Is government the reason GitHub is removing the repo?
If so, then this is exactly an abridgment of rights, and GitHub would be an accomplice to the government is that violation. Government asking for someone's rights to be violiated, no matter how politely they do so, is still a violation of rights.
Absolutely nobody will admit to the dynamic and will actively avoid any attempt at on paper recognition of it, as to do so will completely destroy/dismantle the PD chain.
In short, the government is effectively accountabilty laundering in order to for keep out money launderers.
Why do some people jump to interpret things that way? There's something kind of pathetic at the heart of that.
Green has a Constitutional right to publish anywhere, and GitHub is somewhere, so he has a Constitutional right to publish on GitHub. That does not mean the Constitution compels GitHub, it simply means the Constitution does not restrict Green.
No he doesn't, he's merely allowed to do what Github lets him do.
Anyway, this is getting rather silly, so I'll leave you with this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ohDB5gbtaEQ.
You’re struggling with basic concepts. Constitutional rights in general do not compel private actions; they restrict government powers.
If I have the right to life, there is a constraint prohibiting others from taking it from me.
Likewise, if I have the right to publish on Github, then Github does not have the right to stop me.
Seems to me that you're the one struggling with basic comprehension.
Is how I read it.
> The first may protect the right for Github to host the repo (though even that seems somewhat a stretch)
There's a rather murky limit on freedom of speech, I'm really not sure where it stands with regard to instructional content in general - however some such content has been constrained before; usually regarding weapons (or really any content that the government can argue is weapons related).
It's murky, and subject to government overreach.
> but it certainly doesn't grant or protect any right to publish on Github servers.
The first constrains the government, it in no way constrains private entities.
In fact (given the corporate personhood), to require that a private entity publish content from a third party would be compelled speech, and a breach of the entity's first amendment rights.
Common misconception.
You can post the machinist drawings for any unclassified (or classified, if somehow you came across them without having signed any paperwork related to security clearances). That is protected by the Courts.
Where you get into hot water is ITAR and restricted exports where free speech runs into the whole national security/foreign affairs jurisdiction by the Feds. You cannot post the manual for an F-16 for instance, in such a way as it could be accessed by adversaries of the United States. Access to that type of information has to be gated behind some form of arcane onboarding process to ensure one is actually authorized to see it.
There was an attempt at gating 3d printed gun patterns I think, but all the courts would let through is that a manufacturer must ensure the recipient is a U.S. Citizen, so it switched from published on website, to shipped on CD iirc.
Haven't checked on recent developments.
I don't believe it's murky at all, but defined deliberately in fuzzy terms in a number of important ways, one of which is the avoidance of precipitation of criminality. Criminality defined as that which is harmful to society. Although it may sound weak, compared to the presumed unfettered principles invoked above, should one or other of a separating couple used Tornado Cash to rinse common property funds, something that isn't drug dealing or terrorism anyhow, nevertheless it's laundering and using a device to commit a crime without which device that crime may not be possible. Federal proceedings against Tornado Cash have given the unlawful enterprise unprecedented profile and it follows that the motivation for anyone who strives for continuance of the same or similar, in light of the reasons for federal action, could be construed as being potential criminal too. Frankly I am stunned in the era that recognizes hate speech, that the automatic right to unfiltered and inconsequential freedom of speech is claimed so crudely, so reflexively and on such narrow and unexplained grounds..
The first part's maybe true, the second part is bullshit.
Microsoft just did some risk management and decided that it's not worth it to keep their own users data. I find it quite interesting that someone puts Github's management in a difficult situation. Are they gonna terminate Prof Green's account too? Are they gonna hunt down every copy of the source code on Github? Are they giving high-profile users a special treatment?
Looking forward to how this plays out.
Even if some activist executive would allow it, Microsoft’s lawyers would absolutely not.
And the shareholders also wouldn’t.
Don’t forget that the purpose of a business is to create shareholder value (as defined by the shareholders themselves), and I highly doubt that the majority of Microsoft’s shareholders would see any value in this. Just liability.
Conclusion - not worth it.
> Are they gonna terminate Prof Green's account too?
Probably not.
> Are they gonna hunt down every copy of the source code on Github?
Probably.
It's a perversion of the concept to jump to must produce a positive financial return. Sometimes you just need an organization to coordinate something that eases a societal ill.
That business schools have forgotten this, and that we don't remind people of this consistently is a tragedy. It cuts off entire avenues of collective organization to get things done. Some times "getting it done at minimum outlay" is enough.
At no point I suggested that. I said "shareholder value, as defined by the shareholders themselves".
"value" doesn't imply fiscal.
Yeah it proyects it against the government. Everybody else is still free to sue, take down, deny access, whatever.
Republicans would say "hell no it's our sovereignty", Democrats "maybe", the American courts: "maybe but probably not"
Never. Or immediately, depending on your perspective. Either way, there’s no need for further paperwork.
> Treaties to which the United States is a party also have the force of federal legislation […]
— https://www.senate.gov/about/powers-procedures/treaties.htm
If this professor is unconnected to the sanctioned Tornado Cash service, then Github shouldn't have to worry about running afoul of the sanctions by hosting the code.
gitlab isn't bought and paid for, so forcing the issue only stands to win them PR with hackers.
You seem to be under the impression that "the government" is a monolitic beast that all operates together.
There are other parts of government that would like nothing more than to see OFAC get a bloody nose over this (eg, other agencies that believe they should be the ones regulating crypto).
He republished it on GitHub: https://github.com/tornado-repositories
Even more generally, governments ruled by laws do not care in the sense that they do not, as a system, carry grudges and the like. A government contract is awarded by tender, for which there are rules. And unless you have exactly the same people handling two issues, there's just no mechanism for any interest to bend the rules to be transmitted from one group of people to the other.
There are sometimes cracks in this system, but even those are somewhat formalized: "buy American" rules, for example. There are also rules that apply to government contractors but not businesses operating in the private sector exclusively, such as higher minimum wages, enhanced environmental protection, or union requirements. The reason here is that these can be instituted by the executive alone, without the legislative.
But punishing a single company just because they're taking an issue to court? That'd be consider rather corrupt. It's also silly: there are thousands of lawsuits between governments and private businesses every year. Every single Fortune 500 is probably involved in a few dozens at any given time.
If he does not, then he is not a participating entity in the sanctioned service, and is unlikely to attract serious attention from the Justice Department.
It’s nice of the EFF to throw down a gauntlet about free speech, but I expect it will be ignored in favor of sanctioning others who operate cryptohash laundering services.
However, I observe with these sanctions that both the US judiciary and those of many others countries has decided cryptocoin laundering is not a protected human right, due to the balance of harm caused to societies outweighing the rights of the individual. It’s your right here in the US to declare that they’re wrong, but I do not see in your reply any new evidence or arguments presented that would change the course of the US government.
> If the ether is proceeds from a crime, then this is literally just money laundering.
> There’s also this weird delusion that if you put some dirty money in a box with clean money and shake it, then it all comes out as clean — and not that it all comes out as dirty.
> The bad takes were all variations of the fundamental fallacy of cryptocurrency: that you can code your way around the rules of society.
1: https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/2022/08/09/us-sanctions...
That's the exact take that brought to closure of tornado.cash. If you start with two distinct piles and at the end you only get one some-of-these-might-be-dirty pile, the solution to this is to destroy the mixer, not to sift through bank notes. The reason why we don't consider everything that has touched dirty money to be tainted is explicitly to protect people who may have been inadvertently brought into it.
Touching the tornado cash contract is a poison pill right now.
This is well beyond the regulatory and legal powers of the U.S. Treasury and the DOJ. That is not the letter of the law with regards to money laundering, and the agency cannot invent new laws out of thin air. Nor can they blanket ban a technology or code just because they have to learn new stuff. Could Congress pass such a law? Sure, but even then, we'll go to the mats in the court and in state legislatures. Nevermind that criminalizing and demonizing a large portion of the population hurts your re-election chances.
Even torrenting, as egregious as the copyright abuse was in Pirate Bay's heyday, was never banned in such a way. Email scams from Nigeria never necessitated the shutdown of email. VPNs continue to operate.
Nevermind that similar cases with regards to cryptography have already gone to court, which ruled in favor of speech: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/04/remembering-case-estab...
The XKCD example is amusing, but fails even the most basic cross-examination. Surely officers with a court-issued warrant for probable cause of a crime should be able to inspect a person's home or things. Maybe they could find a private key written on a post-it note somewhere in the person's home. That's all fair and good, and no one is arguing against that. Clearly, it's not very scalable, nor should it be. We operate under the presumption of innocence in free societies.
We all have a problem with illegal, abusive, mass surveillance. It is a violation of human liberty and a disturbing trend that has to be pushed against to prevent a full-on dystopian, authoritarian hellscape where you don't even have paper cash as an outlet from the panopticon. To avoid that future outcome, to preserve the freedom of your children, you have to fight for privacy and transactional liberty. My ancestors were willing to bleed and die for liberty. Some of us still are, today. Never wake a sleeping lion, indeed.
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2022/08/code-speech-and-tornad...
> In keeping with our longstanding defense of the right to publish code, we are representing Professor Matthew Green, who teaches computer science at the Johns Hopkins Information Security Institute, including applied cryptography and anonymous cryptocurrencies. Part of his work involves studying and improving privacy-enhancing technologies, and teaching his students about mixers like Tornado Cash. The disappearance of Tornado Cash’s repository from GitHub created a gap in the available information on mixer technology, so Professor Green made a fork of the code, and posted the replica so it would be available for study. The First Amendment protects both GitHub’s right to host that code, and Professor Green’s right to publish (here republish) it on GitHub so he and others can use it for teaching, for further study, and for development of the technology.