Moderator time is more precious than your time, if you feel that you've been wronged then you could have just said what you thought was wrong rather than to demand a fix to your liking. This is further amplified by the fact that you have a major stake in the property whose link you posted here. Your website, your rules, HN -> HN's rules.
- "instead of the way it already worked when you joined." Just because it worked this way does not mean it is right.
- "HN -> HN's rules." Yes, Captain Obvious. this does not mean their rules make sense and certainly does not mean a user voicing an opinion on how the rules should be changed is entitled.
it would be nicer from a transparency perspective to make these kinds of changes easily auditable by adding an "edited by" in the full page or a dedicated audit log. it would strike a balance between letting moderators improve the community while improving transparency at the system level.
Allowing people to editorialize headlines and pick biased sources skews the discussion.
Since we want to limit multiple similar discussion threads but allow everyone to continue talking, this is a good compromise.
Giving too much credit to a biased source or blogspam post goes too far in the direction of skewing the discussion IMHO.
Also the link or headline might change multiple times. Best to just keep it simple.
"super labor intensive to boot" - it should be in the CMS code to show a flag if "edited".
Also the fact that he can fundamentally change what a user posts and then choose whether or not to disclose it in comment section is a flaw.