No cash upfront, equity is somewhat preserved and the rest becomes a source of potentially passive income.
Note. He has to leave. The situation is now untenable.
Depending on how the investor looks at this that is not a run race, it may very well be the investor that sides with the OP and together they may be able to kick out the aggressor.
Meanwhile, at most the company can generate $5K a month in revenues. That’s not a business, that’s a part time job with a partner you cannot trust.
Also, seen from the other side: They made a contract offering 40% in four years (conditionally) - most importantly only relevant when the company/idea survive that long and are thus profitable/worth something. Why should they suddenly pay this (or a meaningful fraction?) out after one year? Or give an "outsider" 40%, which will most certainly be difficult to explain to future investors?
That doesn't mean they'll only get 40% after 4 years.
The obvious answers are
- they are a jerk to work with and they won't admit it - you are a jerk to work with and they won't tell you - something else
If it's something else and there is real money at stake both of you should be able to work something out.
Otherwise it's one of the first two - which is much harder to deal with
FWIW that's only true if he was being paid at least minimum wage. Otherwise he would be entitled to some equity even if he didn't hit his cliff.
Might be different in other jurisdictions.
Typically: in the case of a liquidity event or if there is a termination without cause in order to gain control of the co-founders shares. Those terms are pretty common, and without having seen the vesting agreement we shouldn't make any guesses as to what is in there. Leaving can be many things, and co-founders typically don't have the authority to fire each other at will without grave consequences.
Of course, I've since learned that pretty much _anything_ can be re-worked in an M&A agreement -- "we're not buying you without striking this clause" -- so it's no silver bullet.
Also, I don't know for sure, but I imagine they know the reason (even if they don't agree with it).
There's a few different valuations. There's how investors value it, which can be different between investors. There's also a 409a valuation, which is what the government deems it to be "actually worth".
But since the OP hasn't vested, the number that matters here is the strike price at the time the OP got their shares, which is likely ~$100. At some point the OP wrote the company a check for $49 (or so) to "legally buy" their shares (49%). But they haven't vested, so these shares are in a sort of "limbo".
So, the company can't just take them back, since it would be stealing $49. The OP also hasn't earned the shares, per the vesting contract.
This means the company has to pay back the $49 if they're going to take the shares back. It might seem silly to be talking about so little money, but that's all the OP means (even if they don't realize it) when they say the company has the right to buy back the shares.
Wasting 3 years is not worth the time. The Op should eject and focus on building something else or the same thing with a new co-founder.
And I think that is also the best option. Just mentally evaluate the ROI of this project to zero, and try to focus on something else now. With startups you got to get used to the fact that failures and misinvestments happen.
>Same goes for giving you the 40%... there's no way they can build a company when someone not involved owns a huge stake.
This actually happened to one of my professors, which represents the opposite end of the absurdity. He started the company with a friend. The company pivoted to a completely different direction and the friend left because it was outside his expertise. My professor wanted to "do the right thing" and preserve their friendship, so he let the friend keep all the equity. In the end, the friend ended up getting millions of dollars despite producing 0 value to the company.
There has to be some middle ground here, like offering options to the company to buy back OP's shares at the current valuation plus interest. If company still can't afford a buyback a few years later, then they didn't grow the company enough to deserve to own those shares anyways.
So what the industry has mostly converged on is a pretty basic, simple-to-understand solution that has a small enough number of dials that people can work it. It covers the main outcomes reasonably well if people are not too terrible. And if people are terrible, well, no mechanism is really enough.
And if people are trustworthy, then you can figure out things even the mechanism can't account for.
In the early phase of a startup it quite often happens that equity is given on very relaxed way on good terms. For example someone can work only short time in the company and still get nice piece of equity, just because other founders are lazy or careless.
A lot related to startups is "play stupid games, win stupid prizes". Sometimes you can get lot of equity & money if you just happen to be in the right place at the right time. Other times you end up working a lot and get nothing.
Maybe his cofounders threat that it’s 3% or nothing is bluffing. It doesn’t really make sense for his cofounder, because that guy maybe is in the same situation if OPs contract is favorable. Maybe It’s 40% or nothing for him.
The only acceptable advice here is to go talk to a lawyer. That’s it. Internet advice about things like this is always bad even when it is meant well
What's the best case scenario they could get out of it? Maybe 6% equity, or maybe a $10k severance. But going after a company with no revenue and only $40k in the bank doesn't really seem like the best use of anyone's time, energy or money.
There's minimal available short-term value, and litigation/fighting will sharply blunt any potential long-term value.
Or there’s something better that I can’t think of because I’m not a lawyer who deals in this and don’t know the specifics.
It’s just bad to give really any advice here, which is part OP’s fault really because he should not be asking a lawyer rather than Internet randos.
Even if it's telling you to get a lawyer?
Seeking expert knowledge is good advice in most situations. If you have the time, and the issue is potentially costly or valuable to you, then you should almost always gather the best information before deciding.
The difference this time is they is more knowledge, clearer path and knowledge of what a competitor is doing. Consider it draft 2..if that's a direction you want to go.
> there's no way they can build a company when someone not involved owns a huge stake.
So what? That sounds like their problem, not his.
> But I'm 99% confident you won't get anything out of this, so it's best to just walk away.
Possibly. But is that is the case, why not just keep the 40%? He's got nothing to loose. So in that case, there is no need to give in to someone else being unreasonable.
He's on a vesting schedule, and currently has 0% (his cofounder also has 0% currently, assuming they started at the sam time). They both entered this agreement to only get ~40% if they work there for 4 years (and at that point, they'll likely have to revest).
Vesting schedules were created for this exact situation.
If the choice is between "giving up" or getting as much equity as possible, for example by stalling for a month until he vests, but also causing those other problems that you mentioned, then the choice should be clear.
Stall, and get the larger amount of equity. He's got nothing to lose, right? If you have nothing to lose, then there is no reason to not take as much as you can.
I don't think it is some costly effort to simply stall for a month, and refuse any deal. He doesn't need a lawyer or anything. He can simply refuse a deal, and continue "negotiating" until he vests and gets his guaranteed 10%.
Because if they were to fire him, then they'd basically have to fire them like a week or 2 before his vesting cliff, with an establish history of an attempted negotiation.
Firing someone a week before they vest, in order to claw back the shares, because the other person refused your offer, is likely illegal, and not "good faith".
If he is already in a situation where he has nothing to lose, you may as well force the other person to engage in the possibly illegal action against you.
Or, at the very least, get them to make the illegal threat in a way that you can document it.
Even the bluff, or threat of legal action, against a questionable practice, is a huge problem for a company, that most founders do not want to have to deal with. And he doesn't have anything to lose anyway...
That doesn't mean you have to sue them right now. Even the threat of mentioning that this might be illegal, and that you are at least considering legal action, could force the other person to give in, and not do the possibly illegal thing.
Or even beyond that, if there is a documented evidence of these illegal actions, what you can do is simply not sue now, and only sue later on, if the company is actually worth something in the future, and it makes sense to do so. All upside, and no downside. Don't pay the court costs, unless there is something to gain.
* The 3% he's been offered, which while paltry compared to the 40% he had if things had gone better is still not a small amount of equity to hold in a successful company.
* Many thousands of dollars in legal fees.
* Many months of effort and stress.
People on message boards have weird ideas of what does and doesn't constitute lawful termination. Hiring in the US (I'm assuming this is the US, because there was a $100k investor) is at-will, most especially so in companies documented carefully enough to have 4/1 vesting. There is likely no such thing as a "bad faith" termination; there is only termination authorized by contracts establishing who manages the company, and termination that isn't.
Again, by all means, pay a small amount of money to get a competent lawyer to verify that's the case. Everybody on this thread will likely say "go ahead and fight" if it turns out this person can't be fired, so you can just stick a pin in that thought and we can continue to discuss the more realistic scenario.
Threatening to sue: also often a bad idea! If it's not credible, and everyone knows you don't have the resources to litigate, and that even if you did it would be economically irrational to do so, then the threat does the opposite of gain you leverage; meanwhile, threats can trigger other legal problems for you. Advice I'm pretty confident in giving: don't trust a message board post that tells you to threaten legal action.
Sorry but this is simply not true regarding vesting specifically. There are laws that prevent someone from being fired 1 day before vesting for the purpose of clawback.
EX: This source is about retirement vesting. Not exactly the same, but close.
https://jimgarrityonline.com/2014/10/08/fired-just-before-ve....
This source says the following "assuming this termination is made for good-faith reasons, such as business downsizing or poor work performance.", implying that if it is not for good faith reasons, and just for getting back the shares, that this is illegal.
Also from this source: " In general, to avoid costly lawsuits, companies consider future vesting dates when terminating employees. They may delay the termination date, extend it by using "paid time off" days, or accelerate the upcoming vesting to avoid appearing to terminate an employee merely to forfeit soon-to-be vested shares."
So companies specifically try to avoid this situation, because they know it is illegal.
https://www.mystockoptions.com/content/can-company-fire-me-o...
Here is a source that says the following:
"These cases provide very powerful ammunition to employees who are either negotiating for additional severance or engaged in litigation with their employer.
First, Kelly and Newberger provide an employee who was wrongfully terminated with a legal basis to become fully vested in any options that were previously granted."
https://sebastianmillerlaw.com/fired-employee-entitled-accel...
And here are a bunch of lawyers agreeing with me that this is illegal:
"AT will is one thing, this is quite another. This is an obvious scam by the employer to avoid having your stock vest, which is not only not fair, its illegal in my view"
"In Mass., if an employer terminates an employee for the purpose of preventing a right to compensation to vest, the employee has a claim for the compensation. "
"There are certain kinds of showings that you need to make in order to be able to collect in this circumstance. The short answer is that you may very well be entitled to the stock."
https://www.avvo.com/legal-answers/i-was-terminated-one-day-...
Thats why I am saying that this threat needs to be documented. It is quite clear, that there are many cases where terminating someone, for the purpose of getting back shares or retirement or bonuses, is very illegal.
Here's a Santa Clara Law Review article (take that for whatever it's worth) on almost exactly this scenario, in the context of Zynga, citing Newberger, and suggesting that "company determines employee is not worth the equity they were originally allocated" is a valid reason to terminate an at-will employee (even if it is, as I'm sure we all agree, bad business):
https://digitalcommons.law.scu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?artic...
But look, I'm not saying that this person shouldn't talk to a lawyer; in fact, I'm saying the opposite. Find out if the termination is valid. But be clear-eyed: when you get a straightforward answer to whether you can be terminated, and it confirms that the termination is valid, stop there, and don't spend a fortune in money and time fighting a foregone conclusion.
Like tptacek said a few times in this thread, they should read the contracts and see if they can be fired, but it's very likely they can be.
But knowing what we know, what's the best case scenario for the OP? Even if he's 100% right and the cofounder is the worst human being on the planet, what's ultimately the best outcome they'll get out of a startup with $0 revenue, maybe a potential $60k ARR with ads (but maybe not), and has $40k in the bank?
I get the impression this is all happening because things are going badly, not because things are really about to take off.
My point is that it may really really suck, but I just don't see a path, even if everything goes perfectly, where the net gain is worth it.
This is such a tired line. No, we don't know the other side. But the OP is here and asking for advice, so rather than sliding into some kind of false balance you could simply assume that they are telling the truth and basing your advice on that. The obligation to inform is on them, and speculation on your part what the other side may or may not be is pointless.
> But knowing what we know, what's the best case scenario for the OP? Even if he's 100% right and the cofounder is the worst human being on the planet, what's ultimately the best outcome they'll get out of a startup with $0 revenue, maybe a potential $60k ARR with ads (but maybe not), and has $40k in the bank?But knowing what we know, what's the best case scenario for the OP? Even if he's 100% right and the cofounder is the worst human being on the planet, what's ultimately the best outcome they'll get out of a startup with $0 revenue, maybe a potential $60k ARR with ads (but maybe not), and has $40k in the bank?
That's all speculative.
> I get the impression this is all happening because things are going badly, not because things are really about to take off.
Alternative point of view: if it was worth nothing the co-founder wouldn't be making such a play to own it all.
> My point is that it may really really suck, but I just don't see a path, even if everything goes perfectly, where the net gain is worth it.
But that's exactly why the OP is here: to ask people if they do see such a path. If you can't see such a path then maybe just stay out of it rather than trying to talk the OP into something that they may regret gravely?
having said that, you can walk away. and still piss on their cake.
but this a toxic partner. you cannot work with them. that's for certain. you will have to walk away.
This is very unsound and simp like advice. He has built it. If anyone walks away it is the other guy and not him
You literally have nothing to lose by just waiting for the equity to vest and keeping your 40%. Fuck the co-founder. Fuck 3%.
Worst case you end up with 40% of nothing. Walking away you end up with 0% of nothing. If you don't stand up for your equity no one will. And if you let him get away with this, down the line he'll do the same shit to someone else. Stop this guy now in his tracks, don't let him swindle you and everyone else.
Don't be an idiot.
It could happen! They might reasonably spend $400-$500 figuring that out.
This doesn't have to be a protracted legal battle, but reading up on documents they signed, figuring out their proiories (continue in biz? get at least some value out? etc) and negotiating in good faith is something that might come very handy later, in another startup, with much more to lose.
It's not me, but if it were, I'd approach the getting fired problem with "look, I build this. You can fire me, but you don't have money for adequate dev and average Joe will run it into the ground in two months. Your greed will make you lose everything", and also approach the investor (if they're hands on) with the same rationale.
Also agree with the point you made elsewhere - this can get gut wrenching (even without any lawyers getting involved) and if you're prone to dwell on negative thoughts, pretty damaging to your morale through the duration. Money spent fighting is not the only downside.
I would take 10% for the first year of service and walk with it, not expecting anything. The angel put in 100K for 10%, and you worked for a year for 10%. very simple.
I'm not sure what I'd do but I'd view a 51/49% split as suspect from the start.
It's honestly a terrible situation
https://github.com/minimaxir/hacker-news-undocumented/blob/m...
Walk away. It's not fair, but starting a company isn't like getting a job. It's a relationship and a risk that doesn't always work out. Sometimes you find more money and success than you could ever dream of, and other times you waste 11 months.
Here's my thought process. You and your cofounder aren't going to be able to work together after this. The company has no money and no value, so you're trying to get your portion of something that doesn't exist. Them raising money to pay you just kills their chance at ever being successful... plus, who would give a company money just to pay someone out? Same goes for accelerating vesting on the 40%... there's no way they can build a company when someone not involved owns a huge stake.
You could spend time and money trying to right this injustice. And yeah, it is an injustice. But the worst thing you can do is tie your identity to this. There's not much upside to fighting it; all you'll do is spend more time, money and energy you could be using to start something new.
I've had this happen to me before, so I completely understand what it's like. You feel helpless and shitty and like you wasted a ton of time. Rather, do your best to put it behind you, and focus on what benefits you got out of it.
Did you learn about a new space that will make you extra valuable to another company? Even just having a founder mentality will raise your value to a startup. Did you learn things you would do differently? You can start another company, and do it better this time.
I know it sucks. But I'm 99% confident you won't get anything out of this, so it's best to just walk away. It's cheesy, but "success is the best revenge." Your relationship with this company failed, but you haven't. Don't tie your personal journey to this one company.
Good luck, and my emails in my profile if you want to talk!
(Also, a few years ago I wrote about going through it: https://medium.com/@gkoberger/five-years-time-6a6ae1157a66)