1) there is a constant amount of overhead that is always needed regardless of how long you work for in a week. Meetings and collaboration to figure out what to build, discuss issues etc. if these take up 10 hours a week a full time dev has 30 hours to do other things where as a half time dev only has 10 hours. So 2 half time dev just doesn’t get as much done as 1 full time. I guess this is also why 2 engineers don’t get twice as much done as 1, all things being equal.
2) Most part time dev candidates I’ve seen aren’t doing just a single part time job, they are doing either multiple part time jobs or a full time job + part time job. Either way the mental energy is already gone.
Maybe there is a way to make part time work, I just haven’t figured it out yet.
In other professions where the shared state isn't as big, such as medicine or therapy, you see way more part time style work happen actively in the industry. Be it working for 2-4 clinics part time or just doing half hours so they can focus more on other things in their lives.
Another kind of role that I think works well part time is an advisor / consultant expert role where your hired to verify things are being done correctly in your sub field and are used to train others design wise as a 3rd party. Which is another sr / experienced type of role.
Another type of part time that might work is working on your own project as a solo dev in maintenance mode once your established. But also only lasts so long as competitors get ahead of you.
Part time not working well is something inherent to the job itself unfortunately.
This sentiment is what GP points out is cultural, not practical or factual. If you compensate them well for the hours they work, many part time devs will have superior per-hour output to FTEs and also be grateful for the added flexibility you afford them.
We hired a stellar part time dev recently (contract hire to start, we just increased his rate and verbally stated we are interested in continuing the relationship long-term if he is, and offered written agreement if he is interested), and he has been working out great. The option is open to him to work full-time whenever if/when he wants by planning it ahead of time with us, but our default expectation will remain being part-time so he can pursue his game development on the side.
Finding a great part-time team member is no different than a great FTE, once you and the employee are both free of the cultural negative baggage associated wtih part-timing.
There's your problem.
It sounds like you just amortize the "meetings" differently. Having to answer lots of async emails / slacks can waste just as much time as scheduled meetings.
Sounds like you work at startup rather than corporate. My current job is basically building on something somebody else has already prototyped. I hate it, it makes my days dull. But then one day I realized, that if I could do it as a part time job then I'd have no qualms of not wasting my mental energy, I'd gladly do what is required, clock out and spend my creative energy outside of work or with other part time gigs.
That don’t need to spend lots of
time getting context. They can figure
out how to solve problems matching
your team’s coding style without
extra meetings.
I've worked a variety of enterprise-y developer jobs, and I don't find that to be the case at all. I mean, that context is the job.Coding bits of functionality for an existing business is not a matter of "matching the team's coding style."
Heck, there are often not even engineering "problems" to "solve." It's a matter of figuring out integration with existing systems and processes, understanding the business itself, etc. That's why part-timers don't make sense. They can't just walk in, sit down, and code.
And if you could tee things up for them, to the point where they could just sit down and code, then 90% of the work is already done. And your part-time coder will take longer to deliver... why would management want to wait 2 weeks for a part time person to complete 40 hours of pure coding work, versus 1 week for a fulltimer?
Yeah, I think you could step back from that at some point and be a heck of a part-time asset.
1. Your knowledge of the app and organization would likely decay over time.
2. I'm not sure the the organization would love this move. It would be better than losing you entirely, but probably not as valuable as having you fulltime. From your perspective, 50% of your time is better than 100% of nothing. From their perspective, they're probably going to take the "glass half empty" view.
It might be more work to develop a specification that requires no context to complete than to do it myself.
I too would crave a part time programming job, mind you, but I think that only works on a team that is completely part time.
If my experience is anything to go by, this sort of self-directed collaboration—think "design discussions" rather than "meetings" or "ceremonies"—will end up far more productive for everyone involved.
Doing it in a meeting where everyone has different questions, tangents and other cruft that you have to sit through is extremely inefficient.
Additionally, everyone can focus on producing and consuming information in the downtime between focus-work sessions, without interrupting flow at someone else's convenience.
In all cases, quality documentation is more likely to produce accurate information transfer with less time wasted by everyone involved.
Fix your management and you'll be able to hire part time easily.
It depends more on the personalities, values and organization of the workplace and the team — for any size, if more than 20% of people involved need to spend more than 2 hrs/week in meetings — it is an organizational/ops issue, not an inherent feature of the work.
> more foreign the domain the more time is needed to coordinate work
More foreign to who? If it is foreign to individual team members, then it is a problem of insufficient onboarding/training material and process, poor documentation, or under-qualified hire.
The only way I see real value is if you’re the sold dev/architect or if you can come in and confidently pick up tickets and they’re properly scoped and documented.
If you need developers to spend so much time ideating and figuring out how and what to build, you’re mismanaging those developers imo.
I have successfully gotten 80% four-day-week at a string of engagements... but I work in the non-profit academic sector, and get paid quite a bit less than that $200K+ salary.
I think a four-day-week, or even a three-day-week, makes a lot more sense than tha 4-hours-a-day 5-day-week the OP was suggesting.
Because, yeah, one (or certainly two) meetings could pretty much blow a 4-hour-day. But at the 4-eight-hour-day schedule I've been doing, I feel like there is still plenty of time for meetings and overhead, and I am pretty confident I end up 95% as productive working a four-day 32 hours as I would be working 40 hours. I feel like it would still work pretty well at 3-eight-hour-days too.
Below that -- or trying to work four-hour days instead of fewer eight-hour days, I could definitely see problems with "overhead" or lack of commitment.
I can only speak from my experience working 80% time in several different jobs, in nonprofit/academic environments. As above.
(I enjoy writing code, if writing code was "barely" part of the work I wouldn't still be here. It seems like it would be impossible to get anyone who was good at writing code in a development/engineering job where coding was barely part of the work! But I'm not sure what this has to do with the feasibility of less than full time work as an engineer/developer).
Remote-first, multi-time-zone companies simply don't do meetings. All communication is async and written down. Work gets done without a lot of hemming and hawing and meetings-with-no-agenda-to-talk-about-setting-an-agenda-for-a-future-meeting. It's much more efficient to come to a decision over 7 asynchronous back-and-forths, and people have the opportunity to do some research during the conversation so their decision is better informed. The whole Open Source world [when development is not done within a corporation] works this way.
I think the problem is corporations are obsessed with a definition of productivity as "the person is constantly productive". If you're not in a meeting, or have a ticket in progress, or are doing training, clearly you are just wasting time. You can't be allowed to just ruminate, or research, or play around with an idea, or talk to other teams. They'd rather you be writing code now that will be obsolete in 6 months and take a year to replace, rather than take 2 months to come up with a plan for your code that will take 3 months to write and last for 3 years. We rush into things because we have to have something to show for our work every day, and as a result the quality is poor, and that costs more in the long run.
Having worked for such companies, this is not true, at least in my expreience. Plenty of meetings. Very long ones sometimes, 2 hours is not unusual; 3, 4 hours sometimes on Zoom or Hangouts.
> [non-remote-first companies would] rather you be writing code now that will be obsolete in 6 months and take a year to replace, rather than take 2 months to come up with a plan for your code that will take 3 months to write and last for 3 years.
Hmm. I can assure you some remote-first, multi-time-zone companies would also rather you be writing code now that will be obsolete soon than take substantial time to come up with a plan for code that will last years and serve the product well.
Visibility counts for a lot in some remote-first environments. Depending on the management, they may regard the best form of visibility to be regular code updates, PRs, issues filed etc, rather than taking your time over deeper design and research. If they pay more attention to quantity than effectiveness, that can mean shipping code and iterating every few days is something they are looking to see, and a high priority if you want to keep your job. Async written communication on design is sometimes seen as too much talking, not enough doing.
As a full time senior engineer I’m responsible for oversight and guidance on three separate work-streams, so I have to go to all their meetings. If I were part time then I could be involved in just one of them, and go to only those meetings.
I have a friend that can really work 4 hours a day, but he is a special case where he does not have a family to upkeep and no mortgage. He is also a bit hard on the frugality.
But finding such person is basically 1 in a million. If I post a job with 4h a day which amounts to 1/2 of a normal salary I will probably never get a candidate. If I post a job with normal salary and then start explaining that it is 1/2 hours and accordingly paid, some people will get angry.
I think you're mistaken about that. If you can persuade candidates that it really is 4h a day at 1/2 of a normal salary, you will get candidates who are excited by the job because it opens up their time for other opportunities for hobbies, home life, side projects, open source projects, looking after family, other consulting gigs, education, etc.
However, for developer roles you might find that potential candidates don't entirely believe the ad. I think they'd imagine the employer having unrealistic expectations of what 4h reasonable output looks like, so that they'd feel pressure to work overtime, resulting in closer to 8h anyway while pretending to get it done in less, for 1/2 of a normal salary.
It would be much easier if I get someone CV and he writes cover letter explaining that he would like to try such an arrangement.
I tried to get part time dev for Kibana/Elastic needs like 4 hours - anyone I approached was not even willing to discuss "why" they just said no. People also don't have time to listen to your persuasion, most of the time it is clear cut and goodbye.
You can argue that half time engineers are more than half as productive as a full time engineer because as others have said full time engineers don't work a full 8 hours anyways. While theoretically that's true, as I originally posted, that's not what I've seen. Based on my anecdotal experience, half time engineers are less than half as productive as a full time engineer.
So from both a productivity and economic perspective, it hasn't made sense.
Another factor is that often the cost of developers is not the most significant factor. If a company can get say $100m of value out of $10m of salary cost on engineers, it doesn’t really make sense to instead spend $6m to get $80m of value.
And just adding more people isn’t easy as each person increases communication overhead.
That some people live in houses they couldn't pay for on $150K doesn't mean that $150K isn't possibly a "full time salary". $150K is definitely in the category of "a full time salary", many people make this much or less working full time.
That a skilled engineer could possibly make $150K for working 50% time -- is a choice not available to most people, most people don't even have the choice to make $150K working full time! So a skilled engineer has that option, make would be a (healthy) full-time salary for most of the USA, working only half-time. Or anyway would, if employers would hire like this. That's the point I meant to be making.
Income distribution in the US does continue to get more uneven every year.
However, I'm not "there" yet as a developer. Maybe in a few years after I've proven myself.
Have you considered older workers that are nearing retirement? They're probably looking to lean-out, and a part-time job could give them activity in their lives, while getting you someone who is highly experienced in getting things done. You wouldn't be paying benefits, but probably a higher hourly rate (for less than 40 hours) to compensate.
Or job sharing, where you bring on two part-time workers. My sister did this for many years - it gave her time to raise her children while being able to pay a nanny + daycare. She worked Mon-Wed, and her job partner worked Wed-Fri. The overlap allowed them to coordinate, and they were able to call and send texts to each other at other times.
Who cares if they have 6 jobs, that’s not for you to worry about.
If they get good work done on your project and skip the extra meetings, they’re worth keeping around.
Well yeah. There’s your problem.
I've worked part time for a startup remotely across timezones. I personally credit the technical lead for the most part for its success. Then, the chemistry within the team was really good. When someone says something others tend to get it. And the planning. The tech lead sets up the goals for the quarter and push back on distractions from the business side except on rare occasions. The management was also very competent, they seemed to listen to the engineers.
In theory hiring freelancers part-time should be a great solution for everyone involved, in practice the issue is flakiness
Or is your point that part time employees are more likely to slack off because they are looking for other work/have other responsibilities that take precedence?
Because I've definitely seen my share of fulltime employees who slacked pretty darn hard.
You can have actual employees working only 24 hours a week.
Daily meetings kill flow
> 15 minute standup.
It's literally called a "standup" to enforce the most important rule: it should be much shorter than 15 minutes.
Thanks, I'm familiar with why it's called a stand-up. On my teams the go-through-the-kanban-board phase of the meeting is generally faster than that. But that phase also tends to spark post-standup discussions. "Oh, you want to work on that subsystem too? Let's talk a bit about where we want to take it." I think it's better if people allocate time for that, which is why, especially in places like this, I'll talk about it as I did.
If they want to change the hours then renegotiate time and salary.
If not what's the difference, do you think?
I'd say it would probably be important to have a set schedule for the less-than-full-time workers. Or at least as set as the full-timers.
It seems like it's almost impossible to get a role that's explicitly part time (as you've experienced) but plenty of companies are willing to offer lower salaries while turning a blind eye to enforcing the supposedly 40 hour work week.
The other ways seem to involve some combination of working for yourself, consulting, and short periods of full time employment interspersed with not formally working.
It's kinda either/or
I have done both part-time consulting and part-time contract development. Pure consulting (when one's output is advice) is doable part time, because you're not a blocker and generally don't have to keep up with the day to day.
But I would only do part-time contract development under pretty specific circumstances: 1) I'm the only dev on the project (or at least I know the other devs really well), 2) I am not on the critical path for anything urgent, 3) the organization can sustain an interest in the work (and therefore in paying me) despite it not being urgent.
For example, I knew somebody who needed a discrete service, a PDF form-filler, replaced. The old version was a pain operationally and I think it was built on EOLed tech in a language the team didn't know. That was a fine part-time project because the existing thing worked tolerably well; I was just cleaning up a mess that bothered them. I'd feel the same about, say, tech debt cleanup. Or quick, throwaway prototyping.
But in general, software is a team sport, a collective intellectual work that requires a high level of coordination between both devs and many others. I don't want to be part time on a team of well-meshed full-timers because the overhead of keeping track of the team's progress is fixed. I'd have to spend a notable percentage of my time keeping up, and I'll be adding to the coordination burden of the team despite not contributing as much, so my net ROI is lower. I'd hate it.
That said, I'd be interested to see a project that's, say, all 4-day-a-week people. Maybe even people who work 6 hours a day, 4 days a week. I could imagine that working pretty well while still being enough to keep stakeholders satisfied.
And even for issues that are "cultural", I think one needs particular strategies for managing them. Stakeholders for the important projects that are being delayed will generally not be excited about that. And given that most companies have competitors, those stakeholders might have legitimate reason to want things to go 25% faster. So I'd be curious to see what strategies people have for solving the cultural problems.
The secret is to take a full time job and then only work 20-30 hours a week. Pre-pandemic I was only really productive 4 hours a day anyways, but I had to sit in an office the entire day. With remote work, it’s much easier to do “full-time” work.
But working remotely, the reality is that at least some people can get off without working a 9-5 day so long as they are at least somewhat available during the workday.
Another blocker is the inane requirement in employment agreements by many large corps in the US that they own your IP while you work for them, regardless how it was developed or what the topic is (one place I worked at owned children's books if you published them, despite being a software developer). Until that is unacceptable, either legally or culturally, working part-time presents a conflict of interest. Rather than valuing the breadth a part-timer might bring, it's viewed as a liability.
OK
> Garbage.
Hmm...
Good luck negotiating that with a FANG, smaller companies won't give a damn (unless they have a dumb HR department who doesn't understand how hard hiring devs is)
A lot of this translates to the work environment. Someone making $300k might feel exceptionally rewarded for their work, until they find out that their peer makes $320k. Suddenly that $300k no longer looks that desirable anymore. Call it an innate quest for justice, call it culture shock, call it whatever you want - if you cannot see why your individual arrangement might produce a net negative result for the rest of the company, then you're ignoring the reality.
You just have to implement certain rules and treat everyone the same. You're either a full-time company, or you're a part-time company. You're either an on-site company, or you're a remote company. If you allow hybrid, you have to allow it for everyone. And if one person gets to work 20 hours a week, then it needs to be a 0-friction process for everyone else to transition to the same arrangement if they so desire. From a staffing point of view, that last part is an absolute managerial nightmare ("sorry, the project will be pushed back by 12 months because all of our engineers decided to move to part-time, and we cannot hire new engineers, because the existing staff may also move back to full-time at any given point").
There is, however, a solution for you - just work for extremely well-funded early-stage startups, because their CEOs will be more than glad to rock the boat internally in exchange for your skills and experience that they would be otherwise struggling to find in a full-time hire. By the time that startup scales and their CEO starts thinking about culture and retention, you'll be off to the next boat that you can rock as hard you'd like.
The deal in companies is that it's relatively easy to reduce your work % but it's a one way street. To get back your manager needs to find a budget the same way as if they were hiring (but I don't know anyone who did want to increase it back).
Seems to work well.
Salaries (even full-time) are crap though.
I've had managers/POs/PMs/... work 90% and simply take every Friday afternoon off.
But if you're a dev then yes, taking half a day off is pretty meaningless. I see it as a way to force yourself to take 22-23 additional days of vacation, and at least two of these every month.
1. not in demand fields but fields that for some reason are momentarily needed by the company.
2. fields the company hopes to teach someone else to handle.
3. using technology that the company wants to move off of because they don't have anyone that knows it anymore.
Those fields - Accessibility (achieving WCAG 1.0 conformance), XSL-T - had an xml + xsl-t generating website, team is rebuilding to React and know nothing about the old tech, DSSL stylesheets that needed to be moved to XSL-FO. I also nearly had a part time JQuery maintenance 2 month project about a year and a half ago.
My suspicion, if it's an in-demand field people want you full time, that stuff is IN DEMAND after all.
1.) A significant percentage of cost per employee to a company is benefits. So work half-time and the breakeven to the company is probably something like 1/3 pay if you get full-time benefits.
2.) The above doesn't even count that there are a lot of other overheads (management, coordination/meetings/collaboration) to having more people doing the same work.
3.) It depends what part-time means. Many of us might be OK with 4-day workweeks or shorter days--though to some degree those may be possible in practice today with the appropriate workload and degree of synchronicity. However, if your preference is to take month+ blocks of time off on a regular basis, that's much more difficult to accommodate. (And, if you unplug during those times you lose a lot of context. Earlier in my career, I did take month long vacations now and then but it's hard to norm as a regular thing for lots of good practical reasons.)
I'm in a similar boat, and I've been doing part-time work through Toptal. You certainly get more opportunities if you're full time, but I've been able to steadily get 10-20 hours a week at a rate that would come out around $300k if I was working full time. For me that is plenty to live comfortably and I'm able to choose to have more free time and not feel "owned" by a full time salary position that would likely be more like 60 hours a week of my time.
If you think your job as an engineer is to build a solution as a team, then one person hopping in and out of availability creates a hassle for an entire team. Can't have project meetings on Mon / Fri because X is never there. If a project with involvement by a part timer isn't done by eod Thursday, a fulltime person has 2 dead work days until the part time person shows up again. etc etc.
Someone from EST works 9am-1pm; someone from PST starts work at 9:30am. Daily overlap: 30 minutes.
Yes it could be solved if you want to define core hours in the middle of the day, but I suspect people who want half time work don't view working in the middle of the day every day as the point of the exercise.
Working becomes so much more relaxing.
It gets weird on a team of full timers if the part time person is expected to interact with the full timers at all, especially if they are all working and need to communicate with the person but they are out.
Believe me, I sympathize though. It does create a strange dynamic though.
1. Ask about the makeup of a typical team. The more layers of bloat and regurgitation between the customer and the developer, the more likelihood that the people doing the actual work need a high degree of hand-holding.
2. Ask about their overall approach to customer success, and specifically, what they do before they start development. Good quality consulting firms will have entirely separate non-development projects focusing on fully understanding the problem space before they ever start development. If their customers just throw software requirements on their desk and ask work to start tomorrow, they’re probably not competing on premium quality solutions.
3. Ask about how (or if) the development team works cross-functionally with the customers’ business teams. Burn-and-churn shops will hide their developers from their customers. High performing teams may send a developer solo on a flight to a customer site.
What does this mean?
- Straight up ask them if they're an MSP, lol. MSP isn't a bad business at all; I highly recommend it for juniors needing an in or people who want a lot of exposure to a lot of companies simultaneously. But you don't want MSP work.
- Avoid avoid AVOID WITCH companies (Wipro, Infosys, Tata/TCS, Cognizant, HCL). While they have _some_ A-team strategic work, the lion's share of their business is butts in seats labor arbitrage.
- Also avoid WITCH-adjacent companies (Teksystems et al). Same reason.
- Do a LinkedIn deep dive. If a majority of the company's employees work in an offshore location, they are more than likely butts in seats. This isn't always the case, but it's generally safe to assume so. If you're really interested in what they've got going on, bring it up in the interview and turn your bullshit meter to 11.
- This gets a little tricky for big tech shops, though (Red Hat, IBM, Accenture). They have a lot of butts-in-seats stuff, but they also have a lot of very interesting, very high-impact projects. There are ways to monitor what you're being considered for during the interview process; see below.
- Ask about some engagements they've done (client names don't matter), generally ones they are proud of. Ask about how those projects were structured, the number of people involved, and the objectives. Huge implementation projects usually have a high BIS factor, but some consulting companies charge through the roof for onshore consulting with an emphasis on high-quality software craftsmanship. This usually comes out in the interview; the interviewer mentioning xDD, hard 40 hour limits, and first principles is a good sign.
- Ask them "in your opinion, what's the ratio of staff augmentation to strategic work at this firm?" BIS work is called "staff augmentation" or "staff aug." Not all staff aug is BIS (some better firms take staff aug since it's much easier to sell than strategy but the consultants assigned to those still have autonomy, i.e. they can roll of when they've had enough/they can contest decisions with support of their engagement team/etc), but a high ratio of staff aug to strategy work smells like high BIS.
- The technical interview should be focused on your thought process and experience. "Tell me how you designed this system/explain this decision/if I changed x, what would happen" are some questions that should come up. If they are asking you very-specific trivia (what command would you run to do x/what is the name of y component that does z), then expect a high BIS factor.
Contrast that with when I gave up and decided to make myself available for full-time (remote) work. In the span of about 5 weeks, I got over 200 recruiter emails, interviewed at 10 companies, and received 10 offers, mostly in the upper end of the $200k-400k range.
I firmly believe that this is a cultural block, rather than one that's rooted in rational/pragmatic concerns. Tech companies want to feel like they're getting your full intellectual output, even if that's demonstrably false in the status quo. There's also this issue that gets brought up of "if Bob is gone half the time, isn't that going to breed resentment with his full-time coworkers?" (answer: only if you have a shitty "butts in seats" management culture).
I honestly don't think we're going to see meaningful change in this area for a while. The 40-hour work week is something that's heavily ingrained in tech culture, to the point where certain companies' "perks" are heavily tuned towards incentivizing you to stay at the office longer and frequently turn that 40 hours into 60. I think it will take an external disruptive event on the scale of COVID-19 in order to change this aspect of tech culture.