A phone at cruising altitude can see and try to connect to a huge number of cell towers at once. Like, orders of magnitude more towers than it would be able to see even from the top of a mountain. Plus, you're constantly disconnecting from some towers and connecting to new ones. This puts a strain on the cell network systems.
One person won't have a negative impact but then you multiply the problem by the number of people who fly daily.
This doesn’t track. What about trains?
While I have never read anything concretely analyzing the handover pattern of devices on airplanes, I would expect that since a very large number of cells are almost equally visible/equal signal strength, the network would have to frequently handover the device from one cell to another.
The handover process is, for voice traffic, very resource intense. (in GSM) it involves duplication of traffic to the neighboring cell and a lot of coordination.
I think that could be the reason for why mobile operators find airplane-borne devices annoying.
I am also unconvinced that handsets on aeroplanes are really a problem for the network, but trains aren't the counterexample you're making them out to be.
Gogo provides inflight Wi-Fi in the US through its ground based towers and all the antennas are pointed at the sky :)
Flights (at least in the US) fly roughly a direct route, but ATC spaces out planes and small weather diversions are common. So it’s more like a band of coverage needed between cities. Also, the combinatorics of considering every US city pair that currently or has previously had commercial service between gets long. Then you would have to consider every route that an airline in the future may offer, even just seasonally. Then if you calculated the optimal route between each pair and figured out the width of the cellular coverage at 30,000 ft from a single cell tower below, I don’t think it would be possible to offer service to every domestic flight in the US without achieving complete coverage of the US.
China on the other hand has a limited number of very narrow flight corridors that all commercial aviation is restricted to because the majority of the airspace is government controlled. That’s the only nation I can think of that would have enough air traffic to justify terrestrial tower installation but whose domestic flights are confined to a such a small part of the airspace that it would be possible to provide service to all domestic flights without achieving coverage of all Chinese airspace.
Also, they don't really ask for airplane mode anymore, at least not when I'm flying.
https://pocketnow.com/airplane-mode/
The problem is significantly lessened for trains vs. planes though because you're traveling an order of magnitude slower and hence you switch cells an order of magnitude less frequently. Also many commuter rails run alongside major highways or boulevards, where the cell systems are built assuming lots of cell handoffs at roughly highway speeds. If enough people used high-speed rail to overwhelm the cell system we'd probably see announcements to put phones in airplane mode there too, but very few folks will travel long distances at high speeds on a train.
https://www.transitchicago.com/cta-to-bring-4g-wireless-serv...
That's a pretty insane claim in most of the world. Lots of people expect and enjoy full coverage on train or subway rides. I work at a carrier and the signal strength and cell capacity on trains are part of the top metrics we use to benchmark the quality of our network and the customer experience.
Why would you be expected to do this when we don't require drivers to put their phones in airplane mode? I get that US trains are slow compared to other parts of the world, but does the Autobahn require airplane mode? Doubtful since my German car happily connects to my phone in multiple ways.
> That's a pretty insane claim in most of the world.
So is this:
> but very few folks will travel long distances at high speeds on a train.
Millions of people travel long distances on trains: 353 million/year on the Shinkansen network, 1.5+ billion/year on China high-speed rail, 110 million on France's TGV. These passengers use their phone without overloading the cell networks.
I think the challenge isn't so much "lots of people in one place" as "lots of people travelling extremely fast with line-of-sight to hundreds of cellular towers at the same time".
If cells A and F are on the same channel pair and a handset can see both towers the tower the handset is not talking to just has a higher noise floor. It's like in an apartment if the next unit over is on the same WiFi channel.
You'll note that in older generation cell systems theaters, malls, and stadiums were terrible places for cell signals. Now many have micro/nano cells that cover much smaller areas to deal with congestion. Handsets reduce their output power when the received signal strength is better. So a handset will readily talk to a microcell at a stadium rather than try to talk to a tower further away (with a worse signal).
But for planes, hundreds of passengers hitting dozens of towers simultaneously on the same channel pairs would be rough on switching. Carriers need to know where in the network to route messages to handsets. If a handset is handing off to multiple towers quickly or worse hopping seemingly randomly to towers as a jet flies over it'll be difficult to keep it connected. Multiple that by thousands of people in the air at any given time. Areas near busy airports would have absurdly unreliable connections for people in the air and on the ground.
Not once has any of my carriers even said “please turn on airplane mode to help the network”. Instead it’s an in-passing recommendation made by air stewardesses so boilerplate it feels like superstition.
I wonder what the actual impact is and how that relates to the low effort messaging around airplane mode.
> Trains are what keep groceries on your shelves. They almost had general strike last week because the drivers only have 5 days a year not working. No weekends, no sick days, etc.
Are you trying to disagree? That sounds extremely human-hostile.
Please, just don’t.
At 20 miles out, a device on the ground starts losing line of sight, at 20 miles out, a device on an airplane starts receiving horizontal line of sight.
I can get the EM interference angle just fine, which stays (or stayed until recently) in place as a vestigial CYA rule of a time when cell phones were crude enough to be able to produce a spark which is what makes gas stations display a "no cellphone" sign to this day because back then it could ignite gasoline vapour.
Trains also have trees, hills, buildings, earth curvature, etc obstructing how many towers your phone can see. Planes generally have a clear LOS to the tower over a significantly larger area because of the altitude.
If the radiation pattern of the tower wasn’t the shape that it is, the problem would be even worse in fact.
The fact that aircraft systems are sensitive to frequencies outside their allocation is ridiculous. If literally anyone else was camping on frequency bands they didn't have the rights to the various regulatory bodies would be up in arms.
As a private pilot and software engineer interested in spectrum policy, I’ve been following this closely for years as it’s wound it’s way through the FAA. I have yet to see any convincing, reproducible evidence that any radio altimeters that are operating within specification (filtering out all signal below 4.2 GHz) have malfunctioned due to interference from 5G cellular signals. The one thing the FAA and airline industry claim as evidence is a study by an industry group (Radio Technical Committee for Aeronautics), whose members include radio altimeter manufacturers who would benefit from large retrofits/upgrades. The RTCA didn’t actually do any of their own testing, they received aggregated data from AVSI, a Texas A&M aerospace research group, which had done a study in 2019 on radio altimeters interference. In 2020 the FCC determined that AVSI study “does not demonstrate that harmful interference would likely result under reasonable scenarios (or even reasonably 'foreseeable' scenarios to use the parlance of AVSI)”. Then, two years later when the FAA went to the NTIA (National Telecommunications and Information Administration), which is the agency tasked with managing federal spectrum and agency spectrum disputes, and demanded they stop the FCC from letting carriers turn on networks in the C-band, the NTIA refused because its own technical experts had already evaluated the technical data that RTCA used as evidence that any 5G use of 3.7 GHz - 3.98 GHz band would cause interference severe enough to cause a catastrophic crash resulting hull loss.
Also, when this whole fiasco unfolded neither Verizon or AT&T had spectrum even close to the radio altimeters band. Of the C-band spectrum (3.7 GHz to 3.98 GHz) that was auctioned off a few years ago, only Block A which is between 3.7 GHz and 3.8 GHz was being used. So in addition to the existing, and potentially larger than technically required, 220 MHz guard band between 4.2 GHz (where radio altimeters start) and 3.98 GHz, when the airlines were threatening to cancel service to the US and the FAA was waging a PR war against the FCC the spectrum in question was 3.7 GHz - 3.8 GHz. Even if Verizon and AT&T rolled out 100% of the 5G spectrum they had the ability to use in 2021, it would have meant 5G cell service was within 400 MHz of the radio altimeter spectrum. The entire allocated band for radio altimeters is only 200 MHz (4.2 GHz - 4.4 GHz). Additionally, other countries like Japan have cellular providers operating in 4.0 GHz - 4.1 GHz. Japanese aviation officials (unlike the FAA) actually configured different types of 5G equipment and radio altimeters and tested them, including to see the minimum guard band needed. They found 60 MHz was the minimum guard band needed and therefore the “standard” 100 MHz guard band would be fine. They also found you shouldn’t install 5G towers directly below the approach path of an airport, but that even high powered 5G base stations won’t interfere with radio altimeters if they are 200m away.
I think by far the most comprehensive explainer for this whole saga is by Harold Feld of public knowledge, which if you’re not familiar is a nonprofit advocating for an open internet which includes white papers and FCC testimony on spectrum policy they view as beneficial the public, such as allocating more of the federal government, specifically the military’s, huge bands of essentially unused spectrum. It’s on his personal blog. https://wetmachine.com/tales-of-the-sausage-factory/what-the...
It’s actually an FCC regulation that requires it, so it’s not a courtesy as you say.
First of all, if you've ever been to an event with hundreds or thousands of people (such as a parade or a rally), you'll notice that even though you have "full bars", your service is degraded beyond usability, and you'll receive text messages hours late.
But in this case, the issue is that people's phones will be trying to connect to many different towers in short succession, as the plane travels.
> Instead, it’s interference caused by altitude and the pinging of towers.
I don't believe you. Regardless, I have never used airplane mode on an airplane and I never will.
I guess I'll continue to ignore that law :)
That might have been a concern when 2.5G was cutting edge and HLR/VLR databases ran on Sun hardware of the period. Even then, hundreds of updates in a couple seconds was not a huge challenge.
Like a lot of what airlines tell customers, it is a self-serving version of reality, strongly colored for airlines' convenience and deniability.
There was never any risk. Someone wrote an article in the times suggesting "perhaps" and people freaked out.
There has never been a single instance or study to support this claim. The entire idea airplane mode is a farce.
I was in university once doing a signal interference lab: we had set up an circuit and we're trying to induce current in it from another circuit. Suddenly the oscilloscope on the receiving end showed a couple of wild spikes, and I received a text message on my trusty Nokia 1611: apparently 900 MHz was in the sweet spot.
Source: This is a lie but sitting behind someone on a plane who gets a call is super annoying.
This was in France if that's a relevant clue.
Boeing has an issue where its radio altimeters are affected by C-band 5G transmissions. I believe maybe the pilots were relying more on the precision of the altimeter because their vision was impaired due to the bad weather? The whole 'turn off phones' instruction could be because people would follow the unusual request to turn off their phones instead of just telling them to put it in airplane mode (which is so common that some people just don't bother)
Whether electronic devices inside the plane are such problem I don't know.
Realistically there isn't an issue with leaving a cell phone on and out of airplane mode going purely based on how many people forget or ignore the directions everyday and how infrequently there are problems. But I'll make two points:
The idea that a cell phone transmitter can interfere with an airplane is by no means outrageous. Sure, a modern iPhone/Pixel/whatever has to meet certain emissions and interference standards. And modern airliners are designed with some interference rejection in mind. And ancient airliners from the 70s don't rely on a lot of electronic systems at all. As for airplanes designed in the 90s, well it's not silly to ask whether 200 people with 1W transmitters would interfere with the electronic systems. A properly functioning compliant phone shouldn't, but there's still some risk. Incidents do happen, though they are generally minor. I was on an airplane that had to abort a landing and go-around because they couldn't hear the tower over cellphone interference (voice comms are analog). Obviously no one died, but we were still delayed a bit.
It probably makes sense to relax the rules, but it is incredibly frustrating to see the attitude of "if they don't force me to turn it off it must be OK". The FCC requires you to turn off transmitters to avoid interference. The airline asks you to do so for the same reason. Experts in the field (myself included) are telling you there's a small risk and you should hit the airplane mode button. There's zero benefit to keeping your cellular service active in flight at all. But everyone's seen some article on Facebook (or in this case inverse.com) that says maybe there's a big conspiracy and everyone's lying to them. So they take a risk (albeit an extremely small one) with the lives of 200 other people. For no gain at all.
So do whatever you want, there's nothing I can do about human nature, but believe me when I tell you there's no government conspiracy to make you press the little airplane button funded by the cell phone companies. Yeah, the risk is probably negligible - it's just really hard to prove it and easier to make a small ask of passengers.
I suppose this issue will actually fix itself with the advent of cheap Internet onboard the plane via WiFi, which combined with VoWiFi, will effectively switch cell off automatically when connected. People are more likely to use free WiFi onboard than to voluntarily remember to switch the Airplane Mode on.
(Without Airplane Mode, the phone will keep trying to connect to cellular towers, which just makes the network experience unstable)
Perhaps "Underground Mode" would be more suitable in a modern context /s
As a tangent, I feel that a lot of these problems are fundamentally because engineers don't understand how poorly their software performs on unstable networks. Unless you live in a large metropolitan area with a well used underground transit network (in the USA, I suppose NYC would be the only qualifying city... sigh), you'd likely never experience these symptoms on a daily basis.
I don't honestly believe many developers don't experience this a lot. It's probably just such a transitory experience that it's not worth the rearchitecting required to really solve it.
Or anywhere more than ~50km from the nearest town. I dunno what coverage is like in the U.S. but in parts of Australia it’s not uncommon to lose reception when country driving.
By far, my #1 wish for my iPhone would be a mode to basically "detect subway networks constantly changing" and just give up trying. Like, if it observes all cell and wifi networks disappearing entirely together with movement... then totally new ones appearing... every 45 seconds... just stop. And wait passively until there's some kind of heuristic indicating you're above ground, before trying to establish new connections with everything.
Obviously make this optional, but I turn on airplane mode every time I enter the subway and turn it off after I leave, just so I don't have to worry about running out of battery during the day otherwise in case I take 3-4 trips.
Also even if i'm listening to music I have downloaded locally, Apple Music will do a system-wide popup complaining that it lost cellular connection. Sometimes in Safari a webpage that was downloaded at the station will suddenly erase itself and attempt to refresh itself upon losing connection. Those are usually the kinds of ad-ridden sites that are making nonstop ajax calls, but sometimes that's what i'm reading.
Yes, you would think ... but that is not the case.
QA and design of modern mobile apps and software - and even devices and appliances - neglects the testing of bad network connectivity.
Both my physical Sonos devices and, for instance, the apple-provided podcasts app, can handle being fully offline reasonably well. On the other hand, if you start dropping ~50% of packets they lose their mind and (in the case of Apples podcast app) freeze or crash.
‘Because of the long historical association of activating that mode on airplane flights?’
“Well, yeah, but, like, it’s actually anachronistic, because it doesn’t really affect the airplane anymore if you’re transmitting.”
‘Okay, but, I mean, it is the mode that, even today, in 2060, most commonly comes up when you’re on a pla—‘
“Look, I was just trying to sound wise. Just let me have this one.”
“Well Nancy, before instant interdimensional travel…”
You can, just long press the wifi icon in control center, it will expand to show all wifi points nearby. Then click on "settings" button, and it will take you to the actual wifi settings page in the settings app.
This isn't a recent change btw. Idk when they added it, but I remember using it since at least iOS 13 or 14, which was 2-3 years ago.
If you want, you can also just add that shortcut to lockscreen as well and do it via a single tap from there (which is also less clicks than even control center).
0. https://support.apple.com/guide/shortcuts/run-shortcuts-tapp...
Actually photograph was already out of date, because graph had morphed from "to write" to making any kind of image. Which itself I believe meant something akin to inscription /engraving.
Actually while photograph may no longer be a graph as in image on a surface, in some ways it's still an image impressed on rocks. Made using lithography. Have we gotten closer to its roots?
No, they were all floppy. You are just thinking of the hard plastic case that 3.5" diskettes had. If you crack it open and disassemble it, the actual spinning disk is just as floppy as the 5.25" was.
This is as opposed to a "hard" disk which is a hard platter inside a fixed disk.
I'm probably being a simpleton, but this sounds like inadequate firmware to me. At the very least: Airtags have GPS, so shut them off when they are at $ALTITUDE.
You turn it off at $ALTITUDE. When do you turn them on ? There's no button and it is powered off.
Guessing it was 470 passengers on the plane trying to connect at the same exact moment.
The whole "turn off your devices" thing is more about validating compliance and making people pay attention during the most incident-prone times of flight (takeoff and landing)
https://www.inverse.com/article/51015-cell-phone-use-on-airp...
At one point, when both cell phones and laptops were new, there was perhaps a risk to the airplane's electronics. Modern cell phones have been steadily tuned to reduce interference with other electronics though - good thing, otherwise you couldn't use them in a modern home with its dozens of connected devices. And modern avionics have been shielded to protect them from outside electronic interference - also a good thing, otherwise the next terrorist could simply turn their laptop on. The ban on electronic transmission is one of those regulations that was a response to technology at a particular point in time but now is largely vestigial. You can tell because it's rarely enforced, and yet bad things do not occur just because you forgot to turn your phone to airplane mode.