News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by runevault on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:39PM (#29177552)
I mostly agree with you, with the caveat of brigading being a very real thing that lowers the information value. But then why show upvotes either because positive brigading is just as damaging to the information as downvote brigades.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by pugets on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:53PM (#29179710)
YT can counter brigades by giving viewers even more statistics about a video. Example: what’s the like to dislike ratio of a video in the past 7, 30, or 90 days, compared to all-time?

Steam (a video game store) does this already. They categorize reviews as either being recent (made in the last 30 days) or all-time. If a game has excellent all-time reviews, but mixed recent reviews, then you can suspect something has recently upset the playerbase.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by eropple on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:47PM (#29180529)
You can't, however, determine if what upset the player base is "the game developer is a woman" or "the game developer is gay" or "a streamer with a toxic following got mad at the game".

It is low signal all the way through, and relegating likes and dislikes to a signal for recommendations is wise.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by pugets on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @07:12PM (#29182750)
I don't want video game recommendations from someone that wants to sell me a video game, because they have a financial incentive to sell me a $60 game that I'll like instead of a $10 game that I'll love. No, I would much rather trust the opinions of people who have bought and played the game. I want to know if 99%, or 90%, or 65% of players gave it a good recommendation.

Long-time Netflix subscribers might be having déjà vu right now. Old Netflix had a ratings system, and users could filter content by average rating and see the top-rated movies and shows. Netflix later replaced that system with a recommendation engine. Not only does the recommendation engine not get my taste right, but it sure seems to recommend to me a lot of Netflix Originals.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bavell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:28PM (#29181109)
Umm... What? I have never seen any of those things you mentioned on a steam review, ever, in my ~15yrs on the platform.

The steam review graph is a fantastically useful tool for users with a huge SNR and I don't understand why you think otherwise.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by fishtacos on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:57PM (#29181488)
You can probably google more, but here's a prominent example of why you're incorrect with your assumptions:

https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2018-09-25-total-war-rome...

"Total War: Rome 2 has suffered a Steam review bombing run over women characters and a recent update - but it turns out the game is working as intended.

"Creative Assembly's PC strategy game, which came out in 2013, saw hundreds of new negative Steam reviews this week over the frequency with which women generals show up in the game and related claims about historical accuracy."

and another one:

https://www.techspot.com/news/91212-life-strange-true-colors...

"The reason behind the Chinese users' anger is the inclusion of a symbol banned in their country. On the main street of the game's Haven Springs setting is a shop called Treasures of Tibet, which displays a Tibetan flag prominently outside the store."

Valve has come out on more than one occasion to let customers and studios know that they are constantly working to mitigate brigading.

EDIT: While not the norm, as you were alluding, gamer toxicity and brigading can also be relatively mainstream. A popular website among such circles is

https://www.oneangrygamer.net/

Reading the posts and comments can be quite revolting.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bavell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:54PM (#29182088)
Neither of the articles claim what you're claiming though ("game dev is a woman/gay", etc). What assumption have I made that you think is incorrect? I just made an observation that in my extensive history on the platform I've never encountered what you stated.

Really though, my main point I actually care about making is that the steam review system is far superior to a simple like/dislike system which YT implements.

At the bottom of your first article:

> Meanwhile, Total War: Rome 2 has an "overwhelmingly negative" recent reviews rating, with a "mostly positive" overall rating.

Ahh, so it seems the steam rating system is working! Even though these games got "brigaded", users are still able to see the overall and historical ratings to get a better picture of what's going on.

This actually lets you see the rating before the brigade started. And if the game is actually good, the brigaded ratings will amount to a blip amongst the other reviews. Case in point, here is the current steam page for R:TW2, with "very positive " overall rating: https://store.steampowered.com/app/214950/Total_War_ROME_II_...

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by fishtacos on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:38PM (#29182461)
"Neither of the articles claim what you're claiming though ("game dev is a woman/gay", etc). What assumption have I made that you think is incorrect? I just made an observation that in my extensive history on the platform I've never encountered what you stated."

-- Anecdotal evidence doesn't mean that it didn't happen. My personal experience of using steam since its inception (HL2 launch on Steam, 2004), so roughly 17 years, is that I've come across this on a more than a few occasions. I tend to collect digital goods in a hoarding method, so I'm up to over 3700+ games in my library and I check a lot of them out when I can, even if I have no time to really play them anymore. The firs thing I read?

REVIEWS!

As mentioned - this is not the norm, and I agree with your general premise, but please don't dismiss what actually happened and what I witnessed (no, I don't have screenshots because I wasn't documenting it happening in real time when it occurred). The examples I brought up were illustrative of some gamers' groupthink mentality (including oneangrygamer.net, which has in mid-2021 disabled comments because they were ridiculously toxic - misogynistic, sexist, homophobic and racist)

Also - I'm not OP, FYI. I was backing OP's point.

I can't be bothered to respond to the rest of your post, unfortunately, because it comes across as vapidly dismissive.

Look up GamerGate if you'd like more information on brigading and misogynistic groupthink among related sub-communities.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Jensson on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:37PM (#29181236)
You can't vote for a game on steam unless you own it, that makes brigading mostly ineffective.

What you are thinking of is metacritic where anyone can post, it is very prone to brigading, but steam reviews isn't.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by tgittos on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:15PM (#29181672)
Except you can buy it, review and then request an almost unconditional refund.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bavell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:57PM (#29182117)
How many times can you get away with this before steam wises up? My guess is not many. They also have your CC. Makes it a pain for anyone but criminals to successfully brigade en-masse.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by Jensson on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:22PM (#29181750)
Which is a huge hurdle compared to just clicking a button with zero possible consequences.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by scoopertrooper on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:01PM (#29178898)
Seems like a middle ground solution might be to restrict the display of downvotes to videos that meet a certain viewership threshold. That way organic voting would make brigading more difficult.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by a_f on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:53PM (#29179722)
Steam has a useful chart which shows the votes/reviews over time with the ability to filter by language, purchase type, play time etc. Youtube could implement something similar to help shine a light on brigading
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by bavell on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @04:22PM (#29181026)
The steam review graph is brilliant and an example of getting it right. YT seems to have succumbed to it's incumbent position in the market and has stopped innovating - it now seeks only to maintain the status quo and apparently thinks dislikes are a threat to that.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by dcow on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:42PM (#29177600)
Exactly. Seems like you could just throttle votes or abstract the metric to smooth out spikes and account for brigading in either direction...
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by prions on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:48PM (#29177704)
So you'd rather they manipulate the data and potentially mislead users? Sounds like a slippery slope to me \s
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by fuckcensorship on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:54PM (#29178773)
YouTube has been manipulating like/dislike data for the White House for months now [1].

[1]: https://81m.org/

Archive: https://web.archive.org/web/20211023061808/https://81m.org/

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by mike_d on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:56PM (#29179769)
It looks like the creator is counting any decrease in dislikes over time as manipulation, without a firm understanding of how large scale systems work.

Say for example I used a batch of 100 HN accounts to mass downvote your comment. After a while an hourly job runs that looks at all those votes in aggregate and determines they were coordinated (for simplicity sake they all came from the same IP) and removes them. You'd see a large shift in the net score of your comment all of the sudden. This isn't HN manipulating anything, it is them doing their job to prevent abuse on the platform.

[dead]
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by malwarebytess on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:09PM (#29182225)
Oh honey.

Or, you know, some of those votes are fraudulent (bots, dupe accounts, tactical voting, etc) and they're being removed?

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by lalaland1125 on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @06:38PM (#29182468)
What would even be the point of faking the dislike/like counts? Does anyone actually look at them compared to polls?
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by jakear on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:42PM (#29179530)
It's interesting data, but the obvious response from YouTube would be "we run sophisticated click fraud detection algorithms and periodically remove interactions determined to be from fraudulent accounts; given the current political climate White House videos attract more of these types of fraud than other videos on our platform and thus the effect is more pronounced on their videos". The numbers in question are small enough (~1k missing interactions) that it doesn't seem totally unreasonable.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by dcow on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @12:53PM (#29177774)
No I'd rather have a know established system/metric in place that amortizes brigading so as to diffuse the effects of mob attacks on internet content.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by csee on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @01:10PM (#29178033)
I don't even buy YouTube's claim that "brigading" or "dislike attacks" is a real thing or a problem. If they have a minimum number of minutes that a video needs to be watched before a vote is counted, then that vote is legitimate, full stop. YouTube are simply unhappy about which videos users dislike, whether it's the White House's videos, important brands, or YT's own videos.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by davorak on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:04PM (#29181568)
> If they have a minimum number of minutes that a video needs to be watched before a vote is counted

I think that unintentionally removes down votes on obviously bad videos that people do not waste much time watching.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by JoshTriplett on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:51PM (#29182058)
Agreed. Sometimes you know within a couple of seconds that a video isn't what the title and thumbnail claims it is, and that's a great reason to hit "dislike".

For instance, an hour-long video claiming to be what you're looking for, but actually consisting of a still image and a URL to a scam/spam site.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by JoshTriplett on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @05:49PM (#29182036)
> I don't even buy YouTube's claim that "brigading" or "dislike attacks" is a real thing or a problem. If they have a minimum number of minutes that a video needs to be watched before a vote is counted, then that vote is legitimate, full stop.

I've seen dislike attacks happen. And if it takes a non-trivial procedure to make them count, people will document that procedure. For instance, hypothetically:

"Alright everybody, here's the link. Remember, mute the tab right away but don't mute the video itself; wait 2 minutes (the timer that starts when you click the link will go green to let you know), then click the dislike button."

I've seen much more complex instructions offered as part of gaming a poll, as well as sites built to help semi-automate or simplify the process.

The key distinction that would be useful for YouTube to measure: did you encounter the video and then dislike it, or did you visit a video you were referred to for the sole purpose of disliking it? I don't think hiding dislike counts serves that purpose, though.

Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by dcow on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @02:02PM (#29178932)
I like that solution even more.
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by lrem on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:23PM (#29180177)
Isn't that what Reddit is doing to quite some success?
Re:Making the dislike count private across YouTube by smaryjerry on Wednesday November 10, 2021 @03:21PM (#29180144)
Spikes don’t really mean anything. If a video ‘goes viral’ it will all of a sudden get a lot of responses. And sometimes those will all be bad if it’s a bad video or unpopular opinion. Interpreting that as bot voting or manipulation should have nothing to do with spikes.