News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by Andrex on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:42AM (#29567471)
Whenever I transpose my comments to HN, I usually do some light editing. The following comment is unedited because this headline kinda fired me up.

Considering how Google’s treated AR and VR in the last 10 years, hyping people up then quietly pulling back support and finally cancellation after just 2-3 years, I don’t see this going well.

They had a toehold 6-10 years ago which they could have easily kept iterating on and making small marketshare gains, but I guess that wasn’t good enough. Now instead of entering 2022 with 10-20% marketshare, a mature platform, and developer/user mindshare, they’re starting the new year with none of that and the idea “Hey maybe we should try AR/VR stuff again.”

Get bent Google. You shouldn’t have cancelled Daydream and killed the small amount of goodwill you were starting to cultivate. Lenovo got burned, developers got burned, users got burned. And they still want to try again?

Instead of taking your Google Glass ball and running home with it after everyone was mean about the idea, maybe listen to the feedback and change the product? But no, despite Glass being introduced almost purely around consumer-targeted ideas and concepts, it’s now an “Enterprise” product out of reach of us mere mortals.

ARCore, with its many naming and branding changes, has also failed to catch on like Google hyped.

Google, you’re charging into battle with Apple and Zuck and you got a dildo made of American cheese. Good luck.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DkXnLUpXgAEz6Yg.jpg (via HBO's Succession)

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by fossuser on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:09AM (#29567921)
Google seems unfocused - AR is an example of this, their messaging platforms and failure to leverage Google voice for 10yrs after the acquisition are too.

I’d bet on Apple, FB, or some new entry (harder without the underlying OS).

DeepMind is the most interesting thing coming out of Google imo.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by hiptobecubic on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:56AM (#29568515)
Google is unfocused. That's the how the company is designed. It's a federation of VPs, each trying to build a little fiefdom and buy a third bay area house. Sometimes this works well because it fosters competition, but there's a definite lack of coherency.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by ksec on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:28PM (#29571203)
They wanted a letter starting with A to be the parent company of Google. It should have been ADHD and not Alphabet. /s
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by azeirah on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:16PM (#29571737)
:(

Adhd people can be very focused

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by throw10920 on Thursday December 16, 2021 @01:48PM (#29582132)
Can be, on occasion, when focusing on something that's highly interesting to them.

Stable products and visions are definitely not interesting to Google.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by selestify on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:33PM (#29570558)
Was that just a random number you threw out? Because it's depressing if even VPs can only afford three Bay Area homes.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by fossuser on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:34PM (#29570579)
I'd guess a VP can afford just one? Median housing price is 3M in Palo Alto.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:10PM (#29571682)
I mean a good senior engineer is making $450k+ per year, I don’t know what a VP makes but it’s gotta be pretty high? Anyone know?
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by temporalparts on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:16PM (#29571059)
I'm guessing Google VPs make ~5 mil a year, given that L8 engineers make ~1 mil a year [0]

[0] levels.fyi

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by sombremesa on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:13PM (#29571711)
There are huge issues with how these salaries are reported. When you include stock compensation especially: what about vesting schedules and taxes? You can leave a job (by choice or otherwise) where you worked for a year and were making "1 million a year" with less than $300k in total compensation.

It feels like a little trick being played on the employees, kind of like unlimited PTO. I'm sure some people actually enjoy the full benefits of what they're promised, but I'd be surprised if that's a majority.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by comp_throw7 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:12PM (#29573219)
Equity compensation at places like Google vests monthly with no cliff, and it's taxed as income. You get what you see on the tin.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by sombremesa on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:30PM (#29573373)
> places like Google

Which place aside from Google?

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by comp_throw7 on Thursday December 16, 2021 @03:02AM (#29576109)
Facebook, Amazon (mostly cash bonus first two years, but still "vests" monthly with no cliff), Uber, Lyft (every 3 months), Snapchat, etc. It's not all of them but it's an increasing number.

Also, even with a 1-year cliff, for most people it'll still basically be indistinguishable from cash? Leaving (or getting fired) before you hit the 1 year mark is pretty rare, and after the first cliff it usually transitions to something like every 3 months.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by sombremesa on Thursday December 16, 2021 @12:17PM (#29580702)
The cliff is irrelevant, if you leave before you fully vest your pay rate does not actually match what you claim.

The reason I brought up taxes (which might seem odd to people since compensation usually ignores them) is because they will significantly change the equation for various reasons. (AMT, RSUs taxed as short term gains and not long term, state tax affecting comp regardless of cost of living, etc.)

Ultimately, any compensation number that rolls all of this up into one number is mostly useless for actually knowing how much money you’ll have in N years, but it is useful for comparing offers, which is fine - but then these numbers shouldn’t appear without qualification in the type of discussion where personal finance is involved.

Not to mention that since this is a forum where many people are involved in startups, a 50k salary often (ok, maybe not often but I’m on 1/1) turns into several millions in a few years. Does that mean founders should claim they were making $2 mil per year? I don’t think so - but that’s the only comparison available if you use levels.fyi.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by what_ever on Thursday December 16, 2021 @01:35PM (#29581938)
> The cliff is irrelevant, if you leave before you fully vest your pay rate does not actually match what you claim.

This doesn't make sense as well. You don't need to work at Google for a year to get the first year's equity. So there is no one year cliff.

The frequency of how often you vest is also monthly. Specially at the L6+ levels. So you will lose at most of one month's equity (i.e. 1/48th of the grant) if you are bad at planning your last day. So to put actual numbers again, let's say your offer is 240k cash + 240k RSUs every year. So you vest 240k/12 = 20k in RSUs every month on say 20th of the month. If you leave on the 19th of your 12 month of the employment (i.e. before finishing one year), you don't lose on 240k of RSUs but just 20k of RSUs. So you will earn 220k of cash + 229k of RSUs before you leave.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by comp_throw7 on Friday December 17, 2021 @11:00PM (#29601503)
One of your original claims was this:

> You can leave a job (by choice or otherwise) where you worked for a year and were making "1 million a year" with less than $300k in total compensation.

For the purposes of discussing compensation at FAANG & similar, this is basically untrue. If you work at those companies for a year you'll take home (short of a massive movement in stock price) something approximately resembling what was promised to you. Taxes do not change the equation on this, since vested RSUs are taxed as income (_not_ short-term gains; them being the same rate is irrelevant - they are in fact just reported as income on your W2, without being broken out from your salary, it's literally one number). AMT applies regardless of whether your income is derived from vested RSUs or base salary - if you work at Netflix you're probably getting hit too. I don't see how state income taxes are relevant, since, again, those apply exactly the same way to RSUs as they do to salary.

> Ultimately, any compensation number that rolls all of this up into one number is mostly useless for actually knowing how much money you’ll have in N years

Uh, no? You can straightforwardly project your take-home pay over time; if you want to be really precise you can do it as a probability density function to take into account the potential movement of the stock price over time based on the volatility.

This is all a bit of a distraction from your main point:

> I'm sure some people actually enjoy the full benefits of what they're promised, but I'd be surprised if that's a majority.

Untrue! Obviously, trivially untrue, as demonstrated above.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by what_ever on Thursday December 16, 2021 @01:32PM (#29581905)
> RSUs taxed as short term gains and not long term

That's not correct. RSUs get taxed as normal income. So whether you get $600k cash or $300k cash + $300k of RSUs, your tax bill is the same. The gain on the RSUs get taxed as short or long term capital gain. That comes into picture when you sell. If you auto-sell, there is no/very little gain, so no additional tax there and for intents and purpose, it's as if getting $600k in cash.

The numbers reported on levels.fyi are not useless. They give you a good idea of what one can get if they started working there at that moment. You can extrapolate more out of it by understanding the stock gain.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by sombremesa on Thursday December 16, 2021 @01:45PM (#29582101)
How is it incorrect? Short term gains are taxed the same as income, which is exactly what both of us are saying.

This is setup to favor people who don’t understand taxes, so they don’t screw themselves over. It ends up screwing people who do understand taxes.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by what_ever on Monday December 20, 2021 @03:38PM (#29630008)
If you read my comment again, if you sell your stocks immediately after vesting, there is little to no gain. You can even do this automatically at Google using autosale program. Yes, this is short term gain, but it's negligible compared to how much you are getting paid. e.g. Let's say the stock was at $1000 when vested and by the time you got around to sell it 5 days after it's at $1050 - 5% gain which is not so common in usual scenarios. You will pay short term capital gain tax only on $50. This is the only additional tax you will pay compared to getting $1000 in cash as part of your base salary. The $1000 stock itself will be taxed as normal income.

The gain you get on the stock from vest till you sell is a bonus anyway compared to if you were just given straight cash.

I would advise you to run some actual numbers to get this. I don't need to as I have been getting paid this for last 5 years at Google.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by reaperducer on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:26PM (#29572398)
It feels like a little trick being played on the employees

It's a common trick.

In the 1990's Bill Clinton famously categorized people who made $200,000 a year as "millionaires." Why? Because they "should" be able to save a million dollars within five years.

People in power find it easy to play word games with other people's money.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by romanhn on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:42PM (#29571974)
It's all fairly straightforward actually, as long as you're familiar with how compensation works at big companies (salary, stock, bonus, refreshers). Blind and levels.fyi have raised the transparency on comp quite a bit. $1M/year total compensation (that's annual comp, not the total four year vest) is reasonable for a L8/director-level at the tech giants. This is before tax of course, which is how literally everyone talks about compensation.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by akomtu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:19PM (#29571105)
VPs start at about 2M/year before taxes. That doesn't buy you much in the Bay Area.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by romanhn on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:43PM (#29571990)
That's a very odd take. There are very few homes one wouldn't be able to afford (yes, with a mortgage) at 2M/year.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by jkubicek on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:21PM (#29571787)
I bought a $1MM house in the bay area on a salary 1/10th of that. $2MM/year TC buys you a heck of a lot of house.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by akomtu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:26PM (#29571839)
You probably meant you were given a loan to buy a house.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by xyzzyz on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:31PM (#29571888)
Yes, that’s how people typically buy houses. Deeming a salary low if you can’t buy a house with one year of after-taxes, after-expenses income, sounds rather insane to me.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by akomtu on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @07:47PM (#29573506)
No, they don't. They lease houses from banks, with a possibility to buy it in 30 years.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by xyzzyz on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @09:41PM (#29574198)
That’s not how mortgage works, no.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by fizwhiz on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:47PM (#29570709)
> buy a third bay area house

In palo alto / atherton no less.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by moritonal on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:34AM (#29568193)
It hurts to see it the accidental implication that DeepMind came out of Google. DeepMind was one of the UK's greater recent creations and it got bought/absorbed for a pittance in exchange for custom TPUs.

I'll agree though that DeepMind would not have been able to exist really without Google's ongoing funding and hardware, so maybe it is Google's creation at this point.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by fossuser on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:35AM (#29568219)
Yeah, I didn’t mean to imply that Google created it or anything. For better or worse they are owned and supported by Google now though.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by ca01an on Thursday December 16, 2021 @04:54AM (#29576679)
Did DeepMind have anything to do with the TPUs? I was under the impression another group in Google designed them
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by folkhack on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:48AM (#29568395)
> their messaging platforms and failure to leverage Google voice for 10yrs after the acquisition are too

The Hangouts > Chat transition is exactly this. Objectively, they've made it worse and more buggy on their own Android platform. Ever since the transition I talk to friends less on Google services. Many of us jumped to Discord

Don't even get me going on the Gmail rollout...

Google was once an innovator (search, Gmail, Docs) but I'm not expecting quality from any of their future product rollouts... especially if it's an existing product.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by aceazzameen on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:28PM (#29570492)
This upsets me, because I genuinely liked GTalk and early Hangouts. The constant rebrands and iterations made me and my friends stop using G's chat products too.

I too don't expect quality from anything Google anymore. It's become an untrustworthy brand.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by fossuser on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:52AM (#29568459)
Yeah - I moved off every Google service during covid (switching all accounts to fastmail was the biggest pain, but once moved has been great).

One nice thing I'll say is Google's data tools and privacy controls are great. It's very easy to export/delete/control your data there from the settings if you dig through them.

The only thing I still use regularly for personal accounts is YouTube premium.

Thankfully no friends use hangouts and I was able to move the stragglers to signal. I personally don't like discord either, but it's harder to get people out of that one (for now).

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by dehrmann on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:11PM (#29569507)
> Google was once an innovator (search, Gmail, Docs)

Docs was from an acquisition.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by simonh on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:03PM (#29570905)
I used to think that mattered, but I’m not so sure any more. After all the people that developed that product became part of Google, and they didn’t become any less the innovators of it as a result.

I think what matters with an acquisition is how it’s managed and how the technology is developed. I think it’s unarguable Google has put significant investment into docs and done a good job developing the product so I have no problem at this point giving them credit for it.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by tata71 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:17PM (#29574397)
If you want maintained, passionately developed software, it absolutely matters.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by dvh on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:23PM (#29571156)
I used to use Google docs because it was faster that starting libre office. Now Google docs starts 15s for empty document.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by sciurus on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:27PM (#29572402)
FWIW on multiple browsers on several different computers I've never had Google docs take anywhere close to 15 seconds to load.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by Taylor_OD on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:25AM (#29568076)
It's not impossible to "focus" Google but lets not pretend Google is making these decisions to focus on something or not. It's small groups of people or singular people who make these decisions and those visionaries can easily change their focus or be offered a more compelling role at a start up doing the same thing after they spend 12 months learning how to do it at Google.

I don't love Facebook/Meta but it looks like they put a lot of eggs into the Metaverse bucket. Google has never really done that. They have dabbled and because its Google people assume its going to be big or meaningful. But once people internally make enough progress to get promoted and move around internally its not going to continue to be supported without guidance from the top and the top doesnt care about AR/VR/Metaverse. Or at least they havnt until now.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by potatolicious on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:28PM (#29571198)
The two statements don't really work together:

> It's small groups of people or singular people who make these decisions and those visionaries can easily change their focus or be offered a more compelling role

True! All companies face this problem. Smart, capable people have options and frequently will decide to leave and do something else/go somewhere else.

> but lets not pretend Google is making these decisions to focus on something or not

This is where the disconnect is. As a company you decide what things are priorities, and you build teams to pursue those priorities in a way that is resilient to people leaving - even extremely senior leadership individuals.

If a project withers and dies because a key player leaves, then it never had the company's focus. Part of effectively managing a company is to ensure your most important things don't have a low bus factor (or in Google's case, a bug factor of exactly one).

MS, FB, Apple, etc, all have a record of being able to relentlessly pursue a particular goal despite being subject to the same workforce attrition forces that affect Google.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by fossuser on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:31AM (#29568155)
I’m a little confused by your first sentence because it sounds like we’re mostly in agreement?

Google does a bunch of random things kind of haphazardly. Whether this is caused by incentive problems around promo or something else I don’t know.

I don’t think they compare favorably to Apple, Zuckerberg, or modern Microsoft. I’d guess it comes from the top.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by jfim on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:25PM (#29574435)
> I don't love Facebook/Meta but it looks like they put a lot of eggs into the Metaverse bucket. Google has never really done that.

They did with Google Plus, and they eventually killed it.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by taneq on Friday December 17, 2021 @08:55AM (#29592114)
Google isn't one entity any more, it sounds like it's more like some kind of unofficial in-house version of YC except with more politics because the startups are more closely coupled.

Also DeepMind didn't come out of Google, it came out of some British boffins that got acquired for squillions (comparatively, I mean it's only a serious and arguably somewhat successful attempt at building general AI, it's not like it's adtech or finance or something else really important...) and as far as I can see the number one thing Google has done to help them, other than throwing money at them, is to otherwise leave them the hell alone.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by Const-me on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @06:13PM (#29572746)
> harder without the underlying OS

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with the current mainline Linux. There’re issues on desktop, sure. But VR/AR stuff is not similar to desktop, quite the opposite, it’s similar to embedded. For newer mobile GPUs, Linux even support Vulkan in addition to GLES.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by pjmlp on Thursday December 16, 2021 @04:05AM (#29576412)
But the tooling (vs Metal/DX/LibGNMX/...), oh my.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by rl3 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:44PM (#29571390)
>Google, you’re charging into battle with Apple and Zuck and you got a dildo made of American cheese. Good luck.

Zuck's vision is trash to the point I question whether the man's had an original idea in his life, so I'm not completely discounting the American cheese monstrosity as somehow prevailing.

I don't really care for Apple either, but I suspect they're going to "win" by virtue of focus and culture alone.

Of course, if any of these three entities win, it is the world that loses. Rather, continues to lose—depending on how you look at it.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by urthor on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @06:13PM (#29572743)
Whilst I'm all for ragging on Facebook's missteps, their vision seems pretty good if I was in Zuc's shoes.

They want to be vertically integrated, discount Apple in this space.

They're deploying cost effective hardware combined with vertically integrated software stacks that "just work."

And they are leveraging things Facebook does extremely well, targeting extreme volume for cost amortization, UX and building microtransaction loops.

Like it or not those are things you can't say Facebook is bad at that stuff generally speaking.

Everything about the Facebook metaverse vision is cynical from a societal aspect.

But the business case is fine.

They won't make any money for about 10 years, but after 10-15 years of Quest like products, they will be doing well for themselves.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by rl3 on Thursday December 16, 2021 @01:25AM (#29575563)
>Whilst I'm all for ragging on Facebook's missteps ...

I prefer ragging on their very existence, but to each their own. :)

Certainly not disputing they know how to make money. I'm sure they'll make a killing on AR/Metaverse bullshit.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by pjmlp on Thursday December 16, 2021 @04:02AM (#29576398)
Users of React, React Native, Folley, GHC, Flow,.... seem to appreciate their existence.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by monkeynotes on Thursday December 16, 2021 @08:46AM (#29578004)
I think it's possible to respect the software their developers create and dislike the business goals and cynical approach to making money.

Facebook has made some wonderful software, and it has fundamentally degraded humanity.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by pjmlp on Thursday December 16, 2021 @09:19AM (#29578335)
Not when that software is made with blood money, so to speak.

This is what I find so hypocritical on Facebook complaints, washing over how the meat for the sausage is paid for and the animal was slaughtered, only because it tastes good and the complainers want more of it on their plate.

If what Facebook does is so amoral then don't use software paid with selling their customers' data.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:15PM (#29569573)
> Considering how Google’s treated AR and VR in the last 10 years

You mean how they've treated a large proportion of their customer-facing products?

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by alfiedotwtf on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:44PM (#29570002)
i read the title, and thought of Google Reader, then came for the comments.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by ksec on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:26PM (#29571179)
>Google, you’re charging into battle with Apple and Zuck and you got a dildo made of American cheese. Good luck.

This is rare on HN. But true. Google's new CEO still have a lot to prove. The problem with Google was they were not found upon a product DNA. They have very little if any product sensibility.

At this rate, Google search may be first to be disrupted before Facebook. Apple has its cracks but still far too minor.

It is also interesting this is finally the mainstream view, at least the top HN comment. Prior to 2016, people still believe AMP in good faith, Firefox compatibility was not Google's fault, ads by Google were Ok.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by eitland on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:27PM (#29571857)
> At this rate, Google search may be first to be disrupted before Facebook. Apple has its cracks but still far too minor.

After a few years of using DDG which is equally bad as Google but has less and less annoying ads I tried out Kagi last week.

The difference is so big I don't care to verify with neither DDG nor Google: I know based on long experience how bad their results are.

Kagi has so far been a breath of fresh air, a taste of how search used to work when Google actually found the things I asked for, not the thing an insanely annoying AI think I want.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by ksec on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:54PM (#29572086)
Yes. And I forgot to mention in my original post, I only just realise very recently, in a lot of cases every single results in the first page are now Ads. Every single one. I have to scroll down to below the fold to get the result I wanted.

I dont think any one at Google cares about UX anymore.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by bsanr2 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:06AM (#29567884)
Tango did, 7 years ago, everything ARKit does today. All they had to do was loss-lead on a showstopper of a phone with one killer app. They basically stripped down Tango to create ARCore, and lost the SLAM space to Apple and Niantic. No one realizes it yet, but this is about as bad as Microsoft losing the web to Google.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by egypturnash on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:03PM (#29568630)
Isn't Niantic something from Google?

checks https://nianticlabs.com/en/about/

Keyhole made what got renamed Google Earth when Google ate them, ten years later the core of that team started Niantic Labs inside Google, made Ingress, a few years later Niantic left Google (with funding from Google, Nintendo, and Pokemon) and made Pokemon Go. Niantic has acquihired a few companies working in related spaces.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by bsanr2 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:49PM (#29571448)
>Google let Niantic go.

Oh, I didn't know that. That's even worse. Niantic is positioning itself to be a competitor to Apple in the global spatial map game.

Explains why Go released on Android first, though. Neat. I hope that doesn't change now that they're running with 6d.ai.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by pjmlp on Thursday December 16, 2021 @04:11AM (#29576452)
Mostly because ARCore tooling looks like desktop Linux UI/UX just like everything else that Google has produced in 3D tooling space for Android.

I guess SceneForm was the best that they could manage to come closer to Metal Frameworks, and they just killed.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by jayd16 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:25PM (#29569698)
I think Asus did have Tango phones but it wasn't quite powerful enough. It couldn't compete with sexier flagships of the same year.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by dwighttk on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:26AM (#29568089)
Glass was not AR. It was a tiny screen you had to shift your focus to.

I should change my usernames to glasswasnotar because I feel like I am always saying that when people talk about glass and ar

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by dougmwne on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:13PM (#29570330)
I disagree. It was and is an AR product.

Re-watch this early promo video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ErpNpR3XYUw

There are several clear AR features displayed. There's a location based notification about the subway service upon getting close to the entrance. There's overlaid compass based walking directions. There's GPS based location identification and check-in. AR is more than just computer vision driven overlays. Though that tech wasn't available to be put in a HMD at the time, these GPS driven features absolutely were AR features and the original Glass should rightfully be considered the first AR consumer product.

Furthermore, the product still exists as the Enterprise Edition 2 and this current version supports computer vison and object identification applications, further strengthening its AR use cases.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by dwighttk on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @02:27PM (#29570476)
Sure if the experience of using it had been anything like that video it would have been AR, but it was not like that. I’m sure they wanted AR glasses but instead they built a tiny screen you could look at when you weren’t looking at what was around you… kinda like a phone that you didn’t have to hold.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by zucked on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:02PM (#29568619)
How is a tiny screen overlaid in an accessible field of vision, not totally obscuring your perception of reality, NOT "augmenting reality"? I agree it barely meets the threshold, but I don't write it off as not AR full stop.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by a4isms on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:24PM (#29568916)
AR is colloquially understood to mean overlaying your field of vision with graphics that interact with reality in your field of vision.

By way of a real-world example, military pilots have heads-up displays that overlay IDs of aircraft on the aircraft as they appear to the pilot. That's AR.

My volvo has a heads-up display that show me my speed, the current speed limit, warnings, lane guidance... But none of that points to anything in my field of vision. Not AR.

Mercedes also have heads-up displays, and while I don't own one, I saw a demonstration where when you are using adaptive cruise control, it highlights the car it is following. That's AR.

The above is my lay understanding. If you buy this distinction between "heads up display" as a general term, and "AR" as a specific use of a heads up display, then Glass was not AR. It was just a heads-up display.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by dwighttk on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:26PM (#29568948)
Glass had no overlay.

You don’t see reality and the screen at the same time. It is reality or the screen. (Just like a phone that isn’t running an AR app)

Looking at the screen does obscure your perception of reality because your eye has to change focus. The little prism was transparent but it may as well have been translucent because you couldn’t focus on the screen and the world at the same time.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by panzagl on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:42PM (#29571980)
Sounds like it was just shitty AR
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by dwighttk on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:16PM (#29572289)
Wasn’t even that.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by jayd16 on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:23PM (#29569673)
It wasn't an overlay and wasn't powerful enough to do much with the camera in any realtime way. It was closer to a low powered smart watch that's mostly always in view.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by dwighttk on Thursday December 16, 2021 @04:04PM (#29583899)
This is a better description than I’ve been using… since it was so underpowered it was more like a smartwatch than a phone.

But it wasn’t even mostly always in view… when you weren’t focused on it I guess it could kinda flash and make you focus on it, but it had no overlay ability.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by throw10920 on Thursday December 16, 2021 @01:46PM (#29582110)
> Considering how Google’s treated AR and VR in the last 10 years, hyping people up then quietly pulling back support and finally cancellation after just 2-3 years

s/AR and VR/half of the products that Google develops/

Google has some kind of inability to develop stable, boring, long-lasting products, instead prioritizing UX churn and new half-baked features over fixing old bugs or optimizing for performance.

There was a very insightful comment on the Teams 911 thread a few days ago[1] - the entire thing is worth reading, but the most important point is "Google is not setup in same way and internal incentives are not like that, judging by hoard of messaging apps. They are simply setup to make very short projects that do not require long-term commitment."

I do not trust Google to make stable (or privacy-preserving, which is especially relevant to AR...) products.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29496753

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by abstrakraft on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:12PM (#29568755)
Google projects are like Rule 34: if you can think of it, someone at Google is working on it.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by pjmlp on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @10:57AM (#29567745)
Add SceneForm to it, announced with fanfare at IO and slowly forgotten.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by n8cpdx on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:30PM (#29568997)
Not just forgotten, deprecated with no notice after my team built our product with a dependency on it.

You might say, “why would you be so stupid to build your AR product on top of Google’s primary, supported, promoted, first-class way of doing AR?” And I would say Apple hasn’t fucked me over like this. In fact, Apple has continued investing in their AR offering and now makes Google’s ARCore and SceneForm look like a fucking joke.

Google Maps AR - oh yeah, that’s an API feature of ARKit now. Want to have high precision location with Google ARCore? Go fuck yourself. (I’m directly quoting Google here, don’t @ me for the language; when you’re getting gaped by Google day after day, I guess some blue language slips in)

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by jaegerpicker on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:35PM (#29571914)
100% I was a massive Google VR/AR adopter. Usually I'm a big iOS fan but I switched for a while because of Google's work there. I believe strongly that AR is the next major platform but I HIGHLY doubt Google will have a place in that market. They ignored Daydream and then killed it. ARCore is terrible to work with and pretty far behind ARKit and even Unity/Unreal's AR lib's. I'll never trust Google again given how terrible they have been to AR/VR.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by mikro2nd on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:51AM (#29568440)
Sounds like they read some headlines along the lines of "Meta... metaverse... blah, blah, blah..." and had a bout of tech-envy. Again.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by rvz on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:21AM (#29568018)
Except they are trying again, but this time with the acquisition of North. [0]

We'll see how this goes against what Meta and Apple has to offer for AR glassess.

[0] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/06/30/google-acquires-north-augmen...

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by Zak on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @03:31PM (#29571247)
It seems to me that Google only iterates on things that are immediately successful. That doesn't work for something like consumer AR that hasn't really been done before; multiple iterations will be required to get it past the toy/demo/beta phase.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by potatolicious on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @01:39PM (#29569931)
The moment I saw the headline I was itching to express this exact sentiment.

Google seems unable to plan long-term - they had some of the most interesting VR and AR tech early-on but completely squandered the early lead by lacking any institutional commitment to the field.

Google was among the first to put specialized sensors on devices to gain a structural understanding of your surrounding physical environment. They canned it.

Google was among the first to ship accessible, affordable VR devices via Daydream. They canned that, too.

Google's SLAM implementation was best-in-class for a while, and has basically failed to turn that into anything while FB caught up.

The company as a whole seems to have no concept of long-term strategy. Every endeavor is dipped into with the most tepid of toes, and abandoned at the first sign of difficulty (see: Stadia, Allo, oh boy I can continue). A ton of fantastic research and work goes into products that the company should continue investing losses in for long-term strategic advantage, but the company ends up pursuing the worst of both worlds: paying for the R&D and then changing strategies on a whim.

I know the messaging thing is a dead horse but it deserves to be beaten some more: Google should be fielding an iMessage competitor by now, if only to complete the platform narrative, even if it will always lose to WhatsApp. But instead it has no iMessage competitor and has rebooted its messaging strategy 10x for no discernible results. The minimum of what they needed to do was just to field a competent, stable messaging app that serves as a usable baseline for Android users... and they failed even that.

And having been inside the sausage factory myself there's one huge lever that can be pulled here: Google upper management needs to get way more obsessive about products and long-term roadmaps.

The reason why these projects die so easily is because they tend to be owned by mid-level managers and junior execs, a tier of the company where there is intense turnover. Projects die when their patrons leave the company, get promoted, move orgs, or just generally lose interest. There is frequently no champion for the project besides whichever manager/junior exec owns it. If the company hopes to invest in a field long enough for it to actually bear fruit, the commitments need to come directly from the top.

A lot of this is the hangover of Google+, whose shadow every project (even non-social media ones) lives under. The company seems desperately afraid of making multi-year commitments to things unless they are bearing immediate fruit, out of fear that they'll pull another G+, where failing ideas continued to get disproportionate investment via dictat. I don't know what the right solution to that is, but it certainly isn't what they're doing right now.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by ilamont on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:44PM (#29571992)
Considering how Google’s treated AR and VR in the last 10 years, hyping people up then quietly pulling back support and finally cancellation after just 2-3 years, I don’t see this going well.

Not just AR/V like Glass. Web and mobile software, hardware, and platforms.

We've seen so many projects launch with incredible hype and die on the vine a few years later or wither to insignificance from lack of customer support, developer resources, or a workable strategy. Nexus. Blogger. Stadia. Music. Plus. Wave.

The lesson is clear: Google can't be trusted.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by clem on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:05PM (#29572188)
Has Stadia died already?
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by sciurus on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @05:32PM (#29572439)
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by bsedlm on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:09AM (#29567928)
wasn't Microsoft also in this race with the HoloLens?
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by emptyfile on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @12:32PM (#29569019)
What Microsoft did with Hololens is a great example of what Google should've done.

But that actually requires management with a vision.

Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by loeg on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:23AM (#29568057)
Not past tense -- HoloLens is a product they charge real money for.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by monkeybutton on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:33AM (#29568188)
And soon to be mass producing. They will be supplying 120k units the US army.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by iamricks on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:35AM (#29568214)
I have a friend who works at a company that uses HoloLens, their use case is so that mechanics working on planes can be remotely guided by a more experienced mechanic (not sure if they're engineers?) on what they have to do to repair the aircraft.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by N1H1L on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @04:39PM (#29571948)
This is because in Google, you are promoted/feted based on products you create, not what you maintain unless that's bringing in so much ad revenue that you can be spun off into a separate division.
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by penjelly on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:10AM (#29567948)
daydream was my intro to vr, now a proud index user. Im also sad they completely dropped support for it, imagine buying a new phone and it losing an awesome feature for seemingly no reason (yes i understand google wouldve had to spend money supporting it)
Re:Google is building a new augmented reality device and ope... by kwertyoowiyop on Wednesday December 15, 2021 @11:50AM (#29568421)
Now they can call it MetaGlass!