don’t loathe to use. Obviously in my closest park the architect designed something of aesthetic merit and it is always broken. Operational concerns, basically cleanliness, trump everything with public toilets.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by aix1 on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:21AM (#33288254)
Transport for London once spent £39m (about $60m 2010 USD) on attempting to build two lifts (elevators) before abandoning the project:

https://www.mylondon.news/news/local-news/transport-london-w...

Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by stuaxo on Friday October 21, 2022 @11:05AM (#33288776)
There's a of work needed to put in public infrastructure, this seems like a non story.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by mancerayder on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:01PM (#33292436)
The people's money going straight to the crapper.
Re:San Francisco to spend $1.7M on single public toilet by ThePowerOfFuet on Saturday October 22, 2022 @06:23AM (#33297019)
>UPDATE: Celebration for S.F.’s $1.7 million toilet canceled after backlash: "The cost is insane."

https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/bayarea/heatherknight/article...