News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by lifeisstillgood on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:55PM (#25510426)
I disagree - keep the 40%, this will at least force them to come to you with why they want you to leave.

The obvious answers are

- they are a jerk to work with and they won't admit it - you are a jerk to work with and they won't tell you - something else

If it's something else and there is real money at stake both of you should be able to work something out.

Otherwise it's one of the first two - which is much harder to deal with

Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by tptacek on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:59PM (#25510465)
What "40%"? The entire point of the vesting agreement, bog standard in every competently run startup, is that he doesn't have 40%. In fact, if he's leaving less than a year in and his partner has the contractual authority to sever his employment, what he actually has is zero.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by Alex3917 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:24PM (#25510793)
> If he's leaving less than a year in and his partner has the contractual authority to sever his employment, what he actually has is zero.

FWIW that's only true if he was being paid at least minimum wage. Otherwise he would be entitled to some equity even if he didn't hit his cliff.

Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by tptacek on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:29PM (#25510848)
Interesting. Say more? Thanks!
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by Alex3917 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:34PM (#25510895)
IANAL, but my understanding is that in order for the company to keep ownership of your designs, code, and other IP, you'd need to get some sort of consideration for that work. If you've been paid at least minimum wage then that counts as consideration, but if you haven't then you need to negotiate something reasonable in situations where a founder leaves the company before their 1-year cliff. 3% is fine, 0% wouldn't be fine though, unless again he had been getting paid. This is the reason why startups are always supposed to pay each founder at least minimum wage, even though normal employment laws usually don't require an owner of a business to pay themselves anything.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by Robin_Message on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @05:51AM (#25516363)
In the UK, founder agreements and similar with IP clauses are signed as deeds, not contracts. I understand the salient legal point is that a deed does not require consideration.

Might be different in other jurisdictions.

Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by jacquesm on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:19PM (#25512001)
"Accelerated vesting".

Typically: in the case of a liquidity event or if there is a termination without cause in order to gain control of the co-founders shares. Those terms are pretty common, and without having seen the vesting agreement we shouldn't make any guesses as to what is in there. Leaving can be many things, and co-founders typically don't have the authority to fire each other at will without grave consequences.

Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by valuearb on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @07:14PM (#25512992)
If he/she has these protections, they would not have posted asking for help. Truth is they likely have very few options, can be terminated any time the shareholder & founder want, and whatever shares they own will be diluted to 3% or less if they choose.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by jacquesm on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:03PM (#25513935)
People are rarely aware of all the details of their contracts. I know that must sound funny to those who won't sign anything without reading it and understanding it but it is't rare at all for someone to be handed a 'standard' contract and signing it without fully understanding all the implications. Hence my first advice to hire a lawyer.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by jacquesm on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @12:07AM (#25514573)
And that should have been 'isn't'.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by alisonkisk on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:21PM (#25514041)
OP doesn't really understand their situation or their rights; that's why the submission was created. Also considering the OP's writing, they probably don't fully grok the legalese of their contracts.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by CodesInChaos on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:18PM (#25510710)
Depends on the terms of the agreement. In my case the unvested shares had to be returned if I terminated the employment or the company fired me for cause, but not if the company terminated the employment without cause.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by tptacek on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:30PM (#25510860)
I've had clauses like that too, as part of M&A, but haven't seen them in company formation docs. This seems like a thing you can discover quickly and relatively inexpensively.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by jgraettinger1 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:18PM (#25514346)
Yea, this is called a "double trigger" and is often written into founder reverse vesting agreements signed during formation. The idea is that at first, you can be fired as per usual like any employee. But, if there's a significant change in control of the company (e.x. M&A of >50% of outstanding shares), then _one_ of the triggers has been met. At that point, if you're fired without cause, that's the second trigger and remaining unvested shares immediately become fully vested.

Of course, I've since learned that pretty much _anything_ can be re-worked in an M&A agreement -- "we're not buying you without striking this clause" -- so it's no silver bullet.

Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by gkoberger on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:58PM (#25510451)
Just to clarify, this person doesn't have 40%. They currently have 0%, and their agreement states they only get 40% if they work there for 4 years.

Also, I don't know for sure, but I imagine they know the reason (even if they don't agree with it).

Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by spottybanana on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:03PM (#25510521)
The OP however didn't say who has the power to fire and on what kind of terms. If the other founder can fire him, the 3% was offer for him to leave on good terms. Because they could just fire and OP would get actually 0% and no discussions or negotiations needed.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by dgacmu on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:23PM (#25510783)
It's a little more complicated than that. As they described it, they own 40%, but if they leave early the company has the right to buy back certain numbers of the shares at the original price. The one year cliff suggests that at this point, the company can buy back everything, but in another month, they will have 10% that's not touchable.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by gkoberger on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:27PM (#25510834)
Yeah, but each share is valued at a fraction of a cent. The company will have to cut a check for a few dollars. (Happy to explain more if you’re interested!)
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by thomasahle on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:50PM (#25511069)
If the company has already taken investor money, say x dollars, for 10%, doesn't thst mean the company is worth 10x dollars?
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by gkoberger on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:35PM (#25511542)
It's complicated! I'll do my best to explain it simply, but there's a lot of nuance.

There's a few different valuations. There's how investors value it, which can be different between investors. There's also a 409a valuation, which is what the government deems it to be "actually worth".

But since the OP hasn't vested, the number that matters here is the strike price at the time the OP got their shares, which is likely ~$100. At some point the OP wrote the company a check for $49 (or so) to "legally buy" their shares (49%). But they haven't vested, so these shares are in a sort of "limbo".

So, the company can't just take them back, since it would be stealing $49. The OP also hasn't earned the shares, per the vesting contract.

This means the company has to pay back the $49 if they're going to take the shares back. It might seem silly to be talking about so little money, but that's all the OP means (even if they don't realize it) when they say the company has the right to buy back the shares.

Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by Blahah on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @08:35PM (#25513468)
Can the company in this situation generally force the return sale of the shares for the strike price at the time the shares were issued? And assuming 1/4 of the shares are vested after 1 year, can the company still buy those vested shares? How does valuing those work?
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by gkoberger on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @08:39PM (#25513486)
Basically, since the OP didn’t vest. It’s only worth anything if it vests, so in this case it’s less about forcing and more about just tidying up the paperwork from a legal place.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by mamon on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:06PM (#25511245)
No, that means that this one investor THINKS they are worth 10x dollars. Other investors might value the company differently, based on number of customers, cash in bank, their own subjective opinion on the product, etc.
Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by joeblau on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:26PM (#25510825)
They don't have 40%, they have 0% and will get to 10% in 1 month. Then have to accrue 1% for the next 36 months after that.

Wasting 3 years is not worth the time. The Op should eject and focus on building something else or the same thing with a new co-founder.

Re:Ask HN: Co-founder wants me to leave but won't entertain ... by spottybanana on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:00PM (#25510490)
I understood "walk away" meant walking away without any kind of papers signed. That would mean, that if the other stakeholders want something from OP they have to approach him and make a clear offer.

And I think that is also the best option. Just mentally evaluate the ROI of this project to zero, and try to focus on something else now. With startups you got to get used to the fact that failures and misinvestments happen.