News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by jackson1442 on Thursday May 13, 2021 @11:22PM (#27150334)
A price increase that effectively stops people from hoarding gas would be equally as effective at stopping people who need gas from affording it.
Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by tbihl on Thursday May 13, 2021 @11:32PM (#27150398)
Addressing legitimate problems of hardship can be dealt with from the other end, by channeling resources to those people. In the mean time, higher prices mean that supply isn't interrupted, and for the vast majority of people that means that you don't fill up your car and your wife's car and your lawnmower and a 55gal drum, because it's not worth it. You just skip a few trips and let your gas tank get below half a tank. And if you were wrong about thinking you could hold out, you can still buy gas because it's not sitting in your neighbor's new gas cans in his garage.

We shouldn't have widespread shortages for the sake of theoretical people whose existences are structured around 5 gallon commutes and razor thin margins tied with no lines of credit to float a week of double gas expenses.

Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by upbeat_general on Friday May 14, 2021 @12:56AM (#27150845)
By “theoretical people” I think you’re referring to a very sizable portion of the population.
Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by ImPostingOnHN on Friday May 14, 2021 @08:13AM (#27153375)
The people who would be hurt by such an increase, absent already-in-place assistance, constitute the vast majority of people. And, unfortunately, nobody is helped by "can be dealt with" -- the policies to prevent their pain, and to prevent disadvantaged folks from being disproportionately impacted by such an increase, need to be in place before the increase.

The reason, which is likely apparent to both of us and everyone reading this, is that such assistance would likely never be put in place, and the only help ordinary folks will have in the event of such an increase is wishful thinking.

Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by fsckboy on Friday May 14, 2021 @10:54AM (#27154948)
> The people who would be hurt by such an increase, absent already-in-place assistance, constitute the vast majority of people.

and so you suggest hurting the vast majority of people even more?

That's right, your suggested approach of keeping artificially-low-prices-that-allow-hoarding leads to zero gas at the pumps, and zero gas at the pumps hurts the vast majority of people very directly and very effectively.

Allowing prices to float higher in a shortage solves the allocation problem for scarce resources by ensuring that people think twice about how they use it, while keeping it available. Ignoring that the resource is scarce not only doesn't solve anything, it makes the problem worse.

Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by ImPostingOnHN on Friday May 14, 2021 @05:22PM (#27159855)
>and so you suggest hurting the vast majority of people even more?

1. More people are hurt by price gouging of products with inelastic demand than hurt by limiting the price increase.

2. A completely floating gas price disproportionately affects disadvantaged folks who have no alternative, even when there are no outages.

I mean, I totally agree with OP, there's a straightforward solution: set up a government program that insulates people from the effects of a floating price proportionately to how disadvantaged they are, and then, after that, let the gas price float. That way we get your idea without hurting anyone! Win-win.

Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by CleaveIt2Beaver on Friday May 14, 2021 @11:54AM (#27155598)
What crazypants world do you live in where the vast majority of people have all that excess, but the poor are in the minority?
Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by fsckboy on Friday May 14, 2021 @10:45AM (#27154858)
> A price increase that effectively stops people from hoarding gas would be equally as effective at stopping people who need gas from affording it.

no, your statement is false.

Hoarding cheap gas results in zero gas at the pump, and that is MORE effective at stopping people who need it than high prices do.

That's right, market pricing solves allocation problems that your misguided approach creates.

Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by WalterBright on Friday May 14, 2021 @01:02AM (#27150886)
You can't buy gas that isn't there. Anti-gouging laws simply result in no gas available.
Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by foerbert on Friday May 14, 2021 @01:23AM (#27151012)
And rationing can address that problem. These complex issues are never so simple.
Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by WalterBright on Friday May 14, 2021 @01:35AM (#27151082)
Rationing makes simple things complex. For example, rationing assumes that everyone has exactly the same need. Trying to fix that is hopelessly complicated.
Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by foerbert on Friday May 14, 2021 @01:58AM (#27151197)
I don't see how that's an argument against anti-price gouging laws though. It's not like price gouging solves that problem. Fundamentally a shortage is just never going to give perfect results.

Even simplistic rationing is at least relatively fair and can ensure at least a base level of availability. For the major necessities this can be pretty reasonably accounted for to ensure nobody suffers from some extreme deprivation.

It also lets you at least put some somewhat predictable cap on how fast resources are going out. Allowing price gouging doesn't let you predict much of anything, and I'm not sure it even slows the outflow given the uncertainty of these situations.

Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by WalterBright on Friday May 14, 2021 @02:16AM (#27151277)
How high prices work is:

1. only those who really need it buy it

2. others are encouraged to increase supply

For example, before anti-gouging laws, when a hurricane interrupted the gas supply, people from a state over would immediately fill jerry cans with gas and drive into the disaster zone, selling gas out of the back of their pickups.

Anti-gouging laws put a stop to that. Now nobody gets gas until FEMA gets around to it.

I've talked to people who lived through WW2 gas rationing. It was a mess of mis-allocation. People who didn't need their ration turned into criminals selling it on the black market. People who needed it turned into criminals buying it on the black market. It was pure political theater.

Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by foerbert on Friday May 14, 2021 @02:42AM (#27151451)
This is not the whole story, by any means.

Those who buy it are those who can afford it. They also (think) they need it, for some reason. That can include the intention to legally resell it. Buying suddenly comes with even more time pressure. Buying now becomes both a hedge and speculation, with zero legal risks.

Sure, people bringing in supplies on their own sounds good. It can even be good. But how much does it actually bring in? Does it come with other problems, like additional stress on infrastructure? If this really is such a great thing, I don't see how it should be wholly incompatible with anti-price gouging laws. If you want to specifically incentivize private transport of goods from out of the area, you don't have to allow them to be sold for any price, nor do you have to allow it for goods already in the area.

As for the black market, I'm not sure that's a bug. It makes it harder, and adds some risk, to acquiring more. If you actually need it enough, you'll do it. There some be some correlation between actual need and willingness to participate in the black market. With proper use of the discretion available to law enforcement, maybe this even enhances how well the goods end up distributed. That's a big "with" but still.

Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by WalterBright on Friday May 14, 2021 @02:51AM (#27151504)
> As for the black market, I'm not sure that's a bug.

Rationing implies a black market must be illegal. Besides, it enriches random people who don't need gas, at the expense of the people who went to the effort to supply it.

If that isn't a topsy-turvy unjust, inefficient and inequitable way to run an economy, I don't know what is.

Rationing suffers from the delusion that bureaucratic rules can distinguish who needs something and who doesn't, and denial of the existence of normal human motivations.

Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by nickff on Friday May 14, 2021 @01:30AM (#27151047)
Then you get a black market... it's almost a cobra effect.
Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by foerbert on Friday May 14, 2021 @02:05AM (#27151227)
Sure. I'd guess it still adds enough friction to help result in a better distribution of goods in the end. The time, effort, and (legal) risk you are willing to take to acquire something should correlate decently with how much you really need those goods.
Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by jackson1442 on Friday May 14, 2021 @10:36PM (#27161801)
What price do you suppose is high enough to effectively stop hoarding?
Re:Colonial Pipeline Paid Hackers Nearly $5M in Ransom by WalterBright on Saturday May 15, 2021 @02:57AM (#27163047)
Keep raising the price until the traffic to your gas station is at sustainable levels.