> https://stsci-opo.org/STScI-01G7ETPF7DVBJAC42JR5N6EQRH.png
Is this for real?! It looks like it came right out of a Sci-Fi movie/book. Could anyone explain how much of this is post-editing magic?
Almost all the light in this image is way off the red end of the human visual spectrum, of course. The shortest wavelength filter is F090W which has a center wavelength of 902nm, about the same color as the light coming out of a TV remote infrared LED, which is barely visible in pure darkness.
This is what it looks like through a film SLR, without the detail enhancing filters: http://www.phys.ttu.edu/~ozprof/3372f.htm Here's a 20 minute exposure through a telescope: http://www.phys.ttu.edu/~ozprof/3372fk.jpg Maybe what you would see with your own eyes through binoculars at a dark site well away from city lights. A dim red smudge, hints of finer detail.
The redshift on the other JWST images is because most of them are of objects that are much, much, much farther away. Infrared telescopes are great for observing those, but that's not the only thing they're used for.
A good way to see this is comparing it to Hubble [1], a lot of the extra detail you see is thanks to IR letting you see the stars behind.
What I was asking is: Is the target's normally-visible light redshifted into the same bands that JWST is measuring, higher? or lower frequency?
That doesn't have anything to do with why JWST uses IR.
NGC3372 is a cloud of (relatively) hot gas and dust. It's emitting broad spectrum blackbody radiation: it's emitting on all wavelengths. You can look at the same cloud at different wavelengths and see different things, telling you what parts of the cloud are at what temperature, or relative chemical composition, or what parts are ionized: http://legacy.spitzer.caltech.edu/uploaded_files/graphics/fu... Nothing here is redshifted, Spitzer is just capturing different light entirely.
In the side by side of JWST and Hubble https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FXecm6vXwAMPhoc?format=jpg&name=... https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FXecnp2XkAE4Rs5?format=jpg&name=... you see broadly the same thing, but Hubble is almost all visible-light while JWST goes deeper into infrared and sees cloud structure that Hubble doesn't.
The NIRCAM instrument on JWST has a wavelength range of about 600 - 5000nm [1]. The human eye is sensitive to around 380nm - 700nm.
To shift blue light (380nm) down to the upper frequency range of NIRCAM (600nm) requires a redshift of:
z = Δλ / λ0 = 0.58
This is related to the velocity of the object by:
z = v / c
and the velocity is related to distance (approximately) by the Hubble constant (H0 ~ 71 km/s / Mpc):
d = v/ H0
So we can rearrange and solve for distance to get:
d = z c / H0 = 8 billion light years.
The southern ring nebula is more like 2000 light years from us, so not even vaguely far enough that NIRCAM would see "originally-visible" light. The deep field image might actually be far enough... the faintest galaxies there might be something like 12 billion light years away [2].
[1] https://www.stsci.edu/jwst/instrumentation [2] https://www.nasa.gov/content/discoveries-hubbles-deep-fields
What causes this "smoke"?
In smokey or smoggy air, the red light is also scattered.
The "smoke" in a nebula is mostly gas and dust. It's either left-over primordeal matter (hydrogen gas, some helium), or ejecta from novas and supernovas --- star-smoke if you will, though it's created by nuclear fusion rather than chemical combustion.
JWST's IR sensors can cut through that dust more readily than Hubble's optical-range sensors could, and pull out more detail on the dust to boot (based on my own viewing of comparative images).
I'm not sure if the dust is reflecting light or glowing from heat, though my hunch is it's mostly reflecting. Stellar gas that gets hot enough will also glow in infrared (or higher) wavelengths, and that might also be picked up by JWST. I suspect there will be targets demonstrating this in future.
Anyway, that looks like science fiction because science fiction borrowed that look from astronomy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nebula
how does the scale of color shifting relate to the red-shift present in deep-field subject?
Idly wondering: are the furtherest objects being captured, so red-shifted, that the translation for human viewing done in these images more or less balances that out, so what we see in the translated images for some thickness of distance-bubble, is what we would see from a much closer perspective with the naked eye, akin to "true color." (I.e. so close that the relative red-shift would be insignificant...)
What you'd want to see specifically are the emission spectra showing absorption lines for well-known spectral bands. This shows specifically how red-shifted the light is, and is how red-shift was initially detected.
I doubt that there's an intentional mapping of red-shifted appearance + spectral sensitivity to near-and-unadjusted appearance. Though that might be possible.
In practice, I suspect the bands JWST is receiving don't map well to the RGB sensitivity of the human eye, but insteat JWST's sensitivity is tuned to scientific interests and value.
The coloring is usually done to indicate different temperatures or wavelengths detected, so it can be a bit misleading.
https://images.app.goo.gl/9gqtdbcsBxY6RonY9 https://images.app.goo.gl/pG7sfjLGU9nqmAvH7 https://images.app.goo.gl/JGebDZ7V5EamKoY89
i.e. If we were moving at the same velocity of the Nebula looking with our own eyes.
i.e. What it would look like "in real life if I actually went there"
But that's with a telescope and long exposure & image stacking. But still in RGB as humans would see it.
I guess there would be a point that if you were not so far away, but still far enough away - it would light up the sky. This is emission nebula after all.
BUt if you were in it, it would be so diffuse that you wouldn't know it... perhaps a weird glow if you were near some of the forming stars.
Not much weirder than looking at an X-ray image.
The deep field image says it's about 2.4 arcmin across[1], Stephan's Quintet image is about 7.4 arcmin across[2], etc.
[1] https://webbtelescope.org/contents/media/images/2022/035/01G... [2] https://webbtelescope.org/contents/media/images/2022/034/01G...
[-----------] °
[--------] '
[----------------------] "
[----------------] ,,"
Super easy.
The moon is about half a degree or 30 arcminutes wide. This doesn't make sense but give it a try tonight if the moon is out.
FWIW many of the galaxies and nebula you see in astrophotography are actually bigger in the night sky than one might guess. Andromeda for example is about 6 times wider than the moon at ~3 degrees across - https://slate.com/technology/2014/01/moon-and-andromeda-rela...
The moon is between 29.4 and 33.5 arcminutes wide, depending on where it is in its orbit. So about a tenth of the width of the moon.
this is so much more digestible than "grain of sand at arm's length", and those two metrics dont feel at all equivalent -- the moon is not ten grains of sand at arm's length wide, right?
in either case, 1/10 the width of the moon is so much easier to comprehend. when is the last time anyone tried holding a grain of sand at arms length? what a weird comparison to make when everyone on earth already has a stable/familiar reference in the sky.
[1] https://astronomy.com/magazine/stephen-omeara/2010/01/stephe...
There are a few others to be found (I suspect image duration is much shorter than for the Deep Field).
Even as far-from-primary-interest-objects, amazing detail.
> Webb's First Deep Field (NIRCam Image)
Is this image distorted in any way at all? It feels like the galaxies are somehow oriented around a center spot. Not all of them, but enough to give the image a distorted feeling. Probably it's just my mind pattern matching against something that doesn't really exist.
This image shows profound "gravitational lensing", which you know. But what you might not know is that is precisely _why_ they chose to photograph it.
This galaxy cluster (SMACS 0723) may be the most well known and powerful gravitational lens we have observed. The galaxies shown distorted around the edges are actually behind the lens, but are magnified by it. This means we can see even farther in this region of space than normal, because we compound the power of the JWST with the power of this natural lens.
It all adds up to providing the "deepest" view of the universe yet, allowing us to see galaxies at a distance of more than 13.2B lightyears. This lets us see structures formed in the infancy of the universe, that wouldn't be possible looking at most other points in the sky, or even anywhere else in this deep field besides the perimeter of the lens in the middle.
Other features include the prominent arcs in this field. The powerful gravitational field of a galaxy cluster can bend the light rays from more distant galaxies behind it, just as a magnifying glass bends and warps images. Stars are also captured with prominent diffraction spikes, as they appear brighter at shorter wavelengths.
[0] https://webbtelescope.org/contents/news-releases/2022/news-2...
Can this be adjusted for?
Wouldnt the pico-arc of the overall array affect the image output due to the distances involved such that we receive "false gravitational lensing, simply based on distance from the sensor"
?
I wonder if a more precise version(s) of the hex lenses could be made such that they can 'normal-ize' on a much more refined basis.
I know that each JWT is already capable of mico-flexes to each cell... but if we can develope an even further refinement (Moores law on the JWTs hex lenses resolution) we will be able to make thousands of images with varying the the normalization to each receiving area and comparing image quality.
Also, I am sure there are folks who know the reflective characteristics of photons from each wavelength that would allow for orientations for each wavelength.
--
Do ALL 'light' wavelengths, particles bounce off the reflector materials in the same way? - meaning do infra waves/photons bounce in the exact same way as some other wavelength with the exact same orientation of the sensor?
---
Do they do any 'anti-gravitational-lensing' correction calcs to 'anti-bend' a photons path to us to 're-normalize' the path that we should have seen?
Whats the current science behind such?
I worded that poorly ;
Wouldn't one be able to adjust the perceived path of the photon after time, to adjust for re-normalizing the path of the photon based on the understanding of the gravitational arc imposed on such -- meaning the astro equivalent of "ZOOM. ENHANCE!" :-)
Eg, you'd normally see the side view of an object, but the lensing gets you the top and bottom views
Lets assume you have a 'straight' vector of line of sight pointing your Earthly-Bound-Lens [hubble/jswt/whatever] at the object of interest.
you also have an idea through previous observations of gallaxies on the line of sight, which will have gravitational impact on the trajectory of the photons of interest...
the arrival photon's wiggle represents a wobble in time to get to earth. Meaning it changed phase multiple times between our sensor receiving it, and its origin.
If one could look at the path and the grav-lenses it went through, one may be able to extrapolate a more clear picture at various distances(times)....??? /r/NoStupidQuestions
( I am picturing a straight shot - but the photon traveled between many other celstials - and those
Meaning that no matter waht, when we speak of gravitational lenses, we could, usting JWST account for the "wobble" of a photon, nased on the accurate knowledge of where a body was, via measuring through multiples of JSWT observations... (ideally through actually multiple JWSTs, in differnt locations)
The idea being that if we can triangulate a more precice location between earth [A] and galaxy [N] - set of all galaxies/bodies/whatever,
We may be able to calculate the influence of gravity lens upon phont differentials based on when they came from and how far...
Ultimately making adjustments to the output of an image \based on super deep-field focus which is effectively selecting to the phtons of interest... and we can basically "carbon date" the accuracy of an image with a higher resolution?
What i think is pretty cool is that the gravity lens actually allowed hubble to see galaxies it may have not ever seen had there not been a gravity lens and now that we have JWST we see many more distant galaxies (and more of the same galaxy reflected in more positions)
What does jupiter, PLUTO look like from these lenses???
THE FUCKING MOON
WE SPENT *BILLIONS* -- Why dont we have live streams?
GO FUCK YOUR NSA
--
WHO PAID FOR IT.
The data should be global. define a SINGLE national defense trope. and back it up.
The EHT images are created using synthetic aperture techniques to create an effective aperture with a diameter of earth's orbit around the sun. But this is only currently possible at radio frequencies due to our ability to capture, store, and coherently combine the phase information. It's essentially SDR beam forming across space and time.
We can also study black holes though visible and IR observations through their effects of the things around them-- lensing from their mass, matter heated up by falling in. Here is an image I took of the relativistic speed matter jet believed to originate from black hole in M87: https://nt4tn.net/astro/#M87jet ... and Webb can do a lot better than I can with a camera lens in my back yard. :)
Aside, there is some controversy about the EHT black hole images. A recent paper claims to be able to reproduce the ring like images using the EHT's imaging process and a simulated point source-- raising the question of the entire image just being a processing artifact. https://telescoper.wordpress.com/2022/05/13/m87-ring-or-arte... Though it's not surprising to see concerns raised around cutting edge signal processing-- LIGO suffered from a bit of that, for example, but confidence there has been improved by a significant number of confirming observations (including optical confirmations of ligo events).
Small correction: The EHT is a synthetic aperture telescope the size of the Earth, not the size of the Earth’s orbit around the Sun.
Synthetic aperture telescopes need both amplitude & phase information from each observing station & have to combine the phase of simultaneous observations in order to create the final image. We can’t do this on the scale of the earth’s orbit, because we don’t have a radio telescope on the far side of the sun!
Maybe one day ...
You, sir, have just contributed a prime example of HN comments at their best. Your astrophotography is outstanding. Thank you for sharing! :)
Another question: are they already planning a successor to JWST? Is something better even possible? If it took more than 30 years, we should start sooner than later :)
https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2021/10/28/starship-is-st... is correct. No NASA planning, including for space telescopes, shows any understanding of how much Starship changes the game. Instead of one, we can put up a network of telescopes. And try out crazy ideas.
Here is a concrete example. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/231032662_A_Cryogen... lays out how a 100 meter telescope could be erected on the Moon to study the early universe with several orders of magnitude better resolution than the JWST. The total weight of their design is around 8 tons. With traditional NASA technologies, transport of the material alone is over $30 billion and it had better work. With Starship, transportation is in the neighborhood of $10 million. Suppose that precision equipment added $40 million to the cost. Using Starship, for the cost of the JWST, we can put 200 missions of this complexity in space. Using a variety of different experimental ideas. And if only half of them worked, we'd still be 99 telescopes ahead of the JWST.
So where is Starship? It is on the pad, undergoing testing. They have a list of 75 environmental things to take care of before launch. Which means that they likely launch this month or next. At the planned construction cadence, even if the first 3 blow up, by Christmas it should be a proven technology.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SAFIR is the closest to a proposed JWST successor; the others largely serve different purposes.
I just wish NASA had provided a link at the bottom of their low-res image pages to intermediate sized images (~4k) for desktop viewing.
However, after spending 10 minutes on mobile this morning, I was unable to find any high resolution images, and many images had that anti-pattern of a BS HTML gallery that severely restricts interacting with the image.
More here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absorption_spectroscopy
Much more about this particular graph here: https://www.nasa.gov/image-feature/goddard/2022/nasa-s-webb-...
Stephan's Quintet (NIRCam and MIRI Composite Image):
https://stsci-opo.org/STScI-01G7DB1FHPMJCCY59CQGZC1YJQ.png
Southern Ring Nebula (NIRCam and MIRI Images Side by Side):
https://stsci-opo.org/STScI-01G79R28V7S4AXDN8NG5QCPGE3.png
“Cosmic Cliffs” in the Carina Nebula (NIRCam Image):
https://stsci-opo.org/STScI-01G7ETPF7DVBJAC42JR5N6EQRH.png
Webb's First Deep Field (NIRCam Image):
https://stsci-opo.org/STScI-01G7DDBW5NNXTJV8PGHB0465QP.png
Exoplanet WASP-96 b (NIRISS Transmission Spectrum):
https://stsci-opo.org/STScI-01G7NBXDHYYSVBP2M476PRGG3A.png