Are there very smart people at Harvard, and other prestigious liberal arts universities? Absolutely. But there are lots of people who are merely above average and lucky, by dint of birth or chance, and some people who aren't even above average. (FWIW MIT and Caltech have much better claims to being filled with the smartest people in the world -- rigorous standards of admission, no legacies, NCAA Div3 athletics, etc.)
I did get to take a Unix Security Holes course with DJB. That was the first semester I was there, and that was kind of another mistake. When you're doing 400 level classes your first semester, it sucks when you have to go back to the basic 100 level classes to complete an arbitrary requirement for your degree. (Had to take "Intro to Java" taught by a chemistry professor. He did not know how to program. Huge waste of time and the state's money.) I have avoided a number of security pitfalls in my own work because of what I learned in that class, though, so it was definitely worth taking. Set me up for a career of accurate and bug-free code ;)
(Incidentally, what precipitated me dropping out was the Unix Security Holes course. The homework for the class was to find 10 security flaws in existing software. This was quite the easy task back in 2004. I found a bug in the course registration system. The vendor that made it was infinitely appreciative, patched it instantly, and sent me an iPod as a thank you. The school was very mad at me and tried to have me expelled for violating their computer use policy ("hacking"). It was a client-side XSRF issue though, so technically their computers weren't used, and I obviously investigated the flaw responsibly; the system wasn't destabilized, no production data was changed, etc. DJB fought hard for me and I didn't get expelled. Also got one of the highest grades in that class! The school did silently block me from using computers in computer labs and using the course registration system, though, after DJB's rage had blown over. I didn't have the will to fight it, so I just left.)
TL;DR: go to the best school you can get into and afford. You won't regret it.
A sad (albeit true) reality of democratised education adjusted for profit.
DJB = Daniel J. Bernstein [1]
UIC = University of Illinois at Chicago
You might be conflating class signaling with intelligence. I've dealt with plenty of people from Harvard that did not impress in the slightest, but oh boy were they good at getting their suits tailored.
One snobby rule there that some kids had was to always pretend like you know more than you do, and never show weakness. So you have to say "Whaaaat? You've never heard of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle?" -- even though you only learned about it last week. You psych out the competition so that you don't have to compete on a level playing field.
Yeah, probably says I know something about normal distributions work.
He's essentially saying at a societal level/personal income level - a STEM degree from a mid tier school > generic liberal arts degree from a top tier school. Particularly if the recipient is not truly passionate about the liberal arts degree and is using it as a backup plan.
I think what you are experiencing is a bit related to survivorship bias. You are being exposed to the people who passed the gauntlet of getting into the top-tier school and graduating in presumably STEM. Of course those folks are smart and there are reasons you'd be blown away by them.
It may be a smart choice, but not all smart people who try to make that choice get in.
> The first time I was exposed to people from top-tier universities is when I entered the industry. I was absolutely blown away by the quality difference.
I’ve worked in software engineering with Harvard, Stanford, and MIT students. The only difference I saw was during their first couple of years out of undergrad where the people who went to prestigious schools had more confidence to jump in and solve problems. After those first two-ish years, people’s abilities correlated more with who they were and not where they went to school.
But not all top students in mid-tier attempted to go to Harvard. So if you were basing the "smartness" of these two populations based on this single decision alone, then the low-tier students at Harvard would be smarter because 100% of them attempted to go to Harvard, which was a smarter choice than the choice made by some of the students at mid-tier universities who chose not to apply to Harvard.
> After those first two-ish years, people’s abilities correlated more with who they were and not where they went to school.
In my experience, peoples' first few years out of college has a huge effect on their career trajectories. People I know who had high salaries out of school continue to have high salaries. People who didn't get good entry-level jobs continue to struggle (relative to the rest of the pack, they're not starving).
Have you considered that the students whom you are working with were among the bottom quartile at their alma mater? The very best tend to take unique paths.
In general the phds I've worked with were tbh below the average- they always seemed to be big on ideas but less so on actually implementing them and following through.
This was from my days in the finance industry, working in algo trading/hft, but I will admit I was definitely in a tier below the groups that were absolutely minting money, but these were coveted jobs.
Regarding phds, I totally agree that they are not effective workers usually. The desire to get a phd is almost like a mild form of ocd where people get obsessed with one particular problem and are willing to dedicate ungodly amounts of time to the topic. This is usually the opposite of what you want when trying to deliver something in the commercial sphere.
If they had had an "intro for beginners" and "accelerated intro", I would have probably stayed in the program. Also if their upper-level courses weren't like 60 hours of homework per week for one class. At a certain point I realized I just simply didn't have the stamina to do 60 hours for one class and all my other classes. So it was sort of like applying to be a doctor -- you know one of the prereqs is rotations where you don't sleep for 2 days straight, and if you can't do that, then for some reason, you can't be a doctor.
That other time, genius recreates the entire playing field and good habits are left sitting around staring at each other trying to figure out what the hell just happened.
In every successful startup I worked at (3 of 20ish), I observed the opposite.
Curious on your perspective why professionalism and good work habits beat "genius" at startups.
I would have assumed the opposite. My view of startup life was that it's about managing your money, your hiring/firing, your sales, and what you focus on.
That's about good prioritization and productivity per minute.
(a) is more probable. Sustainable business start-up success of the non-banal order requires high general intelligence. It does exist. But 9 times out of 10 hard work and people skills will win.
Perceived genius (or more appropriately, assumed genius) would be more accurate. The people who are the least scrupulous, most creative, and technically competent are very successful. Startups aren't usually successful because of sweat hard work, but realizing a combination of opportunity and reach, rather than contracting as much software development labor as possible.
You can’t tell from a high school transcript whether someone got an A because they’re brilliant and didn’t have to study at all, or whether they got an A because they studied hard.
Most of my friends who went into ivy leagues were outgoing and did tons of extracurriculars and studied hard. My friends who were naturally brilliant either stuck to the subjects they liked, and ended up getting their doctorate at a state school, or they had had their success derailed for some other reason.
When you know you are smart there is no reason to prove it to yourself by going to a fancy school.
Unfortunately you need to prove it to other people later, and going to the fancy school is a very simple signal.
I honestly think IQ scores primarily measure how much you want to score well on an IQ test. You can improve your scores by 10 points according to scientific papers just by being more motivated and not quitting, not being distracted and so on.
Real (ie. official medical) IQ scores seem to be heavily skewed around age and speed. So the same performance would get you a super high score in a 5-year-old and a mediocre score in a 10-year-old, which is weird because the questions are explicitly trying not to test language/knowledge type stuff that would change a lot between those ages. And the same answers would get a far higher score if you bashed them out in 15 minutes than if you took 2 hours on them. I haven't gone back to re-examine it but I remember thinking that you were way better off smashing through the questions as fast as possible and getting a few right than carefully considering the questions... which is an odd way to define intelligence.
I never thought of my disillusionment with engineering in the context of other students, but rather just as an absolute: "Engineering is too hard for me." Taking Calculus at not-Stanford may have led to a very different result.
And perhaps not all have the mental fortitude to stick with it in the background like you did - which is a net loss for society.
Two years later, I re-took the class to improve my grade. Ended up with a B - and the class average was round B at that time, with only around 15% of class failing the final exam.
(I suspect we met, at least briefly, somewhere along the way. Hi!)
I hope your visit was fun :). Your Antarctica beard on your website threw me for a loop.
Thomas Sowell, in Inside American Education, argues that promoting students to more difficult colleges while ignoring SATs is not doing those students any favor. A firehose-pedagogy accepted by those with SAT scores 200-300 points higher can completely demoralize someone who could have done perfectly well at a moderately-paced school. However, the competition to practice AA leads, he argues, those more advanced schools to ignore SAT scores in admission for the schools' benefits, but not the benefit of the students so admitted.
I doubt it. As my professor used to say, math is math. Plus, intro-level undergrad math courses are pretty standardized across the US. Similar textbooks, similar problem sets, and similar past exams.
There's nothing wrong to feel calculus is hard even if you're the top of your high school class. Most people hit a wall at certain abstraction level. Malcolm wrote in his book about smart people simply not being able to grok organic chemistry. Some of my smart classmates could not really understand the concept of limit intuitively. Some of them dropped out of abstract algebra course. I myself dropped out of model theory as I couldn't get why I should even bother with the course. None of these failures prevent people from finding success in other areas.
Stanford's introductory CS sequence has a good reputation however. Consider this course (for example) which teaches students bare-metal programming (and real-world interfacing) on a raspberry pi: https://cs107e.github.io/schedule/
Sadly the universities with courses like this seem to me mediocre at advertising that, no, if you are not specifically very very good at math (and very very good at following a very fast paced course and you don’t have a strong background), then that’s not the class for you and you should be in the other honors math class.
As an example, we had to prove all continuous functions on a closed interval are monotonically continuous on that interval, in Calculus I. Which we had in our first semester with no choice. I doubt this level of rigor is at all common.
that's because the way it's presented is silly. limits aren't the key idea, the continuity of the reals is.
I don’t think it’s about how professors teach, but about that people simply can’t get some abstractions. Have you seen kids in high school who can’t do algebra even if you find the best teachers for them?
1. How do you even express the idea of continuity if not through limits? (Sure, there's the topological definition and the epsilon-delta criterion but those are merely an abstraction or a different way of phrasing the same idea.)
2. The key difference between the rationals and the reals is that the latter are Cauchy-complete. How do you even define (in an intuitive way) what that means without referring to limits?
3. The reals are typically constructed as (equivalence classes of) Cauchy sequences, i.e. by their very definition they are the limits of their Cauchy sequences.
instead go directly from integers to reals by introducing countable vs. uncountable infinities.
in most calculus teaching, continuity is quickly stated and then there's a bunch of rules and these seemingly contradictory discussions involving delta and epsilon. they're not contradictory if continuity is understood and internalized.
I adjusted majors in no small part because of intro organic chemistry. Just didn't connect.
I don't know. Calculus (and a lot of CS nowadays) is pretty standardized across schools. Same textbooks, similar problem sets and curricula.
People dropping out of engineering isn't anything new [0].
What is new is: students were told all their life that “they’ll make it” in life.
Spoiler alert: not everyone does. Most will never make 7 figure compensation as a SWE, for example.
The source of my anecdote are the discussions I've had with the the recruiters at my company. They've also told me that Harvard/Yale graduates are way more likely to be prima donnas and leave the company after a short time in order to advance somewhere else.
Schools like CMU, Berkeley, UIUC, etc. have different overlaps.
edit: This is just cold, hard data. Undergrads do not choose CMU/Berkeley/UIUC and whatnot over Harvard, Yale, or Princeton. Despite higher grad school rankings.
I'd love to see your data about whether students choose ivy vs. top state. I wasn't aware that existed so was just speaking from my experience knowing > 10 people choose U of I over ivys, including harvard.
I got a full ride to both Princeton and CMU for CS, and chose Princeton because I preferred their program. I was not the only one to do so.
Blanket statements are dumb ... typically :).
Brown and Dartmouth and Cornell are Ivy League and few would choose any of them over MIT or Stanford. Ivy League and top are not the same.
Are students at top tier schools like that smarter than the average bear? Sure. Geniuses? I guess a few are, but most of them are just pretty smart + hard working + reasonably disciplined. Which is a pretty good combination that will help most people in their life.
Sometimes I get the feeling that some people expect that if they meet someone who went to an ivy/stanford/mit/chicago and that someone doesn't blow them away with their uber-genius greatness, that those schools' reputations must be total BS. IMO, that's unreasonable.
The smartest undergrads in the county are still at your HYPSM universities.
However, the median intelligence at these schools has definitely dropped drastically as these schools are putting less of an emphasis on SAT scores and the like.
Of Buchanan and the nine justices involved in Dred Scott, only one was a New Englander and he was one of the two dissenters. Both dissenters were educated in New England but only one from the majority. On the other hand, the list includes five Southerners, two Pennsylvanians and three from Dickinson College.
* James Buchanan - Pennsylvania, educated at Dickinson College in Pennsylvania
Majority from Dred Scott:
* Roger B. Taney - Maryland, Dickinson
* James Moore Wayne - Georgia, educated at what later became Princeton in New Jersey
* John Catron - Tennessee, self-educated
* Peter V. Daniel - Virginia, one year at Princeton, then self-educated
* Samuel Nelson - New York, Middlebury College in Vermont
* Robert Cooper Grier - Pennsylvania, Dickinson
* John Archibald Campbell - Georgia/Alabama, University of Georgia
Dissenters in Dred Scott:
* John McLean - Ohio, Harvard
* Benjamin Robbins Curtis - Massachusetts, Harvard
Please don't create accounts to do that with.
As for the general grade inflation problem: It is confusing that Harvard's grade distribution is so different than schools with similarly strong student bodies like Princeton, Columbia, UChicago, Berkeley, etc. Especially very, very large portion of students are legacy / recruited athletes / very wealthy donor parents. According to the affirmative action lawsuit, over 10% of the student body alone was on the "Dean's interest list," a very elite group of autoadmits, for example.
McNamara (Vietnam), Kissinger (illegal bombing of Laos), Clinton (impeached), Bush (WMD lies), Ted Cruz and other senators who literally can't pass 7th grade science. I can continue for an hour.
I went to Iowa State for undergrad and then did a masters at Princeton immediately afterwards. I greatly appreciate both schools.
At Iowa State, most of my classes were easy. But I pushed myself with the sheer quantity of classes I took. I was super involved in extracurriculars and still went out multiple nights per week. I was one class short of a double major and I spent a semester abroad. My only regret is not spending 2 semesters abroad. It was an incredible time.
Princeton also did not disappoint. The Graduate School is for sure the most intellectually rich environment I've ever been in. Academically, it was far more demanding, and pushed me to a much deeper level of engagement with my studies. I also know that Princeton would have been a way too intense environment for me at 18. At 22, it was what I was looking for.
I also went to NYU for another masters program, which was in many ways even more different from the first two universities. Some people just go there to be at university in NYC, but it's a sprawling school with tons to offer and feels physically and socially much more integrated with the real world than campus-centric universities.
I don't think there's a one size fits all answer for whether to go to Harvard or any other school.
But yes, from a credential standpoint, a masters program can upgrade your prestige, for sure. Although it would be important to note that there are social aspects of the Ivy League in undergrad experience that aren't the same in grad school (and vice versa), if that's what someone is looking for.
In the context of grade inflation, this sounds like Harvard is actually one of the better choices and that grade inflation is a desirable property of an elite university
With a grade curve that high, a B usually means one of the following:
1. Tough weeder course.
2. The person does not really understand the material, especially for upper division courses.
3. Something personal (illness, family issues, personal issues, etc.).
For folks who care about grades, like hiring officials or graduate admissions folks, they typically know about the grade inflation.
It might be a benefit in law school admissions that mostly use a strict formula with gpa as part of that formula.
Anyway, if someone is choosing Harvard over another school due to GPA inflation, then I have a feeling that they won’t gain that much at Harvard or the other school(s) that admitted them. That seems to be optimizing for something fairly minor in the scheme of things.
It’s the median that’s interesting. My undergrad median was deeply disappointing. Couldn’t write a simple paper. Literally did not understand how to construct an argument.
Grad school median was solid and impressive e
In my experience it was highly correlated with work ethic, many top tier graduates would come in with a push to work exceptionally hard. Sometimes they’d come in with an attititude that they’d “made it” and not work hard enough.
I still work in SWE, and began doing it in HS when I was 17.
Partner and I discuss frequently that I would have been better off somewhere else.
The only thing I've found that they do regret is spending the tuition money and walking away without a degree.
This is one theory as to why HBCU's do such a better job at preparing the next generation of black scientists, engineers, doctors, and lawyers then other comparable schools.
I do think society in general and finance/medicine/law (which are harder to analyze based on test scores/leetcode and have more fuzzy needs for network effects) still uses legacy measurement techniques for "worthiness".
The top US 10 universities producing tech staff: https://www.techrepublic.com/article/top-10-universities-tha...
The report identified the following universities as having the most graduates become employees at major tech companies, along with the number of employees.
University of Washington (16,786 employees)
University of California–Berkeley (13,260 employees)
Stanford University (12,973 employees)
University of Texas–Austin (11,049 employees)
University of Southern California (9,071 employees)
Arizona State University–Tempe (8,320 employees)
Carnegie Mellon University (8,274 employees)
Georgia Institute of Technology (7,961 employees)
University of California–Los Angeles (7,829 employees)
University of Illinois–Urbana-Champaign (7,671 employees)
Employers may be interested in your schooling if you're fresh out of school, but after that, they're much more interested in your work experience.
I went to community college and then transferred to an fairly inexpensive 4-year college. In my first job I got a huge amount of work experience and leveled-up to the senior software developer title.
Maybe an employer after that first job would look at me suspiciously for my choice of schools, but they really shouldn't.
I've heard there are employers that have an irrational attachment to certain prestigious institutions.
Also if you've always been the smartest at your school you might not realize you won't be the smartest at Harvard until you get there.
[1] Not literally THE highest ranked. There’s reasons to go to UPenn instead of Harvard, but if you get into Harvard and go to a state school instead, you might be screwing up.
In my IT batch, even when I didn't study a lot, there were semesters where I got academic awards. And with my remaining free time, I was able to focus on things I was interested in. No stress. I don't have any regrets, but I just wonder how my life would have turned out had I taken CSE. I would have most definitely landed somewhere else, doing something else in life. Better or worse, I don't know.
Do good employers recruit from Maryland? Will you find FAANG and all the investment banks there? How tight is the Maryland alumni network?
I didn't go to a school anywhere near as prestigious as Harvard, but I did go to one with a strong reputation and it means that there is a strong community and good employers recruit from there.
The degree is a small part of university.
If he decides to go to grad school, he'll be screwed even though he's been on the plus side of the curve in all of his classes so far.
Full disclosure: I went to the top-rated college I got into, and purposely chose not to go to the top-ranked law school that I got into. The difference wasn't huge (UCLA vs Michigan), but it did mean I wasn't in the top-10. But I saved a bunch in tuition, and that allowed me to have the flexibility to leave the law several years later and bootstrap a startup. OTOH, maybe I would have had an amazing legal career had I gone to Michigan!
Something like 99% of Harvard end up graduating, so simply having a Harvard degree doesn't tell me much more about you than simply having an admission letter. If you were admitted, then it's almost certain that you'll get a degree.
So, if instead you hold onto your admission letter, as proof of ability, and then go to a lower tier school where you can be more certain to be one of the biggest fish in the pond, you get the best of both worlds. Hell, even include a list of "universities admitted to" on you resume to signal the brand name to employers that aren't smart enough to realize the brand doesn't matter much anymore.
Then again, why would you want to work for an employer that still puts stock in college brand names over individual ability?
This could have made sense before Harvard's financial aid became so generous, but now they give loads of aid to middle- and low-income students.
It would sound a bit weird to keep saying "I got into Harvard...", likely for the same reason you mention at the end. Who wants to be an eliteness snob? Unfortunately there are many such people in the world, which is part of the reason their cachet persists.
I've taken to laughing when someone proudly states that they went to a brand name school.
Meticulous? Sure. Does she present herself as if she's a Harvard grad with the economic status that usually entails? Absolutely. But I know several people who graduated from a small directional university who are absolutely smarter than she is. Same with grads I know from Cornell, Penn, and Yale. Maybe the mystical "school where everyone is actually super-intelligent" exists somewhere, but if so, I don't know the name of it.
Unless your professors are so lazy that they're grading on a bell curve, there's no need to be afraid of any class. Test scores and project grades are based on rote knowledge and level of effort, not innate talent... and Harvard educators are usually vastly superior to those of "lesser" schools.
Disclaimer: I don’t necessarily agree with these views, just summarising what I’ve seen.
I mean Balmer and Allen met gates at Harvard...
Its not the only thing, I suspect it not nothing.
- a better CV - a better network
Anyone who takes this advice is indeed self selecting and I suppose that's good, because anyone who can't see that obviously shouldn't go to harvard in the first place!
There are maybe five U.S. senators with Harvard degrees who can't pass a 7th grade climate science unit.
You don't see this from MIT, Chicago, Berkeley, Northwestern.
I can't really imagine a worse school. Except Yale.
EDIT: Not coincidentally, it was an admin brought in from Yale who got this ball rolling.
On the other hand, not passing it lets them keep their job.
This seems like an easy decision, especially for someone smart enough to finish a degree at Harvard. /S
Why You Shouldn't Go to Harvard
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7J-wCHDJYmo&t=12s
Acclaimed author Malcolm Gladwell has some advice for teenagers looking into college.
"If you want to get a science and math degree, don't go to Harvard," he says. Harvard is filled with the smartest people in the world, and perversely that makes it a dispiriting place to go to school.
At Harvard, the lower tier students are as smart as the top tier students at an average school. However, the lower tier students get just as discouraged at Harvard as the lower tier students at an average school. The result: They don't get their degrees in math or science. The problem is that even a smart kid struggles to keep up when competing with the uber smart. As a result, the kid feels inadequate and drops the degree.
This is crazy, because as Gladwell points out, a science and math degree is the "most valuable commodity any graduate can have in today's economy." He says that "as as a rule of thumb, your odds of successfully getting a math degree fall by two percentage points for every ten point increase in the average SAT score of your peers."
So, if you're a kid and you have a choice between, Harvard and the University of Maryland, go with Maryland because its SAT scores are 150 points lower on average. That means you have a 30% better chance at getting your degree. However, most people will still choose Harvard, even knowing this, says Gladwell. Why? Because we have an irrational attachment to certain prestigious institutions.