A lot of people here are saying this is incredibly common which is frankly pretty surprising to me. Does it really happen through shell LLCs?
I am definitely aware of execs prioritizing startups they've invested in, which is... not a great look.
But this seems to be a different thing. Kail wasn't an investor. He explicitly drafted agreements that paid him a fraction of the money flowing from Netflix. This seems almost like embezzlement to me (not a lawyer! just a guy using words he has heard!):
> Two days before Unix Mercenary was registered, Kail signed a Sales Representative Agreement to receive payments from Netenrich, Inc. amounting to 12% of the billings from Netenrich, Inc. to Netflix for its contract providing staffing and IT services to Netflix. Later in 2012, Kail began to receive 15% of all billing payments that VistaraIT, LLC, a wholly owned company of Netenrich, received from Netflix. From 2012 to 2014, Netenrich, Inc. paid Unix Mercenary approximately $269,986, and VistaraIT, LLC paid Unix Mercenary approximately $177,863. The payments stopped in mid-2014, after Kail left Netflix.
Of course that would not help a company while it is happening, we only check a very small fraction of all offerings. In a perfect world an accountant would catch this.
One case I ran into was very much like this one: a whole bunch of hardware was sold at above sticker price, on top of that much more hardware was sold than what the business could reasonably expect to be using. The a-technical management never caught on to this until we showed up, the fall out from that case was fairly spectacular.
Just to add a few points:
- This is much easier to do in Europe where entities are more public.
- I regularly see (probably 1 out of 20 deals) companies where there is some level of a conflict of interest between the owners/management and a 3rd party. The most typical one is where the CTO of a small ($3M revenue) software company also owns the outsourced dev group in India. The implications are numerous here.
An undisclosed conflict of interest is always a problem.
Can you help me understand why this is? If a known conflict of interest may or may not be a problem for the downside party why does that change if the conflict is unknown?
I can see how it can become a problem, and how the downside party is at a disadvantage but I’m not understanding why this is always a problem.
A conflict of interest is not necessarily a problem as long as the conflict is disclosed so that dealings around that conflict can be scrutinized.
But if you never disclose it, then problem or not, no one will know.
Example where this went bad:
- "Acme Co." has an offshore/outsourced dev group in India called "Offshore Co.". Offshore does all of their software development, maintenance, infrastructure, etc.
- CTO who is employed by Acme wholly owns Offshore Co.
- PE Group ("PEG") buys Acme Co. and takes a controlling interest
- PEG decides Acme should do something strategic.
- CTO disagrees with strategic direction
- CTO operates Offshore Co and decides to hold the company hostage and directs his resources to stop maintaining the code, infrastructure, etc. anymore unless they do what the CTO says
PEG/Acme could simply stop paying Offshore/CTO but since they don't know how the code works, etc. they basically don't have a choice.
There really isn't any "public" info about tech DDs that I could share. The tech DD world is growing likely crazy so if you have a business and tech mind, you'll likely find companies hiring for roles, even if you don't have specific experience.
These are two books that might help you provide perspective on M&A/PE that you would learn if you got into DD:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/1973918927/?coliid=IOSLH6YRD3CP6&c...
https://www.amazon.com/HBR-Guide-Buying-Small-Business-ebook...
For reference - I've done 250+ DDs myself and my firm has done over 500 over the last 6 years.
Assuming the receiver uses a proper offshore construct to accept the payment, this would go by unnoticed by your DD?
But most interesting: What is your best guess - Your partner says you find “a hand full” from a few hundred - how many of these cases do you miss because the recipients use a not easy traceable proxy entity to collect the payment?
Do you try to uncover such hidden actions, if yes, how?
Also, is there a good reason why someone would not use a offshore proxy/holding?
That's the 'million dollar question', and in some cases substantially more than one million. I think the reason a good number of these people get caught is (1) things like the Panama papers and other leaks like that have made it harder to do this, and have also brought the not insubstantial resources of the authorities to review these constructs and (2) most people never expect that during DD such a thing would be checked.
It's typically quite a surprise when we start asking about the activities of companies that the other party believes are well hidden.
There are some criminal service industry leaks that are public, or have been public, yet it doesn’t appear more than a few individual have the motivation to follow trough in combing them. At least this is true for groups who would publish on their findings.
Also, if you do tech DD - most techies are happy to share details that unknowingly might expose because they tend to be less business savvy. CEO/CFO's on the other hand...
Managed to BS the second team way better after that — and they were eager enough to have a share of the rocket ship at all cost.
Guess they weren‘t too happy losing most if their series B invest.
https://jacquesmattheij.com/due-diligence-survival-guide/
and part II:
https://jacquesmattheij.com/due-diligence-survival-guide-par...
Note that these articles are now about a decade old, I probably should update them to reflect the experience gained since then and changes to the state of the art in tech.
Kail's own sentencing memorandum points out that OpenDNS rewarded a different Netflix employee with stock options. Also, presumably, super illegal.
Companies that I’ve worked for and companies that I’ve advised or invested in have never had a problem with me making an intro under such terms (and sometimes we bought, sometimes we didn’t, but in either case, I was out of it after the intro; the very most an advised company would get is a better/more truthful explanation of why we decided not to buy.).
It is illegal when they are tied together as a quid pro quo, and further, when it is undisclosed. In every case any company I ran has ever done this, we fully expected the other party to disclose the conflict of interest to their company before becoming an advisor. Of course we have no way of confirming this, but this is also why none of the startups themselves were charged here.
Second hand, an acquaintance worked on a tobacco account where they were spending government-mandated anti-smoking funds on a digital marketing campaign and they were asked to deliberate overbill and churn on work without delivering. People went to jail.
Third handed story because I knew some folks who used this software, a vendor once extracted about 1000% of their contract price in kickbacks building HR software for the city of new york: https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/29/nyregion/three-men-senten...
Thank you for your honesty and self-awareness. This framing also amused me.
But neither of those are quite right:
1) the same tax deductions are available on your normal schedule C
2) while acting on behalf of your LLC you’re still personally liable for your actions (let alone your illegal schemes).
If you’re going to try to avoid it by paying no salary and all distributions for work that you personally did, you’ll likely fall afoul of the “reasonable salary” test, designed to prevent exactly this.
I'm not a tax accountant or a lawyer, just happen to run my own consulting through an S-Corp. I still pay myself around half of the net revenue the S-Corp brings in as a regular employee, and that portion is taxed under FICA.
1) The benefit only applies to profits above "a reasonable salary". You need to determine and potentially later defend what you chose as a "reasonable salary".
2) Once you have over ~150K income (including your day job's salary and LLC profit), social security taxes phase out so most of the benefit is gone (just the medicare portion remains), unless you have a HUGE LLC profit.
3) There's overhead in filing taxes on an s-corp.
All this probably makes sense if you have >$100K LLC profits and no other big income source, or maybe if you have >$500K LLC profits regardless. You'll def want an accountant. Companies like Collective.com exist to make it easier to go the s-corp route if you choose to go that way. But it is complicated for some minor savings.
Your business also gets tax breaks you don't, namely on (paying for your) health care, (paying for your) retirement savings, depreciating assets, (paying for your) salaries, food, travel, lodging, equipment, and services. Further, the cap on business 401k accounts is way, way higher [1]. The ability to sock away even more pre-tax money in a retirement account, and deduct your health insurance from your taxes is insane.
The biggest downsides, at least for me, have been the infra to get it all going. I have an accountant, a lawyer, a financial planner, and an army of online services that help me stay legal and paid up. That said, I'm still coming out ahead (e.g. they don't cost $24k/yr and you guessed it, startup costs are tax deductible), so the gains are there.
(I think paying taxes is patriotic, but I don't think it's reasonable to pay taxes on $200k of income for one year, and then only make $60k of income the next year. I also don't think it's reasonable for me to pay ~40% of my income in taxes while big corporations and the rich pay very little so....)
[1]: https://www.fidelity.com/learning-center/personal-finance/re...
Most of the other things you list are available to sole proprietors too: "(paying for your) retirement savings, depreciating assets, (paying for your) salaries, food, travel, lodging, equipment, and services"
I'm not sure about health care, are you sure there's no way to deduct it as a sole proprietor?
"forming an LLC will not protect you against personal liability for your own negligence, malpractice, or other personal wrongdoing that you commit related to your business"
from https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/limited-liability-pr...
My understanding is it won't help you if you're just consulting by yourself, because everything is your own action.
Obviously, an LLC cannot shield you from criminal liability.
(disclaimer: I work for Stripe which had a product that works like that, but not anywhere near that team)
> generally courts have a strong presumption against piercing the corporate veil, and will only do so if there has been serious misconduct. Courts understand the benefits of limited liability... As such, courts typically require corporations to engage in fairly egregious actions in order to justify piercing the corporate veil
LLCs still protect personal assets in the general case.
"forming an LLC will not protect you against personal liability for your own negligence, malpractice, or other personal wrongdoing that you commit related to your business"
from https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/limited-liability-pr...
I have a highly paid accountant who says otherwise. Care to elaborate?
Embezzlement: Misappropriation of funds Fraud (in the inducement): (Specifically wire/mail fraud when talking about contracts): Misrepresentation of contractual terms to induce entering into a contract. (Here the misrepresentation is the amount of money that the vendor was going to charge netflix since technically his kickback would've reduced the expenses to Netflix)
As an intern at one place I had to spend hours studying and then taking a test to ensure I complied with anti-bribery rules. I’m sure this didn’t just come up because one person did something bad.
Also the fact that he can fundamentally change what a user posts and then choose whether or not to disclose it in comment section is a flaw.
Moderator time is more precious than your time, if you feel that you've been wronged then you could have just said what you thought was wrong rather than to demand a fix to your liking. This is further amplified by the fact that you have a major stake in the property whose link you posted here. Your website, your rules, HN -> HN's rules.
- "instead of the way it already worked when you joined." Just because it worked this way does not mean it is right.
- "HN -> HN's rules." Yes, Captain Obvious. this does not mean their rules make sense and certainly does not mean a user voicing an opinion on how the rules should be changed is entitled.
it would be nicer from a transparency perspective to make these kinds of changes easily auditable by adding an "edited by" in the full page or a dedicated audit log. it would strike a balance between letting moderators improve the community while improving transparency at the system level.
Allowing people to editorialize headlines and pick biased sources skews the discussion.
Since we want to limit multiple similar discussion threads but allow everyone to continue talking, this is a good compromise.
Giving too much credit to a biased source or blogspam post goes too far in the direction of skewing the discussion IMHO.
Also the link or headline might change multiple times. Best to just keep it simple.
"super labor intensive to boot" - it should be in the CMS code to show a flag if "edited".
Wow! I was evaluating SumoLogic and Splunk in Netflix back then. Neither of them was suitable for our use cases. We ended up rolling out our own solutions. As far as I recall, the eng org didn't use Splunk or SumoLogic. Kail headed the IT department, though. Maybe they used SumoLogic.
All this for 500k? Seems like a lot of trouble for the equivalent of a year as a C-Level.
It is possible that your perceptions of how easy it is to extract millions-scale dollars from the business world is skewed. Google suggests 1.7M is the median lifetime earnings in the US, 2.7 is the average. Getting that in a handful of deals could tempt all sorts of people.
I understand the sentiment that "it takes two", but I'm of the opinion that it's the one accepting bribes that is the root cause of the problem.
It is the people accepting bribes who are taking from their company, university, or government and creating a pay to play market.
Then it’s optimal to offer bribes indiscriminately, just to turn around and report them for accepting.
I was at Yahoo around the time this was revealed, and I don't think he was fired immediately after Netflix making the claims public. He was still CISO/CIO/some shit and used to participate in mailing lists, iirc.
I wonder how much he got in severance from yahoo, to round out the list of chutzpah-s
If he was in the lower class then this post would not exist. He's be in jail and it would all be forfeit before due process.
Or maybe he was just that good about hiding it, IE only soliciting via the business entity which then took a “commission”?
With regard to kickbacks, I have no idea how it was 'sold' to the startup; for all I know it was sold as a separate entity that Netflix buys from which they have premade contracts for, etc. I wasn't there, but I wouldn't assume Sumo or Netskope are running around offering people bribes. My guess is it went the other way.
Generally, the company will have a limit (somewhere in the $25-$50 range) on gifts you could give or receive without prior authorization. So maybe I can take you to a bar or coffee shop and get you a drink or two while we talk. But not a dinner at a high end restaurant, or a sporting event or a vacation in Hawaii, because the risk of being corrupted (on the receiving end) or reputational risk from being seen as corrupt, was too great.
This is particularly potent issue for American companies because of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. The FCPA means that US companies (and their subsidiaries, contractors, etc.) have to draw these sorts of lines over the entire world, or be subject to heavy penalties, even in countries where it might be more common and legal.
One area that's more fuzzy is free passes to user events, i.e., a DreamForce or Oracle World. We clear these per our process and are fine to accept them because we were going to spend money on sending someone anyway. We saved the company money. Also: it was never indirect between individuals, it was company to company.
Edit: The 2021 angle is that he was sentenced today. You would know that from OP's original article, but not the newer DOJ link.
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-11-26/netflix-c...
Being able to detect whether a given employee has taken a bribe from a vendor might trip over SOX-relevant things incidentally but not directly. For example, you might need to certify that every employee has taken anti-bribery training every year, and that's your preventative mechanism so at least employees know what is permissible and what the consequences are.
Unless you think nobody is going to look at this and go “these are consequences that could apply to me”?
SOX compliance builds a paper trail so crimes like this are recorded and uncovered.
https://www.justice.gov/usao-ndca/pr/former-netflix-executiv...
Some fun details:
Kail did his criming through a shell LLC he set up called "Unix Mercenary".
He took between 10-15% of the total billings for each of the companies he hooked up with this scheme. None of those companies were charged (more's the pity).
They got him on mail fraud, wire fraud, honest services fraud, and money laundering. The victim of the fraud was, of course, Netflix itself.
Additional fun facts from PACER:
He's seeking to exclude his shares in Sumo Logic and Netskope from forfeiture, arguing that they were largely the result of his own hard work, which takes some serious chutzpah.
All of this apparently happened back in 2014 (the conviction is recent). If you're wondering what Netflix thought of all this, Kail apparently left Netflix for a job at Yahoo, from which he was fired after Netflix found out about his scheme and told Yahoo.
Kail's sentencing memorandum is a fun read (again: chutzpah). For instance, this gem:
Further, though Mr. Kail complained of problems with Sumologic (as one would see with any new startup), the product itself was “useful,” according to Ashi Sheth. (R.T. Vol. 8, p. 1670-71). As described below, at the time, Sumologic saved Netflix from paying for a far more expensive and inferior product called Splunk.