News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by polynomial on Monday August 22, 2022 @08:52PM (#32559263)
Can you elaborate on this?
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by yarg on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:01PM (#32559313)
The First Amendment rights of corporations is at play here.

> The first may protect the right for Github to host the repo (though even that seems somewhat a stretch)

There's a rather murky limit on freedom of speech, I'm really not sure where it stands with regard to instructional content in general - however some such content has been constrained before; usually regarding weapons (or really any content that the government can argue is weapons related).

It's murky, and subject to government overreach.

> but it certainly doesn't grant or protect any right to publish on Github servers.

The first constrains the government, it in no way constrains private entities.

In fact (given the corporate personhood), to require that a private entity publish content from a third party would be compelled speech, and a breach of the entity's first amendment rights.

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by jayparth on Monday August 22, 2022 @10:22PM (#32559854)
What I took it as was “the first protects Green’s right to republish on GitHub [from government censorship].” Of course the first does not compel GitHub to allow him to do anything on their servers, but it does protect what both parties consented to do from government censorship.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by salawat on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:55AM (#32565805)
>I'm really not sure where it stands with regard to instructional content in general - however some such content has been constrained before; usually regarding weapons (or really any content that the government can argue is weapons related

Common misconception.

You can post the machinist drawings for any unclassified (or classified, if somehow you came across them without having signed any paperwork related to security clearances). That is protected by the Courts.

Where you get into hot water is ITAR and restricted exports where free speech runs into the whole national security/foreign affairs jurisdiction by the Feds. You cannot post the manual for an F-16 for instance, in such a way as it could be accessed by adversaries of the United States. Access to that type of information has to be gated behind some form of arcane onboarding process to ensure one is actually authorized to see it.

There was an attempt at gating 3d printed gun patterns I think, but all the courts would let through is that a manufacturer must ensure the recipient is a U.S. Citizen, so it switched from published on website, to shipped on CD iirc.

Haven't checked on recent developments.

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by retcore on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:28AM (#32560477)
> There's a rather murky limit on freedom of speech,

I don't believe it's murky at all, but defined deliberately in fuzzy terms in a number of important ways, one of which is the avoidance of precipitation of criminality. Criminality defined as that which is harmful to society. Although it may sound weak, compared to the presumed unfettered principles invoked above, should one or other of a separating couple used Tornado Cash to rinse common property funds, something that isn't drug dealing or terrorism anyhow, nevertheless it's laundering and using a device to commit a crime without which device that crime may not be possible. Federal proceedings against Tornado Cash have given the unlawful enterprise unprecedented profile and it follows that the motivation for anyone who strives for continuance of the same or similar, in light of the reasons for federal action, could be construed as being potential criminal too. Frankly I am stunned in the era that recognizes hate speech, that the automatic right to unfiltered and inconsequential freedom of speech is claimed so crudely, so reflexively and on such narrow and unexplained grounds..

Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by omniglottal on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @02:50PM (#32584022)
Potentially criminal acts are legal.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by dtgriscom on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:00PM (#32559309)
Github doesn't have to publish or host anything they don't want to, and they may decide not to for many reasons (business, appearances, phase of the moon, etc).
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by drak0n1c on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @12:17AM (#32560397)
Unless one of those reasons is persistent government requests/pressure on Microsoft/Github. Then it's a convenient way around first amendment protections.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by blitzar on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @04:51AM (#32562162)
Is a subpoena, in full compliance with the law, considered to be persistent government requests.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by encryptluks2 on Monday August 22, 2022 @11:09PM (#32560085)
I mean if they don't want to because of someone's race then that is against the law. Same with religion. So start a religion that incorporates these ideals.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by Dalewyn on Monday August 22, 2022 @11:59PM (#32560313)
IANAL, but I recall a religion needs to have existed before so-and-so date (I don't recall exactly) to qualify as a religious exception. Meaning your Swimming Lasagna Monster religion you created yesterday doesn't qualify.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by ipaddr on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @02:14AM (#32561033)
The scientology example tells us the opposite.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by yellow_lead on Monday August 22, 2022 @08:55PM (#32559283)
GitHub doesn't have to host anything it doesn't want, regardless of free speech
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by dekhn on Monday August 22, 2022 @08:57PM (#32559289)
he said it would be interesting if github chose to un-host it but then he'd just move it to a university server.
Re:Republishing a fork of the sanctioned Tornado Cash reposi... by nominusllc on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:15PM (#32559406)
If Github consents to storing it on those grounds, they have that right, in my unlicensed opinion.