News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by qwertox on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:35PM (#29177489)
Hmm. For me the dislike button was informative. If feels like they are trying to create a world where everything can only be good, better, even more better, which just doesn't represent reality.

Imagine Stack Overflow only having the option to upvote Questions and Answers. The ratio of likes vs dislikes of a TED talk does help me to decide if I should stop watching a video which just isn't getting better.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by spurgu on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:55PM (#29179742)
Yup. If I'm watching a positive review of a [insert-object] I'm planning on buying and it has 10k likes visible while hiding 2k dislikes I'm probably going to get horribly misled.

While if it's a video of a political debate I would expect there to be a ton of dislikes by default, so I suppose it wouldn't matter much in that scenario.

And in howto/explanation-videos, if dislikes aren't shown, there's no signal for people telling them whether or not it's a good explanation.

I suppose you could devise a dislike count yourself by calculating the likes/views ratio. But why... people are deliberately putting their content up publicly for display and as such are opening themselves up for scrutiny/criticism/dislikes. It can't be all praise and hugs and kisses. That's how we treat children.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bellyfullofbac on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:04PM (#29179896)
I guess we can make our own standard, someone should comment something like "This video is garbage." or simply "Dislike" and the amount of thumbs up on that comment can be taken as video dislikes.

I sometimes look for obscure how-to's, and I get garbage videos not even answering the question. If YouTube can get rid of all that garbage, then not having a dislike button is fine.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by spurgu on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:03PM (#29181535)
> someone should comment something like "This video is garbage." or simply "Dislike" and the amount of thumbs up on that comment can be taken as video dislikes.

The problem with Youtube as I see it is that these comments never rise to the top. It's always compliments and ass-kissing and high-fives that make it there.

Twitter tends to gravitate towards the opposite.

It's all fascinating though.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by datenarsch on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:27PM (#29182373)
> The problem with Youtube as I see it is that these comments never rise to the top. It's always compliments and ass-kissing and high-fives that make it there.

That's because they have engineered their comment system in a way that comments the AI perceives as negative are shadow-banned or buried deep down so people don't get a chance to read them.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by NavinF on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:26PM (#29182360)
The uploaders of garbage videos will delete all comments along those lines. The inability to delete dislikes is what made them so useful.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bellyfullofbac on Thursday November 11, 2021 @03:27AM (#29185732)
The alternative would be a 3rd party browser extension, that store the dislikes on a 3rd party server...

In the 90's there was an add-on that allowed anyone to comment on any webpage: http://alumni.media.mit.edu/~orit/utok.html

Although imagine having such a tool nowadays and opening cnn.com, it'd be like walking into a MAGA rally.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by runevault on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:39PM (#29177552)
I mostly agree with you, with the caveat of brigading being a very real thing that lowers the information value. But then why show upvotes either because positive brigading is just as damaging to the information as downvote brigades.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by pugets on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:53PM (#29179710)
YT can counter brigades by giving viewers even more statistics about a video. Example: what’s the like to dislike ratio of a video in the past 7, 30, or 90 days, compared to all-time?

Steam (a video game store) does this already. They categorize reviews as either being recent (made in the last 30 days) or all-time. If a game has excellent all-time reviews, but mixed recent reviews, then you can suspect something has recently upset the playerbase.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by eropple on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:47PM (#29180529)
You can't, however, determine if what upset the player base is "the game developer is a woman" or "the game developer is gay" or "a streamer with a toxic following got mad at the game".

It is low signal all the way through, and relegating likes and dislikes to a signal for recommendations is wise.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by pugets on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @07:12PM (#29182750)
I don't want video game recommendations from someone that wants to sell me a video game, because they have a financial incentive to sell me a $60 game that I'll like instead of a $10 game that I'll love. No, I would much rather trust the opinions of people who have bought and played the game. I want to know if 99%, or 90%, or 65% of players gave it a good recommendation.

Long-time Netflix subscribers might be having déjà vu right now. Old Netflix had a ratings system, and users could filter content by average rating and see the top-rated movies and shows. Netflix later replaced that system with a recommendation engine. Not only does the recommendation engine not get my taste right, but it sure seems to recommend to me a lot of Netflix Originals.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bavell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:28PM (#29181109)
Umm... What? I have never seen any of those things you mentioned on a steam review, ever, in my ~15yrs on the platform.

The steam review graph is a fantastically useful tool for users with a huge SNR and I don't understand why you think otherwise.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by fishtacos on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:57PM (#29181488)
You can probably google more, but here's a prominent example of why you're incorrect with your assumptions:

https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2018-09-25-total-war-rome...

"Total War: Rome 2 has suffered a Steam review bombing run over women characters and a recent update - but it turns out the game is working as intended.

"Creative Assembly's PC strategy game, which came out in 2013, saw hundreds of new negative Steam reviews this week over the frequency with which women generals show up in the game and related claims about historical accuracy."

and another one:

https://www.techspot.com/news/91212-life-strange-true-colors...

"The reason behind the Chinese users' anger is the inclusion of a symbol banned in their country. On the main street of the game's Haven Springs setting is a shop called Treasures of Tibet, which displays a Tibetan flag prominently outside the store."

Valve has come out on more than one occasion to let customers and studios know that they are constantly working to mitigate brigading.

EDIT: While not the norm, as you were alluding, gamer toxicity and brigading can also be relatively mainstream. A popular website among such circles is

https://www.oneangrygamer.net/

Reading the posts and comments can be quite revolting.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bavell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:54PM (#29182088)
Neither of the articles claim what you're claiming though ("game dev is a woman/gay", etc). What assumption have I made that you think is incorrect? I just made an observation that in my extensive history on the platform I've never encountered what you stated.

Really though, my main point I actually care about making is that the steam review system is far superior to a simple like/dislike system which YT implements.

At the bottom of your first article:

> Meanwhile, Total War: Rome 2 has an "overwhelmingly negative" recent reviews rating, with a "mostly positive" overall rating.

Ahh, so it seems the steam rating system is working! Even though these games got "brigaded", users are still able to see the overall and historical ratings to get a better picture of what's going on.

This actually lets you see the rating before the brigade started. And if the game is actually good, the brigaded ratings will amount to a blip amongst the other reviews. Case in point, here is the current steam page for R:TW2, with "very positive " overall rating: https://store.steampowered.com/app/214950/Total_War_ROME_II_...

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by fishtacos on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:38PM (#29182461)
"Neither of the articles claim what you're claiming though ("game dev is a woman/gay", etc). What assumption have I made that you think is incorrect? I just made an observation that in my extensive history on the platform I've never encountered what you stated."

-- Anecdotal evidence doesn't mean that it didn't happen. My personal experience of using steam since its inception (HL2 launch on Steam, 2004), so roughly 17 years, is that I've come across this on a more than a few occasions. I tend to collect digital goods in a hoarding method, so I'm up to over 3700+ games in my library and I check a lot of them out when I can, even if I have no time to really play them anymore. The firs thing I read?

REVIEWS!

As mentioned - this is not the norm, and I agree with your general premise, but please don't dismiss what actually happened and what I witnessed (no, I don't have screenshots because I wasn't documenting it happening in real time when it occurred). The examples I brought up were illustrative of some gamers' groupthink mentality (including oneangrygamer.net, which has in mid-2021 disabled comments because they were ridiculously toxic - misogynistic, sexist, homophobic and racist)

Also - I'm not OP, FYI. I was backing OP's point.

I can't be bothered to respond to the rest of your post, unfortunately, because it comes across as vapidly dismissive.

Look up GamerGate if you'd like more information on brigading and misogynistic groupthink among related sub-communities.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Jensson on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:37PM (#29181236)
You can't vote for a game on steam unless you own it, that makes brigading mostly ineffective.

What you are thinking of is metacritic where anyone can post, it is very prone to brigading, but steam reviews isn't.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by tgittos on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:15PM (#29181672)
Except you can buy it, review and then request an almost unconditional refund.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bavell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:57PM (#29182117)
How many times can you get away with this before steam wises up? My guess is not many. They also have your CC. Makes it a pain for anyone but criminals to successfully brigade en-masse.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Jensson on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:22PM (#29181750)
Which is a huge hurdle compared to just clicking a button with zero possible consequences.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by scoopertrooper on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:01PM (#29178898)
Seems like a middle ground solution might be to restrict the display of downvotes to videos that meet a certain viewership threshold. That way organic voting would make brigading more difficult.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by a_f on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:53PM (#29179722)
Steam has a useful chart which shows the votes/reviews over time with the ability to filter by language, purchase type, play time etc. Youtube could implement something similar to help shine a light on brigading
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bavell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:22PM (#29181026)
The steam review graph is brilliant and an example of getting it right. YT seems to have succumbed to it's incumbent position in the market and has stopped innovating - it now seeks only to maintain the status quo and apparently thinks dislikes are a threat to that.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by dcow on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:42PM (#29177600)
Exactly. Seems like you could just throttle votes or abstract the metric to smooth out spikes and account for brigading in either direction...
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by prions on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:48PM (#29177704)
So you'd rather they manipulate the data and potentially mislead users? Sounds like a slippery slope to me \s
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by fuckcensorship on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:54PM (#29178773)
YouTube has been manipulating like/dislike data for the White House for months now [1].

[1]: https://81m.org/

Archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20211023061808/https://81m.org/

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by mike_d on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:56PM (#29179769)
It looks like the creator is counting any decrease in dislikes over time as manipulation, without a firm understanding of how large scale systems work.

Say for example I used a batch of 100 HN accounts to mass downvote your comment. After a while an hourly job runs that looks at all those votes in aggregate and determines they were coordinated (for simplicity sake they all came from the same IP) and removes them. You'd see a large shift in the net score of your comment all of the sudden. This isn't HN manipulating anything, it is them doing their job to prevent abuse on the platform.

[dead]
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by malwarebytess on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:09PM (#29182225)
Oh honey.

Or, you know, some of those votes are fraudulent (bots, dupe accounts, tactical voting, etc) and they're being removed?

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by lalaland1125 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:38PM (#29182468)
What would even be the point of faking the dislike/like counts? Does anyone actually look at them compared to polls?
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by jakear on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:42PM (#29179530)
It's interesting data, but the obvious response from YouTube would be "we run sophisticated click fraud detection algorithms and periodically remove interactions determined to be from fraudulent accounts; given the current political climate White House videos attract more of these types of fraud than other videos on our platform and thus the effect is more pronounced on their videos". The numbers in question are small enough (~1k missing interactions) that it doesn't seem totally unreasonable.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by dcow on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:53PM (#29177774)
No I'd rather have a know established system/metric in place that amortizes brigading so as to diffuse the effects of mob attacks on internet content.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by csee on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:10PM (#29178033)
I don't even buy YouTube's claim that "brigading" or "dislike attacks" is a real thing or a problem. If they have a minimum number of minutes that a video needs to be watched before a vote is counted, then that vote is legitimate, full stop. YouTube are simply unhappy about which videos users dislike, whether it's the White House's videos, important brands, or YT's own videos.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by davorak on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:04PM (#29181568)
> If they have a minimum number of minutes that a video needs to be watched before a vote is counted

I think that unintentionally removes down votes on obviously bad videos that people do not waste much time watching.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by JoshTriplett on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:51PM (#29182058)
Agreed. Sometimes you know within a couple of seconds that a video isn't what the title and thumbnail claims it is, and that's a great reason to hit "dislike".

For instance, an hour-long video claiming to be what you're looking for, but actually consisting of a still image and a URL to a scam/spam site.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by JoshTriplett on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:49PM (#29182036)
> I don't even buy YouTube's claim that "brigading" or "dislike attacks" is a real thing or a problem. If they have a minimum number of minutes that a video needs to be watched before a vote is counted, then that vote is legitimate, full stop.

I've seen dislike attacks happen. And if it takes a non-trivial procedure to make them count, people will document that procedure. For instance, hypothetically:

"Alright everybody, here's the link. Remember, mute the tab right away but don't mute the video itself; wait 2 minutes (the timer that starts when you click the link will go green to let you know), then click the dislike button."

I've seen much more complex instructions offered as part of gaming a poll, as well as sites built to help semi-automate or simplify the process.

The key distinction that would be useful for YouTube to measure: did you encounter the video and then dislike it, or did you visit a video you were referred to for the sole purpose of disliking it? I don't think hiding dislike counts serves that purpose, though.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by dcow on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:02PM (#29178932)
I like that solution even more.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by lrem on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:23PM (#29180177)
Isn't that what Reddit is doing to quite some success?
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by smaryjerry on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:21PM (#29180144)
Spikes don’t really mean anything. If a video ‘goes viral’ it will all of a sudden get a lot of responses. And sometimes those will all be bad if it’s a bad video or unpopular opinion. Interpreting that as bot voting or manipulation should have nothing to do with spikes.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by daveoc64 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:36PM (#29179457)
Downvotes on Stack Overflow/Exchange require users to meet a reputation threshold (much like HN) and each downvote removes 1 reputation from the user that gives the downvote.

Dislikes on YouTube and similar platforms don't have any cost or barrier to entry.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by jonnycomputer on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:58PM (#29179794)
I wish they'd cost reputation here too. Behavioral experiment after experiment has show people will engage in costly punishment to maintain norms, so don't need to worry about under-downvoting. But enabling downvoting to be costless (and anonymous) does have downsides.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by suyash on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:43PM (#29179554)
but everyone can still the the count - that is the main point here
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by daveoc64 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:46PM (#29179612)
Everyone can see the count on Stack Overflow, but there are several mechanisms in place to protect that count from all sorts of abuse (bots, tactical voting, second accounts etc.).

The same is simply not true of YouTube or any other kind of social media upvote/downvote system - anyone can sign up for an account, and their votes immediately count and have equal weighting.

The same is not true of Stack Exchange or HN, where you have to put a lot of effort in with a community to be able to downvote something.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Tijdreiziger on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:53PM (#29179711)
> The same is simply not true of YouTube or any other kind of social media upvote/downvote system - anyone can sign up for an account, and their votes immediately count and have equal weighting.

I don't think this is true for YouTube - you need a Google account, and you can't create a Google account without verifying your phone number. (Unless you can create numerous accounts with one phone number? But that seems like an easy loophole to close.)

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by ziml77 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:13PM (#29180893)
Google does let you create multiple accounts with a single phone number. There's legitimate reasons to have multiple email addresses. I have a handful of different ones that I use for different identities I have online.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by mywittyname on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:11PM (#29179990)
I have multiple Google accounts on one phone number. I'd probably leave google if that limitation were put in place.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Tijdreiziger on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:20PM (#29180131)
A limitation of, say, 10 accounts for one phone number doesn't seem unreasonable to me.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by peeters on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @10:54PM (#29184268)
That's not actually true. There's a reputation threshold (1000) to see how many downvotes the post has: https://stackoverflow.com/help/privileges/established-user. Without that privilege one can only see the net votes.

I've argued against it in the past (since it's very important context to any reader) but to no avail. An upvote and a downvote rarely cancel each other out. They have different units and shouldn't be summed together. A score of 25 could mean the answer is perfect but has only seen moderate traffic, or incredibly dangerous but has seen high traffic.

Here's a good list of controversial answers on SO: https://data.stackexchange.com/stackoverflow/query/466/most-.... They would mostly look like great answers from the net score.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by pjmlp on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:04PM (#29179900)
I really don't get this modern culture of positiveness, people cannot take a negative remark of any kind, kids should not play with anything that can hurt themselves, we are forbidden to say anything that can be interpreted in a negative way,...
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by userbinator on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:50PM (#29180568)
I find it ironic that your comment is downvoted ;-)

I agree, this "toxic positivity" can't be good for society in the long term. The continued drive towards stupidity and unquestioning, docile populations is going to slowly turn into a massive dystopia.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by pjmlp on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:25PM (#29181062)
As if I would care, I have seen plenty of stuff in this world, and yes we must care for the others and respect them.

There is a red line between caring for the others, and what is nothing more than plain censorship via "toxic positivity".

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by ohyeshedid on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:47PM (#29178659)
Likes and dislikes don't ultimately matter to Google, engagement does. Viewing is enough: likes, dislikes, comments; those are just multipliers.

Hiding dislikes is something Brands want.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by ridaj on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:14PM (#29180047)
Public dislike counts were opportunities for brands to own up to their ambition for authentic engagement. This is maybe the main thing lost here - without putting this at stake, and with full moderation powers on their video comments, brands basically only have a veneer of authenticity at this point. There's not as much at stake for them anymore, very limited downside / reason to care.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Igelau on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:24PM (#29182347)
> engagement

That's the word. It isn't really "likes" in the sense that we normally think of it. It's ticks on the relationship of "engagement" to "dollars".

IIRC, Facebook was pretty upfront about this being why they didn't implement a "dislike" button; the information wasn't valuable to them.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by epolanski on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @07:35PM (#29182970)
Facebook said it lowered engagement iirc, same reason why they removed likes count on Instagram, it reduced engagement, people posted less if they feared being judged by the number of likes.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by ohyeshedid on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:29PM (#29196310)
And now you've got me wondering if anyone has ever tried to compare likes to profitability of product launches.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by allenu on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:43PM (#29178582)
I also found it informative. If I see a clip explaining something that has a large number of dislikes, I immediately back out and look for another one. Most of the time, those dislikes are warranted.

I honestly don't know if it's a generational thing or overall cultural shift, but it feels like negativity (at least in the workplace is where I've seen this) is either less tolerated or less shared. There's a bias towards being positive about everything, even for things that aren't... great. It feels like self censorship, and this isn't even for things that are political, just subjective.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by adoxyz on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:42PM (#29177617)
100% agree. If they're going to do away with the dislike counter, then do away with the like counter as well.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by mattowen_uk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:45PM (#29178630)
My opinion on this, is that they should hide BOTH the counts, and only the creator can see it.

Keep the actual buttons, as they signal to YouTube what you do and do not want to see in future, but the actual counts only have use to the creator... and even then a simple ratio or percentage alongside the video in the Creator Studio is enough; there's no need for actuall numbers.

What's not been mentioned is that YouTube add a small % of fake clicks to the like/dislike buttons, and also hide the real counts for a while, if there's a rush on clicks (to dissuade click-bandwagoning).

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by esnard on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:28PM (#29178350)
Yeah, that bugs me a lot, especially since the comments section of a video can be heavily censored by the author.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by adminscoffee on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:14PM (#29179125)
yeah good is ruining everything they touch
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by quotemstr on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:52PM (#29179701)
> If feels like they are trying to create a world where everything can only be good, better, even more better, which just doesn't represent reality.

It's part of a trend towards fake, cloying, passive-aggressive forced positivity across the whole industry. It's a California thing.

Time was, if you didn't like a bit of code, you could say so. Nowadays, you have to wrap criticism in right zillion levels of disingenuous praise before you can even start getting to the point -- and the you get fake "thank you for the excellent feedback!!!!1!!" typed with gritted teeth and fantasies of backstabbing later on.

I've always found the in-your-face New York style more genuine, more honest, more efficient, and ultimately, kinder and more respectful.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by ghosty141 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:08PM (#29179018)
I think this shows what standpoint Google has in this: The dislike button is not supposed to be used by the user, but rather the creator.

You as a user should watch the video no matter what and then rate the creator, not skip it if you see a large amount of dislikes.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by DoItToMe81 on Saturday November 13, 2021 @02:49AM (#29208204)
No, thanks. I use Youtube for technical videos and videos pertaining to certain tasks and the dislike ratio is nearly always an indicator of whether or not the video is misleading, incorrect or uninformative.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by kingcharles on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:08PM (#29179025)
In New World Order everything is doubleplusgood.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by notreallyserio on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:58PM (#29178840)
Removing downvotes from SO seems like it would be a net good. Instead of downvoting, people could be more encouraged to post better and more correct solutions.

A good intermediate solution would be to only record downvotes that come with a comment.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by politician on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:27PM (#29180232)
There's no salvaging what SO has become - the place where good complex questions are promptly closed by uninformed moderators. The place where questions about new versions of software are closed as duplicates of questions about older obsolete versions whose answers are no longer relevant. The place where popular questions with hundreds of upvotes and strong discussions are closed as off-topic.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by manquer on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:49PM (#29180551)
If you see SO as community for developers these are all problems yes, however if you see it as a high quality wiki or KB, most of these issues are not problems for readers[1] . All knowledge repositories go through this problem, Wikipedia sites are equally notorious for making it very hard to contribute. As a KB grows older and larger, it becomes hard to balance the need to keep the current KB clean and enable creation of new content.

Typically administrators respond by making it harder for the contributors rather than taking risk of poorer quality for the users, to contribute you have to become effectively professional and abide by institutional rules you may not agree with. Distributed editing tools only solves part of the problem and cannot not solve how to keep generating professional quality content without paying.

Strong moderation is what differentiates SO from Quora, I rather live with SO style rules as a contributor than suffer poor Quora type content quality as a user.

[1] I am cognizant of outdated version problems you raised, my anecdotal experience is in general the quality of answers that are present for a reader has not dropped massively in last 10 years.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by notreallyserio on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:09PM (#29180843)
If you see SO as a high quality anything, I'm not sure what to say. It's filled with people answering the question they wish was asked instead of ignoring the question they're not satisfied with.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by manquer on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:29PM (#29181117)
I don't know a platform today that has better content than SO for technical questions.

My code throughput have reduced a lot in recent years with changing roles and I prefer reading the actual documentation, I am no longer solving a immediate/specific problem. Even then I still click search hits on SO few times a week, and most times after clicking through a few questions I can find what I need.

Your(others) experience will vary from my mine of course, but I don't see anyone attempting a better model or better content short of source documentation .

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by eitland on Thursday November 11, 2021 @01:31AM (#29185071)
Like Google their main competitor is their former selves.

As the mix of us who knew early versions of Google and Stack overflow gets diluted year by year by new users who don't know how well these systems used to work this will become less and less of a problem for them so they can sleep well at work.

Until someone disrupts them. I'm happy to say it feels we are getting close to that moment now ;-)

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by jokethrowaway on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:24PM (#29182346)
The best use of SO for me is: - Write an elaborate question about an apparently unsolvable problem - Realise the mistake while trying to explain it to the SO crowd - Close the website

At some point I wanted to have a high score to see if it would affect my daily rate (it didn't) or if I could use it somehow (same as having tons of stars on GitHub - another useless errand).

I started replying to a bunch of questions and the sheer stupidity of most of them made me realise I wasn't ready for that. Most of the content on SO is not great. There are definitely few gems in there and I certainly enjoyed "the <center> cannot hold", but most of the times the docs are better.

On a side note. I never understood people that copy code from Stack Overflow. I can understand people who are not familiar with a programming language - but surely if you're a minimum proficient it would be faster to just write what you need to do or look for a library to do it?

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by manquer on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:33PM (#29180322)
It is likely I may know enough to judge a proposed solution is wrong or inadequate etc but not enough to write a better one. Vast majority of users who can down-vote would come under this category.

Encouraging them to write their own solution or even a critique/comment is not necessarily better.

You can also down vote questions not only answers, a question could be poor but it does not mean I can come up with a better one.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by notreallyserio on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:07PM (#29180800)
IMO it's perfectly acceptable to not only not downvote but to ignore a question or answer if you don't know/don't want to put in more effort to figure it out. Maybe someone else has faced the problem and understands how the questioner came to write the question they did?
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by manquer on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:19PM (#29180982)
Many times it is not hard to figure out why the question was written in a bad way. Spending time in the review queue can give a good sense on bad types of content that are typical on the site.

Common issues I come across are very vague statements without an actual question, very broad advisory /opinionated questions, very specific solve this bug in my day job/code , no examples/illustrations added, or a big log or code dump - i.e. no effort to separate out the actual problem statement, do my homework kind of questions, typically there will already be comments asking for improvements without much impact.

I wouldn't down-vote a question that I don't fully understand ( I guess that is true for most users too), at the same time I want to make sure bad content is not encouraged. It is just internet points for both users, nothing to fret about.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by tester756 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @11:59AM (#29190205)
>Removing downvotes from SO seems like it would be a net good. Instead of downvoting, people could be more encouraged to post better and more correct solutions.

and way more spam, no thanks.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by kobalsky on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:48PM (#29178671)
for all practical purposes it was cosmetic.

I constantly got heavily downvoted slideshow + text-to-speech autogenerated garbage videos that were ranked above good videos on search results

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by president on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:06PM (#29180793)
> If feels like they are trying to create a world where everything can only be good, better, even more better, which just doesn't represent reality.

If they actually believed in the rationale behind this change, they would get rid performance reviews for engineers at Youtube too.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by genewitch on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:40PM (#29177580)
Kinda of ironic that you can't downvote/dislike on this site here without enough upvotes yourself...
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by dcow on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:48PM (#29177695)
How is that ironic? It's a well established spam prevention measure not a complete removal of a useful metric. It exists prominently on e.g. stack exchange sites and has been a common feature in general on reputation based forum software. What's perhaps ironic is that you can't see vote counts on HN comments _at all_ unless you're the author. So HN has already implemented this feature they just did it sensibly and included upvotes (on comments, at least) too. Most ironically, the front page shows only up-vote counts, something people are citing as a ruined experience in the case of YT removing the dislike count yet is par for the course for submissions on this very site.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by crowbahr on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:42PM (#29177612)
That's not the solution proposed by youtube though: They're _never_ allowing you to "prove yourself" the way that hacker news does.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by LarrySellers on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:48PM (#29177690)
There are no dislike/downvote buttons on submissions on HN (only comments), no matter how much you "prove yourself"
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by WithinReason on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:12PM (#29178071)
"flag" is used as dislike
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by cute_boi on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:43PM (#29177623)
actually this is good because it helps to mitigate bot somehow.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by mattowen_uk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:47PM (#29178660)
To have full rights in a civilised society, you need to prove that you can be a good citizen first. What's wrong with that?
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by lovethyenemy on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:11PM (#29179076)
Guilty until proven innocent is an incompatible maxim for civilised society.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by aeternum on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:36PM (#29180372)
Parent said full rights. Some rights must be earned or granted after some time period. A society that immediately gave children the right to drive and carry handguns would likely not stay civilized for long.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by SV_BubbleTime on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:00PM (#29178880)
> To have full rights in a civilised society, you need to prove that you can be a good citizen first. What's wrong with that?

That’s literally not the case anywhere though. Maybe China’s social credit system, maybe, but even then I think you start with a presumed “innocence”.

I can’t think of any system of rights that are afforded after evidence merit and not birth. That’s not what rights are.

Not going to ask you what full rights means, as it implies you consider rights a gift from a government and not restrictions on a government.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by gowld on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:01PM (#29179849)
Downvoting is a privilege, not a right. Like driving a car on a public road. Don't nitpick words, speak to the main point.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by jonnycomputer on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:59PM (#29179814)
How about driving licenses?
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by SV_BubbleTime on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:19PM (#29180117)
Privilege, not a right.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by jonnycomputer on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:30PM (#29182409)
When is a thing merely a privilege, and not a right? Particularly when both can be conditional or qualified? I'm not sure this isn't playing a game of semantics--just because its called a privilege and not a right in the American context, does not mean that an argument that driving is not a right and merely a privilege.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by SV_BubbleTime on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @07:14PM (#29182766)
Rights are restrictions people have placed on the government or has imposed on itself, as enumerated in say, a charter or constitution. These are not gifts from the government as list of things you can do, but a list of things they can’t do. Bestowed on birth, and infringed upon only when necessary as agreed upon by the people for reasons.

Privileges are features that may be taken for granted as rights but are not enumerated protections. You have no right to drive, it’s a privilege that we all agree is handy.

I don’t think you are playing with semantics, but this is not a difficult concept.

GP makes a completely baseless claim that you don’t have “full rights” until someone says you do. They are talking about privledges.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by jonas21 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:49PM (#29179662)
Imagine a News site for Hackers that only had the option to upvote stories. How horrible would that be?!
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by badRNG on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:52PM (#29179694)
HN has a downvote button, but only for those who've engaged on HN for a bit prior to downvoting. It helps prevent abuse.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by rnd0 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:56PM (#29179772)
What's "a bit"? I've been here since 2017, 371 karma, still no downvote option.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by TravisHusky on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:03PM (#29179886)
If I am not mistaken, it is an option at 500 karma.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by phaedryx on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:04PM (#29179890)
I gave this comment an upvote. Let's get you over the threshold.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by DoreenMichele on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:05PM (#29179907)
Trust me: that strategy only works on April 1st.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by rnd0 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:12PM (#29180016)
It's the thought that counts -and I appreciate the thought!
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by DoreenMichele on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:23PM (#29180171)
I was poking fun at myself. I'm probably the only one who thinks it's funny.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by phaedryx on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @09:43PM (#29183841)
haha, I lost some points on that comment.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by rnd0 on Thursday November 11, 2021 @05:36AM (#29186518)
"Karma is meant to be spent" -which is a bit of a conundrum to me because I can't figure out how to "spend" karma without simply spamming every thread I see in hopes of getting up-votes (which I'm pretty sure is the opposite of what the karma system's intent is).
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Buttons840 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:55PM (#29179747)
I've been on HN for nearly 10 years and can't downvote stories. Not a complaint, just an observation.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by rnd0 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:59PM (#29179809)
> Not a complaint, just an observation.

Same. It feels like a passive-aggressive elitism, and not simply an anti-abuse feature.

Given the site we're on, I don't have a problem as much with the elitism (I'm not the target demographic, after all -I'm older and not working in tech) as much as with the "passive-aggressive" part of the rhetoric behind withholding downvote capability.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Ensorceled on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:07PM (#29181590)
It IS an anti-abuse / anti-sockpuppet feature. I can see why you think it is elitism since, in a way, it is. But I don't understand why you think it's "passive aggressive".
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by mike_d on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:01PM (#29179857)
You should be able to downvote comments, since you have more than 501 karma. The analog for downvoting submissions is the "super downvote" of flagging (and in turn vouching), which requires 31 karma.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by aeternum on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:31PM (#29180291)
The flag button serves as a downvote for stories. Seems like a good system since people are less likely to hit flag just because they disagree.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Cd00d on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:59PM (#29179813)
You have a karma > 4k... I don't understand. Maybe you haven't noticed the little down arrow next to the poster's username?
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Buttons840 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:12PM (#29180011)
I can't downvote stories, but can downvote comments. Just to clarify. I edited my original comment so perhaps you replied before my edit.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by runevault on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:10PM (#29182234)
No one can downvote stories as far as I know, flag is the downvote at the story level.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by blendergeek on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:57PM (#29179786)
You need a "score" of at least 500 to get to use downvotes.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by lrem on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:13PM (#29180030)
9 years and 2500 karma in, still no downvote button on stories... I believe it is documented somewhere that the button does not exist.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by scrooched_moose on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:55PM (#29179741)
Just for comments though, right?

Stories can only be flagged, which as I understand can lead to bans/losing the privilege if it's abused.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by spurgu on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:57PM (#29179792)
Yes. I think you need 500 karma and it's only for comments.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by pizza234 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:53PM (#29179718)
There's a significant difference - misleading/malicious content.

A fake trailer can for example be spotted by the number of negative votes. If the negative votes concept is gone, using a low number of positive votes as indicator is less effective.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by epolanski on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @07:38PM (#29182994)
And comments can be censored.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bogota on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:53PM (#29179705)
HN does have a downvote button you just don’t have enough reputation to use it yet.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by xg15 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:51PM (#29179684)
To be fair, you can downvote comments here, which is often used effectively. Comments with a high dislike count are even specifically highlighted.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by FridayoLeary on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:12PM (#29180876)
i don't know. The more i look at hn the more i appreciate the thought that went into it. Stories are far more black and white- either they violate the guidelines or not. The only thing a downvote would do is to make the story float all over the front page as there is an inevitable vote war. I would even say that most users don't like any given news story, which would lead to the situation that everything would get downvoted into oblivion. Comments OTOH lend themselves far more to moderation by downvotes. Remember we still get the "nuclear option" of flagging a submission.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by sytelus on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:00PM (#29179827)
It is horrible, you just don’t know it it. There is always people like dang dedicating his life to fight all the spam. Look at “new” page and see how many dead links are being submitted each hour.

When you put dislike button, you are adding a degree of freedom in expressing an intent for the user. It is upto you, how you use this information. Most systems fail in this task and then they just remove the degree of freedom as their solution.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by DoreenMichele on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:03PM (#29179878)
Nobody goes there anymore. It's too crowded.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by curtis3389 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:51PM (#29179685)
Hacker News has a downvote button, but you need enough karma to unlock it.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Shared404 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:52PM (#29179704)
They were mentioning stories, which afaik has no way to downvote - though I may just have not unlocked that yet!
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by vadfa on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:53PM (#29179719)
Stories can never be downvoted. Only comments can be downvoted.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by dang on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:04PM (#29179898)
I assume this is sarcastic but flags on stories are a significant option.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by jonas21 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @07:29PM (#29182915)
Yeah, and it seems like you'll still be able to flag videos on YouTube too. The change makes YouTube more like HN, which I personally feel is a good thing.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by smsm42 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:03PM (#29181548)
Not too horrible but a bit annoying. Fortunately, HN is not that site.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by TigeriusKirk on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:59PM (#29179820)
It'd be a lot better, actually. Downvotes are social poison.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by jeffbee on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:54PM (#29179736)
It would be MetaFilter, a site with a noticeably higher level of discourse than HN.