News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by mmaunder on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:24PM (#32558607)
Representing how? What action are they anticipating?
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by dekhn on Monday August 22, 2022 @08:22PM (#32559049)
This isn't the first time smart cryptographers have forced an issue like this. He wants the government to threaten GitHub and him with a lawsuit, and they have to sue him in court (which the government wants to avoid as they have a significant chance of losing). Like Clipper and Bernstein v. US, where EFF was involved.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by nimbius on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:15PM (#32559409)
exactly this. Microsoft will always heel to the short leash of US sanctions because the losses for them are tangible: billions in government contracts.

gitlab isn't bought and paid for, so forcing the issue only stands to win them PR with hackers.

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by nl on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:23PM (#32559461)
> Microsoft will always heel to the short leash of US sanctions because the losses for them are tangible: billions in government contracts.

You seem to be under the impression that "the government" is a monolitic beast that all operates together.

There are other parts of government that would like nothing more than to see OFAC get a bloody nose over this (eg, other agencies that believe they should be the ones regulating crypto).

He republished it on GitHub: https://github.com/tornado-repositories

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by IfOnlyYouKnew on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:54PM (#32559651)
More commonly, these are simply different matters, and the different parts of Government that handle them don't care.

Even more generally, governments ruled by laws do not care in the sense that they do not, as a system, carry grudges and the like. A government contract is awarded by tender, for which there are rules. And unless you have exactly the same people handling two issues, there's just no mechanism for any interest to bend the rules to be transmitted from one group of people to the other.

There are sometimes cracks in this system, but even those are somewhat formalized: "buy American" rules, for example. There are also rules that apply to government contractors but not businesses operating in the private sector exclusively, such as higher minimum wages, enhanced environmental protection, or union requirements. The reason here is that these can be instituted by the executive alone, without the legislative.

But punishing a single company just because they're taking an issue to court? That'd be consider rather corrupt. It's also silly: there are thousands of lawsuits between governments and private businesses every year. Every single Fortune 500 is probably involved in a few dozens at any given time.

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by nl on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:55AM (#32560611)
Indeed, I think this is a even more accurate characterization of how government actually works.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by djbusby on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:57PM (#32559666)
Microsoft owns GitHUB and you're talking about GitLAB and those are different things.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by nimbius on Monday August 22, 2022 @10:04PM (#32559724)
correct indeed, my bad. I've been in gitlab all weekend
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by quantum_solanum on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:16AM (#32565262)
Gitlab has a number of government contracts including, for example, with the NSA.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by guipsp on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:28PM (#32558633)
Well, they expect OFAC-based legal action by the government, of course.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by altairprime on Monday August 22, 2022 @08:14PM (#32558991)
If he stands up and operates a for-profit instance of the service, then he will have committed the crime that led to the sanctions against the original operators of the service.

If he does not, then he is not a participating entity in the sanctioned service, and is unlikely to attract serious attention from the Justice Department.

It’s nice of the EFF to throw down a gauntlet about free speech, but I expect it will be ignored in favor of sanctioning others who operate cryptohash laundering services.

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by chrisco255 on Monday August 22, 2022 @10:29PM (#32559883)
I don't think there's any for-profit argument by the Treasury against Tornado Cash. But for what it's worth, the smart contract is still live on the Ethereum mainnet. Given that it is immutable, it is not possible to take it down. It's also trivial to fork and I imagine several forks already exist on mainnet and across various EVM forks by now.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by altairprime on Monday August 22, 2022 @11:44PM (#32560256)
Unprofitable money laundering operations collapse from the costs of meeting demand at scales large enough to offend the United States government, and so require no special prosecution or censure in order to fail. Cryptocoin laundering is highly desired by those that would launder currency, and so is not exempt from this outcome.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by chrisco255 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:00AM (#32560631)
Immutable smart contracts on blockchains are available to anyone with the few dollars worth of ether or other base chain currency necessary to execute the contract on-chain. They do not cost anything to operate after being deployed. In that sense, Tornado Cash is a protocol, that has more in common with HTTPS than with a business operation. Smart contracts can be thought of as software-defined protocols. Given that HTTPS and other forms of encryption are used on the regular, for both good and nefarious purposes, I see no reasonable argument against mixers. There has to be a path for on-chain privacy. It is a human right. It's also a U.S. constitutionally protected 4th amendment human right.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by altairprime on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:02AM (#32561405)
Whatever their benefits, mixers also enable and support the laundering of illegally-obtained currency and the circumvention of government sanctions. These points are both reasonable arguments against mixers. It remains to be seen whether society as a whole will accept your argument that mixers are an innate human right, protected under the constitution.

However, I observe with these sanctions that both the US judiciary and those of many others countries has decided cryptocoin laundering is not a protected human right, due to the balance of harm caused to societies outweighing the rights of the individual. It’s your right here in the US to declare that they’re wrong, but I do not see in your reply any new evidence or arguments presented that would change the course of the US government.

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by d4rti on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @03:46AM (#32561725)
I think David Gerard summarises nicely here [1]:

> If the ether is proceeds from a crime, then this is literally just money laundering.

> There’s also this weird delusion that if you put some dirty money in a box with clean money and shake it, then it all comes out as clean — and not that it all comes out as dirty.

> The bad takes were all variations of the fundamental fallacy of cryptocurrency: that you can code your way around the rules of society.

1: https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/2022/08/09/us-sanctions...

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by ohgodplsno on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:17AM (#32564470)
> There’s also this weird delusion that if you put some dirty money in a box with clean money and shake it, then it all comes out as clean — and not that it all comes out as dirty.

That's the exact take that brought to closure of tornado.cash. If you start with two distinct piles and at the end you only get one some-of-these-might-be-dirty pile, the solution to this is to destroy the mixer, not to sift through bank notes. The reason why we don't consider everything that has touched dirty money to be tainted is explicitly to protect people who may have been inadvertently brought into it.

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by ohgodplsno on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:01AM (#32564284)
Taking down a more public side to it (tornado.cash) has the effect of restraining the type of users that will now use it. Instead of privacy zealots (10%), money launderers (20%) and random users (70%) (numbers mostly pulled out of my ass for demonstration purposes), by making it only accessible to a much more select audience, you'll basically lose most of the random users. And believe me, if the US Treasury sanctioned it because 20% of the money going through was laundering (and the other 80% making it much harder to trace), when 66% of your traffic becomes money laundering, not only will they sanction harder, but they will also start going after actual people.

Touching the tornado cash contract is a poison pill right now.

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by chx on Monday August 22, 2022 @11:31PM (#32560193)
Potentially you are challenging one of the world's largest governments to find a way to stop it. I dunno what they can or what they will do but imagine this scenario: they sanction it in a way that you are guilty of money laundering if a copy is found on your computer -- now running the Ethereum mainnet or any fork that contains it is illegal in the United States. Do not think the DoJ won't. Refer https://xkcd.com/538/ or James Mickens' https://www.usenix.org/system/files/1401_08-12_mickens.pdf for some hilarious hard truth on what happens when cryptographic research meets a real world government agency. Also refer the old saying "never wake a sleeping lion".
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by chrisco255 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:27AM (#32560769)
> you are guilty of money laundering if a copy is found on your computer -- now running the Ethereum mainnet or any fork that contains it is illegal in the United States

This is well beyond the regulatory and legal powers of the U.S. Treasury and the DOJ. That is not the letter of the law with regards to money laundering, and the agency cannot invent new laws out of thin air. Nor can they blanket ban a technology or code just because they have to learn new stuff. Could Congress pass such a law? Sure, but even then, we'll go to the mats in the court and in state legislatures. Nevermind that criminalizing and demonizing a large portion of the population hurts your re-election chances.

Even torrenting, as egregious as the copyright abuse was in Pirate Bay's heyday, was never banned in such a way. Email scams from Nigeria never necessitated the shutdown of email. VPNs continue to operate.

Nevermind that similar cases with regards to cryptography have already gone to court, which ruled in favor of speech: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/04/remembering-case-estab...

The XKCD example is amusing, but fails even the most basic cross-examination. Surely officers with a court-issued warrant for probable cause of a crime should be able to inspect a person's home or things. Maybe they could find a private key written on a post-it note somewhere in the person's home. That's all fair and good, and no one is arguing against that. Clearly, it's not very scalable, nor should it be. We operate under the presumption of innocence in free societies.

We all have a problem with illegal, abusive, mass surveillance. It is a violation of human liberty and a disturbing trend that has to be pushed against to prevent a full-on dystopian, authoritarian hellscape where you don't even have paper cash as an outlet from the panopticon. To avoid that future outcome, to preserve the freedom of your children, you have to fight for privacy and transactional liberty. My ancestors were willing to bleed and die for liberty. Some of us still are, today. Never wake a sleeping lion, indeed.

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by __MatrixMan__ on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @01:17AM (#32560717)
I agree, but GitHub is going out of their way to censor this code, and developers in other countries are being arrested for writing it. Maybe a high profile case of "the code will remain available" will dissuade those who intend to follow suit.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by mmaunder on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:34PM (#32558696)
Green wouldn’t have standing for EFF to participate if USA goes after MS. So I’m curious what they’d go after Green for.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by mikeyouse on Monday August 22, 2022 @07:47PM (#32558789)
He's the maintainer on the repository - so presumably that.

(https://github.com/tornado-repositories)