The main equation for general-use household robots is: can it beat human fares?
A good weekly cleaner (4 hours) is about €22/h in Paris, or €4.5k/year.
Let’s say your robot lives 4 years, similar to your computer (which seems fair, since it is one, and an abused one at that). Since you amortize its price over 4 years, its initial cost must be below €18.3k ($21k) with human-quality-parity.
Personally, though, I would bet on dedicated, single-purpose robots, working together through wireless communication. Simpler to build, less costly, easier to replace. One small wheeled quadcopter for cleaning surfaces, one wheeled laundry box to carry it to the washing machine, one arm attached to the washing machine to put it in, etc.
Hotels have a variety of tasks they would love to replace a host of low cost labor with robots with.
Someone in a higher income bracket wouldn’t think twice about that cost if it did significant work. On the other hand, the bar is high (cleaning, folding, picking up -- all are still fairly challenging AI problems, to say nothing of the "business" logic that would go into it).
Then you've got that quality servos are expensive. Some of that can resolved with volume, but not all of it.
In fact, France would probably be a very attractive country for this technology because of this.
Lamplighters are especially useful to consider here.
How many lives has electricity saved? How many ICUs can operate continual machines because of it? How many people at risk of heat stroke can run AC in summer because of it? How many transplants and temperature controlled medicines got delivered because of it? What about its role in food safety? What about timely communications of life saving information, like those lost at sea asking for help, or severe weather alerts advising others to shelter? That's just the beginning, it seems incalculable really.
That lamplighter should have had a society willing to catch them during the transition. But imagine if it solved this problem by holding that one person's job sacred at the cost of millions of other lives instead.
It's absolutely good and relevant to worry about individual cases, but it seems like society is better off if we allow jobs to adjust to the actual current needs of humanity, rather than holding them fixed. Then we just also try to do our best to take care of as many of those who fall through the cracks as we can.
The amount of time we used to spend making a single yard of cloth, or creating 10 pounds of flour is almost unfathomable today.
The prevailing economic theory was that we would automate away so much work that leisure time would prevail. Instead our massive increases in output have just driven greater consumption.
But the difference made by housecleaning robots isn’t the straw the breaks the camels back.
It would take a massive breakthrough in AI to eliminate the majority of knowledge workers at the scale that agriculture and textiles have already been transformed.
Trying to stay as ethics neutral here.
We will probably see something like "Human assisted AI" with a sliding scale from mostly human to mostly AI for various tasks at various stages of development. The operators will be sourced where work is cheap, like Amazon Mechanical Turk.
Once VC gets it they'll fund the first few generations of bots on optimism alone.
Honestly who cares if it cant do everything. Nor can robotic vacuum cleaners and I have three.
@spykie So what if it cant go up stairs, have robots on each level. If it cant pick its self up, have multiple, let them help. Most things it cleans are light, so no problem there either. Cant interact buttons? Give it a rotating toolhead.
@bArray it doesn't need to operate autonomously, see the Human assisted AI argument. With good UX one remote operator will control five or six bots at once, tagging objects, issuing instructions. Give the User a good AR app, let them issue location based instruction around the house that the "AI" (remote operator) will slowly handle during the day.
Honestly, this space will be a primary design driver soon. I cant totally see IKEA making robot compatible cupboards.
If this space isn't huge I will be incredibly surprised.
Mmm...I guess it's fair to assume that the IQ of a human cleaner is superior to anything resembling a Roomba. Would you hire a human cleaner and grant them access to your living area? And if so would you be monitoring their every move while they go about the job?
Bezos & company aren't exactly considering the plights of their employees/independent contractors for their quarterly financial report.
Is it bad that I rank how successful a venture might be based on how many jobs it might destroy?
The bigger issue, IMO, is avoiding distasters like Roombas trying to vacuum dog poop.
I agree, although I saw it as implied!
Robots are like AI: once they become widely used, they are no longer called robots. :)
To me, dish washers, mixers, vacuum cleaners are all robots that can be part of the household fleet.
Mixers and food processors are robots in French:
https://www.robot-patissier.org/robot-menager-robot-patissie...
https://translate.google.com/#view=home&op=translate&sl=en&t...
The thing about examples like the washing machine is, I haven't looked but I would be surprised if there isn't already a networked washing machine, less the powered door, that is meant for smart homes.
I'm happy with our Roomba. We don't have any dogs but is it really that bad!? :-)
Two months ago, my partner vacuumed up fox poop. No idea why he thought it was a good idea. We realised it wasn't when the soft, sticky debris coated the inside of the vacuum cleaner's flexible hose. :(
The smell only improved after I cleaned every internal crevice. Including submerging the crinkly part of the hose in a half-full bath and pulling through a sponge three or four times.
We still have to put deodorant beads inside the vacuum cleaner bag.
Robonix Philosophy at play here, inspired from Unix philosophy [1]
- Make each robot do one thing well
- Expect the output of every robot to become the input to another
- Design and build robots to be tried early, ideally within weeks
- Use robots in preference to unskilled help to lighten a chore task
It's a totally different use case to have a labor-saving device available 24/7. For example, I did not stop using my dishwasher when I hired a cleaner, and my cleaner does not do my dishes or put them away.
https://www.reviewed.com/dishwashers/best-right-now/the-best...
The knowledge workers automate jobs away, leading pundits to say the future for low-skilled workers is to provide boutique services for the upper class. The end being that the upper class is too ashamed to actually consume those services if it means looking at a person...well, that's sort of a delicious irony, isn't it?
I have also heard about people getting cleaners who initially do a good job, but whose work quality degrades over time. You wouldn't have that problem with a robot.
For high risk people, this might be a good alternative for normally-simple tasks they can't do by themselves.
A safe assumtion is that all IoT devices spy on you. I wonder how much longer there actually are robot vacuum cleaners that are safely offline for sale with full functionality.
- 4-year robot lifetime is overly pessimistic. If upgrade is not the reason (which has nothing to do with lifetime, it's your choice to upgrade), a robot could last way more than 4-years (especially with right-to-repair laws in place).
- That said, such a robot will most likely be available for less than $21k and very soon in the near future.
I find interesting to address the middle one statistically.
A given machine has a number of random events that can kill it. Each possible event type i can be modeled as a Poisson process Xᵢ with, in a given year, probability λᵢ. The machine survives in a given year if no occurrence of event i happens, with probability Pr(Xᵢ = 0) = exp(-λᵢ).
For instance, a device with an average lifetime of 8 years and a single possible cause of death, has λ = -ln(½^⅛) = 0.087.
Given N independent event types (say, if you have on the order of N components), the yearly survival of the overall machine has probability Πᷡᵢ exp(-λᵢ).
Thus the lifetime of the overall machine is ln(½)÷ln(½^(Σᷡᵢ 1÷Lᵢ)) = 1 ÷ Σᷡᵢ (1÷Lᵢ) if each component has lifetime Lᵢ.
For instance, two components with an average lifetime of 8 years yield a single machine with an average lifetime of 4 years.
The more death-causing event types there are, the smaller the lifetime; and a general-purpose robot inherently has more.
I believe this result is counter-intuitive, and is the reason you might be led to think I am overly pessimistic.
> ... N independent event types ...
So if the robot blows a $0.03 (i.e., 3 cents) electrolytic cap [0], that's an independent event type that "killed" the machine? Just trying to get a sense of how you define "machine kill" (and as I said I mentioned a big caveat of right-to-repair laws).
That's what I think the value is for this robot. A quick clean, reorg of the room / house.
This reminds me of the little swarm of robots that come out of the walls to clean up spills in The Fifth Element.
This is where raising the minimum wage can spur innovation. If we gradually increase the cost of human labour (with higher wages, and other conditions), then the market will be motivated to fund & find technological solutions.
Set an example by putting away your own groceries as soon as you put them in the kitchen. Boom 5k saved.
Maybe they will grow up to not be the type of person who leaves all of their crap on the table of the university table after they are done studying.
To be clear: I am not shifting on you as a parent. I am making fun of owning robots to do the specific things you mentioned. Obviously if you are immobile in some sense it would be great to have a cleaning robot
I own a house now with a dishwasher; I don't NEED it, but it sure is convenient.
Anyway, when it comes to kids picking up their shit, the important part there is that they learn the importance of not living in a fucking tip. If they or a robot or the well-paid help does it, it doesn't really matter in the end as long as it gets done.
I have seen recent college grads go over a year without washing/changing their bed sheets. In one case I found a couple dead bugs under the sheets. It may be pure laziness but in that case they are also feigning ignorance.
Obviously this evolutionary bias has gone a little off the rails with humans and we now have health and psychological problems as a result of efficiencies. I guess that's where self governance kicks in, unlike other organisms we can reason and adapt in spite of our fundamental evolutionary programming. Whether or not this evolutionary experiment works out is still yet to be determined.
I still say the same about dishwashers. In the time it takes me to sort things into what can and cannot safely go in the washer, scrape off the food residue, load the machine, and unload the machine, I can simply wash the dishes and stack them on a rack to dry.
Vacuum cleaners are useful but actually not very important in the kind of dwelling that the robot could inhabit because it will have to have flat floor with no carpets so a broom will do just as well (or a Roomba type cleaner).
If you have an ineffective dishwasher, you have to do lots of prep before putting dishes in, exclude lots of things from getting washed, etc. That takes longer, plus you don't cycle it as often, so you might find that you need a dirty dish and need to wash it by hand.
A very effective dishwasher is one for which you don't need to prep the dishes (just put them in) and can handle most of what you need to wash. It takes less work to use, and cycles more frequently. You can also cycle more frequently by getting a smaller machine.
The opportunity to invest in effective appliances is one reason it's nice to own a home, as opposed to renting.
Especially in the age of COVID-19 in the US, I can't imagine what it would be like to live in a super cheap crappy apartment like we were before.
Bonus, we also spend a lot less on electricity! We moved into a new-ish apartment building and I can keep the AC on 70 in Texas and my bill is less than $40/mo. In my old apartment, I would keep it at 76 during the day and only move it to 72 right before bed to save money. Bills were regularly $100+. Modern construction has so much energy savings built in to code now that you could potentially save money by moving to a more expensive apartment in a new building.
Most of the specific things they mentioned have nothing to do with being a parent, and also apply to people who do not have children.
Open up jobs, pay a decent wage, and stop this line of thought about exploiting people as much as possible for as little money as possible.
Caregiving is a great job for those who don't have a job. More importantly, SV seems to be forgetting the human component of care giving. A robot _cannot_ possibly take the place of an actual human. It's just not the same.
Probably because low cost always seems to mean low income, low status, long hours, and insecure employment.
- operate in your particular setting (it's likely over-trained for that specific environment)
- run for long periods of time as a fully autonomous robot
- be anywhere near small humans or animals
- do any of the tasks in the video with any kind of speed or precision
- learn new tasks
- handle multiple objectives, or even process the request of a single objective reliably
This is nowhere near being consumer grade. It'll either ship half-baked or you'll have to get on the "it's just around the corner" train, along with the autonomous vehicle guys.
It was to highlight that this really isn't the "do everything" robot that it's being advertised as that some are assuming it will be.
> The Roomba or any of the autonomous grass mowing robots
> can't do any of the things you mention either, and yet
> they are commercially successful in the consumer world.
No, but they are significantly cheaper single purpose robots that do their intended tasks well. This is aiming to be a more generic robot that does everything badly, at a much higher cost.
> there is a lot of potential here despite of the
> limitations
Well, the problem for researchers beforehand wasn't a lack of nice robot platforms to use. Some robotic arm controlled by a laptop on some wheels will already get you quite a lot of this functionality.
Really what a lot of researchers want is a nice framework that already offers a bunch of functionality they don't want to program themselves, so they can work on the more exciting cutting edge stuff. It needs to be robust enough to allow them to hack on random research hardware.
The Pepper robot falls slightly short on this for example, as many places have purchased one hoping it could be a robotic PoS/mobile FAQ - in reality it was just a mostly buggy experience for consumers.
I had a look at the code, it seems to run ROS, offer some possibilities, but I couldn't see at a quick glance some high level functionality they could hack on top of (although I could have missed it).
I could make a list a mile long of all the things my dishwasher cannot do... does that mean no HNs have dishwashers?
> infinite list of things it can't do?
When that infinite list is things people want. I speaking of course from the "consumer" perspective and outlining some reasons why this robot is many, many years away from being ready for that market. This particular robot will likely never be anything other than a research platform that has all support dropped for it after a few years.
> I could make a list a mile long of all the things my
> dishwasher cannot do... does that mean no HNs have
> dishwashers?
Your dishwasher is not an autonomous robot, arguably it's not even a robot. It does one very specific task mostly well. This robot is marketed as some generic home automation machine, which it isn't.
It only needs to be able to do juuust enough work to justify its cost (obviously not true yet).
Roomba is, for example, an even more limited device, but since it does one thing well enough to justify a $500-$900 price.
Talking about all the myriad of things it can't do is just pointless.
The problems I stated are really some of (but not all) the key problems that need to be solved in order for it to do as the advertising suggests. To put the problem into perspective, with billions of dollars man could send people to the moon, but is still unable to solve some of these fundamental robotics problems with similar funding.
I agree though, if this is ever to be a consumer product then it needs a massive reduction in scope and price drop (depending on what problem it solves). It's hard to think of a problem that is as commonly shared and simplistic in scope as hoovering without being a gimmick though.
You've got cooking which is basically automated through meal prep (e.g. microwave meals or even fast food services). You've got cleaning clothes - but the scope is enormous. Dusting and putting small items back in their correct location may be the only real possibility.
- You have to deal with and anticipate the behavior of dozens of other people/animals/machines.
- If you mess up you can injure or kill people.
This robot doesn't really have either of these issues. You'd have to be careful around babies and very small animals, that's true, but there's still a huge potential market even if you remove small pet owners and parents of toddlers.
Beyond that training the machine to identify common household items and tell it where to put them (the remote goes there, the backpack goes there, the shoes go there etc...) doesn't seem too far fetched. Being able to do the laundry (minus any ironing and assuming that you have a drying machine) also seems feasible to me. It won't be able to learn new tasks but if it's successful enough the company making them could continuously update it to implement new features, similar to how smartphone voice assistants keep improving and becoming smarter as engineers handle more corner cases.
Now are these features worth the current price tag, or even half of it? Absolutely not IMO, but that's obviously only for rich early adopters at the moment. If it gains enough traction I'm sure it can improve a lot and fast while cutting the price.
Record all conversations in your house
Record all movement in your house
Record every time you enter or leave your house
Record how long you spend doing tasks (watching TV, shitting, cooking breakfast)
Recommend products for you to purchase based on actions within your house
Recommend products to replace the previously recommended product you purchased
Send all of your recorded speech and movements to law enforcement
- stick a knife in your throat while you sleep
(Assuming it is always-on and connected to the internet, and has zero-day vulnerabilities which it obviously will)
- Gather & sort laundry, maybe even put in the washing machine
- Gather dishes and maybe put them in the washer
All chores easy for an able bodies human. But imagine having some disability or getting older. Getting back that autonomy in your life is definitely worth the money. Heck, if I have to pick between playing with my newborn son or doing the above and the likes, I'd trade my car for a robot that can do this.
You'd be surprised at how much dexterity and precision all these things need. I doubt this robot can handle that.
But oh no, having people around and paying them a decent wage smells like socialism! Anti-individualism! Better to pay 20K for a half-assed robot that can only do a fraction of what needs to be done than to pay someone's wage, right?
You could have a maid but then you need to have them around all the time or you need a lot of space. Also many places in Europe it's essentially illegal to have a maid.
Utter bollocks!
Presumably you aren't offering enough money. Anyway that is a far cry from illegal. Au pairs are not maids.
Over here, in Eastern Europe i have no need for a car(i sold it this year, after 10 years).
Public transport is really decent if you use it outside of rush hours, most stores are in walking distance(not only form my location but all over the city). And there is a great network of cycle lanes so you can easily cycle to work.
Plus our cities are usually wide, but not tall, which means more places for developers to build houses.
That's the kids responsibility after they are done. Otherwise I do like the application to keep things tidy. It's a small thing but it improves quality of life and removes a common task of dealing with clutter. I think a lot of robots will start with huge limitations that nearly paint it into a corner. Eventually a more generalized platform will exist. Too many companies are attempting to make that today and skip the necessary steps in between.
Actually putting things in their proper place is a chore, no matter how old you are.
You would probably want some bleach-safe clothing though.
It's trying to work within the limitations of the robot and figure out what value it can bring that is the interesting part.
I mean I get that luxury and convenience of this robot taking care of stuff that you find boring or tedious, but imagine this robot being able to do certain normal every-day stuff that you're actually no longer able to do yourself? (Or maybe you're capable but it hurts to do, you get the idea)
A few years ago I had my leg in a cast, and I'm just thinking if this robot could've helped me put on my sock?
Cheaper option might be to have less stuff in the house :P
What makes you say that? All it needs is a "knuckle" on the backside of the grasping arm, to push things with.
We already make gloves that work with touchscreens, so the knuckle can work with them also. Vision is the harder part.
You don't need the robot for the first part. I never found the second part that valuable.
Lots of washing machines and other household equipment now has APIs, so interacting with buttons or touch screens might not be necessary.
I think the 6x label on the dusting Spiderman scene is where I lost any interest. If it's that slow then it would take weeks to pickup the pile of Legos sitting on my floor right now, assuming it could.
- go up stairs
- get up after a fall / reset itself
- pick up heavy objects
- precise motion (so no cooking)
- interact with buttons or touch screens (so laundry might be hard)
The one use case I think it might be worth it is if the robot can take a room full of toys and return everything back to where it belongs. Kind of like a one click, reset this room. If it can help me keep organized and clean around the house that would be a big win. Also, if it can help me detect which clothes are still wearable and which I should probably wash, that'd be nice.
I'd gladly pay 5k for a robot that can auto-organize my stuff around the house, even if it involves a lot of customization and setup. Imagine leaving your groceries next to the fridge and coming back to a perfectly organized fridge. Or letting your kids play in the play room and then the robot comes in and puts all the toys back. Or if you just tend to leave stuff out (throw your clothes on the floor or forget to return stuff), the robot can put it back.
I think that's a legit use case.