News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by nickjj on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:19AM (#27660886)
I know the post is about Windows 11 but I installed Windows 10 for someone on a laptop about 2 months ago and it had the most crazy dark pattern I've ever seen to be able to proceed past the installation screen without a Microsoft account.

Short of not connecting to the internet first the only way I saw where it was possible to create an offline account was to first attempt to sign in using an incorrect password with a hotmail account. It was only after failing that where an option appeared to create a local account.

It doesn't stop there too. Now once in a while when they turn the machine on and reach the login screen, there's a big banner that says something along the lines of "Hey, you're missing out on very important features and are less secure by not registering an account with Microsoft..." with a call to action to link a MS account. This also hides the login screen by default and the only way to ignore that and get to the login screen is to click somewhere in the empty space but for a non-technical user this isn't intuitive. They always try to click the only thing that looks clickable. It's so shady.

Sadly I had to make a MS account for them in the end to unlock Windows "S" mode into a regular version of Windows 10 Home so I could install an app that wasn't in the app store on their machine. The only way to do that was to make a MS account for the Microsoft Store but fortunately you can still login to Windows itself with the offline account. It never ends.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by alpaca128 on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:31AM (#27661006)
Microsoft really is one of the worst examples in the dark pattern department that I've ever seen.

Same with their email service, where you can register an account without issues and after a few weeks of use I was presented with an unskippable input field for my phone number. Don't want to give MS your phone number? Too bad, better hope you don't need those emails anymore.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by nayuki on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:47AM (#27661912)
This makes Microsoft's purchase of LinkedIn a good fit as another master of dark patterns.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gentleman11 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:51AM (#27662730)
LinkedIn is so full of dark patterns that there is barely room for the site any more. I keep missing recruiter messages because my LinkedIn email just goes to spam because they send so much junk to try and boost engagement. It’s like being stuck in a room with a car salesperson. I’m thinking of deleting it
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by sm4rk0 on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:14PM (#27664556)
I've deleted my LinkedIn account the same day I found my data and trust were sold out to MS without my consent. And I don't feel I'm missing anything.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by naikrovek on Monday June 28, 2021 @02:19PM (#27665545)
you may be shocked to learn that your consent is not required in order for one company to buy another.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by sm4rk0 on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @05:51AM (#27673808)
I just don't like the fact that most people find it approprate to be treated as goods on sale and the only choice we have is "take it or leave it".
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by hda2 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:11PM (#27670892)
For transferring his data, it should be. It's his data not theirs to leak.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by naikrovek on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @03:14PM (#27692399)
in an ideal world, yes, and we do not live in an ideal world, unfortunately.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by milkytron on Monday June 28, 2021 @02:12PM (#27665422)
I deleted mine after their class action lawsuit.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by developer93 on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:05PM (#27663650)
I have a separate email for job hunting which LinkedIn and Xing etc go to, and it only gets opened when I need a new job
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by username90 on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:25PM (#27663919)
Linkedin used to ask you to pay them to view public profiles if you were logged in, but if you logged out you could see the profile just fine since it was public. And there was no limit to that either, didn't need to get there from google etc. Not sure if they still do that.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by nix23 on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:20AM (#27661576)
I really don't get it. Microsoft has an OS and a Cloud (Azure and Windows) and make pretty much good money with it, but both have a great need for privacy. I really don't get what Microsoft is thinking.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by toyg on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:39AM (#27661806)
Microsoft is thinking that Apple somehow manages to have billions of people creating "iTunes" accounts, and they don't, and what the hell, John, why don't WE get all that sweet data and them big account numbers, can't we do what they do? Sure, Bob, but some people will get upse--Screw them, John! what they gonna do, move to Apple and pay more get the same treatment? Just fix the damn process, John, I want those account numbers up 300% by Q3.

...Alright Bob, you're the boss.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by agloeregrets on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:16AM (#27662282)
....actually you do not need an iCloud account to use a mac or iPhone, but on iPhone you do need an iCloud account to download apps. On mac you can setup and use the machine entirely offline forever.

The same irony goes for the Windows 11 CPU support, the next version of macOS supports machines twice as old as Windows 11 supports. Microsoft embraces alt payment methods in the store and supports regulation, Apple doesn't and is the monopoly. The world is upside down in such strange ways in 2021.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by toyg on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:31AM (#27662475)
> you do not need an iCloud account to use a mac or iPhone

... but you are similarly prompted and dark-patterned to create one anyway. It is just marginally easier to skip the choice, if you don't mind being nagged or diving into the buried option you need to switch it all off. And without an account, loads of features like family Screen Time don't even work.

Apple paved the way, while MS was being cautious because of the browser-related legal challenges. They made all this socially acceptable, so at one point the guys in Redmond rightly went "why can't we do the same?" and here we are.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by agloeregrets on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:50AM (#27663448)
Microsoft started the majority of this back in Windows 8 and made it a dark pattern to skip in 10, this isn't really an Apple thing. The whole industry moved this way.

Windows 11 breaks the bar here and requires internet now. It's not a dark pattern or skippable like you are implying here and it's not on remotely the same level as Apple or Google. Microsoft clearly is being the worst of anyone here.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by toyg on Monday June 28, 2021 @02:13PM (#27665438)
Windows 8 was a reaction to the iPhone wave in everything, from the UI to this.

> it's not on remotely the same level as Apple or Google

Oh, it absolutely is. "The healthier one is a leper", as they (used to) say where I'm from .

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gentleman11 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:54AM (#27662772)
They aren’t afraid of those legal issues any more. They basically say Firefox is malware if you try to install it and you have to click that you are okay with insecure software to continue
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by mavhc on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:44AM (#27661865)
They're thinking they need to make it 1 click to buy things from Microsoft
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by CSMastermind on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:48AM (#27661924)
In the case of requiring a phone number for emails it's to try and cut down on spam / bots abusing their service.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gabereiser on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:08AM (#27662173)
you would think, but that's not the case. It's used to correlate data sharing between data brokerages. Facebook has your number, Twitter has your number, Microsoft has your number. What better FK to link all this data together than that? Now Microsoft knows what you searched for. Twitter knows what you bought on Amazon. Facebook knows who you hung out with. It's all about the data brokerages.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by judge2020 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:14AM (#27662248)
Obviously it can be for more than one purpose. See spam reports from [email protected] with phone number $x? Disable sending email for all accounts with that phone number. They've already signed up for three accounts this month with that number? Stop them from making any more without paying for a new number.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gabereiser on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:25AM (#27662388)
I mean, sure, it can be used this way. Often is for email deduplication of accounts. It's real strength comes from 3rd party data brokers and correlating various data profiles to you, the consumer.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gigel82 on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:11PM (#27663722)
I'd be very surprised if these companies actually share the private data with each-other (or any external party for that matter). I worked at a FAANG and they take private data handling very seriously (you can't even access it internally without a very involved approval process and always partially).
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gabereiser on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:46PM (#27664211)
They don’t share it directly with each other, it’s through data brokers. Oracle being the biggest (here in the states) along with Experian, equifax, etc. I’m not talking about platform specific data. I’m talking about browser history, cookies, transactional, and the like. I know for a fact that one FAANG uses your browsers history to run adtech against it to show you relevant ads related to a previous search. Just because you couldn’t access it, doesn’t mean someone else wasn’t.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by reaperducer on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:44PM (#27664969)
I'd be very surprised if these companies actually share the private data with each-other (or any external party for that matter).

They share it with "trusted partners." Which means data brokers. It's like money laundering, but for information. Look for the word "partners" in the small text of anything you commit to from signing up for e-mail to installing software to buying a car.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by sys_64738 on Monday June 28, 2021 @03:21PM (#27666498)
They share salary information with data brokers.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by no_time on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:37PM (#27664867)
>Microsoft really is one of the worst examples in the dark pattern department that I've ever seen.

It's insane. Every I reinstall windows and try to download Firefox, the number of times Microsoft pleads to continue using Edge is increasing.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by naikrovek on Monday June 28, 2021 @02:17PM (#27665505)
it's not really a dark pattern if it's not trying to trick you.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by alpaca128 on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @05:35AM (#27673693)
It literally injects a "are you really, definitely sure you want to switch away from Edge?" kind of entry in the top search results when you use the preinstalled Edge to look up another browser. That is absolutely a dark pattern in my book, of the manipulative and desperate kind. Not to mention the constant struggle to (re)set your favorite browser as default where Windows fights you at every corner in pretty much the most extreme way that Microsoft can hope to get away with unless they want to risk sanctions from the EU.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by GuB-42 on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:41AM (#27661117)
Google does that too.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by probably_wrong on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:17AM (#27661543)
That's how I lost my GMail account - they demanded a telephone number so I relented and gave them mine, but they refuse to accept it. They won't take my work number either.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by saul_goodman on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:46AM (#27662672)
Phone numbers have become the new SSN tied to your physical identity. In most cases you have provide extremely detailed personal info to get a working phone number. There are probably still some ways crafty folks can get a working phone number without it being tied to your physical identity, but you must go way out of your way to do so.

Privacy and freedom of speech are dead, long live the constitution.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by pmoriarty on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:33PM (#27664036)
The saddest thing is that many HN readers (and the tech community in general) have been instrumental in privacy's demise.

Despite paying lip service to privacy, many people here still work on privacy-eroding companies and services.

How many people here work Facebook, Google, Microsoft, or LinkedIn, Palantir, etc... (not to mention less well-known names that still erode privacy).. probably a lot.

Many founders (another group heavily represented on HN) are just after their pot of gold at the end of the IPO, and will gleefully walk over as many users' backs as it takes.

In some ways worse, though, are the people who are intimately familiar with technology, and who are enabling the people at the top. These people all have a choice of who to work for and what to do. No one's holding a gun to their head making them work on tracking and spyware and user-disempowerment, and yet they do.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by john2010 on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:06PM (#27664459)
you are absolutely right. Even a google employee uses lineageos to avoid tracking but I am sure they deliver the code to millions of innocent...

https://libredd.it/r/LineageOS/comments/nnccvr/google_locati...

https://www.azmirror.com/2021/05/24/newly-unredacted-documen...

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by wyldfire on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:54AM (#27662778)
It's frustrating for sure but the reason that they want a phone number is because it's an excellent key to join lots of independent records about you. The companies who ask for your phone number don't care if the phone company knows where you live. They don't even need to ask the phone company, all they have to do is join up with a vendor who you did disclose your address to.

You can at least do yourself a mild favor and don't tell your phone number to all those brick n mortar companies who ask for it. "we'll never call you" -- of course they don't, they just want your individual identity to track you.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by dolmen on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:18PM (#27663818)
It's at least an excellent key that they can provide to country authorities if they request one.

That's also an excellent way to ensure the user juridiction based on the IP address and phone number country code for 99% of users.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by at-fates-hands on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:05AM (#27662885)
I've tried several privacy apps where you can set up phone numbers not attached to your identity and google refused to let me use any of them.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by r00fus on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:52AM (#27663467)
What I did: create a Google voice number on my google account, then used that GV# as my Gmail account.

It's an ouroboros of Google.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by maskedinvader on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:07PM (#27663656)
Thats a bad idea I think, if you get locked out of your gmail account, you might not be able to get a reset code on your GV number either.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by r00fus on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:17PM (#27663802)
Been locked out several times and I could always get by with my backup email and/or providing account details. They never sent anything to my phone.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by dzdt on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:54AM (#27661298)
Twitter also. You can create an account without a phone number but in about 2 weeks it is locked unless you supply and verify one.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by SketchySeaBeast on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:10AM (#27661464)
I got my account reported and locked on twitter and they would only unlock it if I supplied my phone number. Now I have no twitter and am honestly happier for it.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by croes on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:43AM (#27661848)
My Twitter account got locked in about a minute.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by b0tzzzzzzman on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:00AM (#27662060)
Took about 5 for me.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gentleman11 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:52AM (#27662745)
Took me a day
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by diogenesjunior on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:06AM (#27661416)
Yep. Main reason why I do not use Twitter. I'll stick to HN.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by pansa2 on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:43AM (#27661859)
Facebook does exactly the same.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by Asooka on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:52AM (#27663466)
In my case they accepted a shady Romanian SMS service account. Had to try several until one worked.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by tu7001 on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:25PM (#27664722)
I have twitter without phone number, typing from Poland
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by tinus_hn on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:41AM (#27663325)
Google paved the way for that trick, Gmail does exactly the same.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by r00fus on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:49AM (#27663434)
So is there a way to use Gmail without creating a "Google" account?
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by BeetleB on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:00PM (#27663573)
I believe he is referring to the need to provide a number to continue to access your Gmail account.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by dolmen on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:13PM (#27663750)
And now Gmail does it for the birth date.

After login I have to reload https://mail.google.com to skip the form.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by LightG on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:51AM (#27662738)
Increasingly Google also ... hate it.

Like, look, I don't want or need to give you my phone number, capiche? Try Tinder and get off my case. Thanks.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by grishka on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:02PM (#27663604)
What happens if you use that account with an email client instead?
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gruez on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:52PM (#27664298)
AFAIK many mail providers have disabled password authentication via IMAP/SMTP. They force you to go through oauth flow (ie. opening a webview to log in).
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by raxxorrax on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @05:30AM (#27673662)
IMAP does accept plain text passwords, but this is not a real security threat either because of TLS. I hate all the FUD security blogs that tell you otherwise. This "industry" has become extremely useless and doesn't even give sensible security advice anymore.

Yes, of couse 2FA is theoretically better. Until facebooks leaks half a billion phone numbers + account information. That is a vastly more serious threat.

I don't know a single case where TLS was compromised from an IMAP client. Perhaps if it is 15 years old? I hate this industry so damn much. People should be homeless, not security advisers...

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gruez on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:08AM (#27675947)
>I don't know a single case where TLS was compromised from an IMAP client. Perhaps if it is 15 years old? I hate this industry so damn much. People should be homeless, not security advisers...

You're thinking of the wrong threat model. They're not concerned about passwords being stolen being in transit, but rather using the IMAP endpoint for credential stuffing attempts. An IMAP login attempt contains very little zero metadata, so it's very hard to judge whether it's legitimate or not. With a web login you can get tons of stuff to judge the authenticity of the user, eg. fingerprinting.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by grishka on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @01:00PM (#27678627)
On a related note: people like criticizing Telegram because its encryption is "not industry standard". Except Telegram has existed for 8 years now, and MTProto encryption still hasn't been compromised.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by politelemon on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:18PM (#27664621)
Same with Google. Same with Apple. Each I feel are worse than MS. The other day I tried using an iPad and could not proceed without signing in, and giving over my credit card details. The dark pattern being that it tricks you into thinking that you _can_ proceed without either.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by HeckFeck on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:18AM (#27661552)
It is a shame to watch the decline of Windows. There isn't much I can recommend to non-technical users looking affordable computing relatively under their control. Manipulation and user hostility is unacceptable.

Any of these possibilities would be nice:

* The market presents a kinder (and equally-affordable x86) solution and users follow.

* ReactOS lurches leaps and bounds ahead.

* Microsoft realises this trajectory is wrong and rows back.

* Everyone wakes up and realises that Stallman was right.

For the foreseeable, none are likely. What we really need is something to go horribly wrong that demonstrates practically why remote control and data collection of your own system is a bad idea. That will be the only way the point is driven home for the passive masses, unfortunately.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by nickjj on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:52AM (#27662740)
Running native Linux for non-technical users ends up being a great move as long as the programs they want to run work on it. For example imagine a retired non-technical person who occasionally trades stocks. Even major trading platforms like Interactive Brokers have native Linux clients.

Non-technical users want a stable system that doesn't constantly change. Windows loves to hit you with popup notices or UI changes where if you take the "ok" route things about your system change, or you accidentally click a notification that comes up and suddenly your browser is changed or worse. They also don't want to turn on their machine and have to wait 30 minutes for an "important update". They just want to turn their machine on and have it be exactly how it was yesterday.

A non-technical person I know thought he was hacked and wanted to buy a new computer because a shortcut icon was moved from his desktop to his recycle bin and he thought someone wiped out his computer. Now in Microsoft's defense they didn't delete his shortcut, but that's the type of mindset non-technical folks have. The slightest change is a catastrophic event.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:09AM (#27662927)
> Non-technical users want a stable system that doesn't constantly change.

...and you're recommending Linux Desktop for that? An operating system famous for breaking compatibility with itself every 2 years or so? Not to mention between distros. I mean, I suppose you can just leave them on some arbitrary un-updated version of Ubuntu forever, but the same could be said for Windows 2000.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by nickjj on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:36PM (#27664068)
> I mean, I suppose you can just leave them on some arbitrary un-updated version of Ubuntu forever, but the same could be said for Windows 2000.

Certain programs they run won't work on old operating systems like Windows 7 or 2000 but they work on Windows 10 and Linux. Running an unmaintained old copy of Windows 7 would be pretty bad for someone non-technical because if they decide to ever go-to a questionable site of their choosing, chances are they will get themselves in trouble with a virus / malware.

You can run Xubuntu 20.04 LTS for a few years with unattended updates turned on so they get automated non-UI breaking security patches. Then when it goes EOL upgrade to the next LTS, or even turn on unattended upgrades too with a stipulation that something might change once every few years instead of twice a week. It's a really good environment IMO.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by michaelmrose on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:40PM (#27664119)
Nothing is making you run arch Linux with gnome wayland on your btrfs raid 5 with pipewire sound.

One could have installed mint mate 16 in 2013 and painlessly updated between versions without huge difference between then and now.

Linux isn't a product like windows it's an ecosystem use whatever works for you.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by cosmojg on Monday June 28, 2021 @02:10PM (#27665399)
Lmfao, it's 2021. Stop parroting this tired meme. Linux runs beautifully if you aren't doing anything crazy with it.

I say this as a sysadmin responsible for maintaining a small fleet, the majority of which are Linux boxes. I've wasted far more hours helping end users with OS-level problems on Windows and, to a lesser extent, macOS. This is in spite of the fact that, again, the majority of the machines I manage run Linux, and all of these users are similar in technical capability.

Give it a try yourself. I'm sure a lot has changed since you last used it. Oh, and make sure you pick something that holds your hand a bit like Manjaro, Pop!_OS, Mint, or EndeavourOS.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday June 28, 2021 @02:25PM (#27665628)
I've been using Linux Desktop on and off for 2 decades now, have contributed to open source projects on Linux, have built my own Linux distro, and was once president of a LUG. It is my personal opinion that it isn't a good desktop operating system. You're free to disagree, but don't assume that I have no idea what I'm talking about.

And you might have been slightly more persuasive by not being a condescending ass, but that's asking a lot of a Linux Desktop evangelist in my experience.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by dgan on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:31AM (#27663193)
This is misleading, as you can always turn on security updates, and turn off applications upgrades. I don't even know that's possible on Windows (I guess answer is a loud and clear NO)
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by wrs on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:48AM (#27663421)
For a few years, until that version stops getting security updates. E.g., about three years for Debian. [0]

[0] https://wiki.debian.org/DebianReleases

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by Silhouette on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:10PM (#27663716)
Debian Stable typically gets ~3 years of official security updates, but then in reality the LTS project is excellent and probably gives you two more years, and now there's also the ELTS project that might give you two more beyond that.

Which major commercial OS has a realistic expectation today of getting security updates for so long without being forced to change other parts of your system that you like as they are? Windows did, if you go back to the days when Microsoft published product lifecycle information many years into the future, before 10 deliberately broke that whole model and the stability that came with it.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by wrs on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:24PM (#27663910)
MacOS averages 3-4 years too. My point was just that if you want a user experience that never changes and only gets security updates, Linux isn’t the answer either (as the great-grandparent comment implied). At most, if you luckily sync up with an LTS version, you get a couple more years.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by beagle3 on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:04PM (#27663633)
I just set up Ubuntu 20.04 with Unity which is still there, and it looks exactly the same as the 14.04 it replaced. Might not be there in 22.04, who knows. But even switching to Ubuntu Gnome is less of a difference than the Win7 -> Win8 -> Win10 transition I had to guide some older family members through.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by dolmen on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:26PM (#27663943)
> Ubuntu 20.04 with Unity which is still there, and it looks exactly the same as the 14.04 it replaced

That's not what users aged about 80 think. From direct observation, a print icon moving or a menu bar disappearing are just enough to make them crazy.

I know someone who keeps the old computer from 2008 around because "I prefer how Gimp is organized there".

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by mixmastamyk on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:02PM (#27663603)
Xubuntu hasn't changed substantially, and Ubuntu Mate only a bit in a decade plus.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by wbsss4412 on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:56AM (#27663518)
You can run LTS versions of Ubuntu and receive support for 5 years.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:04PM (#27663627)
Non-server Windows editions, at least before 10, had security updates for almost 10 years. And new software often continues to function on old versions of Windows for far longer.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by wbsss4412 on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:15PM (#27663783)
I wasn’t trying to imply that Ubuntu has longer support than windows, only that it doesn’t constantly make breaking changes. If you want you can use it and update once every five years and have a fairly stable desktop.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:34PM (#27664043)
Sure, if you don't count all the software that no longer has a package in the latest version's repo and therefore is no longer available. Oh and whatever features GNOME decided to remove this time.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by wbsss4412 on Monday June 28, 2021 @04:19PM (#27667443)
I suppose I don’t have enough experience because I stick to the latest LTS.

I agree that the Linux desktop has its shortcomings, but I still feel that it would be a great option for plenty of people who default to windows today. Especially if they spend most of their time in the browser as it is.

I’ve been a happy Ubuntu user for several years now and I’m not a tinkerer or anything, though I am more technical than the group we have been talking about.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by michaelmrose on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:45PM (#27664191)
So don't use gnome and switch to something that isn't abandonware
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday June 28, 2021 @02:30PM (#27665705)
So, deal with things changing all the time. Exactly the thing we were trying to avoid with this exercise.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by michaelmrose on Monday June 28, 2021 @04:30PM (#27667627)
I think in 18 years exactly one piece of software I wished to keep using has died an untimely death and it was impractical to keep using it.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by grishka on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:07PM (#27663663)
In other words: people hate updates. Especially so if those updates don't give them anything new but just move stuff around instead.

That's what everyone working in IT should understand. No, you can't "always push an update". Always treat your every single release like your last one because there will be many people who will stick with that version.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by queuebert on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:10AM (#27662199)
It would also help if decision makers at large organizations would stop forcing everyone into Microsoft products such as Teams, Outlook, etc., when much better alternatives exist.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by sys_64738 on Monday June 28, 2021 @03:26PM (#27666580)
What is a suitable replacement for Teams?
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by bserge on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:23AM (#27662360)
Year of Linux on desktop, it's coming home boys!

I'm joking but secretly hoping it happens.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by Eric_WVGG on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:56AM (#27662798)
I'm over in Mac-land so a bit unclear on the state of things, but it seems like the problem must be marketing by now, right? I can't think of any use cases for mainstream users where Windows is a requirement.

Graphic designers, digital art types, and musicians are all fringe and mostly on Mac anyway. PC gamers are a fringe crowd. Practically all productivity software has migrated to the cloud. Desktop Linux usability seemed to meet the standard of Windows XP and Windows 7 years ago.

Is the problem really that you still have to grapple with graphics drivers on the CLI? Or is it just that Best Buy and CostCo still don't have motivation to put shiny Linux machines on the shelves?

and yeah I know all about the various shady Gates/Ballmer-era OEM deals… I just can't believe that not one OEM has snapped by now.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by kitsunesoba on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:18AM (#27663038)
Linux simply has too many rough edges still exposed to appeal to a lot of less technical users. Even in the best case scenario (super standard desktop with hardware well supported by FOSS drivers), there’s always some odd thing that requires one to pull out the terminal, usually because UI functionality was insufficient or failed to work as expected.

That does not bother me or probably most of us on HN much, but for most people it’s like periodically needing to muck around under the hood of their car. It’s too much, they just want to drive and take the vehicle in to get oil and brake changes every once in a fairly long while. Anything more is tedious overhead.

The situation with proprietary drivers still kinda stinks too. The distros I’ve seen handle it best are Ubuntu with the proprietary drivers control panel and pop!_OS which just sidesteps the issue altogether for Nvidia hardware by shipping an ISO with non-free Nvidia drivers included, but the rest just leave you with a package manager, terminal, and whatever you can scrounge up on the internet. Yeah it’s technically the responsibility of Nvidia, etc to fix that, but it’s negatively impacting adoption nonetheless.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by caeril on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:29PM (#27664780)
> has too many rough edges still exposed to appeal to a lot of less technical users

This is ridiculous. Not only does Ubuntu LTS work just fine for my incredibly non-technical wife and children, but my wife prefers it to Mac OS.

Linux with a basic Gnome desktop has been perfectly usable for well over a DECADE now for non-technical users.

This particular bit of FUD has been wildly inaccurate at least since Fedora Core 3.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by chopin on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:10AM (#27662950)
When I buy a computer, Windows 10 is installed as default. You have to go out of your way to get a computer which hasn't. I think it's as easy as that.

I've setup Linux on all machines I own or maintain, for all users including my wife. The frequency of hickups is not higher than it was with Windows and It's easy to roll back to a known good configuration, much easier than with Windows. I never looked back.

Edited to add: The last machine I bought was a Purism laptop. The first machine which did not have Windows pre-installed.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by anthk on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:45AM (#27663384)
>Is the problem really that you still have to grapple with graphics drivers on the CLI?

Bullshit on distros like Solus OS.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by alasdair_ on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:47PM (#27664224)
>PC gamers are a fringe crowd.

Sure, if 1.5 Billion people are a "fringe crowd"

https://www.extremetech.com/gaming/314009-3-billion-people-w...

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by Eric_WVGG on Monday June 28, 2021 @06:32PM (#27669136)
Wow, never seen those figures before… well forgive my American myopia. I would still describe American PC gamers as “fringe”, but I had thought the Asian market was similarly leaning toward console players, clearly that is incorrect.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by kiawe_fire on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:49AM (#27662719)
Perhaps I’ve just become “one of those people”, but I honestly think if not for the buzz around the M1 from Apple, we would be seeing a lot more activity on the Linux side.

“The year of the Linux desktop” always feels like just a couple of bad big tech decisions (and an absence of good decisions) away.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gentleman11 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:57AM (#27662807)
Linux needs killer app equivalents. Many of the foss versions of windows programs have pretty painful UX or are missing key features (eg, smart select in gimp is really frustrating to use vs photoshop or affinity). Foss really needs to start tempting designers to participate more
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by willtim on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:19AM (#27663041)
It's worse than that. The desktop efforts are heavily fragmented and arguably the leader, RedHat's "Gnome", while quite polished, is actually quite user hostile (e.g. works very differently to anything else, perhaps to dodge patents; and constantly changes/removes popular features). Linux needs to have a standardised "platform" with stable APIs.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by techrat on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:15PM (#27663774)
Good luck getting anyone to agree on anything.

It's why everything is so fragmented to begin with. "Oh, I don't like what X is doing, so I'll fork it and make Y."

If I were in a position where I managed several distros... I could say we could just suck it up and universally use XFCE, but then there's always someone who won't like that and they'll respin a distro to have some other DE instead.

It seems with every decision we end up with another fork.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by michaelmrose on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:58PM (#27664373)
XFCE is honestly a mediocre middle ground between the actual minimalism of a window manager or the better functionality of say kde.

Most fragmentation is actually entirely different software with the same end goal as opposed to actual forks and it's not really clear that the developer of foo would have joined forces with the developer of bar had he not started his own project.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by techrat on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:00PM (#27664402)
Like I said, good luck getting anyone to agree on anything.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gentleman11 on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:40PM (#27664900)
It’s not user hostile, I love gnome. It might slow down if you don’t reboot (could be a hibernation or suspend issue?) but the Ux is great. Windows is a nuisance after using gnome. You do need to install some addons that should be built in
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by willtim on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @11:44AM (#27677541)
I could not find any add-on (that still works) to give me back my tray icons. Not even Apple would take this feature away.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by techrat on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:10PM (#27663707)
The 'desktop' is an outmoded concept anyhow. More is being done on Mobile to the exclusion of the desktop. Who needs a big machine with a monitor when you can do just about everything on a Chromebook or iPad?

As far as Linux on ________, Let's look at where we're at now.

Supercomputer. Linux runs the entire Top 500.

https://itsfoss.com/linux-runs-top-supercomputers/

Severs/Websites. 75% are Linux or variants.

https://w3techs.com/technologies/overview/operating_system

Mobile. 72% is Android alone, which counts for Linux IMNSHO.

https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/worldwide

ChromeOS now exceeds MacOS market share. Apple had already been making (painful) attempts to move away from the Desktop.

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/02/the-worlds-second-mo...

And, of course, there's the Linux Subsystem for Windows.

Linux won. It's over. Windows might be holding onto a majority if you only count desktops, but given even Microsoft has moved towards supporting Linux directly on their own OS... and moving towards Cloud As a Service and hosting, yep, Linux on Azure... Even Microsoft knows that Windows has found itself facing the once unthinkable: support Linux or find yourself increasingly irrelevant. Windows on ARM failed. Twice. Windows Mobile in all of its variants are dead now. Microsoft released an Android device. So given everything that we use today, something that ISN'T running a *ix type kernel is, in fact, the minority.

Microsoft is grasping harder with Windows 11... and in their shortsightedness, they ended up excluding huge chunks of systems that were still being sold even as recently as 3 years ago. It's quite unthinkable to me because the one and ONLY one major killing feature of Windows in general was that you could install it on decade-old hardware. Win10 ran pretty decently on my Phenom II x4 desktop which had 16GB Ram. Why shouldn't it?

And now Win11 is looking to exclude first gen Ryzen.

https://www.extremetech.com/computing/324157-windows-11-may-...

The tighter the grip, the more that will slip in between their fingers...

At this point, it's becoming easier and easier to support Linux... thanks to Proton on Steam, more native binaries (BlackMagic, for example, with DaVinci Resolve), more apps becoming webapps and only needing a web browser. At this point, I think what we're waiting for is for legacy companies like Adobe to shit the bed and render themselves irrelevant. (And boy have they gotten close.)

Yeah. The year of Linux on the Desktop is a meme... but should it actually happen... the concept of 'desktop' won't matter anymore, IMHO.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by michaelmrose on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:00PM (#27664410)
Screen space and input matters especially with complex tasks.

Due to heat and therefore power constraints an ipad shaped device will remain sub par compared to a PC shaped device.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by techrat on Monday June 28, 2021 @03:08PM (#27666308)
External monitors.

Also, laptops.

People have been able to do without full-fledged desktops quite well for a while now.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by michaelmrose on Monday June 28, 2021 @04:21PM (#27667479)
Just wanted to add I agree with nearly everything you said save desktops.

>Who needs a big machine with a monitor when you can do just about everything on a Chromebook or iPad

You did say we didn't need laptops or monitors.

People having been able to do without full fledged desktops doesn't imply the format is either dead or without merit.

It remains the best tool for the job for many many tasks especially if you have a merely average amount of funds or need above average performance.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by elliekelly on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:52AM (#27661972)
Why does Apple make it so difficult/borderline impossible to run MacOS on non-apple computers? Would it cut into their computer sales that significantly? I would imagine most people who want (and can afford) a Mac would still buy one.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by ravenstine on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:16AM (#27662267)
What do they stand to gain in making macOS easy/possible to run on other vendor hardware? That opens them up to headaches that don't bring in revenue. They are in the hardware business, not the OS business. Their OS development is just a necessary evil. Apple wants people to buy their hardware. If the customer wants macOS, they'd be best off buying the one hardware that's designed specifically for macOS. This is unlikely to ever change because it's been Apple's business model from the very beginning, and it's served them well overall.

I'm not saying anyone has to like it, but there's an inherent advantage in not having to support other hardware of varying degrees of quality. Honestly, I'll take that form of vendor lock-in over frequent pointless changes, having advertising shoved in my face, and being forced to have an online account. Perhaps my opinion will change if Apple follows suit (they won't), but for now it was pretty easy to set up my M1 Macbook Air without signing in with an Apple ID.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by neodymiumphish on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:02AM (#27662096)
> Would it cut into their computer sales that significantly?

Is this a real question? Many of the edge cases, both high cost and low, would disappear for Apple.

Additionally, all the tech support will fall on them.

Lastly, any bad user experience (cheap device with crap battery, low quality hardware that doesn't match the software experience, etc) would have a negative effect on them as a brand.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by voakbasda on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:13AM (#27662231)
No, they wouldn’t. My last “Mac” was a PowerComputing clone, because other manufactures were doing hardware better than Apple. Jobs killed the clones, and I became a Linux user that never looked back. Apple maintains their walled garden because they know that their users would quickly realize the grass is greener on the other side of the fence.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by macintux on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:53AM (#27663489)
> Apple maintains their walled garden because they know that their users would quickly realize the grass is greener on the other side of the fence.

I've been on both sides of the fence, worked for a Linux company for a few years, and I'm very happy in the walled garden.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by nine_k on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:21AM (#27663070)
In short, Apple is a hardware company. It sells you electronic devices with some software and firmware required for these devices to function.

The software component in a Mac or an iPhone is larger than in a microwave oven. There is still equally zero incentive to port it to third-party devices, because it's the devices that bring in the revenue; software is a cost center.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by TheRealDunkirk on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:33AM (#27662509)
Holy moly! If there was ever a self-answering question on this site! Look at how much traffic is being generated by Windows 11's lack of support for older hardware, and how confusing it is -- even for technical users -- to figure out of their machines are TPM-capable at all, or if it just needs turned on in the BIOS -- in order to install it. After 19 years of Linux on the desktop, and always dual-booting Windows for gaming, I'm delighted to spend the extra money on Apple hardware (and game on a PS) to avoid all of that sort of nonsense now. You may not like them, but Apple makes the answers to these kinds of questions pretty clear. I'm glad Apple doesn't waste their time and energy with supporting every piece of kit under the sun.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by michaelmrose on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:02PM (#27664429)
If you can sell a computer for 500-1000 more than your competition why sell an OS for 100-200.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by elliekelly on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:39PM (#27664113)
It’s super disappointing to receive such hostile responses to a genuine question but I appreciate the two people who replied kindly.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by fouric on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:55PM (#27665155)
I would also settle for:

* The FTC actually does its job and takes action against Microsoft for antitrust violations.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by unknown_error on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:48PM (#27664240)
Why would non-technical users want computing under their control? Isn't the market going the other way, more and more towards walled gardens? Seems like a Chromebook or iPad would have far fewer headaches for the typical user who just wants Facebook and email.

The web as an open platform is a dev manifesto; for everyone else it's just a glorified entertainment and information hub, and making it safer and easier for them is what the market wants. Not more openness, but less of it, because less openness means less cognitive mode. They don't want to think about 100 ways to do the same thing, each with a different license and complex venn diagram of incompatibilities. They just want to get on with their day.

"If something goes horribly wrong"... even in that case, the vendors are less likely to fuck up than most users. Google/Apple/Microsoft clouds are much better at keeping data safe against device failures and ransomware than local Windows installs managed by average users ever were or could be.

If anything the future is really dumb computing, where the internet is just another appliance not too different from your radio or the television. Apps with corporate content hubs, not open platforms.

Computing as an open platform was due to the industry by and large being created by engineers. Now with mass adoption, we're seeing a switch to producer vs consumers, with different paradigms/devices/needs for each, like the differences between magazine publishers and readers. Readers don't care what software was used to create a magazine, they just want to pick it off a newsstand and read it. Same with digital entertainment; the underlying stack shouldn't be their concern if their intended usage is simply content consumption. Windows adds only unnecessary complexity to their usage. Stallman is not an average user, and it would be a massive disservice to humanity to design for the average user as though they were Stallman.

Not all freedom is beneficial. Sometimes it's just yet another useless decision to have to make in a world already overflowing with excess information. The human brain did not evolve to make careful cost-benefit analyses for every trivial thing in a post-internet world.

Even devs are moving towards serverless. Content creation might eventually move to "OS"-less, where content creation is moderated by walled hubs like Adobe apps on the iPad and developer experiences happen in virtualized clouds with web-based IDEs. Bare metal appeals to engineers, but for everyday users and developers, again, it's just excess cognitive load. Please don't make people think about useless crap. There are already infinite upcoming crises -- of the global sort -- for anyone born in the last few generations. Computing trivia is just... trivia, no more inherently interesting than the proper type of lubricant to use on the machines in the factory that makes their toaster. Don't make them think without good reason.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by ukyrgf on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:32AM (#27661025)
I'm at a small business that gets maybe 2 dozen new computers a year but line 1 on my setup list is "DO NOT PLUG IN THE ETHERNET CABLE"

I can't believe it's come to this...

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by rootusrootus on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:51AM (#27661251)
Surely the 'professional' versions don't have this requirement? I'm quite far from a Windows expert, but at the company I work for the IT folks control all aspects of authentication and maintenance (e.g. patches all come through our own servers, not MS or Apple). They'd tell MS to piss off if they tried to require employees to have MS accounts.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by ioulian on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:03AM (#27661378)
I've only installed PRO versions of Windows 10 and you CAN setup a local account even if internet is plugged in. It is however, hidden behind a few clicks so you must actively search for it.

EDIT: maybe I'm wrong now, as other comment says they changed it a few months back. My last install was somewhere in Dec/2020

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by colejohnson66 on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:48AM (#27661923)
I just installed a copy of Pro last week, and was able to make a local account just fine. It’s hidden in the corner under what looks like regular text, but is actually a link (versus the big button to use a MS account). And a few more screens in, they’ll ask again with the same small link in the corner. And I think it asked one more time before finishing.

Dark patterns abound. It’s horrible, but there are ways around it. For reference, this is in the US (if it matters).

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by buran77 on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:33AM (#27661738)
I installed a 21H1 Pro version just yesterday. On the user creation screen the local account is still hidden behind a "Domain join instead" button where you can actually use a local account. Of course most people at home would actually actively stay away from that button thinking it must lead to some enterprise IT voodoo.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by TheRealDunkirk on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:27AM (#27662414)
I don't "do" Windows any more, except that it's installed on the company laptop. I do all of my work on a Mac, and gaming on a PS. So I am watching these Windows 11 threads with a lot of amusement. The fact that Microsoft is playing games with this -- such that you can't be sure what's happening, even on their "pro" SKU -- is telling.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by mschuster91 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:35AM (#27662530)
I did an install of Windows 10 Pro N on a Mac Pro a couple weeks ago (followed this guide: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/opencore-on-the-mac-pro..., search for "Installing Windows and Linux " section).

The Mac was connected to the Internet, I had to do a couple of clicks during the setup to create a local account but it was easy enough to do - I had not searched beforehand and I hadn't set up a Windows machine in the last five years or so.

Side note for fellow people willing to run W10 on Mac Pro's, two things: the multi-socket variants won't run on the Home edition, you need the Professional edition, and if you're using Opencore you will need to enable the OpenShell EFI shell as you'll need to run bootmgfw.efi once from the UEFI shell.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by a2tech on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:54AM (#27661295)
No, Windows 10 Pro/Enterprise does the same thing until its bound to a directory.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by Aerroon on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:06AM (#27662145)
My guess is that the Pro version won't have the requirement yet. But in the future they'll require it for Pro as well.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by 83457 on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:02AM (#27661364)
I know no internet connection used to be solution, but I thought there was an option to bypass the ms account requirement during setup for the last couple years?
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by scrooched_moose on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:11AM (#27661476)
Its slowly became harder from update to update over the last couple years of updates, and completely removed under normal circumstances in one of the last major updates.

AFAIK leaving the ethernet unplugged is the only way to do it now.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by BLKNSLVR on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:39AM (#27661812)
I did it recently by accident. When it asked for an email address I entered [email protected] with the C word as the password.

This obviously failed as a legitimate Microsoft login, but it did, very handily, offer the option to create a local account instead.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by hilbert42 on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:56AM (#27663526)
"I did it recently by accident. When it asked for an email address I entered [email protected] with the C word as the password."

Hey, stop plagiarizing me! ;-)

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by joejacket on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:38AM (#27661093)
This is standard procedure for everything, it's been that way with ’smart' TVs for years.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by aclelland on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:01AM (#27661358)
You want an even darker pattern? Try requesting the windows telemetry data from a PC which isn't logged in through a MS account. You'll spend weeks going back and forth trying to explain to their support agents that you can't login to the website because you don't have an account. Frustrating doesn't begin to describe it. I've still not been able to get anything from them despite a 30 email chain.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by linker3000 on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:25AM (#27663129)
Are you in the UK/EU? Hit MS with a subject access request (SAR) as per GDPR Article 15, and the clock starts ticking; the data processor (MS) must then provide all the personal data they hold on you, and other supplementary information. within one month (extendable by another two).
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by gigel82 on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:31PM (#27664004)
I'm curious what'll actually be in there; please do this and report back.

I keep hearing the line of MS's evil data collection to serve you ads and whatnot but I suspect the truth is much milder; they probably have mostly usage telemetry to drive their investment decisions and possibly perf / bugs because they fired their testing team.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by BLKNSLVR on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:35AM (#27661770)
Microsoft have become the best advertisement for Linux on the desktop.

This kind of advertising actually worked on me.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by hilbert42 on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:11PM (#27663724)
Yeah, unfortunately that kind of advertising only works on the likes of you, me and other HN readers. The rest, even quite savvy technical people (as I've found), simply put up with the problem—that's if they recognize it as such. Microsoft knows this and writes us off as our numbers are in the noise. Essentially, to MS, we're irrelevant.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by x86_64Ubuntu on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:01AM (#27661351)
I had the same story as you. I was setting up my mother's laptop, and of course they are pusshing 'S' mode. The narrative is that for security reasons, S-mode will only allow things from the Microsoft Store to be installed. MS knows this, and to disable S-mode so you can install something like Chrome, you have to create an MS account. No matter where I looked, there was no way to disable S-mode without creating an account.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by Tepix on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:31AM (#27661001)
Indeed, a few months ago Microsoft changed Windows 10 so that the only way to install it with a local account is to disconnect the LAN cable
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by teh_klev on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:16AM (#27661521)
I had to perform a fresh re-install on a laptop earlier this year and even had to go to the lengths of physically removing the WiFi card from the machine before I could get the local account option to appear in the installer. What an absolute fricken waste of time.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by hilbert42 on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:31PM (#27664000)
Right, we need laws to stop this practice. If, say, I bought a new laptop several years ago with Windows 10 on it and agreed to the terms and conditions at that time and Microsoft then increasingly tightens those rules with updates etc. then I'm forced to agree to the new terms that I now disagree with or otherwise I could potentially be in trouble. This ought to be a job for consumer law.

Moreover, MS is inexorably moving stuff, utilities etc, that were once on its website to its store that requires login for, it seems, similar reasons. Clearly, knowing exactly who we are has financial benefits for Microsoft or otherwise it wouldn't bother.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by Nexxxeh on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:01AM (#27662075)
My usual procedure is make a restore USB drive using whatever tool supplied, or just clone it with TrueImage, in case something goes arwy.

Then: "Disable secure boot, wipe SSD, reinstall Windows without connecting to the Internet".

You'll end up with a relatively bloat-free non-S Windows 10 install with a local account, no BitLocker (although it can be enabled later), and Windows will generally install all the hardware drivers for you.

Anything missing that you want can be grabbed from the manufacturer's website. Once everything's done, re-enable secure boot.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by hilbert42 on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:07PM (#27664474)
Agreed, this ought to mantra for everyone. Ever since XP, I have always installed or setup Windows in essentially this way—and I never do the setup with the internet connected (not even with Linux). If in the middle of the process I need an updated hardware driver then I'll download it on another machine.

Once the setup is done and the O/S configured exactly the way I want it (which often takes me considerable time), I'll then mirror the drive.

I then progressively repeat the process in stages, first with essential utilities, text editors and maintenance tools and work up to bigger programs, word-processors etc. At the end of the process I'll end up with at least four mirrors. If anything goes wrong I can restore the image which typically takes me 7 to 10 minutes and I'm right to go.

Doing the job in multiple stages is good idea if you want to remove traces of a program that, say, won't allow easy re-installation for licensing reasons. All such program are relegated to a latter-stage image, so the process then is to restore the immediately preceding one that is 'clean'.

Only when I'm finished saving the last image and I'm totally happy with the installation do I connect the internet.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by Osiris on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:12AM (#27661487)
I just installed Windows 10 on a laptop for my mom. On the account setup screen there's a little skip button to create a local account without a Microsoft account.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by sp332 on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:16AM (#27661533)
Your computer was connected to the internet and you're using relatively recent install media? I'm asking because I haven't seen that behavior in years.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by danieldk on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:26AM (#27661655)
I had a Windows 10 Pro laptop for the last 7 months or so (but ditched a few days ago it because Windows has become so terrible) and the two times I installed it, I definitely had an option to create a local account. At some point it was in the lower-left while onboarding (carefully disguised as some clickable text rather than a very visible button).

Both times the machine was connected to the internet. One time with the standard Lenovo media, one time from a fresh Windows 10 Pro ISO.

Could there be a regional difference? (I am in the EU)

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by dsissitka on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:18PM (#27663830)
They've removed it from Home but it's still there for Pro.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27624555

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by giancarlostoro on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:10AM (#27662191)
> I know the post is about Windows 11 but I installed Windows 10 for someone on a laptop about 2 months ago and it had the most crazy dark pattern I've ever seen to be able to proceed past the installation screen without a Microsoft account.

I would set it up without access to internet as the easiest way to force it. It is pretty awful this has to be done this way. Eventually I will just exclusively use Ubuntu and call it a day.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by JoeyBananas on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:59AM (#27661346)
it's time to ditch Windows for linux
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by tabulatouch on Monday June 28, 2021 @09:20AM (#27661573)
I am always surprised by the lack of a proper "Linux Wine" OS, binary compatible with Windows, but with linux under the hood..
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by sempron64 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:30AM (#27662465)
I think the core problem is that wine needs to be tweaked and adjusted for the applications which are running, and often running certain software requires strange things with winetricks. It’s not stable enough for a distro
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by bserge on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:24AM (#27662381)
Maybe if WINE ditched their "clean room" directive...
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by mschuster91 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:36AM (#27662545)
They can't, it would open them up for so much legal trouble. Just look at the entire SCO saga.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by prionassembly on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:55AM (#27663510)
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by vageli on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:09AM (#27662179)
These days there is Windows Subsystem for Linux (WSL).
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by dkersten on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:52AM (#27662744)
Which is a subsystem of windows to run linux, not a subsystem consisting of windows to run on linux. Ie that doesn't solve the problem of "I don't want to run Windows but want Windows software", but rather it solves the opposite problem of "I'm on Windows and want to run Linux software".
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by vageli on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:14PM (#27664563)
Ah, I see I misunderstood the comment to which I replied.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:25AM (#27663118)
If only I could, but my experiences with Linux Desktop continue to be even more frustrating and painful than Windows despite Microsoft's apparent continued efforts to destroy desktop computing as a concept. Worse yet, the Linux Desktop community has demonstrated not only an inability to remedy said frustrations, but also a complete lack of desire.

I have some issues with choices made in Haiku, but overall it has a clearly superior understanding of desktop and personal computing and it would be great if it could become a reasonable alternative for me within the next decade.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by darknavi on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:48PM (#27664233)
In the leaked Windows 11 build the setup flow got slightly less "dark pattern"-y. There is a small video of it here (linked to timestamp):

https://youtu.be/odZSCdNTFPw?t=305

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by noobquestion81 on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:34PM (#27664847)
I had the same experience a couple months back trying to set up a gaming PC. This was after the initial screen set my speakers to max and then blasted Cortana screaming at me in different languages. This was at about 3am in the morning, and I have pretty good speakers. After recovering from my heart attack, I then proceeded to fight for ~20 minutes on how to install without a Windows account - since I had already set up Wifi, the easiest way was to unplug my router for a bit. After a while Windows booted up, but would constantly BSOD on reboots. I gave up and bought a console.

Absolute trash OS, sorry.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by dudul on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:58AM (#27662813)
Happened to me a few months ago too when setting up a new machine. The language was also so convoluted and strange that I didn't quite catch that this was creating an online account at the time.

I found a way to revert it and make the account an offline account afterwards, but I was so furious about this crap.

That being said, I don't see the banner you mention.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by reaperducer on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:19PM (#27664632)
"are less secure by not registering an account with Microsoft"

More accounts equals less security. That's a fact. If Microsoft believes this, it's not worthy of our trust.

If it's just marketing hype, ditto. I don't trust companies that outright lie to me.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by charwalker on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:56PM (#27665168)
If online you have to set up as if it's a domain/work PC then say use an account or similar.

I just run installs offline if possible, for home use, and make sure any place I'm working has a WSUS server/etc I can point MDT to.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by hk1337 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:53AM (#27662759)
Albeit, it's not that obvious, you can create an offline account without failing to sign in. Maybe it's different with anything below Windows 10 Pro but that was my experience.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by nickjj on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:00AM (#27662837)
> Maybe it's different with anything below Windows 10 Pro but that was my experience.

It is different with the "S" Home edition which is what comes with a lot of decently spec'd laptops for typical personal use.

I run Pro here and there's a secondary text link off to the side that you can click to make an offline account. That link doesn't exist with the Home edition (specifically the "S" edition, I don't know about the regular Home edition).

In all cases this is with the US version too, which might play a role in what's seen when people install Windows across the world.

Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by hk1337 on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:37AM (#27663263)
Yeah, Pro (and above) is also the only one that has the Hyper-V or whatever, if that's even still a requirement.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by lowercase1 on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:54AM (#27662780)
My username is "fucky" after I used an name to describe my feelings of having to create/use a Microsoft account. Exercise to the reader to guess the unshortened name
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by fencepost on Monday June 28, 2021 @11:22AM (#27663084)
Now I'm feeling like I should create Microsoft accounts using the names of prominent Microsofties.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by Wistar on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:58PM (#27665205)
Atop this crap is that, whether Pro or Home sku, MS account or local, the user is set up by default as an admin account.
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by keb_ on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:11AM (#27662205)
Stuff like this makes me scared to upgrade from Windows 10 LTSC (1809).
Re:I Will Never Use a Microsoft Account to Log Into My Own PC by sitzkrieg on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:59PM (#27664393)
just reinstalled ltsc and intend to use it forever