Over one third of pedestrians killed in the US each year have been drinking too much to drive.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/08/05/drunk-...
Okay so a third of all pedestrian fatalities have been over the driving limit of alcohol, as the article points out. That sounds horrible. It sounds like you should never drink and walk, ever.
Thing is, there were only 1,547 pedestrian walking deaths in the whole 311 million person country in 2011. That same year there were 32,479 automotive fatalities. Throw in liver disease victims[1] and you’re looking at maybe a 1:60 ratio of pedestrian walking to every other kind of alcohol death.
More people actually die of “natural heat and cold” than alcohol related pedestrian accidents.
Alcohol is generally bad as we all know, and leads to all kinds of bad health outcomes, but I’d argue that pedestrian accidents are the least concern if we are to prioritize.
[1] There’s a bit of a silent fatty liver disease crisis going on, but that’s just obesity doing its thing. I’d love to see more urgent action on obesity.
I've walked home drunk from bars more than a few times and I've never experienced any trouble using crosswalks like normal. I'm pretty certain it's much safer than driving home drunk (not that I drive to bars in the first place.)
Somebody who's not really thinking, or just stumbling around and being goofy. Lots of people including myself have said "DUDE wouldn't it be funny if we did [X incredibly stupid thing]?" while unreasonably drunk. Normally calm people start fights with people who can clearly kick their ass after a couple drinks. Probably a few think they can take on or play chicken with a car. Some people also just blink for a second and suddenly they're asleep, if they have enough drinks.
Depression may be a cause, but honest accidents and impaired thinking are definitely big reasons.
If you can't tell for sure, are you certain that you weren't drunk yourself?
And though it was the kind of town that would make you want to top yourself, i think the real reason was there was a pub on either side of the tracks.
Taking an uber is always the move.
Rehashed here: https://freakonomics.com/2011/12/28/the-perils-of-drunk-walk... Google will provide people who don't like assumptions made in Levitt's math.
Disclaimer -- I did research for Levitt and John List when I was planning to go for an Econ PhD, but on nothing related to drunk driving.
No, being outside so drunk that you can't control yourself enough to correctly cross a street is not a "not a big deal".
Or at the very least, to walk cautiously after having several drinks.
A child was fatally hit by a truck at a tram station after another child pushed them. The truck driver tested positive for pot and was ultimately acquitted because the court concluded that even if the driver had been perfectly fit for driving, the accident would have been unavoidable.
I can not remember but I am certain that the driver had to face additional charges for driving under influence but this is another thing.
In the U.K. 1-2 years it seems.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Causing_death_by_dangerous_d...
Having read the facts appeal case you linked to it does not seem unreasonable (colliding with pedestrians on a marked and signed road crossing, travelling at >30mph). In the U.K. there is definitely an expectation that you slow down before a crossing.
In this case the court applied the minimum sentence and appeal rejected the victims’s side request for a harsher sentence.
The facts in the appeal case list many factors, some of which are not in favour of the driver (one pedestrian was trying to pick up the other so they were unlikely to have been lying down on the road and oncoming vehicles were flashing lights as a warning).
Obviously every instance is circumstantial, and I didn't really read anything about the case, but if drunk people were lying down in the road, at night, in dark clothing, I don't see a crime.
Sold few thousands of them to Russian retailers at around 2008-2009, when I worked in a trade company in Singapore.
Previously they were used by Taiwanese taxis to record what's going on inside the car.
Russian's immediately found an inventive use for it, and instead made them to videolog what's going on in front of the car.
I kinda hate driving at night. People can barely keep from getting into accidents in broad daylight imagine at night time.
So you think that he should spend 1.5 years in a Russian prison for that? A sentence that may very well ruin him psychologically for the rest of his life? And/or leave him with TB and/or Covid-19? (and here I note that American prisons are not much better, if at all).
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/41023722-the-million-dol...
I think both the US and Russia should dramatically rethink their approach to non violent crime. Both countries have ridiculously high incarceration rates.
I may be wrong, but I believe most people on HN feel the same way.
Also, to be clear, are you sympathetic to the incarceration of drug dealers and thieves but not sympathetic to the incarceration of someone who accidentally killed someone in an auto-pedestrian accident?
Didn't see this because you added it in an edit. I think we should generally avoid prison time as much as possible, for all of these cases.
I just get frustrated when I often seem to see people defending people with similar social status to themselves, but having apparently no sympathy for people of different social circumstances.
Clearly the consensus on HN is not entirely the same way, as some of the other replies to my comment show.
I am sorry for having assumed intentions that you don't have, though, more trying to comment on a general trend I've observed.
It is simply the case that things happen out of a driver's control. In the US you'd be looking at a consideration for involuntary manslaughter charge (or perhaps a lesser negligence charge) if it was found that they were speeding or impaired. Absent those circumstances, it's unlikely any charge would be brought forth. There are some other ways a similar charge could be brought in an investigation, but that's generally how it goes.
A final note on the topic of getting drunk and playing in traffic. I highly recommend you get people that do stuff like this to sign up for organ donation. I have a good friend who had a congenital heart defect that benefited from a heart transplant. This was after the donor walked into traffic blitzed on holiday. So it might be that out of the tragedy of a wasted life they might be able to save someone else's.
The correct take is jail time for non-violent crime and no jail time for programmers who (regardless of whether we believe his story) killed someone?
Circumstances as described possibly mitigating some aspects of this, but driving (or motorcycle riding) is an inherently and widely known dangerous activity. Situational awareness is a requisite practice.
The only way you do not notice incoming shit at this speed riding a bike is because the shit literally jumps at you.
I know only too well what the "courts of law" are like in Russia. My opinion is that the guy got a wrong lawyer who either could not pass a bribe to the judge, or the other side passed a bigger bribe.
But yes: a proper respect for circimstances and situation might have avoided the accident.
A good portion of my reasoning comes from my daily dealings with my kids. This case bears many strong resemblances to arguments they come to me with.
Edit to clarify: when my kids come to me with an argument because one was careless and hurt another, the defense is usually that they were acting as reasonably cautious as could be expected. My justification in grounding them (after getting the facts and eyewitness testimony) is that I would have acted more cautiously than they did given the circumstances, and would not have caused the same injury, so that their caution wasn’t really as cautious as should reasonably be expected.
hold on... no one ever said anything like that. not a single comment here. let's keep calm.
the whole situation still seems unreal to myself...
if you read below, someone who can actually read the court documents said the victim was not lying around, but actually helping the other person.
just too much unknown to form our own personal judgement here. that's all i was trying to say.
And I'm not. The Russian justice system convicts 99.75% of those accused. The police work may or may not have been reasonable, but the judgment is a rubber stamp.
a. He was driving a motorcycle and b. One of the victims was not lying on the road, but instead standing and trying to pull up the other (or so I've read)
This is the only difference.
Most countries require greater care at pedestrian crossings.
The court report says he was going 60kph. That’s barley over 35mph, a normal speed limit for city streets. So it appears he was not speeding.
If it really was a drunk guy, literally lying down in the road, at night time (!?!), I don’t think anyone could be reasonably expected be able to respond to that in time.
We don’t know, but assuming that is actually how it played out, it doesn’t sound like the driver did anything malicious. He’s lucky he wasn’t killed himself. I don’t think it’s fair to say ” Most countries require greater care at pedestrian crossings.”
We have no idea what the road or crossing looks like. An awfully unfortunate series of events for both parties it sounds like. Very sad.
In Russia, pedestrians have right of way on such a crossing, and drivers are required to be able to stop so that if a pedestrian starts crossing, they can yield (is that the proper term in English road rules?) to that pedestrian - i.e. even if you can't see any people, the marked crossing is considered as a warning to drivers that there might be pedestrians crossing and they must be able to stop and yield there.
So in cases of poor road conditions (e.g. ice) and poor visibility, they would be legally required to choose a speed so that they can do so suddenly if needed. This necessity to drive slower given the street signs and conditions is also explicitly mentioned in the court ruling as part of justification of why the defendant is considered guilty.
So it's not really an analogy of a person lying on the road, because that's not a "normal" stretch of road - if someone decides to drunkenly crawl across such a pedestrian crossing, then that would be stupid and reckless and dangerous, but legally they still would have right of way and cars would required to stop and yield as if they had a red light.
My uncle told me a story once how he stopped just in front of one, and the only reason why he saw him was because of a reflection from an incoming car didn't look right on the road surface. His intuition is quite good as he's an experienced driver. He just said he slammed on the breaks because it looked funny. I never forget that story and always make sure that I can completely see the surface I'm driving on. I'd imagine it would be the same thing quite common in Russia, or anywhere really... Especially around crossings
Edit: To make my main point more simply: when my kids come to me because one hurt the other through carelessness, but they’re defense is that they were reasonably cautious, I would answer them, “it wasn’t reasonably cautious because the outcome was that you hurt someone else in a way I don’t believe I would have because I would be more cautious than you were given the same circumstances.” Driving 35 MPH when it’s marked 35 MPH isn’t as cautious as is reasonable when you add in factors of nighttime, hill, and oncoming headlights (effectively high beams).
It is. But the underlying point being made by several people appears to be that they believe he _was_ driving cautiously. And that it just so happens that, even doing so, the situation was such that it was still reasonable for him to not be able to avoid the collision.
The main impediment to seeing them seems to be the headlights of oncoming cars, possibly while coming over a hill. I always slow down in exactly those circumstances (hill and oncoming headlights) for similar reasons: you just don’t know what’s over the hill, and it’s an extra few seconds of travel time. There’s no downside and only extra caution and safety for all involved.
I highly recommend driving like you say, and do so myself. The last points on my license were were over 15 years ago. But I don't think someone who was failed to be extremely careful to this level deserves 1.5 years in a harsh prison system. Maybe lose his license, but not prison.
Looking at the police report, I do wonder what the punishment would be in other countries. It seems the victims were laying drunk on the ground in dark clothing at top a hill (edit: hill not mentioned in police report, but seems logical given the headlight statement), causing the headlight beams to not illuminate them. On top of that, incoming traffic blinded the driver.
This is of course according to his testimony, but I can't imagine I (or anyone else) would have been able to avoid such a situation.
Edit with source:
Citing the actual circumstances of the accident, he emphasizes that he could not notice the pedestrians in a timely manner, as they were below the light level of the headlights of the vehicle(R.G. - lay, P.A. - tried to lift it), were dressed in dark clothes, street lighting was insufficient, he(Pushkarev D.V.)was blinded by the distant light of the oncoming car. Further, the author discloses the contents of the testimony of witnesses A.A., A.Y., A.M., I.K., A.S.,focuses on the behavior of victims at a pedestrian crossing, which contradicted the requirements of p.4.6 of the Rules of the Road of the Russian Federation. It notes that the victims were in a state of alcoholic intoxication, behaved inadequately. It points out that p.14.1 traffic rules of the Russian Federation provides for the duty of the driver to pass pedestrians crossing the roadway, and not lying on it. He insists that he would have noticed the victims and was able to prevent the attack if they were moving on the crossing upright.
https://kraevoy--alt.sudrf.ru/modules.php?name=sud_delo&srv_...
Transalted by Bing.