News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by m463 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:02AM (#26014879)
What I've always wondered is - why don't we put a supercapacitor between a an EV battery and the motor?

This means that EVs of all kinds, could not only get crazy acceleration, but could also recover all the energy of regen. Even battery packs with a very good layout can absorb a fraction of the acceleration energy, and less or none when the battery is cold or at the upper range of capacity.

I remember reading an article about a porsche in a car magazine (many) years ago that discussed not the horsepower for acceleration but also the horsepower absorbed by the brakes to decelerate.

It might have been 500 horsepower to accelerate the car, but since the brakes were very good, it could absorb 900+ horsepower when bringing it to a halt.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by xoa on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:01PM (#26015770)
I've wondered about hybrid supercap/battery designs as well, but up until recently it's apparently often been easier/better to just go with a bigger battery. String more small cells up together, get more performance and also more absolute energy available (range).

That said, while it's a completely and utterly different area, I've actually now experienced my first hybrid using equipment just a few weeks ago and it was pretty interesting: the latest Black Diamond avalanche airbag (JetForce Tour 26L). Avalanche airbags are now quite common safety tools for heavy snow back country or mountaineering, and in an avalanche can help keep a person from being completely buried (or at least keep them much much shallower). Fundamentally, they need to extremely rapidly inflate a significant volume with gas or air on demand, with long term reliability in standby, and while being part of a human portable backpack carrying other stuff and thus as light as feasible. It doesn't take much absolute energy, but inflating in a couple of seconds does take a huge amount of power.

The original ones used compressed air or small explosives, which obviously are consumable and present problems traveling by commercial air. They're also harder to test/practice with. Electric fan models came about like 5-6 years ago, but extremely high instantaneous power demands in this application meant big fat lithium ion batteries which are fairly heavy. Fine in a car, not so man portable.

The JetForce uses Alpride's E1 supercap design fan. The supercap can be charged off of USB or just a single pair of AA batteries in the field, and can hold charge for a good 2-3 months. It shaves a solid couple of pounds off the previous lithium ion design.

Anyway, niche application but it was pretty neat to me anyway to see some real practical gains come about from newer supercap work. I'll be curious if hybrid designs continue to make inroads in other places characterized by sharp power spikes with less overall energy demand.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by cestith on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:53PM (#26016617)
With something that has one quarter the energy density but four or more times the power density, the right place to put it commercially might be between the charging station and the batteries rather than the batteries and the motor. Replace 25% of the batteries with this, charge it in a fraction of the time of the full battery pack, then have it charge the batteries while you're driving down the road. I don't need 5500 horsepower. 390 miles on a really short recharge cycle makes a lot of sense.

If one could do both, that might be nice. But cutting charging time while maintaining most of the range makes more sense than having acceleration bursts to the wheels that never make it to the road.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by blueblisters on Friday February 05, 2021 @11:05AM (#26037757)
Sorry I don't quite get this - why would you charge the battery with the capacitor while you're driving down the road? Can't you just drain the capacitor and use the energy for driving?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by m463 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @03:29PM (#26018694)
that's a cool idea -- put the supercap between the motor and battery, but also attach the charging port to the supercap.

It would be a buffered input to the battery no matter where the energy comes from.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by linsomniac on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:17AM (#26015095)
I've been told that the Tesla Model S is the first car that had a 0-60 time that matched the 60-0. I had one of the Ludicrous models as a loaner a few years ago, and I'd believe it. I could feel the tires hunting for grip during acceleration.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by m463 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:35AM (#26015369)
But if you look at the power-meter thing, the acceleration power is many times the regen power

http://st.motortrend.ca/uploads/sites/42/2017/02/2017-Tesla-...

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by linsomniac on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @05:07PM (#26019798)
Yes, that is absolutely true, regen is only capable of a fraction of the 1,000bhp the electric motors are capable of. This is why the performance Teslas have fancy-schmancy huge ass red brake calipers.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by mikewarot on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:29PM (#26016225)
I have to believe that tire grip is the limiting factor... the maximum seems to be about 2.3 g

The fastest braking from 60-0 is 16 meters (53 feet), according to https://fastestlaps.com/lists/top-quickest-stoppers-60mph

Using the physics calculator at https://www.calculatorsoup.com/calculators/physics/uniformly...

This gives a deceleration of 22.5 m/sec^2, or about 2.3 g.

I'm amazed it can go above 1 g, actually.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by linsomniac on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @05:17PM (#26019906)
That 53 feet 60-0 is a Ferrari race car, which has aerodynamics that sucks it down to the ground, more than 1g of additional downforce. Often referred to as "they could drive upside down to the roof of a tunnel.

Years ago in Denver when they had F1 racing, I remember a news story about preparations the city had to do for the race, which included welding down the manhole covers. Because the amount of suction these cars make would pull the manhole covers off as cars drove over them.

Also, traction is more than just friction. There's a mechanical component to it, the scraping off of the rubber from the surface of the tire.

Also, as far as the 53 feet goes, remember that this car was extremely light, 1400lbs. The Tesla Model S weighs almost 5Klbs for comparison.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by m463 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @07:03PM (#26020927)
I loved the story of the Chaparral 2J with "active downforce":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaparral_Cars#2J

Two fans adapted from a military tank engine were housed at the rear, driven by a single two-stroke twin-cylinder engine.

...

The skirting produced a zone within which the fans could create a vacuum producing downforce on the order of 1.25 to 1.50 G when the car was fully loaded

Maybe this sort of thing will make a comeback :)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_gas_thruster

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by mikewarot on Thursday February 04, 2021 @04:32AM (#26024025)
>That 53 feet 60-0 is a Ferrari race car, which has aerodynamics that sucks it down to the ground, more than 1g of additional downforce.

That downforce drops to zero long before the car stops.

>Also, as far as the 53 feet goes, remember that this car was extremely light, 1400lbs. The Tesla Model S weighs almost 5Klbs for comparison.

It doesn't matter how much something weighs... the kinetic energy scales linearly with weight. The F-16 fighter can pull 9gs, and it weighs 20,300 lbs.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by linsomniac on Thursday February 04, 2021 @11:44AM (#26027032)
I don't know how the ground effects and wings scale, but I'm sure it's dramatically less at 60 than at 200MPH. But I'd also suspect that it is non-zero. It's also possible that this stopping distance was measured with the aerodynamics tuned for 60-0 braking, because they adjust the aerodynamics all the time.

>It doesn't matter how much something weighs

Stopping distance is absolutely, 100%, impacted by the weight of the car.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by faeyanpiraat on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:52PM (#26016587)
Its not that amazing, an alternative perspective is that in nature you have animals which can climb vertical walls, which is equivalent to having a grip that can whitstand 1g?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by colejohnson66 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:54PM (#26016631)
Tangent: why does a car going above 2 Gs feel, for lack of a better word, not scary, but a roller coaster pulling the same feel scary (in an exciting way)?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by jandrese on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:04PM (#26016818)
I've never tried it, but there are plenty of reaction videos of people doing a ludicrous start in a Tesla and the passengers showing expressions of fear and surprise.

If you are the driver then being in control probably helps quite a lot. In a roller coaster you are always a passenger.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by bluGill on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:04PM (#26016827)
Roller coasters are engineered to feel like they are about to fall apart. There is a reason they creek and shake: they were built to creek and shake. They put in lots of unneeded supports that are made to shake excessively, meanwhile the actually supports are hidden so you don't notice they are doing the real work.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by danans on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:50AM (#26015579)
I've wondered the same for a while, but the best I can figure is that up to this point the use of super capacitors hasn't been worth the added complexity.

Also, the power output of Li-ion batteries has gotten so high that the supercapacitors only offer power benefits for marginal use cases.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by gens on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:46PM (#26017438)
As others have said, the energy that a supercapacitor can store is practically nothing compared to lipo. And that is by weight, when supercapacitors are less dense then lipo.

If you want more power you can just put more batteries in parallel. Or use batteries with lower resistance (the flat ones).

As for gathering bursts of energy; Again the problem is energy capacity. The (potential) energy released by braking really hard is really high (per time).

You could use a flywheel battery for that. They can take it. They are even used in roller coasters just for that purpose (granted they use big flywheels).

Considering people usually break "softly", it is just not worth it.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by upofadown on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:59PM (#26016723)
Perhaps for electric aviation? That is an application where high peak power can make for a takeoff on a shorter runway.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by jsight on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:20PM (#26017083)
AFAICT, the practical difference isn't that big, the supercapacity energy density is much lower, and it is always more worthwhile to just add more batteries.

EVs already use their friction brakes pretty rarely, so the potential gains aren't even that big.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by numpad0 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:36PM (#26016355)
Energy density is 2-3 digits lower for typical EDLC vs Li-ion
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by nerpderp82 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:00PM (#26016727)
Tesla bought the premiere energy storage capacitor company.

https://www.maxwell.com/

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Hypx on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @05:21PM (#26019953)
Fuel cell cars are starting use supercapacitors like this.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Tade0 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:31AM (#26014487)
73 Wh/kg is a decent number. IIRC the previous gen Prius had 46Wh/kg batteries.

Perhaps with some reconfiguration it would be possible in the future to give those old machines some additional oomph, as the discharge limit in their NiMH battery packs is way below the combined power of the two motor-generators(21kW vs 60kW).

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by hinkley on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:40PM (#26016418)
For comparison, Maxwell has supercaps with a power density of 5.9 Wh/kg. But it's also rated at half a million charge cycles.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by numpad0 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:52PM (#26016591)
I wonder why no one is talking about acceleration limiters implemented in pedals and inverters in non-Tesla cars. The reason why only Tesla is famous for its instant torque is because only theirs don’t have it.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Tade0 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @06:21PM (#26020574)
My Toyota hybrid has instant torque - just not a lot of it. It's only really noticeable in the "power" (I guess calling it "sport" would be too much) setting.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by numpad0 on Thursday February 04, 2021 @09:11AM (#26025423)
I was thinking about a potato video I no longer have links to, that explained how shifting from N to D or B(not sure which) while flooring accelerator bypasses an undocumented safety limiter and cause the car to jump forward harder than the car normally would. Nissan Leaf reportedly has a similar jerk limiter feature.

Isn’t it a bit odd that no one talks about it? Though probably the fact is just that no one take stock Prius or Leaf seriously

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Tade0 on Thursday February 04, 2021 @11:29AM (#26026854)
I think it may be from R to D - I do that a lot and you're almost guaranteed to get all the torque you want this way - at least I always had, as opposed to just accelerating from a standstill, to which sometimes the ECU would react with a cold "yeah, no".

I read that in the former case it's connected with the fact that the motor-generator attached to the sun gear has to start turning in the opposite direction to assist acceleration - the high-pitched whine of the inverter appears to support this theory.

As for talking about it: I guess people just assume all EVs have instant torque. I for one was surprised to learn that the Renault Zoe has a delay put there supposedly to emulate an automatic transmission.

The IONIQ hybrid on the other hand, which I've test driven, has to react like a regular automatic because the electric motor is sandwiched between the engine and the transmission. I was meaning to get it after my first Toyota hybrid got stolen, but the way it reacted to throttle input turned out to be a deal breaker for me.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Animats on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:48PM (#26016529)
The actual figures are a tested energy density up to 73 Wh/kg – thus about 28 percent of what today's state of the art EV batteries offer

So, no, this isn't useful for battery electric vehicles. Hybrids, maybe, for vehicles with an underpowered main engine and electric boost for acceleration.

... retaining 90 percent of their initial storage capacity after 10,000 full charge/discharge cycles.

So, not a good power supply filter either. 10,000 cycles of the power line rectified to DC is under a minute and a half.

There are applications for big pulsed power sources, but not that many of them. Flashguns for cameras. Aircraft carrier catapults. Nuclear weapons detonators. Railguns. Big spark generators. Most of the applications that need a huge power spike are military.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by nerpderp82 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:52PM (#26017519)
> So, no, this isn't useful for battery electric vehicles.

This is absolutely useful for anything with a high momentary power draw. Even with the quarter of the energy density. These aren't going to supply all the energy, just the peak power. The main pack can be sized for slightly above the average power draw, and it can charge the boost pack that needs to get you up to speed or handle the surge current sink from braking.

Who would use a multifarad capacitor for filtering a rectified AC line? Why is this an argument? This isn't a capacitor, it is a battery with capacitor qualities.

I feel like the internet was built for arm chair generals to attempt to rain on parades.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Animats on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @02:24PM (#26017952)
There are already ultracapacitors used for high short term power draws. There's a nice motorcycle prototype which uses ultracapacitors to boost acceleration.[1] The Lamborghini Sian uses the same trick.

The article says the energy storage is "mostly capacitive", so it's reasonable to compare this with ultracapacitors.

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/billroberson/2019/12/22/nawas-r...

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by nerpderp82 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:09PM (#26022469)
These are batteries with capacitor level charge and discharge rates. Even above what Maxwell can supply, these batteries will absolutely buffer high current loads unlike anything we have seen.

If these were integrated into exiting lion packs, it would extend life while supplying much higher instantaneous peak currents.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by tzs on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @05:44PM (#26020211)
> So, not a good power supply filter either. 10,000 cycles of the power line rectified to DC is under a minute and a half.

Are batteries involved in this used in such a way that they undergo a full charge/discharge cycles for every cycle of the incoming AC power?

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by sterlind on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:52PM (#26017525)
For nuclear weapons, do you really need that much power to detonate the TATP? Or are you talking about the kinds of detonators you'd need for pure fusion devices?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Animats on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @02:29PM (#26018021)
Not really. The usual setup is charging up a capacitor and discharging it through a "detonator" which is just a resistor. The resistor explodes and starts the main explosive. This is done to get synchronized detonation of all detonators, which is needed for symmetrical implosion. But that problem was solved in the 1940s and the power supply has been tiny since the 1960s. So it's not a problem that needs solving. This is all on Wikipedia.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by csours on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:11PM (#26016927)
What about holding the charge from regenerative braking?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by m4rtink on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:14PM (#26016982)
What about using this for grid scale energy storage ?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by ksec on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:44PM (#26017407)
That was my immediate reaction as well. Even on a cycle per day that is ~27 years for Grid usage while still retaining 90% of capacity.

Consider weight and volume isn't a concern for Grid Scale Energy Storage I assume this is a good fit?

Not to mention for something like AirPod....... no more throwing them away due to absurd Battery degradation, at the expense or lower connection time.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by tyingq on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:16AM (#26014337)
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by magicalhippo on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:19AM (#26014360)
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by tsmarsh on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:30AM (#26014476)
As a turbo for cars to enable focusing on super high wH/kg storage class batteries this is interesting.

But as power delivery for drones and rail guns these could be game changing.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by LeonM on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:48AM (#26014682)
Current battery tech can already deliver enough charge/discharge current to act as a momentary power boost for combustion engines. Many hybrid systems act this way, providing additional acceleration and/or torque filling (i.e. delivering power in between gear-shifts of the ICE). Maybe you could recoup a bit of additional power during hard braking with supercapacitors, but in practice I doubt it's going to make a meaningful difference.

For drones I don't understand why supercapacitors with equal energy density would be beneficial? I don't own a drone, but is charge time an issue?

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by maxerickson on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:02AM (#26014881)
If you can charge a capacitor, your storage battery doesn't have to be designed to meet peak power requirements, rather, average+capacitor charge.

Whether it makes much of a difference who knows, but it may open up different chemistries or whatever.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by JulianMorrison on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:03AM (#26014886)
Drones probably care more about the output rate than the input rate? If you need a fast recharge you can change out the battery, so that has to be less of an issue. With high output, the drone can go fast, change course in a hurry, carry a lot of weight, or fly into a headwind.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by sandworm101 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:13AM (#26015036)
I've always wondered about capacitors for bulk storage in cars. What happens in an accident? What happens when that capacity is bent/dented/broken? A Li battery will catch fire, the speed of that fire limited by the speed of the various chemical reactions. But a capacitor is an electrical device. The charge would move so much more quickly. Would this be more explosion than fire?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by derekp7 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:25AM (#26015209)
I've always wondered the same about a vehicle carrying around 15 - 20 gallons of highly flammable and explosive liquid fuel. What happens in an accident, where a spark in the wrong place with the correct mixture of fuel and oxygen can cause an explosion or hot burning fire?

There's been a few times I've driven by a car fire, and even from the opposite side of a divided 4-lane highway, the heat I felt was impressive.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:30AM (#26015304)
I'm really sick about this whattaboutism that every internet discussion about electric cars invariably devolves into at least in part.

Fire requires fuel, oxygen and ignition (heat). Liquid fuels require external ignition. Batteries do not. But you also have to pump liquid fuels around and generally handle them more to make them do work.

Batteries are more dangerous on a fundamental/conceptual level because they have everything they need to release their energy all at once. So we build them with hard casings for the same reason we build large safety factors into pressurized gas containers so in practice it doesn't really matter.

Batteries and liquid fuels aren't really better or worse than each other from a "much safety or "won't somebody think of the children" point of view. They just require slightly different engineering considerations for an equivalent level of safety.

This is directed just as much (ore maybe even more) at the parent comment as it is at you.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by EricE on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:47AM (#26015534)
Capacitors are not batteries nor liquid storage. Unlike chemical based energy storage, capacitors can dump all their energy at once. Literally!

Look up the definition of an explosion. I’m super excited about super capacitors - I think they are going to be required in order to make electric cars truly feasible - but the concerns around the safety of them should be dismissed just because they might hold up progress!

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Tostino on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:08PM (#26015883)
Generally super capacitors don't have quite the same oomph as a regular electrolytic capacitor in charge/discharge. They lie somewhere between electrolytic and modern Lithium chemistries. Still can be super dangerous...
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:02PM (#26015790)
There's some pretty basic electrical trickery that can be applied to limit current in the discharge direction without limiting it in the charge direction.

I'm dismissing these concerns not because they might hold up progress but because they're well withing what Donald Rumsfeld would call a "known known" of engineering difficulties.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by derekp7 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:46AM (#26015514)
I agree with you on this, hence phrasing my comment as a reverse "what-aboutism". Handling of liquid fuels has improved quite a bit to where it typically isn't a problem. Whereas at one time you had cars (I'm thinking of a 60's Mustang) where if it got rear-ended gas from a ruptured tank could slosh into the passenger compartment. This isn't much of an issue with modern car designs.

And cars have come along way in the ability to protect the occupants. That same protection measures can be applied to the battery compartment if necessary (steal roll cage, elastic restraint system, air bags). Yes, these things need to be thought about, and yes we do have agencies such as the NTSB and insurance standards that will solve the problem.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by sandworm101 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:42AM (#26015469)
The speed of a chemical fire, be it from a fuel spill or chemical battery, is limited by chemistry. Even a fully involved burning fuel tank is limited by the availability of oxygen, the math involves wind speeds and circulation of gas over a flame. Short-circuit a normal battery and the math is all about heat and chemical bonds. Short-circuit a capacitor and the math become quantum, involving numbers like the speed of light.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Koshkin on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:55PM (#26016647)
Depends on the fuel. The speed of the 'chemical fire' (which is what it is) inside a shell casing, for example, is very high.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by bluGill on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:10PM (#26016916)
Gasoline is only flammable in a narrow range of air/fuel ratios. Too much air and there isn't enough fuel to sustain combustion, too much fuel and there isn't enough air. There are plenty of people who have demonstrated dropping a match into a gas can and the match goes out with only a slight poof of a flame. Full gas can can sometimes survive the building they are in burning down (if the can is sealed - doesn't melt - there is never enough air inside to light the fuel)

That isn't to say gasoline isn't dangerous. However it isn't quite as dangerous as you seem to think.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:26AM (#26015216)
My concern if this is used in cars is, what grid can support this? You'd have people drawing so much power that it charges almost instantly but existing residential lines won't handle it at scale. Maybe specialized stations can handle it, but home charging doesn't seem real. Unless you limit the rate, but then what's the benefit?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by lazide on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:43AM (#26015477)
Home charging often doesn't need a faster rate.... because you're at home. Same with office charging. Where the faster rate is usually required is where you are somewhere you DON'T want to spend any significant period of time (like on the side of the road in the middle of nowhere, or on a road trip and don't want to stop longer than it would take to use the restroom/grab a snack). Those places are also places that already tend to have tons of specialized infrastructure and are co-located in places to maximize convenience (you know, gas stations, tow trucks).

Gas cars don't have the advantage of being able to charge overnight when you're sleeping, or during the day when you're in meetings or hacking away on something - so in this sense, it's a solid 'pro' for electric vehicles.

It would be pretty easy to setup large scale energy buffers at the equivalent of an electric gas station - from stationary li-ion battery banks, to flywheel energy storage, to supercaps - if spikes were a major issue.

With California (and others) having excess capacity during the day due to Solar, it also allows better arbitrage opportunities, though not clear it would offset the costs.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:36PM (#26016354)
I'm not saying benefit compared to gas. It's a question of benefit compared to lithium batteries. You're trading range for charge speed, but most people don't need faster chage speed today because the range is sufficient, with the exception of road trips.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by lazide on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:48PM (#26016535)
At which point it matters at lot? It's why I haven't bought electric, as well as others that I know who do long road or wilderness trips somewhere. I don't want to spend hours waiting for a charge somewhere.

You have to provision vehicles based off outlier usage (I've used zipcar, normal car rental services, etc. - they are terrible during exactly the times I would need them most, like holidays and months it's good to travel or visit somewhere, and are not reliable), and try to not ruin too badly your 90% pctile usage efficiency while doing so.

If a vehicle is a huge hassle (or impossible) to use for what I'd want to do 5% of the year, I either need a second vehicle for that 5% of the year (even more expensive and maintenance heavy), or a single vehicle that can cover 100% of my usage.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:55PM (#26016641)
I don't see how this will help with wilderness trips, especially with the reduced range.

It shouldn't take hours to charge with specialized stations. Sure, the capacitors will give you a charge in minutes, but a supercharger station will give you a charge in about 1-1.5hr. Timing that with bathroom and food breaks should work well.

The capacitor charge stations would need to be more numerous for the decreased mileage. And with the ability to charge at home except for road trips, what makes that model viable?

Edit for sidenote: wilderness areas don't allow motorized vehicles, so maybe that doesn't matter.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by bluGill on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:13PM (#26016974)
There are a lot of wilderness areas that allow for motorized vehicles.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:17PM (#26017030)
Not if they are truly designated as federal wilderness areas.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by lazide on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @03:02PM (#26018424)
A place doesn’t have to be federal wilderness to be wild - and all of the federal wilderness I know of have a nearby trailhead or similar you drive to for access.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @04:23PM (#26019288)
In that case everyone has a different definition of wilderness. If a place only needs to be wild, I know some neighborhoods that would qualify. Yeah, they tend to have access points and some trails. I wouldn't call where you're parking wilderness.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by lazide on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @09:16PM (#26021796)
Uh huh. At least based off the classical definition, “an uncultivated, uninhabited, and inhospitable region.”, about 80% of Wyoming, most of Utah, and Montana at a minimum count. Some of that is federal wilderness, but the vast majority of it is not.

Even here in overdeveloped California, the majority of the Sierra Nevada and Northern Coastal range easily counts, as does the ranges in the Mojave.

Federal wilderness designation is an administrative one to apply certain rules to a portion of federally controlled land, not a classification of the remoteness of something or a statement of how untouched it is. Technically the moment you step off Yosemite valley floor you’re in federal wilderness - try to not get distracted by the 1500 tourists staring at you or the 10 giant busses idling in traffic 100 feet away.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Thursday February 04, 2021 @08:38AM (#26025187)
I still think it's against the true spirit of wilderness if there are motorized vehicles. Sure places might be remote, but are they really that wild anymore if you're taking vehicles into them, creating dirt roads, etc - I don't think so. Not to mention, if it's not government owned land, then it's clearly owned by someone and one would be trespassing, something that wouldn't exist in true wilderness where no one person owns it.

The area immediately around the roads are not wilderness in Yosemite, according to their maps.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by sandworm101 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:54AM (#26015649)
They could just discharge one capacitor into another. The capacitor at the station (or in your garage) could slowly charge over a long period. Then you could move that power into your car's capacitor almost instantly on demand, limited only by the thickness of your cables.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:46PM (#26016510)
Aren't these very expensive? Why do it this way if the lithium batteries provide enough range, with the exception of road trips? Sounds like it would be twice the expense since you'd need 2 capacitors (not to mention the graphene used).
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by danans on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:58AM (#26015715)
> what grid can support this?

The charging rate is limited both by the charging controller on the car, and the controller on the charging station. The standards for both of these are developed in consortia that include representatives of utilities and grid operators, so these things get taken into consideration at a very early stage.

> Unless you limit the rate, but then what's the benefit

Yes, as you say, specialized stations that have a buffer between themselves and the grid.

Also, regenerative braking requires storage systems to absorb much higher instant power than plug in charging. If the round trip efficiency of these is better than existing battery tech, that would also improve overall range.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:09PM (#26016900)
I could see the braking being an improvement. But I just don't see it justifying the decrease in range.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by danans on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @03:09PM (#26018484)
Agreed, but I think the decrease in range could make sense for frequent start and stop use cases like city buses, which also are less hampered lower energy densities because of their high volumes.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @04:26PM (#26019333)
I think that could make sense. They could also bring back the electric trolleys that the buses killed off in the first place. Not sure which one would be lower for infrastructure and maintenance costs.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by alvarlagerlof on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:40AM (#26015438)
At home, does it really matter all that much how fast it is? I would suspect that overnight is fast enough for most. Charging stations could have buffers.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:44PM (#26016480)
My point is why would people trade range for faster, more frequent charging. Most people don't need extra range. The time you need extra range or fast charging is on road trips. Even then, you generally want to stop for food, restrooms, etc and super charger stations can give you a pretty good charge in a fair amount of time.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by bluGill on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:18PM (#26017043)
Most people do not stop as often as their doctors would tell them to. For medical reasons you should stop often. (experts don't seem to agree on exactly what the right amount is, but for discussion lets call it 5 minutes out of every hour). Note that the stop is to move around, if you sit on a toilet for that time it doesn't count.

Many people will stop only for fuel every 3 hours, and try to get everything they need to do (restroom, buy snacks, eat...) in the amount of time it takes the pump to fill the tank. This isn't a good idea, but it is what people in the real world do.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:22PM (#26017107)
Yeah. I remember a 12 hour trip that I made with a single stop for fuel in the middle. Definitely rough.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by solarkraft on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:19PM (#26016045)
Cars can already pull many times of what a home connection can handle. No problem, since you have all night.

> but then what's the benefit?

Braking and fast charging.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:40PM (#26016421)
I could see how braking can help. But why should I sacrifice range for faster and more frequent charging? Especially if the house connection can't handle the near instantaneous charging?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by bluGill on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:35PM (#26017291)
Because the 5% long trips are the only time this matters. For long trips you should stop every hour, for medical reasons. So if we can get enough range that you should stop anyway, and the stop is short, overall it isn't much of a cost. Batteries take too long to charge even at fast charge rates, but if we can do a 5 minute charge to add an hour of range that is enough.

I'm not sure if I believe the above, but it is a good argument.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by giantg2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:48PM (#26017461)
I generally agree, but there's another element to this - charging station viability. Only the special charging stations will be able to do the fast charging. How available will those be? It seems to me that it might not be financially viable to have fast charging stations widely available if for the other 95% of times people are charging at home, especially if they need buffers from the grid to handle the capacity.

Over all, I think supercapacitors will be a good option in the future, but not at the current energy density. Especially if they're relying on graphene and the fast charging will essentially require a second one to act as a buffer for the grid.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by bluGill on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @04:49PM (#26019611)
That is an open question. I think I can comfortable predict that along major routes (hiways) there will be charging stations. There may not be a charging station in every small town like there is a gas station. Though I predict that hotels will all have slow charging stations (probably tied to your room key).
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Aardwolf on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:58AM (#26014803)
Does it also keep its charge for long enough, like at least a few days?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by tempodox on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:18PM (#26017048)
The use case seems quite different, but my solar watch uses a (super?)capacitor to buffer the energy delivered by the solar cells. When fully charged, it can run for more than a year in the dark (i.e, you can go beyond the polar circle without worrying that your watch will go belly-up in the middle of the polar night). Which is to say, existing capacitors are already darned good at retaining charge. I'd assume the tech described in the article has charge retention “good enough” for the intended use case.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by raisedbyninjas on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:35AM (#26015360)
Anybody else resigned to scrolling by these headlines every month/week for the past five years? I just want to be notified when something is cheap, lasts, and out of the lab.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by desireco42 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:12AM (#26014287)
This is fantastic discovery, I don't want to take anything from it. If you would have your car battery in such form, in case of accident, there would be potential that all this static energy gets released at once, which wouldn't be pretty.

Again, really good discovery, even if capacity is not on par with current batteries, making it practical would allow for more reusable energy storage.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by EricE on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:51AM (#26015606)
Not sure why people are down voting you - unlike chemical energy storage solutions capacitors can indeed dump all their energy at once. The literal definition of an explosion.

Not saying it should preclude them from use; indeed I think super capacitors are the only thing that will make electric cars acceptable. Just saying that it’s something that needs to be addressed as part of their design.

Huge amounts of energy that have the potential to be released instantaneously should ALWAYS be respected/considered and not glossed over, especially for something intended to be deployed widely in vehicles where accidents/physical destruction does happen.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by desireco42 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @03:32PM (#26018732)
It is a HN thing, people don't want to hear anything that isn't agreeable :).

You said everything and I am sure they will come up with some technological way how handle discharge in case of accident, in case capacitor batteries become a thing.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by BenjiWiebe on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:42PM (#26017381)
Larger capacitors tend to have much higher output resistance. They can dump their power quickly, but not nearly as fast as a tiny capacitor.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by sigmaprimus on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:46AM (#26014661)
>>They will be excellent for quick-response power-smoothing and peak load management in industrial settings.

I know they are talking about feed back from very large multi-phase motors but...

I wonder if they could leverage the power from electrical storms? Literally lightning in a bottle?

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:25AM (#26014425)
> [...] research [...] the QUT team describes a design

Yeah ok cool, join the giant pile of revolutionary battery designs and remind me when it's a physical product, tested, verified and ready for mass production.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by gameswithgo on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:02PM (#26016768)
People like to make this snarky comment a lot while ignoring that over the last 30 years batteries have in fact become enormously more energy dense. The revolution came a tiny bit at a time and it is here.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by syntaxing on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:16PM (#26017016)
Serious question, has this been the case? I was under the impression even Tesla/Panasonic couldn't figure this out and ended up just stuffing more batteries into the unit rather than making the cell themselves denser.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by ashtonkem on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:22PM (#26017105)
Right, but it’s been incremental steps in improving a “boring” technology, not the new and revolutionary replacement that ends up getting voted up to the top of HN.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by gameswithgo on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:34PM (#26017275)
I lived through the transition to lithium ion batteries in the first place, that was pretty revolutionary.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by ashtonkem on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:40PM (#26017354)
They also took about 20 years to go from the lab to the electronic store shelf, and another 20 years still before they were first put into EVs.

Revolutions do happen, of course. But incremental improvement is both necessary and often overlooked.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by protoster on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:31AM (#26014484)
Absolutely agree, it feels like I'm reading about revolutionary battery tech on a weekly basis, with no actual products in sight.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by DennisP on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:39AM (#26014588)
Nobody's impressed unless someone triples battery density overnight with a radical new chemistry, but lithium-ion energy density has tripled since 2010.

https://cleantechnica.com/2020/02/19/bloombergnef-lithium-io...

There's a long road between the lab and production, but having all this cool stuff in the lab suggests that the long-term trend can continue for a good while.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by rasz on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:29PM (#26016227)
Did it now? Because Toshiba Libretto 50CT came out in 1997 using 1200mAh 17670 cells. Today, after 23 years you cant buy 3x the capacity even in 18650 form factor, with best cells available topping out at 3500mAh.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by scythe on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:04PM (#26015834)
In fairness, the desire to see a new chemistry is not purely an attraction to the new and shiny:

https://ceramics.org/ceramic-tech-today/energy-1/pursuing-a-...

> ...the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), a country that produces more than 60% of the world’s cobalt. A significant amount of cobalt in the DRC is mined by children...

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by adolph on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:04PM (#26016826)
The linked article’s source is a 2018 Fortune article [0]. As it won a Pulitzer Prize, the article is mirrored on their site [1].

The parent’s linked article claims that a significant amount of the largest cobalt producing area is mined by children. The source article states that industrial-scale output dwarfs the production of the more than 100,000 so-called artisanal cobalt miners which include an unknown number of children.

I can’t say that I’m not saddened by thinking of kids, mine or others, mining for a living. The first image that comes to my mind is b/w pictures of Welsh coal mining kids. Stepping outside of my frame of reference, I can see the set of interests that bring about children mining in the DRC.

Congolese activists working to end child labor say poverty has driven up the numbers. “Because of the economic crisis, there are about 10,000 of them,” says Hélène Kayekeza Mutshaka, who coordinates a monitoring program in Kolwezi that the government began last year, to try to stop children from mining cobalt. Mutshaka says she faces strong resistance from poor families, who have long sent their children to dig for minerals in order to supplement their meager earnings. “They believe they can try to make it into the middle class if they work as artisanal miners,” Mutshaka says.

I’m less sanguine than the article about getting less child labor by moving on from cobalt. The likely scenario is that the industry moves to another similarly rar-ish element and the child miners in DRC move in to another hazardous occupation since the perceived rewards outweigh the risks.

0. https://fortune.com/longform/blood-sweat-and-batteries/

1. https://pulitzercenter.org/reporting/blood-sweat-and-batteri...

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by adrianN on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:14PM (#26015982)
It seems to me that the problem is not the chemistry, but the geopolitics that allows using raw materials that were made under such conditions. I bet Congo could get their act together if other countries actually gave them proper incentive.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by baybal2 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:09PM (#26015902)
And the remaining 40% are not a candy countries either: Cuba, China, Russia. The only standout is Australia.

Then, the whole of world's refining, and relevant battery chemical industry is in China.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by wutangson1 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:30PM (#26016262)
>"There's a long road between the lab and production"

Very well put, and often overlooked. As is the road to actual viable commercialization.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Hypx on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @07:51PM (#26021263)
That graph seems to miss some of Panasonic's cells back in 2010. We definitely saw 3100mah 18650 cells 11 years ago.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by LegitShady on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:49AM (#26014696)
How come aa batteries are still 2000-2500 mah still?
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by StillBored on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:32AM (#26015318)
Well there are:

https://data.energizer.com/pdfs/l91.pdf

But the problem isn't just capacity its maintaining the traditional zinc-carbon voltage profile. There were a bunch of much higher capacity Li/AA batteries from various manufactures that used buck converters inside the "cell" but they have fairly short lifespans, and efficiency loss due to the electronics.

For a lot of cases, companies just abandoned the AA form factor and embedded a rechargeable battery.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by colejohnson66 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:48PM (#26016540)
Why is “lithium” a buzzword? A lot of products (especially Sharper Image and the like) advertise “advanced lithium technology” as if a rechargeable battery is a premium feature for a reusable product.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by JulianMorrison on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:00AM (#26014824)
They won't be being made with the latest tech, since consumers aren't too battery life sensitive and changing up the production lines costs.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by jahnu on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:40AM (#26014597)
Chart most battery metrics over time and you'll see great progress in the past few decades.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by derekp7 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:19AM (#26015121)
edit -- somehow clicked on wrong comment
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by MereInterest on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:22AM (#26015148)
It looks like you responded to the wrong comment. From context, I think you intended to respond to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26015036
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by derekp7 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:27AM (#26015232)
Thanks, it is weird how the brain works where you could swear you are clicking on one spot, but end up clicking somewhere else. Just like when I come home from the grocery store with diet soda instead of regular -- I'd be looking at one product, reach for it, and somehow grab the wrong one.

Every time this happens I swear it is a glitch in the matrix or something.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by anthropodie on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:54AM (#26014753)
As soon as I read graphene, immediately I thought this looks like a pipe dream. We have been hearing about it for years now.

Anyone know if any product with graphene as a main component ever been mass produced?

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by magicalhippo on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:00AM (#26014829)
In the Supporting Information[1] it says that the graphene acid they used was made from "commercial Fluorinated graphene oxide".

So I imagine that is not a huge issue.

[1]: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/adma.202004560 (pdf at the bottom)

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by nine_k on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:01AM (#26014856)
IIRC there is only one lab which produces grapheme efficiently enough for research purposes, which supplies many other researches.

When many labs will efficiently produce graphene, we will have made a step towards small-scale industrial production. Not yet, AFAICT.

Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by chromaton on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @01:39PM (#26017335)
You can buy Li-Ion batteries for drones, robots, RC, etc. that claim to use graphene. Turnigy, for example.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by Causality1 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @11:53AM (#26015617)
There's a great way to save yourself time on these battery articles. Ctrl+F "patent". If they haven't bothered filing for a patent they have zero faith it will ever be scalable.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by SubiculumCode on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:02PM (#26015794)
and you probably post this same comment on every battery article.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by MaxBarraclough on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:09PM (#26015905)
That doesn't address their point. There really is a steady stream of 'promising new breakthroughs' in battery technology that never go anywhere. I made the same observation independently, years ago.
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by colejohnson66 on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @12:51PM (#26016572)
To add to the sample size of n=1, a few months ago, there were many articles about “nano diamond” batteries that will supposedly solve the radioactive waste problem. Dave Jones of EEVBlog debunked it pretty quickly: https://youtu.be/uzV_uzSTCTM

Basically, every few months, a company comes out with claims that battery tech or e-waste has been revolutionized, but it’s always a bunch of bunk claims made using a multitude of weasel words.

[dead]
Re:Hybrid supercapacitor offers NiMH energy density, charges... by wffurr on Wednesday February 03, 2021 @10:07AM (#26014233)
The article, which is not paywalled and is a fast read, also doesn't mention cost. The energy and power density is closely correlated to physical size, so that's covered. The article does mention durability, but only in the context of the lab's testbench:

"The QUT team is pleased to note that these hybrid supercaps also last about twice as long as lithium batteries on the test bench, retaining 90 percent of their initial storage capacity after 10,000 full charge/discharge cycles."

The article keeps mentioning "lithium batteries" which I presume refers to LiIon/LiPo/LiFePO rechargeable batteries and not disposable Lithium batteries, but it's not certain.

Overall it's not a great article. Mostly a fluff PR piece for Queensland University's lab.

I'd still plead with you to read before commenting, especially something snarky and dismissive.