There are lots of infrastructure management teams taking security more seriously than they were a month ago. That alone is worth more than $5M
The fact they caved so quickly tells me they are years away from a reasonable security posture.
Without widespread ransomware scammers, the risk of getting compromised is just theoretical, not tangible. Companies can get away with ignoring security concerns for a long time and might never be impacted by it.
Thus, companies which are paying a premium for better security might never be able to benefit from the mitigations they are implementing, and could be outcompeted by the companies which simply got lucky enough to avoid being attacked.
Eventually we end up with major too-big-to-fail megacorps like Equifax getting hacked by trivial exploits because nobody took advantage of them when they didn't have such a strong market position.
Still, this might lead to their first solid security hire that can bring about change in the form of zero-trust principles, security in depth, etc.
> to have any chance of stopping a targeted state actor.
Given unlimited resources, interest and budget, no participant in the modern digital landscape has a significant chance of stopping motivated threat actors.
> The fact they caved so quickly tells me they are years away from a reasonable security posture.
Yes, obviously, but driving change is about incrementally tending to a desired state. Your fatalism is, quite frankly, unnecessary, not that you're not entitled to your opinion, just that disagreeing with GP or stating they are naive because this won't bring about perfect, all-encompassing change is not useful.
And if one target is so critical that it could take out a society, perhaps it would be better to either 1. Make it so minimalistic that it can be fully audited and secured or 2. Broken into smaller pieces and decentralised so they can either qualify for #1 or increase the total cost and complexity of compromise.
E.g. warm blankets at home, and food that doesn't need to be boiled, if cannot heat the house because the oil and electricity system is broken for a while?
The preppers are the other side of the same coin. The only thing they seem to never run out of is toilet paper. Who the fuck cares? Pentesters have the same energy. They tell you about what software not to use (anything in their automated suite), followed by a bunch of meaningless bullshit. It is a form of anti preparation, it would not have helped Colonial at all.
You talk about crippling, and in the biggest audition for crippling society in the world, time after time it’s the Everyman being an idiot - or a Prepper being too smart for their own good - that is responsible for all the bad.
We shouldn't have widespread shortages for the sake of theoretical people whose existences are structured around 5 gallon commutes and razor thin margins tied with no lines of credit to float a week of double gas expenses.
The reason, which is likely apparent to both of us and everyone reading this, is that such assistance would likely never be put in place, and the only help ordinary folks will have in the event of such an increase is wishful thinking.
and so you suggest hurting the vast majority of people even more?
That's right, your suggested approach of keeping artificially-low-prices-that-allow-hoarding leads to zero gas at the pumps, and zero gas at the pumps hurts the vast majority of people very directly and very effectively.
Allowing prices to float higher in a shortage solves the allocation problem for scarce resources by ensuring that people think twice about how they use it, while keeping it available. Ignoring that the resource is scarce not only doesn't solve anything, it makes the problem worse.
1. More people are hurt by price gouging of products with inelastic demand than hurt by limiting the price increase.
2. A completely floating gas price disproportionately affects disadvantaged folks who have no alternative, even when there are no outages.
I mean, I totally agree with OP, there's a straightforward solution: set up a government program that insulates people from the effects of a floating price proportionately to how disadvantaged they are, and then, after that, let the gas price float. That way we get your idea without hurting anyone! Win-win.
no, your statement is false.
Hoarding cheap gas results in zero gas at the pump, and that is MORE effective at stopping people who need it than high prices do.
That's right, market pricing solves allocation problems that your misguided approach creates.
Even simplistic rationing is at least relatively fair and can ensure at least a base level of availability. For the major necessities this can be pretty reasonably accounted for to ensure nobody suffers from some extreme deprivation.
It also lets you at least put some somewhat predictable cap on how fast resources are going out. Allowing price gouging doesn't let you predict much of anything, and I'm not sure it even slows the outflow given the uncertainty of these situations.
1. only those who really need it buy it
2. others are encouraged to increase supply
For example, before anti-gouging laws, when a hurricane interrupted the gas supply, people from a state over would immediately fill jerry cans with gas and drive into the disaster zone, selling gas out of the back of their pickups.
Anti-gouging laws put a stop to that. Now nobody gets gas until FEMA gets around to it.
I've talked to people who lived through WW2 gas rationing. It was a mess of mis-allocation. People who didn't need their ration turned into criminals selling it on the black market. People who needed it turned into criminals buying it on the black market. It was pure political theater.
Those who buy it are those who can afford it. They also (think) they need it, for some reason. That can include the intention to legally resell it. Buying suddenly comes with even more time pressure. Buying now becomes both a hedge and speculation, with zero legal risks.
Sure, people bringing in supplies on their own sounds good. It can even be good. But how much does it actually bring in? Does it come with other problems, like additional stress on infrastructure? If this really is such a great thing, I don't see how it should be wholly incompatible with anti-price gouging laws. If you want to specifically incentivize private transport of goods from out of the area, you don't have to allow them to be sold for any price, nor do you have to allow it for goods already in the area.
As for the black market, I'm not sure that's a bug. It makes it harder, and adds some risk, to acquiring more. If you actually need it enough, you'll do it. There some be some correlation between actual need and willingness to participate in the black market. With proper use of the discretion available to law enforcement, maybe this even enhances how well the goods end up distributed. That's a big "with" but still.
Rationing implies a black market must be illegal. Besides, it enriches random people who don't need gas, at the expense of the people who went to the effort to supply it.
If that isn't a topsy-turvy unjust, inefficient and inequitable way to run an economy, I don't know what is.
Rationing suffers from the delusion that bureaucratic rules can distinguish who needs something and who doesn't, and denial of the existence of normal human motivations.
But then the outcome would not have changed, the people who hoard will be worse off, the people who produce a valuable commodity will be better off and there is incentive for people to contingency plan and have gas reserves for when things get tight.
That is a strict improvement. Plus, you're probably being overly pessimistic - people will stop hoarding once the price gets high enough. The shelves would not be bare.
> These are not individuals with any knowledge of economics - theyre not doing it for trade, they're doing it out of belief.
The people with knowledge of economics don't have much of an advantage though, do they? When has an official body ever been banging the drum before a major crisis issuing panicked warnings? Every crisis it turns out all the people held up as experts had grossly misread the situation.
People with knowledge of economics often get bowled under by people with a knowledge of politics or of statistics when it comes to trading.
Last year when all the grocery stores were running out of staples, I was unluckily traveling for work where there are no grocery stores. Upon returning, I conveniently found that my neighborhood co-op still had eggs because, while almost all eggs had been sold out, no one wanted to hoard $7.50/dz eggs, meaning I had the opportunity to get eggs if I really wanted them. I was able to buy eggs and did so, adjusting my habits accordingly to operate on fewer (but not zero) eggs. Everyone else who had visited that store had the same opportunity, and they also had the chance to compare their own desire for eggs against others' desires to recognize that they could do with fewer, as could I. At the end of the day, having reduced amounts of something I want is way less impactful than having none.
The only problem here is if gas stations talk to each other to set a price, but that is collusion, and is illegal independent of gouging laws.
I'm not buying gold, but the odd thing is that Russian and Chinese central banks are. I would assume those people know a thing or two about economics. I'm curious to see what the future holds.
They’re already the #3 and #1 producing countries world-wide.
[1] https://www.marketwatch.com/story/why-russian-and-chinese-ce...
no, you've got it exactly backward. People buying it more than ever is driving the price up, and the feedback of higher prices is actually slowing down their purchasing not only by changing their minds, but also because their purchasing budget is spread more thinly.
Maybe. But, I tend to lay the blame with the foreign criminals/adversaries who attacked us rather than a panicky handful of my fellow country people.
Not sure why some here are blaming the victims while giving the criminals a pass, and even thanking them as if unsolicited, live pentesting on critical infrastructure with a side order of extortion is a good thing.
I bet a lot of companies, including Colonial, are investing more in security, including hiring more people for security.
Me: Only if you learn it.
Penetration testing is part of a security program. If you don't have a security program, penetration "testing" isn't useful whether it's painful or not.
Haves the careers or investments of anyone significant who brought things to this point been screwed? If not, nothing will change.
As someone with a lot of friends and co-workers who are on the info-sec side, the stories I repeatedly hear of how many times they visit the same company year/year and little if anything is done to harden their networks, and impose stricter security on their users is way more common than it should be.
Most, if not all of these networks should be taken offline and siloed, but you know that won't happen now, the genie is out of the bottle. If they did, it would create a much smaller attack surface for critical infrastructure. As it sits now? Doubtful we would go back to that world.
2. Agree that paying leads to bad outcomes. But I also suspect the feds put some pressure on Colonial. Voters remember gas lines and the pump prices.
This was my thought was as well. I thought they were in on this before it hit the public media. For me, it was like in the movies when the feds are trying to tap the line and the person is trying to keep the bad guy on the line as long as possible so they can trace the call?
My theory is the feds encouraged Colonial to string it out in order for them to get as much information on the hacking team as possible. From what we're seeing now (bitcoin seized, servers seized) it sounds like the Feds have them nailed pretty good and their gamble paid off.
I'd expect there will be some serious talks about how much to pay to prevent things like this. 5 million, once? Meh, why bother taking security seriously? I suspect the lost revenue is tougher to swallow.
I dunno. you gotta pay every month forever, for protection against maybe something bad happening someday? It's an insurance premium, but you don't get made whole.
I guess, I'd expect companies to start paying a little for infrastructure so they can buy good insurance policies. backups would get you a lot.
It'll be interesting.
Hardware write-enable switches on the drives are 2 or 3 cents.
This is analogous to overspecialization in an ecological niche where there was no predation.
As ransomware becomes more widespread, it becomes more and more detrimental to companies to pursue short-term security savings. That's good for everyone.
These may be the same thing however.
The situation of not being able to tell is pretty good.
At the very least, $5M seems a good start to fund an ongoing effort at developing cyber attack capabilities.
I’m wondering if in the grand scheme of things this could be one more reason to speed up development of solar/wind + distributed energy production.
Nonsense. This is not an academic exercise. Our country is being attacked by "nation states" (do more research) and we need to respond accordingly, treating it as the national security threat it is and making the perpetrators pay a heavy price. If they'd bombed our critical infrastructure, no one would be sitting around saying, "oh this is good for improving our defense. Thank you for dropping bombs on us."
The idea that they are doing us some kind of service and we should just play a game of defensive cat and mouse, hoping for 100% effectiveness (which we know is impossible) is absurd.
Wake up. We're at war.
With whom? And given that nation states have engaged in this sort of thing for years, and that the US/5-eyes/etc also engage in these activities, do you really want to turn a cyber/cold-war into a hot one?
The solution is defense-in-depth, with liability on the providers of software, which will require them to insure, which will raise prices, which will force them to address security as COGS which will force them to reduce their attack surfaces to reduce their insurance premiums.
I didn't say we needed to turn it hot. Where did you read that? But, I do believe this idea that we "shouldn't escalate" emboldens the aggressors.
There is no defense-only solution. Your profile says you work in IT, so you know that.
Why are you against punishing/deterring the aggressors?
Yes, we could "unbomb" it for some amount of money. But, we generally use the term "repair".
But, that's a great point: as long as we can undo the damage for some amount of money (via repair or paying extortion), we should let foreign adversaries dictate the terms on which they'll allow us to operate our infrastructure.
Still, do let us know when you think we should be concerned. 2 more pipelines? 3 more hospitals? 4 more police stations?
$5 trillion ransoms? Maybe? No? Perhaps when infrastructure outages and other attacks cause deaths?
At least according to https://finance.yahoo.com/news/colonial-pipeline-paid-hacker...
Krehel (chief executive officer and founder of digital forensics firm LIFARS and a former cyber expert at Loews Corp) said a $5 million ransom for a pipeline was “very low.” “Ransom is usually around $25 million to $35 million for such a company. I think the threat actor realized they stepped on the wrong company and triggered a massive government response,” he said.Unless Vlad starts frowning on this behavior, which persists at his pleasure, it may take that (or a seriously escalatory cyber response) to lower the threat to acceptable levels.
Assuming you were in a TV show, and offered two options: Spin wheel 1 with a 95% chance of winning $5M, or spin wheel 2 with a 50% chance of winning $50M, which one are you going to spin? The EV is higher on the second one, sure, but taking the near-certain 5M may still be a better choice - a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.
Additionally, this group is said to do its research and adjust ransoms accordingly, so it seems likely that the ransom amount was a carefully thought out choice.
Example: Say you have $10⁵, and you have the option to play game 1, which offers a 95% chance of a $5×10⁶ prize, or game 2, which offers a 50% chance of a $5×10⁷ prize. By the Kelly Criterion, the value of a scenario is the expected value of the logarithm of your wealth under that scenario:
• not playing at all = lg[10⁵] = 5
• game 1 = 95%×lg[10⁵ + 5×10⁶] + 5%×lg[10⁵ + 0] ≈ 6.6
• game 2 = 50%×lg[10⁵ + 5×10⁷] + 50%×lg[10⁵ + 0] ≈ 6.3
So game 1 is the best option if you have only $10⁵. On the other hand, if you have, say, $10⁶, then game 2 is the best option.
• pay for security that prevents attacks = lg[company value – cost of security]
• don’t pay for security = attack probability × lg[company value – cost of dealing with attack] + (1 – attack probability) × lg[company value]
Never negotiate with terrorist. As long as they feel there is a chance they will get paid it never stops. Burn it to the ground, but do not give in.
This lesson should have been learned at school. If you give in to the bully you get exploited more.
Sure it's more work to fight. But it makes sure you're not abused so much.
Both amounts are enough for me to never work another day in my life, and instead focus on building what I want to build. Past that massive increase in quality of life extra money is relatively meaningless (to me) .
This is the same reason that people who decry spending money on lottery tickets as a stupid thing to do based on the EV alone are thinking far too simplistically.
That was exactly one of the reasons why I showed that example.
While this may be different for a gang that has to split the money N ways, the "bird in the hand" might still be worth the two (or ten) in the bush, due to this or other factors.
I can start building it now. But after already spending 40 hours a week writing code at my day job and having those problems swimming around in my head all the time it's hard to find the motivation to do more, even when what I do for my day job isn't as creatively fulfilling.
They called this: "The extortion economy: How insurance companies are fueling a rise in ransomware attacks. Even when public agencies and companies hit by ransomware could recover their files on their own, insurers prefer to pay the ransom. Why? The attacks are good for business." [0]
[0]: https://www.propublica.org/article/the-extortion-economy-how...
> ProPublica has found that they [insurers] often accommodate attackers’ demands, even when alternatives such as saved backup files may be available.
What a perverse set of incentives. Insurance companies are paid to manage risk. Risks go up the more they pay ransoms. As risks go up, the risks are more visible, more companies get policies, insurance gets more money. This is bordering or racketeering.
How many times do people on HN say “back up your files”. Certainly that’s the way to do it if you want less ransomware. It’s not sexy, it’s not “visible”, but it will reduce your risk. But apparently, the goal here is to encourage more ransomware.
We had a similar issue with builder's insurance down here in Australia. It's was (and still is) cheaper to get insurance than build a quality building. Eventually that caught up with the builders (and they moved to using a seperate corporate entity for each building and closing it after the building is built, but that's another story of corruption).
Hmm, so if buying a house, it can be good to first find out if this house is the only one the construction company has built
> insurance companies make some profit, specially in the beginning
I've gotten the impression that CEOs often don't plan much longer than any bonus program periods?
And, later when getting too expensive, can't they just then start telling the companies to use their backups instead.
Backup media must be append-only unless a physical write-enable switch is pressed.
Physical write-enable switches used to be standard.
I'm not buying the crazy argument that remote update is necessary to remove malware installed using remote update.
Not to mention, rewarding people for bad behavior is never a good idea. I learned this as a child... "If you give a mouse a cookie, then he'll ask you for a glass of milk."
So they have to follow through with unlocking and they have to use an amount of money low enough to make the decision obvious.
5M, 50M, 500M, 5B, 50B?
I wonder how the government would react if a hacker group held gas/power/clean water/etc. hostage for millions of Americans for a ransom in the tens of billions
The “utility" acting in Flint was state and state-imposed local government officials, 9 of whom have been criminally indicted for their role, so manifestly the government has something of a problem with it.
War.
Transcript of Whitehouse Press Briefing: https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/press-briefings/202...
In the grand scheme of things it's very low likelihood we'll see any level of prosecution for this incident in the next year or two, if ever. And even then it will likely only result in attribution in a random report a year from now with no actual consequences for the attackers.
The final thing is the amount of money isn't extraordinary. As others have said it's mostly a rounding error in annual revenue that passes books of a company like this.
The insurance may demand better practices for lower premium in turn
Basically the large oil firms know they hold all the cards so they regularly delay payment as long as possible.
This problem needs to be solved in collective level.
My guess is they lowballed - $5m is considerably less than other payments I have seen them take before for a much bigger catch.
You can’t hire cleaners. Site cleanup is suspended. Your insurance is invalid if workers are onsite while hazmats are left uncleaned. You shut down on the day you were about to ship a full warehouse of product. Manufacturing grinds to a halt because the outbound warehouse is full. You have to cease goods incoming because they were misusing the day-labor app for handling delivery grunt work.
Ph0bos Security Services also hacked your email so now everyone has to use personal phones and WhatsApp but upper management won’t share their numbers with anyone except the foreman so he is now the bottleneck for everyone who needs approval to make out of budget purchases to handle the capacity overload that’s happening everywhere except for hazmat cleaning.
But the pumps were airgapped so at least they didn’t get hacked.
At some point it will wake up the authorities to go after them more seriously too.
$5m was 100% a lowball because of the geopolitical implications of this attack.
If you think it's about the ransom though, think bigger. Can you even imagine how many billions of dollars silicon valley is going to make off it? They just paid Microsoft dozens of billions for some AR glasses.
How much for some software to prevent cyber terrorism? How much did TSA get to secure planes? $8 Billion/yr.
$18 Billion for border protection.
How much for cyber border protection? $100 Billion? Where will it go? Google? Microsoft? Palantir? Facebook? Twitter? Amazon?
Trillions.
They haven't even gotten started. $5 Million is pennies. Rounding error.
Even if they don’t pay, the scammers buy puts on the public stock for the companies they’re ransoming so they profit off of blowing them up too.
I’d imagine that’s easier to track and stop, but it’s interesting.
$5M for shutting down that major of a pipeline seems like too little, unless, of course, they weren't expecting the company to even pay. Now that these actors know that the oil (and quite likely other utilities) are more than willing to pay big bucks to get back online, they will be targeted far more.
There are so many reasons this is very very bad.