It does not discuss the safety concerns of dating, either online or offline. It does not discuss the cost of identity verification and other security measures. It does not discuss the revenue model at all.
Craigslist and Tinder work because it's no more risky than chatting with a stranger at a bar, assuming you're smart and invite them to meet at a public place first.
AM works [1] because it charges significant amounts of money and works very hard at background checks.
All other sites in-between fail because they want to be the 'Amazon/eBay of dating', wherein they stand up a classifieds site with profiles, refuse to charge enough money to perform background checks, and promptly turn into a lemon market populated by malicious actors who are represented as vetted and safe.
There is no mistaking what you're getting on Craigslist or Tinder for "vetted and safe". You're getting a complete stranger who you haven't seen in person yet. If that's your bag, you're set.
There is no mistaking what you're getting on AshleyMadison, either. It's what they say and they work very hard, and charge quite a lot, to ensure that you'll only meet safe and vetted people.
If you want to play the in-between market, you need to charge a lot of money for accounts and use most of that money to vet people's identity. You can charge less money than a specialist site like AM ("affairs only"), but you can't have any free users, or you'll just become a lemon market like all the rest.
It's unfortunate that AM is so focused on affairs, because their model is the only one that seems to be working as an alternative to the classified-ads approach. Safety and secrecy cost a lot more than Okcupid was ever willing to charge.
[1] Not that AM is any more successful, and in fact might be more fraudulent than the rest! e.g. https://gizmodo.com/ashley-madison-code-shows-more-women-and...
But, I mean, who would’ve guessed a company based on the idea of having affairs would have shady as fuck business practices? eye roll
This could be something that one could actually disrupt. Problem with Tinder is that its interest is not aligned with users who seek long term commitment. Tinder needs its users to stay in the swiping pool to create revenue. The users (at least some of them) on the contrary wish nothing more than finding the right partner and stop using Tinder.
An anecdote from Bumble app, whenever a user finds a partner and therefore stops using the app, the app notices this and starts to aggressively match the user with new partners. This sudden influx of new potential partners makes commitment hard for some users.
If the incentives would be aligned, the user would pay for finding the long term partner and for abandoning the app, instead of paying for super likes etc.
Traditional matchmakers who charge a fee only after you decide to get married, have much better aligned incentives.
If they get one month of revenue and you are happy, they made a profit from you for one month and there are no drawbacks.
If they didn’t charge you enough to profit from one month of usage, that’s on them for undercharging.
What fee is profitable in this scenario, for running a short-term subscriptions business? $50/mo? $100/mo?
With any subscription model, satisfying you immediately literally gives them the worst possible financial outcome - matched only by scaring you away immediately.
The worst possible financial outcome is that no one pays anything.
The best possible financial outcome is dependent on your goals.
Do you intend to maximize profit for a 3 month period and then shut down and take your profits to the bank? If so, then you set up the app, sell 3-month subscriptions, and shutdown after 3 months. You will be reviled by all for your tactics, and you'll probably be sued for refunds, but you will have achieved the "best possible financial outcome" for your goals.
Do you intend to maximize revenue over a 10 year period by getting VC investment and going net-negative every month until someone buys you out for your customer database? If so, then you're competing with Facebook, and you will either succeed (because Facebook buys your dataset) or fail (because they don't need to buy your dataset). Your users will suffer the lemon market described upthread because you can't convince the VCs to spend enough money on human verification, and you'll find yourself mocked in the press when your cheapo validation AI rejects 5% of your userbase for having legal names the AI finds offensive.
Do you intend to profit by 15% from every customer for however long they are a customer, and continue profiting in this manner for as long as you have customers? If so, then you set up autoscaling, attract customers, and scale up or down as necessary based on their matchmaking successes.
What, precisely, is your "best possible financial outcome" for a dating site? If it is to maximize revenue growth, then you will fail, because as you pointed out succinctly, it's not possible to maximize revenue in dating without working against yourself.
It seems like a plausible business model too, since presumably cheaters aren’t expecting long-term relationships and will be back for more.
Sure, there are drunken Vegas marriages to strangers which fall apart 24 hours later, but I think those are the exception.
There are possibly therefore other gatekeeping opportunities to consider along with those you suggest and the brilliant parent "lemon market" comment, subject to the scale barrier noted.
Craigslist and Tinder work because it's no more risky than chatting with a stranger at a bar
Um, take a look at what Tinder demands in terms of device privileges.Meanwhile, Craigslist dropped the dating categories a couple of years ago (in the US, anyway).
A real innovation would be to solve this problem of asymmetric information in dating in a similarly robust, yet scalable fashion.
For example:
* Credible testimonies from ex-partners
* Certification of claimed characteristics (photos, age, weight, income, educational achievement, ...)
* ???
* profit
I don’t know how to achieve these - I’m pretty sure blockchain is not the solution, but something might be possible in that space.
It’s hard to know if that person really was an asshole, or if the person writing the review was the asshole. The only way to know is to accumulate a bunch of separate reviews and maybe try some complicated ML algorithm on the intricacies of the messages/find trends in a person’s reviews (if everyone around them is negative, it’s probably not other people), but...if you start to get to a point where someone has an obvious trend, they’ve probably been through loads of partners, and people looking for dating and not hookups generally don’t want someone who’s churning through new partners constantly.
If you have a solution to this problem, divorce attorneys around the world would pay you for it. It’s way more valuable than a dating app.
Jesus christ HN. Not everything is a datapoint to be gamified and exploited.
I wouldn't trust a testimonial from your ex-wife (because either she will hate you or, if you're such a great person as she says, why did she leave you after so long?)
And I wouldn't trust a testimonial from you previous exs, back in the late 90s, early 2000s, because you probably changed a lot since then.
At the opposite end of the spectrum, if I was looking for a long-term relationship, I'd be very wary of anybody providing me with many testimonials of ex-boyfriends from the last 2 years.
This certainly doesn't match my experience.
Among the people I've known, people who don't mind interacting with previous partners are anomalies.
Apps can then strictly filter according to those preferences (some allow disclosure, all have fuzzy filtering at best).
I don't think the core idea in the post would work, though. Scarcity would only be present in the app, genders that enjoy a natural abundance of choice would probably open the other apps after swiping left on everyone in this one.
That's the algorithmic match and the human match. I am X looking for Y, etc.
> Monogamy status
And then of course every single dating site lets you write custom descriptions. (Though IMO it's fair to assume monogamy since that is the overwhelming majority. [1])
[1] https://www.npr.org/2019/02/18/695731314/the-new-sexual-revo...
My argument is that it is actually not (edit/evidence: the prevalence of cheaters), as identifying any other way is met with being a "cheater" or a "slut." Encouraging people to truthfully and shamelessly admit what they are will likely be better for everyone in the long run. Granted, this is a societal problem, but many apps have had an impact on society.
for what it's worth, I've never really encountered issues with people outright lying or seriously misrepresenting themselves on dating apps. the people I've met up with were more or less "as advertised". I think the problem is more that a couple pictures and a short bio just aren't a lot to go on for judging compatibility. also in my experience, people tend to have a list of things they definitely don't want in a partner, but don't actually know what they do want. all my successful long-term relationships have been with people I knew for a while before I ever considered dating them. I never considered them an obvious match upon meeting them.
Then both sides are trying get to simultaneously evaluate the other person (aka "get to know them") while trying to make a good first impression (aka "just be your self" and "act confident")
There's nothing shady about this and there's nothing sad or inhumane or unromantic about this either. It's just human nature
"oh but there are so many companies where the employee/employer balance is totally skewed" I hear you say?
Sure Google will make you run some 6 month long gauntlet. Have you ever tried hitting on the hottest person in a bar when the ratio is already skewed against you?
What about if you are John Carmack or Peter Norvig? Do you think they had to invert a binary tree on a whiteboard?
Just as there is someone out there who will find you the perfect match for them (but they just haven't found you yet) so too is there the perfect company/team out there for you too.
The problem is discovery. Imo tinder was best in a lot of ways simply because by being the one most people used, you had the greatest diversity by virtue of pure numbers
So you could find that person who is a liberal but eats meat daily and knits while watching UFC
You can probably test for those skills. I'm curious how.
Of course, you also need compatibility. But I have a hunch that's both overrated and easier to check for on a date.
That's true to just about every problem, to be honest
https://techcrunch.com/2014/02/13/the-dating-ring-sf/
They were featured on a season of the startup podcast https://gimletmedia.com/shows/startup/kwhxma
They shut their doors in 2018
Online dating is mostly IAC, which has 130 brands in the business.[1] Tinder, Hinge, OkCupid, Plenty of Fish, Match, Meetic, Match Affinity, Meetic Affinity, Affiny, LoveScout24, Parperfeito, Twoo, Lexamore.nl, Amoreux, Neu.de, Partner.de, Secret.de, Gencontros, Divino Amor, e-kontakt, Sprydate, Datingdirect, OurTime, People Media, Pairs... are one company.
Tinder demonstrated that people seeking casual sex based mostly on looks is a legitimate audience.
Grindr even more so.
"Honesty" isn't a binary attribute and it might not even be that important.
But let's suppose it is, and you had a 100% accurate honesty test. What then?
Reject the bottom 50% of users from the app?
Match people on percentile of honesty?
Make a score that's a balance between looks, wealth, age, charisma, health and honesty?
It might turn out that honesty correlates negatively with other desirable traits. What then?
Same if they set me up on a date with their friend who ends up being abusive.
Perhaps some people don’t have the time or ability to evaluate a used car, or a life partner. Or they feel the broker reduces risk as they might offer some guarantee of the product.
Still, taking the analogy to its conclusion, there is a market for used cars at reasonable value ( as in, not all used cars are lemons; some are driven to church on Sunday only ).
This is the space Carmax fills fairly well. They do their vetting though. That might be the secret. I have no doubt there is a market for a decent way to date.
Full diclosure: me and my wife met online ( eharmony I think ).
Gatekeeping could be done at scale with a web of trust model.
Personally, the best part of dating apps/site for me was meeting people outside of my social circles or people 30 minutes away. It also let me filter dates based on some kind of criteria besides "cute".
Your other point is valid though, most people just want sex. That isn't a new phenomenon but these apps make new targets easy to find and those targets feel more isolated emotionally than they did in the past.
Sadly this has gotten worse with the post-2010 dating apps / sites. You used to be able to filter by all sorts of things, detailed looks, education, hobbies, smoking,... Now you can only sort by age, distance and by online status (and the last two don't even work properly). It's all looks nowadays, which is kinda annoying since I e.g. would really like to filter by education and smoking. But I guess that would be to superficial and judging...
Bryan Caplan and Robin Hanson make sharp critiques against secondary-education institutions, arguing that signaling of grit and conformity is primary, while learning is secondary; but IMO the dating-pool petri-dish aspect of college (often subsidized by parents starting to think about grandchildren) goes under-examined.
Also, the most highly trained academics are woefully unqualified to make matches. Socially attentive individuals in the relevant age cohort fare probably a lot better. A lot of women, in particular, are half decent at guessing, among the people they know, who might make half-decent matches, partly because they actually know their peers.
This approach enables you to analyse transaction data and filter potential matches based on similarity metrics, E.g. social, health, travel, financial. Once you had a similar score it would present present a set of profiles that you could choose to try and match.
The idea was to filter out the noise and find people with similar social standing, interests, etc and then allow the single to choose whom they find attractive.
Linking a bank account would also provide an extra layer of security in that the user has already provided a form of national identity. I’m not saying this completely guards against fraud, but it’s certainly more difficult than creating a fake email address.
Unfortunately, one of the major problems was convincing users to link their bank accounts, let alone attempting to build what essentially is a marketplace.
Transaction data is read and never stored, just used to processing matches.
The flow was relatively simple, link an account during signup.
The regulation was hard and expensive.
Then you can use an API aggregator service such as SaltEdge, TrueLayer, Teller [1], etc. (I'm not associated with any of these). Or you can try to roll your own.
[0] - https://www.openbanking.org.uk/about-us/ [1] - https://www.truelayer.com https://www.saltedge.com https://www.teller.io
So if you are e.g. into art, going for into a gallery opening might give you more "potential matches" than swyping tinder for a whole day – plus you got to see art.
The biggest lemon problems can be solved by the people by just being careful. I.e. making a video call first, before meeting in real.
> Alice and Bob are both bachelor and could start a family. Time for them to meet.
If you want your community to grow you have to resort to this. If not, don't come complaining when most of your male population starts enjoying their life while cat ladies resent them.
Same as how if you're on tinder, you're not going to magically swipe to a person not on Tinder.
It just so happens there's someone saying "This person isn't allowed to sign up for Tinder, they're emotionally scarred". Which will probably scar them more.
The whole thing with arranged marriages is that the people in the marriage doesn't actually chose who they marry.
What solatic is describing sounds nothing like a arranged marriage. You can always say no and move on, no one is forcing you anything.
There are arranged marriages where parents play the role of matchmaker and chaperones, with the kids having veto power. Or the converse, where the kids select partners from a professional matchmaker's rolls and the parents have veto power.
I also have colleagues that have declined the arranged matches. Their parents weren't happy, but they did it all the same.
How big would your legal team need to be??
aka trolls and spammers will use this feature more than honest people will
So a good signal is probably someone with few ratings. Which would seem to defeat the point of a rating system, as a five-out-of-five rating is now a bad sign.
Anecdotally, this does comport with my experience back when OKCupid would tell you how old someone's account was. It was far easier to make contact and have a conversation with a new account than with one months to years old.
If someone is looking for a long-term relationship, two selective people who both find who they're selecting for in each other seems like a good thing.
(That said, ratings in this area would have a huge number of problems. Not least of which that outcomes would strongly influence ratings, and if both people are happy then they stop needing the service, so any rating will come from a match in which one or the other person wasn't happy.)
Truth is, an app isn’t going to solve for people’s insecure attachment styles and malAdaptive coping strategies.
Perhaps an app that matches based on symmetrical childhood traumas would be a hit.
What incentive does anyone have to keep using the service to provide such "feedback" if they find their match, leaving aside the creepiness factor of a service asking for such information? (And please, don't create such an incentive.) If they find their way back into the service, then (ignoring relatively rare cases) something didn't work out.
So, a service that helped people gain awareness of their patterns and provided a mechanism for mutual feedback would be useful to someone who is interested in improving the skills of love and relationship.
There already exist apps that people use for feedback and communication in romantic relationship.
And, most relationships end (they all do eventually to mortality). How they end is very telling of the success of the next one.
The problem isn’t really the matching algorithms, it's that people lack the understanding and modeling of how to have healthy adult relationships, they carry a lot of unprocessed trauma, and they don't have a context or tools to work through those old patterns.
It's like making an HR app to match a lot of aspiring kindergartners to AI jobs or the space program.
What's the standard when it comes to a date? People's expectations will vary greatly.
Edit: Now that I think about this more, I am not sure how a rating would work. "He's a 5 star! Would totally date him again!" Wait, what? Why would you stop?
A track record is also a red flag. In theory, the ideal partner shouldn't need to date for very long.
I've dated lots of folks who I liked, but did not find "ideal". Or they the opposite with me. They weren't unpleasant dating experiences. My goal, though, wasnt to find the first "good enough" match - I can be happy on my own. My goal was to find the partner I couldn't live without. It seems odd to assume I was/am a dishonest dealer based solely on number of dating cycles.
“If they’re so great, why are they still single” is an incredibly self-defeating approach.
> In economics, insurance, and risk management, adverse selection is a market situation where buyers and sellers have different information, so that a participant might participate selectively in trades which benefit them the most, at the expense of the other trader. A textbook example is Akerlof's market for lemons.
> The party without the information is worried about an unfair ("rigged") trade, which occurs when the party who has all the information uses it to their advantage. The fear of rigged trade can prompt the worried party to withdraw from the interaction, diminishing the volume of trade in the market. This can cause a knock-on effect and the unraveling of the market. An additional implication of this potential for market collapse is that it can work as an entry deterrence that leads to high margins without additional entry.
> Buyers sometimes have better information about how much benefit they can extract from a service. For example, an all-you-can-eat buffet restaurant that sets one price for all customers risks being adversely selected against by high appetite and hence, the least profitable customers. The restaurant has no way of knowing whether a given customer has a high or low appetite. The customer is the only one who knows if they have a high or low appetite. In this case the high appetite customers are more likely to use the information they have and to go to the restaurant.
Mate, good observation with the market of lemons. My thinking. Actually the same in the official job market.
But otherwise you are nuts. "All warfare is based on deception" [Sun Tzu] and "all is fair in love and war" [Proverb]. And, since all relationships sooner or later end in lies, why not start with it? [Lord of War]
Which isn't necessarily due to "players", violent men, etc.
Instagram influencer, paragons of healthy behaviors.
That way people would be less likely to give referrals to people they didn't know well - as you are vouching for them, and it makes it easier to identify sets of bad actors.
If we could make men* not be lemons, then maybe society as a whole would have better outcomes.
But how do you scale up "dating coaches"? (Would you even want to? People will pay easily pay four or five figures for such services right now.)
[* Gender is not binary, etc., but painting with broad strokes to make the example more concrete.]
The reason young people use dating apps is to avoid this old world formalism.
I don't think your idea would get much traction outside of South Asia and the Middle East.
Interestingly, their reputation seems to be again at similar risk because as they've scaled up across the country they've relied more and more on high cost being their gatekeeper over more direct contact with matchmakers. Or at least that's they way it seems from the many emails and calls I see to rejoin with "discounts" jumping an order-of-magnitude every few years from tens of dollars to hundreds of dollars, to now thousands. It's rather extraordinary and it doesn't give me a lot of confidence to rejoin even if I was interested.
I signed up in my 20s. They admitted I was young versus their median, but I wasn't alone and had plenty of dates in the few months I was a member.
There was a lot of appeal to the idea of not dealing with the usual grind of the average dating app, and getting something a bit more personal/high-touch.
(Though even then it seemed apparent that it was less high touch than it seemed for the cost, and the real gatekeeper was the cost.)
There should be ways to sell human-moderated dating apps (Blind Dates as a Service) to young people just on how dumb and how much work even the "swipe left/right" systems are. Figuring out how to scale that cheaply definitely seems to be the impossible problem.
Their process at that time (2008) was to have a set of employees who were matchmakers. They would read hundreds/thousands of family requests and requirements and then hundreds/thousands of applications of the young people from various countries around the world. They would match them with prosperous US families that were looking for an au pair.
As he explained the process I began brainstorming ways to use NLP and earlier versions statistical analysis, machine learning or maybe genetic algorithms to take over or at least assist in what was a very manual process by those matchmaker employees.
He left for a different job not too long after and we never did more than a bit of brainstorming. And, I suspect that this matching is still being done largely through human reading and thinking including how humans "read between the lines" which can sometimes be so accurate and other times just reveal the biases of the matchmaker.
However, thinking about those kind of person to person compatibility and matching problems led me to reserve the domain name trupeer.me - the idea of helping professional career people find their tru peers in industry
Dating markets are lemon markets. The classical example of a lemon market was the used car market - most people who bought "lemons" (unreliable cars) would exploit information asymmetry and sell them on the used market, and over time the reputation of the used car market deteriorated to the point where it was affecting the value of new cars. The car manufacturers solved the problem by introducing gatekeepers - certified used car programs, that certified that the cars weren't lemons.
So who are the "lemons" on dating markets, which bring down the reputation of dating markets for the rest of the players? People who aren't in an emotionally healthy place to make commitments; people who are "players"; people who are violent; etc. It is our experience dealing with the lemons who stay on the dating market that ruins the reputation of the entire dating market and makes dealing with the market difficult.
So the solution is to introduce a gatekeeper. What does a gatekeeper look like? A clinically trained psychologist-cum-matchmaker (pun not intended) who can certify that the matches you are set up with are people with a track record of dealing honestly (for your personal definition of honest) in the dating market. Don't like your gatekeeper? Pick a different one.
So far as I can tell, healthy dating markets are limited to scale by the need to hire such competent human gatekeepers. If anyone has an idea how to automate the gatekeeping in a humane way - you're sitting on a gold mine.