News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by sbierwagen on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:49PM (#33206679)
The first permit for the new units was applied for in August 2006: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogtle_Electric_Generating_Pla...

A mere sixteen years from NRC application to coming online.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by rootusrootus on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:23PM (#33207073)
As a comparison point, the four AP1000s in China took ~9 years to become operational after construction began.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by kelnos on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:31PM (#33207174)
At least construction-wise, it seems Vogtle is in the same ballpark, as they began construction in 2013, after apparently waiting 7 years for permit approval.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by cycomanic on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:20PM (#33208932)
So people always complain that nuclear is so expensive because of the regulations. However wind farms take almost as long (despite being significantly less complex) south fork wind took 4 years for the approval process, that is quite typical. So regulations really can't explain why nuclear is more expensive.

https://www.brookings.edu/research/how-does-permitting-for-c...

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by rootusrootus on Friday October 14, 2022 @09:18PM (#33210648)
I thought it was generally accepted that nuclear was expensive because every installation is bespoke?
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by elFarto on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:53PM (#33206707)
The B1M Youtube channel did a video[1] featuring this plant the other day which goes into some of the delays they had.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dyQMNVSxbNo

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by samstave on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:00PM (#33207505)
Great vid.

How much did Nancy Pelosi make off this project? At 30 billion and her husband being exec at Bechtel, I’m sure a ton went to her…

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by sct202 on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:23PM (#33207764)
I can't find any mention of Pelosi being linked to Bechtel.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by samstave on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:37PM (#33207914)
Her husband.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by samstave on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:15PM (#33209447)
Gosh damn what a bunch of idiots you are to not track these fucking oligarch criminals in our midsts

Pay attention mother hecker

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by aliqot on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:57PM (#33206744)
I'd rather the process not be rushed. These things are supposed to run a very long time, let's get it right.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by bilsbie on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:21PM (#33207040)
But maybe we strive to find a balance. There are real costs to dragging our feet too.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by littlestymaar on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:54PM (#33207427)
Fun trivia: did you know that the control room GUI for the French/Finish EPR was designed for 4/3 displays, and by the time the actual control room was built, there were few of the such displays on the market, forcing them to find and approve new suppliers …
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by bpodgursky on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:33PM (#33207190)
You could have said the same thing if it took 3 years or 35 years.

There's nothing magically "right" or calculated about 16 years, it's just the time it took the gears of apathetic bureaucracy to turn. It's a fallacy to use this as a guidepost for a "responsible" amount of time.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by homonculus1 on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:03PM (#33207546)
Is the bureaucracy really apathetic? It sounds more like active hostility to me.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by bpodgursky on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:54PM (#33208111)
I think that grants them too much agency.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by seventytwo on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:05PM (#33206826)
True… but the world keeps moving regardless. The growing demand doesn’t stop once the permit is issued, so if we can’t build these fast enough to keep up, other potentially more polluting forms of energy will fill the void.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by aliqot on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:08PM (#33206873)
Demand does not incur a debt to indulge. Consume less, make less people, and use less power.

Ask yourself if those things are possible in your life and whether that means perfect should be the enemy of good when bringing in a responsible solution demands responsible care. Your needs for immediate satisfaction do not supersede the longterm welfare of your progeny.

From the outside looking in, valuing current demand over the lives of our children is what got us in this mess.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by inetknght on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:24PM (#33207080)
> Consume less, make less people, and use less power.

Yes, people should consume less oil (but big corporations don't).

Yes, people should use less power (but big corporations just count power as a cost of doing business).

Yes, people should make less people (but big corporations need manpower).

> Ask yourself if those things are possible in your life and whether that means perfect should be the enemy of good when bringing in a responsible solution demands responsible care. Your needs for immediate satisfaction do not supersede the longterm welfare of your progeny.

I have no intention of creating progeny in this fucked up world. Moreover, nuclear power is far safer, per watt produced, than coal or oil.

> From the outside looking in, valuing current demand over the lives of our children is what got us in this mess.

It's not individual people who've got us in this mess. Or rather, it is... individual people working for individual corporations who don't consider individual people anything other than feedstock for corporation profits.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by codegrappler on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:34PM (#33207211)
I tend to have a more optimistic view of life and I have 3 kids. I want to support a world that makes things better for them. I’ve always found the “make less people” claim overly patronizing. It’s fine if you don’t want kids, but the kids today will be running the nursing homes, fixing the infrastructure and running the country when we’re retired. I want to help raise this next generation with good moral values and work ethics. I should be able to make that choice.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by andsoitis on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:54PM (#33207430)
I agree with you, even though I’m not having children (am gay and not interested).

My partner and I just need to fire out who can support us when we’re old… (e.g. help us steer our finances in case we can’t ourselves)

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by kelnos on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:54PM (#33207437)
I think the idea isn't for everyone to stop having kids, but to reduce reproduction down to something near replacement rate, so population growth slows or stops.

There's nothing inherent about society that requires more people than the current workforce to run things in 20+ years, though admittedly, generations are not of equal size (booms and busts in the birth rate over time) and there are often demographic issues as particular generations age out of the workforce.

I too support people's desire and right to make choices about reproduction, but at some point it just becomes irresponsibly selfish for a couple to have more than some replacement-level N number of kids. Not just for the planet, but at a smaller level, too, when considering a family's financial resources, etc. I wish more would-be parents would take this sort of thing into account before choosing (or unintentionally not-actually-choosing) to have a(nother) kid.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by JumpCrisscross on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:03PM (#33207542)
> to reduce reproduction down to something near replacement rate, so population growth slows or stops

Most of the rich world is already doing this [1]. The change was enforced by rising living standards and costs of living. Not proselytising.

[1] https://data.oecd.org/pop/fertility-rates.htm

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by kelnos on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:45PM (#33207341)
> Consume less, make less people, and use less power.

Game theory (and several economic theories) suggest that relying on voluntary collective sacrifice is never going to work. People simply will not do it, at least not in numbers large enough to be effective.

I do try to consume less, but I'm sure I'm still above average consumption-wise, and I'm not sure what other cuts I could make while still maintaining the lifestyle I like. At the very least, I have decided I won't reproduce, so I guess that's something.

Political solutions can force people to do things they wouldn't otherwise voluntarily do, but politicians who make their constituents miserable tend to be replaced with politicians who will... not do that.

I think the only feasible solution is the one we are already pursuing: continue consumption growth, but find and build cleaner, renewable ways to fuel that consumption. It's not happening nearly fast enough, though, is hindered by special-interest groups who have an incentive to fight change, and it's unclear if we'll be able to dig ourselves out of the hole we've made for our species' future generations.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by nicoburns on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:10PM (#33208833)
> Game theory (and several economic theories) suggest that relying on voluntary collective sacrifice is never going to work

It doesn't necessarily involve sacrifice though. Will your life be worse if you have 2 children rather than 3. Or even none instead of 2. For some people it will, but for many it won't. Will it be worse if your house is insulated and requires less energy to heat/cool? Will it be worse if we replace highways with public transit in cities? No, it'll likely actually better (even if you still need to drive, because they'll be less traffic).

It also doesn't need to be voluntary. We could mandate these changes, or strongly incentivise them through tax structures. Many countries have already started doing this in some limited cases.

We should certainly try to find cleaner ways to fuel consumption, because we're of course still going to need to consume a lot. But much like the easiest way (and often the only way) to make software faster is to make it do less work (while still achieving an equivalent or close enough to equivalent result), the easiest way to meet our energy needs in a clean way is to reduce our energy needs.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by lazide on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:23PM (#33209505)
If it doesn’t work, it’s because we’re not trying hard enough/mandating everyone do it?

Authoritarianism on the march again.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by themitigating on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:18PM (#33207701)
That doesn't work because most people don't care and don't want to remove comforts.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by pfdietz on Friday October 14, 2022 @09:17PM (#33210641)
It doesn't work because the cost of my sacrifice is paid by myself, but the benefits of my sacrifice are diffused to the entire society. On the margin it makes no economic sense for me to sacrifice to benefit everyone else (and microscopically myself.)
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by hansel_der on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:16PM (#33265135)

  > Your needs for immediate satisfaction do not supersede the longterm welfare of your progeny.
not to put too fine a point on it, but 'need for immediate satisfaction' is just how it works imho.

not really sure why you are beeing downvoted apart from 'less' always beeing a tough sale.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by MikeCapone on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:53PM (#33207410)
Agreed if what is taking so long makes a difference.

I suspect a lot of it is red tape without a real benefit...

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by CabSauce on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:14PM (#33207651)
If you can identify red tape without a benefit and useful red tape, let me know. We'll be rich.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by concordDance on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:48PM (#33208028)
We can see how useful it is by comparing the 1970s accident and death rate with todays. Doing that we'll find that we're spending over a billion dollars per life saved from radiation poisoning. Which is ludicrously inefficient.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by logifail on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:12PM (#33208307)
https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/11/why-are-nuclear-plan...

"a paper [..] provides some empirical evidence that safety changes have contributed to the cost of building new nuclear reactors. But the study also makes clear that they're only one of a number of factors, accounting for only a third of the soaring costs. The study also finds that, contrary to what those in the industry seem to expect, focusing on standardized designs doesn't really help matters, as costs continued to grow as more of a given reactor design was built."

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by travisgriggs on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:01PM (#33207509)
Trust me. A lot of people benefit (jobs, jobs, jobs!) from these delays. :)

Former commercial nuclear fuel vendor employee here. I did my time with the NRC being part of my life.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by naasking on Saturday October 15, 2022 @01:46PM (#33216928)
The cost to climate change for not hurrying can be considerable. The question is whether going faster is really "rushed", or if the delay is actually unnecessary. Most signs point to the latter.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by DisjointedHunt on Friday October 14, 2022 @01:59PM (#33206768)
Imagine waiting 16 years for a PR :/
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by toast0 on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:23PM (#33207071)
Imagine having good enough specifications that a 16 year old change was still valid. :P

I've seen 16 year old bugs get fixed though. Usually just need to get them retriaged as a security bug, and then all things are fixable.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by kelnos on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:33PM (#33207191)
Funny you mention that; a couple weeks ago I fixed a 16-year-old bug that I myself wrote, in some open source software I started maintaining again after a long hiatus.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by thrdbndndn on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:46PM (#33210128)
Funny everyone thinks it's pull request.

I thought they meant American Permanent Resident (aka green card), which has a notoriously long waiting period.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:12PM (#33206922)
The delays have not come from approval reasons, but from construction mess ups, as well as design flaws (ie unconstructable designs, not designs that would be unsafe if constructed).
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by sroussey on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:25PM (#33207096)
Actually, the rules change every couple of years, which requires change to things already constructed. It’s amazing that the team was able to deal with that and still get it done.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:54PM (#33207431)
What rules have changed in the past five years, when there have been the announcements of delays?

I have been following closely, and never once have I heard of a delay because of regulation changes. Not once! It's all construction.

And with the costs of delays, blaming this on an external party like the NRC would be an essential thing to do to explain it to the backers.

If you have any knowledge of regulations that caused the big delays, I would love to know, and would be very surprised.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by grandinj on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:12AM (#33212542)
It's not that the rules change, it's that the rules (as written) are open to interpretation. So if you design something, get it approved, start building, then get the NRC inspector on-site to confirm, and he disagrees with your interpretation, you get to rip out that piece and rebuild it, with all the attendant delays and costs.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Saturday October 15, 2022 @10:52AM (#33215345)
So what sort of interpretation are we talking about here? Welding quality? Concrete qualities?
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by grandinj on Saturday October 15, 2022 @12:13PM (#33216022)
No, if the rules specified that level of detail, they would probably be all right. The NRC rules appear to be higher level, and built around specifying "safety methodologies", and it's the translation of those safety methodologies to concrete (haha) level detail that gets messy.

Although to fair on the NRC, there was a case where, due to lack of experience, the contractor cast an enormous slab using the wrong rating of concrete, which then had to be removed at great expense and delay.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Saturday October 15, 2022 @09:23PM (#33220269)
I haven't heard anything about interpretation of rules changing that causes problems. I have heard pleeeenty of stories like yours about the concrete.

And that's what it comes down to, EPC and design not understanding each other and mucking it up. Regulations and rules have not gotten in the way or caused ballooning budgets or massive delays.

IN fact, if the NRC had more regulations and required the design to specify how to construct and other parts, then perhaps these projects would not be in so much trouble. But instead all three sides of the deal seem intent on mucking up the construction and then suing each other at the end when everything falls apart.

And that's the problem with the entire nuclear construction industry: no accountability or reliability, and tooooons of corruption. Some of the execs involved with the Summer project are going to jail, and if executives in the US are going to jail for something other than medical regulations (the only regulations with real teeth for executives), then they are hopelessly corrupt.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by pengaru on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:10PM (#33206890)
> Imagine waiting 16 years for a PR :/

Imagine writing bug-free code put in continuous, mass population-critical use for the better part of a century.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by robertlagrant on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:15PM (#33206968)
That would be the analog of a fully autonomous power station. Plenty of people in current ones to watch and patch things!
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tchaffee on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:52PM (#33207402)
> Imagine writing bug-free code

Can't possibly go tits up.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Turing_Machine on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:24PM (#33208405)
Nuclear power has been in use in the United States for over 70 years without a single fatality to a member of the general public. Better than any other energy source.

A few plant and supply chain workers have been killed, but again, fewer than with any other source (mining coal and climbing on roofs and towers to install wind and solar is dangerous, yo).

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tchaffee on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:44PM (#33208613)
The claim was not "relatively safe compared to other forms of energy". The claim was bug free. Which -- if you want to use past history -- is false.

> climbing on roofs and towers to install wind and solar is dangerous, yo

Climbing on the roof of a two story house to install solar panels is considerably less dangerous than building a nuclear power plant. Yo.

> without a single fatality to a member of the general public.

No immediate fatality is the only accurate claim you can make. Over 150,000 people were evacuated from the Three-Mile Island disaster. Due to the stress, there were some increases in consumption of alcohol, cigarettes, and tranquilizers immediately following the accident. The eventual long term effects of those behaviors surely resulted in shorter life spans for at least some of the people.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/003801...

> for over 70 years

That's a short time. Unless you can show the US is somehow exceptional in its quality controls compared to Japan, then a huge disaster like Fukushima is inevitable, and life will be lost.

No one complains about the dangers of the neighbors who use solar energy. No one wants a reactor in their backyard. And it has fair reasoning behind it. You'll never have to evacuate 150,000 people due to your neighbors' solar panels failing.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tchaffee on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:03PM (#33209350)
> In terms of workers killed per watt-hour generated?

> No, it isn't. It's not even close. Yo.

This source says you are wrong. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-from-energy-p...

What source were you using when making your claim?

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by philipkglass on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:33PM (#33209587)
The rate used to be higher for solar, because it used to be the case that most solar modules were installed in small rooftop systems. Now most solar power comes from large ground level solar farms. In 2020, 68% of US solar generation came from utility-scale farms [1]. Over time the solar PV deaths-per-TWh ratio has decreased in 3 ways:

1) Ground level installations have a greatly diminished risk of dangerous falls and have come to account for more wattage than rooftop systems.

2) Installing a solar panel in a large farm instead of on a roof yields more energy output per year, since it usually has mechanical sun tracking [2] and will be oriented for optimum output even if installed with a fixed tilt.

3) Newer panels generate more annual energy output per panel, per kilogram, and per square meter. That means that the same number of full time solar installation workers produce more energy over the system's lifetime.

[1] https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy22osti/81325.pdf page 9

[2] https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2017/09/20/trackers-dominate-u-s...

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Turing_Machine on Saturday October 15, 2022 @09:08AM (#33214434)
> Probably Turing_Machine was remembering an older report

No, I was talking about the United States. Not Chernobyl.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tchaffee on Saturday October 15, 2022 @12:00PM (#33215926)
So you've cherry picked the data to fit your narrative. You're simultaneously claiming that the US can somehow safely build the tall and complex structures for a nuclear plant but cannot safely install solar panels on a 2 story building. That doesn't speak to the safety of nuclear. That speaks to different safety regulations on different types of construction sites or something similar. You need to look at causation, not correlation. There is nothing less safe about solar (even if we cherry pick the US) when compared to nuclear once you look at actual causes.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Turing_Machine on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:37PM (#33217891)
I haven't "cherry-picked" anything.

The Soviet Union (and now Russia) is notorious for having crap technology.

Adding Chernobyl into the mix is like adding the (outrageously high) air crash rates from the Soviet Union into the mix and claiming that it's "evidence" that flying is dangerous.

> You're simultaneously claiming that the US can somehow safely build the tall and complex structures for a nuclear plant

Yes. We can. 70 years, no accidents.

> but cannot safely install solar panels on a 2 story building

I'm saying that the fatality rate is HIGHER for solar panels. Which it is.

I think we're done here.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tchaffee on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:58PM (#33218088)
> The Soviet Union (and now Russia) is notorious for having crap technology.

And Japan too? They had a major and recent disaster. How do you explain that? Crap Japanese technology?

> Yes. We can. 70 years, no accidents.

That's absolutely false.

1961. Steam explosion and meltdown results in three fatalities at National Reactor Testing Station's SL-1 Stationary Low-Power Reactor Number One

1986. Feedwater line-burst at Surry Nuclear Power Plant kills 4

2013. One worker was killed and two others injured when part of a generator fell as it was being moved at the Arkansas Nuclear One.

> I'm saying that the fatality rate is HIGHER for solar panels. Which it is.

It's not. You're confusing correlation with causation. There is nothing particular about solar installations that would result in a higher fatality rate compared to building tall nuclear cooling towers. You'd need to point to some sort of causation to be believable.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Turing_Machine on Sunday October 16, 2022 @03:33PM (#33226510)
> And Japan too? They had a major and recent disaster. How do you explain that? Crap Japanese technology?

I explain that with 1) outdated plant, 2) magnitude 9.0 (!) earthquake 3) devastating tsunami, 4) massive fire, 5) total loss of power to all control systems.

Followed by:

6) still didn't kill anybody due to radiation leaks.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tchaffee on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:02AM (#33231921)
> still didn't kill anybody due to radiation leaks.

So what? Solar isn't killing anyone due to radiation leaks either. The subject is death rate, not death due to radiation leaks.

This is yet another example of you trying to get away with cherry picking data. And failing at it.

Besides the fact that the radiation deaths from Fukushima will come.

At least six workers have exceeded lifetime legal limits for radiation and more than 175 (0.7%) have received significant radiation doses

That will never happen with a solar power plant. Never.

And you avoided the question. Does Japan have crap technology? Is that your explanation for the Fukushima disaster? That was your excuse for Russia. What's your excuse for the Fukushima disaster?

There have been nuclear power disasters requiring evacuation at the minimum in Russia, the US, and Japan. Can you name a solar power disaster?

Several comments ago you said "I think we're done here". And in another comment "Again, I think we're done here". You called that wrong, didn't you? Twice.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Turing_Machine on Saturday October 15, 2022 @09:07AM (#33214429)
It appears that your source is including Chernobyl and Fukushima, while my original post was specifically about the United States nuclear power industry.

https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy

Even giving you the benefit of the doubt there, it's clear that nuclear is extremely safe. Plus it has the added benefit of, actually, you know, working (and by "working" I mean "producing energy in quantities sufficient to run a modern industrial society", not "works in someone's pipe dream").

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tchaffee on Saturday October 15, 2022 @10:23AM (#33215117)
> it's clear that nuclear is extremely safe.

It's clear that solar is extremely safe. And doesn't have a history in the US of evacuating over 150,000 people. Which nuclear does.

> Plus it has the added benefit of, actually, you know, working (and by "working" I mean "producing energy in quantities sufficient to run a modern industrial society", not "works in someone's pipe dream"

Modern solar works and continues to be installed at a rapid rate all over the world. Even France is phasing out nuclear. Westinghouse Electric went bankrupt over the Vogtle nuclear plant in discussion. The U.S. government has given $8.3 billion of loan guarantees to help finance construction of the Vogtle reactor. It's not viable anymore compared to very quick and simple to maintain solar plants. The future is sunny. Which is after all just nuclear energy at a safe distance.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Turing_Machine on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:38PM (#33217901)
> And doesn't have a history in the US of evacuating over 150,000 people.

Sorry, you don't get to count media hysteria as a "risk" of nuclear energy.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tchaffee on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:17PM (#33218231)
> Sorry, you don't get to count media hysteria as a "risk" of nuclear energy.

It wasn't media hysteria. The evacuation was to protect people. On the seven-point International Nuclear Event Scale, it is rated Level 5. It was a partial meltdown, and there was a risk of explosion, releasing radiation into the general area. Not evacuating would have been grossly irresponsible.

It is a matter of historical record that Met Ed had not informed state officials before conducting a steam venting from the plant. Convinced that the company was downplaying the severity of the accident, state officials turned to the NRC.

Twenty-eight hours after the accident began, William Scranton III, the lieutenant governor, appeared at a news briefing to say that Metropolitan Edison, the plant's owner, had assured the state that "everything is under control".

Later that day, Scranton changed his statement, saying that the situation was "more complex than the company first led us to believe". There were conflicting statements about radioactivity releases. Schools were closed and residents were urged to stay indoors. Farmers were told to keep their animals under cover and on stored feed.

Governor Dick Thornburgh, on the advice of NRC chairman Joseph Hendrie, advised the evacuation "of pregnant women and pre-school age children...within a five-mile radius of the Three Mile Island facility". The evacuation zone was extended to a 20-mile radius on Friday, March 30.

Where do you see the press taking action in any of the above except to repeat what state and NRC officials had decided?

Can you name a US evacuation over a solar power accident?

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Turing_Machine on Sunday October 16, 2022 @03:34PM (#33226523)
> It wasn't media hysteria.

It absolutely was media hysteria. Add "stupid and cowardly politicians" if you like. I'd be okay with that.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tchaffee on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:13AM (#33232005)
It absolutely was not media hysteria.

> Add "stupid and cowardly politicians" if you like.

Do you expect the average politician to be highly educated about when a nuclear meltdown in progress becomes dangerous enough to evacuate?

Do you think politicians should be brave about the lives of others when faced with a nuclear meltdown? You can be brave with your own life -- that's your choice for sure -- but asking political leaders to risk the lives of hundreds of thousands of people just in order to make sure nuclear has a good name, seems quite off. Asking people to not be "cowardly" when faced with an actual nuclear meltdown in progress sounds more like a sociopath than of a leader tasked with the responsibility to protect people.

Has any political leader ever had to be brave about a solar power plant disaster? Can you even name a solar power plant disaster?

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by sidewndr46 on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:10PM (#33206895)
Imagine all the dependency rot in the 16 years.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by themitigating on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:20PM (#33207725)
It's not a change to an existing system It's building the entire thing. Also the consequences are significantly worse than a software bug in most cases
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tuukkah on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:58PM (#33207477)
Olkiluoto 3 EPR in Finland (also considered Gen III+) is finally producing electricity in the grid after being shown green light in 2002: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olkiluoto_Nuclear_Power_Plant#...
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by vesinisa on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:09PM (#33207597)
Interestingly both of these nuclear plants (Vogtle 3 and Olkiluoto 3) were built by companies (Westinghouse and Areva) that went bankrupt during the construction.

We sorely need a safe, cost-effective and reproducible blueprint for manufacturing nuclear infrastructure at scale.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Iv on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:20PM (#33207720)
Areva can't really bankrupt: it is backed by the French government, its main owner. It still exist and is basically a public company that critics argue is structured in order to dismantle the industrial companies that were still under public control. But nuclear energy is very unlikely to be really privatized in France. That's a very touch political subject.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by vesinisa on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:37PM (#33207907)
Olkiluoto 3 definitely bankrupted Areva. The company ran out of money and the liability from that one project became a risk for all the other (healthy) branches. They restructured it to different companies with only the problematic Olkiluoto 3 project staying in the original French state-owned Areva. Once this project is complete Areva will be defunct.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by johnchristopher on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:18PM (#33207695)
> We sorely need a safe, cost-effective and reproducible blueprint for manufacturing nuclear infrastructure at scale.

Well, that was part of Areva's branding circa 2009: nuclear's nespresso and selling combustible and reactor in the same package. Full vertical integration: uranium mining, enrichment, reactor building, recycling.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by bouzouk on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:43PM (#33207972)
And do you know what went wrong?
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tuukkah on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:24PM (#33208410)
They sold reactors for 3 billion a piece but it cost them 11 billion to build the first one because they didn't have and couldn't find the necessary competence.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by johnchristopher on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:30PM (#33210020)
I don't have a comprehensive answer. All I know is Areva bought 3 uranium deposits in Africa for ~2.5 billions of € (plus ~1 billion of € for additional services Areva built later, like a desalination plant) but the deposits were ultimately not exploitable (costs of extraction were too high because concentration of uranium in the deposits was too small).

Areva used to be top in their field (mine prospecting, geological stuff) and then discredited. Ended up being bought back by EDF (which is to say, bought back by the French state).

The company (Uramin) that Areva bought (to get the uranium deposit fields) seem to have lie about their deposits' potential. It was before Fukushima sent the price of Uranium down, so they were expecting a lot of return on investments from this move.

The whole affair is riddled with corruption, insider knowledge and incompetence in high level ranks at Areva. Too much easy money if you ask me, then someone (Uramin + insider ?) wanted a bigger part of the pie and the whole cake got poisoned.

edit: also too much money (~10billions) invested in different fields ultimately led up Areva to bankruptcy.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by themitigating on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:16PM (#33207676)
What if it's not cost effective? Can we still do it for the environment?
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:18PM (#33207694)
We could, and would have to, if we didn't have other options that were equally friendly to the environment.

But given two options, one twice (or more) the cost of the other, and with the more expensive option being slower and less scalable, why choose the hard and expensive route versus the cheap and easy route?

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by aeternum on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:30PM (#33207841)
The cheap and easy route is wind+solar+battery?

And what about fusion, we spend a lot on R&D but it's pretty clear it will be even more expensive than fission, if you were in charge would you cancel that effort entirely and shift funds elsewhere?

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by chess_buster on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:15PM (#33208342)
Even Sabine would not do it.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:39PM (#33208568)
Wind+solar+battery is here today, and the faster we deploy it, the more we will save. Every day that we delay the transition is another day that we are overpaying for energy.

If fusion can compete once it happens, bring it on. But it should be targeting a cost of $1-5/MWh instead of $50/MWh.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by pfdietz on Friday October 14, 2022 @09:09PM (#33210598)
Most DT fusion efforts should be cancelled. ITER is an abomination, for example. It has no chance of leading to anything remotely attractive as a power plant.

Helion's approach might make engineering sense, but it's still a longshot. But that's ok for research.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by concordDance on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:29PM (#33207830)
Wait, when did we solve power storage? I must have missed the memo...
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:36PM (#33208530)
I'm the past few years, lithium ion battery storage has plummeted in cost and is seeing massive deployment all around the grid.

Most utilities use five-year resource plans, and even then they tend to use out of day publications for cost guidance, which themselves took several years to be written and get through peer review.

So traditional utility deployment is done on 10-year old info. In more open markets, like Texas, storage is a huuuuge amount of the capital that's being deployed on the grid. And in places with more active residents that force the utility commissions to force the utilities to use realistic numbers, like California, storage is already deployed in GW range. For example, existing storage on the grid today was a bigger player than nuclear during California's recent and massive heat waves.

And one dirty secret that they don't tell you about nuclear: it's also going to need storage. Nuclear is not dispatchable, it can't be turned down on demand, and can't be ramped up. But real power demand varies a huge amount throughout the day.

The only reason France was able to get up to 70% nuclear energy on their grid was by using the continental grid to trade energy with other countries. France has a small number of super expensive nuclear "peakers" but they can only deal with very small fluctuations in demand.

So if nuclear were ever going to be a really major power source, or the only power source, it would require lots of storage to balance load.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by concordDance on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:23AM (#33213195)
> In the past few years, lithium ion battery storage has plummeted in cost and is seeing massive deployment all around the grid.

I advize doing the maths on this. Look at graphs of how much solar and win vary, check total elecricity consumption, look up latest price of li ion batteries and then do a bit of maths to see how much you need so that you get no blackouts in a 10 year period. Then realize you should use compressed air storage instead...

Last I checked, if we use the cheapest form of storage (compressed air) and assume there are enough suitable caves for the huge amount we want, we'd triple electricity costs by switching to renewables+storage.

> And one dirty secret that they don't tell you about nuclear: it's also going to need storage.

Not really, you just need to be able to burn excess power. Which is a very easy thing to do (you can spend as much as you want on turning atmospheric CO2 and water into methane).

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Saturday October 15, 2022 @10:56AM (#33215382)
I have done the math, and that's why I think that nuclear will only be a niche, and expensive, form of energy for a few countries that do not have good renewable resources.

As for CAES, if it can scale and be cheap, great. But there isn't nearly as much evidence of that for CAES as there is for batteries, which are being deployed by the GWh on the grid now, and which have massive plans for expansion in areas where the grid is market based and profit driven, instead of a regulated monopoly that can rest on its laurels.

I occasionally hear about liquid air too, and though everybody I have encountered that works on it is a bit nuts, I am more optimistic about liquid air than CAES for massive scale, as liquid air can be deployed many many places.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by pfdietz on Friday October 14, 2022 @09:13PM (#33210622)
What was holding back power storage was that it's largely unneeded when we're still burning fossil fuels.

No technological breakthroughs are needed for arbitrarily scalable power storage with good efficiency.

https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/1.4994054

"Insofar as the numbers I have presented in this paper are correct, they demonstrate that energy storage is a problem of 19th century science. No future laboratory breakthroughs or discoveries are required for solving it. All that is needed is fine engineering and assiduous attention to detail. Said poetically, this is 21st century rocket science.

Moreover, it is clear from Fig. 11 that the storage capacity of months becomes feasible once the engine (including the heat exchangers) exists as a product one can purchase at a known cost, particularly if the heat is further transferred into cheaper media for longer-term storage, such as rocks underground. Thus, pumped thermal storage with heat exchange is not a niche solution to the energy storage problem but a global one. This is the reason I think it will prevail."

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by concordDance on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:26AM (#33213211)
I'm disappointed that paper contains no cost estimates. Those are the key thing with energy storage.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by leetnewb on Saturday October 15, 2022 @07:09AM (#33213750)
Here is a framework for government backed research into the topic: https://www.energy.gov/energy-storage-grand-challenge/articl...
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by pfdietz on Saturday October 15, 2022 @07:52AM (#33214005)
The paper does contain (rough) cost estimates, specifically the cost per unit of energy storage (about $13/kWh) and the cost per unit of power (from $0.20-0.27/W depending on the choice of gas.) See section V, "Cost".

I'm not impressed with the costing methodology used, but it's probably at least in the ballpark.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by logifail on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:07PM (#33208252)
> We sorely need a safe, cost-effective and reproducible blueprint for manufacturing nuclear infrastructure at scale

Maybe. Or maybe nuclear is actually just too expensive, and we need to stop pretending it's a commercially-viable technology.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tick_tock_tick on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:16PM (#33208899)
I've always wondered is the any reason we can't task the Navy with building these? They already make reactors for aircraft carrier and subs.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by nine_k on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:41PM (#33209150)
The newest US nuclear aircraft carrier uses Bectel A1B reactors [1], which produce 125 MWe and additional 260 MW of mechanical turbine power, which we could optimistically convert into another 260 MWe. This would be 385 MWe.

Each of the two reactors mentioned in the article produces 1250 MWe.

OTOH maybe a row of smaller reactors could offer a better economy of scale for production, even if they require more parts and more maintenance overall.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A1B_reactor

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by brandmeyer on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:03PM (#33209349)
They are extremely expensive in LCOE terms.

Their core life relies on highly enriched uranium. Production and delivery at commercial power scale is a weapons proliferation risk in addition to being more expensive.

Refueling a naval reactor is a multi-year operation that happens only a tiny handful of times in the life of the ship. Current-gen submarines don't get refueled at all. They can get away with this in large part because they aren't running at 100% power. They are shut down in port, and even at sea they only operate at low power most of the time.

To reduce LCOE, commercial power reactors run at full power all the time. Refueling a commercial power reactor takes a month or so and happens every 1.5 years.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Manuel_D on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:38PM (#33209102)
Other countries manage to built nuclear plants on time and on budget. China and South Korea are managing it.

In the west, nuclear plants were more affordable when built at scale. It's not just reactors that are costly, specialty parts like steam generators and turbines are cheaper to produce in runs of 40 instead of 4. It's not so much the blueprint that makes a plant cheap. It's building two dozen of the same blueprint.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Schroedingersat on Saturday October 15, 2022 @12:17AM (#33211707)
What's the price ratio between the first PWRs in the US and canada and the ones started in the late 80s/early 90s after the industry had maximum experience?

We'll just multiply that same ratio by the price of Vogtle and get.. what? $30k/kW?

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by bullen on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:26PM (#33207795)
I think it's still not pushing anything to the grid, it has just reached crusing power: "Regular production is expected to begin in December 2022."
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Gwypaas on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:37PM (#33207916)
It is pushing to the grid, but short stints validating different modes of operation. Easier, and more economical, to use the generators than trying to cool another 30% thermal capacity.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tuukkah on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:03PM (#33208206)
"The electricity production of Olkiluoto’s third nuclear power plant unit started on Saturday, 12 March 2022, at 12.01 p.m."

"The reactor achieved its design output power 30 September 2022."

Regular production will mean all tests have been completed. They are currently ongoing and yes we can notice it in the electricity price when they test shutdowns and 1600 MW (15% nation-wide) disappears from the supply.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by bullen on Saturday October 15, 2022 @08:55AM (#33214362)
Where can one see the status of the power plant.

This is VERY concerning as prices where very high as the plant was operating then?

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by tuukkah on Sunday October 16, 2022 @04:00AM (#33221956)
Here's the planned status: https://www.tvo.fi/en/index/production/plantunits/ol3/ol3for...

Here you can see the current and past national totals for nuclear/hydro/wind/solar etc. production. Choose 12 October to see what it looks like when they tested turning the whole 1600 MW off at once: https://www.fingrid.fi/en/electricity-market/power-system/

Many things have affected the prices recently including imports (or lack of) from Sweden and Norway, exports to Estonia, wind and rainfall situation, as well as other nuclear reactors being offline for maintenance.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by bullen on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:47AM (#33231826)
ok, looking closer at this it seems the production only ramped up in september. Have they explained why radioactive matter was found in the turbine? Impressive that wind produces between 2-3GW!
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by bullen on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:29AM (#33245709)
nm, now it's down to 500MW...
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by acchow on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:14PM (#33207653)
Quicker than building a condo in SF
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by melling on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:45PM (#33207995)
Yes, can anyone explain the problem in any detail? ie more than “regulations”

Decades ago the United States didn’t get to 20% electricity from nuclear power by being so inefficient.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by runarberg on Saturday October 15, 2022 @01:26PM (#33216734)
I’m not entirely sure about the history here, but I suspect the 3-mile island partial meltdown is a big reason why. Regulators realized that the current framework was too lax and too risky so they tightened it. They also retrofitted existing powerplants with newer and better standards which must have cost a lot, popular opinion shifted away from these plants so they weren’t politically popular any more, construction knowledge was lost, and has to be re-learned now in a stricter framework.

The job market is also a lot more diverse now then in the 70s. There used to be a lot of highly skilled construction workers back then. Generally large infrastructure projects take longer and cost more, regardless of the project type.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by kube-system on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:18PM (#33208913)
Well, closer to 17 years, because it doesn't go online until next year.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by elihu on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:46PM (#33209691)
Now that the paperwork has been done once, does that mean it'll be a lot cheaper/easier/faster to build additional plants with the same design?